+Chris V This video is for pitchers who are trying to learn every little detail. People get upset about the balk rule, but without it, the running game in baseball would be pretty much non existent.
Think of it this way. Imagine the natural motion of a pitcher starting from him leaning in towards the plate to go through signs with the catcher, and ending with the release of the ball. If the pitcher deviates, or hesitates from that motion just slightly, it's a balk. Think of the definition of the word "BALK" for second. _"Hesitate or be unwilling to accept an idea or undertaking"_ That is literally what it means in baseball also. Anytime the pitcher is "unsure" of his next move, and it shows in his movements or windup, it's usually a balk. It can seem vague when you see what certain things are called balks sometimes. They are almost imperceptible to the casual viewer, but on the field as a batter or umpire, they are GLARING movements. In other words, they stick out like sore thumbs. lol Hope that helps.
That's for this explanation. I used to think a balk was just when the pitcher went into his wind up and didn't throw or faked the throw, but I saw so many situations where I didn't understand why it was a balk.
once when i was maybe 15 or so, playing rec ball, we were slaying the other team and had a huge lead of 10 runs or so, so the coach was letting anyone who wanted too pitch a bit just to try it out. I'd never done it before so i thought, sure why not? well i balked the bases loaded in three batters and only threw a handful of actual pitches. My coach put me back in my position and i thought "Jesus man quit being so technical I'm just trying to play a game here" it sucked all the fun out of it.
I think you did an EXCELLENT job on this video. Seriously I'm 39 years old and I learned a lot from this video. You covered every aspect you needed to cover to explain the Balk. Again AWESOME video. Thank you.
One quick addition to the instruction, you CAN step to an "unoccupied" base if a runner is attempting to attain that base. Example, Runner on 1st and while in your set, the runner attempts to steal second, you can step directly to and throw to second without penalty.
I've never played baseball, not even much of a baseball fan, but I've always wondered what a balk was. Thanks, Mike. If I had played baseball as a kid, I would've hoped to have a coach like you. Strong work.
Mike, Great job on this video. I'm a huge baseball fan (and hopeful broadcaster) and I have always had trouble deciphering what exactly constitutes a balk. Your clear and thorough video really helped! Thanks!
Nice simple, straightforward instructions for a young guy about to move up to a new/higher level, where the moves they made on the mound and got away with, will now be called. Great video.
Only if you don’t throw the ball. If the ball comes out of your hand in the general vicinity of the plate it’s ok. If you drop it before the fall or hold it it’s a balk.
Thanks Mike. That does clear some of the confusion for me. As a fan that watches a lot of B.ball, I was unaware of all the ways a pitcher can balk. I think this subject could use a lot more explanation.
I can see and respect the necessity for the balk rule, but I believe it really is long overdue for a revisal. To me, there is to much grey area of whether one was committed or not. Yes, they are professional MLB umpires, who trained in making calls. But, spotting such tiny and instant movement from so far away is a foundation laid on potential flaws. Let's not forget, how many incorrect calls are made from a plays the ump is literally standing on top of it...West, Hernandez, Joyce, West again just for good measure. Changing what makes a balk a balk may create problems for players right now, but in the long run of the sport, I think it'll prove beneficial overall
Thanks Mike! This is great for everyone in the ballpark! I'll send this to the umpires in our league, as they're all volunteers and could definitely use your videos!
If I had this resource for learning the technical aspects of baseball, I may have made the Pittsburgh Pirates in 1969. Without a doubt, this is the best resource for any kid wanting to play the game.
