Greatest Mayor play ever. If you can't win normally, you go out in your own terms. Any person who considers that a throw is blatantly missing the rules of the game. No one to betray or throw, he chose who gets the win among the two parties who could, as last town. Coven celebrated too early.
it wasn't a kingmaker, since not voting coven would result in a town loss; which is a gamethrow for town since voting a coven member ends it in a draw. Also coven definitely deserved to lose for thinking they already won the game and outing themselves.
@@gabrielmoreno7112kingmakers were roles that had won or had win conditions completely separate from a faction. Exes, confirmed survs and the like. It did not matter who they won with and could do whatever. Being the last town in an unwinnable game is not the kingmaker problem they were trying to solve. Its those pesky NE or NB that already won.
That mayor was such a chad. He knows he can't win, so he goes scorched earth on the coven. If he can't win, he's taking the entire coven down with him. Man wasn't throwing; he was getting even. He knows the final person is a Doomsayer, he knows the Doomsayer can destroy the coven. So he hands the win to the last neutral evil, knowing they'll destroy the coven for him. The mad man.
It would actually be the best move in a hypothetical ranked scenario as well! Since (I'm pretty sure) a draw wouldn't make the town members lose elo because it's, well a draw, not a "town loses" (even though everyone's dead)
You know, I've always thought that if you were to convert a town of salem game into story format/plot, it would become a really interesting story generating machine. Endless different outcomes, endless amount of plot twists, would be crazy and I could imagine it being made into a story even if it's short, like based off of a single game or several games.
That's what you get for being rude, coven! Just block the doomsayer gracefully, and say nothing about it, pretend to be town, and maybe the surprise mayor will vote the doom instead!
I was Jack and that is what i did. We didn't know 15 his role, but did know he was evil for sure. I tried to get 14 his trust but the other cocky coven just ruined it.
To be fair, really low chance 14 was mayor. I am unsure though if coven could win. Does game auto end if its only Coven and Doomsayer? Because this mayor would have blocked the vote against the coven in a stalemate.
The mayor has to give the doomsayer the win there, not because he wants to give it to him, but because coven was being so smug and thought nothing could go wrong anymore.
Not gonna lie, I really respect pipe for reading what the chat says. I am someone with almost no vision, who cannot read at all, so having this is really nice. Also, explaining what he does, and explaining what other players say/do in the game is actually super helpful for me to understand what’s happening in the game. Thank you Pipe
I love it when people do this, bc for me sometimes I’m playing a game and having a video js run alongside and it’s helpful for me too to have someone read it out, and also means when I’m watching on my phone (pre zoomed in chat days) I didn’t have to squint and figure out everything that was being said. So yeah thanks pipe
There are apps that translate spoken words into text and keyboards that allow for typing blind. Auto-correct for the rest.... It's really not that hard, just different.
yeah, doom didnt even get lucky lol, mayor outplayed them and if 2 and the others didnt scream out that they were coven, it couldve been a lot more difficult for pipe to guess. they just threw their win away. it's their own fault lmao.
I agree with Doom getting lucky tho. They are lucky they didn't get lynched after sheriff found them sus, and they were lucky that the only other non-coven remaining was the Mayor or Prosecutor. But I 100% agree with coven not deserving the win after the gloating. That was cathartic.
i mean the difference is there's no point lynching the doomsayer, bro doesnt care who lives or dies, if he decides 'screw the coven', he can make the town win, or he can side with the coven, meaning they want to keep him around. or he can just be true neutral and just kill another neutral, a coven or a townie. its just a wasted vote in my opinion you wanna get rid of Werewolf and Arsonist tbh
I think there should be a vague chat message the morning after a doom fail to announce the presence of a doomsayer without giving away who it is. Something along the lines of "The Old Ones are displeased..." It will put you on a bit of a timer like the apocalypse roles when they transform since town now knows you exist and will (probably) be looking for you.
A good idea. This could actually help a Doomsayer see if theres any other Dooms in the game (like arso) by not guessing N1 and watching for the message.
