Putting Gordon Ramsay's Scrambled Eggs To The Test

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 май 2024
  • A great scrambled egg recipe is hard to come by, but today we're trying out three of the best from Gordon Ramsay, Thomas Keller, and Heston Blumenthal -- who will wind up being the best? All of these are 3 Michelin Star chefs and are clearly incredible in the kitchen, but which one is the best to make at home? 👀
    #scrambledeggs #eggs #gordonramsay #thomaskeller #breakfast #recipes

Комментарии • 603

  • @gfysyoutube
    @gfysyoutube 8 месяцев назад +38

    I had breakfast at my local IHOP last Sunday. I watched the chef in the kitchen contemplating which one of these recipes to use.

    • @deborahhernandez7785
      @deborahhernandez7785 4 месяца назад +2

      😂😂😂

    • @julesfalcone
      @julesfalcone 2 месяца назад +2

      I'm going to request Heston Blumenthal's next time I notice the chef at IHOP trying to decide.

    • @samsonbelai2489
      @samsonbelai2489 2 месяца назад +1

      😂😂😂

  • @animahmed1190
    @animahmed1190 Год назад +394

    Blumenthal's recipes are always a fuss but they taste really really good. His fries recipe is very good but involves quite a few phases.

    • @dochollowday8288
      @dochollowday8288 Год назад +42

      Yeah, no kidding. Years ago I made his Chili con Carne from In Search of Perfection. Best thing I ever made, by a good margin. But it took 3 days to make, several shopping trips, some mailorders... I will never make it again. But I learned a lot from it.

    • @nicholascrow8133
      @nicholascrow8133 Год назад +2

      Triple cooked fries are the gold standard

    • @shadmanhasan6047
      @shadmanhasan6047 Год назад +4

      HIs triple fried chips is simply incomparable

    • @christopherkarr1872
      @christopherkarr1872 10 месяцев назад

      @@loganliszt4769 I feel as though Michael was trying to maintain consistency between them by including only chives, eggs and dairy. Either that or he didn't have sherry vin handy. I only keep apple cider vin, red wine vin, white wine vin, and 6 varieties of balsamic around.

    • @bearsnevergiveup
      @bearsnevergiveup 9 месяцев назад +2

      Blumenthal's fish and chips - the family thought the vodka strange (they expected beer) until they ate it all up.

  • @amasterfuldesktop4935
    @amasterfuldesktop4935 9 месяцев назад +29

    From my experience the saucepan for Gordo makes a huge difference because you can quickly scrape all the egg off the bottom and sides without spilling shit all over the stove

    • @noriakikakyoin4430
      @noriakikakyoin4430 14 дней назад

      I made them today. They were delicious but yeah… I spilled a bit over the stove.

    • @HaiTharImDavid
      @HaiTharImDavid 14 дней назад +2

      Also I think because of the smaller surface area of the saucepan, as you scrape up the bottom layers to the top, it gives them time to cool off and not continue cooking as it does in a wider pan when they're all spread out and in contact with the pan.

  • @OCRay1
    @OCRay1 10 месяцев назад +115

    If you take and combine your favorite techniques from each of them you would have the best eggs ever. Like the chives from Gordon, the straining of the eggs like Keller and the overall approach of Blumenthal.

    • @dragonoidwarlord201
      @dragonoidwarlord201 9 месяцев назад +8

      I just tried this instead of chives I used brown butter but it was amazing, incredibly creamy and very rich with flavour

    • @noonynoonynoo
      @noonynoonynoo 9 месяцев назад +3

      GENIUS

    • @thezodiacguru-fl3eq
      @thezodiacguru-fl3eq 8 месяцев назад +2

      It's crazy they're over glorifying three styles of custard and try to call it scrambled eggs I don't get it none of the three are scrambled eggs they're just glorified custards put on a piece of bread 🍞 because all of them are not scrambled eggs 🥚 there's no dairy in scrambled eggs either

    • @Sugleknug
      @Sugleknug 8 месяцев назад

      L@@thezodiacguru-fl3eq

    • @jameswyatt4443
      @jameswyatt4443 8 месяцев назад +7

      @@thezodiacguru-fl3eqThat’s ridiculous. So only your dry plain eggs can be called scrambled eggs? Nope. I have never had scrambled eggs without milk, and I’ve never followed a chef’s recipe. Just because they don’t throw plain eggs into a pan, doesn’t mean they’re not scrambled eggs.

  • @lisarogers8594
    @lisarogers8594 10 месяцев назад +24

    No one ever mentions a technique I read about and have been using for years to get rich, luscious, creamy scrambled eggs, and that’s to add an extra yolk (per 1 or 2 whole eggs), preferably beaten and added just at the very end or if I’m lazy, I add it at the beginning. I can’t wait to try Heston Blumenthal’s adding an extra yolk, straining the eggs a la Thomas Keller before mixing in the dairy and seasonings, and serving it on beaches toast with brown butter and chives.

  • @regulartom5736
    @regulartom5736 Год назад +30

    Thank you for posting this, have been making Gordon eggs for a while, am going to try incorporating some of the techniques of the other two and hopefully making an amalgamation of the best bits of each.

  • @pixelpython7567
    @pixelpython7567 8 месяцев назад +4

    Thought I was crazy for straining the eggs, so glad Keller does it too. It really makes a difference, and I love making it

  • @-austin-23
    @-austin-23 Год назад +133

    These longer videos are fantastic! Would love to see more!

    • @ligier
      @ligier  Год назад +13

      comin right up 😤

    • @-austin-23
      @-austin-23 Год назад +2

      @Michael Ligier LETS GOOO!!!

    • @kper5592
      @kper5592 Год назад +1

      Same here! @ligier more long-form please!