Awesome video. Def one of the more confusing rules in baseball. I pitched D3 college and used mostly off speed stuff and used a lot of pick off moves because I sucked and had a lot of base runners. One thing to mention tho about not stopping when you’re coming set in the stretch; if you attempt a pickoff you don’t need to come to a stop. Only if you pitch the ball do you need to come to a full pause in the stretch position. You can come set and attempt the pickoff in one motion. I don’t know if he covered this specifically, but the pitcher has to throw to the base that the runner is on that he is attempting to pick off. He can’t start a rundown - the first; his first throw has to be to the base he is at. He mentioned throwing to a base that is unoccupied, but if you get the guy at first stealing, the pitcher can’t have his initial throw to second. Correction- if the runner is trying to steal the base you can throw to that base. If it’s a pickoff then you can’t. Ive also had this called on me, as this is a move I used to use a lot. pitcher can’t, when in the windup, fake his windup going to the plate even if he steps off with his non throwing foot. I would act like I was going to pitch the ball, but fake the throw home and spin and get the guy leaning at third or pretend I forgot runners were on and throw to first or second. This isn’t used almost ever at higher level ball but I’ve seen a couple guys in JV and legion ball try it besides myself. If you attempt jump throw to first, or third for a lefty (where you jump to face to throw to the bag and your feet are basically hitting the ground at the same time, as opposed to stepping off with the throwing foot first) you have to attempt a throw to the base. Even if you have no shot to get him, you have to throw the ball or it’s a balk. Keep up the good videos. Im not 100% positive on a couple of these but I have had these called as balks or seen them called. No review and some bad umpiring in high School and low level college, so it can be a crapshoot. I hoped this added something useful.
You don't need to drop the ball for it to be a balk -- if it leaves your hand while you're on the rubber (for example you toss it up and catch it) that's a balk. I learned this because in high school I wanted to do a silly distracting trick pitch where I tossed and caught the ball mid-windup.
Here's another balk situation, the pitcher removes his hand from the ball after he has come to "set" position, say, to adjust his cap or scratch his nose. Another one that always gets a response from the coach is when, during a "hidden ball play", the pitcher returns to within 5 feet of the pitchers plate. (NFHS rules)
Son, this is a very good video. I didn't realize about the shoulder turn Balk, but then again, I only played football.. Anyway Mike Scott, Many Thanks! ! !
Steve C gotta say I found your remark very freakin funny. Considering I'm a High School Umpire who takes this avocation seriously I had to laugh. Contrarily to what some (or all) may think of Umpires as being boring, hard nose Drill Sargent type of individuals without a sense of humor, (well some are). Some umpires may not find humor in your remark, well those would be the boring, hard nose Drill Sargent type of individuals. As, for me I thought that your "what the Balk is going on" was very freakin funny, don't ever lose your sense of humor........keep those around you always laughing, it's good medicine for those who need it, COOL?
I just learned about this today. I saw it the second time in an Augie garrido documentary and initially I thought coach was mad about the call being a BALL when it was in reality a strike. Watching it the second time and hearing the pitcher reflect on augies disappointment he said something that sounded like bog.
*Balk Rules* 1) You can't just be up there and just doin' a balk like that. 1a. A balk is when you 1b. Okay well listen. A balk is when you balk the 1c. Let me start over 1c-a. The pitcher is not allowed to do a motion to the, uh, batter, that prohibits the batter from doing, you know, just trying to hit the ball. You can't do that. 1c-b. Once the pitcher is in the stretch, he can't be over here and say to the runner, like, "I'm gonna get ya! I'm gonna tag you out! You better watch your butt!" and then just be like he didn't even do that. 1c-b(1). Like, if you're about to pitch and then don't pitch, you have to still pitch. You cannot not pitch. Does that make any sense? 1c-b(2). You gotta be, throwing motion of the ball, and then, until you just throw it. 1c-b(2)-a. Okay, well, you can have the ball up here, like this, but then there's the balk you gotta think about. 1c-b(2)-b. Fairuza Balk hasn't been in any movies in forever. I hope she wasn't typecast as that racist lady in American History X. 1c-b(2)-b(i). Oh wait, she was in The Waterboy too! That would be even worse. 1c-b(2)-b(ii). "get in mah bellah" -- Adam Water, "The Waterboy." Haha, classic... 1c-b(3). Okay seriously though. A balk is when the pitcher makes a movement that, as determined by, when you do a move involving the baseball and field of 2) Do not do a balk please.
Also 1: You can't fake a motion toward first base. If you motion toward first, you have to throw the ball. This rule only counts for first base. Also 2: You can't step on the rubber without the ball. So, the hidden ball trick that you saw pulled off in one of those Bad News Bears movies? It couldn't happen in real life, because in the movie, the pitcher stepped on the rubber and started his pitching motion without the ball, and the first baseman tagged the runner out when he took his lead. But oops, that's a balk, because you can't step on the rubber without the ball in your hand or glove.
