Thanks so much for watching! :D If you want to trade with the top villagers a lot, you can place a workstation to their side, and make sure they link to it. Then it'll be a mini trading hall too! If you liked this video, consider subscribing for more! You'll be helping us reach 450k subs!! 😋 Happy holidays everyone!!!
I am having issues with villagers on my world they never want to link up to different work stations and all want the same one even if there is enough of the work stations
Todays date is 14th March 2024. Just built this exactly as instructed in bedrock 1.20.70 and can confirm it works perfectly, within about 30 mins or so I had 1 adult in the minecart, 7 adults in the waiting area and just over a dozen babies waiting to grow up. And I didn't remove the trapdoor and it works.
@michaelluster5072 Yup, all I've had to do is give both the villagers up top a stack of food a couple items but yh it still works fine, every now a nitwit will get into the minecart but just kill em and another villager will happily step on.
I have just gotten my first elytra, and now I am working on getting a mending villager. You delivered and I didn't even have to hit the search bar. I have been watching you for a few weeks now. Thank you for your informative videos.
If your looking for a mending villager I suggest getting one villager alone in an area with only a lecturn near by for it to link to, check the trade if he doesn't have the mending trade you can break the lecturn and replace it and he will have a different trade
I swear you are a life saver when it comes to build tutorials and just farms and stuff in general. I'm not very good at making farms on my own even though I've been playing the game for over a year now but it's nice to see somebody looking out for bedrock players
Your upload timing couldn't have been better. I was visiting the old breeder, and saw the villagers off of their boats. I reset them to their positions just to find them off the boat again moments later. I'll use this tutorial to tweak mainly the top area of the breeder. Always appreciate you being on top of all things Bedrock, silentwisperer!
It's like you read my mind. I was having trouble with the last breeder since the update: one villager always escapes the boat and breaks the breeder, and babies wouldn't fall into the baby chamber. This one looks compact and has easy pick-up. Thanks Silent!
As of 11/11/22 I found that if you have no trap door, mob griefing turned ON, and you don't over feed the villagers they should start to breed. Having at least one work station may help, you might have to trade with at least one villager. I even extended the top part of the build by one block to allow the adults to move more. Hopefully this helps anyone struggling to get this farm to work!
Great farm silent. I'm new to minecraft - basically got into it to be able to share it with my kids and your farms are fantastic (and make me look like I know what I'm doing!).
Ive used silent's channel for years now. His tutorials are great for both begginers and advanced players. I too use them for my kids servers. I recently used his mob farm on my kids realm combined with a gold farm to help them get xp after 1.18.12
Still works in 1.20.0!! Tips: •No trap door •Keep beds at same height of slabs •Place beds 1 block away from each side of the slabs to prevent breeding villagers from entering the beds •Have the 2 breeding villagers with a work place on each end above the slab instead of glass (fletching table; make sure they’re linked to their end’s workplace) •Do not over feed breeding villagers (just enough food to keep breeding)
@@taylormiles2587 Yes, having the trap door breaks the breeder. If it's there they never talk, trade food, and breed. If it's not there, the breeder works. I've never had this breeder work with the trap door present. Just stared at my last one for 15 minutes before remembering. Within 30 seconds of breaking the trap door I have 2 baby villagers.
I've been working on my villager trading hall for a few days (painstakingly porting villagers 1000 blocks to my base. This came just in time to ease my pain. Thanks silent. Keep up the amazing work, your vids are awesome
@@d10king94 same here, I fixed that by replacing (carefully!) the fenceposts with a block with a slab on top of it, but when I did that, they floated instead of sank on the water, meaning adults would be with the babies in the final chamber. This wasn't too much of a problem when I built silent's iron farm, but it was a big issue for silent's villager trading hall as babies would've caused a bit of a mess, so I just scrapped it and yeeted food into a pit full of villagers with beds spammed nearby.
@@d10king94 yep! I'm pretty sure that it will work but since the iron farm and villager trading hall are done I'm not gonna be messing with villagers in my world for a while (thankfully, they are a pain in every way possible...)
For all who build this as pf 05-21-2022 the way to fix his build is take the trap door out, turn on mob griefing in the settings, also be at least 150 blocks from the nearest workstation and make sure beds are close for both the top villagers and babies to choose a bed, remove the glass roof but build the walls higher first. I had to trouble shoot my villager breeder a bunch and those were the fixes i made to mine to get it to work properly
for anyone having problem even after removing the trapdoor and replacing the beds- try placing the beds one block higher and if that doesn’t work, replace the villagers. that’s what made it work for me. now it brought me four villagers after just a minute or two
Works very well in Bedrock. 6-18-24 Used to populate an iron farm and a trading center. Be careful with the build. Glass is terrible to build with. Thanks for creating this.
You are a HERO, this guide was super helpful and I was super intimidated at first. Your guides are top tier
3 года назад+4
Nice simple design. I lowered it into the ground (atop a hill) and made one side in glass so it's kinda like an antfarm. I had a problem with kids spilling over and running amok, but after hunting them down and... and putting them in an orphanage where they all get toys and breakfast, I took out the trapdoor in the middle and that seems to have worked. Every now and then I also get kids that float over into the adult chamber as soon as they're born, but at least they're contained.
