Sunak never got voted in by the public. Its an archaic system that dates back to medieval times. Jobs for the boys ' families. Refresh the whole system. Save billions.
@@timonsolus, it depends what the lie is about. In another professions if you lie about important things then it would usually of often come under fraud. For example, lying about finances. Also, what one Member of Parliament or at least frontbencher MP does affects the whole country unlike most other individual workers. So it matters more than ever that politicians are held to account and face severe consequences for lying.
Every day it seems Mr Speaker has to rebuke the government for contempt of the House. How long do we all have to wait until we can vote this shower out?
@heathermoore9892 No he isn’t, he’s independent and elected by the House. He wouldn’t be Speaker if Tory MPs hadn’t voted for him to be Speaker, and they wouldn’t have voted for him if they didn’t have confidence in him
@@phantomhorse8255 Tory party is the vile party, the partygate party, the swim in sewage party, the corruption party, the inept party, the destroy the NHS party, con the public over Brexit party, the shower of Bs party.
Its got to this point because Hoyle has let things slide from minor abuses in the house to increasingly abusive & dishonesty lies. Like an old ineffectual teacher who should have retired years ago. Or should not have been employed in the first place. Bring back Betty Bothroyd.
@markfizz2012 good riddance, one more of the parasites in the ground. None of them are better than any other even going back to WW2 days. A bunch of leeches out to enrich themselves.
The British political system needs to be completely dismantled and started again from scratch, all of these politicians need to be sacked and held accountable for their actions
@@alimetodista3459 in reality the conservative government should be abolished by LAW dismantled and made an illegal organisation to join punishable by a mandatory 20 years in prison and i am being very serious in saying this they have done too much damage to the UK People
Here’s the truth. The whole political system in the UK is a mess. Politicians on all sides have lost sight of why they are there and spend too much time either trying to make headlines to stay in power, trying to smear the opposition to get in power or pursuing personal agendas. It’s a complete mess. What’s worse is we the general public appear to have convinced ourselves that a change in government is the answer. It will make no difference, it may make it worse. Wholesale change is needed
You speak the truth. Split both Labour and the Conservatives into 2 parties (Labour seems to be doing this itself). Both parties are too big and are all over the place with their agendas.
It is worse than that. You hear this debate put forward on question time wherever politician should take second jobs (multiple Jobs) often with various/multiple lobbying groups set up by large corporates paying politicians and pushing there own interests which is undemocratic. There is no debate it is a form of bribary and corruption at the heart of government. Even if it was not a form corruption dressed as secondary jobs how can politicians work through the UK problems if there head is always on the swival never on government business. There is also gift being received.
THATS the end game of being a “democracy”. Where any village idiot can vote, and usually does…. NOT a an intelligent way to run anything, let alone a country.
Whether in the House, committee or constituency business, they ought to clock their hours like many other professionals ( solicitors,consutlants) and be paid prorated on their annual salary. Though when the House of Lords and European Parliament pay by the day,some sign 8n then disappear,but it gets noticed when now it doesn't for MPs.
@@csharpe5787 Thinking thoughts is now a crime? Being an ex public schoolboy is now a crime? Feeling entitled is now a crime? (If it is there are about 200 Labour MPs who fit that bill) OK I get it that you hate Tories albeit for class hate reasons. So vote Labour ... 😏
@@chrysalis4126 You mean lying and misleading like there being WMDs in Iraq, Doctors waiting lists being made better for everyone by just removing the ability to book anything other than the day you are ill, University students being better off by making them pay tens of thousands of pounds in fees, Anti-sematism not existing, 10,000 new police officers only costing £30 each a year ?? There hasn't been a Labour government that has given us a secure, fair and just society regardless of how they want to dress it up. I'm no Tory fan, but right now if you are saying that other parties are above lying and misleading you are sorely mistaken.
Lindsay Hoyle needs to grow a pair. He always shouts and threatens but never carries out any of his threats. It probably took MPs less than a week to realise that they can do or say anything they want to with fear or favour.
The most ineffectual Speaker in recent memory. He can 'call out' Rishi and his government all he wants, as long as he does nothing about it, they'll continue to get away with their casual disrespect towards everyone.
You are an absolute monkey. He can't do anything. He enforces the rules of the House. Ministerial Code has nothing to do with the House of Commons nor is it enforced by them.
@@Station9.75 He should be forcing them to answer questions. Kicking them out of the chamber when they don't and fining them for contempt of parliament.
The American Congress should have a good look at how Lindsay Hoyle or any other previous Speaker runs the House. Nobody is above the rules of Parliament not even the PM
and yet still the govt ignore him and nothing happens, they have learned there are no consequences and will allow this situation to persist up till a couple of months before the election when they will bring in actual enforceable rules which they hope will apply to the future incumbents.
The whole place needs a clear out. Out of touch, out of bounds and seemingly beyond their own rules. And Torys are the worst of the lot. They act like it’s a children’s playground and show about as much respect. But then what do we expect from a party that cheated and lied its way to this position. And half the time the PM can’t be bothered to turn up. Sometimes I wish John Bercow hadn’t retired. Would love to see him tear Rishi a new one.