Faking towards first is allowed to an extent if you don’t feign and throwing motion. You can look andhold the ball as if you’re about to start a throw, but yeah once the arm moves forward, and even if it doesn’t on a jump throw you have to throw it. You can fake to third the same way you can first, as long as you don’t feign a throwing motion, and as long as no one is on first base at the same time. Once you’ve disengaged from the rubber and are not disengaging while in the act of a pickoff move you can do whatever.
I'm sure its been mentioned before, but the fake to third, throw to first move is now a balk in the majors (and a costly one, since there is a runner on third).
This is a good video for balk explanation. The only difference and that's just because of age is when he talks about the slightly open or "hybrid stance" that's basically going to be warned and then called balk from now on at least on the high school level.
Thanks that really helps me.I got called on a balk in one of my games because I put my my foot right by my other and went to second.Thanks for the help. :)
Wow, great video! I had no idea there were this many different types of balk! But I do recall a few times over the years, when I saw this: there was a runner on 1st, and another runner on 3rd. The pitcher began the windup, but then quickly stepped off and immediately went through the motion of preparing to throw to the 3d baseman to pick off the runner there, but then instead, he quickly spun around and threw to first. How is that legal, I wonder?
@username20698 Yes, if playing under Official Baseball Rules (OBR). But in high school (NFHS) the play is dead immediately, even if the batter hits a home run.
I got some free bases as a runner in my youth playing Pee-Wee league as the wild pitchers did this at least a couple of times per game.Funny how 'Walk' and 'Balk' are what many people think is just baseball jargon but 'balk' actually means exactly what it is.
Balk isn't really that complicated. He's just being hyper detailed and repeating himself a lot. The balk rule exists for a reason. Without it, leads and steals would become practically irrelevant / impossible. Also, baseball can be understood on different levels and still thoroughly enjoyed. This video is for people who want to know EVERYTHING. It's not like you have to know all of this stuff to be able to understand and enjoy a baseball game.
Pitcher with open shoulder set position often signal pitch delivery by first move of closing shoulder, slowing delivery time, and helping base stealers. Careful.
Interesting Mike, thank you. It brings a question right away form the 2018 World Series. David Price in my book was "balking" all the time with his left foot. Before throwing to the plate, his left foot leaves the balk several times before the actual throw. Is that legal?
No, that is technically a balk but a lot of guys do that and it’s rarely called. If it’s a constant part of your pitching motion and you do it every pitch it’s usually it’s ok. But if he’s doing it intentionally to deceive the runners it constitutes a balk. I never noticed price doing that but I will def look at that from now on.
Also alot of people don't know this but a right hander technically can pick his front foot up and go to first base as long as it goes directly to first. It can not go up then out to first it has to go straight around to first, but most umpires will call it a balk. And yes i'm talking about RIGHT handers.
Connor Coultas as long as he can get somehow make no movement towards home and land his foot 45 degrees or less towards first base. One the pitcher makes any significant movement forward towards the plate he has to Theo the ball and land his landing foot no more than halfway between first and home. That’s very hard to do w this move and I guarantee it would get called constantly. With cleats and on the dirt it’s almost impossible to do this without making a movement towards the plate.because swinging the front foot around is probably considered moving towards home.
actually guys and gals if your in the stretch you can pick your leg up,as u do so a righty going to first doesnt let his leg move any towards home or he has to throw, but with leg up if you start leaning falling towards first thats not a balk. see what they are not saying is you must throw the ball if you do not step off first. if your set and decide to throw to 1,2,3 then you must throw or its a balk. lets review. step off first do what you want, set and decide to go anywhere other than home must not even lean towards home but pick the leg up as like your going to deliver but instead of home you take that hiked up leg and go to the chosen base but you must throw, or youve balked
Actually, with the pitch clock, now there IS a need to rush when in the position shown at 5:51. The clock runs until the pitcher kicks and moves towards the plate.
@Hollywooddave123 if you're not on the rubber and taking signals its a balk, also if you move your feet in any way to either start a pitch or pickoff, and you don't do either, its a balk.
Great point. If you’re taking pitch signals in a set position off the rubber it’s a balk. You can take pickoff and fielding or bunt rotations for example off the rubber if the catcher isn’t in the crouch and pitcher isn’t set on the stripe. It may be considered a mound visit in some cases. But you’re absolutely right he can’t receive pitch signals from the catcher off the rubber in a typical stretch position.
Baseball is the only sport where something like a balk is more confusing than advanced genetics engineering. But your explanation was pretty good, I admit. I could never figure out what this damn rule meant.
