When the 1st 5 minutes of an emergency call is explaining your defence & not screaming & begging for an ambulance & help, you know something is terribly wrong 😢🙏🕯
I KNOW RIGHT! I came straight to the comments when that call started.... Like why TF are you explaining other things before you say what happened. She guilty 🙄🙄🙄
Facts, why are they acting like this something new, he lives there and can't even remember the last time he seen his son 30lbs in itself is unbelievable he been locked up and they should be severely punished
His embarrassment was so overwhelming and disgusting in himself and the anxiety of his negligence on front Street was too much so he started pounding his car like a toddler throwing a temper tantrum
“My kid is not breathing but, let me explain who’s to blame before I tell you what’s going on” From stoic and explaining it’s not her fault to blubbering to clearly announcing “someone is at the door”. I was screaming at my phone while she’s acting and bad acting, bad acting at that. How is it possible for any human to not have empathy for a child they carried in their body. How are disdain and hate all they feel for a helpless child. Someone at DCFS should also go to prison, this child was failed so badly.
I agree with you 1000%! I’m so tired of DCFS dropping the ball here! Children dying because they WON’T do their job. They need to start putting the workers in jail then bring in all new people that want to be there to save the children. I’m disgusted beyond belief with how the system works. Do you remember the one little boy, he was 3. The system of course dropped the ball. It happened in Carlinville, google Ashley Bottoms. There’s a lot of information about it. This is at the bottom of an article I found! 😡 Strokosch said the child protective services investigator in the case decided that removing Hunter from the home was not appropriate based on the evidence of injuries and the doctor’s evaluation of them. To take a child into protective custody, the Department of Children and Family Services has to prove to a judge that there is an urgent and immediate risk of harm. “We simply did not have that standard in this case,” Strokosch said.
The caseworker was acting within the law which favors family reunification above all. Since the older brother was a teenager he has a legal say in where he wants to live.
I've had issues with them as well! My kids have a well documented history of what it's like at their 'dad's' but nothing gets done! He's fathered 2 more kids with 2 other women, 1 of which left when the child was less than 2 months. She went to school for psychology, and said there was no way in hell she would raise a child there! Before she left him, he was already looking online for a new one! Same thing he did to me! The next one he found is 1/2 his age! That child is not allowed to spend the night at the 'other's ' house, not only because she won't allow it, but because the poor kid doesn't even like going there except for my children! She refuses to allow the boy (the child with 2nd woman) to go to 'her house' so all his time is spent at his grandparent's house! His newest woman (heifer 😂) finally had a kid after spending all his money on her, bit refusing to spend any of his money on our shared children! She only feeds 1 of our children because they have alienated/brainwashed her and I have not had contact with her for 5 years! She says I didn't 'give birth' to her as she 'was cut out'!! WTF?! The 'system' really needs some work on this shit!
@@mbh8621absolutely insane. I’ve actually known a few people who loved their dogs more than their small children, I mean.. dogs deserve love too, but do they deserve to be treated better than your own children, fed better…. Hmmmm
The picture of Navin in a blue hooded sweater is just haunting. Nobody could fail to see there was a massive problem with his health/wellbeing. Child protecticve services, the police, school, health services & every agency involved with this family, from when the 1st baby passed, all dropped the ball so badly on this one. Rip little one. In a better place now.❤ Edit: That defence attourney is just horrible.
They didn’t have custody of him & they let them keep him?! Then they see him skin & bones and still leave him there?! Put DHS in prison for this too. Just as guilty in my opinion. These cases disturb me to the core. Always overweight parents that starve them too. Rest in peace Navin. 💔😢
CPS is failing so many children it's disgusting. I live in NY & the Thomas Valvo case is beyond infuriating & horrific. His so called father was an NYPD cop . Thank God he's now doing life in prison no parole. The stepmother also got a hefty sentence. I feel for his mother. It's all just so wrong.😢😢
Not one actual tear shed by either parent. She was more concerned with lighting her cigarette than saving her own son's life. Truly deplorable, despicable, disgusting trash humans who should never have children.
