Hey Malvi, great video but your definition for dawah can be misleading here. 7:45 Dawah is not the Muslim conversion process. Dawah is conveying the message of Islam to the people.
I’m a revert to Islam. I’m getting my Masters in Islamic studies. I grew into Christianity. Islam is the truth may Allah guide you to Islam brother. A gift to humanity. You’ll have peace.
I'm a revert, how in the world do you get a masters in Islamic studies. I'm genuinely curious. I looked at possibly going to al bayyina institute, but I didn't know there's an actual Islamic studies major. Please tell me more.
Gotta correct you my dude. I appreciate everything that you are doing, however; dawah is an invitation. This is something that can be rejected. That is important. It doesn’t necessarily have to do with conversion.
@@theguyver4934 OFCOURSE what else do u expect .also there is very little "critical sources of islam" there were some arguments about islam in past made by orientalist that were proven wrong by latest historical research . For example that Quran was made later in history by Abbasids to justify their origins .But manuscript evidence proved them wrong . Also the critical sources even exist within Islamic tradition such as hadiths criticism .
9:21 The incident of Ifk serves as a significant demonstration of the Prophethood of Muhammad (pbuh) and the truthfulness of his message. 1.Delay of Revelation: The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) experienced a period of distress due to the accusations against Aisha, during which he did not receive any revelation for a month. This delay was significant, as it highlighted his honesty and integrity; he refrained from making any statements on the matter until he received clear guidance from Allah. 2. The Need for Divine Guidance: The situation was dire for the Prophet (PBUH). Had he been inclined to fabricate or speak on his own accord, he could have done so during this troubling time. Instead, he chose to wait for the divine message, demonstrating his complete reliance on Allah. 3. *Examples of Similar Situations: The text refers to another instance involving the Quraysh sending two men to the Jewish scholars in Medina to inquire about Muhammad (PBUH). They were told to ask him specific questions. The Prophet (PBUH) promised to answer the following day, yet he did not receive revelation for fifteen days, which led to ridicule from the Quraysh. Eventually, the answers came, further proving his Prophethood.* 4. His Restraint: During the Ifk incident, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) faced tremendous pressure from the community. Despite being troubled by the rumors and accusations, he could only say, “I know nothing but good about her.” This was his human response, reflecting his character as a truthful and careful individual. His ability to remain composed and not fabricate a defense for himself or Aisha is a testament to his honesty. 5. The Revelation of Innocence: After a month, when the revelation arrived in the form of Surah An-Nur, it not only cleared Aisha of the accusations but also provided a definitive ruling regarding the incident. The fact that he awaited this revelation instead of speaking out of his own authority further substantiates his role as a true Messenger of Allah. Conclusion: The incident of Ifk is a significant example of the Prophet’s (PBUH) honesty, reliance on divine guidance, and adherence to truth. It underscores that he did not claim to possess knowledge beyond what was revealed to him, showcasing his integrity as a Prophet and affirming his trustworthiness in the eyes of his followers.
Abu Umamah reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever recites the ‘verse of the Throne/Ayatul Kursi’ after every prescribed prayer, there will be nothing standing between him and entry into Paradise but his death.” Source: al-Mu’jam al-Awsaṭ lil-Ṭabarānī 8068 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
How do you know about Ayatul Kursi? Where did you pop up from!? This is very intriguing! Thanks for the video and May Allah bless you with the religion of Islam soon!
1:25 i wouldn't say shia is "one of two major" because shia are around 10-15% max the name shia(شيعة) doesn't mean "followers of ali"(تابعين عليّ) it means first Group, group, sect(فِرقة، جَماعة، طائفة) second Supporters and followers(أنصار وأتباع). because when someone is talking about being shia they would say انا من شيعة علي (i'm of the sect/group of ali). and the term is now used different then the way it was 1440 years ago, because then people wouldn't say they are of someone's sect because there was one way, one truth(way of the Prophet(السُّىة النبوية)) so when people would say "i'm shia" it wouldn't make any sense but saying "i'm of the sect/group of ali" would mean you follow the grandson of the prophet ali not worshiping him like what is happing today. (you should know that the prophet did say and name his successors which the "shia" don't follow now)
Did no one tell you what Da'wah means? Da'wah means Invitation. All muslims have to invite to Islam, but guidance ie accepting or not accepting is in the hands of Allah, hence the Ayat "La iqraha fi-deen" there is no compulsion in religion. Everything starts with intention, so if there is no intention there, then it is not accepted or recognised.
I think the guy is confused. Qur'an will always be the first source and we have Tafasir to explain the Qur'an and then we have Hadith that compliments the Qur'an. Ex. In the Qur'an it says pray and fast, but how do we do that, then we beed to refer to the Ahadith. What times we pray, the different positons, what to recite and so on is all in the Ahadith.
I agree with the hadith part the quran definitely helps understand the Quran and without explaination the Quran would he harder to understand. He doesnt put it as the superior source but a huge help for the Quran so you may understand it more.
@@AssyriacUnitarian not entirely. The Quran is the unchanged word of Allah while the hadis are the prophets sayings however as the prophet didn't speak without Allah's consent you could say.
@blitzkki let me get this straight. The Hadith is the recorded sayings, action, and behavior of the prophets that are recorded by his companions via memorization, then compiled after a series of peer review processes and graded accordingly. The Quran is the recorded message from God that's conveyed by Muhammed that's recorded by his companions via memorization, then compiled after a series of peer review processes that continues to this day? In essence, the Quran is preserved through a hadith process
@AssyriacUnitarian However the reliability is completely different. Each Quran verse is incredible reliable. Why? Because this was compiled by the first caliph and standardized by the third caliph. However hadis have been organized and compiled years later by bukhari and Muslim. And they only picked hadis which were reliable. And there are also sunan which are not as much reliable as the sahih hadis. So in terms of reliability it's different because the Quran was compiled very early on and it just stick like that rather than hadis and scripture for longer for the hadis.
In his context, he is CORRECT. He is NOT saying the Hadith is more important or highest than alQuran. You're misunderstood him. BIG TIME. He was saying WE need hadith to understand Quran, MORE than vice versa. Quran IS kalamullah but without hadith, you CANNOT UNDERSTAND the entirety of it. If you take tafsir classes, you would've known. He clearly said "ambiguity" of verses, and yes, Quran can be VERY AMBIGOUS. Heard of "mutasyabihat"? These verses often talks about the tributes of God, thus can be EXTREMELY AMBIGOUS without the explanation through hadith. You CANNOT explain Quran through your "logic" alone as your MIND ARE LIMITED, hence why you can't understand his statement in the first place. You need hadith to clarify those holes and ambiguity. One wrong mistake, you can falls into blasphemy, meaning attributing God with the same category as His creations. Plus if you studied hadith, you'd known that ALL HADITH (sahih) are a form of revelation from God unto Rasulullah. A wahyu. Meaning FROM GOD as well, Rasul is a walking "QURAN". PLEASE TAKE ISLAMIC STUDIES CLASSES !!!
@@yeclythe issue is his wording and the editor who clipped what he said out of context at the beginning. Saying we need Hadith to understand the Quran is different from saying Quran needs Hadith especially for people who don’t necessarily understand Tafsir etc
One clarification. It is not always that muslims have to be soft. Sometimes, they have to show aggression in a channeled manner. Islam has its own system of what people say "emotional intelligence"
I am a Muslim and to hear this man say Quran needs hadith sounded so wrong, even sacriligious to me. May Allah help that brother with this thoughts. Quran was meant to be understood and interpreted by every kind of person. Islam does not encourage elitisim in religion. Faith is a matter of heart and reason and one must find the answers with his or her own heart, conscience and reasononing. Of course they should also make their historical research but that doesn't mean understanding Quran desparately relies on that.
The Qur'an was revealed to us by the Prophet (SAW) and He was tasked with explaining it, so rejecting the Hadith is rejecting the Prophet which is Kufr
You people do understand that when Muhammed a.s. speaks about religious matters in Hadiths it's not his opinion but rather him speaking from what Allah has revealed to him. The key difference is that Quran is not found to have wrong/made up/inaccurate passages like Hadiths can and did have. That's why they say the best book after Quran is Hadith. They are not equal.
You people do understand that when Muhammed a.s. speaks about religious matters in Hadiths it's not his opinion but rather him speaking from what Allah has revealed to him. The key difference is that Quran is not found to have wrong/made up/inaccurate passages like Hadiths can and did have. That's why they say the best book after Quran is Hadith. They are not equal.
