Tannoy Gold 5 vs Adam Audio T5V || Sound, Distortion & Frequency Response Comparison
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- Tannoy Gold 5 on bhphotovideo: bhpho.to/2ApBIf7
Adam T5V on amazon DE: amzn.to/3aNOd0c
Adam T5V on amazon UK: amzn.to/3b0NNDX
Adam T5V on bhphotovideo: bhpho.to/2NtvWub
------------------------------
Follow me on:
Instagram - / digitalstereophony
Facebook - / digitalstereophony
-----------------------------
Contact me at:
digitalstereophony@gmail.com
----------------------------
All the tracks used in this video can be found here:
• Test Tracks
----------------------------
-Sound recorded using pair of SE Electronics SE8 mics and Zoom H6 recorder
-Frequency measurements done in semi treated room using UMIK-1 microphone
-Levels matched using SPL meter
-All tone controls set to neutral
> 11:53 < Detailed Frequency Response & Distortion Graphs
Instagram - instagram.com/digitalstereophony/
Facebook - facebook.com/DigitalStereophony/
Funny how i always recognize adam now, even with different headphones or speakers, eyes closed etc. Thank you for all t5v comparisons, you helped me a lot to make my choice 🙏
I like how the Tannoy's interpret the high range, its not too bright or harsh
I have just grabbed the tannoys and I must say that the videos don't do them enough justice. I used these videos to help choose which monitors I would consider. Once I heard them in real life it was like WOAH. If something sounds veiled on the Tannoys it's because the sound itself is veiled. The Tannoys have lots of high end, a very well rounded and pronounced mid range, and when placed properly a bunch of good clean bass. If a song is made correctly it sounds amazing. I use mine approximately 50 inches from each ear sitting appx 2 inches below ear height when seated in an untreated room that has furniture in it. I don't hear any weird reflections. They do get quite loud but they aren't meant for super loud listening. They sound great even when being overdriven but it's not something I like doing to a speaker. When I put them on stands I lost some of the bass that was resonating from my desk. It's there but it seems to get trapped behind the speakers mostly. That is something I'll have to work on. Don't hesitate to grab Tannoy Gold 5s for near field monitoring. These translate very well in my opinion.
How's the bass?
@@conraddevera4786 when I had them on my desk (solid oak ) it was beautiful. I have them on stands now and it got lost a bit, but it's probably my room setup. I can hear the bass outside of the room. If you grab these and the bass is lacking try different positionings. 👍
So glad I got the Tannoys today.. they recommended to me by the salesman, wanted the Eris 3.5s but they let me hear them and was sold
hello, do you have good mix results with the gold 5 ?
Eris is 100$, these Tannoy's, a pair is 450$ 😅
I love the contents of this channel. But I wish you could add a simple test on the noise level of the powered speakers, since hissing is a common problem of a lot of powered speakers (and they are intended to be used near field).
Nice suggestion!
Tannoy Gold 5 vs Fluid Audio FX50 would be a great comparison for a future video! :D
Yes! I'm looking forward to this comparison, too. After tons of reviews, the Tannoy Gold 5 are my favorite, but the FX50 could also be interesting.
and vs RCF Ayra Pro 5, as they advertised as "the AYRA PRO is the first Studio Monitor in its class to boast an outstanding 0° phase response." which is what coaxial design supposed to do if i understand it correctly.
Came back to this video after buying T7V's and I feel that the Tannoys have a muffled highend compared to the Adam's. That said the sound of the T7V's is fantastic. Especially coming from KRK 5's. But they could really use a subwoofer for that DEEP trap 808 bass. Bass is still great though.
you have to distinguish between the real sound of the adams and what you hear through that stereo pair of microphones, which can seriously color the sound of the sound source.
The Adams don't have any problems with HF, it's a well-known fact that the Adams' HF are their forte.
I'm surprised how close the Tannoys are to the original. I own Adam Audio F7s. But this comparison is really interesting....and might force me to reconsider.
you have to distinguish between the real sound of the adams and what you hear through that stereo pair of microphones, which can seriously color the sound of the sound source.
The Adams don't have any problems with HF, it's a well-known fact that the Adams' HF are their forte.
Adam the highs are accentuated, not conducive for the ears. The ribbon tweeters are nice but should be padded down a few dBs.
you have to distinguish between the real sound of the adams and what you hear through that stereo pair of microphones, which can seriously color the sound of the sound source.