If the government is called out about the figures or the language that they use in parliament, they should declare where they get their figures and conclusions from promptly. I realise it is against protocol to call another MP a liar, but the government's constant delays in correcting the record (which would be an admission that they have, at the very least, been economical with the truth) do so in the hope that voters will have forgotten about it by the time they get around to doing it. And of course, it works.
I’m glad that the speaker has called out the government, but I think in terms of “do your job” & “show some respect”, I think he needs to look in the mirror
The PM don't have to show up in parliament, he don't have to reply on questions from its members and he can lie as he pleases, because there are no consequences. Conclusion: parliament in the UK isn't function as it should. I always wonder why the opposition is still present every day.
You were doing so well until you suggested the PM can lie as he chooses. He cannot. As Johnson found out. But actually you were right. The PM does not have to attend Parliament at all. There is no rule or convention for it. Of course he does attend but there is no obligation as he is the King's First Lord of the Treasury and is not appointed by the House.
@1chish He can though. Johnson only got found out because politicians turned on him for their own personal reasons (ie Rishi told them to and he’d give them a cushy job). Johnson was speculated to have lied on his first day on the job and was a liar before being hired. He was allowed to continue lying for a very long time.
@@jaybee4288 Sorry A PM< simply cannot lie. You pretty much exaggerated to make a point using 'speculation'. Fair enough I guess but the proof you cannot do as you please is Johnson himself. You make totally unfounded lies about Sunak yourself so maybe don't lecture others?
@andyhemmings7363 "These children" are representative of the society generally. They behave, in all their mannerisms and beliefs, in precisely the same way and proportion to the rest of our society. As the years go by, it seems we become worse and worse. ☹ I feel like gong into the mountains and living like a hermit - not that that would solve any of the problems. We're all in a very bad place.
I would try this if I was Speaker. .if the ministers aren't prepared to do the right thing, go to Charles and tell him directly that we have an impasse in Westminster do something about it.
Billionaire Charlie is too frit to intervene lest his phoney non-job gets removed. He does not care one jot for the electorate, or parliament. He only does what helps himself.
We actually need a new speaker of the house this government is getting away with to much. They disrespect parliament and the press get notice before the parliament sometimes with no over sight taken place. It's time this government was brought to the house and read the act of parliament. It's time this government just go before they reck the country totally.
The rules are outdated. The code is more of a set of strict standards that if not followed aren't met with any repercussions. The only way to ensure this doesn't continue to happen is if the code is changed. It is a disciplinary act for most businesses and can event lead to gross misconduct so why is it different for parliament. They are our representatives, they are there to represent their constituents and do the job we expect them to do.
Stop giving Politicians highly inflated wages and perks and let's see how many stop in the job before they all march off to get a job on a till in Aldi... it must be the cushiest job in the UK..
Sunak is a sociopath who's happy to spend billions of pounds on planes, trains (white elephant), ships, barges - but absolutely nothing on 'people' - (unless they are already super rich!)
@Don-ym8cm They (the politicians) behave, in all their mannerisms and beliefs, in precisely the same way and proportion to the rest of our society. They are representative of it - with all its flaws. As the years go by, it seems we become worse and worse. ☹ I feel like gong into the mountains and living like a hermit - not that that would solve any of the problems. We're all in a very bad place. Show less
The House of Commons always seems to be in recess at the most awkward times of the year. Government has proven that they never want to do any work, leaving it all for other people to do it for them and that includes other political parties
The shambles and shame of British parliamentary politics clearly shows it's not about serving the British people, despite those people paying their wages and pensions. It is more and more about a thirst for power and control at any cost. So, is this what the public want or is it the desire and plan of powerful and influential individuals and their organisations behind the politics? Hopefully, one day the British public will wake up and smell the coffee and unite for a better future for all, rather than just perpetually maintaining the huge divide in wealth and opportunities that exit in Britain.
@theondebray Don't support him but his family had to pull themselves up by their bootstraps when they came over to this Country Perhaps some if the whingers etc could do some hard work and get to the same position
The Speaker would do well to actually get Sunak to ANSWER questions at PMQ, rather than just letting him smirk and chuck the ball back to Starmer. I don’t give a monkeys about who voted on what bill; I want to know what the Tories are actually DOING about this collapsed democracy and abysmal 3rd world conditions we’re all living in.
Profiting mostly. Just look at the Teeside Freeport investigation the Tories are blocking (yes the government is blocking another government investigation into government corruption).
It's a pity that the speaker can't declare a minister (no matter their level) unfit for office -based on the code of conduct for ministers, I for one would give the speaker that power. Shake things up some and get rid of that useless dead wood.
All that's needed is for the minister to be forced to correct the record if he has 'misspoken'. This could be done by the Speaker preventing the minister from speaking in Parliament at all, on any subject, until after he's corrected the record. Any time the minister tries to speak about anything else except correcting the record, he should be forced to leave the chamber for the rest of the day, escorted out by the Serjeant at Arms.
The code of conduct is a sick joke on the public. 1. Its non binding and as the HoC is above the law regarding how it polices itself the 'code' has no legal force 2. The ultimate arbiter of the code is the PM who decides if any complaint is to be investigated and if so then the PM solely chooses how any enquiry is run & by which person who is solely selected by the PM and with (non binding on the PM) terms of reference from the PM and the report goes only to the PM who can disregard the report in part or in total and who does not have to make any part public. 3. The PM can also change the code without reference to anybody else - Johnson did this.
