It is a bop! Everything NewJeans puts out is sounds really good and doesn’t give me a headache. There are some people who are just hating on everything NewJeans because of the office politics going on, when the girls did literally nothing wrong.
@@vlad5042 I’m mainly referring to these two dudes in the video and not seeing as many comments defending the song. But yeah, I think most people like it, I especially do
I think you guys misunderstood the purpose of newjeans, their songs are to make us lighter, not to make us feel something but to refresh the mind, and they do that very well
If you want to introduce New Jeans to a non fan, Ditto is a must. Ditto turned my anti fans friends to die hard bunnies 😂😂 yes, Danielle is always slay she's literally living disney princess n she has credit in How Sweet
Wdym « anti fan » ? How can you be an anti just bc you don’t like songs ? And sorry not sorry but if you became a die hard fan just bc of one song, you re not a fan of the artist.. you just enjoy one song. So your friend isn’t a bunny.
Minimalism is not for everyone. I like NJ music since it feels cleaner, easier, and the ears can wander everywhere without bumping into useless shit, and I don't get sensory overload. I see some people saying their music is somewhat lacking, but I think that's because NJ is simply trying to do the most with the least amount of parts. How sweet instrumental track could easily go into minimal techno album. They have excellent understanding on the art of minimalism.
for a part2: Hype Boy ditto(sideA&B) cool with you(sideA&B), side B has an interlude from the EP -- super shy was filmed in lisbon, portugal and attention, hype boy, eta and cool with you were filmed in barcelona
It seems like he were forced to come. lol. It would have been better if he could explained what he didn't like. From my perspective, it seems like he don't like the overall teenage girl vibe rather than the musical aspects, and if that's the case, it's okay to say so.
@@fijardim7I don’t think that’s what they were saying though. They mentioned the overall teenage girl vibe which is perfectly fine to hate. Especially when it comes to NewJeans who had a controversy for having underage members.
As someone who used to hate on kpop turned NewJeans fan, I obviously didn't like that he wasn't as excited and liking NewJeans too much, nothing wrong with that but I also see he's kinda confused on what NewJeans is offering compared to the normal overly saturated/show off type of KPOP where there's a standard structure and formula. NewJeans was created with going against the norm in mind, their songs were hated when they debuted by kpop fans because it was so different and "boring" but in reality they just keep things effortless and laid back. NewJeans became the new standard and demolished the girl crush trend and the overly structured songs, which is also why they are hated lol. I was surprised how their songs are not annoying the way other kpop groups are that just sounds like pots and pans to me. Their songs are chill and like he said, it's the feeling, it just makes me happy for some reason like a weight is lifted whenever I listen to them with my playlists full of RNB, Rap, old school hip-hop, and some rock.
The excuse for the Cookie lyrics was that in korean, "baking a cookie" is a slang used to refer producing an album, but the way it's said and the whole vibe makes it clearly suggestive for me.
Same, I often don't even pay attention to lyrics the first time I listen to a kpop song, I try to get the overall vibe first, but I only vaguely was listening to the lyrics on that first listen of Cookie and increasingly the alarm bells were going off. Unfortunately, the icky feeling of that song and how MHJ poorly handled the controversy around it made it difficult to enjoy their music. Progressively, her antics made me less and less interested in even trying. It's not any fault of the girls obviously, I feel bad for them and I hope they consider that if they break free from MHJ it might be better for their career overall... do they really want their whole career to be about MHJ?
@@NickaLah If MHJ got fired, Newjeans won't be active for at least two years after this album... HYBE said they will go vacation for 2 years till they found a new producer.
@@user_f777fff but that doesn’t make sense considering MHJ doesn’t produce any of newjeans music all she does is pick their music & concept & they record it & learn the dance for those songs…
You can’t have a hater reviewing K-pop. They ain’t going to like it. It’s already a pre-judged the book by its cover. I love k-pop and NJ is my best 4th generation.
@dolis_pup no because his opinion is already biased to not liking, he will not allow himself to possibly fully enjoying as art because he already has preconceived prejudices, this goes for any genre. Most of these songs in another context in wich he has a positive opinion already would sound different (and even better) to him. That's just how people works
@dolis_pup sorry to break it to you but your personal experiences are not common sense. He is not genuinely trying to find a music that he enjoys in a specific genre to surpass his prejudices, he is literally just being a real hater and taking the extra steps onto it because of youtube views. If he stops being a kpop hater they don't have content, simple as that
@@Talent_more_than_popularityeducate ur self and just watching some pictures isn’t enough. Start thinking and stop hating for no reason. You’re hating on some girls who will never see you, if you dislike them stop clicking on their content
THAT IS MF CRAZY THAT THEY DID THINK HOW SWEET IS THE WORST. Like idc, fuck opinions. They are absolutely incorrect. Their taste is shite if they found How Sweet to be the worst.
i agree w u but i dont think theyre being salty, esp the one guy seems like hes rly into them lol just his opinion. personally it might be one of my fav songs from them i like it more than anything on get up.
About the MBTI thing. The personality type cant change. Its just that the tests do not really work. Also the letters E or I do not mean someone has to be extraverted or introverted. It defines wether the dominant cognitive function is extraverted or introverted. Each personality type has four out of eight cognitive functions (thinking, feeling, sensing, intuition) that are either directed outwardly or inwardly (extraverted/introverted). For example ISFPs cognitive functions: 1. introverted feeling (Fi) 2. extraverted sensing (Se) 3. introverted intuition (Ni) 4. extraverted thinking (Te) There is more to it but i dont want to explain all that rn. Cognitive functions are way more important than the actual letters, but yeah a lot of people spread misinformation about MBTI Anyway, MBTI only gives information about how people take decisions and its not important to know but it can help to have a better understanding a person. Hope this helps
how sweet at the beginning it starts strong but you feel later that they add or (repeat) just to make it a full song but the start of the song is really good
This was painful to watch…. I appreciate that Atom really seems to enjoy New Jeans. I realize I’m supposed to appreciate the honesty but considering we came the realization pretty early on in this video that he seems to hate this music (while acknowledging they can sing)…. mmmm just rough to watch. There are some other song I would have recommended in place of a couple of these but I wouldn’t enjoy sitting through all the criticism again. I personally enjoy their music a lot, I totally vibe on it and I think the repetition is somehow cohesive with my personality. I can listen to New Jeans on repeat.
