How Were Germans Treated In British POW Camps?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 июл 2020
  • One of the most infamous and horrific legacies of World War 2 has to be the way in which certain countries treated prisoners. We are all familiar with how concentration camps were used by Nazi Germany and also how the Japanese treated POW's also. The treatment received by the prisoners in these camps was barbaric as was life inside Soviet camps.
    Today we look at POW/Prisoner Of War Camps at specifically what life was like for German POW's when they were transported to Britain for detainment. Inside Soviet the death rate for any German POW who entered a camp was around 33% which was ridiculously high, due to the ill-treatment and suffering inside there. However in British camps, the death rate for German POWs was a mere 0.03%. In this video we look at conditions inside POW camps that were established in Britain, explore what life was like for German and Italian prisoners who were held there and also see what the aim was for these soldiers. It's clear that the British offered the Germans a more comfortable stay than other nations, but focussed mostly on re-educating them against the evils of Adolf Hitler and Nazism. But also this doesn't mean however that the British were not strict.
    So join us today as we look at, 'How were Germans Treated in British POW camp?' Also we show you around Eden Camp which is today a military museum, but once was a Prisoner of War camp set up for Italian and German soldiers.
    Thanks for watching! Support the channel by subscribing, liking, and sharing.
    Follow me on Twitter: / theuntoldpast
    Follow me on Instagram: theuntoldpast
    Disclaimer: All opinions and comment stated below in the Comments section do not represent the opinion of TheUntoldPast. All opinions and comments and dialogue should discuss the video above in a historical manner.
    TheUntoldPast does not accept any racism, profanity, insults, sexism or any negative discussion aimed at an individual. TheUntoldPast has the right to delete any comment with this content inside it and also ban the user from the channel.
    Music by: I am a man who will fight for your honour by Chris Zabriskie

Комментарии • 1,9 тыс.

  • @benp4736
    @benp4736 3 года назад +696

    0.03% fatality rate. Ive seen more people die at school

  • @markpetersen1738
    @markpetersen1738 3 года назад +1440

    This sounds like a better place to me than some of the schools i've attended

    • @happyheavy3685
      @happyheavy3685 3 года назад +28

      sound about right

    • @markpetersen1738
      @markpetersen1738 3 года назад +46

      @Starseedspirit i wish i was

    • @jonathanwalker8730
      @jonathanwalker8730 3 года назад +4

      It sounds better than my flat.

    • @VonApennn
      @VonApennn 3 года назад +4

      @Dawud why didn’t they go home, were they ashamed, is there nothing for them at home or something sinister on the allies part?

    • @Robsham1
      @Robsham1 3 года назад +8

      @Dawud Just looked that book up and the front cover says "An Investigation into the Mass Deaths of German Prisoners at the Hands of the French and Americans after World War II" - what does that have to do with British PoW camps during the war?

  • @kencur9690
    @kencur9690 3 года назад +1556

    British torture practice:
    “Would you like a nice warm cup o’ tea luv?”
    “Yaa!”
    “Make one yourself!”
    “Neeeeeein!”

    • @kencur9690
      @kencur9690 3 года назад +143

      Harsh, but effective.

    • @red6201
      @red6201 3 года назад +4

      🤣🤣

    • @giroromek8423
      @giroromek8423 3 года назад +42

      Being forces exposed to British weather is a war crime

    • @Herzeleydt_Diesentrueb
      @Herzeleydt_Diesentrueb 3 года назад +7

      Krauts in those days had no idea about tea.
      They would even have burnt the water...

    • @TheDuked
      @TheDuked 3 года назад +3

      Best comment I have seen on RUclips for a long time hahaha

  • @Conn30Mtenor
    @Conn30Mtenor 3 года назад +889

    Quite a few German pow's at Bowmanville in Ontario, Canada returned as immigrants to Canada. That is how well they were treated.

    • @QuantumRift
      @QuantumRift 3 года назад +5

      Yep.

    • @ImCarolB
      @ImCarolB 3 года назад +71

      My father-in-law told how the German pows were allowed to go to Sunday dinner with German-speaking families in the area. In that area, it was Pennsylvania Dutch-speaking Mennonites in southern Ontario. His family frequently had young men to the house. That was a wise idea, as it showed the prisoners the life of Canadian families. I can imagine many of them would have wanted to stay.

    • @LordOceanus
      @LordOceanus 3 года назад +35

      quite a few that were imprisoned in the USA did the same

    • @dionlindsay2
      @dionlindsay2 3 года назад +10

      AND how little was left to them in Germany when the war was over.

    • @theburningtankman9411
      @theburningtankman9411 3 года назад +9

      I currently live in Wainwright Alberta which the camp Denwood was the largest camp of German and Italian POWs the guard towers and a few building still survive being repurposed. the chapel on base used to be a barracks for the Italian mountain troops and if you go in the back room on the walls are Italian sayings and I've found a badge in a little bit of a cubby cut into the wall (it was the badge of the 2nd Alpini Regiment)

  • @michaelegan6092
    @michaelegan6092 3 года назад +739

    I used to live in a village called Sudbury in Derbyshire where there was a POW camp.A German POW would come to my grandparents' house to help with the garden. He was allowed to leave the prison unguarded and at midday my grandfather would take him up to the pub and with other locals, would buy him beers. He would stagger back to the camp and be happy. He used to come back on holiday to be with the people he liked. How many other countries can say the same?.

    • @737simviator
      @737simviator 3 года назад +62

      In order to impede any potential escapes, POWs were paid not in British currency but with “camp money”, paper and plastic facsimiles which they earned for undertaking camp labour. However, somewhat inevitably, a thriving alternate industry sprang up. Willi Bungart is a German POW who was captured aged 17 and spent four years in a number of British POW camps. POWs who were considered to be “benign” were given the opportunity to earn “proper” money by working outside the camps. They were paid a fair wage for this work and many took the opportunity to save for a future outside the camps. The prisoners worked alongside locals and “lumberjills” - members of the Women’s Timber Corps - bringing in the harvest and helping with the timber management: “None of us liked the sugar-beet harvest,” remembers Gloucestershire man Humphrey Phelps in his book on wartime life, “but the Italians talked and laughed as they worked and occasionally burst into song.”
      Even local men and women whose loved ones were away fighting in the war and who were initially mistrustful of the “enemy” in their midst often found that this antipathy wore off once they’d spent some time working alongside POWs. It wasn’t uncommon for friendships to be struck up and for POWs to be invited into civilians’ homes for Christmas lunch. In Scotland, one farmer requested that the Italian POWs working on his farm be given permission to live in one of his outbuildings rather than have to make the long trek back to camp at antisocial hours.

    • @lukekelly8522
      @lukekelly8522 3 года назад +19

      The Germans are definitely our twins😂 great story 👍🏻

    • @edwardlook970
      @edwardlook970 3 года назад +21

      My father also speaks of a similar experience with a German POW. One night he got into a fracas with a local at the pub. The police came round and the other locals vouched that nothing had occurred, and it was made up to get him in trouble. He was much loved by the community.

    • @pjballs69
      @pjballs69 3 года назад +1

      Definitely not Germany...

    • @v_cpt-phasma_v689
      @v_cpt-phasma_v689 3 года назад +17

      Im not too surprised, the germans and Brits are related it was a huge shame the germans were led by the nazis, they never shouldve gone to war with eachother.

  • @orsonkaart1853
    @orsonkaart1853 3 года назад +743

    My uncle was a German P.OW. He never went back to East Germany until mid 60s to see family. He didn't want to go back to a Russian occupation after the war. I dont blame him!

    • @MauriatOttolink
      @MauriatOttolink 3 года назад +4

      Orson Kaart.
      Sehr Klug!

    • @bombadscenes3673
      @bombadscenes3673 3 года назад +49

      Well he’s lucky mines was captured by Russians and was a P.O.W and worked in Russia till the 1962 and still was killed

    • @TheMijman
      @TheMijman 3 года назад +2

      A POW where?

    • @johnnls94
      @johnnls94 3 года назад +5

      Maybe he should Of fought harder

    • @Loup-mx7yt
      @Loup-mx7yt 3 года назад +5

      Bombad Scenes bullshit, literally, the last German prisoner of the USSR was released in 1955

  • @johannescampe9684
    @johannescampe9684 3 года назад +264

    Respect to Britain and Canada from Germany. Thanks for showing humanity in such times and treating our POWs good.

    • @TheDuked
      @TheDuked 3 года назад +30

      We are brothers, and both of our armies knew that. We have always had mutual respect!