@@epincion : Indeed. All proof that the UK is not a modern Western democracy. British democracy is a relic from the past, and not fit for purpose in the 21st Century. (Which also means that the UK should not be allowed to join the EU without root and branch political reform.)
But this government does not responsible or accountable for anything. There are plans, but there is actually no accountability for those plans....(HS2, New hospitals, Net zero, waiting lists, covid response the list is endless....)
Speaker Lindsay Hoyle calls out Rishi Sunak’s ‘disrespectful’ government This was never said. He never mentioned Rishi in regards to this statement, in it's actuality
@@samsowden So it would be fair for myself to also put words in anyone's mouth? This could be fun. Oh wait, oh dear, I could be prosecuted for slander, in that respect. Maybe I shouldn't an also, maybe they shouldn't either?
There are 3 others 1st Wales or Northern Ireland and Scotland all have their own government run their parts of KING CHARLES KINGDOM but that self elected pm wants to give NORTHERN IRELAND U.K AWAY to that rebel biden as he wants all BRITISH OUT OF HIS ISLAND not our country that has never left the UK we are BRITISH citizens but 3rd class as we live BASICALLY in the eu even though the DUP MANIFESTO STATED TO LEAVE CORRUPT eu yes the vote over here went against us BUT THE THOUSANDS OF SMALL FARMERS OF LESS THAN 100 ACRES WERE BEING PAID NOT TO FARM AS THE CORRUPT eu DIDN'T WANT FOODMOUNTIANS THEY COULD HAVE FED THE STARVING IN THE WORLD BUT NO DON'T FARM WE WILL PAY YOU MAY KEEP FEW SHEEP OR CHICKENS BUT NO BEEF CATTLE OR CROPS THEY PAID ALL FARMERS IN THE CORRUPT eu NOT TO FARM SO THEY DID NOT VOTE IN REFERENDUM BUT IN THE ELECTION THAT FOLLOWED THE DUP WON THE MOST SEATS THAT THEY EVER WON THUS ROMAN CATHOLICS HAD VOTED FOR THEM AS 72% IN THE 2011CENSUS STATED THAT THEY WISHED TO REMAIN BRITISH THAT IS 28%OFF BLACKMAILING OUR SELF ELECTED PM
The quality of MPs these days is so low on both sides . They are not in it to help the country , they just want the power . If they were all doing their jobs properly instead of bickering then the country would run far more smoothly .
When are the rules of parliament going to be reformed? The speaker is called them out so many times and yet they don't give a damn more members are parliament have been thrown out for calling ministers liars than minises have been thrown out for lying!!!!!!
I love the way they use the term, MISLEAD instead of LIED OR LIE. No difference between Labour and Conservatives anymore, and parliament is just a Theatre for these clown’s
The government would have been able to get nowhere near their current utter contempt for parliament and Britain had Hoyle not been so tolerant of their years of increasing contempt under May, Johnson and Truss. He swapped being the upholder of parliamentary standards for his desire to be rewarded with ermine.
The Tory party in it's current state is not fit for purpose. Two months ago MP Debbie Abrahams was distributing leaflets in my area on her own< she spoke at length with my neighbour and briefly with me, I was impressed with her integrity, I have have tried to engage my tory representatives by all methods , and have had no response, apathy in the ranks methinks!
Possibly until January 2025 - although I suspect autumn 2024 because the Tories' supporters are mostly elderly and they don't like going out to vote in the cold winter.
A feeble and ineffectual deputy headmaster having a rant about smokers behind the bike sheds. He finishes his speech and the smoker are already looking forward to lighting up at break time.
The ministerial code' has in recent years been raised and questioned as to whether those whom operate within the framework of "Parliament". There should be a judicial body who should oversee when and where the "ministerial code is deliberately violated" as it was during Boris Johnsons time in office during the Covid Lockdown. Having said no punishment by the Metropolitan Police was ever given. The question one needs to ask is the "Law" protecting and serving the Publics best interest and the obvious answer is clearly "No"
@@Anonymous-hz3zz Using the term "Right-Wingers" is very naive, it is almost as if you have been programmed to use it. Let me guess, you think it means Right wing = bad and racist, Left wing = Good and Moral ??
@@shootmcrunfast Far left/left-wing = pathetic Centre left/centre/centre right = OK Right wing = stupidity (more often than not) Far right = dangerous That's my way of seeing the political spectrum, you're welcome
The one that has been in court for threatening a journalist with a baseball bat, lying about driving and having a criminal brother she gave a govt job to Sure
If the people wanted that it would happen, if someone does not get voted into power and they seize power it is a dictatorship. This is the last thing you want, Socialism and Dictatorships (which usually happen under the guise of socialism) always end up with everyone worse off, especially those who have nothing to offer. Regardless of how you view the Tories, Labour were traditionally the party to offer the alternative you want. However, they no longer represent "normal society and council estates" and instead focus on niche and populist demographics. Literally no party represents the traditional British common person who are by a long way the most common demographic. If this is something you are serious about, maybe it is time to start a party that represents the people you want in power ???? It would be a refreshing shake up of politics.
Ive barely been following whats going on in Westminster (im in scotland so we have Humza Useless to worry about); i just came here because i love Hoyle's voice.
