Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Education Policy Stirs Up Language Debate: Mother Tongue vs English | We The People
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 авг 2020
- The government's new education policy states that students should from now on be taught in their mother tongue, regional language, or home language up to Class 5, but preferably up to Class 8. This move has stirred up the mother tongue vs English debate in India. Is learning English at a young age important for children in India to progress in life and achieve their ambitions? Or is it better to teach young children in their mother tongue, so that they grasp core concepts easier? Sarah Jacob discusses a hotly-debated topic on We The People.
NDTV is one of the leaders in the production and broadcasting of un-biased and comprehensive news and entertainment programmes in India and abroad. NDTV delivers reliable information across all platforms: TV, Internet and Mobile.
Subscribe for more videos: ruclips.net/user/ndtv?sub...
Like us on Facebook: / ndtv
Follow us on Twitter: / ndtv
Download the NDTV Apps: www.ndtv.com/page/apps
Watch more videos: www.ndtv.com/video?yt
Sorry to say but majority of children's in india in childhood mainly understand regional language and the initial goal of eduction is to teach something to them so its easy if we use regional language it will be much helpful as compare to others
10:45 nope he is wrong .Here in tamilnadu everyone speak tamil.Only our school teachers especially in private school advice us to talk in English
Give both options English as well as native language, and let the students or their parent decide which school they wanna join.
A survey carried out in Andhra , 95% said yes to English. The irony of this video is that Sharmas kids learned from English medium 😂
@subhadeep mandal lol did you even read what I commented
@subhadeep mandal conversion is a different topic , somebody is learning in English that doesn't mean he ll convert.
Heres some data for you
39.2% of ST students and 49% of SCs study in English medium schools, the contrasting figure for the upper caste is 82%(from Andhra) . Most of the rich rags, politicians, businessman, higher officials even middle class people admit their children in English medium as they could afford.
What sin poors did, why they can't learn in English medium???
And for your kind information learning in English that doesn't mean you need to skip mothertongue subjects. Make at least 2 subjects in mothertongue compulsory.
@subhadeep mandal lol If students learn in English medium schools then Telugu ll disappear 😂😂
Do you even read what I commented ??? There should be atleast 2 Telugu subjects compulsorily, read again compulsorily. Then how students will forget Telugu??? Also government needs to make Telugu language compulsory in every state governments work.
May be the data I provided here is of private schools but does it change the fact that backward class people are in less percentage in Telugu medium schools???Does it change the fact that higher education and many jobs in India became English dependent???
May be it ll be really difficult for government to implement this things but they had to do, it's the need.
If private schools can afford the English speaking teachers and books, then why can't government. This was very childish reason I ever heard that English versioned books ll be expensive 😂 even you know that whole Telugu schools can offer the same books.
Most of the richs are preferring English medium schools, are you thinking they are mad???
The linguistic experts comment that most of students are speaking English. Sorry to mentiin that you are wrong. The students mostly in tamil but yes they have acquire the spoken English professiency
The three language burden is unnecessary not only for our tamil people but for any people in India ...
Because
Mother tongue education in education is strict
Develops understanding and intelligence .. but with multilingualism
What is the use of all students ??????
If you can easily work in other states right away
There are 22 state languages in India, of which 22 languages are given priority, while other languages are strictly ignored.
Further
Language is only a tool for communication.
The tool only does the job of "communicating" through 22 different language tools.
Then
Only two tools that do the same job are enough
One is the state language tool and the other is the world language tool to communicate with the world.
Why is Hindi used as medium of instruction in central school and in private English medium schools of non Hindi states ...if the answer is migration then people of non Hindi states also migrate...if we say most of the people of India speak Hindi then it is not the logic...so in each states the medium of instruction should be both the English and the mothertouge
@subhadeep mandal let the private schools what is your view regarding the Hindi as medium of instruction in central school of non Hindi states....is it right or justice for non Hindi states people
@subhadeep mandal in all puplic schools of Hindi states the medium of instruction is Hindi..
@subhadeep mandal do central govt employees not belong from tamlilnadu,kerala,andra parades , Odisha and other non Hindi states...is there any policy to hire centeralal govt employees only from the Hindi states... The employee may be from any state having any mothertouge...so the unifying language should be English most...then the regional language and Hindi both should be used as second language for medium of instruction and communication...there should not only Hindi is the option after English...regional language should be matter of concern because maximum students in central school are also from regional area...
another buthurt is here.....with his buthurt phobia
A friend of mine studied till 10th in vernacular medium & later complained about of not coping up well in colleges. He was so much frustrated & was of the opinion that vernacular medium schools should be abolished
We are talking of abolishing english medium only for primary. When every child is at the same level no problem would arise. Problem arises when system favors one medium of education
Political parties have no right to decide language policy. It is up to students and parents to decide..
அவர்களுக்கு உரிமை மற்றும் பொறுப்பு, கடமையுள்ளது., மக்களால் தேர்ந்தெடுக்கபட்ட தலைவர்கள்.
எனது வாதம், தாய்மொழி வழியில் மழலை முதல் உயர்கல்வி வரை கல்வி அமையவேண்டும்., பன்மொழிகளும் மாணவர்கள் கற்றுக்கொள்ளலாம்.
first, the mind should develop creativity! Once the mind is developed then you can learn any language fast! primary and middle school should teach in their mother tongue so that their mind-development is completed first!
We completely agree with you. We provide free business education in multiple indian languages including english. We believe education should be available in the language the students are most comfortable in.
@@husstlr Ax xx ln
I was thinking the same just 2 sec ago when I was about to click this video!
We need both the languages , mother tongue and English. Atleast 2 subjects should be in mother tongue and rest in English
@subhadeep mandal how learning hindi protects regional languages?
@subhadeep mandal Is there any Sense in your talking bro 🤔
@subhadeep mandal nope we dont need hindi... and all indian languages are regional languages, including hindi...
