I Compared My Old Reverbs To My Plugins...
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 май 2022
- I compared my old reverbs to my plugins and was rather surprised.
Support this channel by becoming a Patron - / freakingoutwithbillyhume
A huge thanks to my supporters:
Jamie Robinson
Crystal Whedbee
Follow my links:
PATREON - / freakingoutwithbillyhume
Follow me on INSTAGRAM - / billyhume
Friend me on FACEBOOK - / billyhumeproducer
My WEBSITE - www.billyhume.net
Subscribe here - / freakingoutwithbillyhume 
Видеоклипы
I had a few people ask me to do a video comparing modulation hardware against modulation plugins. I don't have much by way of hardware but I do have plenty of chorus pedals. So I just put out a video comparing chorus pedals to chorus plugins. I hope everyone enjoys it. ruclips.net/video/qBoP1H3ocLY/видео.html
They all sound good, but the Rev7 sounds "ready". And in a recording situation, this is gold.
All these years later, and your ears are far more discerning than they once were, so you can hear what "could be" musically - maybe even from that Radio Shack thing!! Tweaked nicely in a mix, and even a tiled bathroom has a tone of mojo. Really nice work man!! Thanks for the share!!
The only bit of old gear I've ever bought twice was the Alesis Quadraverb, it still sounds wonderful! 😎
Fantastic comparison. Thank you for taking the time to do this! For fun I would've loved to have heard Dverb compared as the stock ProTools plug-in.
I love how the spring kind of 'follows' the vocal, intensity-wise, and just sits around it
My theory is that with modern reverbs we spend and lot of time reducing their bandwidth with post eq to get them to sit, then add saturation maybe in post etc yet a reduced bit rate piece of hardware with its physical preamp is doing all that softening and shaping for you.
Exactly!
awesome vid! thank you for being so active to the community, we all truly appreciate everything that you share with us! all this is helpful
I appreciate you watching and sharing!
Excellent video, one of a kind, very good idea. Loved that spring reverb !
Thanks, this was rally entertaining and just shows what you can achieve with limited gear if you learn it well. Look forward to checking out some more of your videos.
I learned most of what I know because I had a limited amount of gear. Too many choices can slow you down and actually deter creativity.
I think that spring reverb is just magic! I must have grown up listening to a lot of spring reverb. Hearing that yamaha rev 7 brought me back to 90's country! super nostalgic sound.
What a great blast from the past! I just subbed! Looking forward to watching more great content from you, Billy.👍
Thank you!
New viewer here, great content… as someone else said, it was clear after about 60 seconds that you’re “in the biz” for real. Reminds me of many fun days spent shooting out gear with my teachers and mentors. In the mid 2000s I started buying hardware verbs for my studio because the reverb plugins available at the time sounded mediocre and were incredibly taxing on CPU. Times have changed but my Wedge, PCM70 and M300 still have this special magic, especially when mixing on a console and summing the returns analog. Thanks for the vid!
Thank you! I sure wish I had a PCM70!
That spring reverb hardware unit is the real secret weapon! Even in mono, absolutely perfect
Twas interesting. Thanks for the mix and great vibes.
You had everything perfectly balanced in level. This is key, to make sure everything is easily comparable and there is no 'louder is better' business, going on. I am a big hardware fan myself. Also have a Midiverb II which I love, as well as a Yamaha SPX990 and a Boss SE-70.
the Boss is insane
Thanks for the terrific comparisons. That's a lot of work. Appreciated.
Thanks!
Glad you changed your mind about the Rev7 on the snare, cause it sounded good to me immediately in the mix!
Seems as soon a real gear is turned on, some kind of 3D is activated… love the music you produce
Thanks so much!
placebo
The EeeMmmTtt patch on the Alesis wedge is my favorite on vocals. It just sounds so good.
I really liked how warm both Alesis units sounded in your video.
I need to try that patch.
Thanks for the trip down memory lane. I remember using a Midiverb III back in the day (the successor to the Midiverb II). Later, I bought an Alesis Microverb and then an Alesis Wedge for my own equipment inventory. Hearing the Wedge again on this video brought back a lot of memories of using it as the primary reverb on lead vocals back then.
Yes, I used the Wedge on a bunch of Lil Jon mixes in the late 90's - early 2000's before I went totally in the box. This was at my home studio called The Zone and I was so embarrassed by the fact that I was using an Alesis reverb that I made a big label that said "X42 Y45 Device" that I put over the Alesis logo so that anyone seeing it would think I had something special.