  • @ligier
    @ligier  Год назад +32

    going to be posting long form videos EVERY WEEK starting today 😤 they're only gonna get better from here but make sure to show some love on the vid and let me know what you wanna see next ❤

  • @PerfectT4ste
    @PerfectT4ste Год назад +116

    You missed the sherry vinegar in Heston's version - it truly elevates the dish to new heights.

    • @stefanmariaschneider
      @stefanmariaschneider Год назад +5

      That's disappointing.

    • @krma4352
      @krma4352 11 месяцев назад

      @@loganliszt4769y’all some weird folk. got too much money

    • @gabrieljohnson4213
      @gabrieljohnson4213 10 месяцев назад +10

      ​@@krma4352sherry vinegar eggs and butter are not expensive

    • @christopherkarr1872
      @christopherkarr1872 10 месяцев назад +2

      @@krma4352 I live paycheck to paycheck and I could make some of the best food you've ever tasted. It's not a matter of how much money one spends so much as it is how they use their ingredients and their knowledge and skill. For example, one of the most decadent desserts I've had is a vanilla panna cotta with candied orange zest and orange syrup. I made it myself out of cream, vanilla, gelatin packet(s) and some sugar and oranges. I also added some canning citric acid for tang. All inexpensive ingredients; a serving costs less than the same volume of store-bought ice cream.

    • @lostboy8084
      @lostboy8084 9 месяцев назад +1

      And Gordon didn't use that pan but a pot

  • @cabbage8388
    @cabbage8388 Год назад +11

    gordon: a knob of butter
    keller: i like straining
    heston: yum buter

  • @typebflieger
    @typebflieger 9 месяцев назад +13

    Great video. I have only done the Ramsay recipe because of the single pan and easy cleanup. Also, the taste has me satisfied for the amount of time it takes. One addition that has helped take these into a new territory: a generous helping of shaved parm or pecorino romano. It adds a salty/umami component that makes the eggs more interesting.
    That said, I’ll give these other recipes a shot soon. Thanks for sharing!

    • @johkonut
      @johkonut 6 месяцев назад +1

      Wow, I'm going to have to try the parm next time!

    • @matthewhudson5685
      @matthewhudson5685 6 месяцев назад

      Yes! A little bit of cheese of almost any type makes the eggs "Pop"!
      But not too much!
      I like to mix in a 'sprinkle' at the very end, right before serving. So just melted, but still separate.

  • @rubssi8741
    @rubssi8741 Год назад +17

    Really enjoy the long format videos, hope to see more!

    • @ligier
      @ligier  Год назад +2

      you’re gonna be getting a new one every week now 😤

    • @rubssi8741
      @rubssi8741 Год назад +1

      @@ligier :pog:

  • @jonahrosen6173
    @jonahrosen6173 Год назад +306

    Gordon advises using a saucepan rather than a frying pan so not 100% accurate

    • @raymondlin8728
      @raymondlin8728 10 месяцев назад +7

      Why. I work in many diners, that's how we do it

    • @rat_king2801
      @rat_king2801 9 месяцев назад +73

      ​@@raymondlin8728because thats the ramsay recipe. not your truck stop eggs.

    • @sherlockhomo-ph4su
      @sherlockhomo-ph4su 8 месяцев назад +7

      ​@@rat_king2801😂😂

    • @Al-zs6tq
      @Al-zs6tq 8 месяцев назад +21

      @@rat_king2801bro is mad over eggs

    • @icankillbugs
      @icankillbugs 8 месяцев назад +7

      ​@@Al-zs6tqthe only time I get mad over eggs is seeing them scorched and brown and crunchy

  • @AnaInTh3Sky
    @AnaInTh3Sky Год назад +7

    Rule of thumb: more butter makes things taste better.
    You are welcome

  • @pegasus210563
    @pegasus210563 9 месяцев назад +1

    I use to melt the butter on high heat in a pan and then turn the heat to low. While butter is melting I whisk the eggs with salt, black or white pepper AND the shives and a teaspoon of water for each egg.
    When butter dont "talk" anymore I put the eggs into the pan and stear together as in the video.
    Think this way gives a better taste, flavor and consistence than most restaurants.
    Offcourse served on toasted white bread (with no kind of sugar what so ever in the recipe) spreaded with butter, as that sweet taste from the sugar destoy the taste of allmost every dish with salt in it.

  • @andreas-panay
    @andreas-panay Год назад +25

    I've gotta try heston blumenthal's but honestly I'm not sure if super silky really appeals to me. I like the fact gordon ramsay's has a bit more texture, and not whisking before cooking must be intentional - feels like he was going for a different thing.
    So I think ramsay's vs the other is more about what you're going for, and the real competition is keller vs blumenthal if you want a super creamy smooth scramble

    • @norwegianblue2764
      @norwegianblue2764 Год назад +3

      I agree. I don't want my scrambled eggs to be "creamy" or "almost like a custard." I prefer a little more substance. With that said, it is nice to see the variety of methods presented in this video. It allows us all to experiment with each of them and come up with our own recipe. First thing I'm going to try is Gordon's approach to cooking the eggs, topped with Blumenthal's brown butter and Keller's parsley. Bacon and toast on the side.

    • @alistairlewis2461
      @alistairlewis2461 11 месяцев назад

      I agree too.

    • @christopherkarr1872
      @christopherkarr1872 10 месяцев назад +2

      It's amazing how an echo chamber can be consistently incorrect. THe three styles of egg are all *supposed* to be custardy. The execution by this youtuber was poor, so only Heston's came out remotely as intended, which *is* a function of the technique and the lower heat conduction by the bain marie. Gordon always says you want the smallest egg curd size possible, and Keller's method is roughly the same.