@subhadeep mandal English & regional language only we don't need any third language
@subhadeep mandal i think your a Hindi bhakt
The basic education should be in mother tongue, because English is just a language which can be learnt later easily in the span of few months, when one aspires to. Secondly the well educated person will take the responsibility to learn English at the later age. There are many examples of hindi medium students doing great in every field with great excellence in English. The medium of subject is mother tongue and no one is stopping the kid from learning English language
We don't have quality education in mother tongues, hence english is preferred. We provide quality business education for free in your mother tongue.
13:18 "for most indians English is their mother tongue" 😄😄
Yes.because they walk in English talk in English .
my mother is tamil and fatehr is hindi and we live in chennai.....i know tamil and english.....my mother and father communicate with each other and with me in english mixed with hindi and tamil.......as i am living in chennai i am fluent in tamil but can speak little hindi....so all these three languages especially english is my mothertongue.....many offsprings of interstate marriages are like this only......nothing wrong
@subhadeep mandal most of my neighbours are interstate marriages but for most of them both of their parents are from southern states so some of them easily pick up both languages like tamil and malayalam.. along with tanglish or manglish😂 which they speak at home.......even my father dosent mind speaking hinglish with me.....i know to read and write tamil and english but i cant read and write hindi as fluently as english or tamil......so in a way english plays a integral part of my social life along with tamil and little hindi and malayalam(as my neighbors and their kids are tamil malayalis and we hang out all the time)....anyway after highschool almost everyone needs english to enter a professional career or certain central govt jobs in india na?....can u become a doctor,lawyer,engineer etc in india without english? i have an advantage of learning english from childhood from my father and mother na?.....i dont mean english repace my mothertongue i mean both of them are my mothertongue in a way......i know to read and write both tamil and english fluently and speak little hindi and malayalam....how much more langauges do i need?😂
@subhadeep mandal it says wherever possible ....so mostly in govt schools only..no private schools will follow that.......so it will again create a division between rich and poor.....poor people who cant afford private schools will be taught in mothertongue whereas private school students will be taught in english earlier and will have advantage in exams,in higher studies and opportunitiesin india and abroad....
i am very fluent in tamil btw......i got 96 percent in tamil in my highschool the highest score in my school district.....the state highest was 98 percent....i read tamil novels,have written poems and columns in thanthi and siruvarmalar and in the local news paper and i often sing thevaram,thiruvasagam and thiruvaimozhi in temples with my mother.there are hundreds of temples here and most of the temples here date back to 600-700 AD and they have sung these tamil vedam or marai since then for thousands of years......i know tamil is important and i dont mean english can replace tamizh...... but english is also important for your career and future and is just as important as tamizh
Indian states have their mother tongue and the Center should respect their language. The center should have English as an administrative language, not Hindi. Imposing Hindi as third language in a state is not acceptable, the center shouldn't impose.
Govt is not imposing anything. Tumne carefully education policy ko read hi nahi kiya it's not about imposing hindi. First you read it. Har cheez ko wrong direction me maat le jayo
@Mr. Comrade in the new. policy . .there is no bar to learn. English and mother regional language. Then why do u worry. It is understood that u are hating hindi which isdeclared asofficial language of our country.
@t s Muthuraman Hi bro in that case Hindi is also foreign to us tamils malayalees Tulu kannadigas and telugus
Sir when central impose Hindi on india .i see central impose english everywhere
@@sid.7146 Hindi doesn't belong to any state. The administrative and communicative language is english which is not imposed. Most of the States have pushed out their mother tongue and put Hindi as their 1st language.
I think this is dumbest debate i have ever seen. No one has even read the basic document, and debating based on preassumtion.
1. It is not mandatory only an advisory, school has the discretion to choose the language-could be english, hindi, regional,local language.
2. Anyhow presently majority of the schools use medium of instruction in local language.
3. Medium of instruction in mother tongue doesnt mean english wont be taught.
4. Pratham report states 50% of class 5 student cant read basic english text. This is because their foundation is weak. Thus inclusion of students in age 3-6 in RTE is a game changer.
5. The most important aim of early education is to develop a thinking mind. If teachers are able to enable students to think they are automatically going to do the rest.
6. Yes english is a global language and learning it early will give an added advantage. This direction is not meant for those schools which are doing good, they will continue to do so. This is specially targeted for schools in faroff region and in distant villages. The panelist are forgetting that most even dont get to go to secondary school forget higher education. Thus this policy along with preprimary education will reduce dropout rates significantly.
And lastly Guys come out of this victorian mindset. And forgodsake ndtv you are calling a poltical journalist and an advocate and a student to discuss on NEP. Cant you find more qualified panelist who are working in this field. The views of even a principal of a normal school will be 10times more worthy than some dumb panelist. Sorry for using harsh words as i was apalled by the ignorance of the anchor and some panelist.
No lol , you are completely right. I'm politically centre left, but putting aside differences and analysing this bill for what it is, this is truly essential. People here are going to completely ignore that it is upto the school, and they have been only encouraged not obligated. Although teaching a global language like English across india, would prove to be very beneficial.
It’s very sad that in the 21st century We are discussing about the language/ mother tongue/ food to eat/ what to dress/ is this what India is… or it’s just a vote popularised
English fluency is only required only for some arts students(only whose major is English) , but India needs more engineers , on the other side , engineers just need enough English to understand the logic and explain it to others over that we have formulas and numbers to understand and explain better . In office meetings as well , people only bother about logic and graphs , no one cares how fluently you presented that . So fck English fluency!
What is an engineer called in Hindi?
@@rajadhirajmaharaj a simple Google search should do the trick , how did you even think that I would know that on top of my head, and over that , how is the above asked question is even related to the point I have made , that shows your damn high retradness level , see this is the problem with today's education system , even simple logic's cant get past your adimantium skulls !