    • @737simviator
      @737simviator 3 года назад +9

      Thats the whole entire idea, so they dont escape. These people where captured from their homes at young ages.... In order to impede any potential escapes, POWs were paid not in British currency but with “camp money”, paper and plastic facsimiles which they earned for undertaking camp labour. However, somewhat inevitably, a thriving alternate industry sprang up. Willi Bungart is a German POW who was captured aged 17 and spent four years in a number of British POW camps. POWs who were considered to be “benign” were given the opportunity to earn “proper” money by working outside the camps. They were paid a fair wage for this work and many took the opportunity to save for a future outside the camps. The prisoners worked alongside locals and “lumberjills” - members of the Women’s Timber Corps - bringing in the harvest and helping with the timber management: “None of us liked the sugar-beet harvest,” remembers Gloucestershire man Humphrey Phelps in his book on wartime life, “but the Italians talked and laughed as they worked and occasionally burst into song.”
      Even local men and women whose loved ones were away fighting in the war and who were initially mistrustful of the “enemy” in their midst often found that this antipathy wore off once they’d spent some time working alongside POWs. It wasn’t uncommon for friendships to be struck up and for POWs to be invited into civilians’ homes for Christmas lunch. In Scotland, one farmer requested that the Italian POWs working on his farm be given permission to live in one of his outbuildings rather than have to make the long trek back to camp at antisocial hours.

    • @AxR558
      @AxR558 3 года назад +13

      @@737simviator This is the exact story that occurred on my families farm in Nottinghamshire, a crashed pilot spent the war working on the farm and they converted a hay loft into a "proper" bedroom for him. He kept in touch with them for decades after the war with regular visits to come and see his friends.

    • @chelamcguire
      @chelamcguire 3 года назад +15

      Your words are so tender and so kind. Clearly, you have been raised by a respectful family. Christmas wishes and blessings from Scotland.

    • @johannescampe9684
      @johannescampe9684 3 года назад +6

      @@chelamcguire merry Christmas my scottish friend

  • @izumiculture4030
    @izumiculture4030 3 года назад +486

    British deciding where POW go
    Britain "What's your favourite drink?"
    POW "Coffee"
    Britain "Send him to America"
    Britain "What's your favourite drink?"
    POW "Tea"
    Britain "You're in"
    And that's how all the Coffee drinkers ended up in America.

    • @impostors6905
      @impostors6905 3 года назад +74

      Britain "What's your favorite drink ?"
      POW "Vodka"
      Britain "Send him to Gulag"

    • @someonecool7316
      @someonecool7316 3 года назад +29

      Britain "What's your favourite drink"
      POW "Beer"
      Britain "Send him to Australia"

    • @oshb5559
      @oshb5559 3 года назад +12

      someone cool Nah they would just send him to a local pub lol

    • @brayden7574
      @brayden7574 3 года назад +21

      Britain "Do you want a cup o water, mate?"
      POW "Ja"
      Britain "Send him to Canada"

    • @winchesterchua7600
      @winchesterchua7600 3 года назад +15

      Brit: Do you like Fruit Juice and smoothies mate?
      German: Ja.
      Brit: Send him to Hawaii.

  • @Moggster23
    @Moggster23 3 года назад +610

    My paternal grandfather was captured by the British in North Africa and became a prisoner of war in Britain. After the war he settled in Britain, changed his name to an English surname, met my grandmother and the rest is history.

    • @burtvhulberthyhbn7583
      @burtvhulberthyhbn7583 3 года назад +31

      Damn good story!!

    • @sarkybugger5009
      @sarkybugger5009 3 года назад +39

      A good friend of my Nan married a german PoW who was sent to Scotland. He was a lovely guy. I don't know where he was captured, or even what service he was in. It was many years ago.

    • @jimmcloughlin
      @jimmcloughlin 3 года назад +27

      Moggy: I am pre-WW2 and as a kid was amazed that POWs would come to our catholic church every Sunday. Other days they worked on the land.

    • @stevekitt52
      @stevekitt52 3 года назад +40

      My Great Uncle served in the Kriegsmarine on a UBoat. Got captured and served out the rest of the war here. While working on a farm, he rescued a young boy who had fell in a river. Met my Great Aunt and became part of the family.

    • @obamatheimposter
      @obamatheimposter 3 года назад +24

      Why not...the queen is German and they changed their name during WWI....

  • @petercavellini3232
    @petercavellini3232 3 года назад +749

    To be honest, I bet some were glad to be prisoners, it more or less guarantee that after the war they’d be alive.

    • @patrickhanratty9779
      @patrickhanratty9779 3 года назад +86

      Better than the Eastern front

    • @lewisner
      @lewisner 3 года назад +77

      As long as they survived the British weather.

    • @wallyklw5
      @wallyklw5 3 года назад +80

      And the British food

    • @brianclark7412
      @brianclark7412 3 года назад +6

      So, so true

    • @davesy6969
      @davesy6969 3 года назад +27

      @@brianclark7412 shut up and eat your rissole!

  • @Fireguy97
    @Fireguy97 3 года назад +317

    I know that many German POW's in Canada were actually left to be on their own during the day. The went into town, some even got jobs with locals, but were required to return to camp for the night.

    • @rabbit251
      @rabbit251 3 года назад +18

      Some prisoners were sent to a military base in southern Wisconsin in the US. From there they were literally farmed out to farm to work. My mother was a child during the war, but rshe remember speaking to the prisoners who loved being there because everyone in the area spoke German (my mother's elementary school taught everything in German. She didn't learn English until she went to high school). She told me the prisoners were very happy to be out of the war. One of my Mom's cousins later married one of the POWs. I remember meeting him and that he spoke English with a thick German accent.

    • @cefngwyn
      @cefngwyn 3 года назад +10

      Only one German prisoner of war ever escaped from Canada and made it back to Germany. Hauptman Franz von Werra was a Luftwaffe pilot shot down during the Battle of Britain and deported to Canada. He escaped captivity by jumping from a moving train and stowing away aboard a freighter bound for Sweden, finally reaching Germany in April 1941. He did not survive the war, however, being shot down over the English Channel off the coast of the Netherlands in October 1941. He was the subject of a book 'The One That Got Away,' by Kendall Burt and James Leasor, and was played by the actor Hardy Kruger in the film of the same name.

    • @lovehandr
      @lovehandr 3 года назад +6

      There were a lot of German POWs in this area that worked for farmers especially in the latter part of the war. They were treated well because it was important that this information got back to Germany through Swiss inspectors. This resulted in Canadian POWs being treated better than those from some other countries, notably Russia. I recently wrote a story about this . A number of families that I know had POW workers and in one case a POW disappeared. The RCMP interviewed the mother years after the war to find out if there was any contact. There hadn't been. Escapees were not a major concern. As some one else pointed out, only one had successfully returned to Germany, and that was while the USA was still neutral and before Pearl Harbor. POWs were required to return to Germany after the war but thousands would return to Canada as immigrants in the following years.

    • @infertilepiggy5667
      @infertilepiggy5667 3 года назад +2

      well yeah, where you gonna run to? the icy forest, the frozen lake or the atlantic ocean? your choice lol

    • @stevemartin6144
      @stevemartin6144 3 года назад

      @@infertilepiggy5667 you obviously have never been to Canada.

  • @TheScaryTruthCatalyst
    @TheScaryTruthCatalyst 3 года назад +281

    My grandfather used to guard German army POW's. He remembered them as polite, working class men who missed their families. They would often be excellent craftsmen and carpenters who would sometimes make wooden toys for the guards children at Christmas.

    • @moeshipley4170
      @moeshipley4170 3 года назад +56

      This just illustrates that the folks most affected by war are the ones who really wanted nothing to do with it in the first place.

    • @billolsen4360
      @billolsen4360 3 года назад +14

      They tell me we had lots of WW2 Italian German POWs billeted in the small farming town where I grew up in northeastern Colorado & worked on the farms owned by various friends of my folks, many of whom were either Italian or German immigrants. They taught our high school students how to play soccer. Never caused any problems as far I heard, were glad to be fed and housed with real mattresses, etc.

    • @MauriatOttolink
      @MauriatOttolink 3 года назад +14

      The Scary Truth Catalyst
      Not an unusual tale.
      I hope that you get to the end. It's worth it.
      There was a great story of a high ranking German Officer..p.o.w who was billeted in a private house in a village in Scotland.
      Much later, the by then elderly lady described their 'guest' to whom they had given hospitality.
      "He was an absolute gentleman. He bowed and clicked his heels whenever we encountered him leaving the house or returning home.
      Spoke excellent English but had to learn our scottish accents.
      He did ANYTHING heavy about the. house. Wouldn't let me or my ailing husband carry anything heavy.
      In the kitchen he was limited but did any of the mundane tasks.
      Eventually he saw that our garden was badly in need of attention and said that at home
      his love was of gardening (Gartenarbeit) and would love to to tidy it up.
      The lawn was restored to its former glory and in autumn before he was repatriated, he gave the lawn its last cut before winter. She was asked for permission for him to plant some bulbs in the lawn. "They will be beautiful in Spring when I am gone... Something by which I hope you will remember me."
      She agreed and chose and financed the purchase of a large quantity of crocuses (croci?)
      and he spent hours of back breaking working, carefully planting these bulbs.
      He eventually made his courteous farewell speech.
      "Vielen Dank für Ihre Freundlichkeit und Gastfreundschaft während meines Aufenthalts in Ihrem schönen Land.
      Wir hätten wirklich nicht im Krieg sein sollen! "
      "Thank you for your kindness and hospitality during my stay in your beautiful country.
      We really shouldn't have been at war!"
      When the crocuses bloomed in March, before the grass needed cutting again, they read
      "HEIL HITLER!" in big letters.

