I remember how important My Little Pony G3 and G4 were to my entire childhood. I'm gonna be 20 in August and it is still a large part of who I am as a human being today. 💕💕 I love how wonderful nostalgia feels.
I think it may symbolise how eating so many carrots made her eye sight so good that she could see into outer space, cuz when she closed her eyes she fell down again.
This song has always confused me. Then I see someone made a PMV of it, and I think "Ok, now maybe I will finally understand this song." One music video later and I'm more confused than ever.@.@
I hate it when I am just minding my own business and next thing I know I'm being sucked through space and time in a symbolic journey. Suddenly I'm thrown into the sun and learn I'm the one who caused the big bang and created all of existence. Don't you just hate it when that happens?
“You try your best but it’s not quite there” She likes gardening, but her plants won’t grow. Hinting at the name of the song. “A rumor that’s not quite as it seems” It DOES grow. “Keep your friends close they’re what drive you to the cosmos that describes you” With the power of FRIE- once again pointing at the “beyond her GARDEN”, she is sent into a multiverse based off fruits and veggies. Because “the cosmos that describes you” for the third time pokes carrot top likes gardening in our eyes.
@@thegoldenbrickstoneI don’t know the specifics but I figure it was not a strike made by WT, rather the automated system recognizing the song and flagging the video once WT had the song uploaded to stuff like RUclips musics library. it’s been eleven years so it wouldn’t surprise me if the system changed and ended up flagging this video even if it had the original song creators permissions.
Oh god... Many years have passed. I just saw brony polka in my reccomend and I realized how good this song actually is. It gives me my childchood vibes
okay, either i think i know the meaning of this song, or its just too early and im thinking too much. so we start off with Carrot Top, a beloved mare who obviously loves gardening. she's trying her best to make her garden grow to at least be a decent garden, but nothings happening. notice how in the animation, shes been focusing a lot on her garden. all day and all night, all she really does is focus on her garden. the title of this song is "beyond her garden," and the chorus of this song says "Carrot Top, go beyond us." i could be entirely wrong, but maybe this aludes to the garden telling her to stop focusing on the garden and to go off and try new things, or else the garden's never going to grow. i'm sorry, this song came out over 7 years ago but i couldn't help but notice the amount of people wondering what the song was about and i got curious too.
This song is.... Very hitting and nostalgic and very.... memorable This song is Grade A masterpiece! Prove with all of my heart. 🌌 Man I Miss the good ol'days
Ok, I swear I quit the mlp fandom about when season 4 started rolling out, but today this song ravaged my mind and I couldn't remember where it was from until I remembered the beat dropping and carrot top being flung through space, so here I am. This is like visiting family that you hated but now missed.
You try your best but it's not quite there You kick your hoof and say "It's just not fair" A simple mare living simple dreams A rumor there not quite as it seems You try your best but it's not quite there You kick your hoof and say "It's just not fair" A simple mare living simple dreams A rumor there not quite as it seems Carrot Top, go beyond us You're a late start, time to fool us Keep your friends close, they will drive you To the cosmos, that describes you Carrot Top, go beyond us You're a late start, time to fool us Keep your friends close, they will drive you To the cosmos, that describes you Brighter than tonight's sunsets Can't mistake the silhouettes Not a sound or a voice nearby Your mane illuminates this gloomy sky Carrot Top, go beyond us You're a late start, time to fool us Keep your friends close, they will drive you To the cosmos, that describes you Carrot Top, go beyond us You're a late start, time to fool us Keep your friends close, they will drive you To the cosmos, that describes you Please ignore my previous comment about me not liking the song :P
I love that animation style, I hate when they look too perfect, I love mistakes in a video, it gives it more texture and imagination in my opinion. I love the little bits of mistakes scattered around the video, it kept me watching it.
Just a great video. Simple but emotive animation, great synching with the song, and memorable story. Also you put in a lot of humor and captured the spirit of the show. This is one of the best pony videos on youtube, top 20 at least.
Wow I didn't know animatedjames animated this! Holy crap no wonder it's so brilliant and inspiring Woodentoaster, and animatedjames well done bravo bravo
i have this in a folder with my favorite songs and the folder is more than 5 years old and this came up when i shuffled... oh the memories... this is still a banger tho
one of my OCs could survive in space, as well as re-entering the atmosphere. the thing is, he is a vampire. but instead of drinking blood, he drains small ammounts of magic from other ponies. he also loses all his powers during the day, so yeah. so, as long as he leaves the atmosphere during the night, he stays in his vampir form, since in space, there is no day or night. he also doesnt need to breathe as vampire and has a low body temperature, so he wont suffocate nor freeze. and the re-entering the atmosphere thing is pretty nice actually: he has an adaptive healing factor, which heals him based on how bad the injury is. small injuries heal slower than big ones, and he even talked to a bunch of vampire ponies during training, while he was burnt by a dragon. the dragon didnt really burn him, since he recovered as fast as he got burnt, but u know what i mean. :)
My God, I remember when I was a little girl and I used to go to RUclips to get a bit on the internet and watch this kind of videos. These things are my whole childhood.