Still, I will put up my futile efforts to explain the logic again to you , Bhai, eh dheek , the minimum English that they are going to teach from class 6 till 10 th is way more than enough to understand our engineering text books , unless you are some English hons student ( the most useless degree ever) , you don't need crazy level of English fluency !
@@Videos-ee2dy You still haven't answered his question, but managed to write bunch of nonsense.
English can be only unifying language ..
English is a foreign language and has no connection with Indian civilization. English is a threat to Indian languages.
We cannot roam around the world by only hindi on our tongue so according to me english being the global language should be taught and for hindi to maintain our culture we should mandatory hindi language till 10 which is already in nutshell I want to say that the present scenario of indian education is the best we can do
*Indian govt Education policy proposes Education through Mother tongue. But the same govt denies language recognition for various Mothertongues.*
*Feeling pity on Rajasthani, Bhojpuri, Chhattisgarhi, Garhwali, Magahi, Awadhi speakers.*
There is a difference between language and dialects.these are dialects.
There is a proven example already where in everybody studied Hindi for the last 50 years didnt get good jobs but people who excelled in English got jobs easier and living a good life. Introducing Hindi or sanskrit is not going to change anything.
@subhadeep mandal bro 😂
Look at China, Japan, South Korea, France, Germany, etc. They get education in their mother tongue and use their mother tongue as a business language. Still they are more rich and developed and have higher average IQ than India. English medium education is a waste of time and money. Studying in English medium schools won't produce creative minds as English is not our mothertongue. Government should improve and expand vernacular medium education till PG and make job interviews to be conducted in Indian languages when you want to work in your own country.
@@jishnuj4522 There is a monolingual policy in China, Japan, South Korea, France, Germany but India is a country of different languages and ethnicities and English is a contact and technology language in India
@@srinidhi7140 I agree that English can be a unifying language but why don't we learn it as a language subject rather than using it as a medium of instruction. We can have multiple medium schools where English can be thought as a language subject. Some examples of English medium education are Nigeria, Uganda, Kenya, Ghana, Ethiopia, Pakistan, India, phillipines, etc. Almost all are backward. English medium education was brought by macualay. The main aim of imposing this system was to make clerks and factory workers who can serve the British. India has 12 crore English speakers which is twice than the population of UK I.e. 6 crore. Still we have less GDP than UK. Our economy is growing only because of our population and not because of English. Learning in English medium schools can help in international communication but it won't produce creative minds since English medium education is all about mesmorising paragraphs and spitting it in the answersheets.
@@jishnuj4522 I also studied Kannada medium until 12th grade and studied English as one language, But it is true that English infatuation has increased among today's modern parents, the belief that our children cannot have a good future if they are educated in Indian languages, In some cases it is true!
Education can be customized for each student. The medium of instruction should be the student's mother tongue. We provide free business education in multiple indian languages.
I am class 12th passed students from a village of Bihar.
I know English language and studied in a private school but in my class more than 70 percent of my classmates did not have interest in study because when they tried to focus on study they felt too much difficulty in study because books were in English and they didn't know English much to understand the chapters of books.
Yeah i know because interest come when you understand the clearly may be the topic story or anything else . First of all we need to understand so that over the world people have been learning not to understand only to bound the communication well connectively but also to improve their country strong from different ways . I'm a student of Meghalaya I'm undergraduate student I dropped off my studied due to economic status
First question itself exposes NDTV, Dr. Panagariya rephrased the question and then answered 😊 one can't fool u if u have ur own mind and yes open to listening...
Until now not even one South Indian language taught to any North hindi belt but the real power house RSS want to push Hindi through education policy. French, Korean, Japanese etc did good because they don't have religious, caste,class roadblocks.
I'm from Meghalaya from remote areas where no English are used more at English but we tried as much as possible because English is mandatory and international language used in different parts of the world not only to income ratio source but to improve communication skills as well.. the respect the most for the female who talked about global language not as colonial language
Entire Internet is in English, youtube, Wikipedia, even if you convert every article on Internet in vernacular languages, how would you get the content creators on RUclips to speak in your vernacular language. Even a guy from punjab would not understand the content of a gujrati or tamil
Who will enjoy Hollywood movies and series 😂
What a finding!!
Means that Only Europe and America and India use internet!!
What about Russia, China, Korea, Japan, France and so many others who don't even know English!!
Are they in some old dark age?
@@universalphilosophy8081 dumb fool apps or social media is in English
@@Avinashm7
Oh!! Really!!
Go to Japan and China.
Wonder who is dump!!
The English that you see on your mobile phone is just some illumination of pixels in certain pattern!! There is nothing English in it.
Everything finally gets converted to 0 & 1 inside the mobile phone processor. It doesn't understand any English.
@Balagopal R I think you were replying to Avinash M
🤣🤣🤣
The policy statement starts as "Wherever possible...". It's not mandatory as is being advocated by the illiterates on the debate. You will be better off to ignore this debate and save 30 valuable minutes of your time
Seriously thats what I was saying, thats already happening across india where english is not spoken primarily.
@subhadeep mandal Throughout history, languages are formed by mixing of local dialects, not "adulteration".Eg- Telugu-kannada, pharsi-arabic, cantonese-mandarin, best eg is african countries. Pure urdu, pure hindi, pure tamil, pure Malayalam exists in its form. You can take pride in sanskrit, without making stupid statements. Secondly, in any dialect, the common man does not speak the pure form. A layman in tamil nadu will not speak pure tamil, it will be influenced by locality. Thirdly, the matter here in the bill is including diversity, you cant do that by promoting teaching in a single language. There is absolutely no point in bringing Hindi as a saviour here, take your nonsense agenda somewhere else, if you cannot support diversity.
I would say hindi sanskrit vs Tamil and other regional language .
Sanskrit and Tamil are the basis of knowledge these should be brought forward.