    • @epona9166
      @epona9166 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@christopherkarr1872 Idk about the other two but Gordon Ramsay doesn't appear to be going for "custardy". I've watched three of his scrambled egg videos and he never says that. Fluffy and creamy is how he describes his eggs.

    • @christopherkarr1872
      @christopherkarr1872 7 месяцев назад

      @@epona9166 In fairness, Gordo's method gets you an extremely custardy egg with good texture and color (at least the MasterChef tutorial version). That said, in that tutorial he left them a bit too liquid-ey (likely on purpose, for dramatic effect). I think he doesn't like comparing it to custard because the eggs aren't meant to be sweet, and 'custardy' isn't a word. Honestly, the variations in doneness in his tutorials gives me pause. He's an excellent restaurateur, and perhaps a great *head chef*, but his consistency needs some work, as does his food science knowledge (as his grilled cheese recipe shows). Besides, the salt may denature the e proteins *if overcooked*, but the pepper will only release its flavor throughout the mix during the cooking process. His method is decidedly inferior.

  • @kevinmoy3752
    @kevinmoy3752 10 месяцев назад +6

    Just wanted to point out that ramsay's method is intended to save time. The bane marie simply gives you a longer grace period to scrape the curds before they get too thick/stiff. With perfect technique, it should yield the same results in a third of the cook time (obviously easier said than done).

    • @christopherkarr1872
      @christopherkarr1872 10 месяцев назад

      Thanks - I just went through four comment threads with people blindly commenting on 'better texture this' and 'I prefer this method' that. They're all intended to have the exact same texture; some people just don't have the skill and attentiveness to do it Keller's or Gordon's way, so the bain marie makes the consistency easier to achieve.

  • @diannegreenshields7421
    @diannegreenshields7421 9 месяцев назад +1

    This is the way that I cook scrambled eggs: I crack a few eggs into a bowl (the amount of eggs depends on the number of people you're cooking for). I then add some salt and pepper, some butter, a splash of water and half a pint of full fat milk (ONLY because I prefer my toast to be soggyfied? That's not a word, but it should be!...in the delicious juices that accrue whilst cooking). The toast will soak it up, making it swell up, which for me...is super tasty! If you don't like that extra juice...just use less milk. Please trust me, for anybody who doesn't mind their toast getting soggy underneath their scrambled eggs, YET STILL have the flavor of the toasted bread...It's a taste sensation! I grate some cheese (I LOVE Cathedral City, Mature Cheese) and chop some chives. I then get a frying pan and add a knob of butter. I melt that on a low heat...(which I continue throughout cooking). While the butter is melting, I whisk my eggs until it's a smooth consistency. I put my bread into the toaster and the frying pan is hot by now so I pour the mixture into it. I constantly stir it until it's almost cooked, take it off of the heat, add a large tablespoon of Creme Fraiche, the grated cheese and Chives, return to the heat and stir them into the eggs for about a minute. (The butter and cheese will have already added a bit of saltiness, so no need for any more. Maybe a wee bit more pepper though...depending on your own personal taste) Butter my toast, put the eggs on top of it then add some of that lovely juice. MY style of cooking scrambled eggs. Super creamy and tasty AF! I hope you guys try it!

  • @arigato22
    @arigato22 8 месяцев назад +2

    I have done all three styles and they taste similar to me. What I read or noticed was also that the different styles; French vs British vs American. I like French and British styles. The French is quite runny which the bain marie is great for... but it takes so long I just cook it in a pan so I just do the ramsay style! I should try brioche bread though! :)

  • @VegasLoungeAct
    @VegasLoungeAct 9 месяцев назад +4

    When I want to spend a little time to give myself luxurious scrambled eggs, I also cook them using a double boiler. This makes them have a velvety texture that's amazing.

  • @michaelfouladi4961
    @michaelfouladi4961 8 месяцев назад +2

    Blumenthal’s recipes always take the longest to make, but they’re more than worth it when you try them

  • @ok373737
    @ok373737 Год назад +3

    Exceptional video! love your high quality content.

  • @derekarnold3665
    @derekarnold3665 Год назад +3

    Heston Blumental uses the classic French technique to make scrambled eggs, namely using a Bain-marie method of not cooking the eggs on direct heat.

  • @arnaldoalegria2209
    @arnaldoalegria2209 Год назад +37

    The chives adds so much flavor to the eggs, that's why I like Gordon's the most

    • @joyalord3811
      @joyalord3811 Год назад +3

      I so agree with you!!

    • @mtl-ss1538
      @mtl-ss1538 3 месяца назад +2

      @@joyalord3811 .. But can he make a Cheese Toasted Sandwich. !!!

  • @axelris
    @axelris Год назад +7

    i’ve done all 3 before too. Heston is the one i make most freq but i do gordon’s with smoked salmon when im in a rush

  • @4DR14NCR41G
    @4DR14NCR41G Год назад +5

    Heston’s way but with the Sherry Vinegar, may take longer but also requires the least attention so can get on with other things and perfect for big gatherings/portions sizes

  • @kper5592
    @kper5592 Год назад +2

    Thanks for doing the investigative work. Imma try all three. Hehe

  • @christopherkarr1872
    @christopherkarr1872 10 месяцев назад +6

    Gordon's method is by far the best for a production kitchen. Heston's is the best for reliable creamy texture. Keller's is somewhere in the middle. Sourdough is the best choice of bread; it complements the richness of the eggs. Truth be told, the texture should have been much more consistent on the eggs, despite the cooking differences. This is a matter of the cook's skill and attentiveness, which determines the curd size and finishing point.

