It looks like the way calibration works is that the piece of metal you insert in the hole will slightly move te piece of plastic that holds the magnet to one side or another. If it can easily be moved like that, i bet it will move with time and friction against the cage and you'll have to keep recalibrating.
Marius Heier's design I think will be the actual definitive hall effect joysticks once he's finally completed his design. They'll probably be more expensive but likely won't require extra PCBs to make them work.
Have them , modded with replacing hall effect sensors with potentiometers for my flydigi apex 2 and works really well. Build quality of the module base is FAR BETTER than alps.
Sadly Microsoft and Sony are never going to use these joysticks, they make waaaayyy too much money out of selling their cheap controllers. I'm getting a new one every 8 months - 1 year. And I know a lots are just like me, this is tons of money for them. :(
@@morrisdennison8039I’ve repaired my controllers with replacement sticks but part after part are continuing to go out on the board. Finally, the A button on the front is giving out on my oldest Series 2 (oldest out of four). I’ve had to desolder-resolder new sticks onto the oldest 2, and had to resolder bumpers on either 2 or 3 of them (each time replacing both bumpers when I’m in there). I’m not sure what to do about the A button going out, though, and that pains me. Some people literally suggest writing over the contacts with a pencil, but I’m looking for a solution not a workaround, and it seems like not many (if any) exist. Long story short, It’s just one thing after another going wrong with them in time… to the point it’s almost better to just start over with a new controller. I as well am unwilling to accept it, and I’m still fighting the good fight of repairs instead of just buying another controller, but man do they make it difficult. If only it wasn’t such a damn good feeling controller in the hands.
Bro i have 3 Xbox controllers with bad sticks. I decided to stop buying them and I ordered 6 of these hall effect sticks from ali express. I installed them and my controllers are practically brand new again. It's totally worth it.
@@carpediem7654 I'm in the same boat. My controllers die from either stick drift, or my cats knock my controller on the floor and it damages the USB port on them. These don't seem super complicated to attach, I just have to learn how to solder and I can stop buying new controllers again. Id much rather buy a 25 dollar pack of replacement sticks and a 10 dollar bag of USB-C ports than a 60-70 dollar new controller every year.
And I just bought a new Stellar Shift controller... This is seriously great to see though! Super excited to get these type sensors developed and finally out to gamers
Bro they’ve been out for decades. And they’re only a few cents more to make. The problem is they save the consumer too much money because the people are buying a new controller every 6-8 months. If they developed high quality first party controllers that used Hall effect Joysticks, they would lose out on MILLIONS in sales.
@@Spazza42 yep. Only a year after the release of the ps3 they switched to potentiometers. So you’ll have some people that will remember stick drift and some that won’t because they were using different controllers.
It is actually pretty sad that sonny and Microsoft doesn't give a shit about their customers in terms of controllers, but there are plenty of people that don't care
unfortunately Jun's calibration add-on isn't cheap. i'd love to add it to my modded controllers but i think i'll wait until the price comes down or an alternative comes around.
i using this hall effect analog on my latest ds3,it works flawlessly,yeah I've been test on stick tester and it has jitter on it just like this person said,but wont effect on the gameplay at all,sony should do this to all his controller 😌
They don't... I've tested them on 3 generations of Xbox One controllers to no avail. I came here to see if there was a way to make them work... But if there is, I haven't found it yet.
I've repaired a couple of controllers from various consoles and if I remember correctly the joysticks on the PS4 and PS5 controllers are pretty much the same.
Cool, the calibration is a pain but I'm glad it exists now, thank you Gulilit. Is there a difference between the blue and mango orange one or they're just colors, any PS5 revision is compatible with any color? God bless Gulikit. Are they better brands though in 2024?
I will try one of the new series of these when my Xbox series controller sticks finally die. TBH canned air and 70% isopropyl alcohol kept mine going. On a PS5 controller this is harder, and needs a bit of soldering, but is still doable if you have basic skills.
