Yeah, i was about to comment the same thing. I mean it's still a nice detail to have. But not on the same level of detail as an accurate piano or guitar player animation or something like that
On paper, yes. But if the artists can't read notes, it's easy to mess up. Meaning you need have someone go over the animations and make sure it's in order.
@@r8420hp it's not that complicated tbh, I'm an artist and can't do music. But I've done some art/animation which have music notes in it. The customer just give me a sheet of notes and I follow them, it just not complicated. And everything have to be double/triple checked before going out to us gamers too
@@shock226 there are a few gems like Stellar Blade. Problem The studio Made Nikke and already have a good Rep also Korean Studio . While other AAA that has been flopping is American made , there's a pattern here .
I wish Robin sang her other songs on ult as well tho I guess designing the notes to match each song may be time consuming. That said, still a really neat detail.
Если это будет хотя бы среднего уровня профессионал или просто энтузиаст того же уровня( но без официального образования) . То сделать это достаточно просто. Хотя 100 вариаций ульты займёт работника на пару месяцев, с, учётом всяких согласований с руководством
I don't think her mellow song would fit as an ult. The finale song would absolutely go hard as an ult alternative, though, but they won't do it for another few patches if they were approved in the first place
I would have been more impressed with accurate mouth animation. Getting sheet music they already own to digitize and animate is just the most logical (and easy) thing in the world
I mean, to be fair, Robin only snaps her fingers to the beat if the battle is just a normal battle with her theme playing in the background. She doesn't snap her fingers for boss themes since they override her Ult song.
Playing on English, her mouth doesn't mouth accurately but she does have two distinct "dances" she does depending on the intensity of the music. You would literally only notice this if you, like me, sat and stared at her for several minutes while the battle was going on.
@@iocu Sure, but since the OP is about 'budget', using their own material cost them nothing, and is just a good optimized use of existing assets. Their actual budget is going into marketing. XD
I mean they did literally create a new species (if that's the right term) of rose just to advertise Argenti, and they paid millions of dollars to put an ad on the Las Vegas dome to advertise Penacony
That’s some pretty complex music too, I see tied 8th-16th, half-beat 16ths, a 16th and dotted 8th, mid 16th beat note changes (16ths are not super common outside of percussion I think)
They probably didn't have to waste any time. They just took the sheet music they already had on hand and then placed it into the game as an asset along with everything else they were already designing for Robin
Hoyo: Use most of the budget to make Robin's music Fans and players: best music ever! Hoyo: Low budget can't add more stuff like Robin's new music with Firefly. Fans and players: Shut up and take my money This was going through my head while watching this video
Well yeah this is the reason they wont have multiple songs during her ultimate because they would have to change the notes and it would be too much development time and effort for a single character
Will this stop people from asking Robin's ult should mixed up 3 songs of hers? Nope, should change this as well if we got more songs. Nothing is enough, some of us wanted more, am i right? Heh...
@@MrYamiBakurabut can robin even qualify as meta? She mainly operates exclusively with FUA, can work DoT characters also, but about half her kit becomes pointless in the process. She focuses a lot on crit especially for FUA characters so even Kafka wouldn’t benefit from that, only the dmg buff and atk buff. And considering I think her is fairly short.
I have Topaz, tried for Robin but lost and I'm not sad. I love Topaz. She is pretty useful on the over world, she's a chest detector. I use her in story modes so I can grab chests while I play so I don't have to come back
are we now glazing over some basic character designs and animations now? Kinda insane how this is considered masterwork when in reality it's 6/10 animation and design
HSR really put a lot of effort to this character it's insane
This guy is everywhere
@@PhoenixLord927 Bro is propagating at this point
And yet I'm not going to pull her because she's a chicken wing.
I mean it’s like HSR’s idol now
@@idontspeakjapanese6289bro worship Tazzyronth
Tbf it's way easier to just put in the song from her ultimate instead of mashing random notes
true, they are the owner of the sheet, just send them to the animators.
Yeah, i was about to comment the same thing.
I mean it's still a nice detail to have. But not on the same level of detail as an accurate piano or guitar player animation or something like that
On paper, yes.
But if the artists can't read notes, it's easy to mess up. Meaning you need have someone go over the animations and make sure it's in order.
@@r8420hp it's not that complicated tbh, I'm an artist and can't do music. But I've done some art/animation which have music notes in it. The customer just give me a sheet of notes and I follow them, it just not complicated. And everything have to be double/triple checked before going out to us gamers too
Yeah. That way, you don't have to worry about 'it' looking GOOD bcz you have the excuse that you actually used the original.