The Adams don't have any problems with HF, it's a well-known fact that the Adams' HF are their forte.
Adam is more expressive but it seems to be exaggerated. Tannoy's sound is more balanced so it depends who likes what.
Wow! After hearing these. Definitely a clear em for the Tannoys!
Listening to speaker comparisons via recordings that are played on RUclips off your own speakers or headphones is a largely useless exercise.
@@polger1739 that doesn't resolve the problem
you have to distinguish between the real sound of the adams and what you hear through that stereo pair of microphones, which can seriously color the sound of the sound source.
The Adams don't have any problems with HF, it's a well-known fact that the Adams' HF are their forte.
I would prefer the Adam’s as a party speaker rather than a studio monitor. There’s more midrange detail in the Tannoy. Comes across in the vocal tracks.
That is a clear win for the Adam T5V.
They have more Punch in the Bass Department that also seems to be more stiff and kicking, while the Tannoy sound slightly wobbely there.
And from the low mids and especially the highs, they are just more clean and thorough, more detailed, brighter with less and less harsh drops from 5khz and especially at over 10khz.
Sometimes they come over alittle to sharp, but that is still better than the sometimes a little hollow or muffled sounding Tannoy's.
Only the bigger drop at around 500Hz is a loss for the Adam's, as this can be clearly heard when male Voices are to be heard, as they come more forward on the Tannoy's.
What one looks for when buying a studio monitor is for its frequency range to be as flat as possible. Tannoy succeeds.
Adam has slight treble enhancements.
Занятно, что при большей неровности графика, Таннои звучат ближе к оригиналу по большей части, особенно на верхах, где у Адамов чувствуется преобладание верхов.
you have to distinguish between the real sound of the adams and what you hear through that stereo pair of microphones, which can seriously color the sound of the sound source.
The Adams don't have any problems with HF, it's a well-known fact that the Adams' HF are their forte.
I'm going to put it to you digital Stereophony which one do you prefer!! considering you're listening to both, you cannot tell from sound clips on RUclips.
If possible give us a description on what you like and dislike about both thanks a lot.
Thanks for all the work man!! Appreciated. Tannoy for me, all the way. Less colouring in the high end
good mix results with tannoy ?
you have to distinguish between the real sound of the adams and what you hear through that stereo pair of microphones, which can seriously color the sound of the sound source.
The Adams don't have any problems with HF, it's a well-known fact that the Adams' HF are their forte.
What Tannoy lacks to be perfect is a super tweeter.
Tannoy gold series don't lack a tweeter. The tweeter is centered in the bass driver.
you have to distinguish between the real sound of the adams and what you hear through that stereo pair of microphones, which can seriously color the sound of the sound source.
The Adams don't have any problems with HF, it's a well-known fact that the Adams' HF are their forte.
I think the Adams are likely to be the best choice. In any case, you should mix tracks using commercial reference tracks for greater accuracy.
I’ll also add on my own that it’s very pleasant to just listen to music on Adams, which expands their application.
I can’t say anything about the Tannoys, because I haven’t heard them live
by just seeing the frequency response i will choose tannoys.
I have tannoy gold 7 whilst i liked them at first i was'nt to sure that i had made the right decision after a while but then i bought sonarworks reference 4 with the mic to eq them and it blew my mind how much better they sounded after (60 hz and like 100 hz it eq'd them down by 6 db the tops wear surprisingly flat anyway)
Tannoy do sound suppressed on the high end or muffled. But at 4:48 I prefer the sound from the tannoy as the adam makes the track sound harsh. Overall Adam wins. Design of the tannoy very nice.
they are both good sounding monitors, my only issue with this comparison is that the tannoys have the front bass ports, so it sounded richer in the lows than the adams... but hey, i could be wrong ;)
6:15 I don't like the look of Adam audio, but it plays much better here. More space, violins really sound like violins, dynamics, better separated instruments.
Unfortunately I cannot demo any of these speakers and I am on the fence between the two. Which of the two would be recommended for flat response, depth and sound stage? It seems like Tannoy's are closer to the original sound track than adams but just curious on depth and sound stage as well. Any help or comments would be greatly appreciated.
you have to distinguish between the real sound of the adams and what you hear through that stereo pair of microphones, which can seriously color the sound of the sound source.