+Phil Dunn Wrong. Very wrong. Reading is your friend. You can no longer feint a throw to third in the Official Baseball Rules (OBR) which govern Major League Baseball. I'm pretty sure that this guy isn't instructing MLB pitchers. For NCAA and High School (Fed), you can still feint a throw to third. Ironically, some youth leagues (USSSA) base their rules on OBR instead of Fed rules. In those leagues, because of OBR, feinting to 3rd is a balk. The rules by which you are playing are extremely important. In most cases, feinting to 3rd is still legal (as of Dec 2015).
+67L48 Relax, really - "Wrong, Very wrong"? yet you accept it's true in MLB and other leagues (e.g., Babe Ruth & Cal Ripken Leagues)...and you have no idea which leagues I had in mind. Expertise in baseball rules, maybe. Expertise in social behavior, well... maybe less rulebook reading would be your friend.
Be aware that faking to third and throwing to first was classified as a balk in 2013 in the MLB. Often times, the lower levels of baseball follow suit when it comes to rules and especially balk rules. Like so others can see.
If you're in the windup, yes, you have to step off. The ONLY thing you can do in a windup is pitch. The only way to do anything else is to step off and become a fielder. In the Set position, you've balked right off the bat. In a set, you must have one foot engaged with the rubber and one foot COMPLETELY in front of it.
To any body who doesn't know. Most baseball select leagues, and i'm pretty sure high school and college (although don't quote me on that) have made it illegal to fake to third and then go to first.
I'm not a big baseball guy, but I follow it a bit and have to say Balk is the most confusing rule in the sport
Been a baseball fan my whole life and this is still too much shit to keep track of.
+Chris V This video is for pitchers who are trying to learn every little detail. People get upset about the balk rule, but without it, the running game in baseball would be pretty much non existent.
I love baseball but the ball confusis me
in any sport. you forgot to say. lol
Think of it this way. Imagine the natural motion of a pitcher starting from him leaning in towards the plate to go through signs with the catcher, and ending with the release of the ball. If the pitcher deviates, or hesitates from that motion just slightly, it's a balk.
Think of the definition of the word "BALK" for second.
_"Hesitate or be unwilling to accept an idea or undertaking"_
That is literally what it means in baseball also. Anytime the pitcher is "unsure" of his next move, and it shows in his movements or windup, it's usually a balk.
It can seem vague when you see what certain things are called balks sometimes. They are almost imperceptible to the casual viewer, but on the field as a batter or umpire, they are GLARING movements. In other words, they stick out like sore thumbs. lol
Hope that helps.
That's for this explanation. I used to think a balk was just when the pitcher went into his wind up and didn't throw or faked the throw, but I saw so many situations where I didn't understand why it was a balk.
thats also a balk, but hes just explaining some balk rules
Now remember all that when your tired in the 7th inning
*You’re
If you have to remember it, maybe pitching isnt your prime position
@@JP5150LBC pros still mess up
You're***
Lmao exacyly
Thumbs up for the spare ball.
That was so EPIC!!
youre a hero mike
The familly is behind you all the way
If a dog barks in the background, that's a balk.
+Tone Riggz But if a dog barks in the woods and no one is around to hear it, it's also a balk.
No,... thats not in any of the rule books...mlb, pro, nfhs, etc; . etc;.....
a home run of a comment!!!
It's only a balk if the dog is Asian.
steve jones--- I think the dog barking comment was supposed to be funny, not serious....jeez.
If it breaths...
*_IT'S A BALK._*
Lol
Unless it’s a queen
Balk is THE toughest call for the ump. Thanks, good video.
Great explanation of a balk, and ways to avoid it. Nice job
Mike Scott - Speaking as an amateur umpire, THANK YOU FOR POSTING THIS.
once when i was maybe 15 or so, playing rec ball, we were slaying the other team and had a huge lead of 10 runs or so, so the coach was letting anyone who wanted too pitch a bit just to try it out. I'd never done it before so i thought, sure why not? well i balked the bases loaded in three batters and only threw a handful of actual pitches. My coach put me back in my position and i thought "Jesus man quit being so technical I'm just trying to play a game here" it sucked all the fun out of it.
