देवेंद्र शर्मा जी एक सुलझे हुए जनता हितैषी सोच के व्यक्ति है जो किसानों के बारे में 100% सही बाते करते हैं किसानों की दुर्दशा करने में सरकार की नीतियाँ ही जिम्मेदार है लालच और झूठ बोल कर सत्ता में बैठ जाते हैं
@@ssingh7391 Most of these so called farmers don't want that. Most of them don't even work in their fields. They want a very high price for their produce while they pay peanuts to the labour who actually work on their farms. This is how Punjabi drug addicts became 'rich'.
फ्री झौला योजना , और नरेगा योजना में जितना धन लगाया जा रहा है , उतने में अनाज गौदाम बनाया जाए ,सब्जी ,फ्रुट के लिए कोल्ड स्टोर बनाना चाहिए ,जिस सें अन्न बर्बाद ना हो ,और किसानो को फसल का सही दाम मिल सके ,अगर अनाज रखने के लिए गोदाम हो तो बणीयों के यहां किसान लुटा ना जा सके 😢😢
True and genuine illustration of current plight of farmer's and farming sector. If MSP can't be guaranteed, than, at least there has to be mechanism to checkmate MRP on real time basis. It's a big question mark over our economic design wherein both producer as well as the customer both are unsatisfied and felt cheated at the same time. High time for serious introspection and analysis of our economic thought process.
We had discussed the whole policy issue during the farmers protests. The agriculture sector should go through wholesale reforms and the new farm laws were a step in changing the status quo. But the resistance to and fear of change sabotaged the whole thing. There is no rocket science in comprehending why prices crash during the harvest season- simple demand and supply equation. MSP is no magic wand. Imagine if there were MSP for the services of a chaiwala or a hairdresser or an insurance agent. The laws of economics applies to all kinds of economic activities- agriculture included.
solution is for farmers to set up co-operatives. and if govt is so benevolent, let farmers sell their produce directly to international market. see the govt sweating blood then.
Issues with farmer laws were that they were not debated and discussed enough across the board and implemented in haste and that's why government failed to convince farmers.
Very nice discussion, we are lucky to have agriculture about 50 percent that is the backbone of our economy if farmers get msp on every crop rice wheat vegetables fruits etc , good suggestions by Sharma ji , we will survive if farmers and farming will survive
Farming is not backbone of our economy. Manufacturing, services and IT are backbone of our economy. They pay taxes. There are thousands of crops grown in India, fruits, vegetable, animal feed, jute cotton, etc. Fisheries, silk, animal husbandry are also part of agriculture. It's impossible to give MSP for everything. No country does that.
@@yourend3177 Farming contributes just 15% of GDP. Also, try growing and selling crops without electricity, water (canals, dams), diesel, roads, fertilizers, pesticides, high quality seeds, storage facilities etc. Agriculture is important but MSP which is currently given to 4-5% farmers is nothing but economic burden.
@@yourend3177 You seem to be confused. Are you saying automobiles, electronics, software, pharma etc is not real economics? Are you saying that we will mitigate effects of climate change by declaring MSP for every crop?
@@1008apocalypse1008 i am saying GDP is not calculated correctly. the industrial growth is NOT equal to GDP. rather market manipulation forms a big part of calculated GDP. and that my friend is the bubble i am talking about, about to burst soon. MSP? govt doesn't allow free markets, does it? allowing farmers to sell directly to customers--ie countries needing them. let laws be formed as such,see 80 crore of our population die off. with climate change, MSP may not be required after all. unaffected farmers will sell their produce at highest price and affected ones will need govt support. again burdening the tax payer. who benefits in either scenario-present or future? not tax payer, nor farmers. people who make laws and control the bulk of wealth earned from those same laws do benefit. who fights? we, city dwellers and farmers, fighting over scraps. fair? not by a long shot! so rather than fight farmers(who are also victims of the same corrupt system as us), fight the corrupt system, which is coming for our(city dwellers by taxes and inflation) money and food too!