@@poonamsharma-ot6jp no language compromise dumb fool
@t s Muthuraman may be out of use but the old written text still exists in sanskrit and to translate or tech sanskrit to young ones we need to continue this
@t s Muthuraman because hindi is regional language and help us to understand things better
The topic is incorrect, it should education in regional language and not mother tongue. as MT is language that individual learns first to talk being born. I'm a Maharashtrian married to Tamil and our daughter's MT is English we live in Dxb and she is learning Arabic from kg 1 and 3rd language Hindi from grade 1. Believe me she is doing fairly good with both which is mandatory. it's finally upto me how do I look at it. I'm looking it as optimistic approach it's better to learn as many languages it's never a waste. Keeping India in mind as the Q raised about transfer of jobs opportunities how will it work need to be worked. In both cases Teachers need to be well qualified and not kamchalo 😀
Most of students can't understand english... If taught in regional language, it will be better for them.
Yeh tou bewakoofon ki sarkar hy
Tell us how would a Malyalmi tamil telugu and many more found themselves flexible in such nonsense policies
U c we all spent most of our time in home and what is the atmospheric lingua of home that only gets common to us. So see that the children having english speaking parent are not getting adv. and then what about hindi speaking family's child. The 3% fact is true and should be kept in mind while opposing the mother tongue's point of view.
Hindi is mother tongue it's beautiful no doubt but mathematics physics chemistry mathematics biology students are being taught in hindi or any yr mother till 12th class after for High education graduation b tech b pharm BSC bba all types of digree we hv to understand only English so it's time to difficult convert yr all syllabus books into English. So much heavy books in class 10 nd 12th physics chemistry mathematics biology u hv read in yr mother tongue. So hindi is own subject itself nd all things should be in English. I think 🙏 I hope people understand education system in india .
I want education to be in mother tongue till P.G. English medium education is of no use for this country. English speakers in India is twice the population of UK. Still we have less GDP than UK. Becoz we are becoming job seekers instead of job creators. English medium education is all about mesmorising paragraphs and spitting it in the answersheets. Do you really think such kind of education will ever produce creative minds. No... Then this English medium education is of no use. Even Finland with a population of 50 lakhs is educating children in Finnish language and today Finland has the best education system in the world. Most non English countries like China, Japan, Korea, Russia, Spain, France, etc get education in their native language. Still they are more developed than India. Why can't India do the same.
This 'Three Language Formula' must be opposed vehemently by all non-Hindi states as it is nothing but the way of imposing Hindi. This is a threat to the very existence of all other Indian languages. English, and not Hindi, must be preferred alongside the state language.
This is what tn was trying to tell non hindi speaking states years back, now and in the future too. It's time for the others to wake up to reality
13:24 has she gone mad?
She think that rich posh areas in cities are entire india?
Not all parents can teach their children English at home if it becomes a necessity due to pandemics to homeschool kids. That is the reason maybe it was decided to teach the child in mother tongue in initial years so that noone will be discriminated legally once the kid starts joining the primary school. Obviously parents who know English will do the needful if they want to teach their kids personally ! There's nothing to oppose about the government policy . The kids need to learn humanity first to get accepted globally not English. Even Chinese don't know English that good they use translators.
Learning in mother tongue in initial years is better, I never spoke in english till my 11th class. And now I cn easily speak better English. I feel ashamed that our mother tongue is being compromised by arguments like transfer, migration etc. If a child understands a concept in Hindi he/she can easily switch to English in future.
But not everyone is as brilliant as Sharma Ji Ka Beta.
Most normal human beings learn languages in primary school period.
After that, natural ability to learn language stops. So, any language learnt afterwards becomes hard AF. And it'll always be a secondary language to them.
Rich people don't have to apply for jobs.
So, Ambanis are okay with Gujarati being school language. Abmani's kids won't learn English, English will learn them.
Dumb fool not everyone are intelligent like you
Hypocrisy like you we people know what language will need not impose on it
@@rajadhirajmaharaj what a joke. I am a rich person and I studied in a Hindi medium school. Even great personalities like Dr APJ Abdul Kalam studied in their mother tongue but we're still successful.
Only Pakistani News channels and NDTV love RSS so much and use the term mostly in all the debates of any kind.
Please dont drag us in your cheezy debates.
Good work NDTV..! For bringing Anand as panelist
No Hindi impose please, I don't know Hindi and won't learn it for anyone. For me is English and Urdu. If you accept me, I am ok and if you don't then burger off.
Difference between Hindi and Urdu is much less than difference between English and Urdu. So if you claim to know Urdu then you automatically know Hindi at second place and English at third place
Agreed
As are Bhai Urdu Hindi lagbhag same he.
At an early age, learning multiple languages is easy because the grasping power of the child is very high. Learning the mother tongue at home and English at school should be preferred.
It will give them an additional advantage, as they don't have to put their effort again into learning English in higher classes, and by saving time, they will learn something productive.
I'm watching this to improve my english
Me: Paints the wall yellow.
Me:Every brick is yellow. So every brick in the world is yellow
Both language is necessary mother tongue or English you can't survive in India with one language
I like we the people program. Very enriching to anyone. Thanks for doing this NDTV team
The first twenty minutes or so was quite boring with fixed mindsets. Towards the end all were talking and nobody listening.
Can't say Hindi unify languages we should lean English this more important in world
Yeah that's why China, Japan, Korea, France, Germany, etc are more developed than India. English medium education is all about mesmorising paragraphs and copy pasty it in the answersheets. Such kind of education won't develop creativity among Indians. This is why education should be in mothertongue.
We get no proper jobs. Like... I am studying with economics, political science and fashion... But if I wish being a CA... Then what is the way.
You don't need a particular subject combination to be a CA. idiot. Needs only a foolish logic to criticise whatever modi does.
Science, commerce and arts students alike can opt for ca.
@@-SurajMondal- Don't be a andh bhakt... U do realise how difficult it is for other stream students to qualify. My point was not just by reformation in education that we can change. But we need more job opportunities in order to make the policy full fledged.
