I'm so, so happy that FiT2 is consistently pulling me back to mlp XD I'm glad to see Cadence be called out by her own subconscious, but at the same time seeing her ball up and squeeze away her feelings tighter and tighter is incredibly scary, especially if it's to the point where she's having night terrors about it. I dearly hope that the dream in this part is fortelling that, even if it will be a long time, Cadence will, at some point, out of necessity for herself and Luna, forgive her. It may even be a step torward forgiving herself. Truly I hope so. Having that mental burden lightened even a little, would give her the energy to better care for her ponies, and even make friends if possible.
Cadence's nightmares have worsened so much since Twilight woke up. First she felt guilty for the deaths of Twilight's parents and ponies she evacuated, now there's also guilt for leaving Luna, Spike and Twilight. As much as it bugged me in the beginning, how much hatred she kept expressing for Luna, I can't help but worry for her safety and sanity and for the safety of those around her now. If the Tantabus showed up, it's serious.
Yup, fear leads to anger, anger leads to hate, hate leads to suffering. Which her hatred towards Luna, even she didn’t mean to cause some harm could will be the ALWAYS be the BLAME for her for all the suffering she had.
I didn't expect to see a borderline suicidal Thorax Nor a starved Thorax... He's so hungry, he needs to eat something before he goes ballistic and starts feeding without his own permission
Wow, I never expected Cadence's sense of guilt was so serious to the point of finding herself alone in those moments (although it is understandable that she is no longer the princess of love at the end of the episode)😔. I wonder if he still has the sense of mercy after meeting Thorax... only time will tell.🤔
Oh my god, this is one of the most wholesome, heart wrenching, and most emotional episodes of Friendship Is Tragic I've ever seen! Cadence has been so depressed after hearing Twilight secretly blaming her for Shining Armor and her parents' deaths, and such rage and heartbreak, and that nightmare Cadence had was so dark! And when Luna talked to Cadence about alicorn magic and emotions, it felt truly emotional and deep to me. She does make a good point about how hatred can make somepony to horrible things, and she is right. Also, Thorax was sneaking around the Crystal Empire at first, but when he talked to Cadence about what he went through and so hungry, lonesome and so depressed, it was so depressing and sad to see this, and when Thorax begged Cadence to kill him... I felt like wailing on the inside! The voice acting and emotions are so perfect! Very beautiful and amazing work, Scribbler! I give you 500/500 points for such an emotional and beautiful episode! Keep up the good work. *Gives you a thumbs up* 💜💜💜💜😭😭😭😭🥹🥹👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻🌹🌹🌹🌹
This episode hit me hard! Thorax is my favourite character from the show and seeing him cry and beg for him to be killed rather than be locked in the dungeon made me cry! The voice actors make the part and they certainly didn’t disappoint for my favourite bug! The fact he’s rather let Cadmece kill him than Chrysalis shows how horrible he’s treated back at the hive. Plus he doesn’t want to take any love but he can’t help it as that what he feeds off. This episode was beautiful and so emotional!
Damn, hearing Thorax begging cadence to kill him right then and there was so sad. Like I never thought I would hear one of the most wholesome changelings to ever exist, begging for death like that. You know a world is depressing when even a wholesome person like Thorax is so depressed that he is having suicidal thoughts. At least cadence did not run away from helping him, unlike the others. As for cadence’s dream, i’m not surprised that a nightmare version of herself is trying to take over. She really needs a therapist. And I’m Happy that Luna broke her vow to stop dream walking to help Cadence. I’m glad she still tries to help other ponies despite what she’s going through.
YES! I'm so excited for this to come back! It really is tragic that Cadence is kind of getting the blame for what happened to Twilight's family that night during the invasion, and the fact that she can't say anything to deny it either really is sad, having no one to talk to about the events besides the one who caused a lot of the damage as well, I'm really excited to see how she'll develop and go about her journey as a lone princess of a nation and also kinda scared how she'll react if she finds out what happened to Twilight...
I'm so happy with the reception my original song "Failed to Love" got. It's been a huge honour composing the new opening theme ^^ I'll have the official lyric video for it released tomorrow on my channel so keep your eyes peeled ;)
As usual I absolutely enjoyed every second of this episode Scribbler! Everything from the artwork and voice acting was done ever so phenomenally, And everyone did such a masterful and brilliant job bringing the episode to life make no mistake about it! Thank you all so much and a very Happy Month Of Macabre to you!!! After having a nightmare like that, I'd like to think that deep down Cadence finally understands that just like her Luna is also emotionally suffering for the mistakes that she made. Cadence may still have every right not to forgive Luna, But she spoke the truth that emotions like hatred and anger are like a poison, And the more you let it consume you the deeper you fall into the dark depths, To the point where you would be too far gone to save. But Cadence wasn't going to let what happened to Luna happen to her, But Cadence was going about it the wrong way. And what she was doing to Thorax was proof of that, For she would rather let throw Thorax in a dungeon and let him suffer without love than become a killer.
(SPOILERS-) I haven't even thought about the Changelings. hearing Thorax just...seem so helpless is so sad...as for queen chrysalis? You know your a bad queen when even your subjects try to escape.
In the comics, the nightmare forces are what caused Luna to become Nightmare moon, so maybe something similar to the nightmare forces is trying to take over Cadance.
Actually it's the opposites... Luna turn the nyxs in the nightmare forces You guys don't get Luna/Nightmare Moo intention from the beginning Plus, she was already Nightmare Moon when she was banished in the moon, how the nyxs suppose to turn her like that?
Ok that beginning almost had me till I instantly realized cadence had another nightmare or panic attack. But also it was so awesome you added thorax! I can't wait to see how the whole series plays out and not to mention a new into song!? WE ARE BLESSED ✨❤️ not to mention the whole dream sequence with cadence was so eerie...
I have never been so emotionally invested in talking horses (excluding BoJack), But these ones are from MLP. H o w How have you done this to me? The whole Friendship is Tragic team should be rewarded with matching twirling mustaches, monocles, top hats, and train tracks. Because I have been tied up and run over by a screaming, sobbing, depressing, beautiful freight train. I am flattened and broken. Curse the amazing writers, voice actors, and artists for making this possible.