The Rev 7 is special. Incredibly musical.
I have the wedge as well and I love all the "wooden" presets. The manual is incredible for anyone wanting to learn aBout reverb
Great video, to my ears the Wedge and Rev7 sounded really pro
I own several multieffect racks, 2 REV500 Yamahas and a MPX500 Lexicon. I also have 2 Eventide H9 Max pedals. It's a very interesting exercise to compare high end plugins to older gear. There is a definite edge of feel from old stuff. But, as always, horses for courses.
Imagine having so much audio hardware gear that you forget you have them in a box or something somewhere. I have 4 hardware units and even that is more than I could ever use as I'm finding out.
Love the video. Noticed you have a QuadraVerb in the rack. Used to love that thing. Extremely versatile. Fairly high signal to noise ratio for studio, but man that thing was great for live shows.
Thanks! I used it as a guitar fx rig back when I played live a lot. Cool unit.
I am particular to the Yamaha, perhaps it is the clarity, but I agree with you more suited to background vocals. We used an SPX90 for years and it was a treasure.
I don't know I really love the MidiVerb. It sounds like it would be amazing on Hiphop and RnB vocals. Thank you for this demo!
Ha ha! Crazy right? I remember the first time I hooked that thing up after years of not using and I was really surprised.
Roland srv 2000 is the best of the lot on snares
my Midiverb II, Rev 1 and SRV2000 sit side by side to my EMT252, Sony DRES777, Bricasti M7 and Quantec QRS. I love the „smaller ones“, they have so much character. Plugins just don’t give me that depth. Big part of the hardwares sound are their analog circuitry around their ADDA converters. Just measure THD on something like an ART 01A or Sony DRE2000 and you’ll start to understand. Its those imperfections that HELP to set the reverb tail apart from the source sound, so more depth, more realism, less perfection…
The old spring reverb sounds much more lively to me. I still love the verbs in my old Roland SE 50
I love my Midiverb II and Quadraverb! They earned spots in my rack as more of an interesting character reverbs. I’ll tend to use realistic room verbs or delay for the rest.
I miss having a live chamber. I keep thinking of building one out here.
Great stuff. You’re an artist and an inspiration
Thank you!
Just amazing content. You give us hope. Thank you
Thanks so much!
These are great examples of how fantastic some of those old racks can revive the "mojo" you may be looking for in your mix.
cheers!
Thank you!
So good. Thanks Billy. 🙌🏻
Thanks for being a part of this.
I liked the comparison and your ability to walk through the different verbs. They each had a different character which definitely stood out.
But the best part was the beautiful song. Truly a beautifully recorded and written track done by musicians with genuine talent and great voices. The reverb just added that layer of sparkle on those great performances.
Loved it. Song was an instant classic!
I miss hearing real songs like this. ❤😢
Thanks so much!!! I always try to find the best music for my videos and I'm lucky enough to have worked with some great artists.
@@FreakingOutWithBillyHume I was 100% sincere. Praise is just as important as criticism as they say.
Good comparison. Pros and cons in each camp.
In the current world of audio we needed this, certainly a breather from what is now normal.
Spring reverb on fiddle can be great. I ran it live back in the day and it was pretty great as long as it didn't feedback!
They all sounded great i really like that spring reverb
The wedge does something I always look for in reverbs: it fits. It just sits in like a puzzle piece, its hard to explain. It's not building up weird low mids, its not washing out everything, it just works. I thought the midiverb was really cool on the drums in the full mix. The Rev7 is something I'd normally like, with the big 80s high end, but there is something seriously weird about the phase with that one. Vintage verb is what I currently use and I'm pretty happy. Also that spring reverb is so vibey and cool. I think in this musical context especially, it sounds like a big old western canyon.
Yes! I used that Wedge on a lot of records before I went totally In The Box. The Yamaha did have some weird stuff going on but I wasn't sure if it always sounded like that or because it's older than the hills., but it still has a cool sound for certain things.
I have a lexicon mpx1 in my rack right now, haven't used in years I was just thinking about using it the other day when I was frustrated with all my plugin reverbs, they all sounded so dense, I think tommorrow I will make a spot in my patch bay, when I heard you testing these old units it all came flooding back that's the sound! I thought I was remembering wrong but no! That is the sound I am looking for, so transparent
Yes, use it. Let me know how it sounded.