i think you guys just aren't fans of the genres they incorporate in general... supershy and eta are 'uk garage' a clubland sound thats made for dancing most songs in the genre have that repetitive nature and i'm a huge fan of the genre so those two songs are in my top 5 of new jeans song... 'how sweet' is 'miami bass' another clubland dance sound and again most songs in the genre have that repetitive sound.. you make the 'rave' reference and thats the genres they mostly incorporate so i think you might be missing the point.... most of their music is based on 'rave' 'clubland' genres. i prefer thse genres to rnb so for me attention and cookie are their weaker songs. different strokes for different folks.. (i'm not a fan of the trap/aggressive rap style of blackpink for example)but you guys would probably much prefer their rnb songs... for me none of their rnb songs make my playlist... apart from bubblegum
My favorite song by them is Gods. I know is produced by league of legends music team, but it brings out something SO DIFFERENT from what they usually produce. I absolutely love their voices there. But I also love New Jeans and Attention, this is probably my top 3. I loved your view points!!! See you next time!
I really love "How Sweet" and the sweet summer feeling it evokes! And TBH "Ditto" and "New Jeans" should be a part of a video like this [we need a part 2 soon].
i wanted to say something on the ETA concept, as you can see it’s about a girl who’s cheated on and her friends tell them to hurry up. That’s why we here horns and the song in general is loud, it can be annoying but it fits the concept. It’s also the same in almost all their songs int he album, ETA, ASAP, super shy (wait a minute), get up (meet me back in five),
Idk guys I feel like if your a true Newjeans fan you should be able to pronounce all the members names 😭 like especially if they’re your second favorite group
the guy from the left is trying his best to find one thing that he's going to hate lmao grow up dude not every song is supposed to be loud or hype beat.
@@hansuuuuuua you’re the ignorant one. Ive been watching him for a while and he actually does like some groups, for example IVE I can’t blame him, ive is just better But its proof if the song or group is good he will compliment them I don’t care what you think, at the end its his taste, if he doesn’t like a group its not a surprise he will find mean words to describe his unlikeness to them But again this channel is called hater reacts and if it offends you don’t click on the video Be ready for “hate” comments from him and grow up
I tend to notice that that depending on how deep you are into the arts, the more enjoyable NewJeans tends to be. The juxtaposition of super shy’s choreography to the lyrics and feel is addicting for lots of people who love to dance and it’s retro almost workout song feel makes it repetitiveness make sense to me is really solid. In my perspective as not just an artistic creative but also as a theatrical vocalist, How Sweet’s flat delivery is supposed to convey Nihility for that person and almost like relief that they’re gone. The song when talking about the person and the things they made you feel is so flat and deadpan because that’s how they made you feel. When they start with the “Toxic lover~ you know better~” you can practically see yourself having a good time with friends sending prank calls and voice messages to the “little demon in my storyline” about how they fumbled you and should know better because you’re so much happier now. In terms of the perspective of just music you want to listen to, these scores kinda make sense. The way I see it, NewJeans is something you have to truly experience to get the full feel. 💜🐰
When I first listened to newjeans, I also thought that some songs parts are annoying, but as you hear more and more times, you will understand their intention and start to enjoy it. (For me lah)
Their opinions are too technically textbook with the foundations being their subjective preferences. For example if we compare it to art, If their preferred style is Van Gogh's then they'll criticize every work of Picasso by stating every Van Gogh element that is missing from Picasso's paintings. They are knowledgeable in the realm of production and music theory so I'll give them that, but they lack an open mind. The main strength and grip of NewJean's music is sentiment and the timing that they debuted. People are reaching the point of burn out from all the EDM, trap, Retro, disco music coming out from 90% of the groups so when they released Attention, everyone was instantly enamored. Looking at most of their songs as standalone pieces of tracks is not the best way to look at them because their songs are objectively not that complicated, complex or dynamic and unfortunately, this channel just does not care about those intangibles which is disappointing but i get that's the way they wanna do it.
I think my problem with New Jeans and why I can't get into their music is that the music is a combination of music made for teenage girls and music made for tictok. Neither of those things are bad things at all, and that doesn't mean that some older people won't like their music as well. But in general I just don't think I'm the demographic, so their music always sounds like it's lacking something for me. However, the chorus to Hype Boy is one of the catchiest things I've ever heard.
The problem with your analysis/reaction is you both focus on finding negatives and then pretending to like some parts just to try and balance your reaction, ie passive aggressive reaction/analysis rather than taking the songs for what they are.
Yeah obviously he’s not going hear the differences in the tracks because you literally played ONLY the upbeat dance songs in their catalog????? It makes no fcking sense to only show him the songs with the same tempo and then by the time he gets to How Sweet he thinks it all sounds the same. No variation from their catalog shown AT ALL. Ditto is by far one of their most iconic songs by how refreshing and different it sounded to the rest of the industry, as well as Cool With You/Get Up. You literally showed him their radio hits. 😐
One thing I appreciate about these guys is that they don't cater to the fans. I hardly ever agree with their opinions, but I can trust they're being honest to their own views. TBH they try to be respectful of the artists while giving their honest opinion on the music. That's pretty rare for a reaction channel.
Hmm suprised...literally 90% reactors from youtube i seen all said it was a BOP...u guys are the 1st one to say it is bad. Still to each their opinion....for me choreo on point ..song maybe not tat good but after listenin to it 10 times....kinda start to grow on me...😅
Ditto and Hype boy are great, and missing them is truly a crime, but y'all, he can´t put all the songs yk, and I mean ALL NEW JEANS SONGS ARE BOPPPP, all these songs he showed today are very famous, I wasn't even a kpop fan and I already had Attention and Supershy on my playlist ykwim?
