AI2 group performance - For the longest time

American idol 2 - The top 7 performing Billy Joels 'For the longest time'

[@JaeJaeBlaze]

Oh geez I was beginning to think no one had this up. This was probably one of my fave preformances. Thanks for sharing!

[@vstreamer]

The harmonies are great on this. Clay's voice is really good. lol at Ruben sitting on the stool - he takes up so much space.

[@PureAloha78]

Love love LOVE it!!!!!!!!

[@TaroUehara]

SOOOO GOOOODDDD!!!!!!!!

[@oraliax]

best group performances

[@dancingbutrfli]

I had forgotten what a good job AI2 did on this song - one of my all time favorites by Billy Joel. Thanks so much for posting.

[@theballer04]

Be that as it may, this is awesome.

[@Totallywild624]

Oh my God! This is like my favourite song ever! Then when Clay sang a bit I almost had a heart attack, he is like my favourite singer ever!

[@Flamesn]

wow! the voice of the man in the middle is awesome!!!

[@kytsky]

AI 2 has always been my favorite. The top 5 are awesome. Love Ruben, Clay & Kimberly. Josh is my favorite. Wish I knew what Trenyce is up to? She is so very talented!!!!!!!!

[@aaalllccc]

i love this! season 2 had the best harmonies

[@ColossusLibra]

The high-pitch voice was just right. It's not out of place. If you listen to Billy Joel's original version, it's really like that.

[@rbartfan18]

I love Ruben singing bass in this!

[@deepoceanmystique]

The best season ever, miss them so badly.. 😭😭

[@taboonalady]

I'm so addicted to this song.
This performance proves that season 2 had the one of the best, if not best, top 12 on AI.

[@54spiritedwill54]

Great performance!

[@garden333]

Clay is the best, but I sure did love hearing AI2 group singing the best. They all did an amazing job. I can't wait until they do the Idol rewind for AI2.

[@McWaters12]

Clay's singing is electrifying

[@JoshFreilich]

They have GREAT harmonies on that song, and I especially like the girls' lower ranges on it. That's surprising.

[@cyrusvail]

i didn't know what is it about season 2's group songs---the voice blendings (or whatever you call it) is the best out of all 6 seasons.

[@Shadywolf09]

Its funny how when the guys step in and start singing that the crowd cheers them on but when the girls sing there are barely any.Great song,Clay is my favoite

[@PureAloha78]

Haha I noticed that too lol

[@dookiekong007]

My school had individual groups of girls and guys from choir to go around and sing thing song to those who you want to be sang to for a low charge but I know people n i didnt have to pay but I had them sang to my crush

[@ajamaicanparadox1]

yea i loooooooooooooooove the top 5 one.. but its not on you tuve nemore it makes me cry.. but this one is so great too

[@BigM161]

tru dat!

[@ishmaelkhalid]

I second that, Tanto92!

[@EndlesslyAlive]

i also agree

[@gracinxangel]

i love that you can hear josh over all of them!!

[@omegazman]

clay, rubin, and josh's voices mix extremely well!

[@therealbroeslie]

I think the best part is at 1:23 (don't know what the singer's name is.
Which part do you like best?

[@emanizzle]

no joke, they did..

[@eecorr]

Well I play piano,drums,bass,harmonica,guitar but you dont hear me complaining :)

[@gsi2006]

i didnt even know they performed this song.... its alright... never beats the original

[@ajamaicanparadox1]

his name is Clay Aiken.

[@firefighter6199]

@rbartfan18 He wasn't singing bass...It was someone back stage...lol He's a tenor

[@ClayTakeover]

@baredd79 They are were like best friends. Clay lived with Kimberly after the show, and he just toured with Ruben. They all got along

[@BigM161]

Ruben's got two girls while the other two guys got one- He's a pimp!

[@Josh057]

ruban doesnt stand out this song. i mean, phtsically he does, but i understand that he's needed for the bass. i really love clay, he's a great singer. but when ruban sung "sweet home alabama", he juss blew me away. i'm glad he won!

[@OMBtaneously]

This is my favorite AMERICAN Idol Group Performance!

[@polishpat822]

hahaha wow how can u forget Ruebens clasic 205 shirts

[@firefighter6199]

@basejumper123 Amen!!! It is not right!

[@firefighter6199]

@Mikakitten1724 Hahaha! That's where you're wrong...I've won several singing competitions over the course of my life, I'm currently the best voted singer in my county, rated best singer in High school, and college, AND to top that all off, I've been talked to by talent scouts. I'm moving on up so you can sit and spin...
I'm only pointing out the obvious...Calm down there....

[@EvilLoynis]

It could be but I think it's either the Blonde or Brunette on the left side.

[@aznpinoy17]

did anyone else hear the mistake between 2:10 and 2:13?

[@moxguy19]

What's the blonde girl's name?

[@Totallywild624]

@firefighter6199 I don't give a flying shit dude, hes still awesome.

[@therealbroeslie]

I agree. Perhaps the pitch is too low for female

[@xbabyholdontomex]

clay shoulda won!!

[@Wat0the0french0toast]

haha the big guy got two women

[@6menonaplane]

Big guy needed 2 girls, nice!

[@sweetipi2007]

no, ur not.....lol...i thought the same thing the first time i watched it. they do look cute

[@noerlund75]

not much but a pitch to high.. but beside that... superb!

[@ClayTakeover]

@NIMRODakaNIMROD Clay Aiken didnt end up being some wannabe bud.

[@PureAloha78]

Kimberly Caldwells hair looks ridiculous.

[@moxguy19]

Sorry, the blond girl next to Ruben is the one I meant.

[@KristieWilson]

Eric Itzin her name is kimberly caldwell.

[@Bba11MANIAK03]

i thought josh was sooo cool.. he's a great singer.. but clay and ruben were better i must say. i still think he's the coolest though.

[@Dreammaster695]

i like seasons 11s better

[@DTraj]

Nice.
Although some of the female singers over-do it and ruin the harmony.

[@Imperator837]

A girl can't sing this song. Only Billy.

[@jcorbin1776]

Btw... uhhh... he's gay...???

[@eecorr]

so what, have some respect its not what you are its who you are..gay or not I bet he can sing better then you ;)

[@Mikakitten1724]

@firefighter6199 But not as queer as your mobile home. Shut up about him being gay, does it matter?
He's an amazing singer I don't see why you feel the need to troll. Yeah, you'll never have a voice as good as his or close to anyone of them, get over yourself.

[@skitzo429]

its actually quite out of tune.

[@janetscarlandmay]

this just ruined the song for me

[@JoshaHoudt]

Not very good.