Old school Bro, Its the way too go Love to hear the difference of the plugin to a Lexicon Lark
First time here. I like your vibe dude. Nice song too.
I'm a hardware man :-).
BTW I like very much your mixes
I wish you the best, thanks for your videos
Thanks for watching and being here! Just put out a new video.
Personally i love convolution reverb. I have a library with IRs taken from the classics, Bricasti & Lexicon classics, EMT plates, Grampian spring etc. It sounds lovely, and with current plugins you can sculpt the length of the tail and such very precisely. Sometimes i put a very short ambience reverb from an algorithmic reverb beforehand just so that the tail isn’t exactly the same every time, which is the problem with convolution reverbs. (You can really hear it on sampled drums.) You can use that trick, i’m not a person who keeps my tricks a secret. I want everyone to make good sounding music.
Yes! I have Altiverb and use it a lot. I've even created some of my own IRs.
would you be awesome and share your IR's?
I would need to export them from Altiverb I suppose. Never thought about that.
Yeah that spring reverb was the feels right there on that vocal
I have one of those Master Room spring reverbs...exact same unit! Never thought of mono/stereo reverb differences too much but when you copied it and offset the duplicate to make a stereo track, that was cool. I'm going to try this myself. It did sound good on the vocal.
I liked the Rev 7 on the snare...not sure if that's what you were referring to as the surprise.
Very interesting. And fantastic music too. I've been buying hardware reverbs myself after trying a Bricasti, comparing it to the Liquidsonics Seventh Heaven - its very different. The hardware reverb gives a sense of space, without really being noticable, the plugin seems glue itself on top of the audio, is very noticable - yet the space is less satisfying. This convinced me to first try an MPX1 - since it was so cheap...it was so much better than any reverb I had as a plugin, that I then went and bought a PCM90, which I'm looking forward to arriving any day.
I do happen to have the Alesis Midiverb you have, it was left in my studio - it works fine but its quite a noisy box and you cannot do anytihng with the presets, even so - still sounds kind of interesting in a way that plugins do not.
Your tests, have convinced me, I'm making some good investments. I preferred all of your hardware reverbs over the plugins.
The Altiverb, sounded kind of lifeless, the REV7 was great, the wedge and the Alesis midiverb - all had something going for it that I preferred. The spring reverb was beautiful on the vocal - amazing singer and song of course, but it evoked something. I am beginning a search now for the unit you have here.
Enjoyable vid, will subscribe for the music alone!
Thanks! You're so right. And you're going to love that PCM90.
I feel the same. I have a Rev-5 and a PCM-81, and it's 'in there' in a way I can't describe.
10:15 to my old analogue sound guy/digital engineer/bass player/Gen X ears, that Rev 7 is spot on.. gives a little sparkle and action to those drums.
And that old spring reverb JUST DELIVERS genuine sound..
I loved that wedge on the Drums
Rev7 sound amazing!
The Rev7 is a great sounding verb but the sound of the spring unit blew my mind. As an engineer that cut his teeth in the early 80's I've had a hard time finding verb plugins that really excite me like the dedicated hardware did back in the day. Especially when it comes to plates. I was lucky enough to mix on a lot of good plates...boy do I ever miss them in my home studio.
Man, I've thought about building a plate reverb. Burt the spring reverb surprised me too, I hadn't listened to it in a long time.
This is great Billy. I actually liked the Rev7 in that snare example (as it didn't murk the waters in the fundamental). It had less of the fundamental of the snare note, which if tuned to the song, would be waaaay different.
Thanks!
Great Video! Thanks for taking the time to make it.
I saw an Alesis Quadraverb 2 at my local Music Go Round. It was only $129 so I gave it a try. IT'S SO GOOD!! I couldn't believe what I was hearing. I didn't know it also had Chorus, Delay, Pitch Shifting and Gated FX! I'm definitely going to snag more rack gear soon.
The Quadraverb rocked!!!
I have several of the old Quadraverb with 2.0 software. My main reverb for 20 years. Only the Bricasti beat it eventually
I bought the Alesis Q20 and it sounds goood! Very similar to Quad 2
What a great voice!...it all works..