Mine too! I’m so glad it’s continuing! at first, I thought it was canceled or discontinue. I hate when series like these be discontinue or cancel. I am so relief that the drama continues. I for one love drama.
What makes this even more sad is that Thorax has no idea how to stop the hunger he has for love but he doesn’t want to treat it like food, but to share it and experience it like friends and lovers do, but the more he tries his hardest to resist taking love the worse his hunger gets..
Im happy that Friendship is Tragic is returned after 9 months. Poor Thorax without Spike to defend him he feel no hope and Cadence sent him to the dungeon giving Thorax a fate far worse than death. I also can't believe Thorax wants to commit suicide and ask Cadence to kill him. I hope there more of Friendship is Tragic and that the next episode is near. Lastly I hope Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy and Applejack returns either the aftermath of Twilight suicide or another meanwhile in Ponyville or the prequel of their side of the story of Rainbow Dash lost wings, Applejack tragedy and becoming Angerjack, Fluttershy captured and imprisoned (that one was dark just like Applejack lost her family and home).
Did Princess_Cadence ambush Thorax the same place where Spike met him? Who could believe that he's in the Crystal Empire when Flurry Heart's crystalling never happened since she was never born?
🎵TRAGEDY! When your fiancé’s dead, and you’ve lost your head, it’s tragedy. When the sun has died, and you’re partially why, it’s hard to bear. With no one who loves you, you’re going nowhere.🎵 Shoutout to The Bee Gees.
I wish that Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy and especially Applejack (Angerjack) to be in that finally and since Applejack is the only pony witness that saw Twilight commit suicide so either she will feel guilty or anger for what happened as soon she finished grieving.
Yayyy! I’m so gald to see this series back! It’s soooo good everything about it the art the VA work the story those dreams and cadence falling though darkness was hunting omg also I’m so gald to see Luna’s half of the pain truly addressed at last! And damn thorax broke my heart I didn’t expect to see a starving suicidal verison let alone hear about a chrysalis who was cruel to an extreme madness!
I’m so happy that this series is finally back and I’m sure you and your team did a fantastic job with this episode and I’m sure that the voice acting is so amazing and we appreciate you and your team for your hard work with this series as always and you guys deserve a great break when you guys are done with all the episodes and that is all I have to say
Thorax? More like Tantalus. So much love from so many crystal ponies just beyond the bars of his cell, and no way to ever reach it or take it without becoming the monster he fears he is.
It was a long wait, but it was worth it. Another plot from the show is added to this story, but of course changed. I remember that I guessed that something or someone is sitting in Cadence's mind and either feed on her emotions or making them stronger to lead to her insanity. Which really, really reminds me about Rocket To Insanity, but I suspect that your story won't copy it, actually. I even suspect that it is one of the official villains doing all that funky stuff. And Cadence is being Cadence. She can't make herself kill a suffering guy, so instead she will imprison him in the middle of an empire full of love, torturing him that way. Good going! 👍 I have few theories what will happen to him. Since it is FiT series, I suspect that his mind will break, and he will either go feral from hunger or will commit s*icide. About more positive theory, I don't think that adding this plot now is a coincidence, so if it is not to add more tragic elements to the story, I think that he might help Cadence understand or learn something, though I'm not sure what.
At last, Friendship Is Tragic 2 continues! I'm super happy that you've decided to continue this spooky and outstanding series, Scribbler! I cannot wait to see what the upcoming episode unfolds for us to see! 🎃🎃🦇🦇👻👻🧡🧡
Awesome!!! I'm so excited this one-year waiting really worth it 👍, Although it still sounds very worrying about what will happen to Cadence in this episode because she hasn't recovered from all this tragedy yet that is stagnant for now and is about to cross the line of what little positivity she has left. 😬
I think Cadence is going to be the catalyst of the changelings coverting to giving love instead of feeding off it. I think it will give her an epiphany of how choosing love, empathy and compassion heals even the deepest, most painful wounds.😢❤
I can’t believe the wait is almost over! I've been anticipating this episode for so long. The story of the two princesses has been captivating. Can’t wait to watch it on Prime tomorrow!
Consumed by nightmares of her failures, Cadence is afraid of what may come for her kingdom. Will she able to break through her chains of grief and improve herself? And what about Thorax? Cadence could have ended his misery, but decided to take him with her to the Crystal Empire. What fate awaits the young Changeling? Guess we'll find out soon enough! See you next episode Scribbler!!!
You and your team did a fantastic job with this episode and the art style was so amazing and the music was so great too and thanks you and your team for this awesome episode and I can’t wait for the next one and I really love this series and that is all I have to say goodbye.
“A cold crystal throne holds a mare barely grown. Her heart soaked in lies… you win or you die…” So many possibilities in this one… I have some ideas most of them do not Shine but I’ll leave for now with a Sombre thought: Without a Day to warm and The Night is now the enemy what can truly rise? Only a… Heartbreaker…
So we're starting off back with Cadence and Luna again huh Scribbler? That's fair to start with the episodes to come which could get more tragic! As much as Luna was justified for killing the Diametes, look what happened. Her rage left her unfocused on those in Canterlot Castle. Shining armor 100% didn't deserve what happened to him. I feel if he was alive, he'd probably rage at Luna for his parents deaths. I hope we get more stories with Rainbow and Applejack and maybe the others as well. But i think this is a nice place to start after a while. Luna needs to tell Twilight the truth about Shining and her parents. Celestia and Shining Armor's deaths sum up what type of series Friendship is tragic is in general that lots of characters will have something that will affect them greatly in this series. I think we can all agree that it was incredibly heart breaking when Luna cried last time!
"Luna needs to tell Twilight the truth". Right.... While I 100% agree with that, it might already be too late. I really hope it isn't, I would hate it if Twilight died thinking she is to blame for Celestia's death, she still thinks it's her fault. I also agree about her parents and brother, especially since Cadance is hurting in the process.