@elvaan I think you understand him wrongly he didn't say Muslims don't need Quran he said Quran needs hadith more then hadith needs Quran Which he means that hadith is important because it explains and put the Quran in way that a normal person can understand and follow it so Quran needs hadith to be understood But hadith is so clear about its teachings that you don't need to go to the Quran so you can understand it
Thank you for trying to share the real representation of Islam and other religions. Myths and stereotypes often off put people from our religion and this may clear the air for them.
1:31 no no its way bigger, shias distort the interpretation of the quran, reject hadiths and insult the wife of the prophet peace been upon him, and insult his companions.
@Syiepherze English is not my first language 😅 İ meant "no, the Hadiths needed the Quran " Because the Quran gives you all the basics the things you should and should not do to get to heaven İf you have the right intentions and truly search for the right Hadith then whatever that Hadith (while it doesn't break any rules in the Quran) is if you do it you will get rewards in heaven Off course many of what the Quran says sends you to the Hadith (like prayer, the Quran says you have to pray like the profit teaches you but not how to pray, because it would take too much place in the Quran) so you may assume that the Quran needs the Hadith more then the other way around however the Quran is a book that by it's own would make you a Muslim with the addition of how to pray But the Hadith by it's own would maybe make you a Muslim now but it would with time become just like the bible altered to the point we're it's a different religion
Because my English is not expert level so i want to explain what da'wah meaning in Bahasa Indonesia as my tongue language. Dakwah dalam Islam berarti menyeru, mengajak, mengajarkan dan menyebarkan informasi tentang Iman dan Islam. Sebagai seorang Muslim kita harus beriman dulu terhadap 6 hal sebelum mendeklarasikan diri sebagai Muslim. Ketika telah menjadi muslim dengan bersyahadat sebagai rukun Islam pertama maka jangan tinggalkan 4 rukun sisanya khususnya Sholat sebagai rukun Islam kedua yang tak boleh ditinggalkan bahkan saat sakitpun selagi masih hidup masih tetap wajib sholat hanya ketika seorang muslim mati saja maka dia tak perlu sholat melainkan disholatkan oleh muslim yang masih hidup. Adapun puasa, zakat dan haji ada catatan wajib jika mampu. Orang yang sudah gak mampu puasa karena alasan sakit yang membahayakan nyawa kalau puasa dan gak memungkinkan sembuh atau orang tua renta yang sudah tak kuat puasa maka diganti dengan fidyah. Kalau sakit tapi bisa sembuh dan masih mampu puasa maka puasanya diganti disaat dia sudah sehat dan mampu di luar bulan Ramadhan. Zakat dan Haji adalah Ibadah dengan ketentuan yang menekankan pada kemampuan financial. Jika tak mampu bayar zakat maka dia menjadi penerima zakat. Jika tak mampu Haji maka kewajiban Hajinya hanya disaat seorang muslim itu mampu baik financial maupun kemampuan fisik karena Haji itu ibadah yang memerlukan stamina yang bugar untuk menjalankan rangkaian kegiatannya. Karena Allah telah tegas menyatakan La Iqroha Fiddin yakni tak ada paksaan dalam beragama. Maka Pendakwah Muslim tak boleh memaksa orang Non muslim siapapun itu yang didakwahinya untuk masuk Islam.
Just wanna point out, like others have mentioned, translating "Dawah" as the act of converting/proselytizing is not really accurate. Dawah means "invitation". While dawah can resemble Evangelical preaching, the best daees are humble individuals who simply invite people to learn about Islam. Convincing someone to convert/"revert" is a goal but it's not necessarily THE goal The Quran teaches us in Al-Baqarah that there is no compulsion in religion
Lmao I find it cute that the people that say “hadith complicated, it’s dumb and it’s made up” ok tell me how the Quran came to be? Without using Hadith, Seerah and scholarly traditions
Not all Hadith are reliable. Unlike Hadith, we can find Mushafs(written copies) of the Quran carbon dated to around the revelation time. But I understand your point. Hadith are still necessary for understanding the time period and the life of Prophet pbuh. When scrutinized under the pressure of known historic facts, some Hadith are found reliable, some are not not. That is why we need a scholars to differentiate the good from the bad. And Seerah is definitely needed for a greater understanding of the timeline of events. Although Hadith and Quran were transmitted mainly through oral traditions, the oral traditions of the Quran perfectly overlaps with the Mushaf. It's proof the Quran has been preserved. I can't say the same about all of the Hadith. I can't just accept any hadith presented to me without proof and context.
I bear witness nothing is worthy of worship exept ALLAH and i bear witness Muhammad is the prophet and messenger of ALLAH and i bear witness Jesus christ is the prophet and messenger of ALLAH and he is the messiah
Great work mate. I love how you can hold these sensitive conversations without necessarily agreeing or disagreeing with what the people in the video have to say. If I were to answer what the greatest threat to Islam is, I would say that freedom of information and modernity would be key factors in people transitioning from a place of "faith" or "belief" to one where people have access to a wide range of viewpoints, especially those grounded in an objective and observable reality without fear of persecution. As wonderful as many people who believe in such religions may make it sound, the truth is often a much harder pill to swallow. This takes a great deal of courage to break free from especially when one is taught that even questioning the faith leads to eternal torture. I wish all those who are honest with themselves the strength to uphold their non-traditional identities and to not succumb to emotional blackmail. Religion is a great tool for guidance for some. I see it as training wheels to live a morally good life and to be a better person. After all, if you constantly need religion to be a "good person" then what would that say about you as a person? Interesting stuff as usual!
I appreciate your thoughtful approach to the question of morality. I would argue, to your last point: humans are born with an intuition to do things that benefit themselves. Whether some of the things we do benefit others, or doesn't effect others, or harm others can be an afterthought. That depends on the level of empathy one has. Empathy can be built in for some, it might also need to be taught, as are narcissist traits and selfishness can also be built in as well. For me I believe religion (specifically Islam, as that's my professed religion, or for this argument, any religion) is a standard for morality. Multitudes of people, billions of moral configurations, from the most selfless to the point of self-destruction, to the most selfish to the point of destroying others, all people along the morality spectrum can look to religion for guidance on how to live their lives the best. There is no judgement when you know not what is right. Blame only falls when you are informed, but defy it.
The reason why that seems strange that the Quran needs Hadith is because the Hadith is the word prophet Muhammad and prophet Muhammad only job as a prophet is to spread the Quran and clearing the misconception that is why god sent him to help people understand it, yes some Hadiths may contradict and the reason why, is some might be made up or twisted into the people that wrote the fake Hadith own words so I think this comment might help you thank you and bye .😊😂
Learn from people who have also left Islam. So you can analyse internal and external reviews. There are many great content creators on RUclips and social media.
Really pressin questions are: A) Why do early meccan surahs have the same rhyme pattern as syriac christian hymns? B) Why is there so much scholarly difference in the interpretation of the quran? C) Why is there no archeological evidence for Mecca (SA) being a trade center? D) Why does the standard islamic narrative on the quiraat and ahruf has holes in it?
That initial statement about Hadith rubs me the wrong way. Yes Hadith is enlightening and important but to prop the Quran against Hadith literature in such a manner sounds crazy to me. Let us be mindful of where the CORE of our religion is found.
The idea that the Prophet Pbuh waited until Aisha RA had her menstrul cycle to reveal the ayah of her innocence does not make sense, because if Aisha got pregnant it would still most likely be the Prophets PBUH child. Since when cheating (which Aisha RA did not do) you would be very careful to not get pregnant and they would of had sex more often with their husband than the one time affair. So even if the Prophet PBUH had control over revelation (which of course he does not) and delayed it to see if Aisha RA would have her period does not make sense because her having or not having her period would not give much information.
Quran: “The book is clear” Muslims: “there are ambiguous verses” 😂 Imagine thinking this is a coherent belief system after thinking about the contradictions for more than a minute.
4:00 personally I find the way Prophet Muhammad’s name is enlarged and all the other Prophets names is smaller. I find it cringe and Allah literally says in the Quran: “…………We make no distinction between any of His messengers………” Al-Baqarah 285
Fairs, but I don't necessarily think its a bad thing, especially since He lead all the Prophets during prayer during al Isra wal Miraj (peace and blessings be upon them all), and he is the Prophet of our time/ummah.