I ordered some of the hall effect sticks for PS4 and did a successful repair. Are the PS4 hall effect sensors compatible with Xbox One? I haven't had any sellers confirm if this is the case or if there are different modules for different systems. I have noticed that there are different drop down boxes for ordering for different systems, but they look identical and the pins line up the same.
it works on xbox I had taken the model for ps4 (my mistake) but it is very difficult to adjust because there is no room for maneuver, so every time you have to disassemble, calibrate, and reassemble hoping that it works. and when you press the left trigger, the stick moves, because under the lt button there is 'a magnet
this is a major pita on the xbox controllers. You need the daughter board connected to actually plug it in to test and zero out the deadzone. Also for whatever reason. I adjust the deadzone in one hole. Its moving. I move and let the stick snap back like you're doing. But its just back to what the deadzone was before. Doesn't change
already sorry for my bad england, but it possible to put hall-effect stick to xbox elite series 2 controller? because default sticks have much deadzone and little bit drift btw i know thumbsticks is different between elite and normal series x
Você chegou a testar o sensor de movimento do controle? Acabei de instalar os analógicos laranjas magnéticos no meu controle e estão funcionando bem, mas percebi que o sensor de movimento do controle que eu uso para mover o cursor e digitar no teclado virtual do PS5 não está funcionando direito. Será que fiz algo errado durante a montagem?
@@VKsChannelvou esperar o analogico do meu outro controle apresentar defeito e então fazer a troca também pra ter outro comparativo mas acredito que eu fiz algo errado durante a montagem do controle que afetou o giroscopio.
Hi there, I just installed Ginful Hall Effect Sticks to my Xbox Series X/S Controller. First everything worked out fine. But after updating the firmware and run the Xbox Accessories calibration after 1-2 minutes connected, the sticks are going crazy . When I unplug the controller and connect it again, everything is back to normal for 1-2 minutes. I already played some games for about 2hours before updating the firmware, so it must be an software issue. Another related problem is when I try to revert the firmware I recevice an error. so I stuck and the controller is useless in this state. Any advice?
Im starting to consider breaking down the old ps3 controllers to see if those ones contain the magnetic sensors instead of the shit potentiometer ones.
I replaced the switches to hall sensors and it worked beautifully for a while then I got the 2 orange blink error. I double checked the battery connector and it seemed okay. What could be the problem?
Whats about xbox some say isn't work for it because left trigger magnet directly under it also there is a video about it it didn't work. But I don't know if what's in the video is xbox magentic joystic mabe he used ps joystick please answer. Already got xbox version
The magnet doesn't touch the sensor, so it's can't wear out, unlike the Alps pots that all the manufacturers seem to use these days. The Alps pot have a metal 'wiper' that presses against a carbon track. Every time you move the joystick, the metal wiper is moving against this thin, carbon track and wearing it away.
@@Mickparrysstepdad i ordered 6 and replaced them on 3 controllers. Brought my controllers back from the dead. Amazing. No need for anymore controllers.
@@TheControllerPlug I can do better than explain. I've got the videos 📽️🎬🎞️🎬 and resistance changes 📊 mapped out for calibration 🎚️🎛️🪛 📈📉 for circularity ⭕ & deadspot 🎯 sake size & positional adjustment to prove the trim pot method. An Xbox one pad 🎮🕹️🕹️🎯🎯🪛 playlist & a DS4 pad 🎮🕹️🕹️🎯🎯🪛 playlist with the bulk of my work in there where you 🫵🏼 & everybody else will understand everything I claim to know 😉😜👍🏼. Look 🥹 & yee will find 🤗 friend, the super simple method of manual resistance manipulation. It's not futile it's mine 😁 😂🤣.
oooohhh, I misunderstood the title. I thought "definitive drift proof" meant definitive proof that Hall-Effect sticks can drift, too, instead of drift-resistant xD
hi vk its been 6 months since ur test video for the switch hall effect sticks, have u got the new 2nd batch sticks and will u make a new video for them and where do i buy the 2nd batch sticks from cos i dont want the 1st batch ones thx
Hi! Yes I did but I haven't been using them on my main joycons because they feel a bit more stiff than original analog sticks, so I put them in my secondary pair of joycons and haven't used them ever since I still use my paper fix and its working perfectly, had to replace the cardboard piece once and thats it
There is a script in python you can run and it will calibrate ps4/ps5 controllers. It's not perfect for hall effects but it makes installing them a lot easier.
would be nice for oculus / meta quest 2 (and maybe 3)? i`m using my 3rd pair of controllers because of that drift. hallsensors would be e great solution.
Acho mais facil vc comprar as pecas e levar em qq loja de reparo e pedir pra trocarem O procedimento de troca é igualzinho a um analogico original, vc só vai precisar calibrar depois
I need a new Xbox elite controller badly but I don’t want to get a new one because I feel like the gen 3 elite controller is going to come out soon so idk
Same, gonna buy the gulikit kk3 max and hope its a good one, while I wait for Elite 3, but if they still don't fix the button issues I won't come back to microsoft.
