Such a crime that this influential progressive group has been totally ignored by the R&R Hall Of Fame. Now that Gary Brooker is gone, it's too late for amends. One of the greatest rock bands ever.
EFF the stupid R&R Hall of Fame. Eff all the awards ceremonies where all the beautiful people gather. EFF all of them. Knowing how great Procol Harum is is enough for me. EFF everything else
R.I.P. Keith Reid who died so recently and of course R.I.P. Gary Brooker, who followed years later after the very beloved percussionist B.J.Wilson. I have been in mourning for Keith, but so appreciate all the lyrics that became Procol songs. My favourite rock band since I was about 12. Got to see them at 15 in the Mothers Club, Erdington, Birmingham. I went alone, lucky for me it was a friendly club and I didn’t try to buy booze. I sat at the front just amazed I was there. Brilliant band.
I am probably the only 81-year-old Procol Harum fan who never smoked dope. (I was involved with developing a technology that is still used in every jet engine still flying in 2021. Drug testing was used even then.) But I was still was able to get "high" on their unbelievable musical talents.
hoy, a mis 69 años, me emociono escuchando a uno de los más grandes grupos que nos dio el rock. un enorme talento, altísimo nivel musical e injustamente relegados. Ellos y The Moody Blues fueron el origen del rock sinfónico de los 70.
Procol Harum,fate parte della mia vita,per sempre nel mio cuore. Che bei ricordi. Indietro non si torna ma i ricordi non si cancellano, Dio vi benedica.
Piękna muzyka i super wykonanie. Byłem na koncercie Procol Harum w Sopocie w Operze Leśnej w Lipcu 2000 roku i ciągle nie mogę się nasłuchać ich muzyki, z Garym Brookerem spotkaliśmy się.przy piwie gdańskim przed koncertem. Bardzo fajny gość.
Años enteros de mi vida buscando este tema, no sabía que era de los magníficos Procol Harum. - I'd been looking for this theme for many years, I hadn't known it was performed by the magnificent Procol Harum guys!!!.... I'm so happy!!!!
Maybe one day people might know how truly great this band was, but some bands don't reach the masses because the sheep people do not possess the originality gean
As many others have said, I never heard this before.....and loved PH since 7th grade, when I first heard Whiter shade of pale. Loved Albinoni's version also. No drumming on that one though. But it all works.
I've been looking for this "French single" for years! Merci, merci, merci bien for posting. Once again, I agree completely with estivator; this posting is truly award-winning. Bless you.
I am an aged Procol Harum fan, and this is an excellent version,but Brian Auger and the Trinity, with Julie driscol were at a pop concert in the late sixties early seventies,(can't remember which one) and Brian Auger played this live, and I will never forget its intensity, I have searched for a long time to try and find this live performance (not the album version) but to no avail, if anyone has a copy, please put it up onRUclips, it is fantastic. Nedsmith
Estaba yo de 10 años en esa fecha y obvio no pude ir , ¿podrias tu darme alguna informacion sobre ese concierto ?? o donde se puede obtener informacion ? , yo empeze a ir a conciertos hasta 1979 aqui en ciudad de Mexico , me tocó ver a WAR , CANNED HEAT , BLACK OAK ARKANSAS , JOHN MAYALL , JOHNY WINTER
Yeah, I stumbled across it many years ago using the original Napster file sharing service. Don't know where it comes from, not on any album I've seen. Might be a studio outtake. See if you can find their version of Blue Danube.
Me too! Born in 1954, I knew and loved them since their beginnings. Still today I Iove them. Their newest work called "Novum" is again very asthonishing. And this one? Great! I also did not know, that it exists. Fantastic!
I'm pretty sure this was made during rehearsals with Edmonton SO with Chris Copping on the Hammond and Dave Ball on guitar. Dave split with PH under acrimonious circumstances, and they used photos of Mick, as on the LP credits *but it's Dave's image on the front cover. Apparently Chris was working this up with the lads in the orchestra and the band decided to try it on for size and record it! Hopefully someone can chime in and add some facts to this. I am not 100% certain, but surely its wonderful.