Yeah, Kazinho pretty much says what I feel about Cookie, BUT just to be clear there are huge differences between Britney having full control of her music/lyrics even as young as 16 and a 14 yr old having no power over whether she sings a song about the smell and taste of her pum pum. We have our own sins in the west for sure, but not only was that decades ago, Britney didn't get this suggestive immediately. Even then, I don't so much have issues with a 16 yr old or older having full control over how suggestive she is while performing, even though I'd hope it's done wisely without coercion. So, it's not like fans were concerned just because were talking about kpop, that is overall more "innocent" and not super suggestive even when we had more "grown" songs. I'd feel the same way if a 14 yr old American girl sang this song. EDIT: I still think this should really only be sung by 18 yr olds or older, but we're not dumb, 16 yr olds are generally not naive... but there's usually a power dynamic in this industry that usually makes me skeptical of what a 16 yr old can consent to when powerful execs hold their career in their hands. Britney however, insists she was in control of most creative aspects in her career, as in no one needed to convince her to be more sexy, despite what happened to her otherwise as far as being forced to perform more than she wanted or do projects she didn't care for.
i get what youre saying.. no problem if they were all over 18.. ideally 21.... but my only real issue was hyein being 14... even haerin being 16 wasnt that bad for me.. i'd question it but it wouldnt piss me off so much.. theres a huge difference in those 2 years of growing in the mental state of what is essentially a child and someone whos essentially pretty much nearly a young adult
if u guys interest in danielle ,she is the voice actor of little mermaid live action korean dub. She sing 'part of the world' korean version too. please check that song too.
you should consider doing one or 2 live performances for each group you check out. For newjeans, I'd recommend their performance of Gods at the League of Legends World championships last year
Ngl I get what he means with the monotony….The uk garage sound worked for Ditto but I don’t like how they made it their identity because the reason why their debut EP was good because of how distinct each tracks were aside from catchy. I don’t like how I had to “marinate” Super Shy and How Sweet to like it. They honestly felt lackluster and repetitive
Honestly I got into New Jeans late, myself and I was torn when I heard Cookie bc I knew about the controversy. It was a part of the reason I avoided the group for a bit, since I didn't want to support a company that I thought was exploiting minors..but mannnn Cookie does kinda slap tho and it makes my grown adult self want to throw it back (which just also further proves it was not an appropriate track for them to release when some of the members were in high school LOL).
For the people who are criticising him., I agree with most of his opinions on first listen what he was looking for that energy, he never got it, he could have if u had shown him Hype Boy and Ditto
I do give Kaz credit for giving specific reasons in his critique of why he doesn't like a song. He just doesn't go "I just don't like it, it doesn't vibe with me". And I agree with him that some NJ lyrics can get overly repetitive (umm, like Super Shy), but to me that's not a deal breaker - the whole vibe of the song works for me. Again props to Kaz for giving us his honest opinion, and I don't agree some/most of them - but that's ok. At the end of the day, we listen to what we like and who cares what other people say
Super Shys Instrumental is based on Powerpuff Girls so I think they were trying to find a way to make the song go with the Flow!! It's just my Opinion doe 😅
It seems like Atom chose the songs from new jeans that he likes and not what would appeal to Kazinho's tastes. If he liked Cookie, then show him Ditto, Cool with you, Gods, Bubble Gum, Hype Boy. He picked the tracks that are meant to be hyper commercial instead.
@@suhkawnit eh I never said the other songs were genre-bending zeitgeist shifting masterpieces. However, there is a marked difference between title tracks and b-sides. For what it's worth, being provocative or offensive doesn't make something revolutionary either; that shits been done to death as well.
@@Lilrascal4lyfe the majority of their discography are title tracks though lol? btw if a song is either too provocative, long, or complex to garner radio airplay, it is by definition not commercial. You don’t hear 10 minute prog epics being released as bands’ title tracks, now do you? No, even though those are probably the best songs, they release the most basic track on the album because that has the most commercial appeal. And that describes NJ’s entire discography. Short, catchy, and basic enough to appeal to the lowest common denominator and avoid being “too much” for anybody
@@suhkawnit I agree about the length of the song being a factor, attention spans have been shrinking rapidly over the last decade. Aside from that, what makes a song too provocative or complex in your opinion? Can you give me an example of a song released in the last 5 years that is both simultaneously entertaining and not status quo? I do have some examples in mind personally, but absolutely none within K-pop, which is why I find your criticism moot. Dreamcatcher for example deviates a bit musically, but if that counts then surely NJ utilizing a dead genre from the 80s in their new comeback fits the same criteria.
@@Lilrascal4lyfe A song can be too provocative for a number of reasons, most commonly due to uncomfortable lyrical themes, extreme vocal deliveries, or unconventional musical arrangements. We already have some examples in the past few months alone when (G)idle released Wife and Revenge. Both songs were banned from public broadcast due to the explicit imagery in their lyrics and/or MVs. Banned songs, by definition, have low commercial potential. You can even throw Super Lady in there - it literally opens with a barrage of belted high notes that a lot of people would find too overstimulating and turn the song off after 10 seconds. Not to mention the lyrics are explicitly anti-male. Now, I’m not saying a song needs to banned to not be hyper commercial. Those are just extreme examples. But NJ songs are the other extreme. Their lyrics are generic pop themes about liking a boy (and yes, it is explicitly about a boy) or, if they’re feeling spicy, vague messages about how that boy wasn’t good for them. They sing in a very limited and basic vocal range that is neither too high or intense too be overstimulating, not too low that it starts to sound too dark or mature. They have very basic and common pop voices that you can hear anywhere. NJ’s entire discography is like vanilla ice cream. Sweet yet bland enough that everybody can at least kind of enjoy it. But it lacks any intense flavor that might make risk turning people completely off. That’s what makes vanilla the most commercial ice cream flavor, and NJ’s music the most commercial in all of Kpop.