    • @chickey333
      @chickey333 3 года назад

      @@MauriatOttolink
      It appears that the German Fascists' had already done a pretty good job of planting some perennial mind speak into his now brain washed thinking process.

    • @Alistplay
      @Alistplay 3 года назад

      @@MauriatOttolink 😂😂😂

  • @heronimousbrapson863
    @heronimousbrapson863 3 года назад +133

    Some of the German POW's sent to Canada were housed in camps near the Rocky Mountains. A few of them were so smitten with the beauty of the area, they emigrated to Canada after the war ended.

    • @stevemartin6144
      @stevemartin6144 3 года назад +4

      @Con Barber , yes he was a penpal of mine.

  • @robertwoodward3085
    @robertwoodward3085 3 года назад +162

    Bert Trautmann was pow a and was employed to carry out agricultural work. He was surprised to receive regular visits from British authorities to ensure he was being fairly treated and well fed

    • @philipm06
      @philipm06 3 года назад +25

      My step dad lived next to Bert Trautmann near Manchester. Bert was a tough ex-paratrooper and very athletic - he was goal keeper for Manchester City and played in the 1956 FA cup final with a broken neck.

    • @dufushead
      @dufushead 3 года назад +3

      Robert is right for sure. To anybody who wants to get a real insight into all this stuff, read Bert Trautmanns autobiography. The book is ace, the man is fucking legend. I went to school with the kids of Italian ex-pow's who'd worked on the local farms, got to know the local girls, and Antonio's your uncle. My old man was on the troopships that carried them. Great vid.

    • @johnconran9327
      @johnconran9327 3 года назад +18

      Yeah Bert Trautmann's story is a good one, Fallshirmjaeger throughout the war, he was captured by Americans but decided to escape from them because he thought they were going to kill him. He ran, jumped over a fence into a field to find a British soldier sitting making tea, He said "Hello Fritz, fancy a cup of Tea?" Which he did. Legend.

    • @Holden308
      @Holden308 3 года назад +10

      One of the reasons that Trautmann and others were surprised was because they had been force fed a false diet of how badly the Allies treated POW's. I'm not saying the Allies were perfect in their treatment of POW's, far from it. But from stories I have read from German, Italian and Japanese POW's, we did tend to treat our prisoners a bit better than they treated ours.

    • @barrybernstein4459
      @barrybernstein4459 3 года назад

      @@philipm06 I remember going to WHL as a kid in 1960 to see Spurs play Manchester
      City. It was the season of the Spurs double. Bert Trautmann played a blinder and
      Spurs dropped their first point after eleven consecutive wins.

  • @macaronisushi4512
    @macaronisushi4512 3 года назад +81

    i know there were a lot of cases were german soldiers would actively seek to surrender to the british to avoid being captured by the soviets

    • @skyhappy
      @skyhappy 3 года назад +7

      Yeah, 3/4 of them surrendered to the Americans/western allies even though most fought on the eastern front

    • @margaretbell5028
      @margaretbell5028 3 года назад +2

      The Germans staved or otherwise killed millions of Russian prisoners of war is possibly the reason for that.

    • @keikei2942
      @keikei2942 2 года назад

      @@margaretbell5028 They also actively committed genocide in occupied Soviet lands and raped and pillaged a lot. Most Red Army soldiers probably knew someone that had been killed and/or raped as a result of actions carried out by the Wehrmacht and SS

  • @holydiver73
    @holydiver73 3 года назад +117

    My wife’s next door neighbour when she was growing up was an ex German Luftwaffe officer. He was shot down and spent the the rest of the war in England. After the war he settled in England, married an English girl had a had a family and he was one of the nicest guys I had ever met in my life. What he didn’t know about gardening wasn’t worth knowing and he taught me a few things. He’s sadly no longer with us.
    In contrast, my Grandfather was captured in North Aftrica in 1941 and spent the rest of the war in a POW camp in saxony where he was maltreated, beaten and tortured. After he came home, he harboured a life long resentment of Germans and vowed never to go Germany again and had to sleep with a nightlight for the rest of his life. He was a great man too and I miss him.
    I highlight these stories to show how we treated our prisoners compared to how the Germans did.

    • @MauriatOttolink
      @MauriatOttolink 3 года назад +8

      HolyDiver73
      Fully understand your position about your beloved Grandfather.
      I'm one generation later and have some sincere and valued German friends of about one and half generations later. They carry this clearly visible National guilt over something which happened about the time I was born and LONG before they were.
      It was all the result of what always happens when a minority takes control with
      outrageous views and then has the power to carry them out.
      WE must beware the same type of growing unscrupulous power-seeking which is happening today!
      Season's wishes to you and may you have a healthy New Year. Prosperous will have to wait!

    • @holydiver73
      @holydiver73 3 года назад +19

      @MichaelKingsfordGray well that’s a rubbish counter argument. You dishonour my grandfather by making it. You idiot.

    • @cheekytyke
      @cheekytyke 3 года назад +6

      @@holydiver73 that is a very gracious reply. Your grandfather must be proud of you. You was obviously brought up well. Seasons greetings

    • @o00nemesis00o
      @o00nemesis00o 3 года назад +2

      Jaded Jedi He was well within his rights to tell the idiot to go jump in a laks

    • @cheekytyke
      @cheekytyke 3 года назад +2

      @@o00nemesis00o he really was

  • @Kevin-mx1vi
    @Kevin-mx1vi 3 года назад +42

    My Mum (born 1932) remembers Italian POWs working on farms close to where she lived, that they seemed very happy to do so, and that they were well liked and friendly.
    My late stepfather was a coal miner in South Yorkshire and worked in the mines with a small number of German POWs who were much appreciated and treated like anyone else. Coal mining is dirty, dangerous work and miners know they're relying on everyone else to get out alive at the end of a shift - the mine itself was a far greater danger than any "enemy".

    • @royfearn4345
      @royfearn4345 3 года назад +2

      And Maggie stuffed the miners! Shame on her.

    • @paulefc1971
      @paulefc1971 3 года назад +5

      @@royfearn4345 the miners were being stuffed long before Maggie came to power, she just finished the job

    • @Kevin-mx1vi
      @Kevin-mx1vi 3 года назад +1

      @@royfearn4345 Don't forget the other heavy industries she stuffed. Funny that they were all traditional Labour voting industries, don't you think ?

    • @o00nemesis00o
      @o00nemesis00o 3 года назад

      Roy Fearn how awful, closing down the evil coal mines

    • @Kevin-mx1vi
      @Kevin-mx1vi 3 года назад

      @@o00nemesis00o It was more about destroying communities because they didn't vote Conservative.
      And mines are not evil, just dangerous, but men were proud to call themselves miners.

  • @gort5583
    @gort5583 3 года назад +269

    Perhaps a good lesson for us all on how to be civil and human even in the worst of times!

    • @Ronnie-Jones
      @Ronnie-Jones 3 года назад +3

      The most forbidden documentary in history:
      “Europa The Last Battle” at archive dot org

    • @tonychristo8393
      @tonychristo8393 3 года назад +6

      Not only civil, which is what I would've expected from the british, even more so than americans, a very wise strategy!! Well done!!

    • @TheWtfnonamez
      @TheWtfnonamez 3 года назад +7

      Wise words brother. Our values mean nothing if we do not practise them universally.

    • @residentelect
      @residentelect 3 года назад +18

      @@TheWtfnonamez
      Exactly.
      I was an RAF medic and did several deployments on Op Herrick and Op Telic.
      During my time on the ground I actually patched up more Taliban fighters, insurgents and Afghan and Iraqi civilians, than Coalition casualties.
      Some of the more zealous combatants would fight us as we tried to administer them aid, and would scream at our translators, demanding to know why we were trying to save them. They had been told by their leaders that British and American forces executed injured combatants via bullet to the head, or crucify them in the desert.
      It sometimes jaded me, but my Boss put it into perspective one day for me; "By doing the exact opposite of what they would do if the roles were reversed is how we know we are better. Just because that guy now laying on the ground was shooting at us not five minutes ago, doesn't give us the right to decide if he lives or dies, and that's why when he's in our hands he's not the enemy, he's a casualty of war."
      Always stuck with me, and helped me keep my faith in humanity despite experiencing some horrendous situations.

    • @TheWtfnonamez
      @TheWtfnonamez 3 года назад +2

      @@residentelect Thank you for your service. Your words were food for thought and very wise.

  • @skylongskylong1982
    @skylongskylong1982 3 года назад +347

    20,000 Germans, and Italians decided not to go home, and stayed in the U.K.
    Check the statistics, it is eye opening.