@@DarkSnowGaming1 Definitely. Poor Cadence is so broken and has no husband now. And i get it Luna killed Shining and she's enraged. What she wouldn't give to be in his hoofs. It also hurts that not only did Cadence find Shining Armor dead, but she found his body blown to pieces. No apology from Luna will fix this. That also hurt when Cadence was in Twilight's bed crying and muttering his name to herself in such a broken tone.
@@Bayden-Bluedash That too but it isn't what I meant. Twilight blames Cadance. She thinks Cadance could have stopped her family from dying, I don't believe she has any clue that Luna was the reason there dead in the first place. It's really depressing to watch, I don't know how much longer I'll be able to actually watch this series before it becomes too much for me, it really feels like this story is doomed to end with a bad ending, with Twilight not being an Alicorn, Pinkie Pie dead, her friends practically hating each other, Celestia dead and Discord not being reformed, Equestria is 1 threat away to becoming a complete wasteland.
@@DarkSnowGaming1 I heard what you said and yeah that is sad that Twilight blames her former foal sitter. Like Cadence would do anything to hurt Twilight parents OR SHINING ARMOR. Twilight has to understand that at least. I know how sad this series is for you. Just hold on. Something at least happy has to come out of all the tragedy. Let's pray at least 1 thing can go right in this series full of tragedy! I know it's hard Dark Snow. I know it's hard. But we'll all face this series together. That scene at the hospital with Applejack was super SAD! "I don't want to see you at the farm EVER again!" That really hurt Rainbow from inside to hear.
This is Part 2 for my afterthoughts! What a way to start back into this series! I meant it when i said Cadence doesn't have to forgive Luna! She just needs to trust her if anything happens in future episodes. Even if that was true when Shining mentioned he was calling for Cadence under the debris, he would still wish for Cadence to be safe! I doubt he'd really blame her if he was alive. I'm glad Cadence also spared Thorax! It was hard watching him cry like that begging her to end his misery and shame. Glad she didn't. She'd be no better than the Diametes. So we know by the next episode it's going to focus on Thorax and Cadence! Thorax has potential for this story now that he's been spared. It's sad Cadence is having these nightmares and hearing Shining blame her for his and his family's deaths. Her love for Shining Armor still stands strong and that won't be taken away from her.
Yo I thought I was ready for this episode, I was totally not. This was so worth the wait that beginning part was so intense and emotional me and my girlfriend were crying. That new intro song sung by muse was beautiful. Well done as always obab you are amazing at what you do. Have a fabulous day and can't wait for the next episode.
What an awesome way to start spooky month! We’re finally back🎃👻💀 I love this series so much! Props to everyone! The music, art, animation and voice acting and the story telling is amazing!! This was incredible as always!❤🥹
We're not even halfway through we are by episode 11. I'm excited to see what will happen until episode 24 and how much Scribbler will make these characters suffer.
Between leading an empire alone, her nightmare self, Sombra, and the trauma of what happened in Cantalot it's only a matter of time before Cadence breaks.
It's amazing, dramatic, emotional and interesting to this episode focus on Cadence. She has getting worse nightmare on their persons that she caring loss in her mind, body and soul. She get think and emotional darkness of past actions even guilt on people loss deeply. I gladly thorax be honest with himself on cadence of his emotions and his sides of story on those events in past. Least he pledge his death on cadence than go back evil queen and can't wait for next episode of this series.
Confession - I have an unpopular opinion in the fact I hated the Friendship is Tragic series but this episode has made me change my mind. It’s a masterpiece and it made me rethink my opinions more. I am going to have to go back and rewatch this series and see. The artwork is amazingly breathtaking.
The OG it showed Adas Personality better and Leon being outraged and saying Cute like that makes way more sense. In the Remake he is angry for no reason and turns her down when he and Ashley can get away easier that way then by using The Jet Ski.
I also agree with some who are saying this could reach the actual breaking point between her and Luna. Sometimes beings can't be redeemed in the eyes of others but Luna can still try to prove she's extremely sorry. It's also high time (even tho it never happens) Luna told twilight the truth cuz just as Dash said: SHE HAS A RIGHT TO KNOW
If she really was sorry she would have told Twilight everything. I really don't understand Luna in this series, it's clear she likes Twilight otherwise she would have told Twilight the truth without caring what Twilight thought of her, the fact Luna hasn't told her shows she somewhat cares about Twilight, either that or she doesn't want to openly admit that she is the cause of her sister's death. Either way it's for selfish reasons. I really hope Twilight didn't die.
@@DarkSnowGaming1 its also a wonder itself how she's managed to even live alongside twilight and still look at her everyday without cracking from guilt
I have a feeling Cadence will go nightmare mode when twilight commits die later on. Will be looking forward to a possible angsty epic dramatic fight between Princess Luna and Nightmare Cadence!
Yeah, her hatred between is becoming more WORSE and out of control which made her ended just like how Luna herself cause it, even though it’s her fault but not as extremely as fault as Cadence.
FINALLY! I was able to get a sec to watch this ep and OMG!! everyone did such an amazing job!!!! AHAHAHAHAH!!! Thorax's VA did such an amazing good! Had me crying with him. And the art!!! EEEEEEEEEE!!! so proud of everyone!!!! Can't wait for ep 12!!!❤
FINALLY! I've been waiting for this episode for ages, thank you Scribbler and everyone else for making this amazing audio drama. The first one was amazing and this one is just as good.
I guess now It's just going to be "canon events", except being dealt with a much more traumatized Cadence instead of Friendship, Mane 6, and Celestia. I wonder what Discord will do, since the PoD was after his awakening, but before his reformation.
Great job, Scribbler. For making me feel for both characters. You are the best to ever do it. I truly mean it from the bottom of my heart. Keep up the great work and take care of yourself. ❤️ 👍👏
I've missed this 2nd story line from friendship is tragic. I am really worried about cadence I don't know what is going on with her and that dream like state but I got a feeling it's the exact same thing that consumed luna a thousand years ago her heart is filled with so much hatred and sadness that it makes her royal dutie of being the princess of love and if you aren't your self whom are you? speaking of which Thorax. I am a bit surprised to see him but not totally as while this isn't in line with the TV series the events it gave are here and given the troubles this would be the best route for him to come to. seeing him beg for death was very sad but even sadder was cadence taking him as a prisoner. this broken version of cadence has left me feeling hurt and scared of her and I am hoping she can change this as the story goes on but she's lost everything so she has nothing more to lose with taking out her anger on others and hurting those she cares for most.