I click on the seller's product page on ali for those boards and one of the three options is "joystick" and is one single joystick with a price over 9000? What's that about?
I only know the phantom hex, it is a modded controller that comes with these sticks installed Other than that you can also buy the controller and the modules and ask a game repair shop to install them for you
Yes there are a few brands out there. I recently got the GameSir Kaleid Flux to use with with my P.C. and it also works on Xbox. Their controllers are officially licenced by Xbox. The price is very reasonable, £50 in the U.K. Nacon and Hexgaming do one for Ps5 but its pricey. Will never buy standard console controllers again.
Does the circularity and jitter matter much? I just watched your video on installing Jun's board, but i dont have anything to solder with. Planning on just using these modules on their own
@@SzadoB How about you don't open your mouth about things you have no knowledge of? Circularity affects precision in all games but how much it affects will vary from game to game. In the example provided in the video can tell you that the experience will vary from not noticing anything to literally being unable to run diagonally in MGS4 (if it were installed on the left stick). I can also tell you these are the exact same circularity issues (slightly less actually) that you would get from a replacement joystick bought straight from ALPS (via Mauser). CORRECTION: These have worse circularity issues than ALPS standard potentiometers. I get around 15% from those.
Você chegou a fazer algum teste separado com esses analógicos laranjas no controle de ps4? Eu tava querendo substituir os meus com eles, mas ainda não tenho muita certeza
So the ps5 version will work with Xbox one s controlle, and not the ps4 version? I found there is 2 model in market 10k and 2k2, I don't know the deference and which one compatible for xbox one s? Iam hella confuse here, hopefully you will answer. You got new sub
So for quick review... is there a video on how to install the hall effect sticks for the PS5? The video for calibration does not include how to actually tear apart the controller and attach the sticks themselves. Also, with the corrective board would be nice too. I have waited way too long for Hall Effect to come to PS4/PS5 and Xbox. This should scare the crap out of Sony and Microsoft because having these installed on a controller would save $70-80 in the course of potentially years. Thank you again for this info. Hopefully a full tutorial on how to put them all together would be great.
yes,i am looking into this but the hall effect sensors seem out of stock on multiple ali vendors?? And the jun zeng's pcb boards+hall sensors are pretty expensive on aliexpress 30$ incl shipping?The hallsensor and pcm board as 1 set should be like 3$ or so as a fair price,.. (The hall sensors are like 40ct a piece and a pcm board like that should be like 1$ a piece max,so 3$ is already a 100% profit.) And to install you have to be a kindoff pro technician with soldering skills and professional gear,because many small mistakes can be made and it wont work.. Anyways thank you VK for this video,hopefully this is a solution for the billion dollar industry of stick drifting controllers,i bet sony and microsoft etc dont like these kind of engineers.Jun Zeng can be a hero for millions of gamers worldwide,if the setup works.It's just a matter of time more vendors will supply the sensors and pcm board for reasonable prices.I am gonna try it out anyway and buy it from Mr Zeng,i do award him for all the work and efford to design the driver pcb board.
Hey Dark,thanks for asking,unfortunately not yet,i do have all the parts from jun zeng now,the total cost came up to 64,25 euro for 2 pairs🤥,because sender forgot to put ioss number on the package,and double vat had to be paid...just finding the time to install,i will update when installed@@dark-california
This is completely unnecessary for daulsense edge since you can just buy new stick modules for it, however with the base daulsense the only option is to completely replace the controller, these halleffect sticks save you another $75 where the edge modules are only $20 and as long as you're not literally destroying your edge $20 every other year isn't bad, but I'm not going to spend $200 on a controller I'm only going to play games casually with
Hope these will be compatible with my PowerA Xbox style controller, would love to switch out the joysticks I currently have for them, one of which is completely busted..(I have 2 of the controllers)
Thanks for the video! Been seeing those Hall effect sticks for a while and have been apprehensive of them
It looks like the way calibration works is that the piece of metal you insert in the hole will slightly move te piece of plastic that holds the magnet to one side or another. If it can easily be moved like that, i bet it will move with time and friction against the cage and you'll have to keep recalibrating.
You can calibrate it online
@@Vianilix 7 months ago you couldn't .
@@nikkopt Yea you were still wrong with your bet
@@Vianilix that's good, I'm glad I was wrong then
@@nikkopt yea me too
Hell yeah, a life without drifting across all platforms is now possible 😌
Now if only Sony, Microsoft, and Nintendo actually uses hall effect sticks instead.