@@-SurajMondal- only about 26% of other stream students qualify. Please analyse every aspect before stating your point.
@@xclarakar1756 because ca is not for other stream like science and arts. If i say i will persue economics hons i can do so but i am from science (pcb) background, and its not for me.
English is the best option. It is the linga frinca in india. Most institutions are imparting education in english medium and sometimes switch to regional languange incase their is complexicity in understanding any statement. We are on a better track and using english has become our habit. While using our mother tongue, we even make use of english words quite often. There is no point in changing the thing on which maximum have got excelence and find much comfort while expressing in english. It is not colonial languange and it is Global. We have to keep this mindset. Our students are already doing better in it since decades and you can not push them back.
Media of education must be in mother tongue. We can learn English as a 2nd language, but it is yet to succeed because our method to teach English is wrong, not teach english by comparing English with mother tongue.English teachers must speak only in English in the English class, do not speak mother tongue in English class
quality education should be meaningful generate jobs. without proper investment in infrastructure you can't deliver results. there should be unique fee structure for poor middle class and rich. the quality of teacher should be the same for all segments of society. courses which are of no use should be thrown out. the govt can say students to pursue engineering and sell pakoda. for example ayurveda these doctors should have integrated medicine curriculum which will help them to work as a govt doctor or serve the poor in rural areas by having their clinics. most of the ayush doctors are working like contract labourers for years. there is no value for them. govt is using them in place of mbbd doctors paying them peanut salaries. their life has become like tissue paper the govt uses them wherever they want however they want and whenever they want. if govt can't absorb them and give them their entitlement it should ban such subjects once for all at least the students time and money is saved
This program was biased from the start. It has 6 members (including the host) against the mother tongue and 2 panelist in favour. But, nonetheless some important points were raised. Shivam Vij rightly pointed out that a lot of students fear english instruction when they switch from their mother tongue. The main reason in my humble opinion for that is because a lot of study material whether in textbook/on internet is in english at the moment. The student is not able to understand these IT/Scientific/Mathematical terms which are usually in english/latin and there is hardly any effective translation present in native languages. Does that mean that we should continue with English? I don't think so because primarily whatever advantages we could have gained from learning english we have reached those limits.
US/EU is not going to give away their menial jobs to anyone due to increased protectionism. With the advent of technology, BPO jobs will vanish. Instead newer jobs in advanced algorithms and engineering would be the new area and there Japanese/Chinese/Koreans have an advantage that they code in there own language. Applying mathematical algorithms is easy if done in one's own language. I think it is with this vision that NEP 2020 has been introduced. Secondly, if we do not develop curricula in our native languages which run in millions, then that is an opportunity forgone. Cryptography can utilise the diversity of Indian languages. Imagine an antivirus written in Garo language, it would be very difficult for our enemy nations to crack such a software. As far as link language is concerned, I think Sanskrit is anyday a better link language than English. It has historically been one. Further, it might help us in Digital revolution as well. The choice is ours, if we let go off of this opportunity, 3% of us who understand english will always be at advantage, rest will suffer.
I have nothing against English. It is a beautiful language but I do feel that if Indians value their native languages over English, we would be better able to compete with Chinese/Koreans specially in science.
Protectionism will go away with Donald Trump so stfu
In fact those non English speaking countries are way ahead in technology and perfection
mara ak dost na 2nd year complete karka final year ka exam nhi da paya tha ... to next year usko bola gya firsa 1 st year ma varti hona ko .. but paisa or year lost ki karan krn sa wo vrti nhi hua kam par lag gya chota sa .... 2 sal college ma 70% marks sa pass hona k bad ab wo 12 pass kahalata ha ... 😐
Bakawas policy ... 😡
Bhai yhi to change kiya hai
Ha toh bhai ab jo privatisation ho raha hai, usme tumhare dost ki kounsi madat hogi?! Ajeeb argument hai...
Paisa nhi thha toh exam nhi de paya.. Phirse 1st year me bharti nhi ho paya paise k wajah se... Idhar problem paisa hai.. Education ko bhi dhanda banake rakh diya hai..
Tera dost isiliye padh na paya..
would you give an interview for a multinational company in sanskrit?
I think english should be compulsory and other languages must be optional and the kid must be free to choose
and if there is a degree in indian heritage, i mean who wants to learn casteist elites conquering kingdoms in a special degree? we can learn this stuff in history/philosophy lessons LOL
You are saying like MNCs exist only in India. Every non English countries like Japan, South Korea, Germany, France, Spain, etc have MNCs but the people of those countries give their interviews in their mother tongue. They also provide education in their mother tongue medium. This is why these countries are more successful and developed than India. English medium education will keep this country behind since it will never produce creative minds. Our economy is growing only because of our population and not because of English.
Total overhauling of the system is needed as ours is a multilingual nation and imposition of any one language could lead to catastrophic outcomes. As every panelist was right to their opinions, there cannot be one formula to help underprivileged and at the same time provide international success to elites. Thus, there has to be quality teachers who are relevant to a particular region to educate the underprivileged and privileged kids. The division of elite and not elite schools should be obliterated to bridge the gap between people of different classes. As long as there is division on the basis of money and status , our nation will be rife with such issues and no policy will be able to match the standard of International education. Hence, the encumbrance would always be on an individual to carve a beautiful career for itself.
Good
I strongly support each states must have their own system of mother tongue instruction from kindergarten to higher research studies., because, India has population advantage.
English will be the link language in inter-state education whereas the actual regional/ all indian languages will remain as the link language of india as it is today.
Mother-tongue based multi-lingual method of education.
what about those students whose mother tongue is not the state's native language? e.g. majority of the people in Mumbai don't speak Marathi as their mother tongue, will the govt of Maharashtra make arrangements for them to get education in Hindi, Urdu, Gujarati, Bengali, Tamil, Malayali, Kannada, Punjabi, Sindhi etc. or will they force the non native Marathi speakers to get education in Marathi? Same goes for other cities like Bengaluru, Chennai, Kolkata, Hyderabad, Delhi etc.