@@immortalpickle3104I agree he led the Prophets in prayer and he’s the last Prophet. But I “feel” personally we as an ummah have seriously exaggerated the Prophet Muhammad to an insane semi divine level. To the point where he’s known by many Muslims as “the greatest of all of Allah’s creation” now that’s insane in my personal opinion. There is literally more Hadiths and Quranic ayah saying that Prophet Muhammad was no more then a messenger and a human being and we should not over praise him, exaggerate him and make him compete with other Prophets by saying “he’s better then all the Prophets and he’s better then that Prophet etc”. It’s inappropriate and cringe 🤷🏾♂️
I mean you have a point, it does feel kinda shirk-y now that I think about it. Like in some mosques you often see the Prophet Muhammad's name (pbuh) right next to Allah swt's and in the same size. But we still testify our belief in the Rasul, no? As long as we don't deify him it's not really a big deal personally. Plus he is quite literally the most influential person in human history. That's a pretty big deal
@@MohamedShou Why should we take your interpretation about the status of the Messenger (SAW) according to the Quran and Sunnah over the consensus of the scholars that he is the greatest of all Creation?
The brother said the Quran (the word of Allah SWT) needs hadith? We never compare what Allah’s own words with his other creations. Sorry to say, it can lead to shirk. It would confuse people that Allah’s world is not good enough as it needs to be supported. All we understand is that hadith clarifies the Quran and Muhammad is the best of examples and Aishah RA once said than Muhammad ﷺ was the walking Quran. But never we ever to say Allah words need the help of others which it may seem to elevates Muhammad sayings more superior than Allah’s words. نَعُوْذُ بِاللهِ “And We have not revealed to you the Book (Quran) O Muḥammad except for you to make clear to them (the disbelievers) what they differed about and as a guide and mercy for those who believe.”(Quran 16: 64) “Obey Allah and obey the Messenger! But if you turn away, then Our Messenger’s duty is only to deliver (the message) clearly.”(Quran 64:12) “Indeed, this (Quran) is the Word of Allah delivered by Gabriel,a noble messenger-angel, full of power, held in honour by the Lord of the Throne” (Quran 81:19) “And We have not revealed to you the Book (Quran) O Muḥammad except for you to make clear to them (the disbelievers) what they differed about and as a guide and mercy for those who believe.”(Quran 16: 64) “Say (O Muhammad), “The holy spirit” (Angel Gabriel) has brought it down from your Lord with the truth to reassure the believers, and as guidance and good tidings for those who submit (to Allah)”.(Quran 16:102) “O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you (truly) believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution.” (Quran 4:59)
Just to precise Women aren't always in a separated area to pray, normally we just normally pray behind the men. But I guess the number of people make them obliged to have a separate room
Generally it’s separate rooms because masjids don’t just serve as prayer spaces it’s more than that and it’s good to give women privacy. The rule of prayer is just that women are supposed to pray behind men
I agree with what the sheikh said but one thing "the Quran needs the Hadith more than the Hadith needs the Quran" I believe in the Hadith's but not all of them are 100% true it was a man made book at the end
'hadith' itself is not a book; rather, 'ahadith' are narrations that are transmitted through chains of narrators. Some ahadith are weak due to fabricators in the transmission or unreliable individuals, others are undoubtedly strong from reliable narrators. To reject ahadith that go back to the Prophet ﷺ by authentic and mass-transmitted means is no different to rejecting a verse of the Qur'an in effect. This is because, just like ahadith, the Qur'an is primarily preserved by chains of transmission. If one were to reject some ahadith because 'in the end of the day hadith is a man-made book (which is a poor understanding of hadith)', then what would prevent them from saying the same about some verses of the Qur'an that are transmitted from narrator to narrator in a chain of transmission as well?
17:00 Is a statement you should take back, there is no uniting with qadyanis, asharis, maturidis or shias, they lack in aqeedah, has he never heard of al wala wal bara? The ikhwanis (wich osama bin laden supported) tried to do the same thing, unite the ummah, will you also unite with the kharijis?
11:43 This statement actually goes against virtually everything God teaches in the Qur'an 🤣 These are God's revelations (Quran) that We recite to you with truth, so in which hadith other than God and His revelations (Quran) do they believe? 45:6 Which hadith after it (Quran) do they believe in? 7:185 So in which hadith after it (Quran) do they believe? 77:50 Or do you have some book in which you are studying? 68:37 And this is a blessed Book which We brought down, so follow it and be reverent so that you may attain mercy. 6:155 This (Quran) is not a fabricated hadith, but an authentication of what came before it, a detailed account of all things, and guidance and mercy for people who believe. 12:111 We brought the Book down to you providing explanations of all things. 16:89 Shall I seek other than God as a lawmaker when it is He who has brought down to you the Book fully detailed? 6:114 We did not leave anything out of the Book. 6:38 What was he saying again?
At the time of moses(as) he was the way to god, at the time of jesus(as) he was the way to god and and now the only way to god(and paradise) is the last prophet Muhammed(saw) until the day of judgment! Jesus fell on his face and prayed and fasted and did not eat pork and was circumcised and his mother was covered and wore a headscarf! Which religion practices that Christianity or Islam? Did Abraham(as) believe in the Trinity? Did Jesus(as) preach the Bible of Mark, John, Paul... in his time? Aren't you thinking? Jesus(as) was a muslim(submitting his will to god) Muhammed(saw) is the decendet of ismail(as)! The other son of Abraham(as)
Muslim creators tent to resort to aggression and their accolades. What are you talking about? I see throughout the video that you came with a baggage. May Allah guide you.
Those are your hardest questions? Really? To me they seemed softballs. Here are some questions you should ask them: 1.Why Khalid Bin Waleed who is arguably the greatest Muslim Warrior killed Maalik Ibn Nuwayrah & then married his wife the same night? How do Muslims justify that action & still consider him a legend? Is that an islamic move? 2. Invasion of Spain & India: How do Muslims justify invading Spain & India & forcing people to either pay taxes or convert to Islam? If this is okay because Islam is the correct religion according to them, then does that Mean Israel is also correct right now for invading Palestine & taking everything from them? Bcuz they also think their religion is right. 3. Why Islam allows to have Non-muslim slaves but its okay to have slaves who are Christians or jews or anything but muslims? Also, adultery is bad in Islam, then why is it allowed to have sex with your slave? I am waiting for the amazing answers from the Peaceful eduacated Muslims. Convince me with logic.
I dont have to a muslim to know that Q1 and Q2 is not an Islamic question but rather a question about a muslim, not the religion of Islam. Also, israel invasion isn't about religion, it never was, neither Orthodox Jews agree with zionism since Jews aren't allowed to have a nation until their messiah established a nation for them... Last I check, neither Churchill or Hitler was a messiah Q3 is the only question directly asking about the tenet of the religion itself. - the matter of Islam having slave is illegal by time thag the Sharia is completed - it wasn't made illegal prior and was the norm of society - the restrictions was made over time and slowly evolved systematically. One of the first restrictions is to give rights to slaves and give social status to be respected as a helper and be treated according to sharia, next to not own a slave who is a muslim, and then a muslim must free X amount of slave, then so on. In conclusion, it is NOT okay to mistreat a person away from their rights of living and liberty regardless of their religion. - which also includes sex with anyone else outside of your spouse. Again, I don't need to be a muslim to take into account history, social standards, anthropology, and comparison between culture vs religion
I would add the list of questions with: A) Why do early meccan surahs have the same rhyme pattern as syriac christian hymns? B) Why is there so much scholarly difference in the interpretation of the quran? C) Why is there no archeological evidence for Mecca (SA) being a trade center? D) Why does the standard islamic narrative on the quiraat and ahruf has holes in it?
Saying the Quran needs Hadith is absolute Blasphemy - the idea that God needs the word of man is absolutely ridiculous - the Quran is the best hadith and your so called "hadith" are full of blasphemy and lies. Before you ask how do you pray - explain to me how Musa (peace be upon him) punched the angel of death away...?
Tell me how the Quran came down? When it came down? Who it was sent to? Who where the first reciters, writers and how was it preserved till this day? How is it recited? Etc etc etc. Without using Hadith, Seerah and classical scholarly traditions
Its only natural for Quran to need Hadith, what are Hadith except the sayings and actions of the Prophet? Even the companions technically had "hadith" to understand the Qur'an, the only difference is they got it directly from the Prophet and we get it through chains of transmission. It's not logical to claim that the Prophet Muhammad never explained the Qur'an to any of his companions.