I think you did an EXCELLENT job on this video. Seriously I'm 39 years old and I learned a lot from this video. You covered every aspect you needed to cover to explain the Balk. Again AWESOME video. Thank you.
One quick addition to the instruction, you CAN step to an "unoccupied" base if a runner is attempting to attain that base. Example, Runner on 1st and while in your set, the runner attempts to steal second, you can step directly to and throw to second without penalty.
TheClearwall that’s a really good point to make the distinction between the pickoff and a caught stealing.
Very well put together video. I never realized how easily a balk could be called or how many different ways a pitcher could commit one.
I've never played baseball, not even much of a baseball fan, but I've always wondered what a balk was. Thanks, Mike. If I had played baseball as a kid, I would've hoped to have a coach like you. Strong work.
There's a great line in Bull Durham when Crash tells Nuke...."don't think, just throw."
I coach an 11u rec team and this was by far the best instructional video I’ve seen on this. Thanks!
Basically it just sucks to be a pitcher
No...not unless you know what you're doing and dont think you can do whatever you want on the mound.....the offense hates that.....
I love being a pitcher, just don't fuck it up.
Pitchers in the big league are fucking cry babies and really get away with all sorts of bullshit...balks arent called no where near enuff
Thank you, you just cleared up an 20 minute debate!
balk rules:
1. dont do a balk pls
2. no balks allowed
3. if you do a balk then you broke rules, don't ever balk
WOW!
Pitching is more than a strong and able arm... it's the most disciplined position in the team.
Thanks for the tutorial...
Mike,
Great job on this video. I'm a huge baseball fan (and hopeful broadcaster) and I have always had trouble deciphering what exactly constitutes a balk. Your clear and thorough video really helped!
Thanks!
Nice simple, straightforward instructions for a young guy about to move up to a new/higher level, where the moves they made on the mound and got away with, will now be called. Great video.
Also if you trip and or fall down during the windup that's also considered a Balk
unless the ball comes out of your hand and rolls across the fair/foul line then it is just a ball.
Yeah
TBPOTUSAOFALL - If you dont have the ball and you step on the mound its a balk too
@@andrewlanoue9104 really?
Only if you don’t throw the ball. If the ball comes out of your hand in the general vicinity of the plate it’s ok. If you drop it before the fall or hold it it’s a balk.
Thanks Mike. This is the best balk explanation I have seen yet. Actually, I can almost understand what a balk is.
Thanks Mike. That does clear some of the confusion for me. As a fan that watches a lot of B.ball, I was unaware of all the ways a pitcher can balk. I think this subject could use a lot more explanation.
I can see and respect the necessity for the balk rule, but I believe it really is long overdue for a revisal. To me, there is to much grey area of whether one was committed or not. Yes, they are professional MLB umpires, who trained in making calls. But, spotting such tiny and instant movement from so far away is a foundation laid on potential flaws. Let's not forget, how many incorrect calls are made from a plays the ump is literally standing on top of it...West, Hernandez, Joyce, West again just for good measure.
Changing what makes a balk a balk may create problems for players right now, but in the long run of the sport, I think it'll prove beneficial overall
Thanks Mike!
This is great for everyone in the ballpark!
I'll send this to the umpires in our league, as they're all volunteers and could definitely use your videos!
If I had this resource for learning the technical aspects of baseball, I may have made the Pittsburgh Pirates in 1969. Without a doubt, this is the best resource for any kid wanting to play the game.
Just a fantastic concise explanation about balks, coach. This umpire thanks you!
Awesome video. Def one of the more confusing rules in baseball. I pitched D3 college and used mostly off speed stuff and used a lot of pick off moves because I sucked and had a lot of base runners. One thing to mention tho about not stopping when you’re coming set in the stretch; if you attempt a pickoff you don’t need to come to a stop. Only if you pitch the ball do you need to come to a full pause in the stretch position. You can come set and attempt the pickoff in one motion.
I don’t know if he covered this specifically, but the pitcher has to throw to the base that the runner is on that he is attempting to pick off. He can’t start a rundown - the first; his first throw has to be to the base he is at. He mentioned throwing to a base that is unoccupied, but if you get the guy at first stealing, the pitcher can’t have his initial throw to second.
Correction- if the runner is trying to steal the base you can throw to that base. If it’s a pickoff then you can’t.
