Anakin DIDN'T Deserve Master Jedi
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 фев 2025
- 🚀 Love deep Star Wars analysis? I got you covered! 🚀
🔥 Main Channel (Movies Analysis): / @criticalanalysishub
🎬 2nd Channel (Shows Analysis): / @criticalanalysishubplus
💡 Support the channel by checking out these awesome Star Wars collectibles & gear on Amazon!
🛒 Top LEGO Star Wars Sets → bit.ly/StarWar...
⚡ Best Star Wars LEGO Helmets → bit.ly/StarWar...
🎭 Star Wars Funko Pop Figures → bit.ly/StarWar...
🔔 Don't forget to like, subscribe, and hit the notification bell to never miss an upload! I post DAILY!
💬 What do you think about today’s topic? Drop your thoughts below!
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Would you have given Anakin the rank of Master?
No if i was a jedi master and took on anakin i woudlve taken him away from the order and trained him out in the galaxy somewhere. The chosen one was a unique case the jedi failed him because despite his clear difference to the rest of the padawans and younglings. The galactic capatal also was not a place of light i believe training him away from coruscant wouldve been better. And as an already emotional initiate he needed to trained to channel and manage his emotions, not surpress them. And they shouldve went back for his mother and give her a good life so even if he didnt get to see her often or at all. Anakin wouldn't worry and fear for her. And if anything happened to her the jedi will have done something to help her and anakin wouldnt have reason to resent. He was a special case that was treated as if he were any other jedi. Obi wan knew this too.
How could you do this? This is outrageous! This is unfair! How could you be on the council? And not be a master?
Take a seat, young darkshadow07186
Its the Jedi. They're jealous, young @darkshadow07186
They're holding you back
@@Dommie222proceeds to literally take a seat and leave
And become a heavily damaged Sith Lord later on with a unstable mind and vengeance
Some of y’all don’t understand something. The biggest reason why he flipped out when he wasn’t granted the rank of master was because Jedi masters could access the forbidden section of the library. The forbidden section had countless secret sith and Jedi techniques. Anakin knew this, and wanted to gain entry so he could save Padme. By denying him the rank of master, in Anikan’s mind, the council was signing Padme’s death warrant.
Why not take Padme to some professional space doctor? He thought she was going to die based off a dream. Calm down dude. Just take her to a doctor and ask her how she wants help
@ Remember, he saw his mother dying in his dreams (visions of a future) and they came true (kidnapped and dying at the hands of the Tusken Raiders). To Anakin, his dreams have a 100% accuracy. So, he overreacts and assumes the absolute worst.
@@Skelta638 while yes that is true but Padme had the right to choose. He should have at least given her the option if he loves her then he knows he can't make every decision for her. If her life is in danger she has the right to know and the right to choose.
@@professorsassafras I’m not arguing with you about that, I agree with that. I’m just giving context about what was going through Anakin’s head.
Padme's fate is irrelevant to the argument. The fact is that as a Jedi, Anakin should never have been in that relationship in the first place. When it comes to being a Jedi: Love is fine; attachment is not. The fact that Anakin formed attachments and allowed his fear of loss to influence his judgment is exactly why he was never fit to be a Jedi, let alone a Jedi Master.
The irony is that if he had learned to let go of his fear of losing Padme, and not try to control her fate, he would have taken a monumental step in the right direction to becoming worthy of the rank of Master.
To me, it felt more like the order failed anakin. Yes he didn't deserve that rank at that time, but that's because the order forced him to ignore his problems instead of addressing them. Repressing emotions never work, and if they had just helped him work it out he would have been an amazing jedi. It also doesn't help that they had mace, one of the most sarcastic asses on the planet, to be the one that told him. If obi wan was the one who told, it likely would have ended differently. Someone he trusted explaining it (even if he didn't agree with it, that might have actually helped since it would have shown not everyone was in agreement) rather than someone who he probably hated at that moment. Sure, he might have had doubts here and there, but if the group listens, it will definitely add loyalty to them. Controlled emotions is a lot better than caged emotions (personal experience here).
He was a unique case, they should have addressed it as such. From my understanding they didn't treat him well even at an early age in training. This was something Luke wound up doing at the end of the original. He controlled his anger, and instead of lashing out like his father (which caging emotions would wind up doing) he instead used it to help him combat Vader. He was in control of his emotions the whole time, and showed the value of being a living creature. The order as a whole just fails in the core due to this fact, and if they had been more lenient, found a way to help those with emotions control them, and taught properly anakin probably would have let mace do his thing.