Perhaps if the speaker could occasionally get back to his constituency and resolve all the issues affecting Chorley in Lancashire !!! If the honourable gentleman remembers where it is ???
The job of being an MP involves more than sitting in the Chamber. They have constituency work to attend to, select committees to sit on, lobbyists to meet with, functions to attend in a professional capacity, and public visits to make on behalf of their briefs and their constituents. Their job is not to sit on the green benches all day every day
when will Ritchy WEF be discussing his apparent precog abilities regarding his investments in ModeRNA & the £172 billion worth of public sector contracts given to ‘INFOSYS’ ?
"If the Ministerial Code is not being adheared to, i really do think the rules need to be looked at again" So change the rules to fit. Sounds about right Bori- i mean Lindsay.
This government shows disrespect to parliament, members of the public and to the people who voted them in. The quicker they go the better
They should be sent to Rwanda or The Hague for their crimes against the British public.
Sunak never got voted in by the public. Its an archaic system that dates back to medieval times. Jobs for the boys ' families. Refresh the whole system. Save billions.
@@username5502 sending them to Rwanda legitimises their lunacy and sending them to the Hague belittles that institution by having them there.
@@TheAceFireChildWell that leaves no choice...I'll gather the kindling then.
Some of them, mainly the current primeminister, were never and would never be voted in, ironically.
'Becoming apparent'. Woah, well done for finally catching up Hoyle! They've been at it for years.
Decades
bercow had much less tolerance 😊
Mr Barraclough woke up
@@NeoFighterXand made it all about himself
Haha and his party? 😂
No consequences and the lying will continue. It needs to be a criminal offence to lie to the public if an MP.
Name any other profession in the UK in which lying is a criminal offence.
@@timonsolus All of them, if you lie about your tax returns.
@@SeeDeeSeanice 😂
@@timonsolus, it depends what the lie is about. In another professions if you lie about important things then it would usually of often come under fraud. For example, lying about finances. Also, what one Member of Parliament or at least frontbencher MP does affects the whole country unlike most other individual workers. So it matters more than ever that politicians are held to account and face severe consequences for lying.
@@timonsolusThat's easy the Police 😅
Every day it seems Mr Speaker has to rebuke the government for contempt of the House. How long do we all have to wait until we can vote this shower out?
@heathermoore9892 No he isn’t, he’s independent and elected by the House. He wouldn’t be Speaker if Tory MPs hadn’t voted for him to be Speaker, and they wouldn’t have voted for him if they didn’t have confidence in him
@@Matt-cz6ti Well the last Speaker was certainly not neutral! That vile Berkow
@@phantomhorse8255 Tory party is the vile party, the partygate party, the swim in sewage party, the corruption party, the inept party, the destroy the NHS party, con the public over Brexit party, the shower of Bs party.
@@Matt-cz6ti He's an MP for the Labour Party.
@@jrobs1133 *Was. The Speaker and their deputies forgo all party affiliation
It`s about time the govenment respected the wishes of the electorate,
What are the wishes of the electorate? Please sum them up without bias so that they can be respected.
Its got to this point because Hoyle has let things slide from minor abuses in the house to increasingly abusive & dishonesty lies. Like an old ineffectual teacher who should have retired years ago. Or should not have been employed in the first place. Bring back Betty Bothroyd.
Good luck with that, she died in February.
@@markfizz2012 Yes I know. 😥
I actually agree lol
Agreed. He's clearly shown bias with when he is/isn't strict as well.
@markfizz2012 good riddance, one more of the parasites in the ground. None of them are better than any other even going back to WW2 days. A bunch of leeches out to enrich themselves.
The British political system needs to be completely dismantled and started again from scratch, all of these politicians need to be sacked and held accountable for their actions
totally agree just like they do in france there being taken to court
Cromwell was last time, this time hopefully Farage.
This country needs a new ruling class, we should start with a group of working class centrists.
@@alimetodista3459 in reality the conservative government should be abolished by LAW dismantled and made an illegal organisation to join punishable by a mandatory 20 years in prison and i am being very serious in saying this they have done too much damage to the UK People
It's based upon trust - Johnson showed how weak that is
Sound and fury from Hoyle. But he will do nothing about it. And government ministers, including Sunak, know that.
Tories have made the Speakers job worthless.
Here’s the truth. The whole political system in the UK is a mess. Politicians on all sides have lost sight of why they are there and spend too much time either trying to make headlines to stay in power, trying to smear the opposition to get in power or pursuing personal agendas. It’s a complete mess. What’s worse is we the general public appear to have convinced ourselves that a change in government is the answer. It will make no difference, it may make it worse. Wholesale change is needed
You speak the truth. Split both Labour and the Conservatives into 2 parties (Labour seems to be doing this itself). Both parties are too big and are all over the place with their agendas.
So what do you propose we do about it?
100%
It is worse than that. You hear this debate put forward on question time wherever politician should take second jobs (multiple Jobs) often with various/multiple lobbying groups set up by large corporates paying politicians and pushing there own interests which is undemocratic. There is no debate it is a form of bribary and corruption at the heart of government. Even if it was not a form corruption dressed as secondary jobs how can politicians work through the UK problems if there head is always on the swival never on government business. There is also gift being received.