The Adams don't have any problems with HF, it's a well-known fact that the Adams' HF are their forte.
I need speakers for entertainment . t5v is better for me . they are crystal clear while gold5 sound Thank you for comparisons, helps a lot.
Подскажи, не устаешь от прослушивания t5v? У меня edifier r 2800, напрягают немного, хочется больше детализации
My favourites for now are Adam T5V, Mackie 524 and iLoud Micro. I like compact size of iLoud, sound of 524`s (a bit more balanced to my ears) and looks of T5V. Pricewise they are close (T5V $30 more) Tough decision to be made...))
is because you havent seen the Presonus in this videos....
@@opamusic9457 Agree, Presonus E5 are very solid sounding ones. Much flatter then T5V or 524, but still keep energy in sound (not boring like HS5). And they have front diffuser placement which is an advantage for me. But... I can`t explain why I don`t want them...)
Павел, мне тоже очень нравятся Маки и Адамы, никак не могу определиться. Во всех тестах предпочтение отдаю более легкому, чистому, сбалансированному звучанию. Очень режит слух зажатость, пластиковость, бочковитость звучания. Послушать Маки вживую не имею возможности, скажите пожалуйста, у вас была такая возможность?
Let me make it easier. The iLouds have very harsh high frequencies. Very fatiguing, sibilant, ear piercing. I returned them.
the ilouds also a have noise problem. Within the surprisingly loud white noise there is a high-pitched sound (I generally have pretty sensitive ears. but I also found the issue mentioned in many discussion forums on the internet)
thanks for the vid!
Both speakers bang for the price, its all about the taste here. Still it's better to listen to em irl before making a choice. More than sure that half of the people who prefered tannoys would go for adams :D
Good as always; i'm looking for a speaker that i'll use for casual listening and as monitor for my Dj booth (no production o mastering/mixing, only djing). I was thinking to Adam T5V/T7V - but in this video the Gold5 seems more pleasant and maybe useful to my needs. Am i wrong? (I know that also JBL 305Mk2 are very good for my needs, but they are estetically ugly to me).
Honestly if you are using it for work at all aesthetics should take a back seat.
@@theenhancer I'll use not for work (as said) , but for listening music in my living, where i have my dj booth , so aesthetic means to me.
@@WolfgangMilesVega Then it will likely come down to price. I know the T5Vs cost double what the LSR305s do where I live.
@@theenhancer here Adam and Tannoy are 159€, JBL 119€, not a great difference.
I currently have the Edifiers R1280T. How much of an upgrade would the Tannoy Gold 5 would be? Or would that just be a cosmetic upgrade?
A lot of an upgrade
@@DSAUDIOreview ok, I ended up ordering the Adam T5V instead, the gold stuff and the ugly knobs started looked cheap. I guess they sound so similar that they will still be a significant upgrade :)
@@codehustler ´for producing/mixing ans so stuff is the adam way better, this up and down from tannoy on the highs, 4db up, 5db down,5 db up, 5db down, on 2-3khz 5 db up and down i dont know, looks more like a hifi speaker. Sometimes switch der Sound from Tannoy to strong, Metal Track for Example. And after 15khz go the sound straight down,
@@jenshuxley it's true .... i am trying the tannoy here ..... the sound is good ! but yeah, it's not very flat ......
Tannoy definitely!
Please fluid audio fx50 vs tannoy gold 5
More faithful to the original Tannoy sound.
you have to distinguish between the real sound of the adams and what you hear through that stereo pair of microphones, which can seriously color the sound of the sound source.
The Adams don't have any problems with HF, it's a well-known fact that the Adams' HF are their forte.
Gold 5
can the tannoy 5 be used to mix music on a terrace as a dj?
Adam Audio T5V
Tannoy Gold 5 - WIN!
Adam Audio T5V👍
They sound like night and day. The T5V sounds overly bright and the Gold 5 sounds hollow on some types of samples. The Gold 5 has wider soundstage.
Agree. But TV5 much more open.
you have to distinguish between the real sound of the adams and what you hear through that stereo pair of microphones, which can seriously color the sound of the sound source.
The Adams don't have any problems with HF, it's a well-known fact that the Adams' HF are their forte.
Adam T5V wins. I wonder whether Kali LP-6 is better or Tannoy Gold 5. They are both about the same price over here.