He did not answer your question about aisha's adultry, he just ranted about the prophet being tested, yeah thats not the issue, the issue is the sources and what they say. Muslim imams and scholars avoid hard questions just like politicians
@NeghmyFren the tradution (sunna hadith) says in many passages that aisha was a kid when the prophet married her, that she was a small skinny kid, so even the argument of (people looked older at that time doesnt work)
The Qur’aan NEVER EVER needs the gibberish argumentative Aḥaadiiṯ (plural of Ḥadiiṯ) which are Muslim men's collections of nonfactual hearsay narratives that have no connections to Rasuulu-LLaahi and Nabii’u-LLaahi Muḥammad ﷺ and his Aṣḥaabat = his companions. The Qur’aan is Allaah’s creation in the same manner Allaah < Al-İlaah created Al-İnsaan = the human of the name Aadam in the Earth Named with the feminine noun Al-Jannat or its selection out of the plurality and the diversity of the Unnamed Earth of this world or this universe - or called in the Qur’aan Al-Ḥayaatu Ad-Dunyaa = the Lower / the Nearer Life in Rusulu-LLaahi and Anbiyaa’u-LLaahi mentioned in the Qur’aan, and the original Qur’aan = Ummu-lKitaabi, without the need of the differences in the so-called the Qiraa’aat -, expressed in the creation of the body of Rasuulu-LLaahi and Nabii’u-LLaahi ᶜİisaa ibnu Maryama and (Qur’aan 19:12) Nabii’u-LLaahi Yaḥyaa ᶜalay-himaa As-Salaamu. KalimatuHu alqaa-haa ilaa Maryama: Kalimat (feminine singular noun) = Word, which carries the meaning of the singular masculine imperative Kun! = Be! Hence, creation as an expression of the Creator of all within the evolution, symbolised by Allaah’s command as His Word in ᶜİisaa (in this Unnamed Earth in this world) and Aadam (in the Named Earth with the feminine noun Al-Jannat, and in this Unnamed Earth amongst his community possibly in Africa before humanity’s "out of Africa" migration and married a woman from his community and had two sons, whom one of them all Rusulu-LLaahi and Anbiyaa’u-LLaahi trace back to him.) No need of humanity’s gibberish argumentative narratives, other than how to perform İslaamic rituals, Aṣ-Ṣalawaat (the five prayers are in the Qur’aan, look below), Aṣ-Ṣawm, Al-Ḥajj.. Allaah’s preservation of the Qur’aan! Four prayers in the Qurʼaan with the word Ṣalaat (صَلَوٰةٌ) or Aṣ-Ṣalawaat (الصَّلَوٰت) is mentioned (and the fifth, part of the plural word and 30:18; five prayers in all) in the Qurʼaan : 1) Ṣalaatu-lFajri (صَلَوٰةُ الفَجْرِ) and Ṣalaatu-lᶜišaaʼi (صَلَوٰةُ العِشَاءِ) in 24:58 and in 11:114 2) Ṣalaatu-lFajri and Ṣalaatu-lMaḡribi expressed as “Perform the Aṣ-Ṣalaat at two ends of the day” (وَأَقِمِ الصَّلَوٰةَ طَرَفَيِ النَّهَارِ) 3) Ṣalaatu-lᶜaṣri expressed as Aṣ-Ṣalaatu-lWusṭaa (الصَّلَوٰةُ الوُسْطَىٰ) = the Middle Prayer in 2:238; in this same Aayat “Preserve Aṣ-Ṣalawaat and Aṣ-Ṣalaatu-lWusṭaa...” (حَٰفِظُوا عَلَى الصَّلَوٰتِ وَ الصَّلَوٰةِ الوُسْطَىٰ...) = the complete five prayers; Four prayers cannot have the middle prayer, or differently said an even number cannot have a middle number, and fifth prayer is صَلَوٰةُ الظُّهْرِ Ṣalaatu-ḏ̣Ḏ̣̣uhri hinted in 30:18, in other words 2:238 with rest in above mentioned indicate precisely five transparent stated prayers, without any form of obscurity! Qurʼaan 20:130 indicates Ṣalaatu-lFajri, Ṣalaatu-lMaḡribi and Ṣalaatu-lᶜišaaʼi, and possibly Ṣalaatu-lᶜaṣri!
Tell me how the Quran came down? When it came down? Who it was sent to? Who where the first reciters, writers and how was it preserved till this day? How is it recited? Etc etc etc. Without using Hadith, Seerah and classical scholarly traditions I’ll be waiting and don’t cheat and selectively use hadith, Seerah and scholarly traditions remember you said “The Qur’aan NEVER EVER needs the gibberish argumentative Ahaadiit” right? Stand on business brother
@mumshorts Astaḡfiru-LLaahi always every error that we humans make, but there's nothing error about the facts of our lives part and parcel of Allaah’s creation and evolution, and for that, the Qur’aan began with: İqra’ = Read / Recite. So, Read Al-Qur’aan and the humankind in this world! Unless, of course, that you're expressing «Astaḡfiru-LLaahi» for your own!
@imk31914 I the one spreading misinformation? Then quote the exact misinformation from my comments above, and I made it to you, and I made it to the first person I replied to in here: Mohamed Shou. About the scholars you talk about, show me proof that they know who Aadam is at all. Other than that, he is the first human Allaah created! And tell me proof from your scholars that they know how plurality and diversity came to be?
Every 68 seconds another American is sexually assaulted. 1 out of every 6 American women has been the victim of an attempted or completed rape in her lifetime (14.8% completed, 2.8% attempted). 9 out of every 10 victims of rape are female. The Majority of Sexual Assaults Occur At or Near the Victim's Home. [RAINN USA] Yall aint no authorities on respect either, sit down.
Hey Malvi, great video but your definition for dawah can be misleading here. 7:45
Dawah is not the Muslim conversion process.
Dawah is conveying the message of Islam to the people.
Why They are Stretegizing then , Different for Christians
Exactly. And it's not conversion, it's reversion, as it is a return to your natural disposition.
@@NurunAlaNour This Shows Your Negligence and Being 1400 Year old Cult Superiority complex oozes out of That Word Revert..
@@KhattaMeethaOficial When you're giving Dawah, you encounter people of different faiths. It's necessary to know how to respond to their questions.
@@NurunAlaNour Dawah is not about reverting or converting people. It's about spreading the message.
I’m a revert to Islam. I’m getting my Masters in Islamic studies. I grew into Christianity. Islam is the truth may Allah guide you to Islam brother. A gift to humanity. You’ll have peace.
Remember learning islam from non-muslims is nullified.
VIVA CRISTO REY ✝️✝️✝️
Jesus is the only truth you need
@@UmmerFarooq-wx4yostop talking nonsense
I'm a revert, how in the world do you get a masters in Islamic studies. I'm genuinely curious. I looked at possibly going to al bayyina institute, but I didn't know there's an actual Islamic studies major. Please tell me more.
Gotta correct you my dude. I appreciate everything that you are doing, however; dawah is an invitation. This is something that can be rejected. That is important. It doesn’t necessarily have to do with conversion.
One other channel I'll recommend is Blogging Theology by Paul Williams
And The Muslim lantern❤
Are you kidding me blogging theology is so one sided he only shows critical sources of Christianity but not of islam
And I'm saying that as a Muslim
@@theguyver4934 you as a muslim believe such sources of critique against islam even exist? are you an undercover christain?
@@Rehab_203 nah muslim lantern is a bad channel .
@@theguyver4934 OFCOURSE what else do u expect .also there is very little "critical sources of islam" there were some arguments about islam in past made by orientalist that were proven wrong by latest historical research . For example that Quran was made later in history by Abbasids to justify their origins .But manuscript evidence proved them wrong . Also the critical sources even exist within Islamic tradition such as hadiths criticism .
The Muslim brothers in this video have done a great job
9:21 The incident of Ifk serves as a significant demonstration of the Prophethood of Muhammad (pbuh) and the truthfulness of his message.
1.Delay of Revelation: The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) experienced a period of distress due to the accusations against Aisha, during which he did not receive any revelation for a month. This delay was significant, as it highlighted his honesty and integrity; he refrained from making any statements on the matter until he received clear guidance from Allah.
2. The Need for Divine Guidance: The situation was dire for the Prophet (PBUH). Had he been inclined to fabricate or speak on his own accord, he could have done so during this troubling time. Instead, he chose to wait for the divine message, demonstrating his complete reliance on Allah.
3. *Examples of Similar Situations: The text refers to another instance involving the Quraysh sending two men to the Jewish scholars in Medina to inquire about Muhammad (PBUH). They were told to ask him specific questions. The Prophet (PBUH) promised to answer the following day, yet he did not receive revelation for fifteen days, which led to ridicule from the Quraysh. Eventually, the answers came, further proving his Prophethood.*
4. His Restraint: During the Ifk incident, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) faced tremendous pressure from the community. Despite being troubled by the rumors and accusations, he could only say, “I know nothing but good about her.” This was his human response, reflecting his character as a truthful and careful individual. His ability to remain composed and not fabricate a defense for himself or Aisha is a testament to his honesty.