    • @nigelmitchell351
      @nigelmitchell351 3 года назад +44

      Wow.! I had no idea it was that many, my Mum's walk to junior school near Coventry took her past Italians working the fields, she always said how friendly they were and used to make the children corn dolls and toys.
      My friend's German father a POW, stayed in England at the wars end, his home was in the Russian zone.
      I used to work at GEC Rugby and there were ex German POWs working there in the 70's along with Poles, Latvians, & Lithuanians, their stories were well worth listening to. One man I remember called Paul told me he had been as far east as Moscow.
      Always amazes me that these all these men were accepted, I wouldn't necessarily say all these men were buddies but they rubbed along without any actual trouble.

    • @ronphillips3339
      @ronphillips3339 3 года назад +16

      In my early career I worked with both German and Italian ex POW

    • @skylongskylong1982
      @skylongskylong1982 3 года назад +5

      @@nigelmitchell351 Thank you for your reply.
      The dark part is German POWs we’re kept in the U.K. till 1948 to work on the farms, and as Labourers.
      Due to Women’s Land Army wanting to return to civilian life.
      Clement Atley Of Labour has a lot to answer for.

    • @nigelmitchell351
      @nigelmitchell351 3 года назад +43

      @@skylongskylong1982 I see nothing wrong with that, call it reparations, many of these men would stay anyway as their homes were in the East.
      Compared to how many survived internment at the hands of the soviets they were very bloody lucky. Also there were no Dachau's in Britain, no executions of airmen in forests.
      I don't believe any Germans were forced to perform engineering roles such as bomb disposal.
      You might consider the treatment of Polish prisoners at the hands of the soviets.
      My neighbour, a Polish officer captured by the Russians, was in forced labour, which meant eradication through starvation in Siberia, before the nazis saved his life by invading Russia and turning the poles into their allies by default. These men and women were offered the chance to join the Red army, which they declined, or be marched all the way to the middle east and j join the British, which they accepted.
      No comparisons are valid.

    • @biulaimh3097
      @biulaimh3097 3 года назад +4

      Their country was destroyed.

  • @99fruitbat
    @99fruitbat 3 года назад +58

    I remember one German POW being amazed at being asked by a British leason Officer , if he was being well treated on the farm he was working on . I can also confirm that my German relatives prayed that it would be the British or Americans who marched into Berlin and not the Russians .

    • @desbrittain9952
      @desbrittain9952 3 года назад +1

      Unfortunately the Americans treated POWs disgracefully in Germany herding hundreds of thousands into open fields without shelter and very little food. Google Eisenhowers Death Camps.

    • @leehotspur9679
      @leehotspur9679 3 года назад +5

      @@desbrittain9952 Maybe the Execution of US troops around the time of the battle of the Bulge had something to do with it ??

    • @angelinazavala980
      @angelinazavala980 3 года назад +3

      @@desbrittain9952 the American prisons were still better than the soviet prisons. Many German soldiers retreated to American/British positions during the very late stages of the war. (not sure if the second sentence is true but I heard it in many videos)

    • @rogoth01themasterwizard11
      @rogoth01themasterwizard11 3 года назад +1

      @@angelinazavala980 soldiers as well as civilians marched for miles west in order to surrender to British forces, i'm not 100% on the details but i was told that the soldiers would still wear their Nazi uniforms but had white armbands or other symbols of surrender when they approached allied bases.

    • @Epiphany-818
      @Epiphany-818 3 года назад +2

      @@leehotspur9679 "the nazis did it so why shouldn't we?"

  • @TimmiTification
    @TimmiTification 3 года назад +262

    As a British chap this makes me proud. Love can set everyone free. ✌️

    • @conor1940
      @conor1940 3 года назад +1

      Pity ye still occupy parts of the world against their will

    • @billybobhouse9559
      @billybobhouse9559 3 года назад +18

      @@conor1940 what parts of the world?

    • @conor1940
      @conor1940 3 года назад

      @@billybobhouse9559 Gibraltar, ireland, Scotland ect

    • @abandonedworldgermany
      @abandonedworldgermany 3 года назад +53

      @@conor1940 Northern Ireland, Scotland and Gibraltar all have had referendums rejecting independence and on my last trip to Gibraltar I remember there being a lot of British flags flown round the country and outsides peoples homes ..

    • @conor1940
      @conor1940 3 года назад

      @@abandonedworldgermany that's just false Scotland was the only one lmao

  • @Chalky.
    @Chalky. 3 года назад +167

    During wars soldiers are essentially just willing or unwilling tools for their leaders, so I do respect how fair they were treat and not just as an enemy to be punished.

    • @idfk1123
      @idfk1123 3 года назад +12

      Its because the British are civilized and dont see every german man (at that time) as an enemy.

    • @anav587
      @anav587 3 года назад +5

      @@idfk1123 Bull shit they were civilized.
      Churchill deliberately caused a famine in Bengal that killed 4 million

    • @idfk1123
      @idfk1123 3 года назад +7

      @@anav587 Jesus, no need to be like that!

    • @iancampbell4373
      @iancampbell4373 3 года назад +1

      @@idfk1123 It is however true!

    • @idfk1123
      @idfk1123 3 года назад +7

      @@iancampbell4373 Well, aside from that he did some amazing things for Britan and its commonwealth nations.

  • @annek.h.9733
    @annek.h.9733 Год назад +4

    The grandfather of a good friend of mine was a PoW in England and he said he and his comrades were treated strict but very well and fair by the English. He was so grateful for it and had nothing but much respect and gratitude for England and its people until he died. Thank you for treating our soldiers so nice though they were enemies. Regards from Germany.

  • @MauriatOttolink
    @MauriatOttolink 3 года назад +52

    WELL WORTH A GOOD READ!
    There was a great story of a high ranking German Officer..p.o.w who was billeted in a private house in village in Scotland.
    Much later, the by then elderly lady described their 'guest' to whom they had given hospitality.
    "He was an absolute gentleman. He bowed and clicked his heels whenever we encountered him leaving the house or returning home.
    Spoke excellent English but had to learn our scottish accents.
    He did ANYTHING heavy about the. house. Wouldn't let me or my ailing husband carry anything heavy.
    In the kitchen he was limited but did any of the mundane tasks.
    Eventually he saw that our garden was badly in need of attention and said that at home
    his love was of gardening (Gartenarbeit) and would love to to tidy it up.
    The lawn was restored to its former glory and in autumn before he was repatriated, he gave the lawn its last cut before winter. She was asked for permission for him to plant some bulbs in the lawn. "They will be beautiful in Spring when I am gone... Something by which I hope you will remember me."
    She agreed and chose and financed the purchase of a large quantity of crocuses (croci?)
    and he spent hours of back breaking working, carefully planting these bulbs.
    He eventually made his courteous farewell speech.
    "Vielen Dank für Ihre Freundlichkeit und Gastfreundschaft während meines Aufenthalts in Ihrem schönen Land.
    Wir hätten wirklich nicht im Krieg sein sollen! "
    "Thank you for your kindness and hospitality during my stay in your beautiful country.
    We really shouldn't have been at war!"
    When the crocuses bloomed in March, before the grass needed cutting again, they read
    "HEIL HITLER!" in big letters.

    • @alexrennison8070
      @alexrennison8070 3 года назад +1

      Sacre Bleu!

    • @StillAliveAndKicking_
      @StillAliveAndKicking_ 3 года назад +14

      Funny but I don’t believe it.

    • @lukekelly8522
      @lukekelly8522 3 года назад +1

      That’s quality

    • @basicallydr3f273
      @basicallydr3f273 3 года назад +4

      funny but i doubt its real

    • @iancampbell4373
      @iancampbell4373 3 года назад +2

      @@StillAliveAndKicking_ It is actually true. There are stories of POWs being smuggled to local dances for a night out. Comrie as a small town did very well from German gratitude to their treatment during WW2 after 1945.

  • @brianrodney5202
    @brianrodney5202 3 года назад +66

    I remember the Italian POWs in Leeds. They couldn't stop smiling ,as they were only too happy to be done with the war !

    • @Hriuke
      @Hriuke 3 года назад +2

      Around Southampton the Italian community is fairly large with guys who chose to stay after the war.

    • @barneyquinn3657
      @barneyquinn3657 3 года назад +1

      Ditto for Dewsbury, where I grew up!! 6 miles from Leeds.

    • @terryofford4977
      @terryofford4977 3 года назад +4

      Hi Brian, coming from Calverley Nr Leeds, I lived adjacent to a POW camp during the war, Italian and later German POW'S The camp near my School was known as Ferncliffe, it was entered via Clara Drive, adjacent to St Wilfred's Church School where I was in the infants class, I'd have been around 8 or 9 by the time all the POWS had left when the camp was taken over by DP's (Displaced Persons obviously avoiding going back to live under Russian rules. I had known prisoners there from being around 4 years of age, Italians were first, Then Germans. There was a Submarine guy there we knew as 'The Captain, and another POW we knew as Hans Sherniman who my 18 years old Brother was to meet up with years later in Germ,any.After the POWS left, the ex Army/POW/ camp became a DP Camp for Displaced persons, Poles and others from Europe, we knew, met, played football/cricket with and many inter marriages took place, all memories about the place were goods, ones.Maybe this short note will jog a few memories.

