I love this scene, because it highlights Hook's lack of hypocrisy. He stood up to Rumple when he was the dark one and holds his same values when the one he loves is the Dark One. Also, people saying that he's a dick for not loving dark Emma and that Belle loved dark Rumple missed the whole point of the scene. Rumbelle was an incredibly toxic relationship, Captain Swan cannot fall into their same patterns. Hook won't let that happen.
+no t cool Amen! No one can deny that he's truly a man of honor! The thing is he still loves her, but he knows that he can't fall into DO's game. Actually that "I loved you" was brilliant! Dark Emma was expecting that he would be by her side, as a puppet, but she is not in control. Hook's love is his strength. He knows there's something behind that pose and he's going find out what it is.
Giu-C Yes! Rumbelle has been nothing but a tragic ship, Dark Rumpel played Belle until the end and everyone saw how much of a toll that took on her. It's incredibly idiotic for anti-CS people to say that Hook is in the wrong here in comparison to Belle
no t cool Agree 100%. Belle didn't know the Darkness. She's a hero. Hook knows it quite well - because he's been there before. The Darkness can't play freely with him as it did with Belle.
EPIC SCENE. WHERE DO I START?? Reason 208402938490283428 why I love Killian Jones; Killian Jones has never once blamed anyone or anything for his former acts as a villain. He’s constantly admitted that his doings were his own. He never pointed fingers. He never used pity or his reason for revenge as an excuse. He doesn’t bullshit. He admits, just like he did tonight…he was a villain. And he is now doing everything in his power to redeem himself, but at the same time he never forgets who he used to be. THAT IS HOW YOU DO A REDEMPTION ARC :) AND this scene was important because Killian knows the Dark One, and he knows Emma. He knew that wasn’t Emma asking the question; it was the Dark One. But he spoke to the Emma he believes is still there somewhere when he said, “I loved you.” That confession isn’t a "breaking up" as some people want to say :( It’s just starting of a new way of fighting for the woman he loved and still loves. He loved who Emma was-the Emma that the darkness wants to erase forever. And this was the best course of action for him to take, imo :) Great moment in this episode, GREAT moment. Heartbreaking, YES. But they ARE endgame. NEVER forget that :)
Huntress4455 I agree with about everything you said, but sometimes, circumstances or people push us so far that they deserve at least some guilt for how you respond. I really think there are degrees of guilt on different people in a scenario like this. But yeah, in the end, we have free will.
in the words of Captain Jack Sparrow. "STOP BLOWING HOLES IN MY SHIP!" now that i got that out of the way, Emma should have known that out of everyone Hook knows how the Dark One works the most. He had just been under his control and almost got killed by RUmple last season so he knows how the Dark One lies, tricks, manipulates and plays games... she underestimated him which is why i think he will be the one to break thru to her
My CS shipper is heartbroken, but has a Hook lover (Hooker 😂) I felt like this was great character development. Admitting that he was the one who turned Rumple, it really shows that he really has changed, in my opinion.
Honestly, i think Emma is in control deep down inside and has a master plan.... she is appeasing the Darkness on the surface...which is why she keeps pleading for him to just "trust her"...i think those words are truely her and not the DO. Completing the dagger back with Excalibur may be what needs to be done to release the darkness?
+toadie107 i agree. watched up to current episodes show glimes of that if you pay attention. it also fits her personality. my only question is how is she hideing the truth from the darkness.
@@shellyhuff3694 I guess in the end, she knew how to make their interests align to a point, at such a point where she could break off and destroy the darkness in her and Killian, but she underestimated how low even a little darkness can bring you, and how far it can go to ruin plans with even the best of intentions
Hook is doing what is needed. He needs clarity now to find out what's behind that door at Emma's place and to find a way to save her from all this DO nonsense she's all pleased by. He's the one who can change the game guys.