No they didn't. They gave sound advice about controlling his emotions and being willing to let go when people pass, as they one day will regardless.
Anakin failed Anakin.
People always forget that the first half of ROTS is Anakin being almost a perfect Jedi.
He saved Obi when he was knocked out despite being ordered to leave him, preached patience when they were trapped in ray shields , shows humility when ObiWan praised his actions. Went to Yoda for advice and council when he was worried about the death he had in his visions.
He was the poster boy for the Jedi order during the war and one of their greatest fighters. And even he didn’t have any expectation of being made a master yet until Palpatine put that idea in his head.
He still had some growing up to do but nearly all of his emotional outbursts in the middle of the film were driven by the fear his wife and children dying during child birth, the insult of being made part of the council but not a master and then have them ask Anakin to go against the Jedi Teachings and work as a spy for the council.
At this point based on his merits, power and disposition I think he was worthy of being a master.
he killed dooku...😊
he still hasn’t grown enough he was purely a good Jedi on the physical side not the mental one
I love Anakin, but I agree. I’m a wholeheartedly defender of the Jedi Order, though I agree that the 1,000 years under the Republic has made them glorified police. The Jedi Order is a religious order of Warrior Monks/Knights, it’s not a life for everyone, which is why there were only 10,000 in a Galaxy of trillions. Anakin simply couldn’t live up to the rules because he as a former slave couldn’t humble himself to serve, which is what the Jedi are meant to do. And, as we see in the expanded universe, we see other Jedi who fell in love (most often with other Jedi) and they either were able to make it work, or they remained friends chose duty. And even Quinlan Vos who also had a brush with the Dark Side and married a non-force user and he chose the light. Anakin simply made his choices and they had consequences for him, the Jedi, and the Galaxy. Excellent video. 👍
I was watching Charlie hopkins last night and it brought up a good point: who told anakin he was the chosen one. They settled on Obi Wan but regardless this was a great mistake. What point was there to telling Anakin, his knowledge of being the chosen one does nothing but harm. It doesn't change what he is but his flaws were rooted in this mistake.
They had long since committed to Mace Windu being their 'chosen one'
To be fair while from a maturity stand point yes Anakin did not deserve the rank of master had Ahsoka rejoined the jedi order at the end of season five both Dave Faloni and George Lucas confirmed that she would have been back as a jedi knight meaning by the jedi code's own rules Anakin should have been made a master about a year before the events of Revenge of the Sith having trained his first student to the rank of knight
While the Jedi Council could have handled things better, and do suffer from being too dogmatic, they were still correct that Anakin wasn't ready for promotion to Jedi Master yet. While the Jedi attachment rule is ridiculous, the fact still is that Anakin's fear of loss, anger and arrogance did indeed obectively speaking carry dangers. If Anakin conquered his fears of loss, got a better handle on his emotions and ego he indeed would have been ready for the rank of master.
I think this issue of whether Anakin did or did not deserve the rank of Master could have been clarified by a few things, specifically:
1. Actually mention Ahsoka Tano as Anakin's (former) Padawan and that she DID earn the rank of Knight, but resigned from the order before being knighted. As a general rule if a Jedi Knight is able to mentor a Padawan to Knighthood, that Jedi Knight is given the rank of Master (and have the fact that Ahsoka resigned before being knighted be the loophole that the Jedi use to justify denying Anakin the rank of Master)...given that Ahsoka Tano did not exist at the time Revenge of the Sith was released and was added to the plot of Star Wars RETROACTIVELY, this is where Special Editions/rereleases of Revenge of the Sith COULD help, specifically in that it would be possible to retroactively ADD a scene where that whole drama surrounding Ahsoka's resignation is at least MENTIONED, perhaps even extending the argument between Anakin and Mace Windu to where Anakin MENTIONS that Ahsoka was basically considered ready for Knighthood but left due to being framed and mistreated by the Jedi (INCLUDING Master Windu), only for Windu to coldly shut Anakin down by saying something like "well she quit without being Knighted, so no, you cannot use her brief eligibility for Knighthood to automatically be granted the rank of Master. Take a seat, young Skywalker"
2. Similarly make it clear WHEN Anakin was knighted, specifically for his expectation of being granted the rank of Master to make sense. The problem with pre-Disney Star Wars' take on Anakin is that there were essentially 3 different implied times of knighting for Anakin, specifically in that most of the EU authors during the time of the Clone Wars Multimedia Project (2003-2005) decided that Anakin was knighted 6 months before Revenge of the Sith, yet the Tartakovsky Clone Wars series implied that Anakin was knighted approximately 4-5 months into the Clone Wars (and thus more than 2.5 years before Revenge of the Sith), specifically right after the Jedi found out about General Grievous at the disastrous Battle of Hypori (judging by what the dialogue of the council meeting before Anakin's knighting implies)---TCW further reinforces this by confirming the date of Anakin's knighting as AT LEAST 2.5 years before Revenge of the Sith. Now if Anakin was knighted a mere 6 months before Revenge of the Sith OF COURSE his anger over NOT being granted the rank of Master would be unreasonable, HOWEVER if he got knighted 2.5-3 YEARS before Revenge of the Sith and had TIME to build his reputation as The Hero With No Fear, then said anger and frustration would be A LOT more understandable, even if misplaced...