  • @Hollis_wants_your_comments
    @Hollis_wants_your_comments 8 месяцев назад

    You ought to try Mandy Lee's 15-Second Scrambled Eggs - excluding the very short prep time, these scrambled eggs really do take only 15 seconds. Anyone can make them without having to attend culinary school. And they beat all three of your chefs' scrambled eggs for creaminess and simplicity by literally hundreds of seconds!
    She serves them with the most amazing Mushroom Cream, and toast for dipping into, not being spread upon. The recipe is on RUclips as well as all over the internet.
    Mandy Lee is the author of The Art of Escapism Cooking. She doesn't suck all the air out of the room like Gordon Ramsey or fuss with prepping a myriad of ingredients to end up with a minuscule amount of food on the plate like Thomas Keller. And even Heston Blumenthal could learn a thing or two from her.
    Her fusion recipes are unlike any you've ever seen, and their uniqueness is a breath of fresh air.

  • @ethan.anderson680
    @ethan.anderson680 Год назад +3

    I use Hestons recipe As I don’t mind the extra time for the extra flavour. The washing up isn’t even that bad as you use just boil the water to wash the dishes.

  • @kingpin__
    @kingpin__ Год назад +6

    ITS FELT LIKE YEARS SINCE THE LAST LONG VIDEO FINALLY

    • @kingpin__
      @kingpin__ Год назад

      Great vid tho man might make them eggs for me tomorrow morning ngl

  • @tiamta
    @tiamta 8 месяцев назад

    where did you get that amazing violin cover of "die hoelle rache" from the magic flute? I can't find a cover without a singer

  • @meanodustino9563
    @meanodustino9563 6 месяцев назад +4

    I do the thomas keller. The egg consistency is amazing once strained. I don’t think I will do any other way now. So much easier to control the consistency as they cook. ❤ add cayenne pepper and some butter and they are fantastic.

  • @ExpatMagyar
    @ExpatMagyar 7 месяцев назад +2

    Chef Jean-Pierre is worth a look too, although not a Michelin Star chef, his credentials and style are impressive. I use his scrambled egg recipe continuously, have tried others too.

    • @willtopper
      @willtopper 5 месяцев назад

      as chef Jean Pierre says ... don't forget to butter the toast ;)

  • @Drake844221
    @Drake844221 Год назад +8

    So, I'm pretty well hooked on eggs these days. Have been for a while now XD I've got a few tricks with scrambled eggs that I've come across. One is from a brunch I had at a local seafood restaurant, which was called a salmon scramble. I loved it so much that I essentially reverse-engineered it. I'll beat my eggs with some heavy cream and minced fresh dill, in prep, I'll get some cream cheese softened up (usually just by scraping it into dollops with a fork to warm a little while I do the rest), and I'll grab some cold smoked salmon, cut up fairly finely. Then, I'll melt some butter in a pan on fairly low heat, and add the eggs in, stirring constantly. When the eggs are starting to come together, I'll add most of the cream cheese, stirring until it is all set. Then, I'll take the eggs off of the heat entirely, add in the last of the cream cheese, mix that through, and then finally add in the salmon, when there's just enough heat left in the system to warm it without really cooking it. It comes out amazingly well, and I've taken to buying packs of cold smoked salmon, pre-dicing the whole thing, and then just keeping it in a jar in the fridge, along with a pack of fresh dill. I'll usually serve it on some lightly toasted shokupan with butter that I get from a local bakery.
    The other thing I've taken to doing with my eggs is beating them with the heavy cream, as before, but also adding in some toasted sesame seed oil, and some really nice soy sauce. I'll also slice up a green onion (usually an entire one's worth), separating the whites from the greens. I'll add the whites to the eggs, mixing them in to cook a little with the egg, and I'll garnish with the greens after it is off the heat. I'll even (often) use cream cheese in this preparation as well, much like the previous one. I came up with this one day when my wife made some homemade crab rangoons, and I wanted to round them out with some eggs to make more of a meal of it while staying true to the flavors already present in the meal. I've continued to make those kinds of eggs ever since.
    I've even been known to combine the two methods to pretty outstanding effect. I've really been enjoying preparing my eggs this way, and I've even been... kind of dissatisfied with the 'loaded' scrambled eggs that I used to make (with diced bacon, ground sausage, cheddar, and whatnot).
    But, at the end of the day, the one of these three that is probably closest to how I make my own eggs at home is Thomas Keller. I don't strain mine, but I do whisk them separately from the pan, and I cook them at a low temperature, stirring constantly. Even the cream cheese serves a lot of the same function as the creme fraiche (though, I should really get some of that and try it out).

    • @user-wg6cm3ko3v
      @user-wg6cm3ko3v 11 месяцев назад +1

      Just going to comment to save this

    • @christopherkarr1872
      @christopherkarr1872 10 месяцев назад

      2 cups heavy whipping cream plus 1TBSP buttermilk plus 12hrs on the counter equals creme fraiche. Another option - though not as silky - is greek yogurt; a bit more tangy and lower in fat. My favorite deviation from these recipes is to add in some grated or microplaned cheese (depending on their meltiness) near the end of cooking and before the addition of the cold dairy (creme fraiche, cream cheese or yogurt).

  • @TommyTipex
    @TommyTipex 11 месяцев назад +2

    Apart from the browned butter additions Heston's method is just the classical way of doing it, Albert Roux said he would only do it that way and if you didn't have time, just boil an egg

  • @irrationallyirritated4011
    @irrationallyirritated4011 8 месяцев назад

    The Blumenthal eggs were FANTASTIC...the beurre noisette takes it to another level.

  • @jamesiyer4937
    @jamesiyer4937 Год назад

    I really enjoyed this video Michael, very interesting!

