Been meaning to comment on this for a while. Really liked this analysis of the adventures because it gave some insight to you as a DM. Good knowing you think about things and make changes that make sense to you for your group as well as your own sensibilities.
@@TabletopBob I do know that. I may have never played 5e, but I played extensively during 1e and my yrs with 2e where almost entirely in at the helm. Hence my appreciation of this insightful video.
When I read through this module, Shemshine's grabbed my attention over all the other ones. I've decided to make a few alterations to the story but overall I think this one is really neat. I'm going to run this one with one of my groups this Saturday, and I'm very excited for it. There is something about music that makes this one all that much more spooky.
Great vid, Bob, and once again you provide great analysis and really helpful advice. I’ve only run Mazfroth’s and the book of the raven, and I wish I’d have listened to you analysis before I had!
@@TabletopBob Soo any intrest in Witchlight or are you more intrested in Strixhaven as a side series? Strixhaven seem to have a feat tree or atlest a line whitsc would be a first in 5e.
Really loved these two videos and your insight into these adventures. It may not fit as well in the format but would you consider doing the other two anthologies yawning portal and salt-marsh? Although from what I hear with Salt-marsh it's more of a pseudo anthology and really meant to be played in order. Also I'm not sure if you mentioned but how what are your feelings on the book as a whole? a must-buy for any aspiring DM or just something to pick up along the way?
Excellent review! I like Alkazaar's Appendix the best. I will have to read Shimeshine's Bedtime Rhyme to get the feel of it.
Thanks for the indepth review! Super helpful
(*rubs hands together*) I have been waiting for part 2!
Thank you so much.
Very useful videos! I think your videos deserve more views. Do you do professional paid DMing?
No I haven't entered that arena yet!
Been meaning to comment on this for a while. Really liked this analysis of the adventures because it gave some insight to you as a DM. Good knowing you think about things and make changes that make sense to you for your group as well as your own sensibilities.
I do feel like many people feel restrained by premade adventures. I hope this shows that you control the reigns.
@@TabletopBob I do know that. I may have never played 5e, but I played extensively during 1e and my yrs with 2e where almost entirely in at the helm. Hence my appreciation of this insightful video.
When I read through this module, Shemshine's grabbed my attention over all the other ones. I've decided to make a few alterations to the story but overall I think this one is really neat. I'm going to run this one with one of my groups this Saturday, and I'm very excited for it. There is something about music that makes this one all that much more spooky.
Agreed I think it is fantastic and music absolutely adds a spooky mood/tone
Great vid, Bob, and once again you provide great analysis and really helpful advice. I’ve only run Mazfroth’s and the book of the raven, and I wish I’d have listened to you analysis before I had!
Thank you for the kind words! That just means it's only up from here 😆. But really they're all pretty fun. Some just need a bit of reworking. Enjoy!
@@TabletopBob Soo any intrest in Witchlight or are you more intrested in Strixhaven as a side series? Strixhaven seem to have a feat tree or atlest a line whitsc would be a first in 5e.
@@piens51 I'm interested in all of it! Witchlight is currently in the works for live play on the channel. More info to come.
Really loved these two videos and your insight into these adventures. It may not fit as well in the format but would you consider doing the other two anthologies yawning portal and salt-marsh? Although from what I hear with Salt-marsh it's more of a pseudo anthology and really meant to be played in order. Also I'm not sure if you mentioned but how what are your feelings on the book as a whole? a must-buy for any aspiring DM or just something to pick up along the way?
Thanks for the kind words! It's possible. I just don't have the time right now with all of my other projects. Maybe at some point though.