3. Perhaps in order to heighten the tragedy of Anakin's fall to the Dark Side, extend the scene where Obi-Wan, Yoda, and Mace Windu are all talking about Anakin's mission to spy on Palpatine, and have the conversation shift to his outburst and questions of the extent of Anakin's trustworthiness. There I would reveal that ALL 3 Jedi Masters (and really the WHOLE COUNCIL AND MOST OF THE JEDI ORDER) KNOW about Anakin's relationship with Padme, but are playing along with Anakin's belief that he is somehow successfully hiding it by NOT TELLING HIM THAT THEY KNOW. The reason for this is that they want him to come clean about the matter of his relationship with Padme so as to PROVE that he can be trusted, and to that end even plan to GRANT Anakin the rank of Master as soon as he does come clean about said relationship---that and they know that if the Jedi were to confirm that one of their own were in a relationship with Padme (who is not just any Senator but probably one of the most important, with a track record of being a crucial swing vote), it would ruin her reputation, career, and LIFE (we can even include extra lore in the form of the Star Wars equivalent of tabloids surrounding Anakin and Padme's relationship as well as mention of Padme (AND the Jedi, AND Palpatine) spending huge amounts of money on lawsuits against the tabloid press (this even ties into Star Wars' penchant for social commentary on whichever years the films were released in, given the ubiquity of the tabloid press throughout the 2000s))...
Anakin was better than being a Jedi, the Jedi were so flawed especially the dam council, the council did not treat Anakin right, Anakin responded the way 95% of persons would if they were in his shoes
Well said bro I couldn’t have said it any better myself ✅
People seem to forget / not understand that one bit.
Imagine it you get your arm chopped off , your one of the youngest fastest rising knights in a 3 year war , your more skilled a faster learner & just better then 9/10 of your elder peers & the list goes on to just to be told;
“You can’t have the rank of master”
The Jedi council feared count Dooku & couldn’t even take him down whether he was holding back in combat or not yet Anakin managed to do it whether it was a set up or not a win is still a win YET;
“You still can’t get the rank of master”
Absolutely rubbish Jedi council bro rubbish 😂❌🤷🏾♂️
problem is Anakin didn't earn it. it was Palpatine meddling with Jedi affairs which he had no business doing and it was done intentionally to get Anakin to trust him more then the Jedi. it was a trap and Anakin fell head over heals for it
also letting the guy that slaughtered men, woman and children in a blood thirst rage become a master. what a brilliant idea
@reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134 not to mention that both Dave Faloni and George Lucas confirmed that has Ahsoka rejoined the order it would have been as a knight there for by the jedi code's own rules Anakin should have been made a master about a year before the events of Revenge of the Sith as he had trained his first student to the rank of Jedi Knight
@
That’s fine if your into the Jedi supporting that’s cool
As I said on my prior comment I disagree big time when it comes to If Anakin deserved mastership 🤷🏾♂️✅
Guys like Anakin have proved themselves long enough in that particular organisation so after he got declined mastership he should have up & left the Jedi order permanently 👏🏾
Rubbish organisation , rubbish rules during the high republic / clone wars time period & you need to be a Kiss Ass / teachers pet in order to become great in that group …
#MyOpinions #TeamSithCode 🔥
@@mike16apha16 you know that some of the Jedi master of the council have committed crimes worse that of destroying a settlement of tusken, right?