सप्ताह में एक प्रोग्राम ऐसे प्रतियोगियों के लिए होना चाहिए जो किसी परीक्षा की तैयारी कर रहे हैं ताकि उनको परीक्षा की तारीख का पता चले और कहां कौन सा फार्म निकलने वाला है इसका भी पता चले जिससे हिंदी अखबारों पर निर्भरता कम हो।
Excellent views by Devider ji : MSP for farmers and MRP for consumers ie regulation of middlemen who exploit both farmers and consumers. But who will Bell the cat, who will enact such legislation?
devendra ji neagriculture ko jo bat kahi hai vah kadvi hakikaat hai rahul gandhi ne bhi bharat jodo yatra ke darmyan bataya hai ki gharelu va kutir udyog va agricultire sector desh ki reed thhe unko devlop kiye bina na to envirment sudher sakta hai aur na hi desh ki economics america yourop bharat me nahi ho sakta hai jai kisan
एक किसान के गेहूं (जो ६ महीने में तैयार होता है)की कीमत ₹2000/ कुंटल है। वहीं मिल में पहुंच दलिया निर्मित होकर (10मिनट में) कीमत ₹6000/ कुंटल है जाती है
Na koi sacchai sunna chahta hai na Janna ,ye bharat ka itihass raha hai ,par pahli bar kisan ko Dushman bana Diya Gaya hai desh ka ,isse jayada or kya sarmnak baat hogi ,
Organised Syndicate comprising of Politicians + Middle man supported by politicians + Business wala extort the Kissan. In earlier days King/Nawab/Jamindar extort Kissan, now Politicians are playing the role of King/Nawab/Jaminder, In earlier days force were applied. Now in stead of force, policy is in force. The policy documents are prepared by politician.
There is only one ministry of agriculture which was of recent years bifurcated into some more ministry. There is the ministry for mining, industry, heavy industry etc the list associated with industry is many. Agriculture employs the largest population to compare it with other ministers and one can gauge the intentions of the political parties and the government of the day. Attitudes need to change. The government is following the Western countries model.
FURTHER KISSAN MOVEMENT PREPARATION IS BEING ORGANISED IN 2nd PHASE, AS SINCE NO STEPS HAD BEEN TAKEN BY THE GOVERNMENT, IN FAVOUR OF THE FARMERS. IN THE LAST MOVEMENT WE SAW HOW MORE THAN 500 FARMERS WERE KILLED AND TORTURED. WE SAW HOW ADANI GROUP WAS SUPPORTED BY GOVERNMENT BY DECEIVING THE FARMERS, IGNORING THE MSP DEMAND OF FARMERS.
kisan andolan se kisano ki halat sudharne wala nahi he,Vote k hnsamay Jogi ,Modi,Teni, Cheni, Sengar, asa, dera baba K leek par chalenge Samadhaan, Sahi daam nahi milega
Farming is not backbone of our economy. Manufacturing, services and IT are backbone of our economy. They pay taxes. There are thousands of crops grown in India, fruits, vegetable, animal feed, jute cotton, etc. Fisheries, silk, animal husbandry are also part of agriculture. It's impossible to give MSP for everything. No country does that.
बहुत ही सटीक विश्लेषण, बहुत बहुत बधाई
शर्मा जी को बहुत -बहुत धन्यवाद, कृषि क्षेत्र में अच्छे सुझाव एवं मार्गदर्शन के लिए। धन्यवाद
Devinder Sharma ji ka sujhav wakie sahi aur scientific thought h. Good Sharma ji.
Excellent analysis , thanks The Wire team for valuable information. 🙏
शर्मा जी बहुत अच्छे विचार और जानकारी
ऐसे लोगों को कृषि मंत्री होना चाहिए
Sharma Ji, apki Soch Ati-Uttam hai. Sirf Kisan hi nahi , Desh ke liye bhi
देवेंद्र शर्मा जी एक सुलझे हुए जनता हितैषी सोच के व्यक्ति है जो किसानों के बारे में 100% सही बाते करते हैं किसानों की दुर्दशा करने में सरकार की नीतियाँ ही जिम्मेदार है लालच और झूठ बोल कर सत्ता में बैठ जाते हैं
सत्य वचन
जानते सब है मगर करते निजी स्वार्थ के आधार पर।
Very impressive and informative interview
Valuable points raised about Kisaan.