This could very well be a hint of Hook being the dark one He says '' I loved you'' Which maybe he only said because of the darkness The real Hook would have said I love you
snuttanjonas89rocky late but I’m getting bad into this fandom - I disagree. Hook knows the dark one. He knows emma. He knows how the dark one works - the trickery, the games. And he knows Emma isn’t like that He knows the dark one would want him to admit he loves her, but he knows Emma would want him to be honest And the truth is, he loves Emma. Not the dark one, Emma. And this? This isn’t Emma.
well, when I say this behavior of Emma is sending Hook more to the darkside, you say No! what I'm glad about is the fact that finally he said it, that fact that he was the villain in Rumple's story to begin with!
Well her face completely changed when Hook mentioned that he had held that sword to his throat, I think she was more there to find something that had touched Rumple before he was the Dark One, but I don't think she knew what it would be until he said that. I have a feeling she was mostly there to find out what had touched him, but as we all now know (hopefully anyway, if you haven't finished season 5, which I think you most likely have, don't read anymore) she still loved him, she was doing all this because she loved him and wanted to destroy the darkness in them both. So she most likely also wanted to try to prove that she still loved him, but unfortunately for her, the darkness took over and made her become manipulative. I don't for one second believe that she was the same Emma that we have always known, the darkness did change her, but she still cared, and she was still doing everything she did for love.
I just finished season 4 on Netflix and season 5A isn't on Netflix and season 5B comes out in like a month I have to catch up but how? Someone help 😖😣😂
+Paz Morales thank u lemme try n see,some1 suggested an app but it airs nothing.i had movie tube b4 but it stopped any suggestions for an app you knw(pls?)
Watching him go nuts for us is so fun it's unreal you don't have to die for me to have my revenge on you Hook watching the woman you supposedly love slip away is so much more interesting.
Unpopular opinion, I love Jennifer Morrison but I didn't like her acting as the Dark one. I know darkness probably shows up differently, but I kind of love the gleefulness of Gold and Hook. Without the outfit she just sort of has a lower voice.
I hate that Hook couldn't see anything. She's happier as the DO. She said it herself, she was scarred and closed off but now sh's happy and 'an open book'. I don't understand why Hook can't just accept that. Why no one can accept that.
+AWildLibbyAppeared well... let's put it in these terms: you can be less scared and become "an open book" just being on drugs as well.... But is it worth? Your life will sooner or later go into a dark hole. The Dark One is - in Hook's words - "an evil manipulative killer" that has no mercy and does whatever it takes to get what he wants... Who wants to see a beloved one living in such a nightmare??? What Emma is enjoying now is the sense of unlimited power... that's tasty, yeah, but happy? I doubt it.
Yeah I get that, but he basically just said that he didn't love Emma anymore...the one he spent years trying to get love him...because she's cursed? Thats bull. She may have changed. She may be a bit different. But if he loves her as unconditionally as he claims, if she's his happy ending, surely he can see past all that? Rumple was Belles happy ending. She didn't even get a glimpse at the man behind the beast before he took his fate, yet she still lovd him. She still went back too him after everything. That's what true love is. Also, what was with the whole 'this kiss didn't work because I like being the DO' bull? Rumple liked the darkness. He lived for it. But true loves kiss still broke the curse, if only momentarily. These plot holes are endless.