Your gear is really nice, and that first song is very beautiful, great vocals! I had a nice Ibanez DD 1000 unit years ago, loved it (It almost did reverb lol). Since I got REmatrix and most of the convolution packages from Overloud I never use any of my other verbs. REmatrix has both convolution and algorithm as well. I simply do not even seek better verbs, REmatrix is it for me.
Thanks! I loved those Ibanez units.
Great video! Subscribed 🙌🏻
Thank you!
Interesting comparison. It would have also been interesting to hear a couple of more modern hardware reverbs alongside the others. Maybe an Eventide Space or similar. Rev 7 sounded surprisingly good on the snare in context.
Agree, it opens up. Funny, his first reaction was "no".... ;)
Thank you for this video.
Rev7 is/was a beast.Nice work mate
Thanks!
I felt the the Rev 7 had the most distinctive character. Pleasing but definitely conspicuous. Vintage Verb sounded like it would be good on LoFi or 70's reggae. Dense. As for the others, they did the job without really standing out, which is not a bad thing. The XL-121 was perhaps my favourite. It had a lovely vintage sound. Made the track sound authentic.
Maybe it's due to me coming from the era of sampling drums from vinyl, but I liked the Yamaha the most. It had a crispy crunch, that kind of reminds me of 12 bit samplers. All of the others just kind of had a typical reverb sound. The Yamaha seems like it gives a signature color, which is cool in my opinion.
Crispy Crunch is a good way to describe it.
I didn’t like the spring but with the delay in stereo it came alive and sounded great!
Hello/ my ears hear the greatest panorama and depth of reverb from the plugin L480. Thanks
Your face expression while following the lyrics lol. The passion.
The passion is strong. Sometimes too strong ha ha! Hope you are well.
Billy spectacular thank you 💥💥💜🍀
Thank you sooooo much!!!
Fascinating video, Billy. Thank you! Whilst none of the hardware verbs might be super high end (lexicon, bricasti...) I def preferred all of them over the plugins. To my mind I think there's something to be said about reverb being processed by a dedicated unit because of how these units will be able to keep the time coherence in the effect - especially reverb tails. A thought that keeps popping into mind is that DSP processing is essentially linear, so how is it possible to have multiple (parallel) effects going at the same time without introducing some sort of phase issues with the mix - and this is especially so regarding reverb? I dunno, I can't wrap my head around this idea. Anyway thanks again for a great video
Thanks! I too have wondered why the hardware units sound better. But I think you've got a good theory as to why.
Audio on computers generally is well buffered, so everything should be predictably coherent - ie no phase issues. It is not 'live' in the same way as analogue equipment. You can tell - at different soundcard buffer sizes you can have significant differences in CPU usage.
One of the great features of external effects is the subtleties of the analogue electronics and the ADC and DAC. This even includes how component noise can affect an audio signal as well as differences between opamps, transistor types and capacitors and good pcb layout.
Much of the great gear has 'character's - some gear is used for its transformers, buffers etc and not for the supposed effect itself. In purist terms you might think that is bad, but it's all about colour.
@@l3eatalphal3eatalpha Thanks for the reply. I do understand the benefits of hardware character and colour, and how that would affect the tone of the hardware reverbs. I also understand what you mean by buffering but I still wonder how that buffering is processed. I am not a technical DSP wiz and so I struggle to wrap my mind around how, even including the buffering, the audio samples are processed to be "released" with exactly the right timing. There is so much going on under the hood with multitudes of effects that, as good as the DSP engineering is, I still can't fathom how some sort of subtle phasing wouldn't happen especially with specifically time dependent effects such as reverb. My brain struggles to comprehend :)
@@owlmuso
Because on computers the effects aren't done 100% live, they are buffered so in fact the audio is prepared, phase correct, in advance. The buffer is the look ahead time that the processors have to assemble the audio. Small buffer=very little time=harder on the processor.
If you have a dsp outboard unit eg digital reverb there is nothing that you can do in these that cannot be done in a DAW - just need to reproduce the algorithms and have enough processing power.
The timing is so short it appears live, but if you have a buffer of 512 samples @ 48kHz that is a delay (ie latency) of 512/48000 = 10.7ms, so you barely notice. Except maybe whilst tracking.
Another element with latency is within plugins. Different plugins have their own latency. But this is registered with the plugin, so the DAW can time align them all perfectly. A simple effect may only need eg 32 samples latency (or 0, even, so it actually is live) whilst a complex task may need eg 2048 samples. A DAW will account for all of these in its signal paths (really data paths).