Yes its true, if MSP is implemented across the farming sector, it will be a great boost for our economy.
MSP is payed from taxes. Where will the money come from? Why only farmers? Why not teachers, plumbers, electricians, cleaners?
@@1008apocalypse1008 ever heard of labour laws, which your favorite govt is trying to scrap off too? 🤦♀
@@1008apocalypse1008 there is minimum wage in western countries and same in govt jobs in india also, each every sector should get minimum wage atleast
@@ssingh7391 Most of these so called farmers don't want that. Most of them don't even work in their fields. They want a very high price for their produce while they pay peanuts to the labour who actually work on their farms. This is how Punjabi drug addicts became 'rich'.
Bilkul shi kaha sharma ji ne
मौजूदा दौर का तथाकथित विकास मॉडल की आड़ में बाजारवादियों के सरगनाओं एवं कुर्सीवादियों ने धूर्तता एवं निर्ममता से लूटा है।
Thanks
Always enlightening to hear views of Devinder Sharma
फ्री झौला योजना , और नरेगा योजना में जितना धन लगाया जा रहा है , उतने में अनाज गौदाम बनाया जाए ,सब्जी ,फ्रुट के लिए कोल्ड स्टोर बनाना चाहिए ,जिस सें अन्न बर्बाद ना हो ,और किसानो को फसल का सही दाम मिल सके ,अगर अनाज रखने के लिए गोदाम हो तो बणीयों के यहां किसान लुटा ना जा सके 😢😢
शर्मा जी को बहुत -बहुत धन्यवाद, कृषि क्षेत्र में अच्छे सुझाव एवं मार्गदर्शन के लिए। धन्यवाद
10
Reply
Very nice discussion 👌 😊
Sharma ji mere salute ❤
True and genuine illustration of current plight of farmer's and farming sector. If MSP can't be guaranteed, than, at least there has to be mechanism to checkmate MRP on real time basis. It's a big question mark over our economic design wherein both producer as well as the customer both are unsatisfied and felt cheated at the same time. High time for serious introspection and analysis of our economic thought process.
Good work sir ji 🙏🙏
क्यों कि किसानों को शहरों में ले जाकर मजदूरी करने वाले बनाए जाने हैं???
किसान विरोधी सरकार को झुकना पड़ेगा यह हटा दिया जाएगा किसान एकता जिंदाबाद
We had discussed the whole policy issue during the farmers protests. The agriculture sector should go through wholesale reforms and the new farm laws were a step in changing the status quo. But the resistance to and fear of change sabotaged the whole thing. There is no rocket science in comprehending why prices crash during the harvest season- simple demand and supply equation. MSP is no magic wand. Imagine if there were MSP for the services of a chaiwala or a hairdresser or an insurance agent. The laws of economics applies to all kinds of economic activities- agriculture included.
solution is for farmers to set up co-operatives.
and if govt is so benevolent, let farmers sell their produce directly to international market.
see the govt sweating blood then.
Issues with farmer laws were that they were not debated and discussed enough across the board and implemented in haste and that's why government failed to convince farmers.
Very nice discussion, we are lucky to have agriculture about 50 percent that is the backbone of our economy if farmers get msp on every crop rice wheat vegetables fruits etc , good suggestions by Sharma ji , we will survive if farmers and farming will survive
Farming is not backbone of our economy. Manufacturing, services and IT are backbone of our economy. They pay taxes. There are thousands of crops grown in India, fruits, vegetable, animal feed, jute cotton, etc. Fisheries, silk, animal husbandry are also part of agriculture. It's impossible to give MSP for everything. No country does that.