The thing is new jeans songs are so weird, i had to listen to them like 10 times to start loving them, you have to understand all those strange verses that will get stuck in your head for hours 🤩
I just think it's cool to hear a review from someone who doesn't really listen to the music itself. Kazinho's reviews just seem very honest and constructive. He reviews from a purely musical point of view and I find it very interesting to hear such a perspective. He knows a lot about music and says what he thinks, which is exactly how it should be!
I agree, I enjoy these reviews more than than the ones where people just clearly are faking how much they love the song. And I'm not saying that they all fake it just cause they like the song but some people are uber enthusiastic to the point that i can't even watch cause it's clearly not genuine.
i dont think he knows as much about music as he portrays... he says about newjeans music 'oh maybe if i was at a rave' without even realising the songs hes complaining about are actually based on 'rave' (or clubland) genres.. so of course they are going to be repetitive.. i dont think he even knows the genres of 'uk garage' or 'miami bass' on which the tunes are based on
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
You missed their best ones Hype Boy and Ditto.
Facts ❤
i think he chooses his "bestest" cuz no way theyre gonna watching all of them, but i agree theyre so good 😣
YESS
new reactors always miss them 😭
I think it’s cool because we realize how good is their music, not just mv or visuals.
Where are Hype boy and Ditto? Literally their two best songs...
Agree👍 !!!
Ditto absolutely
cool with you as well😕
Nah only Ditto 😁
@102.22they can watch the performance videos
Am I the only one who thinks How Sweet is a bop? I legit can’t stop listening to it 😭 that chorus is goooood (imo)
YAAAA
lol is it getting hate or smth? seems like most people ive seen liked it
It is a bop! Everything NewJeans puts out is sounds really good and doesn’t give me a headache. There are some people who are just hating on everything NewJeans because of the office politics going on, when the girls did literally nothing wrong.
@@vlad5042 I’m mainly referring to these two dudes in the video and not seeing as many comments defending the song. But yeah, I think most people like it, I especially do
I thought I'm not gonna like it because it feels little different from other NJ's songs that I like, but I actually like how sweet
I think you guys misunderstood the purpose of newjeans, their songs are to make us lighter, not to make us feel something but to refresh the mind, and they do that very well
And plus their songs have story telling and this mf didn't see that
@@beahlunchung-nn8lt SOO REALLL
If u have to explain how a song should be listened to, that's more of a reflection on the song itself than the listener imo
I don’t know about you but Ditto makes me emotional
Whole-heartedly disagree with you on this point. Maybe that’s how you listen to them.
If you want to introduce New Jeans to a non fan, Ditto is a must. Ditto turned my anti fans friends to die hard bunnies 😂😂 yes, Danielle is always slay she's literally living disney princess n she has credit in How Sweet
Wdym « anti fan » ? How can you be an anti just bc you don’t like songs ?
And sorry not sorry but if you became a die hard fan just bc of one song, you re not a fan of the artist.. you just enjoy one song.
So your friend isn’t a bunny.
Minimalism is not for everyone. I like NJ music since it feels cleaner, easier, and the ears can wander everywhere without bumping into useless shit, and I don't get sensory overload. I see some people saying their music is somewhat lacking, but I think that's because NJ is simply trying to do the most with the least amount of parts. How sweet instrumental track could easily go into minimal techno album. They have excellent understanding on the art of minimalism.
Exacto, la razón por la que puedo poner su música por horas sin que me ganas de apagar los audífonos de tantos cambios y ruidos fuertes
The exact reason why they are so big and different from every other group! Their simplicity is a breeze of fresh air!🤌🏻
thisss
agree... not everyone can bop with hard hip hop or high note part. Some other like chill and easy song that clear the mind.
What about Super Shy is minimalist??
for a part2:
Hype Boy
ditto(sideA&B)
cool with you(sideA&B), side B has an interlude from the EP
-- super shy was filmed in lisbon, portugal and attention, hype boy, eta and cool with you were filmed in barcelona
Also Bubble gum too.
not putting ditto is a crime!!!!
He really is a kpop hater lol
Actually, he's given quite a few songs higher than a 10 rating lol. From what I remember Stray Kids, XG, and IVE all got high scores.
to be honest i think hes a hater of pop music in general
@@NickaLah I don't know his way of thinking
@@user-luciddream Maybe he likes rock songs
He doesn't like boring,repetitive music. Newjeans is ridiculously overrated but whatever.
I thought hater was a bait to draw people in but after the whole video you're not lying.
i feel like hes just trying his hardest to not like kpop
@@va13ri35he liked a bunch of other groups actually, newjeans can’t be everyone’s cup of tea
@@za5532 Then why call him a hater? He doesn't hate it then
@@Amourlovess so people would click on the video obviously
@@za5532 I still don't get it.
I LOVE NEWJEANS OMGGGG. OT5 bias here 100%
Fav song ever is Attention, nothing tops it
heeey thank you for the attentioooooon! lol We'll see ourselves out now.
Cookie
It seems like he were forced to come. lol. It would have been better if he could explained what he didn't like. From my perspective, it seems like he don't like the overall teenage girl vibe rather than the musical aspects, and if that's the case, it's okay to say so.
It's definitely not okay to hate on young girls just because. Wtf
@@fijardim7I don’t think that’s what they were saying though. They mentioned the overall teenage girl vibe which is perfectly fine to hate. Especially when it comes to NewJeans who had a controversy for having underage members.
I guess but how do you hate fun like….