Hall yeah 😂
@@nexusprime2487Probably means people buying less controllers, don't think we'll see that happen
@@Lewis99 Of course aside from the consoles, the real money saving graces for them is the controllers.
1st party Dreamcast controllers were Hall. Early PS3 controllers were too, before Sony got smart.
At last! all hail the people who made those
I might get myself a dual sense finally
Marius Heier's design I think will be the actual definitive hall effect joysticks once he's finally completed his design. They'll probably be more expensive but likely won't require extra PCBs to make them work.
Kinda. The pcb will come attached to the potentiometer instead of having to order one separately.
@@tekgeekster which still means only one part to install
@@tekgeekster The point of the video is to replace the potentiometer stick with hall effect sensor stick 😉 no hard feelings 👍
Did he say when he will release the joysticks?
Just here to second what Sam asked
Have them , modded with replacing hall effect sensors with potentiometers for my flydigi apex 2 and works really well. Build quality of the module base is FAR BETTER than alps.
link for Hall Apex 2 please.
no stick drift i assume?
@@tatianamellstrom7806 yes
i'd assume the stick is compatible accross multiple console ?
Sadly Microsoft and Sony are never going to use these joysticks, they make waaaayyy too much money out of selling their cheap controllers. I'm getting a new one every 8 months - 1 year. And I know a lots are just like me, this is tons of money for them. :(
Theys why you need to learn to repair your stuff yourself. I know it’s doubting but once you get the hang of it. It get easier and easier
@@morrisdennison8039I’ve repaired my controllers with replacement sticks but part after part are continuing to go out on the board. Finally, the A button on the front is giving out on my oldest Series 2 (oldest out of four). I’ve had to desolder-resolder new sticks onto the oldest 2, and had to resolder bumpers on either 2 or 3 of them (each time replacing both bumpers when I’m in there).
I’m not sure what to do about the A button going out, though, and that pains me. Some people literally suggest writing over the contacts with a pencil, but I’m looking for a solution not a workaround, and it seems like not many (if any) exist.
Long story short, It’s just one thing after another going wrong with them in time… to the point it’s almost better to just start over with a new controller. I as well am unwilling to accept it, and I’m still fighting the good fight of repairs instead of just buying another controller, but man do they make it difficult.
If only it wasn’t such a damn good feeling controller in the hands.
Bro i have 3 Xbox controllers with bad sticks. I decided to stop buying them and I ordered 6 of these hall effect sticks from ali express. I installed them and my controllers are practically brand new again. It's totally worth it.
@@carpediem7654 I'm in the same boat. My controllers die from either stick drift, or my cats knock my controller on the floor and it damages the USB port on them. These don't seem super complicated to attach, I just have to learn how to solder and I can stop buying new controllers again. Id much rather buy a 25 dollar pack of replacement sticks and a 10 dollar bag of USB-C ports than a 60-70 dollar new controller every year.
Buy the pro controller. Analog stick replacement is only 20 dollars and you don't have to take apart the controller to replace them
finally I can buy anything without a worry
And I just bought a new Stellar Shift controller...
This is seriously great to see though! Super excited to get these type sensors developed and finally out to gamers
Bro they’ve been out for decades. And they’re only a few cents more to make. The problem is they save the consumer too much money because the people are buying a new controller every 6-8 months. If they developed high quality first party controllers that used Hall effect Joysticks, they would lose out on MILLIONS in sales.
Yeah these are nothing new, the Dreamcast controller was a Hall effect stick, as was the PS3 - yeah, Sony used to use these
@@Spazza42 yep. Only a year after the release of the ps3 they switched to potentiometers. So you’ll have some people that will remember stick drift and some that won’t because they were using different controllers.
The RC community has also been using Hall effect gimbals for even longer, actually, these days they’re almost standard in all transmitters.
It is actually pretty sad that sonny and Microsoft doesn't give a shit about their customers in terms of controllers, but there are plenty of people that don't care
Sick edit bro 2:51
unfortunately Jun's calibration add-on isn't cheap. i'd love to add it to my modded controllers but i think i'll wait until the price comes down or an alternative comes around.
i using this hall effect analog on my latest ds3,it works flawlessly,yeah I've been test on stick tester and it has jitter on it just like this person said,but wont effect on the gameplay at all,sony should do this to all his controller 😌
Hello, nice work! Amazing to see that more manufactures are selling this type of joystick, Can you test how they work on Xbox series Controllers ?