@@1008apocalypse1008 really? try running your economy by importing foods for 140 crore people. your foreign reserves will vanish in 1 day. 🤦♀
@@yourend3177 Farming contributes just 15% of GDP. Also, try growing and selling crops without electricity, water (canals, dams), diesel, roads, fertilizers, pesticides, high quality seeds, storage facilities etc. Agriculture is important but MSP which is currently given to 4-5% farmers is nothing but economic burden.
@@yourend3177 You seem to be confused. Are you saying automobiles, electronics, software, pharma etc is not real economics? Are you saying that we will mitigate effects of climate change by declaring MSP for every crop?
@@1008apocalypse1008 i am saying GDP is not calculated correctly.
the industrial growth is NOT equal to GDP. rather market manipulation forms a big part of calculated GDP.
and that my friend is the bubble i am talking about, about to burst soon.
MSP? govt doesn't allow free markets, does it? allowing farmers to sell directly to customers--ie countries needing them.
let laws be formed as such,see 80 crore of our population die off.
with climate change, MSP may not be required after all. unaffected farmers will sell their produce at highest price and affected ones will need govt support.
again burdening the tax payer.
who benefits in either scenario-present or future? not tax payer, nor farmers.
people who make laws and control the bulk of wealth earned from those same laws do benefit.
who fights? we, city dwellers and farmers, fighting over scraps.
fair? not by a long shot!
so rather than fight farmers(who are also victims of the same corrupt system as us), fight the corrupt system, which is coming for our(city dwellers by taxes and inflation) money and food too!
In our Country, only MIDDLE MEN are Benefited, Producers are hardly getting theirs INPUT COST. GOVT. should take care of deprived persons in Democracy
This show is gem.
Bhut galat ho raha hai kisaano ke saath😢😢
Devendra Sharma jaisa krushi vishleshak koi nahi
The best
सप्ताह में एक प्रोग्राम ऐसे प्रतियोगियों के लिए होना चाहिए जो किसी परीक्षा की तैयारी कर रहे हैं ताकि उनको परीक्षा की तारीख का पता चले और कहां कौन सा फार्म निकलने वाला है इसका भी पता चले जिससे हिंदी अखबारों पर निर्भरता कम हो।
sarkari naukri to khatam ho rahi hai,
Excellent views by Devider ji : MSP for farmers and MRP for consumers ie regulation of middlemen who exploit both farmers and consumers. But who will Bell the cat, who will enact such legislation?
Nice views given by sharma
Farmers never donates to political parties hence they are neglected
devendra ji neagriculture ko jo bat kahi hai vah kadvi hakikaat hai rahul gandhi ne bhi bharat jodo yatra ke darmyan bataya hai ki gharelu va kutir udyog va agricultire sector desh ki reed thhe unko devlop kiye bina na to envirment sudher sakta hai aur na hi desh ki economics america yourop bharat me nahi ho sakta hai jai kisan
Relway ki taraha krushi ka Swatantra Mantralaya banaya jaye aur eska bagget Banana chahiye
Thanx Sharma ji.....
Devindra jee this should be done before the seeding that this the cost will come and farmers should get this amount otherwise it will be loss for them
Jo apne batya h halat us se bhi Bure h
Good brother.
👍👍👍
मैं पच्चीस रुपए प्रति किलो से कम पर प्याज ख़रीदना नहीं चाहता और यह चाहता हूं कि किसान को कम से कम बीस रुपए प्रति मिले।
सही कहा आपने
TCBT खेती अपनाए और tcbt ग्रुप से जुड़ जाए अच्छा पैसा मिलेगा किसानों को।
It's Sad that still citizens have not understood that BhajPa leaders are not concerned about common citizens issues
Devinderji namaskr. I want to have a talk with you regarding your suggested reforms. Oblige please. Thanks.
