I am from Karnataka n openly saying from last 1+ yrs of congress govt. Single development project is not started yet ... they are unable even to fill the potholes..... only we are getting corrupted dictatorship ruling 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢... I curse people who voted congress.
Karnataka economy is also waiting to fall, but politicians showing very proud of providing freebies,by devastating public life 😢😢😢😢. Innocent voters didn't understand the trap😮😮😮😮
This Akhil claims to be a Professor of financial management. Does he not know that Ram Mandir was built not by government, s largesse but thru public contribution.
Put an Italian khata khat in government. This the result. Voters be careful before you vote in foreigners in government who come with no commitments to the nation.
The AAP spokesperson lady, who participated in the discussion, reminded the student who studied about coconut tree for the exam and wrote the answer about the coconut tree which she had studied while answering the question about the elephant in the exam saying that the elephant is tied in coconut tree and so on.
Yes Arnab, congress has destroyed India many many years ago. Congrss sold away Jammu a d Kashmir many many years ago. Thanks to our Hon'ble Prime Minister Narendra Modiji. Thank you Arnab.
Brilliant post Sir. I agree, Congress was, is and will continue to be "anti-national". What is needed is a "clean shave" to RaGa in "khatakhat" manner!
All freebies, be it subsidies given to sc, St, obc or subsidies on religion basis everything has to be stopped. Enough of time India has got to lift up people and if these people could not come up then they need to ask the politicians of their respective state. Leaders should teach how to catch a fish and not give anything free. This makes a human dull and dependent.
Himachal me amir log bhi itna jyada ration lete hain jo itne well settled or croro ke malik hain,aata oil sugar sb kuchh free ,i was amazed to see that.
Congress played a game that could be duplicated by opponents for short term gains. Now, BJP is copying. Initially Congress started it and it didn't play a fair game
Arnob Gulami as a true bold anchor u have blacked out shooting down of Aryan Mishra by good hindu gav rakshaks Just imagine the joy u would have got had the dead been Aryan Khan instead of Aryan Mishra U would have screaned yelled and shouted that there was beef in the car Sad for u
Arnob Gulami BJP has released list for Harayana Cong has taken in Vinesh Poghat who is an anti national but BJP has taken in an honest true Indian Sunil eho is the jailor who granted parole to our great rapist saint Ram Rahim😊
Arnob Gulami in a major move to protect Hindus in khatra a bold and courageous school teacher in Amriha UPocked up a 7yr old muslim kid saying that he brought non veg food forunch Such Hindu rakshakss will save hinduism Neither a spineless fellowike Arnob or his patheticviewerswillhsvd the guts to talk on this
India's GDP in 2010 was $1.6 trillion under the Congress ruled party while Modi was Gujarat CM and Gujarat was among the top 5 richest states. Modi's Gujarat never had bankruptcy when Congress was in power. Now why does the Congress of Himachal Pradesh have to blame the BJP where they are in power? Now GDP is almost $4 trillion. India has enough money to handle any state's bankruptcy. Last budget announced, most of this monetary funds goes to every state's. Where are all these funds gone? Looted?
Not just HP, even TN is on the verge of bankruptcy. What is saving the MK Stalin DMK govt out of this bankruptcy is the liquor sales by the state govt. They have high liquor sales target say around 20% yoy growth and 46-50K chores per annum of revenue to run the govt. They have increased land revenue rates in last 3 yrs. Rs 1000 per 1.25 crore women and free bus rides, money distributed to students etc. TN has 9 lk crore debt. High liquor sales target kept by sales govt has lead to 19% of youth addicted and the TN is sharply falling down in all development and growth index. PTR was wonderful as the TN DMK finance minister but was replaced when he exposed 30K crore corruption by the Son and Son-in-law of the first family. I believe the whole INDI alliance driven by PK and Sunil formula is the problem.
Prof Akhil Swamy, the forte of academicians is statistics and data especially if you'r a professor of financial management but you are quoting everything except data.
Courts and election commissioner keeping mum in this issue, take suo moto cognisance and issue guidelines about freebie to save India from economic bankruptcy.