They don't... I've tested them on 3 generations of Xbox One controllers to no avail. I came here to see if there was a way to make them work... But if there is, I haven't found it yet.
@@OmniTechGu Thanks, good to know, we need to wait till they release a working version.
@@OmniTechGu have you tried them on xbox series controllers (9th gen)?
Finally, now we just have to wait for this to become mainstream.
Im excited.
There's several reviews saying the sticks only hold up for a couple of minutes before the calibration gets out of whack again.
I've repaired a couple of controllers from various consoles and if I remember correctly the joysticks on the PS4 and PS5 controllers are pretty much the same.
Cool, the calibration is a pain but I'm glad it exists now, thank you Gulilit.
Is there a difference between the blue and mango orange one or they're just colors, any PS5 revision is compatible with any color?
God bless Gulikit. Are they better brands though in 2024?
Now someone just needs to buy a ps5 controller & install these along with extreme rate back buttons and sell them!
I’ll sell u one that im making rn
Brother let me know im interested if its a dualsense 🙏
@@NebZKwhat all are you wanting done from one?
I will try one of the new series of these when my Xbox series controller sticks finally die. TBH canned air and 70% isopropyl alcohol kept mine going. On a PS5 controller this is harder, and needs a bit of soldering, but is still doable if you have basic skills.
I ordered some of the hall effect sticks for PS4 and did a successful repair. Are the PS4 hall effect sensors compatible with Xbox One? I haven't had any sellers confirm if this is the case or if there are different modules for different systems. I have noticed that there are different drop down boxes for ordering for different systems, but they look identical and the pins line up the same.
Aber beim Xbox controller stört der Lt Trigger durch seinen Magnet den Stick❗❗❗❗❗
Agree
@@DzaceQ So you have to convert the triggers too, but you can't play racing games
it works on xbox I had taken the model for ps4 (my mistake)
but it is very difficult to adjust because there is no room for maneuver, so every time you have to disassemble, calibrate, and reassemble hoping that it works. and when you press the left trigger, the stick moves, because under the lt button there is 'a magnet
You have to buy the correct model
***Has anyone changed the internal spring to increase stick tension ??
this is a major pita on the xbox controllers. You need the daughter board connected to actually plug it in to test and zero out the deadzone. Also for whatever reason. I adjust the deadzone in one hole. Its moving. I move and let the stick snap back like you're doing. But its just back to what the deadzone was before. Doesn't change
I calibrated mine totally online connected to a pc, less than 5% error. I also notice these come out of the box at FULL SQUARE rotation, not good.
already sorry for my bad england, but it possible to put hall-effect stick to xbox elite series 2 controller? because default sticks have much deadzone and little bit drift
btw i know thumbsticks is different between elite and normal series x
They are on AliExpress
Did you find out about putting this on a ES2? My sticks are drifting sadly and I’d like to upgrade mine so I have the best controller possible
@@Ekouhz yes, i just putted hall effect analog from xbox series controller to my elite series 2 and lost useless thumbstick tension.
Você chegou a testar o sensor de movimento do controle? Acabei de instalar os analógicos laranjas magnéticos no meu controle e estão funcionando bem, mas percebi que o sensor de movimento do controle que eu uso para mover o cursor e digitar no teclado virtual do PS5 não está funcionando direito. Será que fiz algo errado durante a montagem?
No meu funciona tudo normal
Pode ser defeito do controle mesmo uma vez q o gyro n tem correlação nenhuma com os analógicos
@@VKsChannelvou esperar o analogico do meu outro controle apresentar defeito e então fazer a troca também pra ter outro comparativo mas acredito que eu fiz algo errado durante a montagem do controle que afetou o giroscopio.
Hi there,
I just installed Ginful Hall Effect Sticks to my Xbox Series X/S Controller. First everything worked out fine. But after updating the firmware and run the Xbox Accessories calibration after 1-2 minutes connected, the sticks are going crazy . When I unplug the controller and connect it again, everything is back to normal for 1-2 minutes. I already played some games for about 2hours before updating the firmware, so it must be an software issue. Another related problem is when I try to revert the firmware I recevice an error. so I stuck and the controller is useless in this state. Any advice?
Hey. Any updates? I was also thinking of replacing my ss controller with these
Im starting to consider breaking down the old ps3 controllers to see if those ones contain the magnetic sensors instead of the shit potentiometer ones.