Ive also had this called on me, as this is a move I used to use a lot. pitcher can’t, when in the windup, fake his windup going to the plate even if he steps off with his non throwing foot. I would act like I was going to pitch the ball, but fake the throw home and spin and get the guy leaning at third or pretend I forgot runners were on and throw to first or second. This isn’t used almost ever at higher level ball but I’ve seen a couple guys in JV and legion ball try it besides myself.
If you attempt jump throw to first, or third for a lefty (where you jump to face to throw to the bag and your feet are basically hitting the ground at the same time, as opposed to stepping off with the throwing foot first) you have to attempt a throw to the base. Even if you have no shot to get him, you have to throw the ball or it’s a balk.
Keep up the good videos. Im not 100% positive on a couple of these but I have had these called as balks or seen them called. No review and some bad umpiring in high
School and low level college, so it can be a crapshoot. I hoped this added something useful.
Great instructional videos. Clear and precise, good examples
Excellent explanation! Thank you for your time & demonstration.
You don't need to drop the ball for it to be a balk -- if it leaves your hand while you're on the rubber (for example you toss it up and catch it) that's a balk. I learned this because in high school I wanted to do a silly distracting trick pitch where I tossed and caught the ball mid-windup.
Ahhh good ol 2009. Beautiful times.
Here's another balk situation, the pitcher removes his hand from the ball after he has come to "set" position, say, to adjust his cap or scratch his nose. Another one that always gets a response from the coach is when, during a "hidden ball play", the pitcher returns to within 5 feet of the pitchers plate. (NFHS rules)
this is great... a clear explanation to something even seasoned baseball watchers get hung up on. thanks for posting
Son, this is a very good video. I didn't realize about the shoulder turn Balk, but then again, I only played football.. Anyway Mike Scott, Many Thanks! ! !
what the Balk is going on
Steve C gotta say I found your remark very freakin funny. Considering I'm a High School Umpire who takes this avocation seriously I had to laugh. Contrarily to what some (or all) may think of Umpires as being boring, hard nose Drill Sargent type of individuals without a sense of humor, (well some are). Some umpires may not find humor in your remark, well those would be the boring, hard nose Drill Sargent type of individuals. As, for me I thought that your "what the Balk is going on" was very freakin funny, don't ever lose your sense of humor........keep those around you always laughing, it's good medicine for those who need it, COOL?
ba dum CHING
I just learned about this today. I saw it the second time in an Augie garrido documentary and initially I thought coach was mad about the call being a BALL when it was in reality a strike. Watching it the second time and hearing the pitcher reflect on augies disappointment he said something that sounded like bog.
Thanks for the video.Could help us pick off some runners as the season gets heated.
*Balk Rules*
1) You can't just be up there and just doin' a balk like that.
1a. A balk is when you
1b. Okay well listen. A balk is when you balk the
1c. Let me start over
1c-a. The pitcher is not allowed to do a motion to the, uh, batter, that prohibits the batter from doing, you know, just trying to hit the ball. You can't do that.
1c-b. Once the pitcher is in the stretch, he can't be over here and say to the runner, like, "I'm gonna get ya! I'm gonna tag you out! You better watch your butt!" and then just be like he didn't even do that.
1c-b(1). Like, if you're about to pitch and then don't pitch, you have to still pitch. You cannot not pitch. Does that make any sense?
1c-b(2). You gotta be, throwing motion of the ball, and then, until you just throw it.
1c-b(2)-a. Okay, well, you can have the ball up here, like this, but then there's the balk you gotta think about.
1c-b(2)-b. Fairuza Balk hasn't been in any movies in forever. I hope she wasn't typecast as that racist lady in American History X.
1c-b(2)-b(i). Oh wait, she was in The Waterboy too! That would be even worse.
1c-b(2)-b(ii). "get in mah bellah" -- Adam Water, "The Waterboy." Haha, classic...
1c-b(3). Okay seriously though. A balk is when the pitcher makes a movement that, as determined by, when you do a move involving the baseball and field of
2) Do not do a balk please.
Excellent info on the ball rule.
Also 1: You can't fake a motion toward first base. If you motion toward first, you have to throw the ball. This rule only counts for first base.
Also 2: You can't step on the rubber without the ball. So, the hidden ball trick that you saw pulled off in one of those Bad News Bears movies? It couldn't happen in real life, because in the movie, the pitcher stepped on the rubber and started his pitching motion without the ball, and the first baseman tagged the runner out when he took his lead. But oops, that's a balk, because you can't step on the rubber without the ball in your hand or glove.