People vote for such promises ..that is the problem ! These work to garner votes and all other parties are forced to do the same to stay in power . Unless people mature , our growth story will always be under threat .
If the Mamata government topples, the credit certainly goes to the doctors and other protestors . But it cannot be denied that a large percentage of the credit should be awarded to Arnab and the republic for the relentless pursuit of justice
There should be a law against freebies!!! Elections should be based on what good promises and actions not by giving free govt money!!! It is deserve to those who pay taxes and later get nothing...
Madam we stay in Mohali and the kind of power cuts that we face here are the worst. This I can say because I have stayed in UP, Haryana and also Maharashtra. So please stop this sermon.
😂😂😂 why can I not stop laughing at Ms. Malhotra. Who believes her!? Raise your hand… and the financial management profession - parents please ask this professor which college and don’t send your kids there. He has completely exposed himself.
Yea, you promise freebies in elections to win and then expect central government to foot the bill. There must be a reason why other party is not promising same freebies because it's not feasible. But who cares, Pappu and his voters lives in present, future is on hope.
Arnob Gulami we r also No 1 nation in population and in Beef exports Do not talk of Aryan Mishra shot dead by Gav rakshaks zJust keep diverting people by ur fake economy debates
We need necessities like unemployment alliwances being a pg with no employment for 10 yrs under modi govt. Only congress n india alliance can fulfill our needs. So pls vote for INDIA alliance. 🗳️🗳️🗳️🗳️🗳️🗳️🗳️for congress ✋✋✋✋✋✋
In the order of importance in today's world, after basic living amenities, environment comes 'Economics'. There never was a time when a 'politician' understood the science and nor a genuine economist agreed with a politician on the best way forward.
There are no freebies for middle class families, 200 units of electricity is minimal average for a normal household in hp and usage till 129 units is a freebie. .0054% of total population of india living in Himachal and Himachal produces 2.57% of total power generation. If the freebie goes to few it's not a freebie considering Himachal govt has failed to produce opportunities for youth. Also 1500 rupees per month paid to women of small districts like Bilaspur. They are just recovering their election spending and advertising it as everything happening due to freebies.
Free, free and what about conditions of roads, how many flyovers , footpaths,what is condition of subways, desilting and garbage removal? How many hours of water supply? Citizens can differentiate from plain propaganda and facts .What the spokesperson meant is if you cannot show grim face then shed crocodile tears for delayed salaries.
India still has a lot to develop, to provide jobs/infrastructure as well as protect the economically challenged section of the population. The budget should find a balance between both. Without proper balancing and planning, giving freebies only makes people dependent on a political party with no actual development in the state.
I am from Karnataka n openly saying from last 1+ yrs of congress govt. Single development project is not started yet ... they are unable even to fill the potholes..... only we are getting corrupted dictatorship ruling 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢... I curse people who voted congress.
My dear this is how Hindus have always been .. selfish , easily bought .. That's why we are whipped throughout the world
Curse arnab the dog instead ...
Any state falling for freebies will have to face this. People understand there is nothing free...
This congress person what he is saying stupid talk blame center we are paying taxes and these fellows distributing our taxpayer money
Congress and AAP are biggest dangers for India
Need parties like BJP and Biju Janata Dal ( BJD)
Company - Khata khat
Director - AAP
Follower - Rahul khan+ Indeeeeee ..
Promise - T&C .
Aise kaise hoga koi bhi garib family ka udhar (Development) .
Himachal had voted congress for freebies..let them face the problem. Central govt should not waste taxpayers money to subsidize himachal
Many using free bees like half bus fair for women free electricity no one ask for it in Himachal
It's congress mess
South should not pay for himachal .we are already being looted now who will pay for himachal? Congress hatao
Yes
@@Divine_wave23brdr u first pay for your own good. If you’re short of rice just ask Himachal, please don’t go around changing everyone’s religion
Karnataka economy is also waiting to fall, but politicians showing very proud of providing freebies,by devastating public life 😢😢😢😢. Innocent voters didn't understand the trap😮😮😮😮
good work arnab
Hahahaha, AAP mahila has cracked the joke of this millennium
And I am really sorry for the students of this financial management professor 🙏🙏🙏
Lies by AAP spoke person...