5. The Revelation of Innocence: After a month, when the revelation arrived in the form of Surah An-Nur, it not only cleared Aisha of the accusations but also provided a definitive ruling regarding the incident. The fact that he awaited this revelation instead of speaking out of his own authority further substantiates his role as a true Messenger of Allah.
Conclusion:
The incident of Ifk is a significant example of the Prophet’s (PBUH) honesty, reliance on divine guidance, and adherence to truth. It underscores that he did not claim to possess knowledge beyond what was revealed to him, showcasing his integrity as a Prophet and affirming his trustworthiness in the eyes of his followers.
Barak allah feek
Is there a video or website that talks about this issue like you did? Could you cite it maybe?
@@Knight-xe3ib wa feeka Barak-Allah.
Abu Umamah reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Whoever recites the ‘verse of the Throne/Ayatul Kursi’ after every prescribed prayer, there will be nothing standing between him and entry into Paradise but his death.”
Source: al-Mu’jam al-Awsaṭ lil-Ṭabarānī 8068
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
How do you know about Ayatul Kursi? Where did you pop up from!? This is very intriguing! Thanks for the video and May Allah bless you with the religion of Islam soon!
Mohammed Hijab catching strays at 13:41 😆
Appreciate your content Malvi!!
1:25
i wouldn't say shia is "one of two major" because shia are around 10-15% max
the name shia(شيعة) doesn't mean "followers of ali"(تابعين عليّ) it means first Group, group, sect(فِرقة، جَماعة، طائفة) second Supporters and followers(أنصار وأتباع). because when someone is talking about being shia they would say انا من شيعة علي (i'm of the sect/group of ali). and the term is now used different then the way it was 1440 years ago, because then people wouldn't say they are of someone's sect because there was one way, one truth(way of the Prophet(السُّىة النبوية)) so when people would say "i'm shia" it wouldn't make any sense but saying "i'm of the sect/group of ali" would mean you follow the grandson of the prophet ali not worshiping him like what is happing today. (you should know that the prophet did say and name his successors which the "shia" don't follow now)
i was going to continue on giving explanations but.. WOW i give up
Love your perspective bro ❤keep up your good deeds & may God guide you to the truth.
I really liked the calm vibes in this video, no more debates and aggressive conversations.
This was beautiful. Thx Malvi.
(Im not gonna read other ppls comment and just comment on what i see)
I'm happy you say Masjid and also know Ayatul Kursi.
Did no one tell you what Da'wah means?
Da'wah means Invitation.
All muslims have to invite to Islam, but guidance ie accepting or not accepting is in the hands of Allah, hence the Ayat "La iqraha fi-deen" there is no compulsion in religion. Everything starts with intention, so if there is no intention there, then it is not accepted or recognised.
I think the guy is confused. Qur'an will always be the first source and we have Tafasir to explain the Qur'an and then we have Hadith that compliments the Qur'an.
Ex. In the Qur'an it says pray and fast, but how do we do that, then we beed to refer to the Ahadith. What times we pray, the different positons, what to recite and so on is all in the Ahadith.
Insanely underrated.
I love your approach to knowledge, so please continue your journey
I agree with the hadith part the quran definitely helps understand the Quran and without explaination the Quran would he harder to understand. He doesnt put it as the superior source but a huge help for the Quran so you may understand it more.
It helps understand the Quran I agree, but it is not more important that the Quran and the Quran doesn't need it at all.
@MuslimLAD btw.
The Quran is a type of hadith😂
@@AssyriacUnitarian not entirely. The Quran is the unchanged word of Allah while the hadis are the prophets sayings however as the prophet didn't speak without Allah's consent you could say.
@blitzkki let me get this straight.
The Hadith is the recorded sayings, action, and behavior of the prophets that are recorded by his companions via memorization, then compiled after a series of peer review processes and graded accordingly.
The Quran is the recorded message from God that's conveyed by Muhammed that's recorded by his companions via memorization, then compiled after a series of peer review processes that continues to this day?
In essence, the Quran is preserved through a hadith process
@AssyriacUnitarian However the reliability is completely different. Each Quran verse is incredible reliable. Why? Because this was compiled by the first caliph and standardized by the third caliph. However hadis have been organized and compiled years later by bukhari and Muslim. And they only picked hadis which were reliable. And there are also sunan which are not as much reliable as the sahih hadis.
So in terms of reliability it's different because the Quran was compiled very early on and it just stick like that rather than hadis and scripture for longer for the hadis.
The Quran is the eternal speech of Allah, and thus The Quran is not in need of anything. Rather, we are in need of it. What he said was wrong.
In his context, he is CORRECT.
He is NOT saying the Hadith is more important or highest than alQuran. You're misunderstood him. BIG TIME.
He was saying WE need hadith to understand Quran, MORE than vice versa.
Quran IS kalamullah but without hadith, you CANNOT UNDERSTAND the entirety of it. If you take tafsir classes, you would've known. He clearly said "ambiguity" of verses, and yes, Quran can be VERY AMBIGOUS. Heard of "mutasyabihat"? These verses often talks about the tributes of God, thus can be EXTREMELY AMBIGOUS without the explanation through hadith.
You CANNOT explain Quran through your "logic" alone as your MIND ARE LIMITED, hence why you can't understand his statement in the first place. You need hadith to clarify those holes and ambiguity. One wrong mistake, you can falls into blasphemy, meaning attributing God with the same category as His creations.
Plus if you studied hadith, you'd known that ALL HADITH (sahih) are a form of revelation from God unto Rasulullah. A wahyu. Meaning FROM GOD as well, Rasul is a walking "QURAN".
PLEASE TAKE ISLAMIC STUDIES CLASSES !!!
@@yecly Brother, respectfully, chill. This is just semantics. See? There is even confusion in the way we speak.
@@yeclythe issue is his wording and the editor who clipped what he said out of context at the beginning. Saying we need Hadith to understand the Quran is different from saying Quran needs Hadith especially for people who don’t necessarily understand Tafsir etc
@@nouramouctar817exactly this is why ppl say we move funny with wordplay all i gotta say is ONE WRITTEN BY MAN AND ONE IS WORDS FROM GOD
@@yecly He did not say WE need the Hadith to understand the Quran. He said, The Quran needs Hadiths. Either he misspoke, or he is wrong. Simple.
Quite a cute project! Wondering what will be next.
The audio and production is reqlly good especially for a small channel
It cost 20$
I wonder how old they are… it’s so rare to find young content creators who are mature and well-spoken.
تحياتي من مصر شكرا
Unity in the Umma a dream.
Amazing video
❤
One clarification. It is not always that muslims have to be soft. Sometimes, they have to show aggression in a channeled manner. Islam has its own system of what people say "emotional intelligence"
I am a Muslim and to hear this man say Quran needs hadith sounded so wrong, even sacriligious to me. May Allah help that brother with this thoughts. Quran was meant to be understood and interpreted by every kind of person. Islam does not encourage elitisim in religion. Faith is a matter of heart and reason and one must find the answers with his or her own heart, conscience and reasononing. Of course they should also make their historical research but that doesn't mean understanding Quran desparately relies on that.
The Qur'an was revealed to us by the Prophet (SAW) and He was tasked with explaining it, so rejecting the Hadith is rejecting the Prophet which is Kufr
The Quran is the eternal speech of Allah, and thus The Quran is not in need of anything. Rather, we are in need of it. What he said was wrong.
You people do understand that when Muhammed a.s. speaks about religious matters in Hadiths it's not his opinion but rather him speaking from what Allah has revealed to him. The key difference is that Quran is not found to have wrong/made up/inaccurate passages like Hadiths can and did have. That's why they say the best book after Quran is Hadith. They are not equal.
You people do understand that when Muhammed a.s. speaks about religious matters in Hadiths it's not his opinion but rather him speaking from what Allah has revealed to him. The key difference is that Quran is not found to have wrong/made up/inaccurate passages like Hadiths can and did have. That's why they say the best book after Quran is Hadith. They are not equal.
@elvaan I think you understand him wrongly he didn't say Muslims don't need Quran he said Quran needs hadith more then hadith needs Quran
Which he means that hadith is important because it explains and put the Quran in way that a normal person can understand and follow it so Quran needs hadith to be understood
But hadith is so clear about its teachings that you don't need to go to the Quran so you can understand it
awesome stuff Malvi
Thank you for trying to share the real representation of Islam and other religions. Myths and stereotypes often off put people from our religion and this may clear the air for them.