Watching your videos before youtube pulls them down has become almost a ritual bro 😂 But id also like to thank you as well, as someone who lives on the east coast of Canada, i probably wouldn't hear about 90% of these cases. So thank you from bringing them to light respectfully
Those parents look like siblings for real. How could that lawyer make that argument with a straight face, they had no legal obligation because they didn't have legal guardianship. Utterly disgusting
That was the first thing i said to myself when I saw their pictures side by side. Their excuse is shameful. No doctor would deny seeing a child because the person with them wasn't a legal guardian. They knew they'd be reported for abuse immediately if anyone saw that kid especially a doctor or nurse.
Tbh....alot of dcf workers care...their is so much bs paperwork cuz our government has to get theirs these processes took months. Now...of course u have ppl who don't give a shit. Unfortunately, human beings r the worst species in the world....and no matter what line of work it is...ur gonna find ppl who just don't give a shit. Makes u wonder why even get into a certain line of work if u truly don't care.
A social worker will only have so much power. Will need hard evidence to get it into court. Abusive families usually only abuse one child, so to most people, even people who are close, like close friends, and even family members outside the home will not see the abuse. Because they abuse one child, it looks like the family isn't the problem. The child becomes the problem. So if u hear a family, a mother, a father, telling on how naughty one child is, it's that child being abused.
It confuses me because myself and my cousin have both dealt with CPS for pretty minor, routine things and they've been HELL to us. (Her son got bit by their small dog; my daughter was born with my prescribed daily meds in her system). All it did was show me that CPS is just like the cops -- completely unreliable with scary power. Maybe they'll be honest and fair and help you, maybe they'll be lazy and ignore a dangerous situation where their intervention is needed, and maybe they'll escalate the situation unnecessarily to your detriment.
It should always be a red flag when morbidly obese parents have underweight children. My first boyfriend was in this situation. His mother had padlocked the pantry & fridge. The kids were all underweight and starving... she was massively overweight.
Every single child starvation case I've seen on YT involves extremely overweight/obese parents. The irony is both mind-boggling and truly disturbing. Impossible to understand.
easy to understand if you assume they were trying to help their kids avoid obesity. the thing is that they apparently lacked the discipline to actually make that work which isn't surprising considering they're obese
@@KingaKucyk no idea how you read my post saying they lacked the discipline to control their child's food intake and somehow think I'm saying they have discipline
8:08 UNUSUALLY THIN??? That poor child looks starved to death. Pronounced jaw bone, cheek bones and chin; like a skeleton. With a big hoodie hiding the rest. Sickening.
You know something’s amiss when the 911 operator has to drag out the actual details for the call… urinates, wipes faeces on wall, G’ma kicked him out, acting up blah blah blah! Then… he’s unresponsive, not breathing, been put under the shower and is only 8 🤦🏻♀️ Wtaf??? Mum (I use that term loosely) starts with her defence then reveals a murder.
That’s another thing that sticks me with me about this case, in the photos of naven he was very emaciated. His jaw was so thin it was nothing but edged bone like his skin was pulled against it, with a sunken in face. And to know that cps took those photos and didn’t save him from that monster is beyond sickening.
Nope. I just lost my 32 yr old son Alexander Aug 26th to suicide by train. I literally went through my front door collapsing and losing my mind. I've not been the same since. I cry all the time and just stare.....she couldn't even squeeze a damn tear. I've cried an ocean. 💔💔💔
I lost a son to suicide too. I’m still completely heartsick. I miss him, I’ll always miss him. I’ve cried an ocean. I can’t understand this inability to care for a child, to torture one, to see them wither away. 30 lbs at death? Oh wee boy I’d have loved you.
