What’s vokals? And it’s prerecorded there is no movement in their voices and stuff and when they remove their microphones they are still “singing” edit: looking at the video rn I actually think some parts WERE live. Guys I didn’t say they can’t sing they r so talented like bffr 💀
@@YusraNiazi-so1il first off yes i get that like all your kpop groups u stan definitely don’t sing live or aren’t good at singing but this is definitely not pre recorded, i can see why you think it’s pre recorded but it’s definitely not, and grow up like are you new to kpop?
This is not prerecorded, this is live. If we listen carefully you will hear the sound of the BM members breathing and their voices are a little swaying because they are dancing.
*The vocals??!! Rami, Ahyeon and Pharita and the screams from fans after their high notes😭Babymonster just casually showing how its done in performing Live!🔥*
@@maxadamdorif you listen carefully you can even hear some fans screaming so can you stop acting so rude and disrespecting Don't share anything which you don't know and maybe mind your own business
@@maxadamdorwe don't need to know this. As a hybe Stan you has really guts to comment toxic under other artist performance. If this pre recorded that's mean hybe artist performance is also pre recorded but why their singing is so bad
@@farbinnabianabia6393 hybe singers sing live and they can sing well but yall love to hate on them so yall only look at the mistakes they make 💀 pathetic
They deserve it but it’s to early in their career 😭 + I think YG will only give the popular members solos so members like Rora or pharita/Rami might not get a solo until the end/nearly end of their career/contract just like how he did with blackpink and I’m pretty sure 2ne1 as well
@@Btsarmygirl234 When Ahyeon was singing her high note.She put her mic early and her high note was still going on.I think there were some parts where there were singing live and some where they were lip singing
@@Bunnie0014it's a prerecorded but it's recorded from live performance, so yeah those are live vocal. Usually they're have multiple takes, and they choose which performance that best visually and combines with which performance that the best by sound. That's why you often saw thr video isn't synchronized between voice and the singer. The funny thing is baemon not only group that did this, ALL group did this but yet alot of them are still bad 😂
@@Bunnie0014So what? Ahyeon, even though she is pre-recorded, can sing very well and you can see this behind the scenes of "Sheesh" where they were training and singing perfectly live!!!!
Wdym barely opening her mouth are the blind??? She is opening her mouth pretty good and stop being toxic and stop laughing at her understand Firstly you have no right to laugh at someone and even though she is one of the main vocalist in the group 🥱🥱
it's because of the recording of the camera, the fancam makes the sound not in the same time as the video, it's a common thing it happens often in fancams
to be more precise, the camera that records the video doesnt always record the audio that is recording through another device so when they combine the video and audio recordings it is often not in sync
We cant deny how talented baemon is, but guys, bffr. Even through just simply looking at their mouths and matching it to their voices we can clearly tell this is pre-recorded.
Videos like this is why prerecorded or live, fandoms should just accept the truth of what a performance is, if youre not going to hold the same standards for all groups and try to uplift those who can clearly sing live while dancing intensely, then, Whether its live or prerecorded, all that should matter is if the song is good enough
Haram has really stable vocals even by bouncing a little and lifting her feet of the ground. I couldn't do that, that's for sure. BM really is full of all-rounders.
@@Btsarmygirl234 huh? I'm not a hater! I luv babymonster. But if they were singing live explain how Ahyeon's voice was audible even tho she moved the mic far away from her mouth?
@@yours.chxcochaez I’m not saying you hater , I’m talking about people who are saying bm lip sync just because kiss of life vocals are bad in their new live performance of sticky just because jealousy You are baemon , how can I think you hate them , I know other people are just jealous, Don’t waste your time by believing on them HAVE A WONDERFUL DAY 💗🥰
You can hear them breathing. Thats amazing theyre so well trained. I dont really like YG groups or Ahyeon or babymonster just cause of the n word and cultural appropriation they consistently do but man are they talented.
The best thing about this group is that ALL of them are talented af... There might be diff in favouritism but on the basis of pure talent you can't choose one over the other ❤
@@kenza_rap it is. mouth movements aren’t matching. the breathing is from the pre-recording that they did before. (most groups do that to make it sound live.)