There should have simply been an election. A „fair“ process.
Every master, knight and padawan has a vote. Those who feel like Anakin deserves the rank of master and those who oppose.
Considering his extraordinary reputation and feats during the war. It’s save to say that the scale would go to Anakin‘s favor . He was already regarded as a legendary hero of the republic in the holonet.
cause somehow voting magically makes things better. funny mustache man was voted into power in the 1930s and there is a reason we have people only over the age of 18 can vote. not everyone is worthy of having a say in every matter as some lack maturity, wisdom and life experiences to make a proper decision on curtain matters
if families voted on what to eat every day better believe they will be having ice cream all the time if the kids got their way
there is also issues with people voting selfishly and not taking anyone else but themselves into consideration
there is a reason curtain criminals lose the ability to vote as well
If that were the case Anakin would have the advantage with the younger Jedi, though would struggle with many of the older ones. Many younglings and padawans looked up to Anakin.
@ Plo Koon, Kit Fisto, Luminara, Aayla, Ki Adi Mundi, Yoda and Obi Wan are fond of Anakin.
There are several Jedi who work beneath the council who’d heard the recent stories of the chosen one making a name for himself.
Ah yes what could go wrong when your ability to gain rank and power was solely determined by a popularity contest.
@ lmao, do you understand the characters in the show?
the Jedi pride themselves to be loyal to the republic. The republic prides itself to be a democracy.
Giving Anakin the rank of master through a vote would only be natural. Even Obi Wan thought Anakin deserved more recognition.
Let us decide when Anakin is ready for the rank of Master, not the Chancellor. I think Obi Wan said it best, "you must be patient, Anakin. It will not be long before they make you a Jedi Master". Boy needs to sit down today, so he can rise as a man and a Master tomorrow.
I actually agree with this video completely no complaints or disagreement at all
Finally someone that understand it, a lot of people blame it all on the council but anakin has as much fault as them, he was reckless, immaturity despite being an adult, like the first thing adult anakin does is disobey Obi Wan in attack of the clones, going on a killing spree after his mom died is another key moment, killing woman and children is as low as you can get, guess Anakin never learned that being able to do something doesnt mean you have to, letting his intrusive thoughts get the worst out of him, he was a time bomb that Palpatine knew when to detonate it. Anakin story is a very but effective tragedy to the point that people think it was everyone else fault but his, but he was no child and was fully aware of what he was doing.
Something I always wondered, what does "bring balance to the force" actually mean to the Jedi? The Jedi council is, at the start of Episode 1, at the height of their power. The Sith are believed to be long extinct. So what is there to balance? After Episode 3, there are only a few Jedi left, and only a few Sith, that seems much more balanced, except that the Sith now rule the Empire and the Galaxy, at the end of Episode 6, there are still only a few Jedi left, but no more Sith but the galaxy is once again freed from tyranical rule. But are Light and Dark balanced at that point?
Balance of the force means the abcence of the dark side since it is a poison on the force
@@Maegorthecrueltargaryen Makes sense but again, at the start of Episode 1 the Jedi believe there are no Sith, so balance would already have been achieved (or believed to be so, anyway)
@@Nosferatu666rules that's why they were sceptical that Anakin was the chosen one.
In my opinion I don't think the Jedi actually knows what "Balance to the Force" truly means. Like I dont think the Jedi understand the prophecy, and I believe the The Jedi when they destroy the Sith the Master and The Appreciate (or general just Sith) is what bend the Force and that and which is why I Think that the all Sith should be destroyed and the Jedi can be in peace, tranquility and harmony. That's what I think personally.
@@Maegorthecrueltargaryen Dark side is a point of view.
Great video. I have come to love hearing your thoughts on a story I enjoy so much.
A bit of therapy could have saved the Jedi.
Of course he didn't deserve it, he was a bomb of emotions, most commonly anger.
You also left out the fact that anakan was actively using the dark side as shown in the clone wars tv show he was the perfect candidate for a sith he checked all the boxers for bieng a sith no wonder sidious wanted him as his apprentice anakan was perfect for the job
@CriticalAnalysisHub: You have got to be trolling in this video because you are observing Anakin from the old and outdated perspective!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Uh... no Duh. There's an entire movie titled Revenge of the Sith that proved that. It came out in 2005.
1:10 1:15 Why didn't Qui Gon Jin see it coming?