    • @generalgta3528
      @generalgta3528 3 года назад +2

      @@terryofford4977 Hey, are you old?! Please reply to me!!!

    • @queenbabylonia4594
      @queenbabylonia4594 2 года назад +1

      I don’t think the Italians wanted to be part of the German regime, Mussolini (Italy’s Dictator) made the pact with Hitler (Germany) , but I doubt the people agreed with Hitlers ideology .

  • @ScienceChap
    @ScienceChap 3 года назад +74

    My late local priest was a former Luftwaffe fighter pilot who was shot down during the Battle of Britain and asked to stay in the UK post-WW2.

    • @fightersweep
      @fightersweep 3 года назад +1

      Fascinating! What was name?

    • @HM-hu4hu
      @HM-hu4hu 3 года назад +1

      @Notareptile Kiddyfiddler?!

    • @charliezz6746
      @charliezz6746 3 года назад

      I'm suprised a former luftwaffe pilot who could potentially have been flying over England hoping to bomb the country perhaps even civilian areas could become a priest years later in an English church etc

    • @MauriatOttolink
      @MauriatOttolink 3 года назад +1

      Science chap
      I hear that he said "Pleeze.. Don't sent mee back to zat bloody saurkraut und currywürst!

    • @soupman3285
      @soupman3285 3 года назад

      @@charliezz6746 He was a fighter pilot. They had nothing to do with bombing england. They just escorted bombers that were actually going to bomb civilian areas.

  • @mrhairyhobbit9999
    @mrhairyhobbit9999 3 года назад +235

    The Canadians treated there prisoners of war so well they didn’t want to leave

    • @K4izerr
      @K4izerr 3 года назад +45

      Sorry for taking you prisoner eh

    • @737simviator
      @737simviator 3 года назад +2

      Thats the whole entire idea... In order to impede any potential escapes, POWs were paid not in British currency but with “camp money”, paper and plastic facsimiles which they earned for undertaking camp labour. However, somewhat inevitably, a thriving alternate industry sprang up. Willi Bungart is a German POW who was captured aged 17 and spent four years in a number of British POW camps. POWs who were considered to be “benign” were given the opportunity to earn “proper” money by working outside the camps. They were paid a fair wage for this work and many took the opportunity to save for a future outside the camps. The prisoners worked alongside locals and “lumberjills” - members of the Women’s Timber Corps - bringing in the harvest and helping with the timber management: “None of us liked the sugar-beet harvest,” remembers Gloucestershire man Humphrey Phelps in his book on wartime life, “but the Italians talked and laughed as they worked and occasionally burst into song.”
      Even local men and women whose loved ones were away fighting in the war and who were initially mistrustful of the “enemy” in their midst often found that this antipathy wore off once they’d spent some time working alongside POWs. It wasn’t uncommon for friendships to be struck up and for POWs to be invited into civilians’ homes for Christmas lunch. In Scotland, one farmer requested that the Italian POWs working on his farm be given permission to live in one of his outbuildings rather than have to make the long trek back to camp at antisocial hours.

    • @PaleRejent
      @PaleRejent 3 года назад +1

      @22 22 umm is this a troll or a neo nazi

    • @matthewthesaladbowl6315
      @matthewthesaladbowl6315 3 года назад

      @Bradyn Urfer I swear USA were famous for atrocities in ww2. That’s what I learned in chocolate land aka belgium

    • @matthewthesaladbowl6315
      @matthewthesaladbowl6315 3 года назад +2

      @22 22 lmao nazi

  • @LukesYuGiOhChannel
    @LukesYuGiOhChannel 3 года назад +40

    Britain showing their class as per usual.

    • @billolsen4360
      @billolsen4360 3 года назад +11

      Well, Brits ARE very hospitable, so I guess that extends to enemy soldiers & airmen as well.

    • @Alexander_Snowden
      @Alexander_Snowden 3 года назад +13

      @@billolsen4360 Of course. We shot you down? Have a cup of tea, and sit out the rest of the war.

    • @madmike171
      @madmike171 3 года назад +7

      @@Alexander_Snowden "Come on lad sit down and enjoy your tea, after all we dinged your nice fancy air-carriage, it's only fair".

    • @wildeyshere_paulkersey853
      @wildeyshere_paulkersey853 Год назад

      And what did we get for it....
      Waste of time.

  • @chickenandmushroompotnoodl3180
    @chickenandmushroompotnoodl3180 3 года назад +133

    I suspect a few “local” football teams lost games on penalties!
    I’ll get my coat.

  • @DawgBreff
    @DawgBreff 3 года назад +111

    During ww2 my great aunt was a member of the "Land Army", working farm land.. one of the farms used Italian POWs, and one day, one of the POWs made the mistake of squeezing her ass... She knocked him out cold with one punch, something he was apparently reminded of and teased by his fellow POWs over for the rest of his time in England.
    R.I.P. Betty ❤

  • @kenttheboomer721
    @kenttheboomer721 3 года назад +11

    My UK parents-in-law told a story of an Italian POW that was allowed to travel from one place to another on a bike. Apparently he would sing loudly with a "....lovely voice...." as he pedaled along. This was in Flintshire of N. Wales.

  • @josephverrett1680
    @josephverrett1680 3 года назад +34

    When I was stationed in England in 1979 I met an ex German POW. He told me that they were sent out to work the farmers fields. Most time with one or no guards.
    I asked him why he didn't escape back to Germany he said he had it made was being fed well and treated better than in Germany and he would have to go back on the battlefield and he was forced into the army and didn't believe in Hitler's war.

    • @andrewripley7461
      @andrewripley7461 3 года назад +3

      Absolutely true. My old mechanic found his way to a Yorkshire POW camp. They we're forced to work on the farms, but if you did you got better rations and this was an incentive. In fact he said that the food was better as a POW than in the army. There weren't any real guards at the camp either, as none of them wanted to escape. He stayed and married a local lass after the war and set up his own garage business.

    • @davidjones332
      @davidjones332 3 года назад +2

      Before D-Day my uncle was a sergeant stationed at St Andrews. All the maintenance of their unit vehicles was undertaken by Austrian POWs, and one actually taught my uncle to drive.

  • @TheFiown
    @TheFiown 3 года назад +39

    There was a camp in Scotland behind my family home and the prisoners came to help in the garden and fields and often made things for the kids, no one treated them as the enemy, it was what it was.

    • @737simviator
      @737simviator 3 года назад

      That is the idea so they dont escape.... In order to impede any potential escapes, POWs were paid not in British currency but with “camp money”, paper and plastic facsimiles which they earned for undertaking camp labour. However, somewhat inevitably, a thriving alternate industry sprang up. Willi Bungart is a German POW who was captured aged 17 and spent four years in a number of British POW camps. POWs who were considered to be “benign” were given the opportunity to earn “proper” money by working outside the camps. They were paid a fair wage for this work and many took the opportunity to save for a future outside the camps. The prisoners worked alongside locals and “lumberjills” - members of the Women’s Timber Corps - bringing in the harvest and helping with the timber management: “None of us liked the sugar-beet harvest,” remembers Gloucestershire man Humphrey Phelps in his book on wartime life, “but the Italians talked and laughed as they worked and occasionally burst into song.”
      Even local men and women whose loved ones were away fighting in the war and who were initially mistrustful of the “enemy” in their midst often found that this antipathy wore off once they’d spent some time working alongside POWs. It wasn’t uncommon for friendships to be struck up and for POWs to be invited into civilians’ homes for Christmas lunch. In Scotland, one farmer requested that the Italian POWs working on his farm be given permission to live in one of his outbuildings rather than have to make the long trek back to camp at antisocial hours.

    • @manutd19999
      @manutd19999 3 года назад

      Your gorgeous

    • @ivartheboneless5969
      @ivartheboneless5969 3 года назад

      It’s a bunch of shit. If your father or brother was out fighting and got caught they would be tortured too death if not worked and starved too death. But when they get caught we let them work on the farms and check in on them too make sure they are doing well. I know we’re meant too be the good guys but when are you just letting people off with horrible crimes.

    • @weirdstonk729
      @weirdstonk729 6 месяцев назад

      @@ivartheboneless5969 In this video he talked about one of the prisons which held POWs with very little to no Nazi feelings, he said the camps which held real Nazis were way stricter and didn't get the luxuries the prisoners in this camp did. British, French and American soldiers who were captured by Germans were also taken care of well although they treated Soviet soldiers like animals (which they returned to German soldiers who were captured after the war).

  • @cricketerfrench7501
    @cricketerfrench7501 3 года назад +20

    My Father "So Nestor how did you come to be a prisoner? Nestor " We were by the sea and it was hot so we went for a swim. When we got back to shore the British were there". Nestor was an Italian who remained in England for all of his life after being captured in North Africa.

  • @Lewakaassemme
    @Lewakaassemme 3 года назад +29

    My (German) grandmother grew up on a farm in Bavaria, where they "employed" a handful of French POWs. She was quite young back then and used to play with them, she told me. They were treated as well as every native worker would have been treated, had their own rooms (she lost all of her four brothers who fell in Russia).
    Many came years later to visit her a couple of times. She passed away five years ago.
    I was glad to know my ancestors behaved human under these circumstances.