It's insane how many times I've heard the whole "he's been drinking his own urine/smearing his feces everywhere" bit from abusive parents. I was just like "NOT AGAIN"
In my city CS always bring a cop with them and if you don’t contact them or they believe a child is being abused, cops will either talk their way in or force their way in. The child isn’t suffering anymore.
Seriously. I’m sorry but I support getting people fixed (yes like dogs and cats) bc oh my god this is happening too much. And does no one use birth control? Does no one seek out the morning after pill!?
That lawyer is a scumbag. "They don't have the responsibility." Bull, everyone has the responsibility to help people, especially children. No hospital would have turned them away.
Why didn’t the parents, specifically the father, return the child to the grandmother if he truly cared about the child’s welfare??? Why were they allowed by DCFS and the court to keep the children if the grandmother was their legal guardian?
I’m like two seconds away from looking into what I need to become a DCFS agent bruh I am sick and tired of hearing these cases where these kids are failed, I’ll work 80 hours a week for the rest of my life if I can get these children out of these situations
I will be certified in January of 2025 in Illinois. I’m forty minutes from where this happened. Dcfs here never intervenes, unless you really didn’t need them. My great niece was abused to the point of no return, in Illinois temporary foster care. The foster mom was just convicted.
Again, another banger of a video. At 8:11 it says this is an actual image from the meeting, and if that's true and the DCFS officer saw that image of what could be mistaken for a holocaust victim and said 'looks okay to me' they also need to be in prison for child neglect or dereliction of duty or something
The 'agencies' need to be held responsible for their gross derelict of duties too. If the grandmother had legal custody, why did they let the children remain there? Why why why????
It’s so unsettling that in at least 4 or 5 cases like this they ALWAYS put the unresponsive child into a bathtub before calling 911… I get that in their mind it’s to try and rouse them to avoid getting in trouble but it’s such an eerie pattern to see 😔😔😔
I suspect it also might be because the poor child is filthy and the "parents" want to cover up their neglect. The victims are almost always denied access to the bathroom and sleep on unwashed bedding or the floor.
@@accidentallyamy1063 I think because they completely neglect the child they’re covered in waste, they use the “trying to wake ~ up” is there reason for putting the kid in the tub, only thing that makes any sense to me.
Even when they cry, they cry because they got caught not because they actually cared. At any second if there is remorse they immediately change their behaviour not a second sooner and that lawyer trying to defend them at the end 😮 smh.
At 1:30. Am I the only one who thinks the parents look related? Round facial shape, protruding chin, cheek flaring angle from the nose down, shape and larger than average bridge of nose, angle of the eyebrows, paler band above the upper lip, tip of the nose pointing down, mouth corners, skin tone and amount of freckles, shape of the eyes and upper eyelids...
Imagine you’re calling 911 because your child is unresponsive and the first thing you say is a long summary of what bad things he’s been doing for the last week, insane
That 911 call was horrifying 😮how truly despicable to start badmouthing you're beautiful son while he lay lifeless on the floor not attempting to help him in anyway. The shock of the dispatcher when she was told the child was only 8 yrs old😢 it makes me so angry and sad that he never stood a chance with that woman who birthed him, she wasn't a mother.
The fathers reaction is so bizarre! That poor boy, failed by the people who were supposed to love and protect them unconditionally! I hope the other boy is back with his grandmother and thriving ❤
My grandson is 4.5 yrs and weighs 30 lbs. He's a tiny kid. Unflippinbelievable..neither of these 2 creatures missed a meal. 🤬 Whatever social workers that saw this little boy in that condition and thought it was a good idea to leave him with these 2 idiots should be fired and jailed. I'm not a Dr nor a social worker, no training in that area, it's not hard to see that he is on the brink of death. Jesus..he looks like a victim of the Holocaust. So disgusting, sick, bloodboiling.. I hope both rot and the rest of their days are filled with misery, hunger, and suffering. Prayers for the Grandma and surviving brother. RIH little man 🙏💙🕊 You deserved so much better.