Chandra B sharma needs much improvisation and better understanding about the language learning.
All the comments are in English..
That's true 😂
as a fluent speaker of English, i have seen a lot of people develop inferiority complex, as they speak broken or grammatically incorrect English, but if you teach english in std 6, u r putting indias growth in reverse gear, this wrong will take decades to correct, thats why u shud nt make uneducated people as cabinet ministers,,, they wont be there to see the negative impact of this policy.... i m glad i mdone with my educn btw... sic
@Saint Peter You are right your dexterity in English can be attributed to your upbringing .Most of Indian kids are not fortunate enough to be born in a family that itself is proficient in English and thus getting a headstart in learning English via having English as a medium of instruction is the only shot of those kids and their parents who aspire to have their children be well versed in English .
Before English and Angrez We Indians had survived more better.I really dont understand why cant we work together to throw English also out? As our forefathers had thrown Brithish rule?.
@Joy esh Those are developed nations ,we are a developing one. Moreover, they are nowhere near as linguistically diverse as us.
@Saint Peter this is true but why go to english medium schools.
@@poonamsharma-ot6jp dumb fool freedom fighters overthrown british
Not your dumb organization rss
I totally agree studying in mother language it makes us to relate everything with our daily life..
Alsoif there is some problem that exists is the problem with the environment in which children are being brought up - if there is positive environment than child too has its effect otherwise if negative than not my problem.
Sorry I have observed the lady name. Yes as she mentioned English has become global language and it the advantage of English.
Sara pl.allow experts to talk.......keep the questions short.......you can see most of the Hindi speaking persons are employed in Maharashtra and Tamilnadu....maharashtara and Tamilnadu don’t encourage Hindi.....English speaking persons succeeded Kalam.sivan.sundar Pichai.shiv Nader.nobel winner Venkat Raman Ramakrishnan....English will easily unite all of us
@unknown 20 Will you give a multinational company interview in hindi or sanskrit?
i agree english is not a measure of intelligence, but it is required for students to exploit as much as they can of global and multinational opportunities. most of the good books for students are in english, not hindi. english is a global language required for most global and international jobs
the problem is, we have too many languages
the best way is to make other languages optional and english compulsory. or all languages optional
Such idiotic arguments, the two side panelists gave. It's problematic so don't do it. They basically says "Instead of finding innovative solutions, no I don't" want it at all. The advantage of learning in mother tongue far out-weight the problems. Plus, remember it's an optional policy and there are numerous solutions to the problems mentioned above.
Very important secondary education to.have English as languge which is a global language. Those who migrate to hindi belt require spoken hindi and not to learn the literary. Similarly those who migrate to Andhra will pick up spoken telugu.
Imposing a blanket rule of a regional language as the medium of instruction upto Class 5 is impractical in a country where rapid migration and intermixing of people with different mother tongues are taking place.
For people who are thinking someone is imposing Hindi on them go and watch Abhi and Niyu's video on this topic. Or I'll do you one better go and read the pdf itself. Not bringing politics here, but the govt. has done a good job in this matter, but people are still trying to bring it down. Makes me sad:(
True bro they are doing really a good work
Anand Kumar Sir..! Ur exactly crrct
There is nothing which can stop someone to do what he wanted to do whether it’s language or any other thing. I did my schooling till 8th standard in Hindi Medium. But I did my higher school, intermediate and graduation in English. And I m doing well in my job.
Why the politicians and bureaucrats set an example by admitting their children to the vernacular schools? What is the success rate of vernacular school students into compititive exams? We are having this option of vernacular medium already in state i think. Let the government give quality English medium education to everyone with an option with vernacular medium then we will see who will opt for which medium. Never forget that now a country is considered as a global village. Think globally a poor student also can become a global citizen with quality education. If you have to keep people to their own states as exclusive groups vernacular medium can be applied to every state and even we can go back to our origins so to say so many countries in India based on languages. Let people make choices don't impose any language even vernacular.
Bhai teri yehi exam .. unki mother tongue me leke dekh.. I bet you will lose.... Instead of teaching maths, science and SS we are trying to teach how to write and speak English... That young fellow was talking about ST SC students are not succeeding in Engineering and Medical because they have to learn english .. if these people have to work in India why we can't change medium of education in Colleges as well.. I have many friends learned BSc in my mother tongue and they are now doing gr8 and in some case even better then those who went english colleges.. hear that guy Anand .. you are no better then him.. it's mindset that need to change... We have classic examples like China, Korea and Japan.. jai Hind
@@jack17482 so a multinational company will conduct an interview in sanskrit?
@@themushroom2130 of course why not?... Have you ever seen Putin talked in English.. or at UN many big leaders talk or give speech in their own language.. so why can't we speak in our mother tongue ... Sanskrit was common language but at the movement we have many languages .. NP with that.... Jai Hind.. cheers
@@jack17482 how does it not complicate this
also, there was no common kanguage for india. there is Pali. there is Tamil, There is malyalam. all existed together
It sounds like all Indian children should have access to quality English language education. NOT HINDI. Switching to Hindi from English won’t change anything.
Great reply journalist.
English should be unify language in India.
Yes because we both are slaves of great British empire. God save the queen!
Tejashree S you RSS supporters are not me.
@t s Muthuraman Its your choice. You can call it Gulam. I call it my accomplishment if I can speak 2-3 languages. By the way, I am Marathi and not Hindi. But I know Marathi, Hindi, English and German. This debate is nonsense. Smart people will learn many languages and others will not. As simple as this.
Haan...par English is spoken by minuscule people...and only unban and educated people know English
@@immigrationcanada1802 haha...in the words of Shashi Tharoor... British empire 1.0 was disaster... British Empire 2.0 wud be Catastrophic...we must get rid of Colonial mindset...par ye English k sath nahi ho sakta...