@@vividloona you make no sense
@@fijardim7 what do you think not liking=hating? don't be dumb
As someone who used to hate on kpop turned NewJeans fan, I obviously didn't like that he wasn't as excited and liking NewJeans too much, nothing wrong with that but I also see he's kinda confused on what NewJeans is offering compared to the normal overly saturated/show off type of KPOP where there's a standard structure and formula. NewJeans was created with going against the norm in mind, their songs were hated when they debuted by kpop fans because it was so different and "boring" but in reality they just keep things effortless and laid back. NewJeans became the new standard and demolished the girl crush trend and the overly structured songs, which is also why they are hated lol. I was surprised how their songs are not annoying the way other kpop groups are that just sounds like pots and pans to me. Their songs are chill and like he said, it's the feeling, it just makes me happy for some reason like a weight is lifted whenever I listen to them with my playlists full of RNB, Rap, old school hip-hop, and some rock.
YES!! 💯💯💯💯
PREACH
The excuse for the Cookie lyrics was that in korean, "baking a cookie" is a slang used to refer producing an album, but the way it's said and the whole vibe makes it clearly suggestive for me.
"Baking CDs" means Write CDs in korean on dictionary. It's not a slang.
@@user_f777fff ooh ok I thought it was just a slang tho, thanks :)
Same, I often don't even pay attention to lyrics the first time I listen to a kpop song, I try to get the overall vibe first, but I only vaguely was listening to the lyrics on that first listen of Cookie and increasingly the alarm bells were going off. Unfortunately, the icky feeling of that song and how MHJ poorly handled the controversy around it made it difficult to enjoy their music. Progressively, her antics made me less and less interested in even trying. It's not any fault of the girls obviously, I feel bad for them and I hope they consider that if they break free from MHJ it might be better for their career overall... do they really want their whole career to be about MHJ?
@@NickaLah If MHJ got fired, Newjeans won't be active for at least two years after this album... HYBE said they will go vacation for 2 years till they found a new producer.
@@user_f777fff but that doesn’t make sense considering MHJ doesn’t produce any of newjeans music all she does is pick their music & concept & they record it & learn the dance for those songs…
You can’t have a hater reviewing K-pop. They ain’t going to like it. It’s already a pre-judged the book by its cover. I love k-pop and NJ is my best 4th generation.
@dolis_pup no because his opinion is already biased to not liking, he will not allow himself to possibly fully enjoying as art because he already has preconceived prejudices, this goes for any genre. Most of these songs in another context in wich he has a positive opinion already would sound different (and even better) to him. That's just how people works
@dolis_pup sorry to break it to you but your personal experiences are not common sense. He is not genuinely trying to find a music that he enjoys in a specific genre to surpass his prejudices, he is literally just being a real hater and taking the extra steps onto it because of youtube views. If he stops being a kpop hater they don't have content, simple as that
@dolis_pup of course people can change opinions, im not arguing that. The thing is that he's not willing to, he's just making it for views
@dolis_pupif u don’t gaf then why u still replyin to them lil bro🤣🙏🏽
you guys should watch their reactions to other groups, seriously.
bro ditto not being here is a crime, like it’s already on the top10 best kpop tracks of all time.
No one can hate NewJeans, They’re a revolution💅✌️💕
What a revolution. It was invented by the fans. Their concept and new songs are a complete plagiarism. And the participants are unemotional
@@Talent_more_than_popularityeducate ur self and just watching some pictures isn’t enough. Start thinking and stop hating for no reason. You’re hating on some girls who will never see you, if you dislike them stop clicking on their content
even stealing blackpink's slogan? ''revolution'' xD
Nothings original about newjeans or there fans@@Orgil0122
@@Orgil0122they don't own the word💀
idk how you say how sweet is the worst of these songs, its definitely one of my fav new jeans songs
It’s a little flat for me personally , cookie is incredible but how sweet is just a little too repetitive, it’s easy going and good vibe which I like
The worst one by far for me is Zero. THIS is freaking repetitive
@@Dragonflyetc its literally a coca cola commercial song??
Personally how sweet is my least favorite new jeans song. So i agree that it's worse than cookie, attention, omg and etc.
THAT IS MF CRAZY THAT THEY DID THINK HOW SWEET IS THE WORST. Like idc, fuck opinions. They are absolutely incorrect. Their taste is shite if they found How Sweet to be the worst.
real how sweet is their best song 😭
@@triplestan_s7better than ditto? For me not. But we can have different opinions.
How sweet is a bop yall are salty
well, u chose to watch this video to hear about they’re opinion. you literally can’t be mad that they’re opinion isn’t yours.
i agree w u but i dont think theyre being salty, esp the one guy seems like hes rly into them lol just his opinion. personally it might be one of my fav songs from them i like it more than anything on get up.
@@yxqiverse Kpop fans are like that, they just like to whine
@user-lv8rg7hj7f and she's just saying she's opinion about they opinion, what's the problem?
@@mr.mauribachmann2632 she wasn’t giving an opinion about they’re opinion, she was straight up insulting them. Is calling people “salty” nice now?
About the MBTI thing. The personality type cant change. Its just that the tests do not really work. Also the letters E or I do not mean someone has to be extraverted or introverted. It defines wether the dominant cognitive function is extraverted or introverted.
Each personality type has four out of eight cognitive functions (thinking, feeling, sensing, intuition) that are either directed outwardly or inwardly (extraverted/introverted).
For example ISFPs cognitive functions:
1. introverted feeling (Fi)
2. extraverted sensing (Se)
3. introverted intuition (Ni)
4. extraverted thinking (Te)
There is more to it but i dont want to explain all that rn.
Cognitive functions are way more important than the actual letters, but yeah a lot of people spread misinformation about MBTI
Anyway, MBTI only gives information about how people take decisions and its not important to know but it can help to have a better understanding a person. Hope this helps
how sweet at the beginning it starts strong but you feel later that they add or (repeat) just to make it a full song but the start of the song is really good
it's a grower tho. i thought the same thing on my first two listens then it kept gorwing on me and now I think it's one of their best!
i feel that more about super shy, i thought how sweet sounded very full personally, and not too repetitive since the verses had different melodies
@@damnthony1074 maybe if i listened to it more
This was painful to watch…. I appreciate that Atom really seems to enjoy New Jeans.