The fact that Jedi who got killed by Jango Fett and Palpatine in a matter of seconds made Master while Anakin did not goes to show that the Jedi promotion process is just a boys' club. Maybe if Anakin was more of a sycophant towards the flawed code of the Jedi, they would've promoted him. But since he had a spine, they didn't.
Also, pissing him off then asking him to spy on the Chancellor is such a stupid move. If you're going to have him commit treason, then at least butter him up first. Maybe if they did grant him the Master title, he'd be more eager to commit treason for the Council. Telling him to get screwed then telling him to commit treason literally showed him that the Jedi have no honor.
A good Jedi master has selflessness, wisdom, knowledge and prudence. Unfortunately Anakin had none of those qualities. He was also pretty young and inexperienced even if the Jedi masters would not notice all of his emotions. The good Jedi master would also know about the history of the Galaxy and the moral philosophy of the Galaxy so that this Jedi master would use that knowledge to make the Galaxy a better place for all of the citizens of the Republic.
0:48 and more so on the part of Palpatine's flattery .
Anakin didn't even want the Jedi Master Rank. He much more cared about the benefit of having more access in the library to save Padme.
He did want the rank of Jedi Master and not just for Padme's sake. He confessed to her his ambition for power.
"I'm not the Jedi I should be. I want more, and I know I shouldn't."
His ambition for power and his attachment to Padme are both reasons why he was not qualified to be a Jedi Master. The Jedi Council had every right and every reason to deny that title to someone who clearly did not deserve it. But it wasn't a punishment or an insult. It was a lesson, and as usual, Anakin failed to learn from it.
You know Anakin Skywalker is just like tarre vizsla Neither one became a Jedi master. They were only Jedi Knights and very powerful and strong ones. Who? exceeded and surpassed many other Jedi Masters in the Jedi Order Really? because we know how powerful strong fast and smart they were Really? also how are the vids that i told you going on
I'd go so far as to say he shouldn't have even been allowed into the Jedi Order. Sure, he's good at fighting, but he fundamentally lacks the right temperament. Same reason some people don't need to be police officers. #macewinduwasright
He was right, because the jedi made him to be that way imo.
@@kerakhunter-b3n I agree wth your take 1,000&.
Through most of ROTS he had shown nothing but the right temperament.
He wasn’t the same person we saw in episode 2, not even close.
@BigHeadClan You must be joking. He spent most of the movie giving into his fear of losing Padme, which in turn, fueled his obsession to keep her alive. He also whined like a brat throwing a tantrum when he wasn't promoted to Master, which he arrogantly assumed would be given to him after his friend, the Chancellor, forced the Jedi to put Anakin on the council. He didn't earn his spot on the council and he certainly didn't deserve to be a master. He was never fit to be a Jedi.
Remember Anakin didn't actually ask for the Position of master but Palpatine did. Watch the movie
He didn't ask to be put on the council, but he fully expected to be given the rank of master just because he would be on the council. When he didn't get it, his reaction showed exactly why he didn't deserve the rank. Anyone who behaves like a whiny, bratty little child in a tantrum is no Jedi Master.
Well, as the usual qualification for becoming a Master is training a Padawan to Knighthood, and Ahsoka only didn't become a Knight because she left, but WOULD have if she returned to the Order, Anakin DID, in fact, deserve to be a Master. At least in that particular regard.
Yeah, you see why Ashoka opens up so many plot holes?
How can you be on the council and not be a master?
I didn’t know Mace Windu had a youtube channel
If Qui-gon had lived and been Anakin's teacher, things would have been so different.
Anakin probably wouldn't have turned to the dark side in that case.
regardless of the situation at the time in revenge of the sith i say anakin should of been made a master for one simple reason. he successfully trained ahsoka. now i know she left the order but that was a chose she made after what the council did to her along with the republic so she has every right to feel that way plus right before ahsoka rejected the offer to come back the council offered to make her a knight if she remained and one of the ways to reach master status is to train a student to knight hood so if not for a technicality anakin would of gotten the rank before revenge of the sith.
These issues speak more to the fact Anakin should never have been put on the council. So personally all this applies better to the promotion to the council.
Not being given the rank of master is a slap in the face by the entire council minus obiwan from anakins POV, evidenced by the fact he talks to obiwan about it afterwards.