I hope that is any help at all. Just keep plugging away - it will all make sense some day and then you will be unable to remember why you didn't get it in the first place.
In the early days of Protools there was no latency compensation. You had to put short delays on each track and delay them to match the track with the most latency. pain in the ass. But they soon made it automatic.
love my tc.electronics M2000. Once I made an as natural as possible room with it for a radio broadcast. It was stunning. When it's on, it sounds like the person was in your room. It wasn't an effect at all, it was the secret ingredient which “holds the room together”.
Very cool!
TC electronic stuff is great I have the unity card in my Yamaha O2R amazing sound.
You are giving me verb flashbacks 😀I can almost smell those units running hot in my room
Ha ha! Not the kind of flashbacks I have. But I do miss the smell of an old school control room.
Rev 7 baby!
Impresive😳 Still have my TC M2000 i loved for live use, in dualmode, and a TC M one, maybe i should hook it up to my DAW🤔🤔 i also like the effects in my MIDAS MR18
Thanks to everyone for watching, liking, commenting and subscribing from this video. I'm not sure why this one finally got views but it's awesome. I love making videos!
I do a lot of different kinds of videos and I put them out when I can between projects I'm working on. I wish I could be more consistent but it's just me doing these when I can.
I've been thinking about the next videos I should make and figured I'd poll everyone here about that. So if you could, please reply to this comment about what videos you'd me to make.
Thanks!
We love you making videos :) This is probably an interesting topic for audio nerds. If you have any other hardware vs plugin comparisons that would be great. I am specifically thinking about chorus effects... *holds thumbs*
Stick a compressor on the send to the reverb, with an EQ in the side chain being fed from the vocal. Find the freqs causing the sibilance and get the compressor to duck when they hit. This will tame the issue with the rev7.
Videos are like songs - better to have a few great ones, that a huge number of mediocre ones. This one was pretty great. I'm happy to wait for yur next.
Videos are so so time consuming. I spend months getting them "perfect" and then just a bit down the road the errors start to raise their tiny heads and make me say Gah. I've even taken some down. Perfectionism is my biggest obstacle, although you might never know it from my videos.
I like the comparisons of plugs and rack gear. A lot of folks who are considering a bit of OTB adventuring find those useful. As said previously, whenever you get to it is fine, make sure you have enough time left over to enjoy. Cheers!
@@wjniemi Thanks! Yes, these kinds of videos are hard to make and I always find errors later and then get complaints. I just put out a new one today and it took a while because I was trying to get everything correct, but I'm sure someone will find something wrong ha ha! ruclips.net/video/qBoP1H3ocLY/видео.html
Great video, and like with all the plugin vs hw comparison, the hw sounds SO much better. It's amazing, lots of plugins with pretty interface but it sounds so cold and lifeless compared to real hardware.
The Valhalla isn't bad, but still "flat" sounding compared to the REV7 for example.
And the huge thing is within the mix. The 480 plugin sounds like a reverb yes, but it also muddies a lot of things around it if you listen carefully. While the HW make the vocal stands out in a beautifull way ♥
We all use plugins because they are practical, but for the best sound even a midiverb wich was considered cheap back in the days, still sounds much better in my opinion. Let them plugged in !
I'd use the hardware reverbs more if I had a better work flow or only worked on my own music. I just need to be able to switch between projects quickly. But doing this video has really made me think about how I might use these more regularly.
Wow, that Rev 7 is something else
great video , thanx 4 that !!
Thanks!
Man there is just something I love about 16 bit digital reverb. I found I missed it when I went to ITB plugins and just couldn’t find reverbs that I liked (of course there are plenty of good ones) I have a wedge too. But Boss’ BR series of recorders have reverbs I love. If it’s 16bit I’m on it
I'm not familiar with the Boss reverbs. I'll have to check them out.
I have the REV4 and MidiverbII. I think they're dandy, and if you like those I would recommend you try a TCElectronics M3000, which is an even better device imo.
For plugins I'm pretty happy with Arturia's Intensity. Thanks for the video.
TC Electronics is the sh__t!
I liked the mono reverb too, gave it a vintage feel
Ever since I did this video I've been narrowing the width on some of my reverbs.
That XL-121 with delay and "fake stereo" has some serious mojo.
What made me curious, I have an old ART rackmount with multiple effects. Back in about 90 when I got it, I thought it sounded cool. In the guitar world, plugins crush it. I seem to remember it having some good delays and reverbs however. It might be fun to break it out. I put it away when I got the amp I was trying to simulate in 99.