AW MAN THAT WAS SUCH A CRAZY ROLLERCOASTER 😭😭 SCRIBBLER!! You totally outdid yourself on the ambiance, the pacing, the sfx, the build-up, AHHHH I could fangirl about your production eye all day 😭😭
What more do we have to see Princess_Cadence being put through when he lost the love of her life and Twilight Sparkle thinks that she's responsible for her family's demise when it's all because of Princess Luna?
I don't know what to expect because this series is dark but it would be so cute if Thorax gave Cadence the love she needs to keep going and vice versa. I can't wait to see what Scribbler is going to do with this story even if it's just as sad as the ending for the first friendship is tragic, the writing is so good.
Scribbler it's good to see you again, thank you so much to remember and continues Friendship Is Tragic 2 episodes good job girl see you on the next episode on the next weekend. 👍👏😉
Yes it's finally coming out this has been one of my favourite audio dramas and I can't wait to see what you've been cooking up I bet it's going to be good.
It’s about time Friendship is Tragic 2 episode 11 came out. It’s been years. I just have a question. This is still going to be a friendship is tragic 3 where princess Luna saved twilight and twilight woke up in the hospital and Luna and the rest of the mane six for waiting for her. with applejack, fluttershy, rainbow dash, and rarity realizing their mistakes and then make up and pinkie pie is in the hospital too, hoping to still be alive I don’t want the mane six to lose one pony pinkie pie is so much fun. I hate for her to die. Hopefully somewhere in her heart she’ll still be alive and the whole gang get back together again. I will love that a lot.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@melonieboonephd I want someone to tell me how many more chapters are left in this prequel and how's it all going to end with the first one ending with Twilight Sparkle jumping off a tower with her fate being unknown
Well I’m going to have nightmares tonight. Everyone involved did a fantastic job. Keep up the good work. Have a wonderful spooky day Scribbler & Friend’s.
This was an awesome episode Scribbler I've said it in the live chat this is better then the actual show to be honest the developers could actual learn from this Friendship is tragic is truly different from the actual show and I love friendship is tragic
If the redemption Thorax thing still happened, I bet Thorax would be worried for Spike and stay by his side during his hibernation. Im just saying if it still happened.
![Friendship is Tragic: Episode 1 - The Mares of Diomedes [Full Cast MLP Audio Drama]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/w8t0rSpAwIs/mqdefault.jpg)
![Friendship is Tragic: Episode 1 - The Mares of Diomedes [Full Cast MLP Audio Drama]](/img/tr.png)
![[MLP Halloween Special] Parallel Worlds: A Rainbow Factory Story -The Audio Drama (GRIMDARK/TRAGEDY)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rlhWT9DZx6I/mqdefault.jpg)
![YoungBoy Never Broke Again - Missing Everything [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dTYeMZGzOzw/mqdefault.jpg)
![Friendship is Tragic 2: A Tale of Two Princesses: Ep08 - Meanwhile in Ponyville [MLP Audio Drama]](/img/1.gif)
Oh yeah, with Spike in hibernation there was no one to stand up for Thorax and convince everyone to give him a chance.
Agreed that was my favorite part of MLP
Yep everything we know of the canon is altered here but i love it.
I'm so, so happy that FiT2 is consistently pulling me back to mlp XD
I'm glad to see Cadence be called out by her own subconscious, but at the same time seeing her ball up and squeeze away her feelings tighter and tighter is incredibly scary, especially if it's to the point where she's having night terrors about it.
I dearly hope that the dream in this part is fortelling that, even if it will be a long time, Cadence will, at some point, out of necessity for herself and Luna, forgive her. It may even be a step torward forgiving herself. Truly I hope so.
Having that mental burden lightened even a little, would give her the energy to better care for her ponies, and even make friends if possible.
Cadence's nightmares have worsened so much since Twilight woke up. First she felt guilty for the deaths of Twilight's parents and ponies she evacuated, now there's also guilt for leaving Luna, Spike and Twilight. As much as it bugged me in the beginning, how much hatred she kept expressing for Luna, I can't help but worry for her safety and sanity and for the safety of those around her now. If the Tantabus showed up, it's serious.
Yup, fear leads to anger, anger leads to hate, hate leads to suffering. Which her hatred towards Luna, even she didn’t mean to cause some harm could will be the ALWAYS be the BLAME for her for all the suffering she had.
I didn't expect to see a borderline suicidal Thorax
Nor a starved Thorax...
He's so hungry, he needs to eat something before he goes ballistic and starts feeding without his own permission
Wow, I never expected Cadence's sense of guilt was so serious to the point of finding herself alone in those moments (although it is understandable that she is no longer the princess of love at the end of the episode)😔. I wonder if he still has the sense of mercy after meeting Thorax... only time will tell.🤔
Oh my god, this is one of the most wholesome, heart wrenching, and most emotional episodes of Friendship Is Tragic I've ever seen! Cadence has been so depressed after hearing Twilight secretly blaming her for Shining Armor and her parents' deaths, and such rage and heartbreak, and that nightmare Cadence had was so dark! And when Luna talked to Cadence about alicorn magic and emotions, it felt truly emotional and deep to me. She does make a good point about how hatred can make somepony to horrible things, and she is right. Also, Thorax was sneaking around the Crystal Empire at first, but when he talked to Cadence about what he went through and so hungry, lonesome and so depressed, it was so depressing and sad to see this, and when Thorax begged Cadence to kill him... I felt like wailing on the inside! The voice acting and emotions are so perfect!