  • @jcl5345
    @jcl5345 8 месяцев назад

    Thomas Keller is famous for straining things. I'm a culinarian, I heard a long time ago that he strains his stocks multiple times, I've heard 5 times, 9 times, even more. Different numbers. Most interesting, he doesn't allow his cooks to use a ladle to push the liquid through, or even tap the strainers (chinois) which is pretty common. He only allows swirling to bring the liquid through.

  • @user-zu6ir6kj5g
    @user-zu6ir6kj5g Год назад

    I was taught the bain Marie method 50 years ago, before Heston was born. His beurrre noisette drizzle is an interesting addition.

  • @masongoldsmith481
    @masongoldsmith481 Год назад +1

    didnt realise how much i wanted this video haha

    • @ligier
      @ligier  Год назад

      boutta start cookin like a 3 michelin star chef for breakfast

  • @alderblanco2362
    @alderblanco2362 Год назад +2

    This reminds me, I need to try again to make a french omelette! I haven't gotten it set enough that it doesn't crack. I've made the Ramsey eggs before as well, super tasty! perhaps I'll try the Keller eggs next! (im not patient enough for the Blumenthal eggs lol)

    • @tornagawn
      @tornagawn Год назад +1

      I had one for my dinner….. I’ve had a flu like illness and wanted something light.
      Just keep it moving, stirring, and tilt the pan, flip and fold. No browning on the exterior, just set but creamy interior.
      The best video I’ve found on cooking a proper French omlet is by the legendary Jacques Pépin, on RUclips.

    • @christopherkarr1872
      @christopherkarr1872 10 месяцев назад

      @@tornagawn That's a great instructional; for more insight, there's also the newer video featuring Jacques on Alex French Guy Cooking's youtube channel.

  • @Vincent_Beers
    @Vincent_Beers 7 месяцев назад +5

    I actually use a combination of all three and just adjust based on mood. Variations on scrambled eggs and omelettes are nearly endless. Once you understand the basic concepts for each you should be experimenting based on what you have available.

  • @JamesCarmichael
    @JamesCarmichael 9 месяцев назад

    I use four eggs, but I'll save two of the yokes. Long gentle cook in the pan, but in a seperate pan I'll poach the two yokes for a minute. That way I can have scrambled egg with some yokes on it. A lovely combo of flavour and texture.

    • @jcl5345
      @jcl5345 8 месяцев назад

      yolks

    • @jcl5345
      @jcl5345 8 месяцев назад

      separate

  • @horrorfan24
    @horrorfan24 Год назад +2

    I've combined the methods. Take the milk, butter and a touch of double cream (no salt added) from HB and cook it in a pan on a very low heat, alla TK. Add the touch of creme fresh, salt and chives at the end alla GR. Job done.

  • @alexbentwood7189
    @alexbentwood7189 Год назад +13

    You should definitely try making Cantonese style scrambled eggs

    • @BlowinFree
      @BlowinFree Год назад +1

      Do they add dog to the mixture 😜

    • @AkkiLad
      @AkkiLad Год назад +4

      @@BlowinFree Unfortunately no, but they do add Asian-level perfectionism! 😄

    • @sc705
      @sc705 Год назад +1

      Canto egg style is the best

  • @elisabethsmith1448
    @elisabethsmith1448 8 месяцев назад

    I love Michael Symon's technique. Quick and amazing.

  • @MeshellD
    @MeshellD 7 месяцев назад

    I'm going to have to try these, I like the french versions better normally. The low heat and constant stirring is a game changer compared to all of the eggs I've had growing up in America, no offense to my home country but they can't cook eggs once you've had eggs from somewhere that is good. I only eat eggs at home now following the french methods and adding a teaspoon of boursin almost at end.

  • @baloghbotond4250
    @baloghbotond4250 5 месяцев назад +5

    The third egg recipe was made by my grandma since I was a little boy and she still makes them today (she`s 83 years old). Imagine the skill and knowledge she knows about cooking everything you can imagine, and she did this before those chefs were even born!

    • @5GreenAcres
      @5GreenAcres 3 месяца назад

      I am a 66 yr old woman who makes them this way but haven't used the brown butter. Anything with butter is great!

  • @jasperyoung2466
    @jasperyoung2466 Год назад +1

    I love the over the top reaction for some goddamn eggs

  • @hanslick3375
    @hanslick3375 8 месяцев назад

    'Literally' beurre noisette means HAZELNUT BUTTER. Because butter develops a hazelnut taste when browned.

  • @vgvlogs4182
    @vgvlogs4182 7 месяцев назад

    Didn’t even need to wait for the taste test to know Blumenthats would taste the best.

  • @jonasholmqvist5231
    @jonasholmqvist5231 Год назад +4

    Loved the video! Made all three myself and agree Heston's is both best and most complicated. However, didn't like Keller's so much. Gets a bit too smooth, prefer some variation in the texture - and the brioche is too sweet for me.
    So would go with Heston's once in a while, Gordon's for everyday meals.

    • @derekarnold3665
      @derekarnold3665 Год назад +1

      Heston uses the classic French method of using a Bain-marie making scrambled eggs. I use that method and add grated truffles. Once in while!

  • @ArizonaGunsDave
    @ArizonaGunsDave 9 месяцев назад

    Nothing beats scrambled eggs with hot sauce on them. I never use salt, pepper or ketchup. Those ingredients are as east coast and white as potato salad.

  • @RufinoMendoza
    @RufinoMendoza Год назад

    The Roux Brothers use the bain marie method as well. Also, according to J. Kenji López-Alt, Daniel Bouloud uses cold butter, which he learned as a young chef in Lyon.

  • @kessler1kessler811
    @kessler1kessler811 Год назад +4

    Gordon’s scrambled eggs have changed my life!!! I’ll take the 10 minutes to make a dish!! 👍👍👍

    • @mtl-ss1538
      @mtl-ss1538 3 месяца назад +1

      .. But can he make a Cheese Toasted Sandwich. !!!