Lovely design ♡ I was using the last one connected with the Iron Farm and redirecting them to a trading hall and works perfect! Will try this one since the previous design is kinda having some issues
Hey guys, if your having a hard time getting these guys to breed quickly, remove the fence gate between them. I couldn't get more than two villagers in the grow chamber until I removed the gate now I can get as many as I need at once
Best villager breeder, i gave the villagers a couple stacks of bread and they made 6 baby villagers in a mater of a minute. Thanks silent for making a easier and better build for Minecraft farms in the future!
Thank you for this villager breeder farm. Actually I really don't like making villager breeders like this but it really is such a hassle going from one village to another to trade for stuff so I decided (finally) to make a villager trading hall. Of course I'll need a villager breeder for the hall so here we are. Again, thank you. ps. It is still working as of Oct. 27, 2022.
I just have 2 villagers and 3 beds next to a nether portal. There is a 1 block tall gap that only allows the babies to go through into the other dimension, which causes them to disconnect from the third bed and allows the villagers to breed more. Been using this trusty strategy since the beginning of time!
Love it! Worked straightaway once I took the trapdoor out. I'm doing your golem and trading day too, so now just to connect them both. Thanks! Easy and clear vid to follow.
How did you connect the two? Sorry for the year late comment but I’m trying to do this exact thing, taking these villagers into the iron farm, how do you start the iron farm?
@@erroricuI transported the villagers using tracks to the trading hall (from the outside). My iron farm was built on top of the trading hall so the iron dropped into chests in the center.
It's over 12 months ago, but from memory I built exactly as the tutorial, but removed the trap door. I was playing on an iPad in survival for this world.
As someone who only watches people who play Java, but can't afford a gaming pc to play it myself, I'm always confused on the differences between each version. Thanks for the tutorial!
Ok so I’ve built your breeder step by step and I built exactly what you just told me. But when I put those two villagers in the chamber, one of them suddenly claimed a profession, and he absolutely refuses to breed, even if I give him any crops he just won’t accept it other than his companion. Any ideas how to fix?
I was having problems with this breeder, my babies would dive into the water and at the bottom, just a tiny bit of their forehead would still be in the water and they would eventually make their way into the adult part. Made a copy of the world and went into creative and had the same problem was going to post here asking for help but found the fix. Removing the source water from above the buttons (so the only water that you put down was the first one) got the breeder working again. Love the vide
What is the purpose of the trap door? My villagers never breed automatically with it’s presence. 1 villager kept throwing potatoes at the other village while the other villager kept ignoring him until I opened the trap door under him. I could only breed them twice in a session before having to quit and return in order to continue the process until I decided to break the trap door and now they’re breeding much more
@@coreybrisiel5516 the reason why they stopped is either because there aren’t enough beds or bread If neither options work, try replacing the villagers
Thank you so much for these tutorials! I just started a new world that is going to be my new PERMANENT world and these are so useful. I used this one and the trading hall one. Thank You!
1.20, atill works. Do not place the trapdoor. I've only gotten the villagers to breed after a few (30-60) seconds. Make sure you have mob griefing turned on. Two stacks of carrots give you ~8 baby villagers. I wonder if it is possible to hook an automated villager wheat/carrot farm to the breeder, with a hopper that is connected to a dispenser powered by a redstone clock. It should feed the villagers in the breeder automatically without player intervention and the only thing you will need is to afk for a few minutes.
Can confirm, as of 2/13/2023 no trap door and make sure beds are placed at eye level to the frisky fellows in the box, and you will have babies EVERYWHERE!
Thanks Silent. I have run into an issue since 1.18.12. As the babies fall down, they are jumping in the water stream and getting pushed into the adult chamber.
had this problem but i just found a solution. to fix it i replaced the chests with waterlogged lower slabs, and moved the flowing water down a block so it's only one layer.
I’ve just made it, removed the trap door and it’s still not working. They’ve definitely linked to the beds. I’ve traded with them both and put workstations close by. Nothing happens. When I throw them wheat, they don’t take it. Any suggestions?
Just what I needed lmao. My previous survival world got corrupted l, and I had to make a new one. I was literally just thinking about starting a new trading hall
@@silentwisperer ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Have you gotten the "Star Trader" achievement? It was very annoying, because you have to get a villager to the build limit. I lost about 20 villagers getting the achievement
Quick NOTE: feeding both villagers at the top may cause baby villagers to go into the adult cell. can get rid of them and nit wits, use mine cart to take them out, drop baby's into a holding area till they grow. push the nit wits into an area with an air block bellow, and a full block above . they suffocate very quick
@@Just_vibing327 you can wait for them to grow up, or you put the cart in same place as for the adults, and put them in a holding area until they grow up
Works amazing. One thing to make it easier to feed the two top villagers is to have 2 dispensers full of food facing the villagers and attach a simple redstone clock (7 Redstone dust and 2 repeaters) if they don't have any food in their inventory.
What happened to iron farms? I built your 1.17 iron farm and it still works just I get decreased rates. I know there were changes but how do they affect your previously made iron farms? Is there anyway I can adjust my current farm without making a brand new one? Or will there be a new farm design soon to accommodate the new changes?
@@silentwisperer I need to make quad iron farm but I need your help silent I don't know how much distance should I maintain between Iron farms and village so please check your Twitter account I mentioned you in tweet
Chek if you have enough villagers. If you just have 19 it doesn’t work to it’s full potential. You have to have 20 villagers to get the most rates from your iron farm.
A tip to start breeding them if you don't have enough food: You can make one of them a Fletcher and trade 32 sticks for one emerald, then you make the other villager a farmer and buy 6 loaves of bread for one emerald.