THATS the end game of being a “democracy”. Where any village idiot can vote, and usually does…. NOT a an intelligent way to run anything, let alone a country.
It is not acceptable, but there know there are no consequences.
its also disrespectful that the house is virtually empty considering they are paid a salary to be there
They’re paid a salary. That’s the problem.
Some will also be attending the various committees, which are an important part of their work too.
@@judithmaca1570 Oh yes the tax subsidise commits, for giving something a 5 year plan then not delivering, very important work.
They're too busy doing their second jobs on GB Spews
Whether in the House, committee or constituency business, they ought to clock their hours like many other professionals ( solicitors,consutlants) and be paid prorated on their annual salary. Though when the House of Lords and European Parliament pay by the day,some sign 8n then disappear,but it gets noticed when now it doesn't for MPs.
There's only about 40 of them in the chamber. No use giving everyone a "stern talking to" when they've already left the room.
When even soneone like Speaker Hoyle is giving vent to how disgraceful the Tories are then you know that they're unworthy of being in power.
So what offences did these terrible Tories commit? Do please enlighten us.
@@1chishThinking they are above the ruled and don't apply to them. They act with a air of public school boys. They are riddled with ntitlement.
@@csharpe5787 Thinking thoughts is now a crime?
Being an ex public schoolboy is now a crime?
Feeling entitled is now a crime? (If it is there are about 200 Labour MPs who fit that bill)
OK I get it that you hate Tories albeit for class hate reasons. So vote Labour ... 😏
@@chrysalis4126 yes of course they are you mindless little Momentum keytapper ...
@@chrysalis4126 You mean lying and misleading like there being WMDs in Iraq, Doctors waiting lists being made better for everyone by just removing the ability to book anything other than the day you are ill, University students being better off by making them pay tens of thousands of pounds in fees, Anti-sematism not existing, 10,000 new police officers only costing £30 each a year ??
There hasn't been a Labour government that has given us a secure, fair and just society regardless of how they want to dress it up.
I'm no Tory fan, but right now if you are saying that other parties are above lying and misleading you are sorely mistaken.
Lindsay Hoyle needs to grow a pair. He always shouts and threatens but never carries out any of his threats. It probably took MPs less than a week to realise that they can do or say anything they want to with fear or favour.
The most ineffectual Speaker in recent memory. He can 'call out' Rishi and his government all he wants, as long as he does nothing about it, they'll continue to get away with their casual disrespect towards everyone.
What can he do?
You are an absolute monkey. He can't do anything. He enforces the rules of the House. Ministerial Code has nothing to do with the House of Commons nor is it enforced by them.
@@Station9.75 He should be forcing them to answer questions. Kicking them out of the chamber when they don't and fining them for contempt of parliament.
They are laughing in the chamber and the public.
@@stevec6427 Thats not within his power
The American Congress should have a good look at how Lindsay Hoyle or any other previous Speaker runs the House. Nobody is above the rules of Parliament not even the PM
and yet still the govt ignore him and nothing happens, they have learned there are no consequences and will allow this situation to persist up till a couple of months before the election when they will bring in actual enforceable rules which they hope will apply to the future incumbents.
If you think he is doing a good job then have a look at the Scottish parliament.
tbh he has been one of the worst SOH we have ever had. It's got to this point partly because of his inaction in the past.
Yes same goes for SE Government,
He's in their pocket so you've got a skewed view - the previous Speaker did FAR more to call them out and that's why he lost the job
He's finally remembering his position
Too, Little, too late
Rishi's gone to sleep again and ineffective?
Whats crazy is how empty that room is
The other ministers are moonlighting with their 2nd and 3rd jobs
The whole place needs a clear out. Out of touch, out of bounds and seemingly beyond their own rules. And Torys are the worst of the lot. They act like it’s a children’s playground and show about as much respect. But then what do we expect from a party that cheated and lied its way to this position. And half the time the PM can’t be bothered to turn up.
Sometimes I wish John Bercow hadn’t retired. Would love to see him tear Rishi a new one.
Berrow was a slimy little creep
Ah the corrupt and self serving bullying Bercow,
There should be an immediate fine for any lie’s or automatic sanctions. It’s become a joke.
Polish Government introduced a No deposit mortgage with a fixed 2 % rate .The Uk could easily do the same
They probably have nationalised banks though
@@jillybe1873 so should we
@@carforumwanker no......we really shouldn't, you only have to look at everything else the government runs and runs badly to realise that.
It's a pity he didnt call out the disrespectful parliament......
He does.
If the government is called out about the figures or the language that they use in parliament, they should declare where they get their figures and conclusions from promptly. I realise it is against protocol to call another MP a liar, but the government's constant delays in correcting the record (which would be an admission that they have, at the very least, been economical with the truth) do so in the hope that voters will have forgotten about it by the time they get around to doing it. And of course, it works.
All they can cling to these days is the ability to lie.
I’m glad that the speaker has called out the government, but I think in terms of “do your job” & “show some respect”, I think he needs to look in the mirror
Spunak sneers while Britain disappears.
The PM don't have to show up in parliament, he don't have to reply on questions from its members and he can lie as he pleases, because there are no consequences. Conclusion: parliament in the UK isn't function as it should. I always wonder why the opposition is still present every day.