That lawyer is 'tarded! These parents KIDNAPPED their neglected and abused children from her mother and refused to give them back to Grandma. The kids were living under their elusive roof and completely in their care! Social services totally dropped the ball, then kicked it into the opponents field goal on this one. Those kids should've been taken back to Grandma and given full custody, where they were thriving, since their parents failed to do the basic for them and arrested the parents on the spot for felony kidnapping. Those boys deserved a stable environment and better treatment.
The thing that gets me the most is that grandma has custody, reported abuse when she allowed the parents to see him, yet she still left him with the parents while she went out of town for a “few weeks”. I absolutely agree that the authorities should have taken them back, but the kids should have been put into foster care instead of with the grandma.
Having a child should absolutely be more outlawed than having an abortion. The pain of being born and raised into a traumatic environment are infinitely more detrimental to that individual and society as a whole than realizing you’re unequipped beforehand and preemptively doing something to prevent a future of prolonged torture.
So many children endure parents like these every day all around the globe. It's such a sad world. I couldn't finish this one, but I wanted to leave a comment for the algorithm. ❤
DCFS had a chance to save this child. Whoever conducted that meeting should have been held accountable, also. How can you look at that child and think “he’s just thin”????
I can’t bear looking at that poor, innocent child 😢 he literally looked like a skeleton yet the DCFS worker didn’t call the cops and immediately take him from the depraved monsters? Until these incompetent workers start being prosecuted this will continue to happen! RIP Nathan 🕊️
I watch alot of body cams. It's always the same profiles in "parenting". And there is always a poor lil pet that no one shows any regard. It's so gutting all around!!!
After watching so many crime videos... I have noticed something. When a "victim" call 911 and instantly starts explaining details instead of stating the emergency... They are guilty.
There will be a very special welcoming party for these two when they get to prison. It's good to know that even inmates have a code of conduct when it comes to these kind of individuals. 🤘🏻🇬🇧
Is it just me, or do the parents 2:25 look like close relatives to each other? Creepy, I've been down that street and used to live not too far from there near the university.
I'm so confused... The grandmother is granted custody. The grandmother goes away for a few weeks and leaves the boys with their obviously unfit parents. Upon returning, the grandmother goes to pick up the boys, but the parents won't let them go. The police and CPS are notified but don't take the children from the parents despite the fact that the grandmother is the legal guardian. Given, those facts, I'm thoroughly confused as to the actions of everyone involved. Why did the grandmother leave them with the unfit parents? Why did the parents want to keep children who they obviously don't give a flying f*ck about? Why did the police and CPS allow the parents to keep the kids despite the grandmother having legal guardianship of them? What the f*ck is going on???
Can’t tell me those parents aren’t brother and sister. Sick pos both of them. They’re certainly not starving. The defence attorney was a pig too. Poor little boy must have been so alone and terrified. The grandmother should NEVER have left those boys with those monsters while she went to see her mum. They were thriving with her. They went to school. They were fed and happy. She had legal guardianship yet no one felt the need to get them out of that house of horrors and give them back. As usual child services fail another innocent child
DCF is a JOKE!! My 7 year old son was physically and mentally abused by his 2 teachers at school. He is autistic and developmentally delayed. My husband and I knew something was up when he would start fighting us and act absolutely terrified to go. We stopped sending him because we knew something was wrong, but he couldn't tell us. The principal finally told us that an investigation was opened up and what had happened. Did the school district do anything against the teachers? Nope, but they opened up a truancy case against us that lasted almost 3 years. 3 years of constant threats to put him in foster care. 3 years of constant home visits, court dates, meetings, and so much trauma. We finally were able to get him back to a different school with the help of home behavioral therapy, but absolutely NOTHING happened to the 2 "educators." They were reassigned and are still teaching to this very day. It's interesting how the agent told us on numerous occasions that she thought the case was ridiculous and totally unnecessary. My son is 20 now and suffers severe PTSD. I think I suffer a bit from it too.... these people put us through hell, and nothing ever happened to the school district after we pleaded with multiple attorneys to help us.