Yeah of all the doomsayer nerfs I’ve seen this is a nice one. personally in my 6ish hours of TOS2 so far I haven’t seen a single doomsayer win, so I’m not inclined to say that doomsayer is too op, but this is a nice little QoL thing
@@placeholderblankspace I had 3 doomsayers kill me accidentally or not. In one mayor revealed d2 and guessed my admirer so he ended up killing 1 coven three townies. Same thing d2 mayor reveal just this time I was tracker. And then giga chad coven win because doomsayer left me to be the only one alive.
Basically the same thing happened to me recently. Coven had it all wrapped up and Doomsayer killed THREE of us and gave it to town right at the end. Sadgehaving.
Would have been hilarious if Pipe had started saying “NOT SO FAST COVEN”. You never know what might happen in a TOS game, and this was the ultimate karma for that arrogant Coven.
I love 2 saying they played better. Yall knew what this man was from the beginning you coulda took him out even town knew he was sus. Doggo is the best We praise Mayor Doggo
It was a loss for the Mayor either way. If he votes out the Doom, then the Coven just kill him at night. So I guess in his mind a loss to a Neutral is better than a loss to Coven.
The absolute epitome of 'If I go down I'm taking you with me!' Was this mayor friggin Andross? That... almost kind of checks, as starfox is a 4 man squad, lol.
Theres something so satisfying about these last second doomsayer wins. I had one earlier with a mayor, tavernkeeper, a coven, and a coroner that had dced. I managed to talk them into not voting, saying the tav should rb the coven so we could see if the DC was the evil. I had already figured out who was who by then lmao.
Man mayor came in clutch bravo to him reminds me of jailer who exes me as AMNE MAYOR who didn’t reveal after I told him in jail n1 and lo and behold Coven won so as a public service announcement:JUST BECAUSE A MAYOR TOLD YOU THEY WERE MAYOR AND DIDN’T REVEAL INSTANTLY THEY AREN’T EVIL GUARANTEED P.S there was a conjuror in as well so I what I was doing was fair
Mayor knew that it likely was Doom + 3 Coven as coven were celebrating, so he would have hit coven anyway. Besides Coven's messages just outed 15 as doom so even if you were tav keep it doesn't matter 2 coven to vote vs one possible tav keep/pois
I had one doomsayer game where i practically nuked the last 3 neutral killing roles. It was a 2v1v1v1v1, and since WW decided to attack me, their attack failed and one townie survived, leading to town win
It's *way too easy* to win as Doomsayer, since there is absolutely no punishment for guessing wrong. You can just keep brute-forcing until you get it right. You also have defense, so there isn't even a sense of urgency - you won't be getting killed early. They absolutely need to add some sort of mechanic where if you guess incorrectly 3 times the Old Ones get furious and kill you, OR make it so that one of the 3 targets *needs* to be evil so it isn't always 3 townies getting screwed, OR you make it so Doomsayer can't target "revealed" roles like Mayor, Pros etc.
@@Kris_2137 That's basically every doomsayer win. You get 1-2 Town Power/TK that confirm themselves and then guess the 3rd one for someone that seems legit until you get it right. The devs can always just delete that achievement if they were to rework the class, not a hard achievement to get anyway.
I had an intriguing pirate game Saturday Morning.N1: Pirate 15 [I lose], D2 15 gets hung, they were Jinx. N2: Pirate 14 since people were pointing fingers so to speak at them after 15 was lynched [I win, PB dies] D3: Town thanks Pirate, things happen, fingers get pointed at 7, I decide "Why not? I got my first win by following the fingers so lets do it again": [I win, Dreamweaver dies, I leave town with my loot] D4: People say TY Pirate and GG Pirate. I kinda tuned out the rest of the game since I had won but town managed to win, thanks in part to me rbing the Jinx N1, killing the PB N2 & Dreamweaver N3.
