She actually sounds sweet, timid, shy, and self-doubting. It is very easy to care for the character. The OG voice actress gave me the impression Fuuka was literally stab me in the back and literally day in defense in a monotone voice: "Noo! It was an accident."
@@ajflinkthe one in the middle was... in the middle performance-wise as well, but because her voice fits spunkier, more energetic characters like Miu Iruma and Athena Cykes, rather than Fuuka
I know that vocally flat and emotionless characters are a thing in Japanese media; however, in the West, it comes across as fake, robotic, and unnatural like the person is on something. To make it worse, Fuuka's character is supposed to be shy and timid, not emotionally apathetic, which is not what she comes across as in the original. Also, I think the voice direction was incorrect in English as she does not sound like this in any future appearances after Portable, especially Reload where her voice actually fits what she is saying. I still cannot get over the OG English voice actress saying a monotone voice: "Don't worry! Fear is only temporary!" I still think it is hilarious.
Her voice sounds iconic! Her flat, nasally voice really grew on me and its a great contrast from Rise and Futaba who scream at every single occurrence. I do like their high energy voices, but Fuuka still has her charm.
As someone who played portable not too long ago, Fuuka's voice never bothered me. Of course, certain expressions at times made me think she lacked expression, but Fuuka's background and demeanour makes me think she's simply flat in that way. It is still a very subjective thing, though, as I don't think we learn enough of her past to actually know. Eh, I respect it
I don´t see a bad acting, not everybody is so emotional and expressive. I have a friend that talks in the same way than her, always in flat tone. Maybe I´m biased because of that.
Also, it could be an issue with voice direction. Even the voice actors on Sonic Adventure hated their lines because they weren't given proper context for their lines.
If you don't see bad acting you are tripping, new one and this one is day and night difference, also for reference stick to JP and you'll realize this is garbage acting
Then there's her navigation, which may be the worst bit of acting I heard in a while. Her voice is all over the place as she tells you their weaknesses then starts telling you the amount of enemies that are left. I'm the kind of person who feels that most anime/game dubs are actually really good, yet I still think she sounds atrocious. It would seem like Atlus agreed, since they changed her VA for subsequent spinoffs featuring the P3 cast.
@myposturesjustfine1086 That is a matter of opinion, not fact. being monotone isn't bad voice acting. Also, what is the point of comparing the english and japanese voices, most people who are playing the game in America are going be listening to the english dub, so what is the point of comparing the two? Unless, of course, you're one of those assholes who think that people who listen to anime with an english dub are stupid
@@mypostureisjustfine Mfw the japanese and English dub have to have the exact same tone and can't have differences to sell the game more/make things more interesting!!!
I never thought there was anything particularly wrong with her voice. Am I tripping lol. I just think that's how she is, an awkward nerd who is a little weird, which makes her unique not bad.
Trying to find comparasion the new dub and the og, cause only played this once, kinda forgot how she sounds like. I remember not interested in her, her personality generaly are my thing but somehow she are not in my radar. Now i know why. The voice acting cannot catch my attention. The New VA are more interesting, the way fuuka sounds really more in cute way that's what i expect from this kinda character. And somehow RUclips recommending this to remembering me that just how fuuka sounds like. Oh my favorite is mitsuru and the new VA nailed it on another level, better than the og in my opinion. Her sounds really mature which is my type💀.
Fuuka’s Vanilla, FES and Portable voice may be flat and not quite expressive, but it still is iconic! You can never forget some of her famous voice lines. I do prefer Fuuka’s Reload va and her voice definitely matches her face, plus it sounds a lot more expressive and has its own personality.
Here's a thing about voice acting, not every line need to be delivered emotionally, especially not this scene that has no implications that the dialogue needed to be dramatically delivered, that's called being tone deaf theater kids
Dude all the voice acting in this game sucked. Even Mitsuru has no range. The direction was awful when dubbing this. But it was a JRPG being localized in the late 2000s what did you expect.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Y'all may hate Fuuka's voice but *GASP* The enemy!!!!!
I Hope that Atlus change her voice actress for the re-release.
@@MiguelS8393 they haven’t done that, it’s just a direct psp to modern consoles port
@@enzhymezthey are remaking the game are you living under a rock
@@davidgunn7058 hell yeah ‼️
#patrickstarsroommate
She was voiced by Wendee Lee in P4 Arena + Ultimax, as well as P3: Dancing In Starlight.