Very beautiful and amazing work, Scribbler! I give you 500/500 points for such an emotional and beautiful episode! Keep up the good work. *Gives you a thumbs up*
💜💜💜💜😭😭😭😭🥹🥹👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻🌹🌹🌹🌹
This episode hit me hard! Thorax is my favourite character from the show and seeing him cry and beg for him to be killed rather than be locked in the dungeon made me cry! The voice actors make the part and they certainly didn’t disappoint for my favourite bug!
The fact he’s rather let Cadmece kill him than Chrysalis shows how horrible he’s treated back at the hive. Plus he doesn’t want to take any love but he can’t help it as that what he feeds off.
This episode was beautiful and so emotional!
Damn, hearing Thorax begging cadence to kill him right then and there was so sad.
Like I never thought I would hear one of the most wholesome changelings to ever exist, begging for death like that.
You know a world is depressing when even a wholesome person like Thorax is so depressed that he is having suicidal thoughts. At least cadence did not run away from helping him, unlike the others.
As for cadence’s dream, i’m not surprised that a nightmare version of herself is trying to take over. She really needs a therapist.
And I’m Happy that Luna broke her vow to stop dream walking to help Cadence. I’m glad she still tries to help other ponies despite what she’s going through.
Luna wasn’t the one in Cadence’s dream, it was someone else…
@@ScribblerProductions101 Wait what? Luna is the only pony that can dream walk. If it’s not her, then who can it be?
@@kingstar5494 Someone a bit closer to home ;)
@@ScribblerProductions101 Lady, you ain't telling us it was Sombra right?
@@theemeraldking3251 What if it's Luna's nightmare fuel, Tantabus?
YES! I'm so excited for this to come back! It really is tragic that Cadence is kind of getting the blame for what happened to Twilight's family that night during the invasion, and the fact that she can't say anything to deny it either really is sad, having no one to talk to about the events besides the one who caused a lot of the damage as well, I'm really excited to see how she'll develop and go about her journey as a lone princess of a nation and also kinda scared how she'll react if she finds out what happened to Twilight...
I'm so happy with the reception my original song "Failed to Love" got. It's been a huge honour composing the new opening theme ^^
I'll have the official lyric video for it released tomorrow on my channel so keep your eyes peeled ;)
I love your original song it was so good and beautiful and you did a great job
You did an amazing job as cadence and your song at the beginning set the tone for the episode. Awesomely haunting vocals.
Congratulations Musescript! 🎉🎉
@@musescript4215 I need to say this now before I forget. You song absolutely fits perfectly well with the theme of this series
I'm definitely looking forward to this song release!
Cadence, please don't become like Sombra.
Thorax I wish you the best of luck.
I hope nothing bad happens to thorax, but this is called Friendship is Tragic for a reason
As usual I absolutely enjoyed every second of this episode Scribbler! Everything from the artwork and voice acting was done ever so phenomenally, And everyone did such a masterful and brilliant job bringing the episode to life make no mistake about it! Thank you all so much and a very Happy Month Of Macabre to you!!!
After having a nightmare like that, I'd like to think that deep down Cadence finally understands that just like her Luna is also emotionally suffering for the mistakes that she made. Cadence may still have every right not to forgive Luna, But she spoke the truth that emotions like hatred and anger are like a poison, And the more you let it consume you the deeper you fall into the dark depths, To the point where you would be too far gone to save.
But Cadence wasn't going to let what happened to Luna happen to her, But Cadence was going about it the wrong way. And what she was doing to Thorax was proof of that, For she would rather let throw Thorax in a dungeon and let him suffer without love than become a killer.
(SPOILERS-)
I haven't even thought about the Changelings. hearing Thorax just...seem so helpless is so sad...as for queen chrysalis? You know your a bad queen when even your subjects try to escape.
Honestly, I’m not surprised that she turned her hive into North Korea.
Heck, maybe it’s even worse than North Korea.
Once again, Scribbler, you’ve managed to find the most amazing music for an audio drama.
Absolutely love Muse’s opening theme!
In the comics, the nightmare forces are what caused Luna to become Nightmare moon, so maybe something similar to the nightmare forces is trying to take over Cadance.
Yup, this is why they should NEVER be an alicorn. (don’t worry, it’s just my opinion.)
Actually it's the opposites... Luna turn the nyxs in the nightmare forces
You guys don't get Luna/Nightmare Moo intention from the beginning
Plus, she was already Nightmare Moon when she was banished in the moon, how the nyxs suppose to turn her like that?
Ok that beginning almost had me till I instantly realized cadence had another nightmare or panic attack. But also it was so awesome you added thorax! I can't wait to see how the whole series plays out and not to mention a new into song!? WE ARE BLESSED ✨❤️ not to mention the whole dream sequence with cadence was so eerie...
I have never been so emotionally invested in talking horses (excluding BoJack), But these ones are from MLP. H o w
How have you done this to me?
The whole Friendship is Tragic team should be rewarded with matching twirling mustaches, monocles, top hats, and train tracks.
Because I have been tied up and run over by a screaming, sobbing, depressing, beautiful freight train.
I am flattened and broken.
Curse the amazing writers, voice actors, and artists for making this possible.
Without Spike being there to defend Thorax, Cadence was being cold with Thorax Without anyone seeing his point of view
Friendship is tragic has always been my favorite series
Mine too! I’m so glad it’s continuing! at first, I thought it was canceled or discontinue. I hate when series like these be discontinue or cancel. I am so relief that the drama continues. I for one love drama.
@@melonieboonephd Im glad it isn't ending on a bad ending
@@unnatrual484Same Too The Part When Cadance Had A Nightmare That Scared The Life Of Me I Was Getting Terrified
QUE ISSO NÃO SE FAZ PROIBIDO%Ø 🗯🗯🚓
Someone hug Thorax! He's a smol bean that needs it!
I know. I would hug him so tight until he begged me to stop
What makes this even more sad is that Thorax has no idea how to stop the hunger he has for love but he doesn’t want to treat it like food, but to share it and experience it like friends and lovers do, but the more he tries his hardest to resist taking love the worse his hunger gets..