I wonder if mayor would of gave doom the win if coven didn't gloat, still at the very least not gloating would of make it hard for the mayor to give doom the win if mayor didn't know there was doom
He tested it before they added to functionality to remove the dead fr9m the automated notes, so its likely alittle more bareable by now, but ,ultiple of his points still stand as far as i can tell for why he didnt like it back then.
I was Jack this game. I knew that Pipe(15) was evil, just didn't know what he was. I was roleblocking him so he couldn't attack either of us and i was faking Tavern Keeper so look legit. I tried to get the trust of 14 to lynch 15, but at the end it backfired lol.
Jack, you forgot the most important rule as a role blocking role. "You cannot roleblock the same person twice!" To be fair, you could have been new but 2 (Medusa) was a very grim person. They gloated too early.
I think the best way to balance Doomsayer is to make it so if you guess 1 wrong you have to wait one night to guess again, 2 for 2 and 2 for 3 to punish not knowing
Doesn't work well for quicker games. I like the comment Josh Creek left, "The Old Ones are displeased," warning town of a doomslayer putting them on the hunt.
How are they suppose to work out what role a coven is? Because of the change to book kills in ToS 2, it's almost impossible to guess who the killing coven role is unless they kill a player with defence
Mayor acting like the Neutral Evil at the end of the game there. I feel like there def needs to be some way of dealing with multiple doomsayers though or just in general. It is close to being on part with the Jester, another NE role. But given the fast-paced nature the game can take on it can be difficult to change it without changing the base of the newly introduced role vs other roles that exist. Maybe changing the name/mechanics of the role to be more thematic for starters, the role is mostly a guess and check method rather than acting like a doomsday clock which is how I'd expect a role called doomsayer to work.
"L Doomsayer"
dies and loses to doomsayer the next day
Famous last words
That ending really was "In comes the Mayor with the steel chair!"
AND HERE COMES MAYOR RANDY OUTTA NO WHERE
Vince McCoven: "Nice try, doomsayer. Nobody's here to stop us!"
Stone Cold Steve Mayor: *glass shattering sound effect, struts down to kill a coven*
AND HERE COMES A GIANT FIST
Motivation moment
“Watch out !watch out! watch out!” 9:55
"imagine mayor"
*instant mayor reveal*
even scriptwriters can't write something that beautiful
6: imagine mayor
14: thou hath awakened the sacrifice for the Old Ones.
Greatest Mayor play ever.
If you can't win normally, you go out in your own terms. Any person who considers that a throw is blatantly missing the rules of the game. No one to betray or throw, he chose who gets the win among the two parties who could, as last town.
Coven celebrated too early.
The devs tried to get rid of kingmakers... but you can never get rid of someone with nothing to lose.
Just another sorta unconventional kingmaker ish scenario
it wasn't a kingmaker, since not voting coven would result in a town loss; which is a gamethrow for town since voting a coven member ends it in a draw.
Also coven definitely deserved to lose for thinking they already won the game and outing themselves.
Yeah pretty much
The chad mayor knew he's dead no matter what, so he took coven down with him
@@gabrielmoreno7112kingmakers were roles that had won or had win conditions completely separate from a faction. Exes, confirmed survs and the like. It did not matter who they won with and could do whatever.
Being the last town in an unwinnable game is not the kingmaker problem they were trying to solve. Its those pesky NE or NB that already won.
That mayor was such a chad. He knows he can't win, so he goes scorched earth on the coven. If he can't win, he's taking the entire coven down with him. Man wasn't throwing; he was getting even. He knows the final person is a Doomsayer, he knows the Doomsayer can destroy the coven. So he hands the win to the last neutral evil, knowing they'll destroy the coven for him. The mad man.
It would actually be the best move in a hypothetical ranked scenario as well! Since (I'm pretty sure) a draw wouldn't make the town members lose elo because it's, well a draw, not a "town loses" (even though everyone's dead)
Its also the objective best move as it is the only move he can do that doesn't lose him the game!
As draw's aren't loses after all.