This Akhil claims to be a Professor of financial management. Does he not know that Ram Mandir was built not by government, s largesse but thru public contribution.
Sir, fact of the matter is around 60-percent of Delhi's expenses is met by Central Government.
@@aruna.bk.2833Because Kejri has to build a palace!!!
KhataKhat goes Patapat 😂
😂
Put an Italian khata khat in government. This the result. Voters be careful before you vote in foreigners in government who come with no commitments to the nation.
Ye to hona hi tha Himachal me 😊😊
Hariyana wale bhi khatakhat ka intzar kr rhe hai😂😂😂
No free electricity in punjab she is lying
The AAP spokesperson lady, who participated in the discussion, reminded the student who studied about coconut tree for the exam and wrote the answer about the coconut tree which she had studied while answering the question about the elephant in the exam saying that the elephant is tied in coconut tree and so on.
Arnab please include tamilnadu state also in yhe list gijing freebies
TN showed the ugly way.
TN is on the way to bankruptcy. Interest alone more than Rs.30 thousand crores a year. Sometimes cost of borrowing as high as 8.99%
Arnob Gulami the Rlys has asked Vinesh Poghat how she can contest polls while being a Rly employee ?She is not Madhavi didi to be in SEBI and ICICI
foolish corrupt congress giving freebies.
Yes Arnab, congress has destroyed India many many years ago. Congrss sold away Jammu a d Kashmir many many years ago. Thanks to our Hon'ble Prime Minister Narendra Modiji. Thank you Arnab.
Brilliant post Sir. I agree, Congress was, is and will continue to be "anti-national".
What is needed is a "clean shave" to RaGa in "khatakhat" manner!
All freebies, be it subsidies given to sc, St, obc or subsidies on religion basis everything has to be stopped. Enough of time India has got to lift up people and if these people could not come up then they need to ask the politicians of their respective state. Leaders should teach how to catch a fish and not give anything free. This makes a human dull and dependent.
More such debates will awaken UP voters who voted unwittingly for Congress alliance.
This is Rahul Khan Vinci... Bharat ki tukre tukre.. jaago Bharatiya
I will not call it freebie , i'll call it khata khatt 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
जर सुब्रमण्यम स्वामी यांनी राहुल गांधी यांच्या नागरिक चे खोटी माहिती देऊन कोर्टात व निवडणूक आयोग याला का देत नाही?? आणि आपले गुहखाते झोपले आहे का??
Himachal me amir log bhi itna jyada ration lete hain jo itne well settled or croro ke malik hain,aata oil sugar sb kuchh free ,i was amazed to see that.
BJP is also no less, following khata khat model too, paying 1500 rs in Maharashtra 😂
Congress played a game that could be duplicated by opponents for short term gains.
Now, BJP is copying. Initially Congress started it and it didn't play a fair game
Justice Now.
Arnab Gowsami great 👍 What can happened Khata khata Khata khata in India 🇮🇳India 🇮🇳 India 🇮🇳
Arnob Gulami as a true bold anchor u have blacked out shooting down of Aryan Mishra by good hindu gav rakshaks Just imagine the joy u would have got had the dead been Aryan Khan instead of Aryan Mishra U would have screaned yelled and shouted that there was beef in the car Sad for u
Arnob Gulami BJP has released list for Harayana Cong has taken in Vinesh Poghat who is an anti national but BJP has taken in an honest true Indian Sunil eho is the jailor who granted parole to our great rapist saint Ram Rahim😊
Well said I personally recognize this outlook on how the countries handle international politics
Arnob Gulami Cong is blaming Modi for his silience on Manipur Truth is Modi has gone to Brunei and Singapore only to solve the Manipur issue😊
🎯💎🏆 Great insightful Debate 🏆💎🎯
लोकः समस्ताः सुखिनो भवन्तु
( May all beings lead prosperous life across Globe 🌍 )
Dear Arnab Sir Ji Go ahead. We really proud about that you really Indians that origin of Bharath like that we are really Bharath. 🙏🙏🙏🤝🤝🤝⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Would like to witness the way sir Arnab changes it's colour when congress comes to power as that day is not far from today
Parliament shoukd bring a law to restrict freebies for states else india will have srilanka situation in every states !!!