Today is 12 Oct 2024, playing on XboxOne Series X, Bedrock v 1.21.31, it still works perfectly, I followed the tutorial to the letter and it's all good. Didn't have to remove the trapdoor or make any changes. The only thing that might trip anyone up is at 3:28 he says to place another one of the stained white glass blocks opposite one of the buttons, truth is, if you followed the tutorial to the letter that block is already there.
This works wonders! I've never build a villager breeder before so I thought it would fail but now I have enough to run my trading hall and my iron farm! Thank you!
6:54 "Or even beetroot, if you're some sort of monster" 😆. Yes, we're trapping them in a glass box for eternity and forcing them to mate through a trapdoor, but there's no need to make it make it unpleasant...
Great video again silent but I'll use this when the "villager despawning bug" is fixed, 3 times this week alone all villagers in my iron farm, trading hall and breeder have despawned on realms, there's literally no point in doing anything with villagers until this is fixed
Thank you! I just started a new world with a village island spawn and due to villagers not being very bright, all but 2 are gone so I desperately need a way to make more ... well, as soon as I make the village dummyproof lol
Just build my second breeder in my survival world (1.20.72). I did replace the 2 glass blocks above the 2 breeding adults with 2 dispensers that I filled up with bread, but still need to test it in case the bread falls to the bottom. All that I have left to do now is to find a good, working iron farm and villager trading hall build tutorial
Works perfectly in ps4 1.19 Bedrock. Thanks to you i'm well on my way to making my villager trading hall :) infact i'm gonna watch your villager trading hall vid now to get er goin!
so i decided to afk it and when I came back, I kid you not, there was witches in place of the top villagers and zombified villagers in the baby and adult chambers. I even had torches everywhere. How should I deal with this?
I'm having trouble getting them to breed. I've thrown stacks on stacks to the villager, but it's just standing still. No cheats, xbox, newest update of 1.18. I did build it underground so maybe I should let in some sunlight? Edit: let it sunlight. No effect. Los iij ng interest in that world anyway
Thanks for the tutorial, I'm in need of a villager breeder, like that you can put it into the ground, am currently creating something to hold the breeder in creative to incorporate when I do my villager breeder on my world. Keep up the great tutorials, they are appreciated by many, myself included.
Nice! I like the floordesign on the breeding chamber, will definitely update my current breeder with that 👍. Also, you shouldn’t let your hatered of beets blind you to their use as villager feed. Even if they are somehow picked up by the babies, they have the benefit of being ”inert” which make them arguably better for this particular purpose than potatoes or carrots (that could theoretically be planted). They are also somewhat cheaper than bread (the other ”inert” option).
1.18 slime fram and Wich fram but what would be fun would be to use villagers as amo for some sort of weapon to kill fantims. Well maybe not to make or use but to woch
I am actually heart-shattered to say this farm doesn't work in 1.18.30 Bedrock, it was such a pain to get the villagers to the farm due to my seed, I have prepared a stack of 8 carrots for each villager, I gave it to them, AFK an hour, not a single baby was breed
I thought this too, I’ve been pulling my hair out for the last few days trying to get it to work as it just suddenly stopped. I even replaced the villagers and wasted upwards of 20 stacks of food and nothing was working. I, just before giving up, removed the trapdoor to see if it made a difference and it’s working completely fine again so that’s all you need to do to fix it. Just annoyed I wasted so much time.
@@silentwisperer yeah, I built the old one a while back and I was confused as to how my villager escaped the boat. The villager's escape was short-lived, however, as he soon died to a zombie with an iron shovel.
Just built on a new world and it wasn't working for me. the I realized I had mob griefing turned off, because my 5 year old son was playing earlier. once I turned off "mob griefing" the villagers started taking food and making baybayz - Thanks Silent!
Does anyone have any advice? Even after removing the trapdoor, and filling both villagers inventories completely with food, they will not breed/no hearts. What else could the problem be?!
Hey silent i found a new way od making a villager breeder First you put two villagers in a boat then push that boat in a bether portal they wont go through it bc mobs in boat cant go through portals but when they will bread since the boat already has two villager it will instantly go to the nether which i think helps with the efficiency
hello, first of all thank you for the tutorial, i did build it in my new 1.18 world and at the beginning it worked perfectly fine! :D but after around 30 villagers they stopped breeding… i did add more beds and threw them around 8 stacks of potatoes but no baby in sight… do you maybe know what else i could do to make the breed again? or do i have to start from scratch? :/
built this thing on java edition, had to remove the middle trapdoor, remove the roof and change some of the topper side glass blocks with vertical trapdoors as well. Only then the "angy villager" particles stopped appearing and the farm started working. (oh yeah and the buttons are destroyed by water, had to use signs instead)
not sure if anyone else is seeing this issue, but if there are alot of babies in the bottom area, the grown up villagers cannot flow freely into the adult chamber and end up drowning
Make sure your following the same exact steps shown here 2:25 break and replace with water source the 2 specific temporary blocks, leaving the middle one without water source.
I've used this build before but I didn't place the trap door because someone said to not do it in the latest patch but now they threw the bread at each other and just stare at each other intimately
PROTIP DEBUG (copy and paste from wiki): Villagers do not accept food or farm food themselves if gamerule "mobgriefing" is set to false. This makes villager breeding only possible with 'mobgriefing' set to true, as villagers cannot become fully "willing" without food.
Probably would be nice to recreate this mechanic in a flying machine, so we can get librarians from multiple biomes after the trading rebalance becomes permanent.