    • @bepolite6961
      @bepolite6961 3 года назад +6

      I served with on a NATO unit in Holland, my boss was German Sergeant Major and many of colleagues were German also, they were a great bunch of guys and our families socialised frequently. I had previously been stationed in Germany and had a smattering of German, whilst these guys had spent 10 weeks in school learning English before being posted to the unit. Inevitably conversations would sometimes be about the wars. The conclusion would be, look at us now and how crazy and tragic the whole damn thing had been. One of the guys told me, his father was the only surviving brother of eight boys, his brothers all died on the Eastern Front, his father, was to young to be conscripted. I have some very fond memories of them all. I particularly remember the guys struggled to understand our, "Brits", sense of humour. In particularly taking the piss out of each other. Mike, our boss, would tell his German comrades, if the Brits take the piss out of you, it means they like you, your considered one of them. The guys struggled getting their heads around that concept. All in our 60's now. often wonder how they and their, now grown up kids are doing.

    • @jamesguitar7384
      @jamesguitar7384 3 года назад +5

      @@bepolite6961We're the only people who will introduce a friend with " This is Bill . He's a knob"

    • @bepolite6961
      @bepolite6961 3 года назад +2

      @@jamesguitar7384 lol

    • @naguerea
      @naguerea 5 месяцев назад

      one of my 4 sons has a partner from Munich, her mother pays for dear Eliga;s private schooling, he is the top skier in his school runs faster than anyone else, speaks German like a native. how we love him.

  • @davidallen1516
    @davidallen1516 3 года назад +51

    If you’ve never been to Eden Camp you are missing a great day out it’s a must see camp....

    • @suzyqualcast6269
      @suzyqualcast6269 3 года назад

      Point taken. Is it near to ex RAF/USAF Edenbridge ?

    • @stevetaylor8698
      @stevetaylor8698 3 года назад +1

      @@suzyqualcast6269 No, I believe Edenbridge is in Kent and is some 250 miles from Eden Camp which is in North Yorkshire.www.edencamp.co.uk/

    • @sunnyjim1355
      @sunnyjim1355 3 года назад

      I've been to Auschwitz. I even spent a night sleeping in one of the prison huts. So, going to Eden Camp would just be like going to Butlins to me.

    • @Fruitgum-xc7co
      @Fruitgum-xc7co 3 года назад

      I've been there during a school trip,

    • @gabrielleconway5219
      @gabrielleconway5219 3 года назад

      visited eden camp a couple of years ago.remember being astounded by the fact that the pow rations were better than what the locals were eating

  • @Dive-Bar-Casanova
    @Dive-Bar-Casanova 3 года назад +7

    A Former German POW lives in our neighborhood and still on occasional evenings walks by our house. 99 years old. Immigrated to the US and became an exec with Benz.
    Captured in Africa, sent to the US and worked a citrus farm not too far from where he lives today.
    "We were well treated, even paid for our work" he once told me.

  • @ThreenaddiesRexMegistus
    @ThreenaddiesRexMegistus 3 года назад +34

    Many Italians were sent to Australia and New Zealand where they endeared themselves to their captors and some even elected to stay after hostilities had ceased.

  • @glenmartin2437
    @glenmartin2437 3 года назад +29

    I have met many German people who immigrated either to Canada, then the USA or directly to the United States.
    Their common remark was "too many ghosts." Many had lost many family members, sometimes their whole family.
    One German man had lost his wife and children, remarried only to have his second wife and children killed during an air raid.
    He hated the Nazis. He commonly asked me how we Americans would even allow the Neo-Nazis to even exist in the United States.
    I simply shook my head and said "We are naively stupid!" He was most grateful to be an American and to be free to remarry and raise children in a free land.

    • @kb.brandyn6798
      @kb.brandyn6798 3 года назад

      They boiled nat Turner alive and ate him in little jars made news articles about it🤷🏾‍♂️ were not too far off

  • @RobWhittlestone
    @RobWhittlestone 3 года назад +20

    In the 1980's I worked with the son of a former German POW who had married an English girl. They settled down and lived the rest of their lives in UK. I am relieved that we treated them decently on the whole. Too many bad things can happen in wartime and it is not easy to keep to an honourable path.

    • @ivartheboneless5969
      @ivartheboneless5969 3 года назад

      Do you not think it’s a bit weird how if they caught your grandpa they would of worked, tortured and starved him too death, but they get caught here any they get given nice place too live a new job and people checking in on them too make sure they are getting treated well. Even when the Germans where the ones doing the most war crimes, and started the war by not abiding by there reparations.

  • @glynnwright1699
    @glynnwright1699 3 года назад +14

    We had a POW camp near our house. When the POWs left, the buildings were turned into home for families that had been victims of German bomber raids and had lost their homes. They continued to be family homes well into the 1970s, until better options were available.

  • @craigs71
    @craigs71 3 года назад +25

    Eden Camp is great place to visit and not too far away is the Elvington Air Museum which is also worth a look.

    • @ml8182
      @ml8182 2 года назад

      What elvington air museum never been

  • @Brigantius
    @Brigantius 3 года назад +10

    Many years ago I knew two former german POWs. One was a work colleague. He had been one of those allocated to a farm and had eventually married a local woman and settled here permanently. He never returned to Germany. He was very fortunate as he had spent much of the war as a soldier on the eastern front but had been in the west when captured by the British. He appreciated the way he had been treated here as a POW. He told me some stories about his experiences of the horrific conditions in the east. The second was a former U-boat officer. He learned good english while in the camps and a few years after repatriation to Germany his employer asked him to help open a branch factory here. He moved his family over here and settled here permanently, where he was a near neighbour.

  • @JimHalpertFromTheOffice
    @JimHalpertFromTheOffice 3 года назад

    I love to study history and glad I stumbled upon your video. It shows a different perspective of a brutal war. Thanks for sharing.

  • @Pitcairn2
    @Pitcairn2 3 года назад +26

    My old friend Heinrich Kistenmacher was captured in Normandy, he did a stint in a US Camp then transferred to Pitlochry in Scotland, they were allowed out with supervison every weekend where they would bribe their guard with 2/6 pence to get into the local dance .. Here Henry met is wife, she was an assistant in Boots the chemist. They married after the war and Heinrich remained in the UK, where he became a manager at the local theatre and he was well respected by the town. later he taught German at a college in the Midlands.. alas Heinrich passed away very suddenly a few years ago, but we still keep in touch with his widow.

  • @spencerwilton5831
    @spencerwilton5831 3 года назад +22

    I still have various items given in thanks to my English grandparents by German POW's who assisted on their farm during and after the war. My grandparents treated them like family ensuring they were fed and clothed as well as their own. Many remained after the war and settled locally, others stayed in touch for the rest of their lives. I'm sure this was not at all uncommon.

  • @generalbee2855
    @generalbee2855 3 года назад +5

    My dad grew up near a POW camp. It had closed long before he was born, but a former POW stayed in the town. He married a local and started his own business. He sold ice cream to people and he was happy. Everyone liked him and he was kind.
    Not everyone on the opposite side of a conflict are evil. Some are quite nice.

    • @naguerea
      @naguerea 5 месяцев назад

      well said .

  • @alanfrehley1373
    @alanfrehley1373 3 года назад +54

    The complete opposite of a Japanese POW camp!
    Excellent video!

    • @billolsen4360
      @billolsen4360 3 года назад +2

      A family friend ended up in one of those in WW2 at age 18. Had very little to eat & the commandant kept threatening him with beheading, probably just because he enjoyed watching a teenager deal with impending death. Never could get a good night's sleep.

    • @davidgiles5030
      @davidgiles5030 3 года назад +1

      A friend's father was captured at Hong Kong. He hated the Japanese with a fury till the day he died.

    • @katsuakira2724
      @katsuakira2724 3 года назад

      Staved because allies decided to bomb fields and blocked food so the remaining left over went to our own the people to blame for starvation was allies who like to bomb civilians

    • @SuperJohn12354
      @SuperJohn12354 3 года назад

      The British invented pow and concentration camps in the Anglo Boer War , they took the families of the Boers locked them up and starved them and purposely infected them with measles and they were the lucky ones, Kitchener the British General in charge would organize sport styled hunts where British soldiers would be rewarded for killing anything that would deprive the enemy of sustenance including women and children, the Term Scorched Earth was invented in this time and referend to the destruction of houses and farms burnt to rumble. The Germans may be remembered for adopting concentration camps and there ruthless efficiency but it was the British that invented them .

  • @manfreddreschflegel1067
    @manfreddreschflegel1067 3 года назад +36

    They were treated very well.My dad told me and he had nothing but praise for the British.

    • @mikewray6387
      @mikewray6387 3 года назад +4

      good to hear Manfred, my father was a british soldier, he met my german mother in Braunschweig after the war, they settled in England in 1951, she never had a cross word said against her , i am the result so i love both countries. schone grussen aus england.