एक किसान के गेहूं (जो ६ महीने में तैयार होता है)की कीमत ₹2000/ कुंटल है। वहीं मिल में पहुंच दलिया निर्मित होकर (10मिनट में) कीमत ₹6000/ कुंटल है जाती है
Sir aap jaise narnalist ko kot kot naman bahut kam loge h jo kishano ki baat rakhte h
अब देश किसी और को प्रधान मंत्री नही स्वीकार करेगा अब मोदी जी का खल्बच्चा बनाकर कुर्सी पर रखकर केजरीवाल जी शासन करेंगे
corporate houses and political party's Nexus is responsible for this
Na koi sacchai sunna chahta hai na Janna ,ye bharat ka itihass raha hai ,par pahli bar kisan ko Dushman bana Diya Gaya hai desh ka ,isse jayada or kya sarmnak baat hogi ,
Up me to kisan ne agriculture pahle hi chhod di.
Organised Syndicate comprising of Politicians + Middle man supported by politicians + Business wala extort the Kissan. In earlier days King/Nawab/Jamindar extort Kissan, now Politicians are playing the role of King/Nawab/Jaminder, In earlier days force were applied. Now in stead of force, policy is in force. The policy documents are prepared by politician.
There is only one ministry of agriculture which was of recent years bifurcated into some more ministry.
There is the ministry for mining, industry, heavy industry etc the list associated with industry is many.
Agriculture employs the largest population to compare it with other ministers and one can gauge the intentions of the political parties and the government of the day.
Attitudes need to change.
The government is following the Western countries model.
FURTHER KISSAN MOVEMENT PREPARATION IS BEING ORGANISED IN 2nd PHASE, AS SINCE NO STEPS HAD BEEN TAKEN
BY THE GOVERNMENT, IN FAVOUR OF THE FARMERS. IN THE LAST MOVEMENT WE SAW HOW MORE THAN 500 FARMERS WERE KILLED AND TORTURED. WE SAW HOW ADANI GROUP WAS SUPPORTED
BY GOVERNMENT BY DECEIVING
THE FARMERS, IGNORING THE MSP
DEMAND OF FARMERS.
Australia Canada me 2. Lakh mahina milta hai kyoki aabadi 3 karor se kam hai
BUT WIRE GROUP HAVE TO FACE THE PROBLEM AS EXPERIENCED
EARLIER IN THE ISSUE OF ADANI
REPORT!!! HOW EVER THAT WAS A
TORTURE TO TIGHT WIRE.
kisan andolan se kisano ki halat sudharne wala nahi he,Vote k hnsamay Jogi ,Modi,Teni, Cheni, Sengar, asa, dera baba K leek par chalenge Samadhaan, Sahi daam nahi milega
Dr Devinder serma ji thanks govt kissan ku marna chati
Farming is not backbone of our economy. Manufacturing, services and IT are backbone of our economy. They pay taxes. There are thousands of crops grown in India, fruits, vegetable, animal feed, jute cotton, etc. Fisheries, silk, animal husbandry are also part of agriculture. It's impossible to give MSP for everything. No country does that.
1se jyada bachcha jyada aabadi jyada garibi
Jyada anaj sabji fal dudh ki ejjat paise nahi milta
To save India simply stop voting BJP in any form of election for next 10 years....Plz share this message...
सरसो का 3500 बिक रहा है
These chirkut experts think that guaranteeing MSP is a child's play and the only solution to farmers' problems.
Very very most i m p
Abe chamu sir aapne toh farm law ka bada virodh kiya tha..
Sabhi ko malum hai fir bhi 1 hi fasal jyada paida karta hai
aj chana mahrstame m.s.p ke niche APMC me bik raha fir sarkar ke m.s.p kis kam ki
Jab kam paida karne par jyada milta hai to kam kyo nahi paida karte
Tum cute ho
Fake argument
Jab tak gujrat desh ke dhan ki ek ek bund na nichod le tab Tak vahi aate rahenge,kunki andhbhakt tab tak saans lete rahenge
Kisaan jyada baimaan or haaraami koi nhi ,, pichle 3 saal inki natanki dekh rhi hai..