![[안방1열 직캠4K] 베이비몬스터 치키타 'FOREVER' (BABYMONSTER CHIQUITA FanCam) @SBS Inkigayo 240707](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Tn3bGHiBWkg/mqdefault.jpg)
OMG Rami's vocal and pharita's high note is perferct
What’s vokals? And it’s prerecorded there is no movement in their voices and stuff and when they remove their microphones they are still “singing”
edit: looking at the video rn I actually think some parts WERE live. Guys I didn’t say they can’t sing they r so talented like bffr 💀
@@YusraNiazi-so1ilalmost every group lip sync when it’s their first performance of a song but they still have good vocals! ❤
@@YusraNiazi-so1ilthis called pratic and trainee chérie its called kpop idol its called being stable . Are you new in kpop ?
@@YusraNiazi-so1il first off yes i get that like all your kpop groups u stan definitely don’t sing live or aren’t good at singing but this is definitely not pre recorded, i can see why you think it’s pre recorded but it’s definitely not, and grow up like are you new to kpop?
@@drtsnfritos I didn’t say they can’t sing 🤷♀️
Rami, Ahyeon, Pharita and Rora demonstrating why they are babymonster's vocal line
Chiqita too.
Chiquita??
Everyone forgets chiquita 🫤
@@eremiophobiaa yes😢
@@ZouMAIGAchiquita isnt
Pharita is so stable.
Prerecorded
@@XccZ9 it's not prerecorded
To me she always sounds too nasal and a bit strained
its prerecorded. @@Neriasangma
This is not prerecorded, this is live. If we listen carefully you will hear the sound of the BM members breathing and their voices are a little swaying because they are dancing.
무작정 소리지르는게 아니라 음색 자체가 다들 매력있어서 듣기도 편함
AHYEON NEVER DISAPPOINTS OMG
It was pre-recorded
@@J4keobs33ed I know, I noticed after but her vocals are still amazing
Ahyeon's voice burst out directly, one person's volume was louder than the other 6 people 😂
@@J4keobs33edso?
It's not like she never sang live.
Go watch her live performance.
@@J4keobs33ed who ask
Effortless singing while they are so powerful parts of Pharita, Rami and Ahyeon aint no joke
It's pre-recorded, that's why it looks effortless. They are really good, but here it's pre-recorded.
@@sasihiranmayi_bro.. they can breathe in recordings too 💀
@@tulipmars realistic prerecorded 😢 accept it, idols jump a bit before recording this
@@tulipmarslive AR
Stop being toxic bish it's not pre recording okay its live@@StrawTERRYbear
*The vocals??!! Rami, Ahyeon and Pharita and the screams from fans after their high notes😭Babymonster just casually showing how its done in performing Live!🔥*
It's prerecorded but they can sing well live
its prerecorded
@@maxadamdorif you listen carefully you can even hear some fans screaming so can you stop acting so rude and disrespecting Don't share anything which you don't know and maybe mind your own business
it’s prerecorded sweetheart
It's honestly hard to tell of It's pre recorded or not
Rami is so stable. Also, I'm in love with her outfit
it’s pre recorded hunny
@@kaeee3eeee it’s not. You can hear them breathing and their voices dazing out a little cause of the dancing.
@@g0blur. I think u are imagining things lmao
@@kaeee3eeee says the one who just can’t seem to stop commenting a load of bullshit on this channel 💀
@@g0blur. Bby u the only one commenting bs but that’s ok, you’ll find out the truth sooner or later lmao😂
Pharita looks like a princess I swear
그냥 흠 잡을 데 없이 완벽하네
Pharita ❤❤Best vocalist with the best tone❤❤
They're ALL so freaking stable, shows what taking time with training does
@@areentmthey need rest too
it’s pre recorded boo
@@kaeee3eeee Fans who went to support them that day said that they heard them singing live every time they performed.
@@Oooppiyyy it’s the person who posted it, they put the pre recorded version
@@kaeee3eeeeso??
장난해? 라이브 미쳤나봐;; 다른아이돌도 잘하지만 끝까지 라이브한 아이돌은 얘네나 엔믹스네;;; 😮
Tapi klo Nmixx itu vokal tone mereka mirip semua, tidak ada yang berbeda...beda jg di tehnik vokal...
엔믹스랑 키스오브라이프 라이브 잘한다고 해서 봤는데..얘네는 어나더레벨.