You were doing so well until you suggested the PM can lie as he chooses. He cannot. As Johnson found out.
But actually you were right. The PM does not have to attend Parliament at all. There is no rule or convention for it. Of course he does attend but there is no obligation as he is the King's First Lord of the Treasury and is not appointed by the House.
@@1chish Thank you for your insight. Maybe I was too cynical about the lying, but lack of moral seems to become custom ... and not only in the UK.
The government are Globalist WEF puppets - just following their orders !!!
@1chish He can though. Johnson only got found out because politicians turned on him for their own personal reasons (ie Rishi told them to and he’d give them a cushy job). Johnson was speculated to have lied on his first day on the job and was a liar before being hired. He was allowed to continue lying for a very long time.
@@jaybee4288 Sorry A PM< simply cannot lie. You pretty much exaggerated to make a point using 'speculation'. Fair enough I guess but the proof you cannot do as you please is Johnson himself. You make totally unfounded lies about Sunak yourself so maybe don't lecture others?
Why the uk keeps electing these children is beyond all reason.
@andyhemmings7363 "These children" are representative of the society generally. They behave, in all their mannerisms and beliefs, in precisely the same way and proportion to the rest of our society.
As the years go by, it seems we become worse and worse. ☹
I feel like gong into the mountains and living like a hermit - not that that would solve any of the problems.
We're all in a very bad place.
The chairman doesn't do his job by not addressing the issues on the spot.
Then sack him!
I would try this if I was Speaker. .if the ministers aren't prepared to do the right thing, go to Charles and tell him directly that we have an impasse in Westminster do something about it.
Both the Government and Savilles best mate - are WEF Puppets !!!
Billionaire Charlie is too frit to intervene lest his phoney non-job gets removed. He does not care one jot for the electorate, or parliament. He only does what helps himself.
We actually need a new speaker of the house this government is getting away with to much. They disrespect parliament and the press get notice before the parliament sometimes with no over sight taken place. It's time this government was brought to the house and read the act of parliament. It's time this government just go before they reck the country totally.
The ministerial code is not worth the paper its written on
They should be respecting the public, nevermind the other MPs
Well MPs are meant to be the public representatives
The rules are outdated. The code is more of a set of strict standards that if not followed aren't met with any repercussions.
The only way to ensure this doesn't continue to happen is if the code is changed.
It is a disciplinary act for most businesses and can event lead to gross misconduct so why is it different for parliament.
They are our representatives, they are there to represent their constituents and do the job we expect them to do.
Stop giving Politicians highly inflated wages and perks and let's see how many stop in the job before they all march off to get a job on a till in Aldi... it must be the cushiest job in the UK..
And nobody makes any mention of the disrespect and utter contempt all MPs of all the large parties have for the voters.
Sunak is a sociopath who's happy to spend billions of pounds on planes, trains (white elephant), ships, barges - but absolutely nothing on 'people' - (unless they are already super rich!)
"Practice what you preach" springs to mind
Politicians are going to destroy this world.
@Don-ym8cm They (the politicians) behave, in all their mannerisms and beliefs, in precisely the same way and proportion to the rest of our society. They are representative of it - with all its flaws.
As the years go by, it seems we become worse and worse. ☹
I feel like gong into the mountains and living like a hermit - not that that would solve any of the problems.
We're all in a very bad place.
Show less
The ministerial code is a joke and not fit for purpose. It needs writing in to law, with real punishments, and a judge can deal with these shysters.
The House of Commons always seems to be in recess at the most awkward times of the year.
Government has proven that they never want to do any work, leaving it all for other people to do it for them and that includes other political parties
He lets it slide too often. Now it is a habit.
The sooner the tories are thrown out of Downing Street the better because respect is earnt, its not a given.
Excellent - this is the type of speaker that this country needs. Well Done !!!!
The shambles and shame of British parliamentary politics clearly shows it's not about serving the British people, despite those people paying their wages and pensions. It is more and more about a thirst for power and control at any cost. So, is this what the public want or is it the desire and plan of powerful and influential individuals and their organisations behind the politics? Hopefully, one day the British public will wake up and smell the coffee and unite for a better future for all, rather than just perpetually maintaining the huge divide in wealth and opportunities that exit in Britain.
2:25 Just what exactly IS the responsibility of the chair?. He seems to have no teeth, and is happy about it..........
Rushi is a golden boy . From a family soaked in Gold...
Soaked in other people's gold.
The Punjabi PM is real sleazeball
@theondebray Don't support him but his family had to pull themselves up by their bootstraps when they came over to this Country
Perhaps some if the whingers etc could do some hard work and get to the same position
@@davidastley5819 If they had to pull themselves up by the bootstraps they never would have raised a Tory.
@@davidastley5819 They pulled themselves up by other people's boot straps.
The Speaker would do well to actually get Sunak to ANSWER questions at PMQ, rather than just letting him smirk and chuck the ball back to Starmer. I don’t give a monkeys about who voted on what bill; I want to know what the Tories are actually DOING about this collapsed democracy and abysmal 3rd world conditions we’re all living in.
Profiting mostly.
Just look at the Teeside Freeport investigation the Tories are blocking (yes the government is blocking another government investigation into government corruption).
Calling it a government is stretching it a bit.😂
Yes, I think crime syndicate is a more accurate description.