Hi. You are partly right in that Chris Copping played this by himself at the start of the Edmonton Concert and it was recorded . In his words, he was exceptionally nervous and wasn't perfect but the orchestra was apparently way out (I think he blamed the conductor). You can read about it on the amazing beyondthepale website for the band.
Excellent - saw them play this and The Blue Danube at the Colston Hall in Bristol. As always, they leave much of the opposition still struggling up the last hill.....
I was one of the stage-crew for that Colston Hall gig. I did both the load-in and the get-out, and watched the PH play from just beside the FOH audio mix position. Fabulous show :-)
I know he was a Venetian composer, but he did not write this adagio. "The Adagio in G minor for violin, strings, and organ continuo is a neo-Baroque composition popularly attributed to the 18th-century Venetian master Tomaso Albinoni, but actually composed by 20th-century musicologist and Albinoni biographer Remo Giazotto, purportedly based on the discovery of a manuscript fragment by Albinoni. There is a continuing scholarly debate about whether the alleged fragment was real, or a musical hoax perpetrated by Giazotto, but there is no doubt about Giazotto's authorship of the remainder of the work."
I was about to say something, but you about covered it. Thanks!I wish there was a little more info about this though, seems like maybe he just lost his woman to an extra-terrestrial sex worm, then his cat had died, and someone shot his dog....then his house burnt down, and he said...well, I think I have a piece to compose! The passion in this composition is so extraordinary!
wonderful rendition...worthy of praise....not TOO over the top (imagine if Emerson Lake and Palmer got ahold of this...yikes..) Now if this WERE ONLY written by Thomas Albinoni...but it's not. "The Adagio in G minor for violin, strings, and organ continuo is a neo-Baroque composition popularly attributed to the 18th-century Venetian master Tomaso Albinoni, but actually composed by 20th-century musicologist and Albinoni biographer Remo Giazotto..." -Wikipedia. But who cares? nice piece here...
Keys an notes are in my opinion as original Albioni. But in modern harder instruments. This is composed for orhcestra violin/ or church-organ/violin. All of tunes seems shortright. Remarkable of Procol Harum!! What a fu... genious band!
Brooker si..ispirava alla musica dei....grandi e si sente...un gruppo troppo..avanti per molti rocchettari di ieri e di oggi...evviva i PH e il loro..mentore Brooker...
![Procol Harum - In Held 'Twas In I [Live With The Edmonton Symphony Orchestra]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5rtMI4_r4jM/mqdefault.jpg)
Such a crime that this influential progressive group has been totally ignored by the R&R Hall Of Fame. Now that Gary Brooker is gone, it's too late for amends. One of the greatest rock bands ever.
EFF the stupid R&R Hall of Fame. Eff all the awards ceremonies where all the beautiful people gather. EFF all of them. Knowing how great Procol Harum is is enough for me. EFF everything else
I agree. It was a formidable band with one incomparable sonority, between classic musIc and rock.
with you
again just FUck the R&R Hall of Fame. They're eejits
Procol was on such a high level that Hall of Fame stuff was nonsense to them!
Awesome Procol Harum. I love their music and still listen to it . They deserved more recognition for their masterful performances. ❤❤❤
R.I.P. Keith Reid who died so recently and of course R.I.P. Gary Brooker, who followed years later after the very beloved percussionist B.J.Wilson. I have been in mourning for Keith, but so appreciate all the lyrics that became Procol songs. My favourite rock band since I was about 12. Got to see them at 15 in the Mothers Club, Erdington, Birmingham. I went alone, lucky for me it was a friendly club and I didn’t try to buy booze. I sat at the front just amazed I was there. Brilliant band.
Well put. I feel the same.
I am probably the only 81-year-old Procol Harum fan who never smoked dope. (I was involved with developing a technology that is still used in every jet engine still flying in 2021. Drug testing was used even then.) But I was still was able to get "high" on their unbelievable musical talents.
I don't smoke because I listen to PH, it's more the other way around..
keep on listening. ALL the BEST to You
it’s never too late to buy some edibles and see what all the fuss was about...
Thank You, dear friend!
Larry Sink, me too (60 years). No DRUGS, but would be missing this kind of BEAUTY OF MUSIC without drugs. So happy, that they did it.
Unici. Non ci sono parole. ❤
Pure courage to play this as Rock band. Beautiful.