Im happy that Friendship is Tragic is returned after 9 months. Poor Thorax without Spike to defend him he feel no hope and Cadence sent him to the dungeon giving Thorax a fate far worse than death. I also can't believe Thorax wants to commit suicide and ask Cadence to kill him. I hope there more of Friendship is Tragic and that the next episode is near. Lastly I hope Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy and Applejack returns either the aftermath of Twilight suicide or another meanwhile in Ponyville or the prequel of their side of the story of Rainbow Dash lost wings, Applejack tragedy and becoming Angerjack, Fluttershy captured and imprisoned (that one was dark just like Applejack lost her family and home).
Did Princess_Cadence ambush Thorax the same place where Spike met him? Who could believe that he's in the Crystal Empire when Flurry Heart's crystalling never happened since she was never born?
🎵TRAGEDY!
When your fiancé’s dead,
and you’ve lost your head,
it’s tragedy.
When the sun has died,
and you’re partially why,
it’s hard to bear.
With no one who loves you,
you’re going nowhere.🎵
Shoutout to The Bee Gees.
Nice Reference
I have a bad feeling that at the Finale will be Cadence making some emotional growth followed by news of Twilight's suicide
I wish that Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy and especially Applejack (Angerjack) to be in that finally and since Applejack is the only pony witness that saw Twilight commit suicide so either she will feel guilty or anger for what happened as soon she finished grieving.
Yayyy! I’m so gald to see this series back! It’s soooo good everything about it the art the VA work the story those dreams and cadence falling though darkness was hunting omg also I’m so gald to see Luna’s half of the pain truly addressed at last! And damn thorax broke my heart I didn’t expect to see a starving suicidal verison let alone hear about a chrysalis who was cruel to an extreme madness!
I’m so happy that this series is finally back and I’m sure you and your team did a fantastic job with this episode and I’m sure that the voice acting is so amazing and we appreciate you and your team for your hard work with this series as always and you guys deserve a great break when you guys are done with all the episodes and that is all I have to say
I can barely contain my excitement!!!
Every episode release is a real miracle!
Thorax? More like Tantalus. So much love from so many crystal ponies just beyond the bars of his cell, and no way to ever reach it or take it without becoming the monster he fears he is.
It was a long wait, but it was worth it. Another plot from the show is added to this story, but of course changed.
I remember that I guessed that something or someone is sitting in Cadence's mind and either feed on her emotions or making them stronger to lead to her insanity. Which really, really reminds me about Rocket To Insanity, but I suspect that your story won't copy it, actually. I even suspect that it is one of the official villains doing all that funky stuff.
And Cadence is being Cadence. She can't make herself kill a suffering guy, so instead she will imprison him in the middle of an empire full of love, torturing him that way. Good going! 👍
I have few theories what will happen to him. Since it is FiT series, I suspect that his mind will break, and he will either go feral from hunger or will commit s*icide. About more positive theory, I don't think that adding this plot now is a coincidence, so if it is not to add more tragic elements to the story, I think that he might help Cadence understand or learn something, though I'm not sure what.
This is why I love month of the Macabre.
At last, Friendship Is Tragic 2 continues! I'm super happy that you've decided to continue this spooky and outstanding series, Scribbler! I cannot wait to see what the upcoming episode unfolds for us to see!
🎃🎃🦇🦇👻👻🧡🧡
Yes, finally this story continues!
Ikr I can't wait!
Awesome!!! I'm so excited this one-year waiting really worth it 👍, Although it still sounds very worrying about what will happen to Cadence in this episode because she hasn't recovered from all this tragedy yet that is stagnant for now and is about to cross the line of what little positivity she has left. 😬
I think Cadence is going to be the catalyst of the changelings coverting to giving love instead of feeding off it. I think it will give her an epiphany of how choosing love, empathy and compassion heals even the deepest, most painful wounds.😢❤
I can’t believe the wait is almost over! I've been anticipating this episode for so long. The story of the two princesses has been captivating. Can’t wait to watch it on Prime tomorrow!
Consumed by nightmares of her failures, Cadence is afraid of what may come for her kingdom. Will she able to break through her chains of grief and improve herself? And what about Thorax? Cadence could have ended his misery, but decided to take him with her to the Crystal Empire. What fate awaits the young Changeling?
Guess we'll find out soon enough!
See you next episode Scribbler!!!
I can't wait to see another Episode 12 I'm so glad to to see Friendship Is Tragic 2: Tale Of 2 Princesses come back after so long I'm so happy
You and your team did a fantastic job with this episode and the art style was so amazing and the music was so great too and thanks you and your team for this awesome episode and I can’t wait for the next one and I really love this series and that is all I have to say goodbye.
“A cold crystal throne holds a mare barely grown. Her heart soaked in lies… you win or you die…”
So many possibilities in this one…
I have some ideas most of them do not Shine but I’ll leave for now with a Sombre thought:
Without a Day to warm and The Night is now the enemy what can truly rise? Only a… Heartbreaker…
So we're starting off back with Cadence and Luna again huh Scribbler? That's fair to start with the episodes to come which could get more tragic! As much as Luna was justified for killing the Diametes, look what happened. Her rage left her unfocused on those in Canterlot Castle. Shining armor 100% didn't deserve what happened to him. I feel if he was alive, he'd probably rage at Luna for his parents deaths. I hope we get more stories with Rainbow and Applejack and maybe the others as well. But i think this is a nice place to start after a while. Luna needs to tell Twilight the truth about Shining and her parents. Celestia and Shining Armor's deaths sum up what type of series Friendship is tragic is in general that lots of characters will have something that will affect them greatly in this series. I think we can all agree that it was incredibly heart breaking when Luna cried last time!
"Luna needs to tell Twilight the truth".
Right.... While I 100% agree with that, it might already be too late. I really hope it isn't, I would hate it if Twilight died thinking she is to blame for Celestia's death, she still thinks it's her fault. I also agree about her parents and brother, especially since Cadance is hurting in the process.
@@DarkSnowGaming1 Definitely. Poor Cadence is so broken and has no husband now. And i get it Luna killed Shining and she's enraged. What she wouldn't give to be in his hoofs. It also hurts that not only did Cadence find Shining Armor dead, but she found his body blown to pieces. No apology from Luna will fix this. That also hurt when Cadence was in Twilight's bed crying and muttering his name to herself in such a broken tone.