It's a pity that the speaker can't declare a minister (no matter their level) unfit for office -based on the code of conduct for ministers, I for one would give the speaker that power. Shake things up some and get rid of that useless dead wood.
Also in favour of ministers being heavily fined for violations of public trust and waste of public funds.
Hoyle is just as unfit for his post as the Tories' ministers.
All that's needed is for the minister to be forced to correct the record if he has 'misspoken'.
This could be done by the Speaker preventing the minister from speaking in Parliament at all, on any subject, until after he's corrected the record. Any time the minister tries to speak about anything else except correcting the record, he should be forced to leave the chamber for the rest of the day, escorted out by the Serjeant at Arms.
The code of conduct is a sick joke on the public.
1. Its non binding and as the HoC is above the law regarding how it polices itself the 'code' has no legal force
2. The ultimate arbiter of the code is the PM who decides if any complaint is to be investigated and if so then the PM solely chooses how any enquiry is run & by which person who is solely selected by the PM and with (non binding on the PM) terms of reference from the PM and the report goes only to the PM who can disregard the report in part or in total and who does not have to make any part public.
3. The PM can also change the code without reference to anybody else - Johnson did this.
@@epincion : Indeed. All proof that the UK is not a modern Western democracy. British democracy is a relic from the past, and not fit for purpose in the 21st Century. (Which also means that the UK should not be allowed to join the EU without root and branch political reform.)
But this government does not responsible or accountable for anything. There are plans, but there is actually no accountability for those plans....(HS2, New hospitals, Net zero, waiting lists, covid response the list is endless....)
But there appears to be no punishment. What is the punishment?
Another 30 second lecture next week.
And here I am sitting in California thinking only members of U.S congress are uncivil.
Dawn butler is a fine one to talk about misleading people after the way she tried to manipulate her car incident.
Hypocrisy on a big scale.
Is this the woman who as threaten a journalist with a base ball bat
His minit of fame...You all hurry up with thee whinging cos im dieing for a number two will thee!!😂
House in disarray!
Speaker Lindsay Hoyle calls out Rishi Sunak’s ‘disrespectful’ government This was never said. He never mentioned Rishi in regards to this statement, in it's actuality
He says he was born in UK he is a liar like Boris before him we need an election NOW
Is there another government not headed by Rishi that I don't know about?
@@samsowden So it would be fair for myself to also put words in anyone's mouth? This could be fun. Oh wait, oh dear, I could be prosecuted for slander, in that respect. Maybe I shouldn't an also, maybe they shouldn't either?
There are 3 others 1st Wales or Northern Ireland and Scotland all have their own government run their parts of KING CHARLES KINGDOM but that self elected pm wants to give NORTHERN IRELAND U.K AWAY to that rebel biden as he wants all BRITISH OUT OF HIS ISLAND not our country that has never left the UK we are BRITISH citizens but 3rd class as we live BASICALLY in the eu even though the DUP MANIFESTO STATED TO LEAVE CORRUPT eu yes the vote over here went against us BUT THE THOUSANDS OF SMALL FARMERS OF LESS THAN 100 ACRES WERE BEING PAID NOT TO FARM AS THE CORRUPT eu DIDN'T WANT FOODMOUNTIANS THEY COULD HAVE FED THE STARVING IN THE WORLD BUT NO DON'T FARM WE WILL PAY YOU MAY KEEP FEW SHEEP OR CHICKENS BUT NO BEEF CATTLE OR CROPS THEY PAID ALL FARMERS IN THE CORRUPT eu NOT TO FARM SO THEY DID NOT VOTE IN REFERENDUM BUT IN THE ELECTION THAT FOLLOWED THE DUP WON THE MOST SEATS THAT THEY EVER WON THUS ROMAN CATHOLICS HAD VOTED FOR THEM AS 72% IN THE 2011CENSUS STATED THAT THEY WISHED TO REMAIN BRITISH THAT IS 28%OFF BLACKMAILING OUR SELF ELECTED PM
Dawn Butler should be sacked.
I really miss John Bercow!
Absolutely, me too.
i miss my ex,s sister.
@@onlyme8117 whatever...
He was a bit of a turd so not sure why 😂
He was a d#ck
they don't care so they can't be bothered.
The quality of MPs these days is so low on both sides . They are not in it to help the country , they just want the power . If they were all doing their jobs properly instead of bickering then the country would run far more smoothly .
When are the rules of parliament going to be reformed? The speaker is called them out so many times and yet they don't give a damn more members are parliament have been thrown out for calling ministers liars than minises have been thrown out for lying!!!!!!
Hoyle has my respect!
He's ineffectual & spineless.
Why?
I love the way they use the term, MISLEAD instead of LIED OR LIE.
No difference between Labour and Conservatives anymore, and parliament is just a Theatre for these clown’s
YES the house of Westminster has turned into a bun fight , how can these clowns ? represent the UK Tax paying voters ? 🤔 ALL PARTIES
They are just laughing at the speaker because he has no power over them just before they go into recess.
issue is though Labour AND conservative are awful. Nobody good to vote for.
The government would have been able to get nowhere near their current utter contempt for parliament and Britain had Hoyle not been so tolerant of their years of increasing contempt under May, Johnson and Truss.