Anything for the Nintendo Nunchuck?
I replaced the switches to hall sensors and it worked beautifully for a while then I got the 2 orange blink error. I double checked the battery connector and it seemed okay. What could be the problem?
Wonder why you just cant calibrate it on the ps5 its self switch lets you do it
Whats about xbox some say isn't work for it because left trigger magnet directly under it also there is a video about it it didn't work. But I don't know if what's in the video is xbox magentic joystic mabe he used ps joystick please answer. Already got xbox version
wouldnt the left stick of the Xbox Controller be affected by the magnet on the left trigger?
This stuff is going to make me buy a soldering iron and save money overtime
What makes these so good?
The magnet doesn't touch the sensor, so it's can't wear out, unlike the Alps pots that all the manufacturers seem to use these days. The Alps pot have a metal 'wiper' that presses against a carbon track. Every time you move the joystick, the metal wiper is moving against this thin, carbon track and wearing it away.
@@Mickparrysstepdad i ordered 6 and replaced them on 3 controllers. Brought my controllers back from the dead. Amazing. No need for anymore controllers.
What is difference in ps3, ps4, Xbox hall effect joystick module??
3:33 Large circularity.
Ide bet i could shrink that to just over 100% with 3x3mm trim pots 😆...
please explain? 🤔😅
@@TheControllerPlug I can do better than explain.
I've got the videos 📽️🎬🎞️🎬 and resistance changes 📊 mapped out for calibration 🎚️🎛️🪛 📈📉 for circularity ⭕ & deadspot 🎯 sake size & positional adjustment to prove the trim pot method.
An Xbox one pad 🎮🕹️🕹️🎯🎯🪛 playlist & a DS4 pad 🎮🕹️🕹️🎯🎯🪛 playlist with the bulk of my work in there where you 🫵🏼 & everybody else will understand everything I claim to know 😉😜👍🏼.
Look 🥹 & yee will find 🤗 friend, the super simple method of manual resistance manipulation.
It's not futile it's mine 😁 😂🤣.
@@TheControllerPlug What pad 🎮 do you own to work on?
Horizon has a high deadzone setting which you can not change, you should have tested the stick on a game where you can change the deadzone settings.
oooohhh, I misunderstood the title. I thought "definitive drift proof" meant definitive proof that Hall-Effect sticks can drift, too, instead of drift-resistant xD
I brought these modules, but using circularity test it makes square shaped as shown in the video, how to make that square to circular?
You can't
Only jun zeng modules can fix curcularity
Why isn't there a company selling upgraded versions of xbox and ps5 controllers with hall effect fixed etc out of the box?
There is. Check out Flydigi Vadar 3 and apex 4.
amazing ! love to see it get done on the xbox please
it is the same process but you have to buy a different module, just solder it in then calibrate and you're good to go!
@@VKsChannel Thanks I just watch his video i was wonder if you need the part in the back on the elite controller.
What module do you need for the Xbox controller. Do you have a link for it?
@@VKsChannel so just install do the hole thing and it's ready?does it also have the jitter/circular issues amd what can be done on xbox
@@VKsChannel is the Xbox consoles do the same as PS5 - eliminate this shaking effect on center position? Did You tested it?
the replacement ones that I get of ebay always give me a square window after replacing, will these give a circular window ?
hi vk its been 6 months since ur test video for the switch hall effect sticks, have u got the new 2nd batch sticks and will u make a new video for them and where do i buy the 2nd batch sticks from cos i dont want the 1st batch ones thx
Hi!
Yes I did but I haven't been using them on my main joycons because they feel a bit more stiff than original analog sticks, so I put them in my secondary pair of joycons and haven't used them ever since
I still use my paper fix and its working perfectly, had to replace the cardboard piece once and thats it
Did you test it in a game in which you can change the deadzone to see if the jitter makes a difference?
There is a script in python you can run and it will calibrate ps4/ps5 controllers. It's not perfect for hall effects but it makes installing them a lot easier.
Does the magnetic field generated by controller vibration affects the sensors?
not really
Vk do you have a video of these working correcting in an xbox series x controller?
No when I bought these they were only available for the ps4/ps5
Without adding a pcb, wich version is better for the ps5, the yellow or blue type hall analog?
did u find out which are better blue or yellow ?
would be nice for oculus / meta quest 2 (and maybe 3)? i`m using my 3rd pair of controllers because of that drift. hallsensors would be e great solution.