You know, I've always thought that if you were to convert a town of salem game into story format/plot, it would become a really interesting story generating machine. Endless different outcomes, endless amount of plot twists, would be crazy and I could imagine it being made into a story even if it's short, like based off of a single game or several games.
@@totallylemon Mayor could have gone for the win by wasting all three trails and getting no one hanged. Then doom kills the three cov.
@@hunterk1575 coven just kill the mayor
The mayor literally went
“If I can’t win, then the Coven can’t win. This town shall burn”
Genuinely some anime shit lmao. "15 get off this planet while you still can. They're not going anywhere."
If i can't have this town no one will have it
"I'm taking you with me."
Laughed so much at 2’s salt 😂 “common coven w” into “coven deserved to win”
I saw that and as like clearly not you knew what 15 was and knew could be threat yet just toyed. So for that reason coven deserved the L
It was so deserved karma 😂 Made me happy
Let this be a lesson. Unless your PM has revealed everyone, sometimes its good to not drop the act till you know everything.
@@Keldiur Lets be honest, its not a good idea to drop the act till you actually have it in the bag. Which they clearly didn't.
overconfidence is a slow and insidious killer
That's what you get for being rude, coven! Just block the doomsayer gracefully, and say nothing about it, pretend to be town, and maybe the surprise mayor will vote the doom instead!
I was Jack and that is what i did. We didn't know 15 his role, but did know he was evil for sure. I tried to get 14 his trust but the other cocky coven just ruined it.
To be fair, really low chance 14 was mayor. I am unsure though if coven could win. Does game auto end if its only Coven and Doomsayer? Because this mayor would have blocked the vote against the coven in a stalemate.
@@Keldiur I know, but i didn't know what evil 15 was and couldn't roleblock twice in a row.
@@KeldiurDoomsayer is non factional so the game ends if it's just doomsayer and Coven remaining.
Mayor: "I am not locked in here with you, YOU ALL ARE LOCKED IN HERE WITH ME!"
The mayor has to give the doomsayer the win there, not because he wants to give it to him, but because coven was being so smug and thought nothing could go wrong anymore.
also because when you can't win, your goal is to force a draw.
Not gonna lie, I really respect pipe for reading what the chat says. I am someone with almost no vision, who cannot read at all, so having this is really nice. Also, explaining what he does, and explaining what other players say/do in the game is actually super helpful for me to understand what’s happening in the game. Thank you Pipe
I love it when people do this, bc for me sometimes I’m playing a game and having a video js run alongside and it’s helpful for me too to have someone read it out, and also means when I’m watching on my phone (pre zoomed in chat days) I didn’t have to squint and figure out everything that was being said. So yeah thanks pipe
I like doing chores while listening to pipetron, so I feel this. Thanks for the narrations!!
How did you type this
This comment feels really sketchy ain't no way he typed that all out with nearly perfect grammar with bad vision
There are apps that translate spoken words into text and keyboards that allow for typing blind. Auto-correct for the rest.... It's really not that hard, just different.
"L DOOMSAYER"
The Chad Mayor: "I will not let my town be destroyed by fools. Love ya, 15, give 'em what for."
(6) Avocado : imagine mayor
*Doggo revealed themselves as The Mayor!*
It was at this moment he knew, he screwed up.
6 jinxed it and coven had to pay for it
That mayor was a gigchad. Saving the town from the coven like that
He didn't save the town, because they were all already dead.
He *avenged* the town. o7
That mayor reveal was so clutch
Medusa: HAHAHAHAH NOT SO FAST DOOMSAYER
Doomsayer: HAHAHAHAH YOUR POISONER WAS TOO FAST, YOU CAN'T ROLEBLOCK ME AGAIN!
9:07: All of those guessed were wrong anyway. So the RB was secretly beneficial for Pipe
In the end they played themselves
L coven
I would've done the same thing as that Mayor. The sheer attitude of Coven would've made me give the win to the other party as well. XD
mayor said "if im going down im taking you all with me!"
"Doom got lucky" said 2 in end chat.
No, you got outplayed by the Mayor.