When you realize Gacha games put more Effort into their games than AAA games
at this point, when i hear a new triple a is coming out, i somehow know its gonna flop somehow
they get so much money per month its crazy
@@shock226 there are a few gems like Stellar Blade. Problem The studio Made Nikke and already have a good Rep also Korean Studio . While other AAA that has been flopping is American made , there's a pattern here .
AAA game its masterpiece back into that day until " Sweet Baby Inc " Join the battle
@@chinyang1200as long as it's not American, we good
"let the show begin"
**barbara noises intensifies*
as a barbara main, i was waiting for this comment
Barbara best wifu
@@animefan699 im pretty sure she's 16 bro
@@moroncosmin and is that a problem
They going all out with their characters fr
I wish Robin sang her other songs on ult as well tho I guess designing the notes to match each song may be time consuming. That said, still a really neat detail.
At the time of making her she only had one song finished and ready so unfortunately they couldn’t add other ones :(
Если это будет хотя бы среднего уровня профессионал или просто энтузиаст того же уровня( но без официального образования) . То сделать это достаточно просто.
Хотя 100 вариаций ульты займёт работника на пару месяцев, с, учётом всяких согласований с руководством
I don't think her mellow song would fit as an ult. The finale song would absolutely go hard as an ult alternative, though, but they won't do it for another few patches if they were approved in the first place
Hoyoverse's Favorite Child
Kiana rocking up.
Bronya would like to have a word
She is Ayaka of HSR (just don't have 200 days banner)
@@Whatever01345Then Sunday is HSR's Ayato (just having a bossfight)
@Whatever01345 nah its firefly
Robin reminds me of barbara from genshin so much. Especially with the "let the show begin" in their skills
Yeah, but she has better design, better writing and actually sings, plus she is now one of the top units
fr
They both sound dead.
@@kevinloddo6883barbara can jump
@@Personpersonpersonperson +climb+glide
I would have been more impressed with accurate mouth animation. Getting sheet music they already own to digitize and animate is just the most logical (and easy) thing in the world
ikr? they already sync JP dubs, why not this song which has only one language?
I mean, to be fair, Robin only snaps her fingers to the beat if the battle is just a normal battle with her theme playing in the background. She doesn't snap her fingers for boss themes since they override her Ult song.
Playing on English, her mouth doesn't mouth accurately but she does have two distinct "dances" she does depending on the intensity of the music. You would literally only notice this if you, like me, sat and stared at her for several minutes while the battle was going on.
idk, almost nothing in Game Art/Design is 'easy'
@@iocu Sure, but since the OP is about 'budget', using their own material cost them nothing, and is just a good optimized use of existing assets. Their actual budget is going into marketing. XD
I mean they did literally create a new species (if that's the right term) of rose just to advertise Argenti, and they paid millions of dollars to put an ad on the Las Vegas dome to advertise Penacony
i love kaeya add
(hoyo pls love all your children, not just honk in the starred rail)
The true definition of you're getting your money's worth
Tru
WEL-COME TO MY… WOooOOOoooOOOORLD 💥💥💥💥💥📢
The fact that I got a ad and it was her song I was oh it from the video then I realized💀
Welcome to my Soul Society
they also did a good job finding chevy for singing it
The music name is Sway my beat into cosmos and tge rylic is "Rise Up Into my World"
Imagine if those notes are actually the notes for Never Gonna Give You Up
Robin and Barbara competing on who would sound more dead when saying
"Let the show begin."
thats unfair tho
Robin has died before
@@roxas5071this was funnier than expected
Me: *doesnt understand music notes
Also me: "ah yes, I understand"
The fact I got a honkai starrail ad and it was robin💀
That’s some pretty complex music too, I see tied 8th-16th, half-beat 16ths, a 16th and dotted 8th, mid 16th beat note changes (16ths are not super common outside of percussion I think)
Also a 4 sharp key
I LITERALLY JUST GOT A HSR AD OF ROBINS ULT😭
Then Barbara....
"LET THE SHOW BEGIN"
**NOISE**
They know there will be player that said "but akhsually, the notes doesn't match"
So they had to waste their time doing it. It was cool tho
Exactly
They probably didn't have to waste any time. They just took the sheet music they already had on hand and then placed it into the game as an asset along with everything else they were already designing for Robin
So they transcribed it from the music sheet.
As a musician, I noticed that as well 😂
My favorite character so far!
*Tonight your wallets cry because of me*
Wow I never realised that.Vey Awesome Hoyo😁😁😁
her singing while other allies in combat reminds me of minmei in macross
similar vibe
ASAMAR ON THE PIANO NICE❤
I love that MiHoYo went 2000% in on robin with the notes, and the promotional material and the freaking ALBUM 😂
Its not allat, they have easy access to the notes, since the music is theirs, they just ahd the animators put it in
Tf man as a metal bassist, i don't know how to read sheet music
I mean what else would they put in the sfx, since it's a musical character, might aswell use her notes sheet as sfx.
yup! I play piano and I noticed there were notes but I didn't play them lol.