Your video brightened my day.Thanks for spreading positivity. keep up the awesome work @Malvi@Hadi
Awesome video
1:31 no no its way bigger, shias distort the interpretation of the quran, reject hadiths and insult the wife of the prophet peace been upon him, and insult his companions.
0:16 no Hadith needs the quran.
Did you mean "none of the Hadiths need the Quran" or "No, the Hadiths need the Quran"? Just want to clarify
@Syiepherze English is not my first language 😅
İ meant "no, the Hadiths needed the Quran "
Because the Quran gives you all the basics the things you should and should not do to get to heaven
İf you have the right intentions and truly search for the right Hadith then whatever that Hadith (while it doesn't break any rules in the Quran) is if you do it you will get rewards in heaven
Off course many of what the Quran says sends you to the Hadith (like prayer, the Quran says you have to pray like the profit teaches you but not how to pray, because it would take too much place in the Quran) so you may assume that the Quran needs the Hadith more then the other way around however the Quran is a book that by it's own would make you a Muslim with the addition of how to pray
But the Hadith by it's own would maybe make you a Muslim now but it would with time become just like the bible altered to the point we're it's a different religion
I think his first sentence is ok
Quran need hadith but don't know about second 🧐
Super good material. High quality!
Subscribed 💚
Let's continue this journey together!
Islam ❤❤
dawah guy on youtube before gta VI
i think you would do a good interview with sneako i hop u get the chance to do such a vid . lov ur vid
Hadi you did good my brother
11:00 AHA. YOUR PROPHET, DIDNT KNOW SOMETHING, UNTIL GOD TOLD HIM 🤓🤓☝️
😭
Because my English is not expert level so i want to explain what da'wah meaning in Bahasa Indonesia as my tongue language. Dakwah dalam Islam berarti menyeru, mengajak, mengajarkan dan menyebarkan informasi tentang Iman dan Islam. Sebagai seorang Muslim kita harus beriman dulu terhadap 6 hal sebelum mendeklarasikan diri sebagai Muslim. Ketika telah menjadi muslim dengan bersyahadat sebagai rukun Islam pertama maka jangan tinggalkan 4 rukun sisanya khususnya Sholat sebagai rukun Islam kedua yang tak boleh ditinggalkan bahkan saat sakitpun selagi masih hidup masih tetap wajib sholat hanya ketika seorang muslim mati saja maka dia tak perlu sholat melainkan disholatkan oleh muslim yang masih hidup. Adapun puasa, zakat dan haji ada catatan wajib jika mampu. Orang yang sudah gak mampu puasa karena alasan sakit yang membahayakan nyawa kalau puasa dan gak memungkinkan sembuh atau orang tua renta yang sudah tak kuat puasa maka diganti dengan fidyah. Kalau sakit tapi bisa sembuh dan masih mampu puasa maka puasanya diganti disaat dia sudah sehat dan mampu di luar bulan Ramadhan. Zakat dan Haji adalah Ibadah dengan ketentuan yang menekankan pada kemampuan financial. Jika tak mampu bayar zakat maka dia menjadi penerima zakat. Jika tak mampu Haji maka kewajiban Hajinya hanya disaat seorang muslim itu mampu baik financial maupun kemampuan fisik karena Haji itu ibadah yang memerlukan stamina yang bugar untuk menjalankan rangkaian kegiatannya. Karena Allah telah tegas menyatakan La Iqroha Fiddin yakni tak ada paksaan dalam beragama. Maka Pendakwah Muslim tak boleh memaksa orang Non muslim siapapun itu yang didakwahinya untuk masuk Islam.
Just wanna point out, like others have mentioned, translating "Dawah" as the act of converting/proselytizing is not really accurate. Dawah means "invitation". While dawah can resemble Evangelical preaching, the best daees are humble individuals who simply invite people to learn about Islam. Convincing someone to convert/"revert" is a goal but it's not necessarily THE goal
The Quran teaches us in Al-Baqarah that there is no compulsion in religion
maariful quran i love that tafseer book but its like impossible to find it in Malaysia..anyone can help me finding it?
Salam alaykum.. I’m not sure tbh tapi cuba cari tafseer ibn kathir or tafsir as sa’di InshaAllah!
Lmao I find it cute that the people that say “hadith complicated, it’s dumb and it’s made up” ok tell me how the Quran came to be? Without using Hadith, Seerah and scholarly traditions
Not all Hadith are reliable. Unlike Hadith, we can find Mushafs(written copies) of the Quran carbon dated to around the revelation time.
But I understand your point. Hadith are still necessary for understanding the time period and the life of Prophet pbuh. When scrutinized under the pressure of known historic facts, some Hadith are found reliable, some are not not. That is why we need a scholars to differentiate the good from the bad. And Seerah is definitely needed for a greater understanding of the timeline of events.
Although Hadith and Quran were transmitted mainly through oral traditions, the oral traditions of the Quran perfectly overlaps with the Mushaf. It's proof the Quran has been preserved. I can't say the same about all of the Hadith. I can't just accept any hadith presented to me without proof and context.
Are u saying the hadith was needed for the Quran "to be"? Lmao wow
@@rongeen4404 This!
I'm not really sure what you mean by this OP? The Quran is standalone
"Vetements du personnel."
Hey, seriously though, this was nice.
I bear witness nothing is worthy of worship exept ALLAH and i bear witness Muhammad is the prophet and messenger of ALLAH and i bear witness Jesus christ is the prophet and messenger of ALLAH and he is the messiah
3:03 cute vid and all BUT WHO’S SLICK HIGH AIR FORCES ARE THESE FOR???
Great work mate. I love how you can hold these sensitive conversations without necessarily agreeing or disagreeing with what the people in the video have to say.
If I were to answer what the greatest threat to Islam is, I would say that freedom of information and modernity would be key factors in people transitioning from a place of "faith" or "belief" to one where people have access to a wide range of viewpoints, especially those grounded in an objective and observable reality without fear of persecution.
As wonderful as many people who believe in such religions may make it sound, the truth is often a much harder pill to swallow. This takes a great deal of courage to break free from especially when one is taught that even questioning the faith leads to eternal torture. I wish all those who are honest with themselves the strength to uphold their non-traditional identities and to not succumb to emotional blackmail.
Religion is a great tool for guidance for some. I see it as training wheels to live a morally good life and to be a better person. After all, if you constantly need religion to be a "good person" then what would that say about you as a person?
Interesting stuff as usual!
I appreciate your thoughtful approach to the question of morality.
I would argue, to your last point: humans are born with an intuition to do things that benefit themselves. Whether some of the things we do benefit others, or doesn't effect others, or harm others can be an afterthought. That depends on the level of empathy one has.
Empathy can be built in for some, it might also need to be taught, as are narcissist traits and selfishness can also be built in as well.
For me I believe religion (specifically Islam, as that's my professed religion, or for this argument, any religion) is a standard for morality. Multitudes of people, billions of moral configurations, from the most selfless to the point of self-destruction, to the most selfish to the point of destroying others, all people along the morality spectrum can look to religion for guidance on how to live their lives the best. There is no judgement when you know not what is right. Blame only falls when you are informed, but defy it.
Except the more freedom of information we have, the higher the number of converts to Islam, especially in the West.
The reason why that seems strange that the Quran needs Hadith is because the Hadith is the word prophet Muhammad and prophet Muhammad only job as a prophet is to spread the Quran and clearing the misconception that is why god sent him to help people understand it, yes some Hadiths may contradict and the reason why, is some might be made up or twisted into the people that wrote the fake Hadith own words so I think this comment might help you thank you and bye .😊😂
Learn from people who have also left Islam. So you can analyse internal and external reviews. There are many great content creators on RUclips and social media.
The prophet too is just a normal human, he too get tested.
Really pressin questions are:
A) Why do early meccan surahs have the same rhyme pattern as syriac christian hymns?
B) Why is there so much scholarly difference in the interpretation of the quran?
C) Why is there no archeological evidence for Mecca (SA) being a trade center?
D) Why does the standard islamic narrative on the quiraat and ahruf has holes in it?