@@vylauvv307실력 이야기하는데 님의 취향드립은 ㅋㅋ
그렇게 따지면 베몬도 취향에따라 호불호 갈림 그게 베몬이 예전에 100위권 밖에서 시작한 이유임 실력이야기에는 실력만 말하세요 이것저것 따지면 이야기가 산으로 감 ㅋㅋ
엔믹스가 얘네랑 동급이지 엔믹스랑 베몬은 ㄹㅇ 취향 차이임 키오라는 아직 잘 몰겠음@@kobol6244
@@성이름-r8r8k 갠적으로 노래실력말고 춤추면서 노래하는 라이브로는 엔믹스, 베몬, 키오프 순인듯 일단 엔믹스는 공식계정에 생라이브 인증되어있어서 확실하고 베몬은 잘하는거 알고 이 영상에서도 잘하는데 엠알제거가 완전 믿을만한건 아니라,, 그리고 키오프도 잘하긴 하더라고요
Pharita's dress is quite simple but her visual and vocal..❤
Her highnote is amazing❤❤
rora have honey vocal the stable queen
yall seriously dont know what prerecorded is
@@maxadamdorwe don't need to know this. As a hybe Stan you has really guts to comment toxic under other artist performance. If this pre recorded that's mean hybe artist performance is also pre recorded but why their singing is so bad
@@farbinnabianabia6393girl… stop embarrassing yourself
@@farbinnabianabia6393 hybe singers sing live and they can sing well but yall love to hate on them so yall only look at the mistakes they make 💀 pathetic
@@farbinnabianabia6393 Someones madddd😌
Pharita needs more recognition 😭🔥
Obsessed with Pharita’s high note 🤩
pharitaa so beautiful❤️
Pharita is so fucking stable 😳😭💥
Indeed
It is pre-recorded but u can see their performance on its live her vocals are pretty good there
Pharita’s cute little english accent is also so cuteee 😭😭😭 shes such a sweetheart
cuz its pre recordeddx
@@just_a_kpop_addictIt's not, you can hear Ruka's vocals in intro and not stable.
i like pharita's voice.
she should be main vocal!
Pharita ❤❤❤
BAEMON always slaysss🤍
Pharita is so beautiful and pretty ❤
Rora Rami Pharita chiqita make me goosebump
핸드마이크로 노래하는데 말할 것도 없이 넘 잘하고 그렇다고 춤을 소화 못하지 않고..
비주얼까지... 진짜 완벽한 그룹이다
Pharita ❤her high noteee im in loveee
음이 갑자기 올라가도 피치가 정확하네.. 진짜 대단하다
The way their vocals are so powerful ❤❤❤❤❤❤
아현.로라.치키타는
변성기라 소속사 관리중
근데도 라이브 할땐 소름 ㄷㄷㄷ
라미랑,아현이 동갑친구임.아현이는 변성기 끝났을거임.
변성기는 같은 나이라도 사람차 있어요
아 관리받는다는게 개귀엽네ㅋㄱㅋㄱㅋㄱ
아 그래서 아현이 목소리가 연습생때와 뭔가 다른느낌이 그래서 인가? 근데 너무 귀엽다 표현이 ㅋㅋㅋ 뼝아들처럼 관리 ㅋㅋ
이렇게 완벽한 노래가 엠알 없이 들릴거라고는 상상도 못함 ㄷ ㄷ ㄷ ㄷ ㄷ 이게 아티스트이자 아이돌 자격이구나
i luv how the choreography adds some breath/pitch control with they're hands
I may be seeing things but look really closely😭
all their vocals are so good! Even Ahyeon's Mic Is getting nearly destroyed on how good she sings
The way the fans have selective hearing when it comes to their favs pre recording is funny ngl
Te lo juro, que frustrante
This is literally 99% lip-synced 😂 what kills me is that everyone knows baemon is CRAZY talented… why do they lie?
@@adriadelicsliterally like baemon is very talented but this OBVIOUSLY pre-recorded
@@MINNIEMOUSE2738real, no one said they aren’t talented so idk why monstiez are making it seem that way 😭🙏
I was scrolling comments and i was worried for a second until i saw yours…this is definitely pre-recording
They are ATE !!!!