@@Bayden-Bluedash That too but it isn't what I meant. Twilight blames Cadance. She thinks Cadance could have stopped her family from dying, I don't believe she has any clue that Luna was the reason there dead in the first place.
It's really depressing to watch, I don't know how much longer I'll be able to actually watch this series before it becomes too much for me, it really feels like this story is doomed to end with a bad ending, with Twilight not being an Alicorn, Pinkie Pie dead, her friends practically hating each other, Celestia dead and Discord not being reformed, Equestria is 1 threat away to becoming a complete wasteland.
@@DarkSnowGaming1 I heard what you said and yeah that is sad that Twilight blames her former foal sitter. Like Cadence would do anything to hurt Twilight parents OR SHINING ARMOR. Twilight has to understand that at least. I know how sad this series is for you. Just hold on. Something at least happy has to come out of all the tragedy. Let's pray at least 1 thing can go right in this series full of tragedy! I know it's hard Dark Snow. I know it's hard. But we'll all face this series together. That scene at the hospital with Applejack was super SAD! "I don't want to see you at the farm EVER again!" That really hurt Rainbow from inside to hear.
@@Bayden-Bluedash I really hope something good happens.
Aww. This is such a sad story... poor Thorax. I thought Cadence was actually going to habe mercy on him. Gueas I can I only expect so much from her.
we've already seen the changelings live in the crystal empire in season 1, thorax as candence's advisor.
This is Part 2 for my afterthoughts! What a way to start back into this series! I meant it when i said Cadence doesn't have to forgive Luna! She just needs to trust her if anything happens in future episodes. Even if that was true when Shining mentioned he was calling for Cadence under the debris, he would still wish for Cadence to be safe! I doubt he'd really blame her if he was alive. I'm glad Cadence also spared Thorax! It was hard watching him cry like that begging her to end his misery and shame. Glad she didn't. She'd be no better than the Diametes. So we know by the next episode it's going to focus on Thorax and Cadence! Thorax has potential for this story now that he's been spared. It's sad Cadence is having these nightmares and hearing Shining blame her for his and his family's deaths. Her love for Shining Armor still stands strong and that won't be taken away from her.
Yo I thought I was ready for this episode, I was totally not. This was so worth the wait that beginning part was so intense and emotional me and my girlfriend were crying. That new intro song sung by muse was beautiful. Well done as always obab you are amazing at what you do. Have a fabulous day and can't wait for the next episode.
Thank you so much for letting me be a part of this project Scribbler! I can't wait to see what the next episodes have in store!!
What an awesome way to start spooky month! We’re finally back🎃👻💀 I love this series so much! Props to everyone! The music, art, animation and voice acting and the story telling is amazing!! This was incredible as always!❤🥹
Is it just me, or are Cadence's dreams starting to remind me of the Nightmares from remembrance?
We're not even halfway through we are by episode 11. I'm excited to see what will happen until episode 24 and how much Scribbler will make these characters suffer.
Between leading an empire alone, her nightmare self, Sombra, and the trauma of what happened in Cantalot it's only a matter of time before Cadence breaks.
It's amazing, dramatic, emotional and interesting to this episode focus on Cadence. She has getting worse nightmare on their persons that she caring loss in her mind, body and soul. She get think and emotional darkness of past actions even guilt on people loss deeply.
I gladly thorax be honest with himself on cadence of his emotions and his sides of story on those events in past. Least he pledge his death on cadence than go back evil queen and can't wait for next episode of this series.
???: Poor Thorax. Going through this world's horrible unforgiving twist! Now I feel more sympathy for him... Don't let him out of your sight. Please.
Are going to see the emergence of a dark Cadence and if so can we call her Heart Breaker😁 Thank you Scribbler and Friends for telling a great story 😎
Confession - I have an unpopular opinion in the fact I hated the Friendship is Tragic series but this episode has made me change my mind. It’s a masterpiece and it made me rethink my opinions more. I am going to have to go back and rewatch this series and see. The artwork is amazingly breathtaking.
We were finally waiting for to watch the next episode. She was more excited to see everything until the end.
The OG it showed Adas Personality better and Leon being outraged and saying Cute like that makes way more sense.
In the Remake he is angry for no reason and turns her down when he and Ashley can get away easier that way then by using The Jet Ski.
I also agree with some who are saying this could reach the actual breaking point between her and Luna. Sometimes beings can't be redeemed in the eyes of others but Luna can still try to prove she's extremely sorry. It's also high time (even tho it never happens) Luna told twilight the truth cuz just as Dash said: SHE HAS A RIGHT TO KNOW
If she really was sorry she would have told Twilight everything. I really don't understand Luna in this series, it's clear she likes Twilight otherwise she would have told Twilight the truth without caring what Twilight thought of her, the fact Luna hasn't told her shows she somewhat cares about Twilight, either that or she doesn't want to openly admit that she is the cause of her sister's death. Either way it's for selfish reasons. I really hope Twilight didn't die.
@@DarkSnowGaming1 ya, very true 🙁
@@DarkSnowGaming1 its also a wonder itself how she's managed to even live alongside twilight and still look at her everyday without cracking from guilt
@@kaijunasan4497 Do we know how long Twilight lived in Canterlot Castle after leaving the hospital before going to find her friends?
I feel like this Cadence and Remembrance Cadence could be friends
I wasn't expecting Thorax to be in this
I feel like the next episode will show Cadance slowly but surely see thorax like Spike did, but in a different way, who's knows!
"Will Thorax survive?" That is the question we're probably asking ourselves. My answer, "We'll just have to wait and see."
I have a feeling Cadence will go nightmare mode when twilight commits die later on. Will be looking forward to a possible angsty epic dramatic fight between Princess Luna and Nightmare Cadence!
Yeah, her hatred between is becoming more WORSE and out of control which made her ended just like how Luna herself cause it, even though it’s her fault but not as extremely as fault as Cadence.