That initial statement about Hadith rubs me the wrong way. Yes Hadith is enlightening and important but to prop the Quran against Hadith literature in such a manner sounds crazy to me. Let us be mindful of where the CORE of our religion is found.
is this location in houston? i believe ive neen here before
Yeah
It's Taiwan
The idea that the Prophet Pbuh waited until Aisha RA had her menstrul cycle to reveal the ayah of her innocence does not make sense, because if Aisha got pregnant it would still most likely be the Prophets PBUH child. Since when cheating (which Aisha RA did not do) you would be very careful to not get pregnant and they would of had sex more often with their husband than the one time affair. So even if the Prophet PBUH had control over revelation (which of course he does not) and delayed it to see if Aisha RA would have her period does not make sense because her having or not having her period would not give much information.
Quran: “The book is clear”
Muslims: “there are ambiguous verses” 😂
Imagine thinking this is a coherent belief system after thinking about the contradictions for more than a minute.
Is this Masjid Al-Salaam?
Missed the part about hard questions
4:00 personally I find the way Prophet Muhammad’s name is enlarged and all the other Prophets names is smaller. I find it cringe and Allah literally says in the Quran:
“…………We make no distinction between any of His messengers………” Al-Baqarah 285
Fairs, but I don't necessarily think its a bad thing, especially since He lead all the Prophets during prayer during al Isra wal Miraj (peace and blessings be upon them all), and he is the Prophet of our time/ummah.
@@immortalpickle3104I agree he led the Prophets in prayer and he’s the last Prophet. But I “feel” personally we as an ummah have seriously exaggerated the Prophet Muhammad to an insane semi divine level. To the point where he’s known by many Muslims as “the greatest of all of Allah’s creation” now that’s insane in my personal opinion. There is literally more Hadiths and Quranic ayah saying that Prophet Muhammad was no more then a messenger and a human being and we should not over praise him, exaggerate him and make him compete with other Prophets by saying “he’s better then all the Prophets and he’s better then that Prophet etc”. It’s inappropriate and cringe 🤷🏾♂️
I mean you have a point, it does feel kinda shirk-y now that I think about it. Like in some mosques you often see the Prophet Muhammad's name (pbuh) right next to Allah swt's and in the same size.
But we still testify our belief in the Rasul, no? As long as we don't deify him it's not really a big deal personally. Plus he is quite literally the most influential person in human history. That's a pretty big deal
@@MohamedShou Why should we take your interpretation about the status of the Messenger (SAW) according to the Quran and Sunnah over the consensus of the scholars that he is the greatest of all Creation?
The brother said the Quran (the word of Allah SWT) needs hadith? We never compare what Allah’s own words with his other creations. Sorry to say, it can lead to shirk. It would confuse people that Allah’s world is not good enough as it needs to be supported. All we understand is that hadith clarifies the Quran and Muhammad is the best of examples and Aishah RA once said than Muhammad ﷺ was the walking Quran. But never we ever to say Allah words need the help of others which it may seem to elevates Muhammad sayings more superior than Allah’s words. نَعُوْذُ بِاللهِ
“And We have not revealed to you the Book (Quran) O Muḥammad except for you to make clear to them (the disbelievers) what they differed about and as a guide and mercy for those who believe.”(Quran 16: 64)
“Obey Allah and obey the Messenger! But if you turn away, then Our Messenger’s duty is only to deliver (the message) clearly.”(Quran 64:12)
“Indeed, this (Quran) is the Word of Allah delivered by Gabriel,a noble messenger-angel, full of power, held in honour by the Lord of the Throne” (Quran 81:19)
“And We have not revealed to you the Book (Quran) O Muḥammad except for you to make clear to them (the disbelievers) what they differed about and as a guide and mercy for those who believe.”(Quran 16: 64)
“Say (O Muhammad), “The holy spirit” (Angel Gabriel) has brought it down from your Lord with the truth to reassure the believers, and as guidance and good tidings for those who submit (to Allah)”.(Quran 16:102)
“O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you (truly) believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution.” (Quran 4:59)
Just to precise Women aren't always in a separated area to pray, normally we just normally pray behind the men. But I guess the number of people make them obliged to have a separate room
That's true yeah. But even musallas that aren't packed are still segregated for privacy reasons
Really? From what i have seen all the mosque always have separate place for women and for men
Generally it’s separate rooms because masjids don’t just serve as prayer spaces it’s more than that and it’s good to give women privacy. The rule of prayer is just that women are supposed to pray behind men
I'm close to being a quran only Muslim. A lot of Muslims consider me to be non Muslim because of it which is rough but it is what it is.
I agree with what the sheikh said but one thing "the Quran needs the Hadith more than the Hadith needs the Quran" I believe in the Hadith's but not all of them are 100% true it was a man made book at the end
'hadith' itself is not a book; rather, 'ahadith' are narrations that are transmitted through chains of narrators. Some ahadith are weak due to fabricators in the transmission or unreliable individuals, others are undoubtedly strong from reliable narrators. To reject ahadith that go back to the Prophet ﷺ by authentic and mass-transmitted means is no different to rejecting a verse of the Qur'an in effect. This is because, just like ahadith, the Qur'an is primarily preserved by chains of transmission. If one were to reject some ahadith because 'in the end of the day hadith is a man-made book (which is a poor understanding of hadith)', then what would prevent them from saying the same about some verses of the Qur'an that are transmitted from narrator to narrator in a chain of transmission as well?
17:00 Is a statement you should take back, there is no uniting with qadyanis, asharis, maturidis or shias, they lack in aqeedah, has he never heard of al wala wal bara? The ikhwanis (wich osama bin laden supported) tried to do the same thing, unite the ummah, will you also unite with the kharijis?
11:43 This statement actually goes against virtually everything God teaches in the Qur'an 🤣
These are God's revelations (Quran) that We recite to you with truth, so in which hadith other than God and His revelations (Quran) do they believe? 45:6
Which hadith after it (Quran) do they believe in? 7:185
So in which hadith after it (Quran) do they believe? 77:50
Or do you have some book in which you are studying? 68:37
And this is a blessed Book which We brought down, so follow it and be reverent so that you may attain mercy. 6:155
This (Quran) is not a fabricated hadith, but an authentication of what came before it, a detailed account of all things, and guidance and mercy for people who believe. 12:111
We brought the Book down to you providing explanations of all things. 16:89
Shall I seek other than God as a lawmaker when it is He who has brought down to you the Book fully detailed? 6:114
We did not leave anything out of the Book. 6:38
What was he saying again?
WHAT!?😂😂 QURAN NEEDS HADITH MORE THAN HADITH NEEDS QURAN😂😂
Quran is كلام الله its whats preserved doesnt need anything.
{ وَلَقَدۡ صَرَّفۡنَا فِی هَـٰذَا ٱلۡقُرۡءَانِ لِلنَّاسِ مِن كُلِّ مَثَلࣲۚ وَكَانَ ٱلۡإِنسَـٰنُ أَكۡثَرَ شَیۡءࣲ جَدَلࣰا }
At the time of moses(as) he was the way to god, at the time of jesus(as) he was the way to god and and now the only way to god(and paradise) is the last prophet Muhammed(saw) until the day of judgment!
Jesus fell on his face and prayed and fasted and did not eat pork and was circumcised and his mother was covered and wore a headscarf! Which religion practices that Christianity or Islam? Did Abraham(as) believe in the Trinity? Did Jesus(as) preach the Bible of Mark, John, Paul... in his time? Aren't you thinking? Jesus(as) was a muslim(submitting his will to god)
Muhammed(saw) is the decendet of ismail(as)! The other son of Abraham(as)
Islam is not a tradition.
Muslim creators tent to resort to aggression and their accolades.
What are you talking about? I see throughout the video that you came with a baggage.
May Allah guide you.
music hram
Those are your hardest questions? Really? To me they seemed softballs. Here are some questions you should ask them:
1.Why Khalid Bin Waleed who is arguably the greatest Muslim Warrior killed Maalik Ibn Nuwayrah & then married his wife the same night? How do Muslims justify that action & still consider him a legend? Is that an islamic move?
2. Invasion of Spain & India:
How do Muslims justify invading Spain & India & forcing people to either pay taxes or convert to Islam? If this is okay because Islam is the correct religion according to them, then does that Mean Israel is also correct right now for invading Palestine & taking everything from them? Bcuz they also think their religion is right.
3. Why Islam allows to have Non-muslim slaves but its okay to have slaves who are Christians or jews or anything but muslims? Also, adultery is bad in Islam, then why is it allowed to have sex with your slave?
I am waiting for the amazing answers from the Peaceful eduacated Muslims. Convince me with logic.
I dont have to a muslim to know that Q1 and Q2 is not an Islamic question but rather a question about a muslim, not the religion of Islam. Also, israel invasion isn't about religion, it never was, neither Orthodox Jews agree with zionism since Jews aren't allowed to have a nation until their messiah established a nation for them... Last I check, neither Churchill or Hitler was a messiah
Q3 is the only question directly asking about the tenet of the religion itself.