This works, cheers, but I would recommend re-building the glass a couple blocks higher to cover the villagers, if they get struck by lightning I believe they can turn into witches
I did a crossbreed with BobertPickles. His top half, you're bottom half. I never need to worry about feeding the villagers, and no extra babies until I pull them out of the system.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks so much for watching! :D If you want to trade with the top villagers a lot, you can place a workstation to their side, and make sure they link to it. Then it'll be a mini trading hall too!
If you liked this video, consider subscribing for more! You'll be helping us reach 450k subs!! 😋 Happy holidays everyone!!!
Could you make a totorial on how to properly link villagers up to beds/workstations? As they just link to random ones
You forgot the ps4/ps5 in the title
I am having issues with villagers on my world they never want to link up to different work stations and all want the same one even if there is enough of the work stations
It's the worst village farm is worst
They look slave for me it's sad
have you heard about minecraft worlds not loading for console especially ps4
Todays date is 14th March 2024. Just built this exactly as instructed in bedrock 1.20.70 and can confirm it works perfectly, within about 30 mins or so I had 1 adult in the minecart, 7 adults in the waiting area and just over a dozen babies waiting to grow up.
And I didn't remove the trapdoor and it works.
Literally came here to check if this was still working so thank you lol
@@captainred7882same here!
Does it still work?
@michaelluster5072 Yup, all I've had to do is give both the villagers up top a stack of food a couple items but yh it still works fine, every now a nitwit will get into the minecart but just kill em and another villager will happily step on.
My Adult waiting area keeps getting nothing but babies... I built it with a bigger drop the initial water area. could this be the problem?
I have just gotten my first elytra, and now I am working on getting a mending villager. You delivered and I didn't even have to hit the search bar. I have been watching you for a few weeks now. Thank you for your informative videos.
If your looking for a mending villager I suggest getting one villager alone in an area with only a lecturn near by for it to link to, check the trade if he doesn't have the mending trade you can break the lecturn and replace it and he will have a different trade
the one time I don't want a mending villager... (wanted unbreaking)
I end up with three in a row
XD
@@Mel-mu8ox I just started a new world and had just iron armour and on my like 5th try j got mending for only 10 emeralds
@@craigharrison6392 I hope its a great seed with many amazing adventures to come.
:D sounds like its already off to an great start :D
@@Mel-mu8ox yeah I hope so, I've not really done much exploring yet, thank you
If your villagers aren’t breeding and one of them is nonstop throwing food to the other one try removing the trapdoor. This fixed my farm instantly.
Thanks for the tip I had the same problem!
came here to ask why is it such an unilateral relationship 😭 thank you!!
You're right. It worked for me!
Bro thank you so much
for some reason one of my villagers just throws unlimited crops to the other one, and they arent breeding, not even hearts
I swear you are a life saver when it comes to build tutorials and just farms and stuff in general. I'm not very good at making farms on my own even though I've been playing the game for over a year now but it's nice to see somebody looking out for bedrock players
Your upload timing couldn't have been better.
I was visiting the old breeder, and saw the villagers off of their boats.
I reset them to their positions just to find them off the boat again moments later.
I'll use this tutorial to tweak mainly the top area of the breeder.
Always appreciate you being on top of all things Bedrock, silentwisperer!
yea the boat is having weird issues. not sure why 🥴
It's like you read my mind. I was having trouble with the last breeder since the update: one villager always escapes the boat and breaks the breeder, and babies wouldn't fall into the baby chamber. This one looks compact and has easy pick-up. Thanks Silent!
As of 11/11/22 I found that if you have no trap door, mob griefing turned ON, and you don't over feed the villagers they should start to breed. Having at least one work station may help, you might have to trade with at least one villager. I even extended the top part of the build by one block to allow the adults to move more. Hopefully this helps anyone struggling to get this farm to work!
thank you
mob griefing...
What if I do over feed
Great farm silent. I'm new to minecraft - basically got into it to be able to share it with my kids and your farms are fantastic (and make me look like I know what I'm doing!).
Nice
ohh how cute, hope you and your children can have much fun with the game
It’s lovely to hear your doing this for your kids!! My kids play games all day and I found it’s a good way to have fun 👍
I play more than my kido, but when she does play...
I envy her aptitude for building amazing things in a short amount of time
Ive used silent's channel for years now. His tutorials are great for both begginers and advanced players. I too use them for my kids servers. I recently used his mob farm on my kids realm combined with a gold farm to help them get xp after 1.18.12
Still works in 1.20.0!!
Tips:
•No trap door
•Keep beds at same height of slabs
•Place beds 1 block away from each side of the slabs to prevent breeding villagers from entering the beds
•Have the 2 breeding villagers with a work place on each end above the slab instead of glass (fletching table; make sure they’re linked to their end’s workplace)
•Do not over feed breeding villagers (just enough food to keep breeding)
do the beds for the babies need to be the same height as the slabs? or just for the breeding villagers?
@@jermychee191no
The trap door is fine as long as you give each villager food
How much food is enough to breed?
@@alexnewell2606 the minimum requirement is 3 bread each or 12 carrots/potatoes/beetroots each but I would give each villager a stack of food.
1.18+ UPDATE: Remove the trap door. That is all.
Does it break the breeder in any way?
@@taylormiles2587 sometimes the villager will just throw food to the other and it will pick it back up. I haven’t found a fix yet
Thank you!