Arnob Gulami in a major move to protect Hindus in khatra a bold and courageous school teacher in Amriha UPocked up a 7yr old muslim kid saying that he brought non veg food forunch Such Hindu rakshakss will save hinduism Neither a spineless fellowike Arnob or his patheticviewerswillhsvd the guts to talk on this
Is Arnab saying central govt will always subsidize for corrupt congress state govt. No way to waste taxpayers money
Great..
India's GDP in 2010 was $1.6 trillion under the Congress ruled party while Modi was Gujarat CM and Gujarat was among the top 5 richest states. Modi's Gujarat never had bankruptcy when Congress was in power.
Now why does the Congress of Himachal Pradesh have to blame the BJP where they are in power?
Now GDP is almost $4 trillion. India has enough money to handle any state's bankruptcy. Last budget announced, most of this monetary funds goes to every state's. Where are all these funds gone? Looted?
Congress pockets
Congress is the most corrupt govt. till date.
Not just HP, even TN is on the verge of bankruptcy. What is saving the MK Stalin DMK govt out of this bankruptcy is the liquor sales by the state govt. They have high liquor sales target say around 20% yoy growth and 46-50K chores per annum of revenue to run the govt. They have increased land revenue rates in last 3 yrs.
Rs 1000 per 1.25 crore women and free bus rides, money distributed to students etc.
TN has 9 lk crore debt.
High liquor sales target kept by sales govt has lead to 19% of youth addicted and the TN is sharply falling down in all development and growth index.
PTR was wonderful as the TN DMK finance minister but was replaced when he exposed 30K crore corruption by the Son and Son-in-law of the first family.
I believe the whole INDI alliance driven by PK and Sunil formula is the problem.
Prof Akhil Swamy, the forte of academicians is statistics and data especially if you'r a professor of financial management but you are quoting everything except data.
Pay Cut Pay Cut ✂️ 😅
Aap party spokes person is so shameless .she keeps on smiling what for?
Pappu😅
Courts and election commissioner keeping mum in this issue, take suo moto cognisance and issue guidelines about freebie to save India from economic bankruptcy.
I don’t know whether it is Shankar Mahadevan’s voice at the beginning of the programme but it is a beautiful desi touch.
Boss ....Jay Hind
I m from Bangalore we are suffering please don't believe in free.
Pathetic Hindus always want only freebies and can easily be bought
Khatakhat khatakhat 😂phataphat phataphat😂Sarkari khazana Safachat safachat 😂😂
Coming election will once again prove that we the people of India put freebies above development, law and order, peace etc.
Let's not listen to the biased AAP long political lectures.
Papp should pay 🐖🐖
People vote for such promises ..that is the problem ! These work to garner votes and all other parties are forced to do the same to stay in power . Unless people mature , our growth story will always be under threat .
A state with freebies cannot survive….
If the Mamata government topples, the credit certainly goes to the doctors and other protestors . But it cannot be denied that a large percentage of the credit should be awarded to Arnab and the republic for the relentless pursuit of justice
Sir what about the security of your employees in Kolkata?
There should be a law against freebies!!! Elections should be based on what good promises and actions not by giving free govt money!!! It is deserve to those who pay taxes and later get nothing...
Jail is waiting to fill
Now BJP may turn back to Himachal, have to take the burden of the whole debt who will pay back,that is questions
Madam we stay in Mohali and the kind of power cuts that we face here are the worst. This I can say because I have stayed in UP, Haryana and also Maharashtra. So please stop this sermon.
😂😂😂 why can I not stop laughing at Ms. Malhotra. Who believes her!? Raise your hand… and the financial management profession - parents please ask this professor which college and don’t send your kids there. He has completely exposed himself.