FINALLY! I was able to get a sec to watch this ep and OMG!! everyone did such an amazing job!!!! AHAHAHAHAH!!! Thorax's VA did such an amazing good! Had me crying with him. And the art!!! EEEEEEEEEE!!! so proud of everyone!!!! Can't wait for ep 12!!!❤
FINALLY! I've been waiting for this episode for ages, thank you Scribbler and everyone else for making this amazing audio drama. The first one was amazing and this one is just as good.
I guess now It's just going to be "canon events", except being dealt with a much more traumatized Cadence instead of Friendship, Mane 6, and Celestia.
I wonder what Discord will do, since the PoD was after his awakening, but before his reformation.
I'm very happy that this awesome series is back again after so long! I can't wait to see what is in store for Cadence.
Great job, Scribbler. For making me feel for both characters. You are the best to ever do it. I truly mean it from the bottom of my heart. Keep up the great work and take care of yourself. ❤️ 👍👏
Wow! Candace taking Throax to the dungeon? Can't wait to see what happens next soon. ^^
I've missed this 2nd story line from friendship is tragic. I am really worried about cadence I don't know what is going on with her and that dream like state but I got a feeling it's the exact same thing that consumed luna a thousand years ago her heart is filled with so much hatred and sadness that it makes her royal dutie of being the princess of love and if you aren't your self whom are you? speaking of which Thorax. I am a bit surprised to see him but not totally as while this isn't in line with the TV series the events it gave are here and given the troubles this would be the best route for him to come to. seeing him beg for death was very sad but even sadder was cadence taking him as a prisoner. this broken version of cadence has left me feeling hurt and scared of her and I am hoping she can change this as the story goes on but she's lost everything so she has nothing more to lose with taking out her anger on others and hurting those she cares for most.
I'm glad you've released only one episode of this series this month of October instead of three or four of them.
AW MAN THAT WAS SUCH A CRAZY ROLLERCOASTER 😭😭 SCRIBBLER!! You totally outdid yourself on the ambiance, the pacing, the sfx, the build-up, AHHHH I could fangirl about your production eye all day 😭😭
Goddess that cute face and adorable hoovsie in the antigravity sweets bag melts my heart every time. ^~^
wow what an eppisode ... I can't wait til the next! Poor Thorax!
NO WAY IS THIS REALLY HAPPINING
Aaaaaah! We ought to call you the master of the cliffhanger scribbler! Brilliant as always.
Can't wait friendship is tragic is my favourite audio drama ❤
Same
Dreams of heartbreak more like nightmares of heartbreak
What more do we have to see Princess_Cadence being put through when he lost the love of her life and Twilight Sparkle thinks that she's responsible for her family's demise when it's all because of Princess Luna?
No, at least controls her dark powers to not corrupt her. But she succeeded, only rage and grief leads her to lose control.
I started crying when thorax started to explain himself.. I feel so sorry for my favorite changeling..
26:10 THORAX NOOO!!!
cadens please he knows he mest up but please don't tourcher him like this
I do feel bad for Thorax. Other than that, I definitely enjoyed listening to the new episode
AT LAST!!!!!!!! The BANGER Is BACK!!!!!!!! 35:38
And so in conclusion, if Earth Temperature were to rise by this one degree, average sea levels would rise leading to a- 🎵MASSIVE TRAGEDY!!🎵
I don't know what to expect because this series is dark but it would be so cute if Thorax gave Cadence the love she needs to keep going and vice versa. I can't wait to see what Scribbler is going to do with this story even if it's just as sad as the ending for the first friendship is tragic, the writing is so good.
Weeee Let's Go The Truama Express Passing Through!
Scribbler it's good to see you again, thank you so much to remember and continues Friendship Is Tragic 2 episodes good job girl see you on the next episode on the next weekend. 👍👏😉
Scribbler how many episodes are coming out on this year Halloween?
If my little pony was a Seinen you would definitely get something like friendship is tragic.
Yeah.
Why do I feel like Cadence might end up letting Thorax disguise himself as Shining Armor, so he can feed and she can "have her husband back"?🤔
I read a story where Thorax was killed a few months ago. If the same thing happens here and thorax dies, I’m gonna be sad and angry at the same time
Yes it's finally coming out this has been one of my favourite audio dramas and I can't wait to see what you've been cooking up I bet it's going to be good.
If I don’t make it to the premiere that day, I apologize. But I’ll still watch it whenever I can!
I’m so glad Thorax is a part of the story now! Though it makes me miss Spike even more :,(
That intro is fire!
It’s about time Friendship is Tragic 2 episode 11 came out. It’s been years. I just have a question. This is still going to be a friendship is tragic 3 where princess Luna saved twilight and twilight woke up in the hospital and Luna and the rest of the mane six for waiting for her. with applejack, fluttershy, rainbow dash, and rarity realizing their mistakes and then make up and pinkie pie is in the hospital too, hoping to still be alive I don’t want the mane six to lose one pony pinkie pie is so much fun. I hate for her to die. Hopefully somewhere in her heart she’ll still be alive and the whole gang get back together again. I will love that a lot.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Sorry to say that tragedy stories usually do not have a happy ending.
@@melonieboonephd I want someone to tell me how many more chapters are left in this prequel and how's it all going to end with the first one ending with Twilight Sparkle jumping off a tower with her fate being unknown
Well I’m going to have nightmares tonight. Everyone involved did a fantastic job. Keep up the good work. Have a wonderful spooky day Scribbler & Friend’s.
This was an awesome episode Scribbler I've said it in the live chat this is better then the actual show to be honest the developers could actual learn from this Friendship is tragic is truly different from the actual show and I love friendship is tragic
If the redemption Thorax thing still happened, I bet Thorax would be worried for Spike and stay by his side during his hibernation. Im just saying if it still happened.
I'm so happy to see that this series is continuing! I was worried it was cancelled.
OMFG a new episode of FIT?? This just made my day!! Can't wait 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Nightmare cadence would be interesting actually
I hate the cliffhangers lol. Hopefully next episode will be out soon