I realize I’m supposed to appreciate the honesty but considering we came the realization pretty early on in this video that he seems to hate this music (while acknowledging they can sing)…. mmmm just rough to watch. There are some other song I would have recommended in place of a couple of these but I wouldn’t enjoy sitting through all the criticism again. I personally enjoy their music a lot, I totally vibe on it and I think the repetition is somehow cohesive with my personality. I can listen to New Jeans on repeat.
What are the songs that guy listens to? I wanna know what is good for him
was expecting you to show Ditto as well
calling How Sweet the worst song might be the biggest bullshit i've ever heard
fr
i think you guys just aren't fans of the genres they incorporate in general... supershy and eta are 'uk garage' a clubland sound thats made for dancing most songs in the genre have that repetitive nature and i'm a huge fan of the genre so those two songs are in my top 5 of new jeans song... 'how sweet' is 'miami bass' another clubland dance sound and again most songs in the genre have that repetitive sound.. you make the 'rave' reference and thats the genres they mostly incorporate so i think you might be missing the point.... most of their music is based on 'rave' 'clubland' genres. i prefer thse genres to rnb so for me attention and cookie are their weaker songs. different strokes for different folks.. (i'm not a fan of the trap/aggressive rap style of blackpink for example)but you guys would probably much prefer their rnb songs... for me none of their rnb songs make my playlist... apart from bubblegum
Not showing the MV for OMG was a choice...
I kinda wanted kazinho to see cool with you😢
What a shame he didn't have the opportunity to listen to it.
i love how sweet and i hope it grows on you guys 😢
My favorite song by them is Gods. I know is produced by league of legends music team, but it brings out something SO DIFFERENT from what they usually produce. I absolutely love their voices there. But I also love New Jeans and Attention, this is probably my top 3. I loved your view points!!! See you next time!
I really love "How Sweet" and the sweet summer feeling it evokes! And TBH "Ditto" and "New Jeans" should be a part of a video like this [we need a part 2 soon].
it's actually crazy how they didn't get the hint of it being a coca cola collaboration 😭
You literally didn’t show their two best hits! How???
i wanted to say something on the ETA concept, as you can see it’s about a girl who’s cheated on and her friends tell them to hurry up. That’s why we here horns and the song in general is loud, it can be annoying but it fits the concept. It’s also the same in almost all their songs int he album, ETA, ASAP, super shy (wait a minute), get up (meet me back in five),
Idk guys I feel like if your a true Newjeans fan you should be able to pronounce all the members names 😭 like especially if they’re your second favorite group
You missed Cool with you, Hype Boy & Ditto
Cool with you is the best one. Deep House vibes. Newjeans cant be stopped! ❤
the guy from the left is trying his best to find one thing that he's going to hate lmao grow up dude not every song is supposed to be loud or hype beat.
You grow up, not everyone supposed to like everything just because its your fav group
@@spicerow shut up you don't know anything. watch all of their reaction before yapping here brainrot.
@@spicerow what is blud yapping about 💀 watch all of their videos first before coming after me brainrot
@@spicerow he's obviously hating to every groups he thinks he's a professional or something LMAO
@@hansuuuuuua you’re the ignorant one.
Ive been watching him for a while and he actually does like some groups, for example IVE
I can’t blame him, ive is just better
But its proof if the song or group is good he will compliment them
I don’t care what you think, at the end its his taste, if he doesn’t like a group its not a surprise he will find mean words to describe his unlikeness to them
But again this channel is called hater reacts and if it offends you don’t click on the video
Be ready for “hate” comments from him and grow up
Come on not again! You’ve done this with your other reaction videos where you leave out the best songs from the groups!
I tend to notice that that depending on how deep you are into the arts, the more enjoyable NewJeans tends to be. The juxtaposition of super shy’s choreography to the lyrics and feel is addicting for lots of people who love to dance and it’s retro almost workout song feel makes it repetitiveness make sense to me is really solid. In my perspective as not just an artistic creative but also as a theatrical vocalist, How Sweet’s flat delivery is supposed to convey Nihility for that person and almost like relief that they’re gone. The song when talking about the person and the things they made you feel is so flat and deadpan because that’s how they made you feel. When they start with the “Toxic lover~ you know better~” you can practically see yourself having a good time with friends sending prank calls and voice messages to the “little demon in my storyline” about how they fumbled you and should know better because you’re so much happier now. In terms of the perspective of just music you want to listen to, these scores kinda make sense. The way I see it, NewJeans is something you have to truly experience to get the full feel. 💜🐰
When I first listened to newjeans, I also thought that some songs parts are annoying, but as you hear more and more times, you will understand their intention and start to enjoy it. (For me lah)
It took a while for How Sweet to grow on me, but I do really like it. It was a similar impression I had with ETA.
Cookie rn is my fav song
The "Take it, don't break it, I wanna see you taste it" line in cookie though 💀
Not introducing your friend to Ditto should be a criminal offense 😭
felony 😭
Their opinions are too technically textbook with the foundations being their subjective preferences. For example if we compare it to art, If their preferred style is Van Gogh's then they'll criticize every work of Picasso by stating every Van Gogh element that is missing from Picasso's paintings. They are knowledgeable in the realm of production and music theory so I'll give them that, but they lack an open mind.
The main strength and grip of NewJean's music is sentiment and the timing that they debuted. People are reaching the point of burn out from all the EDM, trap, Retro, disco music coming out from 90% of the groups so when they released Attention, everyone was instantly enamored. Looking at most of their songs as standalone pieces of tracks is not the best way to look at them because their songs are objectively not that complicated, complex or dynamic and unfortunately, this channel just does not care about those intangibles which is disappointing but i get that's the way they wanna do it.