The foolishness of the council is wild, what harm comes from giving Anakin the rank of master before sending him to spy on Palpatine. Think about the timing, anakins trust is shaken from such an unheard situation of being on the council and not being a master, stated when he says this to Palpatine. The council had given him resistance as the perception changed but the Council sealed their own fate with Anakin, if they showed him trust all of this ends with Palpatine’s Defeat in the office building, specially if mace showed trust and brought him along to arrest Palpatine.
Again Palpatine manipulated the situation because the council slapped Anakin earlier this he plays dead and plays the situation to his advantage. If Anakin had been there from the start of the encounter to arrest Palpatine. Mace and Anakin defeat Palpatine easy. Jedi win
I feel people blame Obiwan too much. Qui gon gave Anakin Skywalker the qui gon seal of approval qnd guarantee he is the chosen one. Which affected his teachings. Any other pupil Obiwan is perfect, Obiwan would be perfect for any other Padawan.... But not Anakin.... That doesn't mean Obiwan was a bad teacher. Anakin has a tendency to ignore even jedi wiser then Obiwan. Cut him at least a small amount of slack please??
he barely earned the rank of knight
He deserves it bro I don’t know what you’re talking about at times
He definitely didn’t based on the Films. Clone Wars maybe but even still.
Separatist propaganda
but how is he wrong though?
I respect your pointers here on this video but this is the only one I disagree with you on so far ✅
Anakin deserved the Rank of master 10 fold
Not only due to his abilities , potential & battlefield skill but the man literally walked the walk physically & talked the talk overall in my opinion 🤷🏾♂️
The Jedi council treated him like a absolute clown show from day one & they need to bear big responsibility in how he turned out
If I was Anakin & I got denied the Rank of MASTER in that situation I would have up ⬆️ & left the Jedi order right there & then SIMPLE!
The Jedi council showed jealousy , belittling , disrespect & literally sonning him like he was a child in that instance so yeah no thank you …
#GoodVideo 🔥🔥🔥🔥
then you would have fallen to the darkside just as Anakin cause you couldn't keep your ego in check
Anakin only got on the council cause Palpatine was manipulating circumstances to get him to trust him over the jedi
you are just a blind fool just like Anakin was and would have been Palps Vader easy
@
I’m a Sith supporter from the very beginning my brother ✅
If I was in that Star Wars universe I would have CHOSE the DarkSide path from day 1 not “FELL” ☝🏾
I abide by their codes , philosophy & way of being & im fully against the Jedi way as a whole so yeah understand that part because it forms my opinions on this particular subject …
Thi opinion is exactly why he didn't deserve the rank. Expecting to become a master as a matter of course shows you don't understand the fundamental principles of being a Jedi. If it's too happen, let it happen, don't force it. Let the force guide you
@@21forevergone The entire problem you are overlooking is not Anakin's maturity alone, but the Council's own ineptitude of handling Anakin.
Obi-Wan went to Anakin in private after the meeting in a scene where he tasked him to spy on the Chancellor himself. Anakin was deeply upset by this having already been frustration with his denial and immediately accuses the jedi council of betraying their morals by spying on an ally and ally of his no less. You are putting to the test a guy who is compromised by the person interfering in the affairs of your organization to spy for you when that goes against your own code? How do you think Anakin will respond to this?
The jedi council was doomed from the very beginning the moment they themselves fail to realize what was truly necessary and allow their own hubris to cloud their judgement. The council may oppress their emotions but they still have them. Anakin may shout them and verbalize his injustices but the Jedi simply acts on them with the same regard but have the audacity to pretend they aren't affected by things like loss and attachments. Yoda wouldn't have felt the need to avenge the entire Jedi order against Palpatine if he was truly "detached" but there he was at his chamber dueling him.
The smartest move was to make Anakin master and guide him directly. The closet way to survey a person and keep them from running loose like he did is to allow them to walk with you. The Jedi failed the politic check Palpatine set for them. I don't think Anakin deserves the rank either but in a very sensitive situation like that you must acquiesce to obtain something greater. Who knows maybe Anakin would have felt "COMMUNION" with the very Jedi order if he was acknowledged.