Sarah jacob.... Maine pehle socha ise hindi nahi aati ... Lekin anand sir se baat karne ke baad I'M SHOKED !
I love the theme song
(Habits, wisdom and mindset of highly successful people) is the best book available on Amazon and Kindle
State language and English
Great advocate this is smart.
Mr. Saravanan is right. English should be the only option to be the unified languange.
When english was not there that we can't communicate with each other? English tech us how to communicate with each other
Poor family children with illiterate parents go to government primary schools. Iinferiority complex is the
Nice good
English should do fine how can one handle learning science social studies in regional language
Hi
Anand sir right word thorough out all Indians students not a face ambrasing feel own mothers language teaching very good new education system thank you our government 😊😊😊👌🏻💪
Today simple software on your mobile can convert any language to any language. Don't even need another interpretor.
Mother tongue and Sanskrit gives better imagination skills and original thinking.
One panelist thinks that language is for career!! Whereas it should be for improving the faculties is your brain.
Advocate advocates that English is mother tongue!! Doesn't even know the meaning mother tongue!!
20:00 if English is levelling language, Sanskrit also does the same, for it takes as much exertion to learn Sanskrit as it is with English, and at the same time, Sanskrit is even linked to Tamil as it is with all the other Indian languages
I think NEP is a good initiative by govt because if we see that when we study and teacher teaches us...we see that he explains all the examples and concepts in hindi but we write it in english...rather if we are told to write them in hindi in our own language, then don't you think that it would be more simpler and easy to understand...so I think teaching in mother tongue is the best way to to retain the concepts of every subject. Well done BJP!
I would rather watch WION than this biased presentation
Hii ttc guys
#
ఎందుకు రా మా దక్షిణ భారతదేశం ప్రజలంతా సుఖంగా ఉండటం మీ ఉత్తర రాష్ట్రాలకు ఇష్టం లేదా?
I condemn your channel for permitting persons to speak in Hindi
This itself is the imposition
You are forcing for separate nation
Tamil Land with Tamil and English and any other world languages but not hindi
Urdu is a best language to communicate all India
Jaa pakistan jaake urdu me communicate kar ....aur haa urdu bhi sanskrit se hi aaya hai..
Ban ndtv
Include english.. wrna sb pdh ke bhi jahil rh jayenge
@Biplab Biswas Jbrdsti rss ka agenda h ye, phle hmlog english aur hindi dono pdhte aaye h school me, to exclude english is a foolish step only, world is going to laugh, world is global now so grow up.
@@REHANkhan-tf6fn You need to see the world to comment about it. I hope you have lived/traveled to other parts of world to gain some insights about education of other countries.
@Biplab Biswas Tagore got Nobel prize because he was able write his songs in English.
The English version got the prize.
Vivekanda also made that speech in Chicago in English, not in Bengali.
And none of these early 20th century elites had to apply for a job or understand complex ideas of science and technology.
Vivekanda himself said that we have spirituality which we can offer to the world but we need technology which the western world can give us.
So, in order to learn what emerging technologies like Machine Learning, data science are and to master them, children need to understand English literature.
And overall, most of the students just want to secure a decent job, they don't become politician or work in shakhas. So, in order to do that, English is the only option.
@@PARTHASARATHISAMANTARAY was english absent there from those syllabus, its impossible to ignore english.
Aapke forefathers Zaahil they kya? Unko to angrezi nahi aati thi.Aapni soch ko Badlein. Hum English ke bina bhi survive kar sakte hain.
I think the education provided in india is pathetic.
Muja Economics Political Science Biology n Commercial Law ma interest tha but previous policy ki waja sa wo nahi la paya ... abhi b malam ha ... sare jindagi rahaga .. 😔😭 kash ye policy 3 sal pahala ata ...
You can always get a degree in entire prodical science.
I think English should garenty ban in India
Let us not get swayed away by random emotions but rather have the discussion or debate based on 'facts' and 'ethics' based on:
(1) Discrimination:
The attempt by any Indian national government of the day to declare Hindi as the 'national language' will make non-Hindi speaking people be treated by the Hindi-speaking people as 'second-class citizens' in their own country. Hindi is NOT the mother tongue of the majority of Indians. Although English is a foreign language to Indians it acts as a good leveler in the sense that it is a foreign language to all Indians - it is foreign both to Hindi-speaking people as well as to non-Hindi-speaking people and so, every Indian gets an equal opportunity to compete at anything via English. Replacing English with Hindi will give a massive advantage to Hindi-speaking people and this will be unfair to non-Hindi-speaking people. English is a neutral language and avoids caste/race discrimination that happens in Indian languages.
(2) Practicality:
Hindi practically has NO use in science or technology. Nobody can become a doctor/engineer/technician etc by just knowing Hindi. Hindi is popular mostly through the overrated Bollywood entertainment insanity. English on the other hand is more practical and widely accepted on the global level and has more value to science, technology, communication, etc than any other language. No Indian language apart from English has the capacity at the moment to have its use in science and technology at national level. Also, English works as a link language practically. I have typed this comment on RUclips entirely in English and people all over the world on social media communicate mostly in English.
(3) Uniqueness:
If the number of speakers is the main criterion for the greatness of a language then the 'crow' should be designated as the national bird of India and not the peacock or that the 'dog' should be made the national animal of India and not the tiger. It is the uniqueness of a language that makes it great and not some population factor. If someone says that many people speak in Hindi in terms of some 40% of speakers then he/she fails to look the other way the majority of remaining Indians (60%) don't communicate in Hindi. Hindi can mostly be read and understood only in North India, and probably in Nepal. But Tamil, on the other hand, is already official in Tamil Nadu, Sri Lanka, Malaysia, Singapore, and to some extent in South Africa. Also, Tamil, Telegu, Malayalam, Kannada, Marathi, Gujarati, Punjabi, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, Urdu, etc. are classical languages and have been in existence in history way before Hindi.