"We deserved the win"
Not after gloating you don't.
yeah, doom didnt even get lucky lol, mayor outplayed them and if 2 and the others didnt scream out that they were coven, it couldve been a lot more difficult for pipe to guess. they just threw their win away. it's their own fault lmao.
I agree with Doom getting lucky tho. They are lucky they didn't get lynched after sheriff found them sus, and they were lucky that the only other non-coven remaining was the Mayor or Prosecutor.
But I 100% agree with coven not deserving the win after the gloating. That was cathartic.
i mean the difference is
there's no point lynching the doomsayer, bro doesnt care who lives or dies, if he decides 'screw the coven', he can make the town win, or he can side with the coven, meaning they want to keep him around. or he can just be true neutral and just kill another neutral, a coven or a townie.
its just a wasted vote in my opinion
you wanna get rid of Werewolf and Arsonist tbh
I love when coven is toxic and start bragging just for their game to end like this lmao xD great video
I think there should be a vague chat message the morning after a doom fail to announce the presence of a doomsayer without giving away who it is. Something along the lines of "The Old Ones are displeased..." It will put you on a bit of a timer like the apocalypse roles when they transform since town now knows you exist and will (probably) be looking for you.
A good idea. This could actually help a Doomsayer see if theres any other Dooms in the game (like arso) by not guessing N1 and watching for the message.
Yeah of all the doomsayer nerfs I’ve seen this is a nice one. personally in my 6ish hours of TOS2 so far I haven’t seen a single doomsayer win, so I’m not inclined to say that doomsayer is too op, but this is a nice little QoL thing
@@placeholderblankspace I'm running around with doomsayer scrolls and I think he is the role I won the second most with after conjuror
@@placeholderblankspace I had 3 doomsayers kill me accidentally or not. In one mayor revealed d2 and guessed my admirer so he ended up killing 1 coven three townies. Same thing d2 mayor reveal just this time I was tracker. And then giga chad coven win because doomsayer left me to be the only one alive.
Basically the same thing happened to me recently. Coven had it all wrapped up and Doomsayer killed THREE of us and gave it to town right at the end. Sadgehaving.
That was truly a BIG MIKE moment by the mayor
Coven definitely couldve won if they just didnt celebrate before crossing the post lmao.
They also could've won if they didnt roleblock the night before. They should've rb'd the day they were going to kill the Mayor
Pulled off the old "PIPETRON CLASSIC"
Who's Pipetron? I've never heard of them
Would have been hilarious if Pipe had started saying “NOT SO FAST COVEN”. You never know what might happen in a TOS game, and this was the ultimate karma for that arrogant Coven.
While it would be rare it would be nice to see an ultra rare NE win screen when town gets completely wiped like this (Exe, Jest, Doom, Pirate).
I love 2 saying they played better. Yall knew what this man was from the beginning you coulda took him out even town knew he was sus.
Doggo is the best
We praise Mayor Doggo
bro the coven saying L got karma lol
absolute Doomsayer clutch when mayor popped out
I think the mayor not choosing doom would've been a throw because draw is better than loss
It was a loss for the Mayor either way. If he votes out the Doom, then the Coven just kill him at night. So I guess in his mind a loss to a Neutral is better than a loss to Coven.
That Mayor truly represents the ideals of Big Mike.
"I DESERVED THE WIN YOU JUST GOT LUCKY"
- an extremely sore loser
"We played so much better neut was lucky" lol they're so salty
That ending was poetic
2 getting rolled over after bragging was too funny
The absolute epitome of 'If I go down I'm taking you with me!'
Was this mayor friggin Andross? That... almost kind of checks, as starfox is a 4 man squad, lol.
Bro was like " I don't care if the doomsayer wins, I only care if the covern loses,"
“We played so much better, neut got lucky” That wasn’t luck, that was a reward for not being toxic.
Theres something so satisfying about these last second doomsayer wins. I had one earlier with a mayor, tavernkeeper, a coven, and a coroner that had dced. I managed to talk them into not voting, saying the tav should rb the coven so we could see if the DC was the evil. I had already figured out who was who by then lmao.