Faking towards first is allowed to an extent if you don’t feign and throwing motion. You can look andhold the ball as if you’re about to start a throw, but yeah once the arm moves forward, and even if it doesn’t on a jump throw you have to throw it. You can fake to third the same way you can first, as long as you don’t feign a throwing motion, and as long as no one is on first base at the same time. Once you’ve disengaged from the rubber and are not disengaging while in the act of a pickoff move you can do whatever.
3rd to 1st is now a balk. Also you can throw to an unoccupied base if a play is imminent.
I'm sure its been mentioned before, but the fake to third, throw to first move is now a balk in the majors (and a costly one, since there is a runner on third).
I've seen umps call a pitchers uniform blowing in the breeze a balk.
Great instruction and demonstration. Now... would someone please explain why the stringent balk rule is necessary?
This is a great explanation. Thank you.
This is a good video for balk explanation. The only difference and that's just because of age is when he talks about the slightly open or "hybrid stance" that's basically going to be warned and then called balk from now on at least on the high school level.
Right about 3:37 is when that's being discussed.
Great Video! Great job Mike.
Thanks Mike! great explanation!
This is actually a really good video describing balks,
The 3rd to 1st move was prohibited starting in the 2013 MLB season
Thank you for this video, I never understood what a balk was until I watched this.
Damn, and I wanted to be a pitcher when I was younger.
Terry Mullholand had a pretty good pick off move.
I'm here because of the anime I'm watching did a "force balk" on a pitcher and a commentator said it was a high level play.
Thanks that really helps me.I got called on a balk in one of my games because I put my my foot right by my other and went to second.Thanks for the help. :)
good job on this subject!
Wow, great video! I had no idea there were this many different types of balk! But I do recall a few times over the years, when I saw this: there was a runner on 1st, and another runner on 3rd. The pitcher began the windup, but then quickly stepped off and immediately went through the motion of preparing to throw to the 3d baseman to pick off the runner there, but then instead, he quickly spun around and threw to first. How is that legal, I wonder?
As an ump, I know that can never have enough balk instruction..... good job.
Thanks for posting this! im a 1st year umpire & it helped
Now that I understand it, pitching on paper, is the most refined and confined movement in all baseball.
Except for Tuesdays when there is a full moon.
That's a schralk.
@username20698 Yes, if playing under Official Baseball Rules (OBR). But in high school (NFHS) the play is dead immediately, even if the batter hits a home run.
I got some free bases as a runner in my youth playing Pee-Wee league as the wild pitchers did this at least a couple of times per game.Funny how 'Walk' and 'Balk' are what many people think is just baseball jargon but 'balk' actually means exactly what it is.
Balk isn't really that complicated. He's just being hyper detailed and repeating himself a lot. The balk rule exists for a reason. Without it, leads and steals would become practically irrelevant / impossible. Also, baseball can be understood on different levels and still thoroughly enjoyed. This video is for people who want to know EVERYTHING. It's not like you have to know all of this stuff to be able to understand and enjoy a baseball game.
Pitcher with open shoulder set position often signal pitch delivery by first move of closing shoulder, slowing delivery time, and helping base stealers. Careful.
you dont need to pause if your picking off only when your going to the plate.
FYI for everyone watching, the move he mentioned at 4:00, the fake to 3rd throw to 1st maneuver, has been made illegal as of the 2013 season.
Good video now I know what to do when I'm on the mound.
Just saw one in the Mets / Braves game on Father's day.
It’s so simple, I can’t believe umps blow so many balk calls
Interesting Mike, thank you.
It brings a question right away form the 2018 World Series. David Price in my book was "balking" all the time with his left foot. Before throwing to the plate, his left foot leaves the balk several times before the actual throw. Is that legal?
No, that is technically a balk but a lot of guys do that and it’s rarely called. If it’s a constant part of your pitching motion and you do it every pitch it’s usually it’s ok. But if he’s doing it intentionally to deceive the runners it constitutes a balk. I never noticed price doing that but I will def look at that from now on.
thanks for the lesson
Very very good explanation
Thank you! Great job!
Also alot of people don't know this but a right hander technically can pick his front foot up and go to first base as long as it goes directly to first. It can not go up then out to first it has to go straight around to first, but most umpires will call it a balk. And yes i'm talking about RIGHT handers.