Seriously, that woman was desperately trying to show her loyalty to Kejriwal and forgot the point of discussion 😅😅😅
Dr.Sundeep Ghosh Was No Alone !
What about federalism spirit? Why don't
give helping hand by the central to the state concerned
Yea, you promise freebies in elections to win and then expect central government to foot the bill. There must be a reason why other party is not promising same freebies because it's not feasible. But who cares, Pappu and his voters lives in present, future is on hope.
Karnataka is next in the list. Wait and watch.
Invited spatial.
Ask a poor peon in himachal. He can't pay his daughter's fee, milk for tea....and so on...
Arnob Gulami we r also No 1 nation in population and in Beef exports Do not talk of Aryan Mishra shot dead by Gav rakshaks zJust keep diverting people by ur fake economy debates
Take the money from Gandhi family, mr vadara and mr. Khadage himachal will get over from this crisis
the end
We need necessities like unemployment alliwances being a pg with no employment for 10 yrs under modi govt. Only congress n india alliance can fulfill our needs. So pls vote for INDIA alliance. 🗳️🗳️🗳️🗳️🗳️🗳️🗳️for congress ✋✋✋✋✋✋
In the order of importance in today's world, after basic living amenities, environment comes 'Economics'. There never was a time when a 'politician' understood the science and nor a genuine economist agreed with a politician on the best way forward.
This is bad arnab... You should not run ads of kejriwal in the middle of your debate😂
Suprem court...Suo moto is only for particular situations
There are no freebies for middle class families, 200 units of electricity is minimal average for a normal household in hp and usage till 129 units is a freebie. .0054% of total population of india living in Himachal and Himachal produces 2.57% of total power generation. If the freebie goes to few it's not a freebie considering Himachal govt has failed to produce opportunities for youth. Also 1500 rupees per month paid to women of small districts like Bilaspur. They are just recovering their election spending and advertising it as everything happening due to freebies.
Excellent HP. YOU CHOSE THIS. NOW ENJOY.
Kajruddin Khan not Kejriwal ji.
Wow, that professor has gone mad 😂😂😂 his students should be shlt scared of their future. What a low life.
In Karnataka also devlopment is khata khat taka Tak 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 0000000000 khata khat
How the chief ministers are getting richer than Ambani and Adani?
Pay liability /worker first. REVADI only if surplus.
FIRST : STOP ALL CENTAL LOANS TO STATES THAT OFFER INDISCRIMINATE FREEBIES
Arnab: Please mute mikes and let one person speak at a time.
All politicians are also becoming richer and richer..
LOP - SIDED BRAINED COMICAL ECONOMIC WONDER!🦉🌚😱
Free, free and what about conditions of roads, how many flyovers , footpaths,what is condition of subways, desilting and garbage removal? How many hours of water supply? Citizens can differentiate from plain propaganda and facts .What the spokesperson meant is if you cannot show grim face then shed crocodile tears for delayed salaries.
Vote buying led to financial disaster.
@Arnab: Are all the economic professors, This stupid?!
2G 3G 4G 5G and now Kejriwal ji?
Opposition is bankruptcy of cognitive skill too....😂
Congress should be renamed as Katakat party.
Ms. Malhotra"'s assets are to be revealed since she joined AAP and the position she had been before the joining.
Why all the debates are happening against non BJP govt. When we will see a debate against MP, UP, RJ and most importantly Manipur volience.
Please we had congress govt 10 years ago. At that time our GDP, was good rupees was strong.inflation was very low.
Hello. Lady! We are the tax payers are suffering for this kind of political parties who disturbed our money free
Who has empowered state govt to spend the hard earned tax payers money to give freebies to buy votes
Congress is filling his own AC fro the states where that is now.
India still has a lot to develop, to provide jobs/infrastructure as well as protect the economically challenged section of the population. The budget should find a balance between both. Without proper balancing and planning, giving freebies only makes people dependent on a political party with no actual development in the state.
Is this a debate or joke? Just a blame game, where the panelists coming from
Only republic shows this.
Other channels not.
Why
Arey falthu congress wala Ram mandir build by people’s money not from the central money