And to include the C-major prelude from Bach's _Well-Tempered Clavier Book 1_ in "Repent Walpurgis_ was genius.
Bellissimo l'Adagio di Albinoni.Mitici i procolHarum
hoy, a mis 69 años, me emociono escuchando a uno de los más grandes grupos que nos dio el rock. un enorme talento, altísimo nivel musical e injustamente relegados. Ellos y The Moody Blues fueron el origen del rock sinfónico de los 70.
Si Señor, tienes toda la razon, y me mociono al recordar cuando los vi en Mexico, (Auditorio Nacional). Thanks for the memories.
Gracias!
Procol Harum!!!Fathers of Art Rock Forever!
Procol Harum,fate parte della mia vita,per sempre nel mio cuore. Che bei ricordi. Indietro non si torna ma i ricordi non si cancellano, Dio vi benedica.
Fanno sicuramente parte dei ricordi di tutti quelli che guardavano Avventura alla tv dei ragazzi....fino alla sigla finale...
Piękna muzyka i super wykonanie. Byłem na koncercie Procol Harum w Sopocie w Operze Leśnej w Lipcu 2000 roku i ciągle nie mogę się nasłuchać ich muzyki, z Garym Brookerem spotkaliśmy się.przy piwie gdańskim przed koncertem. Bardzo fajny gość.
What a great band this was !
Un des meilleurs groupes de tous les temps!
Well Albinioni Bach Mozart .....Procol Harum...Chapeau!
Albinioni Adagio - Rollerball orig.versio.
Unforgettable.
Años enteros de mi vida buscando este tema, no sabía que era de los magníficos Procol Harum. - I'd been looking for this theme for many years, I hadn't known it was performed by the magnificent Procol Harum guys!!!.... I'm so happy!!!!
Amazing! And BJ Wilson the master of playing 3/4 time on drums.
Maybe one day people might know how truly great this band was, but some bands don't reach the masses because the sheep people do not possess the originality gean
It would be hard to possess the originality "gean". Most people have simple genes.
@@miyiazakimou my genes have rips at the knees!
@@SirCamsmorethanalot The arse has long ago fallen out of mine!!!
those who know great music will have to fight to keep the memory of this band alive. There are too many eejits alive now who are truly clueless
Last foreever as the basic new musik newsound as new classic with newse
SWEET MUSIC... amazing sound Classic Progressive FOREVER!!!
The one and only band that was apart from all other rock bands
Beautiful! These Guys Know Their 🎶. Thank You. God Bless.
One of my favorite band and music to life with me
Thank you for the wonderful music you gave to us. It never dies!
As many others have said, I never heard this before.....and loved PH since 7th grade, when I first heard Whiter shade of pale. Loved Albinoni's version also. No drumming on that one though. But it all works.
I've been looking for this "French single" for years! Merci, merci, merci bien for posting. Once again, I agree completely with estivator; this posting is truly award-winning. Bless you.
Fan since I was 8 years old and never heard this. Amazing. Love PH
The Doors and a Dutch band called Ekseption played this piece of Albinoni.
Just picked up on this track, absolutely stunning
Bellissima come " fortuna ". BRAVISSIMI !!!!!!!
You deserve some sort of prize for posting this. Just stunning work by my favorite band.
So true. This rendition sends chills down my spine.
I am an aged Procol Harum fan, and this is an excellent version,but Brian Auger and the Trinity, with Julie driscol were at a pop concert in the late sixties early seventies,(can't remember which one) and Brian Auger played this live, and I will never forget its intensity, I have searched for a long time to try and find this live performance (not the album version) but to no avail, if anyone has a copy, please put it up onRUclips, it is fantastic. Nedsmith
Ohh, heard this one in Copenhagen in the 70'es, all of them committed musicians, so beautiful - I have searched for it ever since, thank you Nicvac:-)
Ned, so have I - with neg response in the PH fb-group, but perhaps at Beyond the Pale?
Chills? Yes!
One of the Most fantastisk croup who came Out of the sixties
ce groupe des 60' reste un des meilleurs pour sa musicalité...il ne reste que Gary Brooker et Matthew Fisher ...qui donnent encore des concerts!