***** Mac as good accept for a ok antivirus. Windows is better for recording, more DL options for videoGames and Better looking. And FL Studios for windows :).
I listen to this at least once a day! Soo many feels...my friend is currently dying. He has 2 weeks and this song makes me so emotional...I start crying...
![[Animation] Beyond Her Garden ll Unfinished](/img/1.gif)
I miss this era more than anything
me too bro
Same 😔
Hello from 2023! (21 of August)
So do I..
GANGINGTONS!!
this is literally memories
*****
wut
Rock Purple ...hoi 😊😘
hi
@@PuffedRockPurple yo
RockPurple but I’m 97 years old and this doesn’t bring back mementos
Was carrot high or something
idk
+Mangle Derp #LSD
+Mangle Derp Nope, shes dreaming, it shows at the end..
Firestar no that is when you stop being high and wake up but realize your in someone else house
This is what happens on lsd lol
I remember how important My Little Pony G3 and G4 were to my entire childhood. I'm gonna be 20 in August and it is still a large part of who I am as a human being today. 💕💕 I love how wonderful nostalgia feels.
Watching this now brings so much nostalgia...
ikr!
:DD
I KNOW RIGHT!
Ikr
SuitedBrony IKR
ikr
I think it may symbolise how eating so many carrots made her eye sight so good that she could see into outer space, cuz when she closed her eyes she fell down again.
I see comments from like 4-5 years ago, I remember listening to this as a child 24/7 where has time gone?
There are like 15 comments-
Dude, you are literally me!
yeah same bro...
This song has always confused me. Then I see someone made a PMV of it, and I think "Ok, now maybe I will finally understand this song." One music video later and I'm more confused than ever.@.@
Watch Beyond Her Tomb someone put a comment of what the story is about according to MictheMicrophone
Kahlor Quiver I like to think of Beyond her Tomb as the official story and this video as the LSD trip version
i see this video and im on LSD @_@
Yes..I don t get it
hi, old comment
I hate it when I am just minding my own business and next thing I know I'm being sucked through space and time in a symbolic journey.
Suddenly I'm thrown into the sun and learn I'm the one who caused the big bang and created all of existence.
Don't you just hate it when that happens?
I love the name XD this comment made my day.
Justice Nugget it's a daily routine for me
Justice Nugget omg ikr
Yeah but first im sucked into a carrot and thrown through the earth and then suddenly im in space and leared i created the Multiverse.
Justice Nugget ugh tell me bout it 😑
“You try your best but it’s not quite there”
She likes gardening, but her plants won’t grow. Hinting at the name of the song.
“A rumor that’s not quite as it seems”
It DOES grow.
“Keep your friends close they’re what drive you to the cosmos that describes you”
With the power of FRIE- once again pointing at the “beyond her GARDEN”, she is sent into a multiverse based off fruits and veggies. Because “the cosmos that describes you” for the third time pokes carrot top likes gardening in our eyes.
DEEP
People think it’s so deep even though it’s legit just a song about gardens
I loved the animation, and her expressions were hilarious!
James: Thanks for letting me use this song Wooden Toaster
Wooden Toaster: *copyright strikes the video*
Wait, that actually happened?
@@thegoldenbrickstoneI don’t know the specifics but I figure it was not a strike made by WT, rather the automated system recognizing the song and flagging the video once WT had the song uploaded to stuff like RUclips musics library. it’s been eleven years so it wouldn’t surprise me if the system changed and ended up flagging this video even if it had the original song creators permissions.
I remember this back in the early fandom.
The nostalgia is real, bros
Oh god... Many years have passed.
I just saw brony polka in my reccomend and I realized how good this song actually is.
It gives me my childchood vibes
Same over here
okay, either i think i know the meaning of this song, or its just too early and im thinking too much.
so we start off with Carrot Top, a beloved mare who obviously loves gardening. she's trying her best to make her garden grow to at least be a decent garden, but nothings happening. notice how in the animation, shes been focusing a lot on her garden. all day and all night, all she really does is focus on her garden.
the title of this song is "beyond her garden," and the chorus of this song says "Carrot Top, go beyond us." i could be entirely wrong, but maybe this aludes to the garden telling her to stop focusing on the garden and to go off and try new things, or else the garden's never going to grow.
i'm sorry, this song came out over 7 years ago but i couldn't help but notice the amount of people wondering what the song was about and i got curious too.
I find it odd that her hair is fluttering while in space, despite their being no air, yet upon reentry it is completely still.