I'm glad that cop standing there with his body cam on her. It's just going to show the jury how fake ass she is. She's more concerned about late and that cigarette then she is about her kid being dead.
How do you not realize your child is unresponsive at 2 in the afternoon ?!?! No contact from 8:30 the night before till 2:00 pm next day !!! Unreal !!! Such scumbag parents.
Unfortunately most of the time dcf does nothing until its too late. My friend is a teacher and he and his coworkers have made multiple dcf complaints about abuse in homes but they do nothing about it. There's a LOT of red tape that seems to not allow them to help children in need.
this is f****** stupid. if they didn't have legal guardianship how did the kids just not immediately get given back to the grandmother? it's crazy how these people are both literally so incompetent that they didn't even realize that they were too incompetent to try raise kids
She can cook chicken for the dogs but she starves her children? Looks like mom and dad never missed a meal in their lives!! Horrendous! Justice for those innocent children!
Starving kid and overweight parents who cant even fake a tear for him.
The only tears they've got are for themselves.
Such evilness when the grandmother would have cared for him
Too many times. A sweet baby gone due to gluttony greed and selfishness.
It is always this way with the neglected kids. The parents are always well fed whilst their child gets starved to death.
Facts!!
When the 1st 5 minutes of an emergency call is explaining your defence & not screaming & begging for an ambulance & help, you know something is terribly wrong 😢🙏🕯
I was baffled by that. Like could you be any more transparent
Reminds me of Arthur Labinjo-Hughes case… the parents did the same thing, blaming the victim and trying to distance themselves
Yeah I… I’m honestly at a loss for words I really can’t comprehend how a mother could be so evil.
It was disturbing to listen to. The first things out of her mouth should have been my son is unresponsive. Poor wee boy 😢💔
I KNOW RIGHT! I came straight to the comments when that call started.... Like why TF are you explaining other things before you say what happened. She guilty 🙄🙄🙄
I can’t wrap my head around parents who fight to get their kids back just to abuse them. Absolutely evil.
Money
They want the benefits$$$
Pure evil!
All about the benjamins. Why they should be left with relatives..😢
Government welfare. Too lazy to support themselves, so they have babies for the foodstamps, free housing & cash benefits.
They are terrible actors. Dad's slamming the front of a vehicle like he didn't watch his son slowly dying in front of him.
@@green2666 I get the horrified feeling they watched him die, they stood by as baby Ervin.
🎯🎯
Facts, why are they acting like this something new, he lives there and can't even remember the last time he seen his son 30lbs in itself is unbelievable he been locked up and they should be severely punished
Facts, lets see him act his way out of being cornered in his cell
By humans that aint helpless babys..
His embarrassment was so overwhelming and disgusting in himself and the anxiety of his negligence on front Street was too much so he started pounding his car like a toddler throwing a temper tantrum
Her sitting there smoking her cigarette, right after being told her child is dead made me feel so much rage 🤬
I literally caught myself with my mouth open in awww with their lack of emotion!! There's no place on this earth for these kinds of people
🤘🏻🇬🇧
She doesn’t care
@@kdizzle901 not in the slightest!! I truly believe that she is relieved the child is no longer her problem
🤘🏻🇬🇧
And not a single tear.
@@DizzKola3 it's beyond appalling!
🤘🏻🇬🇧
“My kid is not breathing but, let me explain who’s to blame before I tell you what’s going on”
From stoic and explaining it’s not her fault to blubbering to clearly announcing “someone is at the door”. I was screaming at my phone while she’s acting and bad acting, bad acting at that.
How is it possible for any human to not have empathy for a child they carried in their body.
How are disdain and hate all they feel for a helpless child.
Someone at DCFS should also go to prison, this child was failed so badly.