And her song has hidden messages
I KNEW IT!
But had no way of testing it
The animations eat HSR budget as they eat my phone inside out
free sound track in the game ;-;
This is the main argument for why they can’t have Robin’s ult play a random one of her songs instead of exclusively Welcome to my World
Hoyo: Use most of the budget to make Robin's music
Fans and players: best music ever!
Hoyo: Low budget can't add more stuff like Robin's new music with Firefly.
Fans and players: Shut up and take my money
This was going through my head while watching this video
To be expected of hoyoverse, nothing is a coincidence and details are down to the pixels
not really, is not that hard to add, people as usual just say "X new character is AMAZING BECAUSE I LIKE IT" without any real understanding
i guess that can be free sheet music
too bad i didnt pull her just for this very reason ULT cant be muted/changed i dont wanna mute any in game sounds and whatnot
but it can be muted
@@ImNOT_aSheep65tecnically by boss battles yeah
Incrivel!
Os mínimos detalhes foram pensados
Full ver piano cover PLSSS
As a Robin main, I can confirm 😂
Wow they actually arent holding back.
All the budget for other harmony character
actually the song that plays is named "Sway to my beat in cosmos" 🤓
I got her first Eidolon yesterday💖
Well yeah this is the reason they wont have multiple songs during her ultimate because they would have to change the notes and it would be too much development time and effort for a single character
I was wandering if those were accurate
Will this stop people from asking Robin's ult should mixed up 3 songs of hers? Nope, should change this as well if we got more songs.
Nothing is enough, some of us wanted more, am i right? Heh...
It's a good thing because always wanting more will lead to better and better games and that doesn't solely apply to games too xd
IF THEY WANT OUR MONEY, THEY BETTER EARN IT.
@@brennandkyour caps lock is stuck
ig this is why they aren't giving her any of her other songs on her ultimate :(
I hope Robin doesn't happen like Seraphine (league of legends) and she really has more songs. I think it's spectacular
These glazes gotta be stopped
Yeah I noticed it too. I've also seen this video before
Was it originally from you?
Yea
@@cryinghuohuo ah well thanks
No wonder you said it was a reupload
So this is why they only gave her 1 song
🤓👆 Uhmmm ACCKSHUALLY the songs name is Sway to my Beat in Cosmos, not Welcome to my World 🤓👆
Correct me if I am wrong but isn't the first note (in the picture) is C but you played a B there
This is crazy
I failed the 50/50 😢
Glad I made her my main lol 😂
Nah it was E major omg
They already have it might as well put it there
It is not too hard but still amazing
and then that's why they are so fcking stingy in Genshin... To rise their budget in HSR.
Boss units overide her ult music, quite sad. Not that it shouldn't, but the cut is so abrupt lol.
What yall expect, Hoyoverse is a music company that make gacha games
to be fair, they already had the notes since they made the songs, they just implemented it
This is legit
Genshin could never :(
I mean, since they already have the original sheet, why not just add it in instead of random note lol.
The Notes Are Well Accurate Though
i'm gonna skip her for firefly
Waifu > meta
@@MrYamiBakurabut can robin even qualify as meta? She mainly operates exclusively with FUA, can work DoT characters also, but about half her kit becomes pointless in the process. She focuses a lot on crit especially for FUA characters so even Kafka wouldn’t benefit from that, only the dmg buff and atk buff. And considering I think her is fairly short.
i mean... they wrote the song in the 1st place. why put random note when u can take less effort just by slap it and still be more accurate
I'm still debating wether to get topaz or robin
Get robin then try getting topaz . Since both are gr8 for a follow up attack team
I have Topaz, tried for Robin but lost and I'm not sad. I love Topaz. She is pretty useful on the over world, she's a chest detector. I use her in story modes so I can grab chests while I play so I don't have to come back
@@Elsa.zoneNt it's aight I lost too and got e2 welt but I got her again after 20 pulls so don't give up!!!
Alternative title : This is where the Genshin budget went:
y'all r so annoying grow up
They don't use it anyway, so its a waste. They aren't going ALL IN their ads unlike HSR's marketing team.
stop the cap
Most of their profit reinvest into rnd and irl event like concert.
Genshin worst mistake make game open world
is she limited?
yep
Well, stop playing wrong thing
You just found that out?
they reuploaded it i think. i remember they posted this when it was leaked
Genshin players punching the air right now
"That should've been money invested in MY GAME" 😂😂😂
If only Genshin would do the same amount of effort
are we now glazing over some basic character designs and animations now? Kinda insane how this is considered masterwork when in reality it's 6/10 animation and design
Genshin Impact are not main priority anymore 😭