I watched this to piss myself off and it did so thank you for this 💕
how sweet it's so hip. What music does he listen to?
I think he is a metal fan if I remember correctly. But he seems very picky about his music
How sweet is fire! 🔥🔥😭
I wish you had reacted to ditto and cool with you :(
Bro with the blonde hair better turn his frown upside down when reacting to NewJeans.
I think my problem with New Jeans and why I can't get into their music is that the music is a combination of music made for teenage girls and music made for tictok. Neither of those things are bad things at all, and that doesn't mean that some older people won't like their music as well. But in general I just don't think I'm the demographic, so their music always sounds like it's lacking something for me. However, the chorus to Hype Boy is one of the catchiest things I've ever heard.
I can’t believe someone even hates newjeans
Never met a new jeans hater yeah your alone on this take 🤩
showing cookie but not hype boy or ditto is definitely a choice.... 💀
Still dragging the song after 2 years?? Hm.
@@ilovecatz1011it’s their weakest song anyone with ears can tell
@@woo3524 Cookie is not their weakest song, it’s literally one of their popular ones
@@shortgirl8962 when i say weakest i mean production wise.. who cares if it was popular 💀
"this song is very suggestive"
"I like how wet the synths are"
i wanna see their opinion on gfriend tbh
The problem with your analysis/reaction is you both focus on finding negatives and then pretending to like some parts just to try and balance your reaction, ie passive aggressive reaction/analysis rather than taking the songs for what they are.
hes literally just giving his opinions on the things he likes and dislikes abt each track...
Why would he have to pretend to like it LMAO
this dude keeps dropping the ball
How in the hell do you not have Hype Boy here???? Damn.
not adding ditto is like baiting him not lo like nwjns
Yeah obviously he’s not going hear the differences in the tracks because you literally played ONLY the upbeat dance songs in their catalog????? It makes no fcking sense to only show him the songs with the same tempo and then by the time he gets to How Sweet he thinks it all sounds the same. No variation from their catalog shown AT ALL. Ditto is by far one of their most iconic songs by how refreshing and different it sounded to the rest of the industry, as well as Cool With You/Get Up. You literally showed him their radio hits. 😐
One thing I appreciate about these guys is that they don't cater to the fans. I hardly ever agree with their opinions, but I can trust they're being honest to their own views. TBH they try to be respectful of the artists while giving their honest opinion on the music. That's pretty rare for a reaction channel.
Hmm suprised...literally 90% reactors from youtube i seen all said it was a BOP...u guys are the 1st one to say it is bad. Still to each their opinion....for me choreo on point ..song maybe not tat good but after listenin to it 10 times....kinda start to grow on me...😅
I mean people has different opinions. Thats how art works
나도 how sweet처음에 들을땐 별로였는데, 나중에 알았지.. 꿈속에서도 나오는 중독적인 노래라는걸..
Ditto and Hype boy are great, and missing them is truly a crime, but y'all, he can´t put all the songs yk, and I mean ALL NEW JEANS SONGS ARE BOPPPP, all these songs he showed today are very famous, I wasn't even a kpop fan and I already had Attention and Supershy on my playlist ykwim?
I like how he's a real hater. Doesn't even know what he hates about it, but he just does.
Hype boy
Dotto
Cool with you
Hurt
How could you not pick these? Please react yo these + supernatural
Yeah, Kazinho pretty much says what I feel about Cookie, BUT just to be clear there are huge differences between Britney having full control of her music/lyrics even as young as 16 and a 14 yr old having no power over whether she sings a song about the smell and taste of her pum pum. We have our own sins in the west for sure, but not only was that decades ago, Britney didn't get this suggestive immediately.
Even then, I don't so much have issues with a 16 yr old or older having full control over how suggestive she is while performing, even though I'd hope it's done wisely without coercion. So, it's not like fans were concerned just because were talking about kpop, that is overall more "innocent" and not super suggestive even when we had more "grown" songs. I'd feel the same way if a 14 yr old American girl sang this song.
EDIT: I still think this should really only be sung by 18 yr olds or older, but we're not dumb, 16 yr olds are generally not naive... but there's usually a power dynamic in this industry that usually makes me skeptical of what a 16 yr old can consent to when powerful execs hold their career in their hands. Britney however, insists she was in control of most creative aspects in her career, as in no one needed to convince her to be more sexy, despite what happened to her otherwise as far as being forced to perform more than she wanted or do projects she didn't care for.
i get what youre saying.. no problem if they were all over 18.. ideally 21.... but my only real issue was hyein being 14... even haerin being 16 wasnt that bad for me.. i'd question it but it wouldnt piss me off so much.. theres a huge difference in those 2 years of growing in the mental state of what is essentially a child and someone whos essentially pretty much nearly a young adult
if u guys interest in danielle ,she is the voice actor of little mermaid live action korean dub. She sing 'part of the world' korean version too. please check that song too.
Attention put my attention on newjeans. The hater is not my cup of tea
Should have done Hybe Boy and ditto
you should consider doing one or 2 live performances for each group you check out. For newjeans, I'd recommend their performance of Gods at the League of Legends World championships last year
Ngl I get what he means with the monotony….The uk garage sound worked for Ditto but I don’t like how they made it their identity because the reason why their debut EP was good because of how distinct each tracks were aside from catchy. I don’t like how I had to “marinate” Super Shy and How Sweet to like it. They honestly felt lackluster and repetitive
Honestly I got into New Jeans late, myself and I was torn when I heard Cookie bc I knew about the controversy. It was a part of the reason I avoided the group for a bit, since I didn't want to support a company that I thought was exploiting minors..but mannnn Cookie does kinda slap tho and it makes my grown adult self want to throw it back (which just also further proves it was not an appropriate track for them to release when some of the members were in high school LOL).
I feel like you picked the most similar songs rather than a variety of their sound. That said I love every single song anyway.
Ditto and hype boy is by far their most viral songs. Why did you skip those?!