+AWildLibbyAppeared No. NO. That’s terrible thinking. That’s the sort of logic that leads to people putting up with their partner’s addiction or bad behaviour. “If I love him enough, he’ll change.” Usually leading neatly to “He didn’t change, it’s my fault, I didn’t love him enough.” NO. Love doesn’t mean putting up with everything the other person does, it means calling them out when needed. Love doesn’t mean making excuses, it means being honest. Love is supposed to bring out the BEST in both of you, not require you to become worse in order to make it work. Right now, Emma is not trustworthy. She’s manipulative, she has an agenda, she’s selfish, and there’s nothing she won’t do in pursuit of her goal. I don’t understand how anyone can look at her right now and think “ah yes, here is someone you could be in a healthy relationship with, she just needs a little love.” NO. Bad thinking. Not romantic. Not healthy. Not good. Stop it. Emotional manipulation, selfishness, dishonesty… those are red flags to be avoided, not wounds to be healed with love. Emma doesn’t need to be loved and accepted in her current state. She needs an intervention. She needs to reject the darkness. And she needs people to be there for her and love her once she does. Because they KNOW that this is NOT THE REAL EMMA. The Dark One is an ENTIRELY SEPARATE ENTITY. It may be a part of Emma right now, but ultimately, it's NOT supposed to be who she is. She has people who love her - including Killian. And I am very very proud of all them for insisting on finding a way to cure her, for not giving in and accepting this, for differentiating between her and the thing possessing her. Because right now, she can’t be herself, she can’t have healthy relationships with anyone, she can’t be happy. And if you truly love someone, that is NOT a state you want them to stay in. (meta from winter-by-the-sea.tumblr.com)
+AWildLibbyAppeared Let's talk about Rumbelle. Rumple had a difficult decision to make at the end of the Frozen season: love or power. Of course he made the wrong choice because Belle commanded him to cross the town line e never come back. That was her "I loved you" moment. Did she love him less? Nope. But still she stood up against Darkness and faced it without being deceived by its games, maybe for the first time. Did that hurt? Of course it did. Both Rumple and Belle felt miserable. But, after that he came back to Storybrooke as the DO and deceived her again into taking the dagger back. Yet she still loved Rumple. One important thing about Belle is that now she knows more about the Darkness' games. She's not that innocent woman anymore that was unable to see that inside the DO there are two entities: the vessel and the Darkness. Yet she has grown as individual! And she's not blind anymore. Hook sees these two separated persona quite well. He knows the darkness intimately - his heart is not as pure as Belle's. Besides that he was the one who has spent over a century trying to destroy the DO. So he knows how the Darkness surrounds its prey and how easy is to be absorbed by it. He doesn't love Emma less. He's still fighting for her. But in that scene you see that he's addressing the DO and he needed to turn the table in that game: he stood up against the Darkness and made it clear that he wouldn't be deceived. But he also addressed Emma to remember that she would have to choose between love and power. That is what that "I loved you" means. It means that the clarity she claims is darkness because she's about to destroy family, friendship, light magic and true love - because as the DO she can't have it all! About the TLK some ppl are saying that Emma is enjoying the darkness so because of that it didn't work. Well, it's obvious that she likes it. Until now she didn't realize the price she'll have to pay for it. But let the theories come. I have no rush.
Huntress4455 Well said!!!! You've pointed out the definition of sick love... and real love can't be sick. It's all about everybody wins. If you loose, that's not love, that's desperate need and self disrespect. Real love is about loving yourself too, and feeling yourself as a whole - so you don't have to worry about finding your other half... If you start a relationship thinking that the person who is standing in front of you completes you, you're already in the wrong path. Love is about to multiply.
![OUAT - 5x08 'I love you, Emma Swan' [Emma & Killian]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WxyajbPZJAE/mqdefault.jpg)
![OUAT - 5x08 'I love you, Emma Swan' [Emma & Killian]](/img/tr.png)
I love this scene, because it highlights Hook's lack of hypocrisy. He stood up to Rumple when he was the dark one and holds his same values when the one he loves is the Dark One. Also, people saying that he's a dick for not loving dark Emma and that Belle loved dark Rumple missed the whole point of the scene. Rumbelle was an incredibly toxic relationship, Captain Swan cannot fall into their same patterns. Hook won't let that happen.
+no t cool Amen! No one can deny that he's truly a man of honor! The thing is he still loves her, but he knows that he can't fall into DO's game. Actually that "I loved you" was brilliant! Dark Emma was expecting that he would be by her side, as a puppet, but she is not in control. Hook's love is his strength. He knows there's something behind that pose and he's going find out what it is.
Giu-C Yes! Rumbelle has been nothing but a tragic ship, Dark Rumpel played Belle until the end and everyone saw how much of a toll that took on her. It's incredibly idiotic for anti-CS people to say that Hook is in the wrong here in comparison to Belle
no t cool Agree 100%. Belle didn't know the Darkness. She's a hero. Hook knows it quite well - because he's been there before. The Darkness can't play freely with him as it did with Belle.