Maintenant Gary Brooker aussi n'est plus là depuis 2022, sauf par sa musique.
PROCOL HARUM É MARAVILHOSO DE QUALQUER JEITO.,ADORO O SOM DELES
Truly beautiful. I wish I had become a fan much sooner. So many great songs in their catalog. And F the RRHOF!!
Esta melodia la tocaron cuando vinieron a México en el Auditorio Nacional.1975.
Estaba yo de 10 años en esa fecha y obvio no pude ir , ¿podrias tu darme alguna informacion sobre ese concierto ?? o donde se puede obtener informacion ? , yo empeze a ir a conciertos hasta 1979 aqui en ciudad de Mexico , me tocó ver a WAR , CANNED HEAT , BLACK OAK ARKANSAS , JOHN MAYALL , JOHNY WINTER
I love that Keith Reid is peeking out of the middle of the photo!
He was just another one of the guys :)
На века музыка!!!! Best......super, foreva
Procol fan since 67 and i did not know of this. THANKS !
very rare
Yeah, I stumbled across it many years ago using the original Napster file sharing service. Don't know where it comes from, not on any album I've seen. Might be a studio outtake. See if you can find their version of Blue Danube.
Neither did I...
Me too! Born in 1954, I knew and loved them since their beginnings. Still today I Iove them. Their newest work called "Novum" is again very asthonishing. And this one? Great! I also did not know, that it exists. Fantastic!
fan since 1970, same
Procol Harum, onnavolgbaar mooi!!. Wat is dit bijzondere muziek en heerlijk om naar te luisteren.
I have this single in my Procol collection...with Gary Brookers signature.
You must be blessed. Congratulation.
the river of ater is in my shoes
Listen how the band is carefully transforming this classical piece of music in their way of making music...
This and it's flip side were performed by the version of the band pictured,@the time of "Exotic Birds And Fruit" and the "Ninth" album..
Gary Brooker vient de nous quitter et j'en ai beaucoup de peine. Sûrement le meilleur de tous.
grandissimi Procol Harum! amazing!
Ab.fab.there.was.no.one.to.touch.them.intheir.time.no.one
Leeds
Powerful and respectful version. Imagine if Reid had been tempted to set lyrics to it. We might have had another wsop.
Ma chi oggi potrebbe permettersi di eseguire qualcosa di simile!? Bravissimi!
hai ragione, nessuno potrebbe riuscirci
perchè no?
@@karstensturm4198 perché ai cantanti odierni se metti una chitarra in mano la scambiano per una racchetta da tennis
@@MrLido50 questa è una domanda che manco Johann Sebastian Bach sarebbe rispondere. Perchè il tennis ai suoi tempi non esisteva ;-)
Malmsteen 😁😎
I'm pretty sure this was made during rehearsals with Edmonton SO with Chris Copping on the Hammond and Dave Ball on guitar. Dave split with PH under acrimonious circumstances, and they used photos of Mick, as on the LP credits *but it's Dave's image on the front cover. Apparently Chris was working this up with the lads in the orchestra and the band decided to try it on for size and record it! Hopefully someone can chime in and add some facts to this. I am not 100% certain, but surely its wonderful.
Hi. You are partly right in that Chris Copping played this by himself at the start of the Edmonton Concert and it was recorded . In his words, he was exceptionally nervous and wasn't perfect but the orchestra was apparently way out (I think he blamed the conductor). You can read about it on the amazing beyondthepale website for the band.
Prog & classical, I like music with intensity, I had forgot that Procol Harum did this
Simply brilliant!
Prześliczne, przepiękne:0
Aż chce się żyć
Damn! This is beautiful!
Likely the best and most moving version of this that I've heard except Doors.
Here is a Swedish very somber version by Monica Zetterlund and Monica Dominique. ruclips.net/video/omZa1Nhfojw/видео.html
Excellent - saw them play this and The Blue Danube at the Colston Hall in Bristol. As always, they leave much of the opposition still struggling up the last hill.....