@@taylormiles2587 Yes, having the trap door breaks the breeder. If it's there they never talk, trade food, and breed. If it's not there, the breeder works. I've never had this breeder work with the trap door present. Just stared at my last one for 15 minutes before remembering. Within 30 seconds of breaking the trap door I have 2 baby villagers.
OMG thank you! I felt like I was going crazy! Instant fix! ❤
I've been working on my villager trading hall for a few days (painstakingly porting villagers 1000 blocks to my base. This came just in time to ease my pain. Thanks silent. Keep up the amazing work, your vids are awesome
You can just bring two in and breed them its the easiest way
My survival farm is filled with your farms. You make the most efficient bedrock farms. Hats off to you man!
Thank you for the new villager breeder! Was having troubles with the last one, couldnt figure it out, and this is going to be very useful!
Me too. Something about the water mechanics and where the babies dropped messed it up I guess
@@chickenspaceprogram yea, not sure, for me, the babies didnt fall into the chamber and just sat on the fence post
@@d10king94 same here, I fixed that by replacing (carefully!) the fenceposts with a block with a slab on top of it, but when I did that, they floated instead of sank on the water, meaning adults would be with the babies in the final chamber. This wasn't too much of a problem when I built silent's iron farm, but it was a big issue for silent's villager trading hall as babies would've caused a bit of a mess, so I just scrapped it and yeeted food into a pit full of villagers with beds spammed nearby.
@@chickenspaceprogram that certainly works XD, hopefully this design is now working for you though
@@d10king94 yep! I'm pretty sure that it will work but since the iron farm and villager trading hall are done I'm not gonna be messing with villagers in my world for a while (thankfully, they are a pain in every way possible...)
I was struggling with this right now haha, always dropping these videos In the right time, great work
I LITERALLY WAS ABOUT TO BUILD ONE OF THESE! Once again, perfect timing
Same lol
For all who build this as pf 05-21-2022 the way to fix his build is take the trap door out, turn on mob griefing in the settings, also be at least 150 blocks from the nearest workstation and make sure beds are close for both the top villagers and babies to choose a bed, remove the glass roof but build the walls higher first. I had to trouble shoot my villager breeder a bunch and those were the fixes i made to mine to get it to work properly
Removing the glass roof worked for me. Thanks a lot! 🙃
for anyone having problem even after removing the trapdoor and replacing the beds- try placing the beds one block higher and if that doesn’t work, replace the villagers. that’s what made it work for me. now it brought me four villagers after just a minute or two
or just don’t use farmers? idk my first ones were farmed so that could be it too
What beds, the one on the sides for the baby’s or the ones right in front of them?
@@demasctitan7551 the one in front of them
"And you can send it off into an iron farm or whatever."
* sends them to the afterlife *
Lol!
Godly reply
Works very well in Bedrock. 6-18-24 Used to populate an iron farm and a trading center. Be careful with the build. Glass is terrible to build with. Thanks for creating this.
Can you do a tutorial on the raid farm you used in the truly bedrock server? Love your videos ❤️
Yasss
I think he already has
No he said he might release a tutorial in January but he doesn't want to release them so close together. I really want it
@@marcusgonzalez8208 what video is that? Please help :/
@@GatsbysGreenLight he hasn't
You are a HERO, this guide was super helpful and I was super intimidated at first. Your guides are top tier
Nice simple design. I lowered it into the ground (atop a hill) and made one side in glass so it's kinda like an antfarm. I had a problem with kids spilling over and running amok, but after hunting them down and... and putting them in an orphanage where they all get toys and breakfast, I took out the trapdoor in the middle and that seems to have worked. Every now and then I also get kids that float over into the adult chamber as soon as they're born, but at least they're contained.
That’s the same problem I’m having but honestly it’s not that big of a bother. They just all grow up together. I don’t need them that urgently
I built this today 09/04/2022 on Bedrock Switch and it still works perfectly WITHOUT the trap door !
Lovely design ♡ I was using the last one connected with the Iron Farm and redirecting them to a trading hall and works perfect! Will try this one since the previous design is kinda having some issues
same
Just used a modified version of this, per this video, to build a triple village auto-farm using five villagers total.
Works lovely. Thank you! 🤗
Hey guys, if your having a hard time getting these guys to breed quickly, remove the fence gate between them. I couldn't get more than two villagers in the grow chamber until I removed the gate now I can get as many as I need at once
Thanks! I threw countless carrots to mine but they just wouldnt breed. Hoping this helps
I tried this and it didnt work. I eventually just decided to make a room full of beds with villagers
Best villager breeder, i gave the villagers a couple stacks of bread and they made 6 baby villagers in a mater of a minute. Thanks silent for making a easier and better build for Minecraft farms in the future!
Thank you for this villager breeder farm. Actually I really don't like making villager breeders like this but it really is such a hassle going from one village to another to trade for stuff so I decided (finally) to make a villager trading hall. Of course I'll need a villager breeder for the hall so here we are. Again, thank you.
ps. It is still working as of Oct. 27, 2022.
I just have 2 villagers and 3 beds next to a nether portal. There is a 1 block tall gap that only allows the babies to go through into the other dimension, which causes them to disconnect from the third bed and allows the villagers to breed more. Been using this trusty strategy since the beginning of time!
Can you post a video or pic on RUclips of your design? I'd like to recreate it in my world!
@@Twigster Sure! I'll make a short video about it soon just for you. :]
Love it! Worked straightaway once I took the trapdoor out. I'm doing your golem and trading day too, so now just to connect them both. Thanks! Easy and clear vid to follow.