This was both an amazing scene and heartbreaking scene.
i was crying god i love them
EPIC SCENE. WHERE DO I START??
Reason 208402938490283428 why I love Killian Jones;
Killian Jones has never once blamed anyone or anything for his former acts as a villain. He’s constantly admitted that his doings were his own. He never pointed fingers. He never used pity or his reason for revenge as an excuse. He doesn’t bullshit. He admits, just like he did tonight…he was a villain. And he is now doing everything in his power to redeem himself, but at the same time he never forgets who he used to be.
THAT IS HOW YOU DO A REDEMPTION ARC :)
AND this scene was important because Killian knows the Dark One, and he knows Emma. He knew that wasn’t Emma asking the question; it was the Dark One.
But he spoke to the Emma he believes is still there somewhere when he said, “I loved you.” That confession isn’t a "breaking up" as some people want to say :( It’s just starting of a new way of fighting for the woman he loved and still loves.
He loved who Emma was-the Emma that the darkness wants to erase forever. And this was the best course of action for him to take, imo :)
Great moment in this episode, GREAT moment. Heartbreaking, YES. But they ARE endgame. NEVER forget that :)
i second you)
Huntress4455 I agree with about everything you said, but sometimes, circumstances or people push us so far that they deserve at least some guilt for how you respond. I really think there are degrees of guilt on different people in a scenario like this. But yeah, in the end, we have free will.
It took me a year to understand Emma was talking about Killian being the DO and how it can make him better.
omg
I don’t get it
in the words of Captain Jack Sparrow. "STOP BLOWING HOLES IN MY SHIP!" now that i got that out of the way, Emma should have known that out of everyone Hook knows how the Dark One works the most. He had just been under his control and almost got killed by RUmple last season so he knows how the Dark One lies, tricks, manipulates and plays games... she underestimated him which is why i think he will be the one to break thru to her
+Killians .Hooker Yes. This. Totally.
yessss its so right
My CS shipper is heartbroken, but has a Hook lover (Hooker 😂) I felt like this was great character development. Admitting that he was the one who turned Rumple, it really shows that he really has changed, in my opinion.
Honestly, i think Emma is in control deep down inside and has a master plan.... she is appeasing the Darkness on the surface...which is why she keeps pleading for him to just "trust her"...i think those words are truely her and not the DO. Completing the dagger back with Excalibur may be what needs to be done to release the darkness?
+toadie107 i agree. watched up to current episodes show glimes of that if you pay attention. it also fits her personality. my only question is how is she hideing the truth from the darkness.
@@shellyhuff3694 I guess in the end, she knew how to make their interests align to a point, at such a point where she could break off and destroy the darkness in her and Killian, but she underestimated how low even a little darkness can bring you, and how far it can go to ruin plans with even the best of intentions
Whatever. Every OTP on this show has had a "break up." And Hook needs to distance himself from Evil!Emma. There's gonna be an awesome reunion :)
2020 anyone?No ohh ok
Me
Me
Me
Hook is doing what is needed. He needs clarity now to find out what's behind that door at Emma's place and to find a way to save her from all this DO nonsense she's all pleased by. He's the one who can change the game guys.
This could very well be a hint of Hook being the dark one
He says '' I loved you'' Which maybe he only said because of the darkness
The real Hook would have said I love you
snuttanjonas89rocky late but I’m getting bad into this fandom - I disagree.
Hook knows the dark one. He knows emma. He knows how the dark one works - the trickery, the games. And he knows Emma isn’t like that
He knows the dark one would want him to admit he loves her, but he knows Emma would want him to be honest
And the truth is, he loves Emma. Not the dark one, Emma. And this? This isn’t Emma.
well, when I say this behavior of Emma is sending Hook more to the darkside, you say No!
what I'm glad about is the fact that finally he said it, that fact that he was the villain in Rumple's story to begin with!