Same here! As soon as she started with the "I told you we needed to X" I, too, was screaming at my phone!
This!!! She called in all nonchalant and told a lame ass story before ever says that he was as 7yr old unresponsive and not breathing like what TF!!!
I agree with you 1000%! I’m so tired of DCFS dropping the ball here! Children dying because they WON’T do their job. They need to start putting the workers in jail then bring in all new people that want to be there to save the children. I’m disgusted beyond belief with how the system works. Do you remember the one little boy, he was 3. The system of course dropped the ball. It happened in Carlinville, google Ashley Bottoms. There’s a lot of information about it. This is at the bottom of an article I found! 😡
Strokosch said the child protective services investigator in the case decided that removing Hunter from the home was not appropriate based on the evidence of injuries and the doctor’s evaluation of them. To take a child into protective custody, the Department of Children and Family Services has to prove to a judge that there is an urgent and immediate risk of harm. “We simply did not have that standard in this case,” Strokosch said.
The caseworker was acting within the law which favors family reunification above all. Since the older brother was a teenager he has a legal say in where he wants to live.
Even the operator sounded pissed. She knew what was happening.
This is beyond disgusting. CPS needs to be held accountable as well. At least to some extent
im sick of CPS not doing their job, sickening
They never are
Unusually thin I can’t believe that was there conclusion he looked like a holocaust survivor
Yes, they dropped the ball again!
I've had issues with them as well! My kids have a well documented history of what it's like at their 'dad's' but nothing gets done! He's fathered 2 more kids with 2 other women, 1 of which left when the child was less than 2 months. She went to school for psychology, and said there was no way in hell she would raise a child there! Before she left him, he was already looking online for a new one! Same thing he did to me! The next one he found is 1/2 his age! That child is not allowed to spend the night at the 'other's ' house, not only because she won't allow it, but because the poor kid doesn't even like going there except for my children! She refuses to allow the boy (the child with 2nd woman) to go to 'her house' so all his time is spent at his grandparent's house! His newest woman (heifer 😂) finally had a kid after spending all his money on her, bit refusing to spend any of his money on our shared children! She only feeds 1 of our children because they have alienated/brainwashed her and I have not had contact with her for 5 years! She says I didn't 'give birth' to her as she 'was cut out'!! WTF?! The 'system' really needs some work on this shit!
Why is CPS ALWAYS involved but never seems to manage to do anything.
bunch of useless females running it on emotions instead of logic
Ignorance, no compassion and easily fooled by an evil monster.
So his dad never looked directly at his child.
Their sole purpose is to cover their own asses and justify their salaries.
Thats what the government pays them to do
They go after the good ones instead. You know.
Everyone around is obese and the child is skin and bones. Wtf
Yes, They Sure haven't missed Any meals!! Sick and Horrific 😢
They’re horrible actors too and they look related
Horrible bastards. Doesn't look like they were withholding any food from themselves..
You know usually when a parent starves their child to death the parent is over weight. It's sick.
Right
Or their dogs. The boy had to steal cooked chicken from the damn dog. Disgusting humans
@@mbh8621absolutely insane. I’ve actually known a few people who loved their dogs more than their small children, I mean.. dogs deserve love too, but do they deserve to be treated better than your own children, fed better…. Hmmmm
Even the dog looks malnourished, meanwhile the adults have not skipped a meal!
The picture of Navin in a blue hooded sweater is just haunting. Nobody could fail to see there was a massive problem with his health/wellbeing. Child protecticve services, the police, school, health services & every agency involved with this family, from when the 1st baby passed, all dropped the ball so badly on this one. Rip little one. In a better place now.❤
Edit: That defence attourney is just horrible.
They didn’t go to school. That’s always a red flag! Can’t blame the teachers.
Anytime someone starts an emergency call with a backstory of everything the victim has been doing wrong lately, they’re guilty 💔
Damn straight so unnecessary for a 911 call
Good observation , never thought of that !