I don't hear any bad voice acting, what i hear is a voice actor trying her best to do flat tone
You mean, do good voice acting?
That's illegal.
Her new voice is literally perfect
She actually sounds sweet, timid, shy, and self-doubting. It is very easy to care for the character.
The OG voice actress gave me the impression Fuuka was literally stab me in the back and literally day in defense in a monotone voice: "Noo! It was an accident."
@@ajflinkthe one in the middle was... in the middle performance-wise as well, but because her voice fits spunkier, more energetic characters like Miu Iruma and Athena Cykes, rather than Fuuka
@@ajflinkwasn't she bullied for being weird and off? The old voice encapsulated that perfectly
Not surprising as her voice actress is highly sought after in the anime world.
I know that vocally flat and emotionless characters are a thing in Japanese media; however, in the West, it comes across as fake, robotic, and unnatural like the person is on something.
To make it worse, Fuuka's character is supposed to be shy and timid, not emotionally apathetic, which is not what she comes across as in the original. Also, I think the voice direction was incorrect in English as she does not sound like this in any future appearances after Portable, especially Reload where her voice actually fits what she is saying.
I still cannot get over the OG English voice actress saying a monotone voice: "Don't worry! Fear is only temporary!" I still think it is hilarious.
*T H A T ' S I L L E G A L*
fuuka’s voice is cute y’all trippin
yeah, specially around October, looks like her voice actress got the hang of it
Her voice sounds iconic! Her flat, nasally voice really grew on me and its a great contrast from Rise and Futaba who scream at every single occurrence. I do like their high energy voices, but Fuuka still has her charm.
i just cant help laughing when she went "Nooooooooo!"
I loved her voice, the hate is kinda sad lmao
Cute?????
At least she tried. Also, Fuuka and Ken's English VAs were uncredited, leaving us to assume who voiced them.
As someone who played portable not too long ago, Fuuka's voice never bothered me. Of course, certain expressions at times made me think she lacked expression, but Fuuka's background and demeanour makes me think she's simply flat in that way. It is still a very subjective thing, though, as I don't think we learn enough of her past to actually know. Eh, I respect it
0:30 "Hold on bro, I'm hacking a hologram."
I don´t see a bad acting, not everybody is so emotional and expressive. I have a friend that talks in the same way than her, always in flat tone. Maybe I´m biased because of that.
Also, it could be an issue with voice direction. Even the voice actors on Sonic Adventure hated their lines because they weren't given proper context for their lines.
@@res20stupid Could be a reason too.
@@res20stupid really hard to be the case since the other va put more emotion, unless she was the only one not given proper context
If you don't see bad acting you are tripping, new one and this one is day and night difference, also for reference stick to JP and you'll realize this is garbage acting
fuuka's voice is fine. it isn't bad. she's flat, because that's how fuuka talks. it isn't bad.
I disagree, compare it with the Japanese version, wich is the primary voice, you will see she is not flat, actually she os way more emotional.
Then there's her navigation, which may be the worst bit of acting I heard in a while. Her voice is all over the place as she tells you their weaknesses then starts telling you the amount of enemies that are left.
I'm the kind of person who feels that most anime/game dubs are actually really good, yet I still think she sounds atrocious. It would seem like Atlus agreed, since they changed her VA for subsequent spinoffs featuring the P3 cast.
Cope😊
She sounds like a robot
cope
its very uncomfortable how a great part of her dialogue is just calling someone elses name
The Persona 3 voice acting makes me want to Persona 3 myself.
Tbf, it was a 2006 jrpg dub
Why is that bad voice acting because she's monotone? Ever thought maybe that's what they were going for
compared to how fuuka's original japanese dub is, in english she's not just dead inside, but just blatant terrible voice acting
@myposturesjustfine1086 That is a matter of opinion, not fact. being monotone isn't bad voice acting. Also, what is the point of comparing the english and japanese voices, most people who are playing the game in America are going be listening to the english dub, so what is the point of comparing the two? Unless, of course, you're one of those assholes who think that people who listen to anime with an english dub are stupid
@@mypostureisjustfine Mfw the japanese and English dub have to have the exact same tone and can't have differences to sell the game more/make things more interesting!!!
@@Maddiephetamine How does removing emotion from the acting make it more interesting?