Great...now I wanna buy a Rev7
I have an SPX90 that is amazing on snares. I have a Rev5 which is the best reverb I have ever used on vocals. It is simply amazing
It's crazy how many records had an SPX90 on the snare. Everyone I knew used them.
The Rev7 is a great bit of kit. Hard to find one in good condition because most people hammered them.
I still use my old Digitech Studio Quads for pretty much everything that doesn't need to sound super spacey. That's Valhalla Supermassive's job.
Supermassive is amazing!
Oh my GOSH - we used to have TWO identical Effectron ll's in our live PA rig...
That yahama sounds pretty good, the problem is the song your using it’s too busy with guitars in stereo so it’s hard to hear the reverb
That spring reverb amazing
Bloody killer vocals!
Two of my favorite singers.
I just looked through and old bin of music knock knacks and found a wedge, totally new and unopened. I bought 2 when they came out and never opened the second. So I pulled it out and took it to my buddy's place and put it on my mic. Totally fine for live.
Wow! So cool!
I noticed that you have an Effectron II - I have 2 of these in my studio, and I use the CV input to control the delay time from my DAW (for recalls and to allow modulation, etc). It would be nice to see you do a comparo between the Effectron and your plugin delays
The Effectron doesn't work. The signal indicator shows input but nothing at output. Haven't gone beyond that in figuring out what's wrong.
Dude your music is excellent!
Thanks!
Before you interrupted in that section I was pre commenting that I thought shorter verbs would be a better suit for this track haha.
Damn that spring reverb was awesome on that Stringdusters song. X times better than the Valhalla! Also, thanks for the great song tip, never heard it before.
Doing this video has made me think about buying another spring reverb.
Excellent video... well done. And a timely reminder that the world's best reverb won't make a generic new country song more interesting.
Thanks! And yes, at the wend of the day THE most important things are the song and performance.
"Generic new country". How many Ivor Novello awards do you have sitting on your mantelpiece?
So This was the first video of the day. Makes me wonder why youtube took so long to recommend your video. Instant sub. I can't tell you the last time i watched a video from start to finish. I miss the road and hanging around like minded folks. I learned in the day from just talking shop. Now all youtube feeds me is some goober with the secret sauce to killer kicks or some shit. Im gonna have to watch this again. Interesting the old verbs seam wider and sit in the mix better. Thanks again for posting this.
Thanks! I miss the road and talking shop too. You might like my videos about not using reverb on vocals and using 2 reverbs on vocals: ruclips.net/video/YfpLnvfw3GQ/видео.html and ruclips.net/video/SUohmVkYhOg/видео.html
@@FreakingOutWithBillyHume Will go check it out now.. I need to watch things the get me thinking in the morn before i start my day. Looks like you got about 160 videos. This should keep me going for a bit.. I also had the CD and Dat player just like yours. The dat player died and never fixed it. I need to, and my son is now 23 and was 4ish when the cd burner ejected the CD. he some how slipped on a stool and pulled the tray out it and broke it. and his sippie cup lid was not on and went on my console.. It just dont seam like that cd burner would have been that old and out of service that long. I guess so.. shit we are getting old.. Dam it..
Oh man... I haven't thought about sippie cups in years. Now 2 of my boys want to be in a band with me. Time flies...
Midiverb II is a sleeper for dark metallic reverb vibes.
Yes!
Bro... those days...are memories! We have entered the future! (Think of algorithm changes...real time!)😮😅
But... but....
That alesis reverb was nice imho. I remember the quadriverb was the go to for many years.
I don’t think I’ve ever heard a reverb I didn’t like.
I like the Valhala best, but all the others are great as well. Although a very interesting video, I would not call it a comparison, plus you could probably make a good mix with any reveb. I Love the song👍🙂
Thanks. kinda like comparing Apples to Oranges, but I've had so many people ask about this.
Funny thing is, when I'm tracking vocals I'll just used the stock Protools reverb on vocals to keep processing down. On a recent project when I got to mixing I forgot to change out the vocal verb plugin on half the songs and realized later. But it sounded good so IO just kept it on those songs.
you should try the Abbey Road Saturator after the reverbs on the returns.
the answer is all of the reverbs. All at once. On everything.
Oh damn.... I should've done that!