That was literally amazing 10/10
Well done Mayor! 💪💪 💪
This game is iconic LMAO
Your night 1 predictions were all N+1 above the actual coven members.
I had a N1 doomsayer win, who guessed 3 coven randomly and won
That should definitely be an achievement if it’s not
@@tisvana18 It would actually get you two achievements.
One for guessing correctly before day 3 (I think),
One for guessing three coven correctly.
Man mayor came in clutch bravo to him reminds me of jailer who exes me as AMNE MAYOR who didn’t reveal after I told him in jail n1 and lo and behold Coven won so as a public service announcement:JUST BECAUSE A MAYOR TOLD YOU THEY WERE MAYOR AND DIDN’T REVEAL INSTANTLY THEY AREN’T EVIL GUARANTEED
P.S there was a conjuror in as well so I what I was doing was fair
Mayor knew that it likely was Doom + 3 Coven as coven were celebrating, so he would have hit coven anyway. Besides Coven's messages just outed 15 as doom so even if you were tav keep it doesn't matter
2 coven to vote vs one possible tav keep/pois
Hey I had also such a similar win where me as Doom killed last living persons and leave the town empty :D
Welcome to the club! :D
the only argument id make as doomsayer at the end is "do it mayor, it'll be funny"
I had one doomsayer game where i practically nuked the last 3 neutral killing roles. It was a 2v1v1v1v1, and since WW decided to attack me, their attack failed and one townie survived, leading to town win
It's *way too easy* to win as Doomsayer, since there is absolutely no punishment for guessing wrong. You can just keep brute-forcing until you get it right. You also have defense, so there isn't even a sense of urgency - you won't be getting killed early. They absolutely need to add some sort of mechanic where if you guess incorrectly 3 times the Old Ones get furious and kill you, OR make it so that one of the 3 targets *needs* to be evil so it isn't always 3 townies getting screwed, OR you make it so Doomsayer can't target "revealed" roles like Mayor, Pros etc.
the problem is that sometimes it just becomes impossible for doomsayer to win.
There is achivement for killing 3 townies as doom
It’s not way to easy it’s only easy if town doesn’t want to play around it
I don't think doomsayers need any nerf, it's alright
@@Kris_2137 That's basically every doomsayer win. You get 1-2 Town Power/TK that confirm themselves and then guess the 3rd one for someone that seems legit until you get it right. The devs can always just delete that achievement if they were to rework the class, not a hard achievement to get anyway.
Coven got what they deserved lmao. They celebrated way too early. If they had been silent they could have been like 15 last evil with 14 and won
Ooga booga new pipetron vid
2 being so full of themselves deserved them the LOSS
Yesterday I had an executioner only win, it was crazy
2 counted their eggs before they hatched
Gigachad Mayor taking the Coven down with him. I respect it.
This is a classic example of what happens when you celebrate too early, and such delicious karma for bad manners. L coven.
that mayor came from like 2 countries away to just scorch the whole town. mega chad move.
Mayor deserves chad of the year for his play there.
What a missed opportunity to make your death note "Not so fast, coven". That would be poetic irony.
2 went down crying like a baby lmao. the embodiment of the🤓emoji
Wow that was such a W mayor honestly
2 and 6 were annoying. it was extremely satisfying to see 2 bite it in the end.
Can you imagine if 8 didn’t fast vote bc they wanted 2 and 6 to shut up and thought mayor reveal was funny lol xd
2 got so salty at the end lol
NOBODY SEES THE LATE GAME MAYOR (mostly cuz they’re dead already)
This is what counting chickens before they hatch looks like.