2:03 what did emma try to do, steal his sword? to heal Rumple? Hook was just a mean to an end?
I'm not sure. I don't know if it was always her plan to get the sword or if that was an after thought.
I think she was there to get the sword the entire time.
Well her face completely changed when Hook mentioned that he had held that sword to his throat, I think she was more there to find something that had touched Rumple before he was the Dark One, but I don't think she knew what it would be until he said that. I have a feeling she was mostly there to find out what had touched him, but as we all now know (hopefully anyway, if you haven't finished season 5, which I think you most likely have, don't read anymore) she still loved him, she was doing all this because she loved him and wanted to destroy the darkness in them both. So she most likely also wanted to try to prove that she still loved him, but unfortunately for her, the darkness took over and made her become manipulative. I don't for one second believe that she was the same Emma that we have always known, the darkness did change her, but she still cared, and she was still doing everything she did for love.
HEART BREAKING...
I just finished season 4 on Netflix and season 5A isn't on Netflix and season 5B comes out in like a month I have to catch up but how? Someone help 😖😣😂
They didn't break up. He never said he didn't love her. All he said was "I loved you" but that doesn't mean he doesn't STILL love her.
Emma has become terrible but did you see her face at the end she was about to burst into tears !
Oh my god!!!! Killian taking responsibility for being the "villain" with Milah and Rumple!
Well... Bam goes my precious ship... 😭😭😭
+Cute McBeauty The ship still sails :) no worries
Sunnysteff123 I know... but I quote Jack Sparrow the Wise: STOP BLOWING HOLES ON MY SHIP!!!! Lol.
thnx for uploading all these,,kindly may i knw where i cld watch full episode (got no cable)
+Paz Morales thank u lemme try n see,some1 suggested an app but it airs nothing.i had movie tube b4 but it stopped any suggestions for an app you knw(pls?)
+Paz Morales it's ok,,my appreciation for takin yr tym to upload n share wit us..thanks loads
Well i watch them on netflix and u can watch full episodes on RUclips but they coast money
this scene makes me feel so sad
Can you upload the clip where David gets a spot on the round table, and everybody's clapping?
Watching him go nuts for us is so fun it's unreal you don't have to die for me to have my revenge on you Hook watching the woman you supposedly love slip away is so much more interesting.
im in pain
This is nearly the same music from Emma killing killian
I love the dark one, she's got an edge to her
LLP
4:46 - 4:50 wtf is he saying I can't make it out 😣
Trinity Swegel what
Those times don’t exist
Trinity Swegel It ain't that long. 😕
GOD FUCKING DAMN IT THERE GOES CAPTAIN SWAN THANKS FOR RUINING MY ALL TIME OTP
+Jimin_A_K They're still endgame. This all part of their story
+no t cool well obviously but still! There goes my otp.
Unpopular opinion, I love Jennifer Morrison but I didn't like her acting as the Dark one. I know darkness probably shows up differently, but I kind of love the gleefulness of Gold and Hook. Without the outfit she just sort of has a lower voice.
I hate that Hook couldn't see anything. She's happier as the DO. She said it herself, she was scarred and closed off but now sh's happy and 'an open book'. I don't understand why Hook can't just accept that. Why no one can accept that.
+AWildLibbyAppeared well... let's put it in these terms: you can be less scared and become "an open book" just being on drugs as well.... But is it worth? Your life will sooner or later go into a dark hole. The Dark One is - in Hook's words - "an evil manipulative killer" that has no mercy and does whatever it takes to get what he wants... Who wants to see a beloved one living in such a nightmare??? What Emma is enjoying now is the sense of unlimited power... that's tasty, yeah, but happy? I doubt it.
Yeah I get that, but he basically just said that he didn't love Emma anymore...the one he spent years trying to get love him...because she's cursed? Thats bull. She may have changed. She may be a bit different. But if he loves her as unconditionally as he claims, if she's his happy ending, surely he can see past all that? Rumple was Belles happy ending. She didn't even get a glimpse at the man behind the beast before he took his fate, yet she still lovd him. She still went back too him after everything. That's what true love is.