He swapped being the upholder of parliamentary standards for his desire to be rewarded with ermine.
The Tory party in it's current state is not fit for purpose. Two months ago MP Debbie Abrahams was distributing leaflets in my area on her own< she spoke at length with my neighbour and briefly with me, I was impressed with her integrity, I have have tried to engage my tory representatives by all methods , and have had no response, apathy in the ranks methinks!
Hoyle seems to be doing his best but I seriously miss John Bercow.
yes
And the "SH*TSHOW" goes on.
Who's surprised??
FRS ! Get that clown out
Its interesting that the chair acts with apparent authority when the house is near but empty
Put another way: it is interesting that MPs absent themselves when a point of order relating to their conduct is on the order paper.
How much longer is that govt (I use the term loosely!) Going to go on for before it folds?
Possibly until January 2025 - although I suspect autumn 2024 because the Tories' supporters are mostly elderly and they don't like going out to vote in the cold winter.
"becoming apparent" jeez Mr Hoyle catch up , it's been apparent for MONTHS!
Mr Hoyle, the ultimate respect to you. Firm, correct, and fair..proper dad….mediator fantastic…
A feeble and ineffectual deputy headmaster having a rant about smokers behind the bike sheds. He finishes his speech and the smoker are already looking forward to lighting up at break time.
The ministerial code' has in recent years been raised and questioned as to whether those whom operate within the framework of "Parliament". There should be a judicial body who should oversee when and where the "ministerial code is deliberately violated" as it was during Boris Johnsons time in office during the Covid Lockdown. Having said no punishment by the Metropolitan Police was ever given. The question one needs to ask is the "Law" protecting and serving the Publics best interest and the obvious answer is clearly "No"
It's not just the government it's the voters .
You should've seen the reaction of right-wingers after the 2019 win, they saw themselves at the top of the world, now they've all gone silent 😂😂
@@Anonymous-hz3zz Using the term "Right-Wingers" is very naive, it is almost as if you have been programmed to use it.
Let me guess, you think it means Right wing = bad and racist, Left wing = Good and Moral ??
@@shootmcrunfast Far left/left-wing = pathetic
Centre left/centre/centre right = OK
Right wing = stupidity (more often than not)
Far right = dangerous
That's my way of seeing the political spectrum, you're welcome
@@shootmcrunfast That pretty much sums it up.
Dawn Butler is a brilliant argument for more immigration
The one that has been in court for threatening a journalist with a baseball bat, lying about driving and having a criminal brother she gave a govt job to
Sure
They want the job because of the paycheck that comes with it, not to help the people its sickening 🤢🤮
Did he basically say ah yes but we should change the rules so we're not breaking them?
WHERE DO YOU THINK? Where do you think todays tories would be if transported to Germany in 1938? Go on! Have a guess!!!
Speaker of the House
Mp Dawn Abbott absolutely correct 💯
Dawn butler
All Labour lot are awful,what a dreadful thought Rayner,Lammy,Bryant Abbott etc
We need people from normal society and council estates to take over 👊
If the people wanted that it would happen, if someone does not get voted into power and they seize power it is a dictatorship. This is the last thing you want, Socialism and Dictatorships (which usually happen under the guise of socialism) always end up with everyone worse off, especially those who have nothing to offer.
Regardless of how you view the Tories, Labour were traditionally the party to offer the alternative you want. However, they no longer represent "normal society and council estates" and instead focus on niche and populist demographics. Literally no party represents the traditional British common person who are by a long way the most common demographic.
If this is something you are serious about, maybe it is time to start a party that represents the people you want in power ???? It would be a refreshing shake up of politics.
what chavs? no thanks
I agree, anyone with an iq over 70 or a degree need not apply.
3 replies are missing*
Ive barely been following whats going on in Westminster (im in scotland so we have Humza Useless to worry about); i just came here because i love Hoyle's voice.
Well said, Mr Hoyle, at last.
Perhaps if the speaker could occasionally get back to his constituency and resolve all the issues affecting Chorley in Lancashire !!! If the honourable gentleman remembers where it is ???
Give themselves two payrises
Where are all the mps? Are they too busy painting walls in detention centres?
The job of being an MP involves more than sitting in the Chamber. They have constituency work to attend to, select committees to sit on, lobbyists to meet with, functions to attend in a professional capacity, and public visits to make on behalf of their briefs and their constituents. Their job is not to sit on the green benches all day every day
All out looking after their second jobs ?
Well spoken, Mr Speaker 👏
DEBBIE CAN DO ONE TOO, have a look at her bullying past during her term has an MP 😂
Good man.
The MP and Ministerial Codes of Conduct are a sham. The Parliamentary Standards office administers the charade.
Does anyone think the UK is ever going to have a PM it can trust?
Me neither.
when will Ritchy WEF be discussing his apparent precog abilities regarding his investments in ModeRNA & the £172 billion worth of public sector contracts given to ‘INFOSYS’ ?
Too right. 🙄
Hoyle needs to be more severe
"Respect all sides of this house!"
cheers
"Except the BNP, UKIP, Reform UK and anyone else who is actually right wing!"
"If the Ministerial Code is not being adheared to, i really do think the rules need to be looked at again"
So change the rules to fit. Sounds about right Bori- i mean Lindsay.
Some politicians want the money but not the job