  • @KeirMurphy
    @KeirMurphy 9 месяцев назад

    Milk and cream when cooking makes fluffy scrambled eggs. I've always had it that way and any other way feels "sloppy" once you're familiar with milk/cream

  • @roboliver9980
    @roboliver9980 9 месяцев назад +1

    Shame you couldn’t find someone to setup a blind taste test of the eggs alone.

  • @heyitsvonage2768
    @heyitsvonage2768 9 месяцев назад +1

    I season in the bowl, and pick out those lumps with a fork... Seems like I've been using Keller's method instinctively!
    But after watching this, I think I'll just steal the best parts of each method. Strain the eggs, cook them in the pan directly, make brown butter to top them 😩

  • @urieled1120
    @urieled1120 Год назад +53

    Keller is the winner. The straining eggs it's also really useful when making french omelets. It's a trick a learned from the omurice video in Japan. The Blumenthal method reminds me of the modernist carbonara, where you are basically making a savory zabaione more than a scrumble egg

    • @joyalord3811
      @joyalord3811 Год назад +3

      Carbonara should NEVER have a "scrumble" egg texture. It should be creamy and smooth with a residual moisture. (You don't put cream or milk in carbonara, either.)

    • @panathasg13
      @panathasg13 Год назад +1

      modernist carbonara or 100% fullproof safe carbonara ;) ??

    • @Tazza19931
      @Tazza19931 4 месяца назад

      Blumenthal's eggs are superior, but not as practical to make regularly at home. Made it once and loved it, but probably won't do it again.

  • @SinForTheSaint
    @SinForTheSaint Месяц назад

    My grandpa used to cook eggs on a double boiler. Always loved his eggs the most. More than anything still to this day

  • @rb4223
    @rb4223 9 месяцев назад

    I mean if I’m spending 10 minutes to watch this I can probably spare 20 minutes to taste it

  • @Dx_Ach
    @Dx_Ach Год назад +2

    The reason why they use a double boiler to cook the eggs because it holds it at a constant temperature the whole time. dont have to worry about the pan heating up. whatever temp the steam is at (100 C) is what the eventual heat of the pan will be assuming perfect heat transfer. If you want to take it up a notch, you can toast some milk powder in a pan, and then mix it into your scrambled eggs. the toasted milk powder is the milk solids you get when browning butter.

    • @terrygerhart1485
      @terrygerhart1485 11 месяцев назад

      ???, a double boilers only holds to 100C at sea level. Better to state it holds temperature of boiling water at a given altitude. Second the double boiler acts as a pressure cookers so it is slightly above the boiling point temperature. How far above depends on how well sealed the double boiler is to reach its final temperature. Water a boiling is not the same temperature as the steam molecule is more energetic than the liquid. By enlarge your most important factors to determine the temperature are the altitude and the seal between the the vessels.

    • @Dx_Ach
      @Dx_Ach 11 месяцев назад

      @@terrygerhart1485 Mate, water cannot get to a temperature above its boiling point. If it did not have nucleation you would not have steam in the first place. If you are using it like a pressure vessel you are just asking for trouble.

  • @nicholascrow8133
    @nicholascrow8133 Год назад +2

    Scrambled eggs are simple, the only points of care are no salt until its cooked, butter and to undercook them as they continue to cook with residual heat. How much you stir will determine the texture, If they are going to sit for any time before serving than finish with either cold hard butter or cream/crème fraiche to temper the mix (i.e reduce the heat) to lower the residual heat and slow/halt the cooking process. You don't need to bother about the on the heat/off the heat deal, just lower the flame (see marco's scrambled eggs, which ironically are closer to what gordon is trying to achieve)
    Heston's method of using a bain marie is great if you are doing larger amounts. The brown butter is just for taste, as are chives, parsley or sliced smoked salmon.
    Lower heat is better, but unless you are going for michelin stars, you can get 90% the same product by 'under cooking' them. (Again, how much you stir determines the texture, stir more often is you want a smoother, custardy egg, less if you prefer a bit more structure in them. Again, never add salt until the end, the salt breaks down the eggs, causing them to break, leaving dried eggs in a pool of liquid.
    As with most things in cooking, specific technique isn't nearly as important as understanding the product and process.

    • @tornagawn
      @tornagawn Год назад +2

      Thank you! I. Glad I read the comments as you’ve saved me the effort of explaining the cooking process a La Harold McGee.
      As you say, the extras are just for taste, the key is preventing overcooking and salting at th3 end.
      Sadly a few of my local cafes serve up what I can only describe as ‘chopped omelette’

    • @diannt9583
      @diannt9583 11 месяцев назад +2

      Excellent post .

  • @scarlett8782
    @scarlett8782 4 месяца назад

    Thomas Keller had me on his side from the first moment Michael said "he strains his beaten eggs" - so do I, and there's a very good reason. eggs have one white stringy part each, and this part is called the chalazae. if you don't strain this out, depending on the dish, it will not mix into the rest of the beaten eggs, develop the texture of chewing gum during cooking, and be very unhappily & distinctly present in the end product. the worst offending example is a souffle or souffle pancake/souffle cheesecake that is made with eggs that are not strained. there will be a tough stringy cooked chalazae in every other bite that you can't stand to swallow.
    go to the dollar store, buy a fine mesh strainer, and strain your eggs. also, add a little heavy cream (skip the milk as it just dilutes the flavor, unless you're using the bain marie method then whole milk + cream are essential) to the eggs before you cook them, and cook them on low heat for a long time. add more cold butter or creme fraiche at the end. serving on sweet brioche is also a great idea, as it balances the savory egg flavor. I don't hate the concept of a brown butter at the end either, but I have to say that I really like the taste and sensibility of Thomas Keller - makes me want to hop on a flight to try his restaurant.