Also, what was with the whole 'this kiss didn't work because I like being the DO' bull? Rumple liked the darkness. He lived for it. But true loves kiss still broke the curse, if only momentarily. These plot holes are endless.
+AWildLibbyAppeared No. NO. That’s terrible thinking. That’s the sort of logic that leads to people putting up with their partner’s addiction or bad behaviour. “If I love him enough, he’ll change.” Usually leading neatly to “He didn’t change, it’s my fault, I didn’t love him enough.” NO.
Love doesn’t mean putting up with everything the other person does, it means calling them out when needed. Love doesn’t mean making excuses, it means being honest. Love is supposed to bring out the BEST in both of you, not require you to become worse in order to make it work.
Right now, Emma is not trustworthy. She’s manipulative, she has an agenda, she’s selfish, and there’s nothing she won’t do in pursuit of her goal. I don’t understand how anyone can look at her right now and think “ah yes, here is someone you could be in a healthy relationship with, she just needs a little love.” NO. Bad thinking. Not romantic. Not healthy. Not good. Stop it.
Emotional manipulation, selfishness, dishonesty… those are red flags to be avoided, not wounds to be healed with love.
Emma doesn’t need to be loved and accepted in her current state. She needs an intervention. She needs to reject the darkness. And she needs people to be there for her and love her once she does. Because they KNOW that this is NOT THE REAL EMMA.
The Dark One is an ENTIRELY SEPARATE ENTITY. It may be a part of Emma right now, but ultimately, it's NOT supposed to be who she is.
She has people who love her - including Killian. And I am very very proud of all them for insisting on finding a way to cure her, for not giving in and accepting this, for differentiating between her and the thing possessing her. Because right now, she can’t be herself, she can’t have healthy relationships with anyone, she can’t be happy.
And if you truly love someone, that is NOT a state you want them to stay in.
(meta from winter-by-the-sea.tumblr.com)
+AWildLibbyAppeared Let's talk about Rumbelle. Rumple had a difficult decision to make at the end of the Frozen season: love or power. Of course he made the wrong choice because Belle commanded him to cross the town line e never come back. That was her "I loved you" moment. Did she love him less? Nope. But still she stood up against Darkness and faced it without being deceived by its games, maybe for the first time. Did that hurt? Of course it did. Both Rumple and Belle felt miserable. But, after that he came back to Storybrooke as the DO and deceived her again into taking the dagger back. Yet she still loved Rumple.
One important thing about Belle is that now she knows more about the Darkness' games. She's not that innocent woman anymore that was unable to see that inside the DO there are two entities: the vessel and the Darkness. Yet she has grown as individual! And she's not blind anymore.
Hook sees these two separated persona quite well. He knows the darkness intimately - his heart is not as pure as Belle's. Besides that he was the one who has spent over a century trying to destroy the DO. So he knows how the Darkness surrounds its prey and how easy is to be absorbed by it.
He doesn't love Emma less. He's still fighting for her. But in that scene you see that he's addressing the DO and he needed to turn the table in that game: he stood up against the Darkness and made it clear that he wouldn't be deceived. But he also addressed Emma to remember that she would have to choose between love and power. That is what that "I loved you" means. It means that the clarity she claims is darkness because she's about to destroy family, friendship, light magic and true love - because as the DO she can't have it all!
About the TLK some ppl are saying that Emma is enjoying the darkness so because of that it didn't work. Well, it's obvious that she likes it. Until now she didn't realize the price she'll have to pay for it. But let the theories come. I have no rush.
Huntress4455 Well said!!!! You've pointed out the definition of sick love... and real love can't be sick. It's all about everybody wins. If you loose, that's not love, that's desperate need and self disrespect. Real love is about loving yourself too, and feeling yourself as a whole - so you don't have to worry about finding your other half... If you start a relationship thinking that the person who is standing in front of you completes you, you're already in the wrong path. Love is about to multiply.
It's hook not Killion
Killian*
Well...
666