For those who are curious, go on RUclips and watch authentic reenactments of dances and music from the court of Louis XIV. You will see how the dancing and music in above scene is far, far from any kind of historical reality--and vastly inferior to the artistry and brilliance that lived in the baroque. Movies like this are not only non-educational, they are anti-educational, leaving us with less than we had before watching!
I agree with your "acceptable artistic license" position. We need that artistic freedom to develop the greatest creativity in all fields. But we viewers should also express our displeasure at those creative choices when we feel strongly about something. My own response was a pretty emotional when I heard this jarring music in a supposedly baroque-period drama. But thanks so much for your balanced response.
The combination of baroque dance inappropriately paired with Peter Gregson's twee score, (plus a thick-waisted Kate WInslet) makes me want to scream and pull out what little hair I have left.
Oh, whatever. You've never heard of artistic license? Anyone with heart left in them can find this scene moving without having to nitpick. And there is NO SUCH THING as "inappropriately paired with" when it comes to dance. EVER. If done correctly you could do it with hip hop and create something beautiful.
On a more trivial note this made me think of the French Angelique films. Corny old tosh but lots of historical detail. I'd like them to do a mini series so all the characters were included. There was a new film made in France a couple of years ago but that version cut out key characters like the Gutter Poet.
This movie is one in a long line of movies that attempts to tell tales of the age of Le roi soleil. Most all of them collapse on themselves. I like Alan Rickman in this role. It is one of the better ones. However the movie itself is just badly written. In my opinion the best attempt is L'Allee Du Roi, it runs to 240 minutes, and tells the tale of the rise of Madame Scarron, from a widow to the second wife of Louis XIV. It is well played, sounds good, well acted is just a better story. ruclips.net/video/z9KcvL8B6E0/видео.html
This looks & sounds dreadful. The music sounded nothing like Baroque music should & the dancers were not in time with the music. The are some beautiful clips of Baroque music & dancing on RUclips. Sadly this is nor one of them.
Les deux hommes qui se prennent la main sont Phillipe d'Orléans et son amant, le Chevalier de Lorraine... A ses côtés, sa première épouse, Henriette d'Angleterre, morte empoisonnée, vraisemblablement de la main du Chevalier...
The music would be perfectly suitable in a different context. In the context of baroque dance, it just seems cold and empty and I think whoever directed this movie wasted an opportunity for more interesting and more beautiful music than this.
For those who are curious, go on RUclips and watch authentic reenactments of dances and music from the court of Louis XIV. You will see how the dancing and music in above scene is far, far from any kind of historical reality--and vastly inferior to the artistry and brilliance that lived in the baroque. Movies like this are not only non-educational, they are anti-educational, leaving us with less than we had before watching!
Entiendo que esta película NO ES UN DOCUMENTAL ACADÉMICO.
I agree with your "acceptable artistic license" position. We need that artistic freedom to develop the greatest creativity in all fields. But we viewers should also express our displeasure at those creative choices when we feel strongly about something. My own response was a pretty emotional when I heard this jarring music in a supposedly baroque-period drama. But thanks so much for your balanced response.
The combination of baroque dance inappropriately paired with Peter Gregson's twee score, (plus a thick-waisted Kate WInslet) makes me want to scream and pull out what little hair I have left.
Oh, whatever. You've never heard of artistic license? Anyone with heart left in them can find this scene moving without having to nitpick. And there is NO SUCH THING as "inappropriately paired with" when it comes to dance. EVER. If done correctly you could do it with hip hop and create something beautiful.
Where the fuck is Lully's music?
Wtf is this? This sounds like Phillip Glass, not like Lully!
O Rameau, Couperin, Marais =( Hollywood you did it again!!
The costumes and dance movements were lovely, but the music did NOT match!
Bibiana Massey the music was awful
@@bronktug2446 The music was fantastic, but really out of place.
Nada que ver la musica con el barroco,solo es musica de cine..
Snape and Rose are dancing together??
