Which Pleco is Best for Algae Control?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 сен 2024
  • In this video we break down whether the Bristlenose Pleco or the Rubber Lipped Pleco is better suited for your aquarium. Enjoy!

Комментарии • 30

  • @mammawombwomb
    @mammawombwomb Год назад +7

    The environment in which a given pleco comes from is everything. Also, most of them are found in colonies, but in tanks like the one in the video is only one of each. The reason why the rubberlips is feeding off of flat surfaces is, because where they come from pretty much all surfaces are smooth and consist of well rounded rocks. It will not eat off of rough surfaces, because it is not designed to do so. The morphology of the two mouths should have been the first giveaway, but it would require some level of analytical observation, which the vast majority of people lack. It is not an insult, it is the case (This video being proof). All of that has direct implications on how fish behave. No wonder the bristlenose is happier there. Unfortunately this mismatch is more common than not is the case of most aquariums out there.

    • @allthingsfishkeeping
      @allthingsfishkeeping  Год назад

      Thanks for sharing your thoughts. Actually I do observe the Rubber Lipped Pleco eating from other surfaces, but just not as frequently as the Bristlenose. And while having multiple can be good in some cases it's not essential. Mine are healthy and doing well. Thanks

  • @oscarchinhaoyumoe-iy3qo
    @oscarchinhaoyumoe-iy3qo 10 месяцев назад +1

    The black one is so cute 4:08

  • @musk-eteer9898
    @musk-eteer9898 4 месяца назад +2

    fishes are friend NOT food

  • @professorh8398
    @professorh8398 5 месяцев назад +1

    Thanks!

  • @yamui2166
    @yamui2166 Год назад +2

    All fish are
    Good.

  • @1domcouk
    @1domcouk Год назад +1

    Great vid. Does your rubber nosed pleco eat the plants in your aquarium?

    • @allthingsfishkeeping
      @allthingsfishkeeping  4 месяца назад

      Thanks! I've never had a rubber lipped pleco eat my plants before.

  • @fishblade_n
    @fishblade_n 11 месяцев назад +1

    Is it just me or can I never get a pleco to go for an aglea tablet?
    They ether go over and don’t come back at it, err leave it alone entirely. Even if I feed at night the lights will come on and the tables just dissolved.

    • @hippoafrojagger1392
      @hippoafrojagger1392 10 месяцев назад +2

      I have two Rubber Lips and I've noticed that as well. The only time I ever see them "munching" on the "tablet" is after it's already dissolved for a few days. I do have snails and shrimps that will eat them right away though.

    • @ImmortalWombat
      @ImmortalWombat 10 месяцев назад +2

      ​@@hippoafrojagger1392id recommend getting a flat rock and putting it in your tank. Then putting the algae tablet directly on that rock. Even if it desolves some should stay there and the rubber lips will definitely love munching on the flat rock!

    • @allthingsfishkeeping
      @allthingsfishkeeping  4 месяца назад

      I would recommend NorthFin Kelp Wafers. Mine will go and munch on those right away.

  • @meep2576
    @meep2576 Год назад +1

    I’m never getting another one after this one dies ( how long do they live) he’s got to be 5 years now. I have a albino one. But I do have to feed him also.

    • @allthingsfishkeeping
      @allthingsfishkeeping  Год назад

      They can live quite a while if well cared for, but I'm not sure of their exact typical life expectancy.

  • @IB0i
    @IB0i Год назад +1

    Have you had any problems feeding Rubber Lip Plecos? Mine does not have any interest in any sort of food I give them, unlike my Bristlenoses.

    • @allthingsfishkeeping
      @allthingsfishkeeping  Год назад +1

      I feed mine North Fin Kelp Wafers and it eats them. Maybe give that a try!

    • @mammawombwomb
      @mammawombwomb Год назад

      Most are wild caught and if their tank is set up wrong, they will starve even longer, before they intake anything. Anything with sharp edges in unsuitable for a rubbernose, or any other catfish form that matter.

  • @LivsTanks
    @LivsTanks Год назад +1

    Any experience clown plecos? Great video😊

    • @allthingsfishkeeping
      @allthingsfishkeeping  Год назад +1

      I don't have experience with them yet! How would you say they compare with these two?

    • @LivsTanks
      @LivsTanks Год назад +2

      @@allthingsfishkeeping similar diet wise but you NEVER see them! I take my tank apart every 6 months to make sure he’s still alive lol

    • @allthingsfishkeeping
      @allthingsfishkeeping  Год назад +1

      @@LivsTanks wow. I think I would personally go with one of these two instead then. I do enjoy seeing them occasionally.

  • @silenthill4
    @silenthill4 6 месяцев назад +1

    fullstop, bristlenose

  • @wcdeich4
    @wcdeich4 5 месяцев назад +1

    Is anyone having success breeding rubber lip plecos?

    • @allthingsfishkeeping
      @allthingsfishkeeping  5 месяцев назад +1

      Personally, I have never tried. But good luck!

    • @wcdeich4
      @wcdeich4 5 месяцев назад

      @@allthingsfishkeeping Actually, I think Ancistrus claro, LDA008 the Golden Marble Pleco would be better. They only grow to 3 inches & the males change color :)

  • @kidtuber3407
    @kidtuber3407 2 дня назад

    Bristlenose plecos only eat Cyanobacteria which is the green algae. They don't eat all the 10 other types of algae like black beard algae, brown algae, red algae or diatom algae etc. One of the best algae eater is for example the "Chinese algae eater" fish. Definitely not the bristlenose. This video is misconseption. In fact bristlenoses are one the worst algae eaters because most L numbered catfish eat more algae than the bb

  • @natehood9226
    @natehood9226 Год назад +3

    Plecos are not cleaner fish if there eating algae there starving they NEED a balanced proper diet

    • @allthingsfishkeeping
      @allthingsfishkeeping  Год назад +2

      I think you're right and it is important to supplement their diet to make sure their needs are met. Some plecos, however, are more true algae-eater than others and can get much of their nutritional needs met that way. I also typically recommend driftwood as a supplement for them. Thanks for weighing in and sharing your insight.

    • @duck708432
      @duck708432 Год назад

      Good thing he says that in the video.