    • @manfreddreschflegel1067
      @manfreddreschflegel1067 3 года назад +8

      @@mikewray6387 My dad once said should you one day meet an english person always treat them with kindness and respect because I was treated that way.Little did he know that one day I would end up living here in Britain.That is now 41 years ago and I haven't looked back since.

    • @mikewray6387
      @mikewray6387 3 года назад +3

      @@manfreddreschflegel1067 good to hear Manfred, your father sounded wise and kind, have a great christmas in these troubled times. schuss.

    • @manfreddreschflegel1067
      @manfreddreschflegel1067 3 года назад +4

      @@mikewray6387 Vielen dank und ich wuensche auch dir und deiner Familie eine Frohe Weihnachten.🍻

  • @moogdome2562
    @moogdome2562 3 года назад +18

    Another really great and informative presentation. thank you.

    • @suzyqualcast6269
      @suzyqualcast6269 3 года назад

      Back that. Used to be several POW camps up round here in N. Derbyshire.

    • @MauriatOttolink
      @MauriatOttolink 3 года назад

      moog Dome
      I couldn't agree more!

  • @desh5164
    @desh5164 3 года назад

    Sensitively dealt with and extremely informative. I very much enjoyed it. Thank you very much.

  • @abandonedworldgermany
    @abandonedworldgermany 3 года назад +2

    Fantastic video very interesting and a side of history we don’t hear a lot about, love the video!

  • @danbreen0
    @danbreen0 3 года назад +6

    Great video! Really enjoyed.

    • @TheUntoldPast
      @TheUntoldPast  3 года назад +1

      Thanks for the comment mate! Glad you enjoyed :)

  • @crumpetcommandos779
    @crumpetcommandos779 3 года назад +7

    Solid video mate!

    • @TheUntoldPast
      @TheUntoldPast  3 года назад +1

      Thanks for the comment mate, glad you enjoyed it! :) I'll be doing another video soon about specifically life at the POW camp I filmed at.

  • @tonyjedioftheforest1364
    @tonyjedioftheforest1364 3 года назад +2

    Should say that this is an excellent video, I have just subscribed.

  • @gringopig
    @gringopig 3 года назад +1

    Excellent presentation! Thank you

  • @FordyHunt
    @FordyHunt 3 года назад +10

    "A society should be judged not by how it treats its outstanding citizens but by how it treats its criminals."

    • @queenbabylonia4594
      @queenbabylonia4594 2 года назад +2

      They were not criminals as such, they were Prisoners of War.

  • @donohoe71
    @donohoe71 3 года назад +5

    Really well researched and narrated video, Love the montage that came with it. Thanks for posting

  • @bionicdibble270
    @bionicdibble270 3 года назад +2

    Great video! Thank you!

  • @radiocrash
    @radiocrash 3 года назад

    What a fantastic video, thank you for making it.

  • @g2macs
    @g2macs 3 года назад +23

    You'll find that Glasgow had a large Italian community mainly from POW's who didn't want to go home. They were well respected (mostly) as they usually ran the best chip shops and Ice cream parlours in the area, In fact, locals didn't say 'chippie' but 'Tallies' when referring to them.

    • @oldman2800
      @oldman2800 3 года назад +5

      An Italian POW camp at Hay in outback Australia was the genesis of the most multicultural city of Griffith in Oz today. The Italian POWs were let out to work as the country was desperately short of labor, friends and relationships were begun as Italians were respected as our allies in WW1. When the war was over all the POWs were sent back home and as Italy was destitute many of them promptly brought their families back to Griffith and turned a sleepy country town into a dynamic modern city bring the best of their culture with them.
      My sister married an Italian migrant boy so it has touched and made an incredible influence for all of us.

  • @terryansell6641
    @terryansell6641 3 года назад +5

    Very interesting video thank you from New Zealand

  • @glenmartin2437
    @glenmartin2437 3 года назад

    Thank you for the video.

  • @bcfairlie1
    @bcfairlie1 3 года назад +1

    Very informative. I knew nothing about this

  • @jimshepard7099
    @jimshepard7099 3 года назад +3

    Well done an excellent video . Can I suggest that anyone interested look at 'The Germans we kept ' based largely on a camp in Lancashire . This was made several years ago and has interviews with ex pow's and also local people . It really does give an insight into post war Britain and to a lesser extent Germany .

  • @oldseadog3386
    @oldseadog3386 3 года назад +27

    My grandfather had several German prisoners on his farm in Essex that went back and forth between the camp and the farm with just one guard. They were glad to be out of the war and worked well.

  • @ezswann8176
    @ezswann8176 3 года назад

    Thanks for the history... love it I subbed

  • @PassportToPimlico
    @PassportToPimlico 3 года назад +50

    Trent Park in London was where all the very highest ranking prisoners were kept, unaware that the British had microphoned the whole place up. That in itself is a fascinating story.

    • @Michaelbos
      @Michaelbos 3 года назад

      Wouldn’t you ? 😎

    • @PassportToPimlico
      @PassportToPimlico 3 года назад

      @@Michaelbos They had microphones in some of the trees. Their handler would walk a general around the park, pausing at a tree to ask, "So what do you think of Mr Hitler?"

    • @alanjm1234
      @alanjm1234 3 года назад +12

      It was found that treating prisoners well, and allowing them to associate with each other (while listening in) was more effective for gathering intel than torture.

    • @geoffstrowger9759
      @geoffstrowger9759 3 года назад +2

      I lived within a mile of that camp and never knew about it until recently!

    • @cideryeti7957
      @cideryeti7957 3 года назад

      Here is a YT PBS film of Trent Park.
      ruclips.net/video/Pu_-BeKwiDY/видео.html

  • @Pynaegan
    @Pynaegan 3 года назад +32

    13:05
    Damn, they even had a place where they could go in order to take matter "into their own hands".

  • @Trevor_Austin
    @Trevor_Austin 3 года назад +8

    Many Italians POW’s were “imprisoned” on the site of the London Gliding Club in Dunstable. They were split into three groups. There were the fascist nutters, disliked by everyone. Then there were the “can’t be arsed” and the majority whom decided to make the best job out what they had. They worked on farms, built houses, did small jobs, baby sitting and were apparently a delight to have around. May did not return to Italy and their descendants are still found in Dunstable, Luton and Bedford.

  • @NilsAlbertsson
    @NilsAlbertsson 3 года назад

    I was lucky enough to visit Eden camp, not long after it opened as a museum several decades ago when I first worked in the UK, and it was good then... it looks like it has grown and improved quite a bit. I would urge and encourage anyone able, to visit the museum.
    Thank you for this video, The UntoldPast.

  • @treadingtheboards2875
    @treadingtheboards2875 3 года назад +2

    Thank you, a very interesting video. I was born in Ayr Scotland in early 1945. In perhaps 1948/9, my family and I lived in a Nissan hut that was part of a large village of huts on the Ayr outskirts.
    In the 1970's, an uncle wrote a story of his life in Ayr during the war years (He was 18 years old at this time.) and of the Italian POW's that would regularly venture into town to visit cafes, cinema and such, and were made welcome my the greater Ayr population.
    He even mentioned that the Nissan Hut that I lived in as a 3 - 4 year old, was a former POW hut that had been transported to Ayr for local accommodation. (Citation needed.)
    15 years ago, I played a German camp commandant in a stage production dealing with British POW's in Germany, doesn't fate have a sense of humor?

  • @elistickband
    @elistickband 3 года назад +30

    My grandad told me that early in the war, when groups of POW's were marched to the local camp, people threw stones at them. At the end of the war, when being repatriated, they threw cigarettes at them

  • @montygemma
    @montygemma 3 года назад +6

    I can tell you from first hand testimony they were treated very well.
    My grandad was injured in Italy and was unfit for service so he spent the rest of the war as a guard.
    He said they all become friends, security wasn't very tight near the end of the war because they were treated so well they weren't going anywhere especially back to Germany and the Russian front.They ate the same food as the guards, got their cigarettes and even on occasions taken to the pub. After the war the guards and the prisoners even wrote to each other.

  • @georgeknobbs504
    @georgeknobbs504 3 года назад +5

    Very heartwarming. Working class people all over the world, from any country, will always find they have a lot in common in terms of values. Its the people at the top who are at odds with each other. The irony is, as it will always be, it's never them at the top who have to kill each other.

  • @bossmusic8536
    @bossmusic8536 3 года назад +6

    *TheUntoldPast* Awesome and very cool music.. congratulations for this fantastic production and wish you all the best.. 🎬🎼👌🌎 i want see you on the top

    • @TheUntoldPast
      @TheUntoldPast  3 года назад

      Thanks for the great comment my friend! Take care too!

  • @j_gibbon
    @j_gibbon 3 года назад +31

    I think everyone in Yorkshire has been to Eden camp for at least one school trip, I went in 2006 I think.

    • @twooontheepicfish7162
      @twooontheepicfish7162 3 года назад +1

      not wrong

    • @leeboy26
      @leeboy26 3 года назад +1

      Three times from three seperate courses. Not complaining, though.