I was one of the stage-crew for that Colston Hall gig. I did both the load-in and the get-out, and watched the PH play from just beside the FOH audio mix position. Fabulous show :-)
@@MrToucana Amazing!! 😁😁🎸🎸
Words cannot express the beauty
Marcelo Alvarenga do say it to Keith reid
Om Hare 🎶🌟 grande saund 🎹🎶🎹
Procol HARUM NOUS DEMONTRE QUE CE SONT DES ARTISTE A PART ENTIÈRE
CET ADAGIO EST GRANDIOSE
Remarkable, joyful, golden soul feeling
Albinoni would be pleased. Then Albinoni would probably have liked Repent Walpurgis too.
Cynthia Savage Albinoni would like all their songs
Albinoni did not write this song, Remo Giazotto did.
I know he was a Venetian composer, but he did not write this adagio.
"The Adagio in G minor for violin, strings, and organ continuo is a neo-Baroque composition popularly attributed to the 18th-century Venetian master Tomaso Albinoni, but actually composed by 20th-century musicologist and Albinoni biographer Remo Giazotto, purportedly based on the discovery of a manuscript fragment by Albinoni. There is a continuing scholarly debate about whether the alleged fragment was real, or a musical hoax perpetrated by Giazotto, but there is no doubt about Giazotto's authorship of the remainder of the work."
I was about to say something, but you about covered it. Thanks!I wish there was a little more info about this though, seems like maybe he just lost his woman to an extra-terrestrial sex worm, then his cat had died, and someone shot his dog....then his house burnt down, and he said...well, I think I have a piece to compose! The passion in this composition is so extraordinary!
Gary Moore and Don Airey also covered this. Although in a more straight 4/4 manner.
pqp,um trem desses chega a assustar,,,,,,fantastico,,,,,,
I did not know this existed! Thanks!
Magnifica. Grande band Procol Harum!!!
Very mastered!
grandiosi
Fantastique !
MUSIC REAL MUSIC
bellissimo....eterni!
RIP Alan Cartwright ++. Great bass line.
Just love the classical brilliance of ph ,although theDoors take on this is probably better. They are both on my favourite playlist ☝️
Großartig!
epici e unici ,,,,,,,,,,,,una stratosferica versione ìììì panta stin kardia moi ,,,+,,,, opou k nase r i p ,,,+,,,,
R. I. P. Gary Brooker 🙏🏻🕯️
Music is beautiful classic. Song Adagio is sad but true.
Intemporelle Magnifique !!!
sublime!!!!!
wonderful rendition...worthy of praise....not TOO over the top (imagine if Emerson Lake and Palmer got ahold of this...yikes..)
Now if this WERE ONLY written by Thomas Albinoni...but it's not.
"The Adagio in G minor for violin, strings, and organ continuo is a neo-Baroque composition popularly attributed to the 18th-century Venetian master Tomaso Albinoni, but actually composed by 20th-century musicologist and Albinoni biographer Remo Giazotto..." -Wikipedia.
But who cares? nice piece here...
Descomunal Procol demostrando su impronta y estilo
Espectacular
Un brano bellissimo
Piękna muzyka młodości
Acho que sempre soube que a minha essência é algo como o que experimento nesta música...
When did this EP come out for sale? Great daring thing to do for a rockband! I love it...
ali asreco,
this was released as a single in france in 1976(chrysalis records,dark green label).
GRAN BANDA BRITANICAFOREVER.
Bellissimo...!
Keys an notes are in my opinion as original Albioni. But in modern harder instruments. This is composed for orhcestra violin/ or church-organ/violin. All of tunes seems shortright. Remarkable of Procol Harum!! What a fu... genious band!
Grande música
Amazing!!!!
I had no idea they did this
But those 42 unliked persons which illness they are suffering in their poor life?
Great Banda músicos atrevidos Grand hotel was Grand Album.
grandissima esecuzione
It was composed by Remo Giazotto. Purportedky based on Tomaso Albinonis fragments. We don't know.
Brooker si..ispirava alla musica dei....grandi e si sente...un gruppo troppo..avanti per molti rocchettari di ieri e di oggi...evviva i PH e il loro..mentore Brooker...
Simplesmente espetacular
Excelenteeeee
VERY GOOD...........................................................
Thank you!
Bello.
Check out the Maurice Andre-Janet Parker Smith version.
Fantástico
Wow 😮.
Only BJ can play that fucking hard. God speed, GB. (1945-2022)
The doors !!!