Ahyeon's singing is so clean
라미는 라이브,mr제거 해도 넘 노래 잘하잖아,,,,..어떡할꺼야 그리구 얼굴도 예쁘고,,,,.... !,,
음… ㅎ 음…. 아니다.
파리타랑 라미 실력 대박이다❤
Ohhhhh pharitta is my queen visual+vocal like angel ❤️
Yes she has one of the best voices in Babymonster but here it’s pre-recorded, doesn’t change the fact she is amazing at vocals tho 💕
The girls needs solo songs!! They are so talented
It’s pre recorded
How does it affect the phrase?@@joykendi09
@@joykendi09 and even if it is? still doesn't change the fact that this group can literally SING 🤭
@@joykendi09can u shut up .
They deserve it but it’s to early in their career 😭 + I think YG will only give the popular members solos so members like Rora or pharita/Rami might not get a solo until the end/nearly end of their career/contract just like how he did with blackpink and I’m pretty sure 2ne1 as well
The way pharita says forever is just so sweet and majestic
코디도 너무 이쁘다
Pharita voice angel❤❤❤❤
이 그룹은 전부가 메보임 ...
구분이 필요 없는 그룹 ~~
로라 비쥬얼은 미스 코리아 나가면 대상 진 임 !!!
라이브는 역시 베몬이지
걸 그룹 최강자다
The live vocals are the queens of the perfect generation
Its pre recorded but they can sing live well
@@Bunnie0014any proof
@@Btsarmygirl234 When Ahyeon was singing her high note.She put her mic early and her high note was still going on.I think there were some parts where there were singing live and some where they were lip singing
@@Bunnie0014it's a prerecorded but it's recorded from live performance, so yeah those are live vocal. Usually they're have multiple takes, and they choose which performance that best visually and combines with which performance that the best by sound. That's why you often saw thr video isn't synchronized between voice and the singer.
The funny thing is baemon not only group that did this, ALL group did this but yet alot of them are still bad 😂
@@Bunnie0014So what? Ahyeon, even though she is pre-recorded, can sing very well and you can see this behind the scenes of "Sheesh" where they were training and singing perfectly live!!!!
Rami vocals are just perfect 💗💗💗✨✨
Pharita was amazing.rami is so stable and beautiful.Rora sounds like an angel.and ahyeon voice is like from heaven
I love the dress of Pharita ❤
베이비몬스터는 너무 아름다워❤❤
음정 정확해 ❤❤❤ 너무 조아ㅏ
OMG PHARITA!?!?!?!
성량이 이 정도는 되야 가수지 ... 아 시원시원해
THEIR VOCALS ARE CRAZY GOOD
Can't take my eyes off Pharita😍🥀
They are one of the most talented gg but you can tell that's pre-record but hope yg let them sing live more 🤍
not pharita barely opening her mouth while doing this note😂
Ikr
Finally someone said this
Wdym barely opening her mouth are the blind??? She is opening her mouth pretty good and stop being toxic and stop laughing at her understand
Firstly you have no right to laugh at someone and even though she is one of the main vocalist in the group 🥱🥱
@@vkookismylife6037smells of jealous 🥱
@@alebooh_8448I know too that u can't even hit a hight note like her
Pharita tiene mucho talento
Babymonster is one of those groups that you can confidently say they have some of the best vocals.
와 이렇게 라이브 선명하게 들리는 거 베몬이 첨인듯ㄷㄷ
심지어 보컬 음원도 조금 날라감
성량이 큰가봐.
최선을 다 해서 부르거나.
MR 제거도 프로그램으로 제거하는거라서 목소리도 섞여서 삭제될텐데, 이들은 목소리도 거의 선명하게 보존되는구나
Babymon members are so talented their one of my fav groups
pharita high notes still going when she already move her mic
it's because of the recording of the camera, the fancam makes the sound not in the same time as the video, it's a common thing it happens often in fancams
to be more precise, the camera that records the video doesnt always record the audio that is recording through another device so when they combine the video and audio recordings it is often not in sync
@@luckyynari i honestly saw this often on baemon performance only 😅 still love their performances and voices though!
@@althy57 well you must not watch a lot of fancams tbh cause that is a common issue esp on inkigayo or smtimes the show too
@@luckyynarijust say it’s prerecorded lol
베이비 몬스터는 멤버 전원이 메인보컬에 비주얼인것 같음. 완벽하다
I’m sure they can sing live BEAUTIFULLY… so why are people pretending that they’re singing live here? 99% of this clip specifically is lip-synced.