@@Miriam_J_ it just does
Don't insult my monotone waifu 😤
Who says waifu in the big 2024
she said she was twelve 🗣‼
She sounds like a menu voice- how was this even allowed
sounds like the voice from the sonic adventure menu
I never thought there was anything particularly wrong with her voice. Am I tripping lol. I just think that's how she is, an awkward nerd who is a little weird, which makes her unique not bad.
This is what i think
Tara Platt slander will not be tolerated
Her new voice actor in Q suits her much better tbh.
If I didn't find her voice funny I'd probably be very annoyed with the delivery
Fuuka sounds like mini mouse
“is the bad voice acting in this room right now?”
Akihiko senpai is in trouble
It kind of makes her unique tho, and she cute 😂
I don’t hear anything wrong with her voice.
Trying to find comparasion the new dub and the og, cause only played this once, kinda forgot how she sounds like. I remember not interested in her, her personality generaly are my thing but somehow she are not in my radar.
Now i know why. The voice acting cannot catch my attention. The New VA are more interesting, the way fuuka sounds really more in cute way that's what i expect from this kinda character.
And somehow RUclips recommending this to remembering me that just how fuuka sounds like.
Oh my favorite is mitsuru and the new VA nailed it on another level, better than the og in my opinion. Her sounds really mature which is my type💀.
mitsuru best girl
the old voice acting was a little corny but it wasn't bad
Fuuka’s Vanilla, FES and Portable voice may be flat and not quite expressive, but it still is iconic! You can never forget some of her famous voice lines. I do prefer Fuuka’s Reload va and her voice definitely matches her face, plus it sounds a lot more expressive and has its own personality.
IS THAT THE GRIM REAPER!?
Best girl Fuuka.
Fuuka: single-handedly making the case for the undub for over a decade.
Bro, no way people are out here defending here voice acting. The cope is crazy
here?
@@nessdbest8708 damn...
whenever I feel like playing the original P3s I hesitate just because of fuukas voice alone...
It’s not terrible it just doesn’t match her design like she sounds more mature then she looks
What is fuuka being fed by her parents
Presumably nothing
Nothing (canon)
Probably child abuse guessing on implications.
Sounds fine to me
fuuka sounds like tikal from sonic adventure omg 😭
Honestly only Fuukas voice in the og bothered me
i disagree
fuuka's voice is nice but she sounds so sarcastic and insincere
I absolutely hate fuuka's english voice
The new one is better
@@renamamiya5997 i agree x100000
Ren Amamiya opposite
@@renamamiya5997 there’s a new one?
The Voice Acting isn't Horrible here.
Before I completed the fuuka sl I tho the reason she was bullying is be her voice
They sound the same! Sorry!
I miss Fuuka's original voice so much.
She like tails from sonic adventure
*L o o k a t a l l t h o s e e g g m a n s r o b o t s!*
What's Bad The Voice Acting Or Your Opinion? 😐
I don’t get it?
The tone and inflection of her voice is flat and altogether bad
Tbh ive always prefered the first fuuka voice u_u
Kuuhaku Oh I thought you were talking about Mitsuru. Duh Fukka’s old voice is bad.
Fides Annika Balmaceda You shouldn’t the new be is better
I love Mitsuru's voice
Hearing while playing Reload is strange and kinda bad, sorry OG fans ☹️
Blame Japanese direction
god actors but...Bad acting, how ironic
Why do people praise bad voice acting in this comment section?
Because nostalgia blinds people
reloads voice acting clears and its not even close😭
thats an opinion
@@Ghoats me when I'm lying crazy style
Unpopular opinion but I don’t find mitsuru’s og voice good either… not as bad as Fuuka but not not good… just okay
How come?
@@myyoutubeaccount4167 comes off as lazy imo
Here's a thing about voice acting, not every line need to be delivered emotionally, especially not this scene that has no implications that the dialogue needed to be dramatically delivered, that's called being tone deaf theater kids
I just hear temari from Naruto, I’m still shocked that Fuukas voice actress does Lulu from FFX
Dude all the voice acting in this game sucked. Even Mitsuru has no range. The direction was awful when dubbing this. But it was a JRPG being localized in the late 2000s what did you expect.
that's why it's much better to play it in japanese
I'll never play reload the new voices are *ASS*
????