- the matter of Islam having slave is illegal by time thag the Sharia is completed
- it wasn't made illegal prior and was the norm of society
- the restrictions was made over time and slowly evolved systematically. One of the first restrictions is to give rights to slaves and give social status to be respected as a helper and be treated according to sharia, next to not own a slave who is a muslim, and then a muslim must free X amount of slave, then so on. In conclusion, it is NOT okay to mistreat a person away from their rights of living and liberty regardless of their religion.
- which also includes sex with anyone else outside of your spouse.
Again, I don't need to be a muslim to take into account history, social standards, anthropology, and comparison between culture vs religion
I would add the list of questions with:
A) Why do early meccan surahs have the same rhyme pattern as syriac christian hymns?
B) Why is there so much scholarly difference in the interpretation of the quran?
C) Why is there no archeological evidence for Mecca (SA) being a trade center?
D) Why does the standard islamic narrative on the quiraat and ahruf has holes in it?
Saying the Quran needs Hadith is absolute Blasphemy - the idea that God needs the word of man is absolutely ridiculous - the Quran is the best hadith and your so called "hadith" are full of blasphemy and lies.
Before you ask how do you pray - explain to me how Musa (peace be upon him) punched the angel of death away...?
Tell me how the Quran came down? When it came down? Who it was sent to? Who where the first reciters, writers and how was it preserved till this day? How is it recited? Etc etc etc. Without using Hadith, Seerah and classical scholarly traditions
Its only natural for Quran to need Hadith, what are Hadith except the sayings and actions of the Prophet? Even the companions technically had "hadith" to understand the Qur'an, the only difference is they got it directly from the Prophet and we get it through chains of transmission.
It's not logical to claim that the Prophet Muhammad never explained the Qur'an to any of his companions.
Is the Quran best understood with your understanding or the Prophet’s ﷺ understanding?
What do you think of Hadith Qudsi then?
If we don't need hadith then tell us from the Quran only what was the former qibla before it was changed to face masjid al haram?
Bros learning Islam from Indians
He did not answer your question about aisha's adultry, he just ranted about the prophet being tested, yeah thats not the issue, the issue is the sources and what they say. Muslim imams and scholars avoid hard questions just like politicians
What do you mean by "the issue is the sources and what they say"?
@NeghmyFren the tradution (sunna hadith) says in many passages that aisha was a kid when the prophet married her, that she was a small skinny kid, so even the argument of (people looked older at that time doesnt work)
@lunastoneheart6045 What does it have to do with the ifk incident, though?
@@NeghmyFren did you watch the video?
@lunastoneheart6045 Not the whole of it, but I did watch the particular person's reply (the one that was talking about the Quran needing the hadith).
The Qur’aan NEVER EVER needs the gibberish argumentative Aḥaadiiṯ (plural of Ḥadiiṯ) which are Muslim men's collections of nonfactual hearsay narratives that have no connections to Rasuulu-LLaahi and Nabii’u-LLaahi Muḥammad ﷺ and his Aṣḥaabat = his companions.
The Qur’aan is Allaah’s creation in the same manner Allaah < Al-İlaah created Al-İnsaan = the human of the name Aadam in the Earth Named with the feminine noun Al-Jannat or its selection out of the plurality and the diversity of the Unnamed Earth of this world or this universe - or called in the Qur’aan Al-Ḥayaatu Ad-Dunyaa = the Lower / the Nearer Life in Rusulu-LLaahi and Anbiyaa’u-LLaahi mentioned in the Qur’aan, and the original Qur’aan = Ummu-lKitaabi, without the need of the differences in the so-called the Qiraa’aat -, expressed in the creation of the body of Rasuulu-LLaahi and Nabii’u-LLaahi ᶜİisaa ibnu Maryama and (Qur’aan 19:12) Nabii’u-LLaahi Yaḥyaa ᶜalay-himaa As-Salaamu.
KalimatuHu alqaa-haa ilaa Maryama:
Kalimat (feminine singular noun) = Word, which carries the meaning of the singular masculine imperative Kun! = Be!
Hence, creation as an expression of the Creator of all within the evolution, symbolised by Allaah’s command as His Word in ᶜİisaa (in this Unnamed Earth in this world) and Aadam (in the Named Earth with the feminine noun Al-Jannat, and in this Unnamed Earth amongst his community possibly in Africa before humanity’s "out of Africa" migration and married a woman from his community and had two sons, whom one of them all Rusulu-LLaahi and Anbiyaa’u-LLaahi trace back to him.)
No need of humanity’s gibberish argumentative narratives, other than how to perform İslaamic rituals, Aṣ-Ṣalawaat (the five prayers are in the Qur’aan, look below), Aṣ-Ṣawm, Al-Ḥajj..
Allaah’s preservation of the Qur’aan!
Four prayers in the Qurʼaan with the word Ṣalaat (صَلَوٰةٌ) or Aṣ-Ṣalawaat (الصَّلَوٰت) is mentioned (and the fifth, part of the plural word and 30:18; five prayers in all) in the Qurʼaan :
1) Ṣalaatu-lFajri (صَلَوٰةُ الفَجْرِ) and Ṣalaatu-lᶜišaaʼi (صَلَوٰةُ العِشَاءِ) in 24:58 and in 11:114
2) Ṣalaatu-lFajri and Ṣalaatu-lMaḡribi expressed as “Perform the Aṣ-Ṣalaat at two ends of the day” (وَأَقِمِ الصَّلَوٰةَ طَرَفَيِ النَّهَارِ)
3) Ṣalaatu-lᶜaṣri expressed as Aṣ-Ṣalaatu-lWusṭaa (الصَّلَوٰةُ الوُسْطَىٰ) = the Middle Prayer in 2:238; in this same Aayat “Preserve Aṣ-Ṣalawaat and Aṣ-Ṣalaatu-lWusṭaa...” (حَٰفِظُوا عَلَى الصَّلَوٰتِ وَ الصَّلَوٰةِ الوُسْطَىٰ...) = the complete five prayers; Four prayers cannot have the middle prayer, or differently said an even number cannot have a middle number, and fifth prayer is صَلَوٰةُ الظُّهْرِ Ṣalaatu-ḏ̣Ḏ̣̣uhri hinted in 30:18, in other words 2:238 with rest in above mentioned indicate precisely five transparent stated prayers, without any form of obscurity!
Qurʼaan 20:130 indicates Ṣalaatu-lFajri, Ṣalaatu-lMaḡribi and Ṣalaatu-lᶜišaaʼi, and possibly Ṣalaatu-lᶜaṣri!
Tell me how the Quran came down? When it came down? Who it was sent to? Who where the first reciters, writers and how was it preserved till this day? How is it recited? Etc etc etc. Without using Hadith, Seerah and classical scholarly traditions
I’ll be waiting and don’t cheat and selectively use hadith, Seerah and scholarly traditions remember you said “The Qur’aan NEVER EVER needs the gibberish argumentative Ahaadiit” right? Stand on business brother
Astaghfurallah
@mumshorts
Astaḡfiru-LLaahi always every error that we humans make, but there's nothing error about the facts of our lives part and parcel of Allaah’s creation and evolution, and for that, the Qur’aan began with: İqra’ = Read / Recite.
So, Read Al-Qur’aan and the humankind in this world! Unless, of course, that you're expressing «Astaḡfiru-LLaahi» for your own!
@@samantarmaxammadsaciid5156 Stop spreading misinformation and misguidance. Stick to the authentic scholars.
@imk31914
I the one spreading misinformation? Then quote the exact misinformation from my comments above, and I made it to you, and I made it to the first person I replied to in here: Mohamed Shou.
About the scholars you talk about, show me proof that they know who Aadam is at all. Other than that, he is the first human Allaah created! And tell me proof from your scholars that they know how plurality and diversity came to be?
respect for women lol
Every 68 seconds another American is sexually assaulted.
1 out of every 6 American women has been the victim of an attempted or completed rape in her lifetime (14.8% completed, 2.8% attempted).
9 out of every 10 victims of rape are female.
The Majority of Sexual Assaults Occur At or Near the Victim's Home.
[RAINN USA]
Yall aint no authorities on respect either, sit down.
I know what your referring to, your answer resides in the Prophets autobiography.
Yes, why?
I am a revert to Islam , woman. Islam is beautiful for a woman. It’s just that a lot of lies and propaganda has been spread .
@@MadMo04 "autobiography" lol
rent free