Their voice🎀✨
Pharitha ❤
Ahyeon's voice for me is the most satisfying to listen to and the most consistent ❤
This is perfect! And the videographer gets a free concert😊
Rami has real talent, it’s just breathtaking every time I hear her voice, I can’t think of anyone better (in my opinion!)
Rami and her voice is heaven 🤍🤍🤍
We cant deny how talented baemon is, but guys, bffr. Even through just simply looking at their mouths and matching it to their voices we can clearly tell this is pre-recorded.
라미 착장 헤어 메이크업 너무 예쁨😊 머리 묶는게 더 잘어울리는!
They are one of the best girl group to sing live!🥰
되게 안정적이고 부드럽게 잘한다
ภริตาเสียงมั่นคงมาก รักคุณนะ 💛🦌
Videos like this is why prerecorded or live, fandoms should just accept the truth of what a performance is, if youre not going to hold the same standards for all groups and try to uplift those who can clearly sing live while dancing intensely, then, Whether its live or prerecorded, all that should matter is if the song is good enough
Haram has really stable vocals even by bouncing a little and lifting her feet of the ground. I couldn't do that, that's for sure. BM really is full of all-rounders.
El vocal de rami, pharita y ahyeon es perfectooo❤❤❤❤
OMG Rami's vocal and charity's high note is perfect
tbh, the best vocals of their gen are all in here 😂 + belle
Rami Vocal VISUAL is crazy 👌🖤
Omg these outfits suit them so well!! The stylists need more praise ✨✨
Real, they look stunning
This song is always going to remind me of my vacation this summer
Rami pharita and Ahyeon vocals in live are insane😮😮
Ruka❤
Pharita❤
Asa❤
Ahyeon❤
Rami❤
Rora❤
Chiquita❤
7 princess❤
7 monster❤
7 little queen❤
Guys ik Babymonster's talent is out of this world but u can clearly tell its pre recorded.....
They sing this much good that haters think they are lip syncing
@@Btsarmygirl234 huh? I'm not a hater! I luv babymonster. But if they were singing live explain how Ahyeon's voice was audible even tho she moved the mic far away from her mouth?
@@yours.chxcochaez I’m not saying you hater , I’m talking about people who are saying bm lip sync just because kiss of life vocals are bad in their new live performance of sticky just because jealousy
You are baemon , how can I think you hate them , I know other people are just jealous,
Don’t waste your time by believing on them
HAVE A WONDERFUL DAY 💗🥰
@@Btsarmygirl234oh ok I'm sorry for misunderstanding 💖
@@yours.chxcochaez 💗🥰
*PHARITAAA RAAMI AHYEOOOON CHIQUITA RORAAA OMGGGG 💋💋💋💋*
Pharita ateee ✨🔥
You can hear them breathing. Thats amazing theyre so well trained. I dont really like YG groups or Ahyeon or babymonster just cause of the n word and cultural appropriation they consistently do but man are they talented.
얼굴도 점점 이뻐지네
The girl singing "I'm spreading my wings" is amazing.
Rami ate😮💨🎀
The best thing about this group is that ALL of them are talented af... There might be diff in favouritism but on the basis of pure talent you can't choose one over the other ❤
RAMI SONUNDA ELBISE GIYMIS!!
Tek Türk ben değilmişimm
@@mutsuzinsan31aaaaa 2 tane Türk
They can sing very well!!
완벽이들,,,
One of the best rookie groups out there!
BM power👍🏼 not only they singing live but sing so well while dancing, bravo👏🏼👏🏼
It’s pre-recorded but they are still real monsters 💕 fighting
even tho this is pre-recorded, i’m sure they can prove their vocals in the future “forever” performances. (they’re so talented)
its not
@@kenza_rap it is. mouth movements aren’t matching. the breathing is from the pre-recording that they did before. (most groups do that to make it sound live.)
Kesinti yok detone yok! Onlar kesinlikle harika
ตัด Sound ออกยังงัย ให้เสียงร้องเหมือนเปิดเทปล่ะเนี่ย สุดยอดมากสาวๆ สุดยอดคุณภาพ YG