Sabe se lguma loja/oficina de console no BR já trabalha trocando esses sticks?
Acho mais facil vc comprar as pecas e levar em qq loja de reparo e pedir pra trocarem
O procedimento de troca é igualzinho a um analogico original, vc só vai precisar calibrar depois
*WHERE IS THE UPGRADE FOR THE LOGITECH EXTREME 3D PRO*
Can you do an update? I want to know how they've held up.
Im using jun zeng sticks now but they should be fine
Hall effect sticks wont wear with time
@VKsChannel supposedly, unless build quality is subpar and other things wear down first.
@@VKsChannelcan you give us an update with the new calibration tool that Xbox released?
Can you make a video, implenting these sticks with Jun's module on an xbox series s/x controller?
Does it work with Xbox series x/s ?
why i cant find the ohms to this? Does it no longer matter when installing hall effects?
Does the hall effect sensor joysticks have any effect on the controller's battery life?
Hello... Can u do it in cod mw2 with maximum sensitivity r3 or aim. I want to see if it gonna have jitter filter or neutralize it by ps5. 🙏🙇♂️
Get jun zeng's module, it has no jitter and its overall much better, the links are in the description
I need a new Xbox elite controller badly but I don’t want to get a new one because I feel like the gen 3 elite controller is going to come out soon so idk
Same, gonna buy the gulikit kk3 max and hope its a good one, while I wait for Elite 3, but if they still don't fix the button issues I won't come back to microsoft.
What is the behavior of these joysticks gaming on Windows PC?
I click on the seller's product page on ali for those boards and one of the three options is "joystick" and is one single joystick with a price over 9000? What's that about?
Probably selling in big quantities for resellers or game repair shops
For those who are not techy person. Can you just buy a controller where this hall effect is installed already?
I only know the phantom hex, it is a modded controller that comes with these sticks installed
Other than that you can also buy the controller and the modules and ask a game repair shop to install them for you
Yes there are a few brands out there.
I recently got the GameSir Kaleid Flux to use with with my P.C. and it also works on Xbox. Their controllers are officially licenced by Xbox. The price is very reasonable, £50 in the U.K.
Nacon and Hexgaming do one for Ps5 but its pricey.
Will never buy standard console controllers again.
Is there anything for scuf controllers?
what if i used the xbox one version on rainbow 2 pro controller
i hope this actually works
Is there dead zone or delay? on those hall effects stick
Does the circularity and jitter matter much? I just watched your video on installing Jun's board, but i dont have anything to solder with. Planning on just using these modules on their own
It doesn't matter, circularity is a pointless test, and jitter is filtered by setting a dead zone
@@SzadoB How about you don't open your mouth about things you have no knowledge of? Circularity affects precision in all games but how much it affects will vary from game to game. In the example provided in the video can tell you that the experience will vary from not noticing anything to literally being unable to run diagonally in MGS4 (if it were installed on the left stick). I can also tell you these are the exact same circularity issues (slightly less actually) that you would get from a replacement joystick bought straight from ALPS (via Mauser).
CORRECTION: These have worse circularity issues than ALPS standard potentiometers. I get around 15% from those.
The problem is not the part or the soldering but the calibration required after installation.
Its a bit finicky but not too hard
easy to do once you do it once, it can sometimes take a while, but I found a trick to it but it involves tinkering on both axis
Does anyone know a service that will put on and calibrate hall effect sensors on your controller of choice?
You might try a local computer repair shop since the tools are essentially the same
Hey man, do you think the Xbox One hall effect modules works for 3rd party? Like hyperkin or powera
Você chegou a fazer algum teste separado com esses analógicos laranjas no controle de ps4? Eu tava querendo substituir os meus com eles, mas ainda não tenho muita certeza
Funciona igual, tem videos no youtube mostrando eles ja
Mas tem q comprar a versao propria pra ps4
Can I use this with a PowerA controller? For the xbox
Is it really worth doing the little PCB's for casual gaming? I'm not sure the circularity or jitter is really a problem for most things?
Still a lot work involved, don’t think I’m ready for this yet!
It’s worth it if it works tho because you won’t have to buy another controller
Do you have the video link to how to install the Jun one with the board? Curious to see how hard it is first before I buy
Jun will send me the modules soon, I haven't got them yet
would this only work on pc after of would the ps5 register the imputs too?