Meh... the only answer is... MAGIC
Kelley McCarron or maybe its just BREAKING PHYSC.
Physics don't work on acid trips.
+gman197002 its called dream magic
+gman197002 Isn't she being flung at insane speeds though
It's time to play: what is carrot top on this time?!
I think either crack or meth
SHES ON CRACK
+Lps M&M's no shes high on carrots or something. An I think it's crack too
Salt
All drugs
I WAS SO YOUNG WHEN I SAW THIS OMG..... I FEEL MY YOUTH... JUST A PINCH....
Same dude :(
Thank you for bringing me back here RUclips algorithm.
This reminds me so much of summer break in middle school when I used to fall asleep with this on loop.
This what I miss about seeing these AMAZING animations I wish he would continue them I love these so much
people say that nostalgia is in two years later, and I'm here in seven yearsl later
Lmao but cry :(
Eight years, bro...
Man I miss the 2010s it was just a golden time
Damn… this is a piece of internet history
This song is.... Very hitting and nostalgic and very.... memorable
This song is Grade A masterpiece!
Prove with all of my heart. 🌌
Man I Miss the good ol'days
I really miss this, loved this era. Goodbye :]
keep your credit score that will drive you into the cosmos that describe you? did anyone else hear that in the bouncing on planets part?
I heard it
Supz it didn't say that
Yolanda Blackson highkey it did
I thought it was friends?
Now I cant unhear it
Ok, I swear I quit the mlp fandom about when season 4 started rolling out, but today this song ravaged my mind and I couldn't remember where it was from until I remembered the beat dropping and carrot top being flung through space, so here I am. This is like visiting family that you hated but now missed.
AAAAAAAAAUGGGGHHH THE NOSTALGIA HURTS MEEEEEE!!!!
I love this and is it just me who would love to have a dream similar to this one in the video ?
Thanks it's a comfort to know I am not the only one :)
Already have c:
lucky =D
theflutterpony123 Steps:
1) Watch when you decide to go to bed
2) Sleep and think about this.Replace Carrot Top with you
3) :) Your Welcome.
i may just try that ... =)
the memories of this video... oh my god.
IKR!
i miss the nostalgia of 2014 she was one of my fav background ponies too
You try your best but it's not quite there
You kick your hoof and say "It's just not fair"
A simple mare living simple dreams
A rumor there not quite as it seems
You try your best but it's not quite there
You kick your hoof and say "It's just not fair"
A simple mare living simple dreams
A rumor there not quite as it seems
Carrot Top, go beyond us
You're a late start, time to fool us
Keep your friends close, they will drive you
To the cosmos, that describes you
Carrot Top, go beyond us
You're a late start, time to fool us
Keep your friends close, they will drive you
To the cosmos, that describes you
Brighter than tonight's sunsets
Can't mistake the silhouettes
Not a sound or a voice nearby
Your mane illuminates this gloomy sky
Carrot Top, go beyond us
You're a late start, time to fool us
Keep your friends close, they will drive you
To the cosmos, that describes you
Carrot Top, go beyond us
You're a late start, time to fool us
Keep your friends close, they will drive you
To the cosmos, that describes you
Please ignore my previous comment about me not liking the song :P
It's so great that you get to work with awesome you tubers like WoodenToaster!
Hard to believe 2013 was 7 years ago... :c
ME NEITHER :C
8...
I miss everything about this video.
I love that animation style, I hate when they look too perfect, I love mistakes in a video, it gives it more texture and imagination in my opinion. I love the little bits of mistakes scattered around the video, it kept me watching it.
I MISS THIS ERA SM
I miss this channel
Man the old old days.
I miss this channel ):
Very nostalgic, even though I'm still young!!
9 YEAR OLD ME VIBED SO HARD TO THIS AND 14 YEAR OLD ME STILL VIBES TO IT
Same 🥺
Much better than these "serious" PMVs.
Has it's own charm ..... good work.
Just a great video. Simple but emotive animation, great synching with the song, and memorable story. Also you put in a lot of humor and captured the spirit of the show. This is one of the best pony videos on youtube, top 20 at least.
the 2020 comment you were looking for.
Yes 🥺
I love this song and this video only stands to do it justice. Nice work.
I almost forgot how much I love this,
2:02 Plot twist: Derpy ate the seeds
I'm so nostalgic for the early 2010s brony fandom, even though I wasn't a part of it then
Faster than a speeding carrot
Awesome love the song, love the video, I actually never really knew who Carrot Top was untill this video
Still amazing til this day
I loved the way you animated the cosmos I'm a brony and I love and the way you expressed it
WoondenToaster. Nice.
I watch this video every day to boost my spirits!!!