(4) Imposition:
After independence, the states in India were formed on a linguistic basis. We have a Maharashtra for Marathi-speaking people, a Gujarat for Gujarati-speaking, a Tamil Nadu for Tamil-speaking people, and so on. Then why does the Hindi belt have many states even when they say that they have Hindi as one language? That is because the influence of Rajasthani, Awadhi, Maithili, Marwadi, Bhojpuri, Santhali, etc. languages was mowed down because of Hindi imposition and they were designated to the level of just 'dialects' of Hindi. Marathi used to be written in Mudy lipi (script) in the past but because of the Devnagri script imposition back in the 1950s for a set of languages like Hindi, Marathi, Konkani, Nepali, Sanskrit, etc. Marathi, Konkani, Nepali lost their influences. The only vague defense BJP gives is the mudy script of Marathi was continuous in nature and would have been difficult to get that type-written on the press - which is an irrational argument because the same press could typewrite all the other languages like Punjabi, Urdu, Gujarati, Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil, Telegu, Odiya, Bangla, Aasami, etc. and somehow just could not do the same thing for Marathi? Marathi people are facing the crisis for the reason that they are struggling to have a script for their own official use and the average Hindi person thinks that Marathi is some kind of a 'dialect' of Hindi. How ridiculous! Marathi historically came into existence way before Hindi was 'formed'.
(5) 2 v/s 3 language formula:
The 2 language formula 'mother tongue + English' is sufficient. The 3 language formula doesn't make sense. What the 3-language formula does is that it wants the non-Hindi speaking states to have three languages -> mother tongue for within the state communication + English for communication outside the state to the rest of the world + Hindi for communication within India with others who don't understand English. This makes the Hindi belt to be selfish to just have one language Hindi as they will not bother to study English. Why should someone from Tamil Nadu or Bengal or Maharashtra have English to communicate with the rest of the world and Hindi to communicate in India when the same Indians can try to understand basic English? English is sufficiently practical as a secondary language.
(6) India identity:
Hindi imposition will destroy the unity in diversity of India. There had been riots over this controversy since 1937, the 1950s, and the 1960s, and might happen now or later in the future. The idea of one nation, one election, one party, one uniform, one language, etc. all this oneness stems from the BJP's RSS ideology which was inspired in turn by Nazi Germany. It is harmful, racist, religiously intolerant, linguistically chauvinistic, and detrimental in nature. Tamil Nadu will be the first state in India to secede from the Union of India if Hindi imposition ever becomes a reality.
(7) Statistics:
Migration for work happens largely from the Hindi belt to the non-Hindi speaking states and not vice versa. Non-Hindi speakers' tax money is taken to promote Hindi and a less or negligible amount is spent on other languages. 60% of the budget is spent on Hindi, 20% on Urdu; for Tamil, it is 0, Bangla it is 0, for other languages it is 0. This is injustice.
(8) Pride:
Pride goes before a fall and the average Indian is somehow blind to this and ironically remains to be. It makes Indians not only hypocrites but also narcissistic to its own neighbors. This is because the current BJP government is systematically trying to keep brainwashing the mass illiterate Indians on the internet through the IT cell and in the open rallies. The current BJP government is heavily influenced by the RSS. Before World War II, the RSS leaders admired Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini. Golwalkar took inspiration from Hitler's ideology of racial purity. The RSS since its formation opposed joining the independence movement against the British rule of India. Excessive pride will cause India's downfall. No wonder the RSS had its roots in Nagpur within Maharashtra (Golwalkar, Savarkar, Godse, Hegdewar, etc. were Marathis) and is now making the average Maharashtrian behave hypocritically diplomatically two-faced for vote bank politics appeasement. Donald Trump in the USA, Scott Morrison in Australia, and Boris Johnson in the UK caused a lot of problems due to right-winged politics of excessive nationalism. People over there realized the mistake of voting for them and then overthrew the governments and brought center-left progressive governments back to power. In India, it is a big shame that people here are still mostly illiterate, blindly religious, and emotional.
(9) Nationalism:
India as a nation is different in concept compared to European nationalism. Nations in Europe have their own national languages because the influence of other languages in their own countries was moved down by singular languages when the boundaries were drawn. In the European Parliament, they still have English as a practical link language. Some people state that China, Russia, Japan, etc. take pride in having their own national languages and not in English and rely on translations all the time in dealing with other countries and not using English. But the communist crazy countries or the workaholic nations treat their own people in their own countries in un-democratic ways just to economically prosper by degrading human rights. One-China policy is degrading Tibet, Taiwan, Xinjiang, and Hong Kong. Japan's workaholic culture is straining the working-class people in the name of pride. Germany was the victim of Nazi ideology in the past. People all the time cannot rely on memory or machine translations/translators and waste time when the same would come naturally in simple communication by knowing basic English. Even the Chinese have now started to aggressively teach their citizens English as a second language. India had prospered before on global level only because of English and now we are going back because of Hindi imposition.
(10) Globalization:
Once upon a time, there was a colonial power but it's all in the past. The British Empire in the 1920s was the largest empire in the world at any point in history. Whether you like it or not like it - it happened and people all over the world were either directly or indirectly influenced by it. The UK, the USA, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand have the English Anglosphere with more geographical areas for economic opportunities than the non-Anglosphere countries. The USA is still the major global power and the internet in the 1990s popularized English even more due to globalization. Nationalism has become useless in the sense that no country can be self-dependent now and the 'Athmanirbhar Bharat' strategy of the BJP government is notorious in the sense that being self-dependent will first hypocritically rely on Russia, USA, etc. for defense from China OR it will replenish the resources of the non-Hindi states to feed the needs of the impoverished Hindi states.
Tamil is a good language
Jacob is genius professional newsreader for ndtv her costumes look she is American she speaks English like American 😇😇😇😇😇