É facil de instalar esses sensores só com um ferro de solda?
soldar é facil, dificil vai ser dessoldar, recomendo usar um soprador termico que é a maneira mais facil
So the ps5 version will work with Xbox one s controlle, and not the ps4 version? I found there is 2 model in market 10k and 2k2, I don't know the deference and which one compatible for xbox one s? Iam hella confuse here, hopefully you will answer.
You got new sub
Does this PS5 joystick work with the Xbox Series S controller?
look like they come with drift preloaded
Are these compatible with Xbox series x? No need for the board? Just solder it? Please some1 answer
Anyone knows hall effect sticks for ps2 controlers?
So for quick review... is there a video on how to install the hall effect sticks for the PS5? The video for calibration does not include how to actually tear apart the controller and attach the sticks themselves. Also, with the corrective board would be nice too. I have waited way too long for Hall Effect to come to PS4/PS5 and Xbox. This should scare the crap out of Sony and Microsoft because having these installed on a controller would save $70-80 in the course of potentially years. Thank you again for this info. Hopefully a full tutorial on how to put them all together would be great.
The sticks with jun's extra board is on the way
I'll make a new video when it arrives
i mean, that's precisely why they don't switch to it themselves i would bet. gotta keep people buying products designed to fail
if someone would be so goated as to make these for old consoles 🙏🏽
Sega Dreamcast had Hall Effect Sticks from the start. And for other Consoles I think you only have to search for and will find everything.
Might do this for a drifting dual sense and use it on pc, worth it?
Wouldn't the Magnetic Left Triggers on Xbox interfere with the Left Sticks because it's right under it?
Well from reports on the internet it doesn't affect it but I can't confirm it for sure
yes,i am looking into this but the hall effect sensors seem out of stock on multiple ali vendors?? And the jun zeng's pcb boards+hall sensors are pretty expensive on aliexpress 30$ incl shipping?The hallsensor and pcm board as 1 set should be like 3$ or so as a fair price,.. (The hall sensors are like 40ct a piece and a pcm board like that should be like 1$ a piece max,so 3$ is already a 100% profit.) And to install you have to be a kindoff pro technician with soldering skills and professional gear,because many small mistakes can be made and it wont work.. Anyways thank you VK for this video,hopefully this is a solution for the billion dollar industry of stick drifting controllers,i bet sony and microsoft etc dont like these kind of engineers.Jun Zeng can be a hero for millions of gamers worldwide,if the setup works.It's just a matter of time more vendors will supply the sensors and pcm board for reasonable prices.I am gonna try it out anyway and buy it from Mr Zeng,i do award him for all the work and efford to design the driver pcb board.
Any updates, what's your experience ... ?
Hey Dark,thanks for asking,unfortunately not yet,i do have all the parts from jun zeng now,the total cost came up to 64,25 euro for 2 pairs🤥,because sender forgot to put ioss number on the package,and double vat had to be paid...just finding the time to install,i will update when installed@@dark-california
Wich version is the best ? White black or red ?
Tienen un driver que corrige la variación de señal
Hi, do you know if it is compatible with NS pro controller?
Will they work with the dual sense edge? If so, I am pretty sure that the ps5 allows for calibration on those.
This is completely unnecessary for daulsense edge since you can just buy new stick modules for it, however with the base daulsense the only option is to completely replace the controller, these halleffect sticks save you another $75 where the edge modules are only $20 and as long as you're not literally destroying your edge $20 every other year isn't bad, but I'm not going to spend $200 on a controller I'm only going to play games casually with
Will i have to keep replacing them?
Do i need now the hall effect sticks with the pcb or just the hall effect sticks without it? Any answer would be nice. Thx.
It depends on which model you choose. June's model comes with a kit which requires the pcb board. The other model doesn't need the extra PCB board.
Hope these will be compatible with my PowerA Xbox style controller, would love to switch out the joysticks I currently have for them, one of which is completely busted..(I have 2 of the controllers)
Would this work on a series 2 elite controller? I’m looking at options for replacing my left and right sticks on mine due to stick drift.
yes you should pick the xbox option when buying
@@VKsChannel do I need to buy the jun module and the sensors? I’m trying to do this on a ES2 controller
Could one install this on an old XBOX 360?
Some third party needs to make a dualsense edge hall effect module
Anyone selling hall effect stick modules for the DualSense Edge?
(I mean so that you can just click them in like the official replacement modules)
What about Elite controllers?
I would like to install them on 8bitdo pro 2, which version should I buy?
I too am interested in this. I like the 8bitdo pro 2 layout and features but I really don't want to deal with stick drift.