Connor Coultas as long as he can get somehow make no movement towards home and land his foot 45 degrees or less towards first base. One the pitcher makes any significant movement forward towards the plate he has to Theo the ball and land his landing foot no more than halfway between first and home. That’s very hard to do w this move and I guarantee it would get called constantly. With cleats and on the dirt it’s almost impossible to do this without making a movement towards the plate.because swinging the front foot around is probably considered moving towards home.
actually guys and gals if your in the stretch you can pick your leg up,as u do so a righty going to first doesnt let his leg move any towards home or he has to throw, but with leg up if you start leaning falling towards first thats not a balk. see what they are not saying is you must throw the ball if you do not step off first. if your set and decide to throw to 1,2,3 then you must throw or its a balk. lets review. step off first do what you want, set and decide to go anywhere other than home must not even lean towards home but pick the leg up as like your going to deliver but instead of home you take that hiked up leg and go to the chosen base but you must throw, or youve balked
Excellent instruction! However, the wind noise was distracting. Consider investing in a windscreen or a zeppelin for your microphone. Good luck!
Actually, with the pitch clock, now there IS a need to rush when in the position shown at 5:51. The clock runs until the pitcher kicks and moves towards the plate.
at 2:57 that dog
@Hollywooddave123 if you're not on the rubber and taking signals its a balk, also if you move your feet in any way to either start a pitch or pickoff, and you don't do either, its a balk.
Great point. If you’re taking pitch signals in a set position off the rubber it’s a balk. You can take pickoff and fielding or bunt rotations for example off the rubber if the catcher isn’t in the crouch and pitcher isn’t set on the stripe. It may be considered a mound visit in some cases. But you’re absolutely right he can’t receive pitch signals from the catcher off the rubber in a typical stretch position.
Great vid, thanks!
Mike Scott...Houston Astros? 1986 NL Cy Young winner? Was wondering what you were up to.
remember , a balk is a judgment call by an ump. satisfy the ump so they will not call a balk on you
Baseball is the only sport where something like a balk is more confusing than advanced genetics engineering. But your explanation was pretty good, I admit. I could never figure out what this damn rule meant.
A bit outdated. You can no longer fake a move to third and then throw to first.
+Phil Dunn Wrong. Very wrong. Reading is your friend. You can no longer feint a throw to third in the Official Baseball Rules (OBR) which govern Major League Baseball. I'm pretty sure that this guy isn't instructing MLB pitchers. For NCAA and High School (Fed), you can still feint a throw to third. Ironically, some youth leagues (USSSA) base their rules on OBR instead of Fed rules. In those leagues, because of OBR, feinting to 3rd is a balk. The rules by which you are playing are extremely important. In most cases, feinting to 3rd is still legal (as of Dec 2015).
+67L48 Relax, really - "Wrong, Very wrong"? yet you accept it's true in MLB and other leagues (e.g., Babe Ruth & Cal Ripken Leagues)...and you have no idea which leagues I had in mind. Expertise in baseball rules, maybe. Expertise in social behavior, well... maybe less rulebook reading would be your friend.
Phil Dunn My league does it all the time.
Yes you can as long as 3rd is occupied!
@@christopherstewart3590 No, in MLB a pitcher, from the rubber, can never fake a throw to third or first base.
great video. thanks
Be aware that faking to third and throwing to first was classified as a balk in 2013 in the MLB. Often times, the lower levels of baseball follow suit when it comes to rules and especially balk rules. Like so others can see.
If you're in the windup, yes, you have to step off. The ONLY thing you can do in a windup is pitch. The only way to do anything else is to step off and become a fielder. In the Set position, you've balked right off the bat. In a set, you must have one foot engaged with the rubber and one foot COMPLETELY in front of it.
Nice Job!!
This helped so much
Great video.
To any body who doesn't know. Most baseball select leagues, and i'm pretty sure high school and college (although don't quote me on that) have made it illegal to fake to third and then go to first.
Connor Coultas most higher level leagues I would assume banned the move. I played D3 ending in 06 and it was banned in our conference.
Never knew what a balk was, until today.
nice job coach. I like the vid.
Pitchers are another breed.
this video needs to be updated....
Stepping off with your glove side foot - that's a paddlin'