Kids, don’t do drugs unless you want to end up as a trippen ginger pony riding a carrot
I feel like I just had a bad trip, but I love it
Wow I didn't know animatedjames animated this! Holy crap no wonder it's so brilliant and inspiring Woodentoaster, and animatedjames well done bravo bravo
This needs more views! One of thr best songs in existence!
3rd grade.. used to bump this everyday
The animation felt SO right with the song.
I think i'm trippin man
Ego Freindly XD
im trippin as well
TRIPPY
wow this is memories (2020)
Indeed it is 🥺
Wow. So anyone else wondering how she's still alive? No helmet and zooms through the atmosphere without burning.
Must say, I love this animation! And I don't comment often under youtube videos, let alone ones over half a decade old.
Aaaaa I miss these days of mlp
I don’t know why but I laughed so hard at this when I was little
i have this in a folder with my favorite songs and the folder is more than 5 years old and this came up when i shuffled... oh the memories... this is still a banger tho
Indeed my Guy! A Banger indeed...so many memories are connected to this song...good times.
Ah, sweet nostalgia. I love this video
I'm years late but this is such good work ♥️ it fits the music so well
I absolutely love the anamation in this video and its AWESOME!!!!!!!
This is why you dont do drugs kids.
XD
doodlerful ikr!
it's a dream.
What if they want that to happen🌚
h
Wherever you are James, I hope you're doing well
Unfortunately he has discontinued is content :(
Soy la única que de pequeña veía esto en inglés y no entendia pero me encantaba demasiado, muy buen trabajo amigo!
Concuerdo contigo
Space core: SPAAAACEEEEE!
Edit: Ahh! The Portal series! THE VALVE CAN'T COUNT TO 3!
This takes me back ;-;
one of my OCs could survive in space, as well as re-entering the atmosphere. the thing is, he is a vampire. but instead of drinking blood, he drains small ammounts of magic from other ponies. he also loses all his powers during the day, so yeah.
so, as long as he leaves the atmosphere during the night, he stays in his vampir form, since in space, there is no day or night. he also doesnt need to breathe as vampire and has a low body temperature, so he wont suffocate nor freeze. and the re-entering the atmosphere thing is pretty nice actually: he has an adaptive healing factor, which heals him based on how bad the injury is. small injuries heal slower than big ones, and he even talked to a bunch of vampire ponies during training, while he was burnt by a dragon. the dragon didnt really burn him, since he recovered as fast as he got burnt, but u know what i mean. :)
nostalgia. brony days were lit.
It is still brony days
@@West-rk7dz everyone is gone.
@@siggym1992 not true. Only some
Sooo, I shouldn't be eating this carrot right now?
BUT ITS SOOOOOOOOOOO TASTY!
Damn it’s been two years already
I'm glad humanity was created and I am living in the decade when I can watch it
Spaaaaaaaacee.
# CarrotTopBestCore
Ponies that talk, use magic, fly, control weather, I'm very sorry but we don't need your logic.
IM A DRAGON FROM MINECRAFT WHO WATCHES MLP I DONT NEED YOUR LOGIC OR REASONS OR ANYTHING!!! ahem. thank you vary much *Sips tea*
Space does not exist that is a fact..........spear
Space. Space?
I'll keep this comment here as a memory, because this is the first time I came across this video.
ur animations are so damn good!
WATCH YOUR MOUTH anyways that song was wack the same words ugh😒😒😒😒😒😒😒😒
The cupcakes Lol they didn't use a bad word for some people they consider it bad but for some people not you don't need to use that tone !
The cupcakes Lol
This is RUclips, kid.
People cuss, GET USED TO IT.
I hate fucking kids like these...
ViviXD why thank you :>
TheTruHudson np
*this hit me with the biggest nostalgia*
BEST SONG EVER!!! Plus very good animation btw!
omg this would be AWESOME if it happened in real life
I was thinking about this but I forgot what it was called so I searched up mlp carrot top song.
This is nostalgic
It's so simple, but sooooo gooood!
This would really good music for a roller coaster
My God, I remember when I was a little girl and I used to go to RUclips to get a bit on the internet and watch this kind of videos.
These things are my whole childhood.
My Bass and windows are just Borken xD
borken? whats borken?
My Window :P
My Bass was to loud...
i Love this Beat...
nico justfun i see what you did there
***** Mac as good accept for a ok antivirus. Windows is better for recording, more DL options for videoGames and Better looking. And FL Studios for windows :).
not the pc-system the house windows xD
I listen to this at least once a day! Soo many feels...my friend is currently dying. He has 2 weeks and this song makes me so emotional...I start crying...
EPIC MUSIC! :D
This is honestly my favorite beyond her garden animation.
Am I the only one living in the future?
I freaking love this soo much! More more! The music brings me back
2022 anyone?
I love how you animate!