@@21forevergone this just shows that You don't understand, Anakin was a hero in the republic and trained Hasoka to the point where she survived battlefields where masters died, if you said he shouldn't become part of the council I would agree but the position of Jedi Master was his right
Whaat? 🤨 this is outrageous 😆
Nice Video, In my opinion I believe that Anakin does deserve to get the Rank of Jedi Master. I truly believe that if he was a Jedi Master he wouldn't turn to the Darkside and wouldn't go near Palpatine since he would be a Master, I think Anakin truly loved Padmé and would do anything to save her since he didn't know. Anakin would be able to go to the Jedi archives and Learn the secrets and find what he's looking for, so then he wouldn't go to Palpatine as much as he did which was why I think that he didn't get the Master rank. The Jedi didn't trust him and if anyone were in his shoes you'll see his point and I think that Jedi Code and rules are to strict and expect everyone to be like them and that doesn't sit well on anyone, and the Jedi didn't even have therapy for Anakin to help with his emotions and that's completely different from taking younglings from birth and has grown with normal human behaviours and emotions to go to the Jedi and remove of his emotions like its nothing, and expect him to learn this, and this is why some may struggle with basic emotions this isn't healthy for them and the believe this is part of being a Jedi is, and if Jedi had known or learned how to control attachment and emotions which is normal I believe he'll be fine. and if Ahsoka didn't leave the order he would've been a Jedi Master before the event of Revenge Of The Sith. You can say the concil did the right thing of not giving him the Rank of Master but I think Anakin should've gotten the Rank of Master.
and I understand what the video say which have good points to add but I think he deserve it. That's my opinion, my personal opinion and I'd like to hear yours why he think he does or doesnt deserve to be a Master Jedi. 😀😀😀
I agree with this. The Jedi should've helped Anakin. If Qui Gon was his master, he would've helped Anakin deal with his issues and none of this would've happened.
Anakin deserved it, honestly. He the rising star if the order, being the biggest war hero showing his leadership, trained ashoka. Beat count dooku when other masters didn't stood a chance. Had greater skill and power than most of the masters than being denied the rank when he has achieved more then most master have in their entire life. They should of just let anakin have the rank.
Nah. L take
From the moment he joined the order they treated him like shit. I was always surprised that as strong as Anakin was in the force he couldn’t feel that the Jedi and their codes were at cross purposes with his. I never could’ve been a Jedi.
And not giving him the rank of master cost them their lives and the lives of the entire galaxy. If they had just given it to him like they were supposed to Anakin would have had no need for Sideous at all because the new rank would have given him access to the restricted section in the Jedi temple and he would have found what he needed for his wife. The Jedi made every wrong choice possible when it came to Anakin and the entire galaxy paid the price for it. Anakin would have never made the decisions that he did if it wasn’t for the foolishness of the Jedi council. Very bad take and an instant dislike for me.
You have as much understanding about what it means to be a Jedi as Anakin does. None at all.
@ Any flaws that Anakin had (which wasn’t even very many during the time of ROTS because he had grown up a lot throughout the war) was nothing compared to all the good that he had done and all the lives he had saved. He was also far more powerful than most of the Jedi in the order. He had more than enough qualifications to be worthy of the rank of master but the Jedi council’s own fear, arrogance, complacency, and assumptions ruined everything because they couldn’t trust in the living force like Qui Gon did. If Adi Gallia could go out in such a weak and embarrassing manner at the hands of Savage Oppress and have the rank of Jedi master then Anakin definitely should. I expect nothing less from an obvious Anakin hater who clearly doesn’t understand anything. Anakin was the freaking hero and poster boy of the republic and won them more battles than any of the other Jedi ever did. Anakin actually genuinely cared about others and their well being while almost all the other Jedi didn’t even give a crap. They would just give some lame and lazy excuse such as it is the will of the force so you should just do nothing and let them die and do not care at all for whatever happens to them or what they may be going through. You’re just as simple and narrow minded as the Jedi council was.
@@SeminooosI can see why you're such a fan boy of Anakin. You're as much a whiny crybaby as he is! 😂
Really though, all that writing you did just proves my point. You don't know anything about what it takes to be a Jedi. You missed the whole point of the video because of your love for Anakin ❤ For what it's worth, you would have been just as much a failure of a Jedi as he was.
@@noname01xr And you would deserve the fate of the Jedi just as much as they did. You’re a fan boy of the Jedi council because you can’t even acknowledge any of the obvious flaws that they had that I already pointed out.
@@SeminooosYou think I should die because we have a disagreement about a fictional character. I honestly feel a little sorry for you. Your life must be really sad if you think another person should be killed over something as trivial as Star Wars. I hope things improve for you.
How dare you! he totally did deserve master Jedi.