How did you connect the two? Sorry for the year late comment but I’m trying to do this exact thing, taking these villagers into the iron farm, how do you start the iron farm?
@@erroricuI transported the villagers using tracks to the trading hall (from the outside). My iron farm was built on top of the trading hall so the iron dropped into chests in the center.
@@ennkay5132 this shows how good the mc community is right here
@@ennkay5132 are the beds in the same place?
It's over 12 months ago, but from memory I built exactly as the tutorial, but removed the trap door. I was playing on an iPad in survival for this world.
As someone who only watches people who play Java, but can't afford a gaming pc to play it myself, I'm always confused on the differences between each version. Thanks for the tutorial!
Ok so I’ve built your breeder step by step and I built exactly what you just told me. But when I put those two villagers in the chamber, one of them suddenly claimed a profession, and he absolutely refuses to breed, even if I give him any crops he just won’t accept it other than his companion. Any ideas how to fix?
same problem
@@perosinalmc7143 have you removed the trapdoor?
@@perosinalmc7143 same
take out the trapdoor. heard it works for most when you do that
I was having problems with this breeder, my babies would dive into the water and at the bottom, just a tiny bit of their forehead would still be in the water and they would eventually make their way into the adult part. Made a copy of the world and went into creative and had the same problem was going to post here asking for help but found the fix. Removing the source water from above the buttons (so the only water that you put down was the first one) got the breeder working again. Love the vide
What is the purpose of the trap door?
My villagers never breed automatically with it’s presence. 1 villager kept throwing potatoes at the other village while the other villager kept ignoring him until I opened the trap door under him. I could only breed them twice in a session before having to quit and return in order to continue the process until I decided to break the trap door and now they’re breeding much more
My villager keeps throwing bread to the other one. Do you think breaking the trap door would help?
They bred alot for a bit then haven't since
@@coreybrisiel5516 the trap door is useless
@@coreybrisiel5516 the reason why they stopped is either because there aren’t enough beds or bread
If neither options work, try replacing the villagers
@@Mike53534 put more beds on the same level as them and removed trap door and its working again
I just build this on my realms. It is working with a nitwit. It is an awesome farm. Now I can start my trading hall.
Thank you so much for these tutorials! I just started a new world that is going to be my new PERMANENT world and these are so useful. I used this one and the trading hall one. Thank You!
1.20, atill works. Do not place the trapdoor. I've only gotten the villagers to breed after a few (30-60) seconds. Make sure you have mob griefing turned on. Two stacks of carrots give you ~8 baby villagers.
I wonder if it is possible to hook an automated villager wheat/carrot farm to the breeder, with a hopper that is connected to a dispenser powered by a redstone clock. It should feed the villagers in the breeder automatically without player intervention and the only thing you will need is to afk for a few minutes.
Can confirm, as of 2/13/2023 no trap door and make sure beds are placed at eye level to the frisky fellows in the box, and you will have babies EVERYWHERE!
thank. you. i couldnt get this to work for ages until i moved the beds higher. life saver
Such perfect timing I'm in the middle of making your crazy iron farm and I'm having trouble with the previous villager breeder with the new update
Thanks Silent. I have run into an issue since 1.18.12. As the babies fall down, they are jumping in the water stream and getting pushed into the adult chamber.
i have this problem aswell
had this problem but i just found a solution. to fix it i replaced the chests with waterlogged lower slabs, and moved the flowing water down a block so it's only one layer.
Can u just replace the chest with honeyblocks?
@@Odien222zxs no, that doesn't work. read my comment above for the fix.
Great design! the only issue i had was that once time a baby villager somehow ended up in the adult spot (he was the only one there though)
Tested in the latest version of Minecraft Bedrock and it works perfect, only modification needed was to remove the trapdoor
I’ve just made it, removed the trap door and it’s still not working. They’ve definitely linked to the beds. I’ve traded with them both and put workstations close by. Nothing happens. When I throw them wheat, they don’t take it. Any suggestions?
Bro they need bread to breed not wheat@@shaunbarratt5541
@@shaunbarratt5541 cant use wheat to breed them need breed or carrots anything but wheat i think will work
Just what I needed lmao. My previous survival world got corrupted l, and I had to make a new one. I was literally just thinking about starting a new trading hall
ah man sorry to hear that:(
@@silentwisperer ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Have you gotten the "Star Trader" achievement? It was very annoying, because you have to get a villager to the build limit. I lost about 20 villagers getting the achievement
Quick NOTE:
feeding both villagers at the top may cause baby villagers to go into the adult cell.
can get rid of them and nit wits,
use mine cart to take them out, drop baby's into a holding area till they grow.
push the nit wits into an area with an air block bellow, and a full block above . they suffocate very quick
where would i place the mine cart to get them out?
@@Just_vibing327 you can wait for them to grow up, or you put the cart in same place as for the adults, and put them in a holding area until they grow up
Works amazing. One thing to make it easier to feed the two top villagers is to have 2 dispensers full of food facing the villagers and attach a simple redstone clock (7 Redstone dust and 2 repeaters) if they don't have any food in their inventory.