  • @benlallier1721
    @benlallier1721 4 месяца назад +1

    I am not a fan of Gordon Ramsay’s eggs but I love the slow cooked eggs by Marco Pierre White. The creamy texture of these eggs make me want to get up in the morning. I will certainly try the recipes of Keller and Blumenthal. Great video.

  • @chrisjvales2
    @chrisjvales2 7 месяцев назад

    Scrambled eggs and omelettes are the perfect chef interview for a job

  • @sigmata0
    @sigmata0 Год назад +21

    I'd be trying Blumenthal's recipe but strain the eggs first. I've also heard he's used vinegar with some egg recipes, something I've experimented with from time to time. You don't need much and it can have a transformative effect on the flavour.

    • @JoshApocalyptical
      @JoshApocalyptical 10 месяцев назад +2

      I couldn't agree more about the vinegar, Like i dont need vinegar to make poached eggs but i add it anyway because i love the flavour, too much definitely tightens the egg too much so i have added a splash at the end before.

    • @julieeldridge8760
      @julieeldridge8760 7 месяцев назад +1

      I like the idea of adding vinegar ever so slightly to the eggs! The flavor combo of a bit of acidity combined with egg in Asian dishes sometimes overlaps and it's always pleasing.

    • @jenkem4464
      @jenkem4464 5 месяцев назад

      Even just a few drops of apple cider vinegar folded in after gives some punch.

  • @twisted_bambi32
    @twisted_bambi32 Год назад +12

    Idk about other countries but in Ireland we always put butter and milk in our scrambled eggs... I'm literally never gonna strain my eggs though 😂

    • @ryanmac8829
      @ryanmac8829 Год назад

      I'm Canadian and I always put butter and milk in my scrambled eggs. My gran was English and Grandad was Irish so maybe that explains why.

    • @sidlerm1
      @sidlerm1 11 месяцев назад

      I'm Swiss and so do we

  • @chriss8206
    @chriss8206 8 месяцев назад

    How about a combination of the second 2 recipes together

  • @blueandwonder2
    @blueandwonder2 8 месяцев назад

    Gordon's is everyday easy, so my go to. But it is essential to use the saucepan, the spatula to scrape down, and season last.

  • @henrygreen2096
    @henrygreen2096 Год назад +2

    I think I prefer Ramsey eggs for taste, but cooking wise I prefer Keller eggs. The lower heat, and the 'baby sitting' is my preferred style of cooking. Which is why I love making porridge and risotto as well. and certain mac and cheese recipes.
    Foods where you let alone for some time aren't my thing.

  • @johntate5050
    @johntate5050 9 месяцев назад

    What about my version. I crack the eggs into a bowl and make sure some shell stays in the egg. I add a spoonful of sewage and heat it in a pan until it burns.

  • @levi-stock
    @levi-stock 8 месяцев назад

    My scrambled eggs are quite simple. I use four eggs, mix them with melted butter, and microwave them to perfection. I place them on toast and add enough sweet chili sauce to mask the flavor of the scrambled eggs. Done.

  • @alittax
    @alittax 9 месяцев назад

    2:18 You could also pour it directly into the pan with the butter.

  • @Bellend361
    @Bellend361 4 месяца назад

    Thank you,going to try Heston’s recipe.👍

  • @kuro1803
    @kuro1803 Месяц назад

    what can i substitute for creme fraiche?

  • @randomme6954
    @randomme6954 9 месяцев назад

    with eggs in NZ costing $1+ each, when available, might have to look for an egg substitute 🤣

  • @benthomas8290
    @benthomas8290 Год назад +1

    Using a rich dark yolk egg like a burford brown will deliver a much greater taste impact than the relative differences across these three methods!!

  • @the_Legg
    @the_Legg 3 месяца назад

    Nice! Now we need this for omelettes. A lot more technique involved.

  • @KAjo07
    @KAjo07 8 месяцев назад +1

    "Only a fool would rush scrambled eggs" Marco Pierre White

  • @chinpohwong4169
    @chinpohwong4169 8 месяцев назад +1

    Heston Blumenthal more towards creamy french style

  • @crystalm4324
    @crystalm4324 6 месяцев назад

    Funny I’ve always made Blumenthal’s eggs using a frying pan on low put on whatever toast or wrap is handy with an added sprinkle of salt and sprinkle of cheese if needed 😂

  • @MarkVO
    @MarkVO Год назад +5

    I agree with the assessment on Heston. I had a period of time in which I was making it quite frequently, but I eventually stopped because it was just taking too long. Now I make scrambled eggs more like Marco Pierre White - very low and slow, and I actually don't use milk.

    • @joshlewis575
      @joshlewis575 Год назад +3

      It's gonna sound weird I know but next time you make scrambled eggs try some cottage cheese in them. My grandma made em like that for as kids. Delicious, cook off a little of the liquid in the cottage cheese 1st and then add your eggs. Hope ya try it

    • @christopherkarr1872
      @christopherkarr1872 10 месяцев назад

      MPW - now there's a chef. Heston Blumenthal is an incredible food experimenter and Keller is so accomplished I can't even imagine. Gordon? He's pretty okay, I guess.

  • @ragupasta
    @ragupasta Год назад +3

    As a single parent I do not foresee Heston's being time favourite for me. Everyone has their own home life so that can differ between people. Thomas Keller's recipe looks delicious to be fair, however (I am a home cook, not a professional) I thought seasoning with salt on raw egg's breaks down the protein structure before you cook it? Gordon's is simply basic and everyone could do it easily.
    Personally I would try Thomas Keller's, it's time friendly, looks good and will have to try it out! I have made Gordon's and it is pretty solid to be fair.