I love when you get hyped up, that was a great ending lol
GG Great video as always :) - Mayor MVP
Bro 2 was so mad ahahah I guess he had to take that L
Mayor absolute W honestly
A NOBLE SACRIFICE
o7 MAYOR
you have my respect
"Overconfidence is a slow and insidious killer"
2 was so salty 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Giga chad mayor
new pipetron video 😼
I feel like if coven wasn’t bragging so much they could’ve won
ive had a doomsayer game which me and the pirate won at the same time for a pirate and doomsayer only
Goated mayor
I had an intriguing pirate game Saturday Morning.N1: Pirate 15 [I lose], D2 15 gets hung, they were Jinx. N2: Pirate 14 since people were pointing fingers so to speak at them after 15 was lynched [I win, PB dies] D3: Town thanks Pirate, things happen, fingers get pointed at 7, I decide "Why not? I got my first win by following the fingers so lets do it again": [I win, Dreamweaver dies, I leave town with my loot] D4: People say TY Pirate and GG Pirate. I kinda tuned out the rest of the game since I had won but town managed to win, thanks in part to me rbing the Jinx N1, killing the PB N2 & Dreamweaver N3.
I guessed 3 ppl as coven N1 and guessed right, got accused of cheating by the players, because I random guessed.
Coven really got instant karma when they tried to screw Doom out of their win.
If they didn't rb him, they mightve still won too.
thank you pipron for GETTING THE ULTRA RARE WIN as doomsayer🙏🙏🙏
I have over 100 wins how do you only have 25!?
Mayor MVP.
CoVeN dEsErVeD tO wIn We PlAyEd So MuCh BeTtEr
No you didn’t. Being smug is exactly what cost you the game. Coven deserved exactly what they got
doomslayer? THE DOOMSLAYER?!
W Mayor
I wonder if mayor would of gave doom the win if coven didn't gloat, still at the very least not gloating would of make it hard for the mayor to give doom the win if mayor didn't know there was doom
Coven threw so hard there 😂
Pipetron do you know that on the notepad you have a red paper on the bottom right that serves as a way to note the roles of each player
He’s used it in one of his videos, but decided he preferred his current method
He tested it before they added to functionality to remove the dead fr9m the automated notes, so its likely alittle more bareable by now, but ,ultiple of his points still stand as far as i can tell for why he didnt like it back then.
Day 6 shouting out Mimyuu
I was Jack this game. I knew that Pipe(15) was evil, just didn't know what he was. I was roleblocking him so he couldn't attack either of us and i was faking Tavern Keeper so look legit. I tried to get the trust of 14 to lynch 15, but at the end it backfired lol.
Jack, you forgot the most important rule as a role blocking role.
"You cannot roleblock the same person twice!"
To be fair, you could have been new but 2 (Medusa) was a very grim person. They gloated too early.
I just got a D3 doomsayer win achieve, guessed cleric, coro, tavern keeper
Toxic players getting destroyed is so satisfying
I think the best way to balance Doomsayer is to make it so if you guess 1 wrong you have to wait one night to guess again, 2 for 2 and 2 for 3 to punish not knowing
Doesn't work well for quicker games. I like the comment Josh Creek left, "The Old Ones are displeased," warning town of a doomslayer putting them on the hunt.
pipe's fav role yessss
11:30 Poison/necro...with 2 Stoned corpses in the graveyard. Right. Still, good video!
2 lived up to their name. Grim as hell. No wonder they lost :p
In the future they will probably nerf doomsayer because if you just randomly shot people as a faction and guess right then where's the fun in that?
How are they suppose to work out what role a coven is? Because of the change to book kills in ToS 2, it's almost impossible to guess who the killing coven role is unless they kill a player with defence
Mayor acting like the Neutral Evil at the end of the game there.
I feel like there def needs to be some way of dealing with multiple doomsayers though or just in general. It is close to being on part with the Jester, another NE role. But given the fast-paced nature the game can take on it can be difficult to change it without changing the base of the newly introduced role vs other roles that exist.
Maybe changing the name/mechanics of the role to be more thematic for starters, the role is mostly a guess and check method rather than acting like a doomsday clock which is how I'd expect a role called doomsayer to work.
Doomsday clock feels too similar to SC/Death tho ngl