What happened to iron farms? I built your 1.17 iron farm and it still works just I get decreased rates. I know there were changes but how do they affect your previously made iron farms? Is there anyway I can adjust my current farm without making a brand new one? Or will there be a new farm design soon to accommodate the new changes?
all my recent iron farms work perfectly. there basically hasn't been any meaningful changes in a couple years now:)
@@silentwisperer I need to make quad iron farm but I need your help silent I don't know how much distance should I maintain between Iron farms and village so please check your Twitter account I mentioned you in tweet
@@jkplays8512 I’m pretty sure if you leave about 100 blocks you should be fine... I did with no problems at all
His iron farm doesn't decrease rate, its always been that rate
Chek if you have enough villagers. If you just have 19 it doesn’t work to it’s full potential. You have to have 20 villagers to get the most rates from your iron farm.
A tip to start breeding them if you don't have enough food: You can make one of them a Fletcher and trade 32 sticks for one emerald, then you make the other villager a farmer and buy 6 loaves of bread for one emerald.
Do you have to build this, an iron farm, and a trading hall a certain distance apart?
Converted the older build I had on my PS4 realm and this version works great. No more issues with the boat. Yay!!
Today is 12 Oct 2024, playing on XboxOne Series X, Bedrock v 1.21.31, it still works perfectly, I followed the tutorial to the letter and it's all good. Didn't have to remove the trapdoor or make any changes.
The only thing that might trip anyone up is at 3:28 he says to place another one of the stained white glass blocks opposite one of the buttons, truth is, if you followed the tutorial to the letter that block is already there.
This works wonders! I've never build a villager breeder before so I thought it would fail but now I have enough to run my trading hall and my iron farm! Thank you!
Great timing! I’m about to build one. Thank you! I was just about to build the old boat one, but was worried about the boat bugs.
Same, I need villagers for my trading hall and this is perfect timing!
That boat bug has been causing me a lot of trouble lately
Literally yesterday I was thinking that I needed a village breeder. Fantastic.
6:54 "Or even beetroot, if you're some sort of monster" 😆. Yes, we're trapping them in a glass box for eternity and forcing them to mate through a trapdoor, but there's no need to make it make it unpleasant...
Ok so I built this next to one your raid farms and when the raid was completed they all blew themselves up with fireworks and it was pretty funny
Is sending the babies to the nether still viable for an infinite breeder?
Great video again silent but I'll use this when the "villager despawning bug" is fixed, 3 times this week alone all villagers in my iron farm, trading hall and breeder have despawned on realms, there's literally no point in doing anything with villagers until this is fixed
Any idea when this is being fixed. Thought I was going mad, they kept disappearing. Got mine all traded up and then gone :(
Just a heads, mob griefing needs to be enabled for the villagers to breed!
Thank you! I just started a new world with a village island spawn and due to villagers not being very bright, all but 2 are gone so I desperately need a way to make more ... well, as soon as I make the village dummyproof lol
Love ❤️ how simple and efficient it Is thank you 🙏🏼
Just build my second breeder in my survival world (1.20.72).
I did replace the 2 glass blocks above the 2 breeding adults with 2 dispensers that I filled up with bread, but still need to test it in case the bread falls to the bottom.
All that I have left to do now is to find a good, working iron farm and villager trading hall build tutorial
if u looking for crazy iron farm go look at jWats05's 11k per hour iron farm
200,000 villagers are ready, with a million more well on the way
Works perfectly in ps4 1.19 Bedrock. Thanks to you i'm well on my way to making my villager trading hall :) infact i'm gonna watch your villager trading hall vid now to get er goin!
so i decided to afk it and when I came back, I kid you not, there was witches in place of the top villagers and zombified villagers in the baby and adult chambers. I even had torches everywhere. How should I deal with this?
😂 Noted. I'll make sure to put a lightning rod next to mine. That sucks though man
I literally just put a huge building around it@@broodingtree2014
6:53 "or even beetroot if you are some sort of monster" casually roasts tizztom lol
just doing my duty 😎
@@silentwisperer lol
Check mob grieving is on cause the last I tested one of your designs in creative, I thought it was broken.
oh true. that needs to be on so they can pick up items!
@@silentwisperer I was messing around in settings thinking it had something to do with the gamemode, then I stumbled across that.
i just want to say that you can use a nitwit and it works perfectly fine! great design!!
I'm having trouble getting them to breed. I've thrown stacks on stacks to the villager, but it's just standing still. No cheats, xbox, newest update of 1.18. I did build it underground so maybe I should let in some sunlight?
Edit: let it sunlight. No effect. Los iij ng interest in that world anyway
Break the trap door. :-)
Thanks for the tutorial, I'm in need of a villager breeder, like that you can put it into the ground, am currently creating something to hold the breeder in creative to incorporate when I do my villager breeder on my world. Keep up the great tutorials, they are appreciated by many, myself included.
Nice! I like the floordesign on the breeding chamber, will definitely update my current breeder with that 👍.
Also, you shouldn’t let your hatered of beets blind you to their use as villager feed. Even if they are somehow picked up by the babies, they have the benefit of being ”inert” which make them arguably better for this particular purpose than potatoes or carrots (that could theoretically be planted). They are also somewhat cheaper than bread (the other ”inert” option).
1.18 slime fram and Wich fram but what would be fun would be to use villagers as amo for some sort of weapon to kill fantims. Well maybe not to make or use but to woch
I am actually heart-shattered to say this farm doesn't work in 1.18.30 Bedrock, it was such a pain to get the villagers to the farm due to my seed, I have prepared a stack of 8 carrots for each villager, I gave it to them, AFK an hour, not a single baby was breed
I thought this too, I’ve been pulling my hair out for the last few days trying to get it to work as it just suddenly stopped. I even replaced the villagers and wasted upwards of 20 stacks of food and nothing was working. I, just before giving up, removed the trapdoor to see if it made a difference and it’s working completely fine again so that’s all you need to do to fix it. Just annoyed I wasted so much time.