I was a Kpop hater myself, and I love New Jeans so much, I am a changed man now.
Cookie represent to CD-ROM you can see CD in MV . Bake cookie = burn CD if you know you know.
For the people who are criticising him., I agree with most of his opinions on first listen what he was looking for that energy, he never got it, he could have if u had shown him Hype Boy and Ditto
we need a part two cause yall missed their best songs imo (ditto, cool with you, gods)
Their best song was Hype Boy btw :))
Not everyone love nj song
But they got a lot of love
Thank you for your review
Hope we can see another genre from NJ
When it comes to NewJeans no one talks about Hurt. One of my favorites
I really love How sweet especially when you listen it multiple times 😭
Danielle is also my bias btw
You got me looking for attentiooooooon~
I have a genuine question, is the guy on the left someone known?
No just a guy
I do give Kaz credit for giving specific reasons in his critique of why he doesn't like a song. He just doesn't go "I just don't like it, it doesn't vibe with me". And I agree with him that some NJ lyrics can get overly repetitive (umm, like Super Shy), but to me that's not a deal breaker - the whole vibe of the song works for me. Again props to Kaz for giving us his honest opinion, and I don't agree some/most of them - but that's ok. At the end of the day, we listen to what we like and who cares what other people say
Super Shys Instrumental is based on Powerpuff Girls so I think they were trying to find a way to make the song go with the Flow!! It's just my Opinion doe 😅
The left guy its funny! It makes seems like is the freaking Max Martin criticizing the songs lmao!😅 where is your hit my friend? 😝
It seems like Atom chose the songs from new jeans that he likes and not what would appeal to Kazinho's tastes. If he liked Cookie, then show him Ditto, Cool with you, Gods, Bubble Gum, Hype Boy. He picked the tracks that are meant to be hyper commercial instead.
All NJ songs are hyper commercial lmao. It’s the most safe, non provoking, inoffensive shit ever
@@suhkawnit eh I never said the other songs were genre-bending zeitgeist shifting masterpieces. However, there is a marked difference between title tracks and b-sides. For what it's worth, being provocative or offensive doesn't make something revolutionary either; that shits been done to death as well.
@@Lilrascal4lyfe the majority of their discography are title tracks though lol? btw if a song is either too provocative, long, or complex to garner radio airplay, it is by definition not commercial. You don’t hear 10 minute prog epics being released as bands’ title tracks, now do you? No, even though those are probably the best songs, they release the most basic track on the album because that has the most commercial appeal. And that describes NJ’s entire discography. Short, catchy, and basic enough to appeal to the lowest common denominator and avoid being “too much” for anybody
@@suhkawnit I agree about the length of the song being a factor, attention spans have been shrinking rapidly over the last decade. Aside from that, what makes a song too provocative or complex in your opinion? Can you give me an example of a song released in the last 5 years that is both simultaneously entertaining and not status quo? I do have some examples in mind personally, but absolutely none within K-pop, which is why I find your criticism moot. Dreamcatcher for example deviates a bit musically, but if that counts then surely NJ utilizing a dead genre from the 80s in their new comeback fits the same criteria.
@@Lilrascal4lyfe A song can be too provocative for a number of reasons, most commonly due to uncomfortable lyrical themes, extreme vocal deliveries, or unconventional musical arrangements. We already have some examples in the past few months alone when (G)idle released Wife and Revenge. Both songs were banned from public broadcast due to the explicit imagery in their lyrics and/or MVs. Banned songs, by definition, have low commercial potential. You can even throw Super Lady in there - it literally opens with a barrage of belted high notes that a lot of people would find too overstimulating and turn the song off after 10 seconds. Not to mention the lyrics are explicitly anti-male.
Now, I’m not saying a song needs to banned to not be hyper commercial. Those are just extreme examples. But NJ songs are the other extreme. Their lyrics are generic pop themes about liking a boy (and yes, it is explicitly about a boy) or, if they’re feeling spicy, vague messages about how that boy wasn’t good for them. They sing in a very limited and basic vocal range that is neither too high or intense too be overstimulating, not too low that it starts to sound too dark or mature. They have very basic and common pop voices that you can hear anywhere.
NJ’s entire discography is like vanilla ice cream. Sweet yet bland enough that everybody can at least kind of enjoy it. But it lacks any intense flavor that might make risk turning people completely off. That’s what makes vanilla the most commercial ice cream flavor, and NJ’s music the most commercial in all of Kpop.
Bro I was a kpop hater but newjeans was my first group and I love them 😭😭 also how was how sweet the worst that’s literally their best song 💀
The thing is new jeans songs are so weird, i had to listen to them like 10 times to start loving them, you have to understand all those strange verses that will get stuck in your head for hours 🤩
of you wanna turn someone into a bunny, Ditto is the magic spell 😭
How is atom still freinds with kazinho? Atom is litteraly silently enjoying the song but then theres kazinho...
i didnt like newjeans at first listen too, but now look at me i am obsessed with all of their songs
they're always finding for that big impact, which is antithetical to what NJ is which is chillax
I just think it's cool to hear a review from someone who doesn't really listen to the music itself. Kazinho's reviews just seem very honest and constructive. He reviews from a purely musical point of view and I find it very interesting to hear such a perspective. He knows a lot about music and says what he thinks, which is exactly how it should be!
I agree, I enjoy these reviews more than than the ones where people just clearly are faking how much they love the song. And I'm not saying that they all fake it just cause they like the song but some people are uber enthusiastic to the point that i can't even watch cause it's clearly not genuine.
i dont think he knows as much about music as he portrays... he says about newjeans music 'oh maybe if i was at a rave' without even realising the songs hes complaining about are actually based on 'rave' (or clubland) genres.. so of course they are going to be repetitive.. i dont think he even knows the genres of 'uk garage' or 'miami bass' on which the tunes are based on
@@jaynadiah5498so true
How do you hear ETA and not immediately think it’s goated!?