    • @T-1001
      @T-1001 3 года назад +1

      1995 for me, when I was in year 4. I bought a 9mm bullet keyring.

    • @j_gibbon
      @j_gibbon 3 года назад +1

      @@T-1001 think I was in year 5 or 6 so 2005/6 can't tell but was a cool place I distinctly remember the hut that had fake fire and the fake smoke stinking and the wood fort play area.

    • @T-1001
      @T-1001 3 года назад

      @@j_gibbon Oh yeah! I'd forgotten about the smells. Come to think of it my best friend bought a small bottle/vial of some sort of smell that he was very proud of.

  • @mats7492
    @mats7492 3 года назад +10

    My grandfather was a German POW in the US.. he always said he was never treated better than there... he actually gained weight and made friendships with the owners of the farms he worked at, getting invited to sit with them at the dinner table and such..

  • @peterherrington3300
    @peterherrington3300 3 года назад

    Really interesting video , top Marks 👍

  • @lancehymers4674
    @lancehymers4674 3 года назад +2

    My dad was a rear gunner in a Lancaster bomber in 12 Squadron RCAF in WWll. He was shot down on his 11th mission over the Ruhr and made it as far as Holland before he was captured. He ended up in Dulag-Luft 13B and said several of the guards were guys who were captured in WWl and always treated the prisoners well because of how well they were treated in captivity. His story of the battle around the camp to liberate it (the SS decided to dig in around the camp after the guards fled to ambush the American unit heading for the camp) and the insane conditions in the camp and nearby town while they were waiting to be repatriated home make a hell of a story. He passed away four years ago. He would have loved this video. Thanks. Lance in Canada

  • @alanmarr3323
    @alanmarr3323 3 года назад +68

    I had an evening of free drinks because the owner of the Cafe had been a prisoner of war in Britain

    • @generalgta3528
      @generalgta3528 3 года назад +1

      Wait, what do you mean?! Please reply to me, buddy!

    • @troikoth3332
      @troikoth3332 3 года назад +3

      @@generalgta3528 yo wtf

  • @monkeydust100
    @monkeydust100 3 года назад +17

    I used to work in a factory (making engine parts)with a guy who was captured by the Japanese, one day a group of japanese came around the factory , I've never seen someone so scared in my life. RIP john .

    • @T-1001
      @T-1001 3 года назад +7

      Not surprising. My great uncle hated them to his last day after what they had done to him. Tortured while building railways, survived a death march and as they retreated he was jammed into transport ships and was twice torpedoed by the Americans. First time he was picked up by a Japanese ship. Second time, he was pinned in the hold when some timber the ship was carrying fell on him as a result of the explosion. He nearly went down with the ship but the wood floated off him as the ship sank. He was picked up by the Americans after that. He weighed somewhere in the region of 5-6 stone.

    • @JohnDayDude
      @JohnDayDude 3 года назад +8

      @@T-1001 For those unfamiliar with the British "stone" as a measure of weight -- one stone equals 14 pounds. A person weighing 5-6 stone would weigh anywhere from 70 to 84 pounds.

    • @Neion8
      @Neion8 2 года назад

      @@JohnDayDude Which in turn is around 31-38kg

  • @HM-hu4hu
    @HM-hu4hu 3 года назад +1

    One of the best parts of this video is the number of very interesting comments with examples and further information and context.

  • @jimmcdonald9244
    @jimmcdonald9244 3 года назад

    Fascinating, thank you. Always wondered how the other side were treated.

  • @sammydingdong4540
    @sammydingdong4540 3 года назад +8

    Very interesting video,sounds better than the "holiday" my Father dragged us to Butlins in the 1960's

  • @frankteunissen6118
    @frankteunissen6118 3 года назад +23

    There were also several thousand German paratroopers in British camps in 1940. They had been taken prisoner by the Dutch in the Netherlands and shipped off to Britain.

    • @MauriatOttolink
      @MauriatOttolink 3 года назад

      Frank Teunissen
      And your point is?

    • @JohnDayDude
      @JohnDayDude 3 года назад +3

      @@MauriatOttolink It's an interesting tidbit of history.

  • @robertocorradi7571
    @robertocorradi7571 3 года назад +1

    Thank you . . . A very good account .

  • @kenmaund2836
    @kenmaund2836 3 года назад

    Excellent presentation. Regarding prisoner placement almost 100 000 Italians were shipped to South Africa, built their own town with a hospital, two theatres and numerous other amenities. The local camp commander was awarded a papal medal after the war.

  • @5amH45lam
    @5amH45lam 3 года назад +4

    To hear how PoWs were treated in the UK during WW2 makes me proud to come from Oldham, and to be British, too. It's not often, if ever, that I say that.
    I used to love hearing my father's stories about the air-raids on, and PoWs in, our town. Since his passing earlier this year, his accounts are now fading into history.
    A superb video, rich in content, expertly narrated. Thank you.

  • @Geoff4822
    @Geoff4822 3 года назад +23

    I interviewed a German POW and he told me that it was the sausages that were the wurst.

    • @MauriatOttolink
      @MauriatOttolink 3 года назад +2

      Geoff Ward
      Ba-bum! Very shrewd.

    • @StillAliveAndKicking_
      @StillAliveAndKicking_ 3 года назад +2

      Groan. Did the bad sausages create sour krauts?

    • @Geoff4822
      @Geoff4822 3 года назад +4

      @@StillAliveAndKicking_ Only in a Wurst Käse scenario

  • @robbabcock_
    @robbabcock_ 2 года назад

    Great video!

  • @nickdougan394
    @nickdougan394 3 года назад +7

    In the mid 1990s I worked for a large agricultural society (The Royal Highland and Agricultural Society of Scotland) and amongst other things they issued medals for long-serving farm workers. At that time many applicants were Germans who had stayed on to work on Scottish Farms, had married and started families.

  • @allenjenkins7947
    @allenjenkins7947 3 года назад +20

    I've been told by several former Italian and German POW's that they surrendered as much to avoid starvation as to avoid dying in battle. For some of the Italians it was the first time in their lives they'd been well fed. Exactly the opposite to what happened to Allied prisoners of the Japanese.

  • @davidbridge5652
    @davidbridge5652 3 года назад +23

    My Aunt is the result of my grandma getting it on with an Italian POW.

    • @Alistplay
      @Alistplay 3 года назад +5

      Cant blame her, those italian men eyy

    • @davidbridge5652
      @davidbridge5652 3 года назад +2

      @@Alistplay exactly, those Latin men with their charm's.

    • @ancientsolar2
      @ancientsolar2 3 года назад +1

      Pow Pow Pow and your Aunt appeared

  • @CancerGaming56
    @CancerGaming56 3 года назад +17

    I know this one guy in my secondary school who’s grandfather was a POW, who left the camp after the war, settled down in Britain and married a British woman.

    • @TheUntoldPast
      @TheUntoldPast  3 года назад +4

      That's a fantastic story mate, it was more of a common thing than you'd think following the Second World War. As the restrictions tended to be relaxed for the prisoners, naturally they became more sociable with people in nearby towns and villages. Infact within a few years after the war had ended, many Briton's had a great degree of sympathy for the POWs. Thanks again for the comment mate.

    • @CancerGaming56
      @CancerGaming56 3 года назад +3

      TheUntoldPast
      You’re welcome for the comment! I also heard about this Scottish village where most of the people there were descendants of German POWs. Forgotten it’s name sadly.

    • @TheUntoldPast
      @TheUntoldPast  3 года назад

      @@CancerGaming56 Thanks mate! I'll have to have a little look into that village! See what I can find!

    • @CancerGaming56
      @CancerGaming56 3 года назад +1

      TheUntoldPast
      You’re welcome

    • @retiree1033
      @retiree1033 3 года назад +2

      Google George Gebauer, Hitler youth to Church of England priest.

  • @exposingproxystalkingorgan4164
    @exposingproxystalkingorgan4164 3 года назад +8

    This video is educational as I did not know this information.

  • @bindgagger
    @bindgagger 3 года назад +33

    "Welcome to Britain - this is how civilisation actually looks..."

  • @amazonianm8876
    @amazonianm8876 3 года назад +5

    In the South Somerset/North Dorset borders where I used to live there were several Italian families who had been POW's and who had settled in the area after the war.

  • @thedevilriders101
    @thedevilriders101 3 года назад

    Wonderful! Thank you!

  • @teresahaigh6082
    @teresahaigh6082 9 месяцев назад

    Hello, I found this report very interesting. I have read about Le Marchant Camp in Wiltshire. I am particularly interested in a certain German POW who was held around the Chippenham area. I have posted his photo on Wiltshire FB pages and found out that his name was Bert Schrader (Schroeder?) and he’s been recognised because he played football for Calne Town in the 1950s. He was engaged to my aunt (they met when she was in the Land Army in Chippenham) but she died from TB in 1956. I would like to find out more about Bert, but I seem to have hit a brick wall now, having contacted Calne Town FC and received no reply, etc.. So, do you have any idea of how I can find out more about this POW - is there a list to be had of the POWs held in England?
    Many thanks
    Teresa