Fun fact: King Louis XIV became King at the age of 4 and his reign lasted 72 years!!
And if he hadn't had diabetes he might have lived longer.
He was a force of nature. The autopsy for example showed he had bowels twice the size of a normal man.
@@NicolasViard-kc9dm wild!!
I am loving that fountain.
On a more trivial note this made me think of the French Angelique films. Corny old tosh but lots of historical detail. I'd like them to do a mini series so all the characters were included. There was a new film made in France a couple of years ago but that version cut out key characters like the Gutter Poet.
Terrible if this is Louis 14 dancing I'm definitely the président of the United States
You are so right, this seems to be for the ignorant. The music makes me shiver, it must be Lully or similar.
Relieved to notice that I'm not the only one to choke on the music. Like, why would anyone do that ?
Woooooo bellissima
This movie is one in a long line of movies that attempts to tell tales of the age of Le roi soleil. Most all of them collapse on themselves. I like Alan Rickman in this role. It is one of the better ones. However the movie itself is just badly written. In my opinion the best attempt is L'Allee Du Roi, it runs to 240 minutes, and tells the tale of the rise of Madame Scarron, from a widow to the second wife of Louis XIV. It is well played, sounds good, well acted is just a better story. ruclips.net/video/z9KcvL8B6E0/видео.html
Je suis la seule personne à remarquer que celui qui joue '' Louis XIV'' est ''Professeur Rogue'' dans ''Harry Potter''????!!!
Non
Allan Rickman ❤
Vulgaire , il ne manque plus que les hamburgers et la boisson qui va avec!!!!
Ce n'est pas une musique de LULLY..
Lully era morto quando il giardino fu inaugurato.
Extrait du film "Les jardins du Roi" un film de fiction d''Alan Rickman
This is beautiful, it's so beautiful
It’s pain.
can we all talk for a moment about the awful cgi of the palace?
No idea why CGI in the first place. They could just flew a drone at the actual place and did a 12 years old photoshop.
Louis 16 enter dance..Tanya Hanna.. prescription..the brothers Grimm..🧙♀️💤💤👀🌹
This looks & sounds dreadful. The music sounded nothing like Baroque music should & the dancers were not in time with the music. The are some beautiful clips of Baroque music & dancing on RUclips. Sadly this is nor one of them.
świetny film
Mocny materiał w chuj
KOZAK
Les deux hommes qui se prennent la main sont Phillipe d'Orléans et son amant, le Chevalier de Lorraine... A ses côtés, sa première épouse, Henriette d'Angleterre, morte empoisonnée, vraisemblablement de la main du Chevalier...
beuk
The music would be perfectly suitable in a different context.
In the context of baroque dance, it just seems cold and empty and I think whoever directed this movie wasted an opportunity for more interesting and more beautiful music than this.
Hans Gruber, Severus Snape-great characters, Alan Rickman also directed this as well as playing the king.
ce n est pas du lully
Lully era già morto quando fu inaugurato il giardino.
La música no corresponde.
gostei
elle est belle cette music
Yet it is so inaccurate with the Baroque period.
That must have been the cheapest interpretation I saw. Even this music..
Especially the music!
This is dubbed, the original had actual Period-accurate music.
Como se ponen a llorar con un chocmans si quieren aprender historia lean un libro 😎
OSKAR KOTAS TO KOZAK
wowowo
White Eric Hall Jennifer Davis Paul
Che film è??
Gran escena y la musica a otro nivel el baile matavilloso.
Grüße an Klasse 9a lmao
Bonsoir
J aimerais savoir le titre de la musique .
À Versailles...pas Lully!
Darude - Sandstorm
eae kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
Nul... américain ?
Que horror! Essa música não possui nenhuma relação estética e histórica com o período. Um desserviço!
La musica è esattamente quella della inaugurazione del giardino, ma Lully era già morto.
@@pattino45 what the hell are you talking about?
The music is anachronic !!!!!!!! It’s awful !!!!!
C gênant
Awful
Dreadful music.