Over here, over there, over ear, over dare, over and over........On sale right now in Agartha!
탄노이는 그 가격대 스피커 답게 중음역대가 좀 떡져서 분리도가 떨어지고, 고음의 양감은 적당하지만 스테레오 필드가 아담보단 좁고 베이스기타 소리 들어보면 낮은 60Hz 대역이 조금 강세를 띔. 좀 더 낮은 가격대에서 정말 좋은 모습을 보여주는 JBL의 305P MKII 보단 나아보일 수 있으나 실은 전체적인 성능은 딱 이 가격대 스피커.
아담은 고역이 너무 강세를 띄지만 그만큼 스테레오 필드는 넓고 저음의 양감은 딱 적당하지만 중음 표현력은 좀 떨어지는 편. 하지만 그에 비하면 악기 하나하나 마다의 음역대 분리도가 가격대비 정말 뛰어남. 정말 이거 하나만으로도 가격대 이상의 값어치가 있음.
thus for you who win here ........ T5V or Gold 5 ?
@@ChrisBessy I think he prefer T5v sound. I've actually used both speakers. and They are all good speakers. But I prefer "Tannoy gold" which has not too much highs and a good midrange.
*so which one?
Tannoy gold is more balanced, an audiophile monitor
At first, they seemed similar to me. But as the video went on and i became more concentrated on what i was hearing , Adam´s emerged as the clear winners. I don´t know if the fact that i´m hearing this in my T5V´s had some influence, though... :)
Can you compare KRK Rokit RP 10-3 G4?
People on bass music, you feel me about theses t5v
TANNOY GOLD vs AVANTONE CLA10 부탁합니다 ^^
제가 이 두가지의 스피커를 전부 구매할 예정 입니다 ^^
그래서 꼭 이 두가지 스피커의 비교를 부탁합니다 ^^
간절히 원하고 있습니다 ㅠ..ㅠ
제발 부탁합니다 ㅠ..ㅠ
완전히 둘다 다른 성향이에요
ADAM wins for ears and eyes !!!
Good music~ and Good speaker~ adam t5v
Can you please feature the JBL nano k4 ! I mean like not a single person is talking about that monitors ! Idk why !?
These are not available in Europe
I know why (after having looked them up). The design on these are absolutley terrible. An abomination if I ever saw one. If you'd put these on the shelves in Europe they would be laughed out of the store!
Can the Adam audios be used as a bookshelf/room speakers?
(Room size is 10ft by 15ft)
Sure they can, especially if you like speakers leaning to the bright side of neutral. Just give them some space from the wall behind them, they need it to sound right in the bass department
@@DSAUDIOreview on there website it's stated as near field monitors and my listening position is around 8 feet away from the speaker, hence the confusion thanks 👍
8 feet should not be a problem
@@DSAUDIOreview thanks mate 👊, I guess my search is finally over lastly would recommend something else that outperforms the Adam's in the same price range but most likely going for the Adam's because of the ribbon tweeters!!
@@DSAUDIOreview Do you think the T7v would be too much for a room like this (3x5m) ? or they (the 7) could sound more balanced than 5 in "hifi mode"?
Adam Audio by far. Surprised anyone is choosing the Tannoys.
Depends on what you are trying to hear.
Adam has piercing highs. Tannoy veiled
Yeah, I concur! Adam is too much this, and Tannoy is too much that!!!
you have to distinguish between the real sound of the adams and what you hear through that stereo pair of microphones, which can seriously color the sound of the sound source.
The Adams don't have any problems with HF, it's a well-known fact that the Adams' HF are their forte.
@@Pavelkozhin Maybe. Human ears are not mics. And the outer part of the ear is also relevant
Адам +
Tannoys bass is loose and undefined. Kickbass is also too slow. The Adams can actually produce clearly different bassnotes instead of one hollow and slowbass-hump. The Adams tweeter is just too much, but I'm not a fan of ribbons. Combine the strengths of both and you have a winner.
tannoy!
Tannoy has more accurate highs, less accurate bass.
Adam win on metal track
Yikes, i thought they were ultra harsh on the metal track.
탄노이가 좀더 어두운 느낌
no ... adam here is too bright lol .....
I thought this was going to be a talking review.
Tannoy always the first...
Адам очевидно лучше.