@@izaakmcquade bro i was so confused why mine wasnt working phahaha
Thanks
I made your old design in which the breeding villagers are in a boat a few days ago; does that one still work well enough?
yea it works fine:) sometimes the villagers glitch out of the boat for unknown reasons, though. bit annoying.
Boat bugs + harder to make (relatively)
@@silentwisperer Okay, thanks.
@@silentwisperer yeah, I built the old one a while back and I was confused as to how my villager escaped the boat. The villager's escape was short-lived, however, as he soon died to a zombie with an iron shovel.
Mine still works but its more glitchy.
Just built on a new world and it wasn't working for me. the I realized I had mob griefing turned off, because my 5 year old son was playing earlier. once I turned off "mob griefing" the villagers started taking food and making baybayz - Thanks Silent!
Oh my god you don't realise how much of a legend you are thank you SO much I didn't know what I was doing wrong
Does anyone have any advice? Even after removing the trapdoor, and filling both villagers inventories completely with food, they will not breed/no hearts. What else could the problem be?!
i have the same problem!
cannot believe how effective this was, tested first on creative and forgot to take mob briefing on so they didn't pick up food for a while...
june 6th 2024
1.20+ can confirm it works on bedrock pc edition
Look at that timing. This was literally my next thing I wanted to work on. Legend
Does anything happen of you accidentally hit one of them
nope
Hey silent i found a new way od making a villager breeder
First you put two villagers in a boat then push that boat in a bether portal they wont go through it bc mobs in boat cant go through portals but when they will bread since the boat already has two villager it will instantly go to the nether which i think helps with the efficiency
hello, first of all thank you for the tutorial, i did build it in my new 1.18 world and at the beginning it worked perfectly fine! :D
but after around 30 villagers they stopped breeding… i did add more beds and threw them around 8 stacks of potatoes but no baby in sight… do you maybe know what else i could do to make the breed again? or do i have to start from scratch? :/
Same here. I can’t get it to work and I only need 4 more villagers
Idk what your using as food I was using wheat and just got it working again by giving bread
@@adomaszowec5 Idk what your using as food I was using wheat and just got it working again by giving bread
is there a villager cap i don‘t know about?
@@adomaszowec5 i have tried everything to make it work again but no luck for me… built a new one around 500 blocks away and it worked perfectly again
built this thing on java edition, had to remove the middle trapdoor, remove the roof and change some of the topper side glass blocks with vertical trapdoors as well. Only then the "angy villager" particles stopped appearing and the farm started working. (oh yeah and the buttons are destroyed by water, had to use signs instead)
I did this and gave them 7 stacks of bread and traded with them but it still wont make more than 16 villagers
Its working now 🎉
OK IDK Followed everything and all they do is toss food back n forth even took out trap door as recommended by comments and still nothing. any ideas?
give a bit more food
not sure if anyone else is seeing this issue, but if there are alot of babies in the bottom area, the grown up villagers cannot flow freely into the adult chamber and end up drowning
A lot of my villagers are drowning. I built it correctly and like 40-50% of the villagers drown as soon as they grow.
Make sure your following the same exact steps shown here 2:25 break and replace with water source the 2 specific temporary blocks, leaving the middle one without water source.
Or just let them keep dying. Villagers cause so much problems.
I've used this build before but I didn't place the trap door because someone said to not do it in the latest patch but now they threw the bread at each other and just stare at each other intimately
PROTIP DEBUG (copy and paste from wiki): Villagers do not accept food or farm food themselves if gamerule "mobgriefing" is set to false. This makes villager breeding only possible with 'mobgriefing' set to true, as villagers cannot become fully "willing" without food.
Thank you so much for your comment, I was building the farm in a test world and they were not breathing and I could not figure out why
omg that was what was killing my farm i bult it in so many locations i was going insain
Is there any way to do this on a realm without having to turn cheats on?
Probably would be nice to recreate this mechanic in a flying machine, so we can get librarians from multiple biomes after the trading rebalance becomes permanent.
I'm adding a trident killer.
Just built it with a carrot farm on top of it, put a couple farmers in there and a bunch of beds and it’s all automated
REMOVE GLASS ABOVE THE VILLAGERS. Make sure you add more glass on the side so they don't escape.
ill see if it works
Thank you it worked
This works, cheers, but I would recommend re-building the glass a couple blocks higher to cover the villagers, if they get struck by lightning I believe they can turn into witches
@@pingandpong674 Ya but thats just as likely as a genshin impact player getting bitches that aren't below 18
If only i had this 3 days earlier 😛 woulda saved me a lot of struggles with my iron farm
Ditto!
the water keeps breaking my buttons
then you aren't playing on bedrock and this exact design might not work for you
@@silentwispererdamn 2 years later and still got the support atleast ik it still works 😂
I love the intro where you say these villagers can be sent anywhere, and you have your’s going to a lava pit. 🤣
this works as of 31/12/2024
thank u
That’s 12/31/2024 for Americans
Thank you so much for this, this works so much better than my old breeder and it’s much more effective and efficient
I live Minecraft human trafficking simulator
Real
This is a slavery simulator
I did a crossbreed with BobertPickles. His top half, you're bottom half. I never need to worry about feeding the villagers, and no extra babies until I pull them out of the system.