    • @xtophergeek
      @xtophergeek 11 месяцев назад +1

      Let me give you another recipe that might be good for a time constrained parent with minions to feed. If you look at the Chinese Cooking demystified channel you will see their Hong Kong eggs, that recipe is awesome and flavourful and not too tricky. However, I use a much simpler variant that still tastes similar to what you find in Hong Kong.
      Break between 3 and 5 eggs (depending on ultimate serving size) into a bowl. Shave, grate or cut some fully salted butter (preferably cultured if you have) into the bowl, about third of a teaspoons worth per egg. Whip well with fork/whisk and let rest a few mins, bring a pan (non stick, steel, iron whatever you prefer. Clean though; no previous cooking residue ) up to medium high heat. Whip the eggs again (try and get some foam), put a small amount of oil (or strained bacon fat) in pan. Poor in the eggs. Wait around 15 seconds and start doing the long folding draws through the pan like on the Chinese Cooking demystified, do them again and flip etc more frequently after that. Wait until almost all cooked but not all cooked (should be much less than a minute in total) and then tip them back in the same bowl.
      The tiny amount of raw egg in the bottom of the bowl will get heated enough from the cooked eggs and after a minute of resting you should filp them in the bowl and they will be glossy.
      All up this can be done in 5-10 minutes, or you can prep the eggs early and then just cook fast when needed. The salted butter seasons the eggs so only need a bit of cracked pepper over the top if you prefer.
      My kids absolutely love Dad's Hong Kong eggs by themselves or stacked into egg, egg and ham, or egg and bacon sandwhiches.

  • @danielesbordone1871
    @danielesbordone1871 9 месяцев назад

    When you're dealing with eggs , Jacques Pepin is number one.

  • @adamr3262
    @adamr3262 Год назад

    Dawg, you really gotta love Nick DiGiovanni to exactly mimic his videos' format lmao

  • @RataStuey
    @RataStuey 14 дней назад

    Heston also added sherry vinegar at the end along with the brown butter

  • @moopnelly
    @moopnelly Год назад

    Salt at the beginning is a sure way to make the eggs tough. Which is fine if you like a rubbery texture. Some people do

  • @JBarr-lw6kp
    @JBarr-lw6kp 9 месяцев назад

    I'm sure they're all deelish, and Ramsay and Keller's techniques are easy enough--but what about those of us who don't like that soft, mushy, custardy texture? The answer is: Stop mooshing the eggs around so constantly, and let them get a slightly irregular consistency-- not cooked more, just played with less. As my grandmother would say, "Stop potchkying around with those eggs!"

    • @JBarr-lw6kp
      @JBarr-lw6kp 9 месяцев назад

      PS: I don't know where that line came from . . . . ignore it.

  • @chilidog73
    @chilidog73 8 месяцев назад

    Just dont overcook, use the creme fraishe or sour cream, season at the end and you'll be super happy with your tasty creamy eggs. : )

  • @TomShaw-zf2hl
    @TomShaw-zf2hl 3 месяца назад

    I also feel that Gordon's recipe is for the masses, I'm sure he would do it very differently if he was making it in restaurant, those 3 chefs though, so hard to compare they're all so fantastic

  • @michaelschroeck2254
    @michaelschroeck2254 Месяц назад

    Typical Sunday morning : “ fast daddy I’m hungry I’m hungry!!!!!!”
    Yeh these recipes are not going to fly.

  • @tovemagnussen4423
    @tovemagnussen4423 Год назад

    Blumenthals recipee is the one I always do, up to the frying, everything goes into the pan. Maybe I should try the slow way next time...?...

  • @worldfamouslanglois4805
    @worldfamouslanglois4805 Год назад

    all those eggs are like 'I COULD HAVE BEEN A CHICKEN!' and we're like yeah .. then we eat you anyway

  • @IonOtter
    @IonOtter 4 месяца назад

    Keller and Blumenthal adding salt prior to cooking, denatures the proteins of the egg whites, making them much more tender. Blumenthal adding milk adds more moisture, which makes the mixture even softer. Ramsey's eggs will be less runny, and will have a bit more tooth to them.

  • @alexbentwood7189
    @alexbentwood7189 Год назад +2

    I recently started putting pecorino in my scrambled eggs and it is incredible

    • @ligier
      @ligier  Год назад +1

      that does sound INCREDIBLE

    • @benmckinstry4023
      @benmckinstry4023 Год назад

      Yum! How much do you put in and how many eggs do you use? Would love to try that myself

    • @alexbentwood7189
      @alexbentwood7189 Год назад +1

      @@benmckinstry4023 I usually do 3-4 eggs and a good pinch of freshly grated cheese/a big spoonful. You don't need that much because pecorino is quite strong so start with a bit and add more to taste. I'd also recommend trying other salty cheeses like feta or goats cheese to see what you like best. I add it instead of crem freche, just before the eggs are done.

    • @benmckinstry4023
      @benmckinstry4023 Год назад

      @@alexbentwood7189 Legend, thanks

    • @BlowinFree
      @BlowinFree Год назад

      Sheep’s cheese 🤢

  • @bonwatcher
    @bonwatcher Год назад

    Without having tasted them, I totally understand picking the Keller recipe for being the best without (too much of) the time or mess. Cleaning up a bunch of dishes and taking forever just to get some scrambled eggs isn't too appealing even if it's sublime.

  • @steveshin820
    @steveshin820 Год назад +3

    You should try Marco Pierre White's recipe next!

    • @ligier
      @ligier  Год назад +1

      100% i need to!!