ABSOLUTELY. They’re guilty every time
They didn’t have custody of him & they let them keep him?! Then they see him skin & bones and still leave him there?! Put DHS in prison for this too. Just as guilty in my opinion. These cases disturb me to the core. Always overweight parents that starve them too. Rest in peace Navin. 💔😢
CPS is failing so many children it's disgusting. I live in NY & the Thomas Valvo case is beyond infuriating & horrific. His so called father was an NYPD cop . Thank God he's now doing life in prison no parole. The stepmother also got a hefty sentence. I feel for his mother. It's all just so wrong.😢😢
What does department of homeland security have anything to do with this how is it their fault
Constantly breaks her acting to answer questions and zero tears, so obvious how she really feels
Not one actual tear shed by either parent. She was more concerned with lighting her cigarette than saving her own son's life. Truly deplorable, despicable, disgusting trash humans who should never have children.
When that operator found out her son wasent an adult her heart must of droped! 😢
I heard that in her voice too
Watching your videos before youtube pulls them down has become almost a ritual bro 😂
But id also like to thank you as well, as someone who lives on the east coast of Canada, i probably wouldn't hear about 90% of these cases. So thank you from bringing them to light respectfully
hopefully they'll allow it to stay up this time, as always love for the support & I try my best to source topics that haven't been covered by most 🙏
Tbh, I initially thought this's a re-upload. I remember watching about this case before. Maybe it is?
I’m East Coast Canada too! New Brunswick to be exact! Also love these videos too!
@@ApeHunchoyou rock man this is a great channel
@LauraDort Halifax raised, newfoundland living 👌
Those parents look like siblings for real. How could that lawyer make that argument with a straight face, they had no legal obligation because they didn't have legal guardianship. Utterly disgusting
Yes , their features are too similar not to be blood related
That was the first thing i said to myself when I saw their pictures side by side. Their excuse is shameful. No doctor would deny seeing a child because the person with them wasn't a legal guardian. They knew they'd be reported for abuse immediately if anyone saw that kid especially a doctor or nurse.
When the mug shots were side by side my jaw dropped.
word
For real!!!!!! Those features are almost identical....
I bet she called herself a, "momma bear," on social media....
Don't they all
Full time yummy mummy 😂
Ewww yeah totally
Yet another case of DCFS letting a kid down! Why do these people have jobs!!! 😡😡
DCS does nothing but fail kids. I've seen it many times. The unqualified fools that work for them is sickening.
Tbh....alot of dcf workers care...their is so much bs paperwork cuz our government has to get theirs these processes took months. Now...of course u have ppl who don't give a shit. Unfortunately, human beings r the worst species in the world....and no matter what line of work it is...ur gonna find ppl who just don't give a shit. Makes u wonder why even get into a certain line of work if u truly don't care.
A social worker will only have so much power. Will need hard evidence to get it into court.
Abusive families usually only abuse one child, so to most people, even people who are close, like close friends, and even family members outside the home will not see the abuse. Because they abuse one child, it looks like the family isn't the problem. The child becomes the problem. So if u hear a family, a mother, a father, telling on how naughty one child is, it's that child being abused.
It confuses me because myself and my cousin have both dealt with CPS for pretty minor, routine things and they've been HELL to us. (Her son got bit by their small dog; my daughter was born with my prescribed daily meds in her system).
All it did was show me that CPS is just like the cops -- completely unreliable with scary power. Maybe they'll be honest and fair and help you, maybe they'll be lazy and ignore a dangerous situation where their intervention is needed, and maybe they'll escalate the situation unnecessarily to your detriment.
@@cowoverthemooI was that child! 😮💨
It should always be a red flag when morbidly obese parents have underweight children. My first boyfriend was in this situation. His mother had padlocked the pantry & fridge. The kids were all underweight and starving... she was massively overweight.
Every single child starvation case I've seen on YT involves extremely overweight/obese parents. The irony is both mind-boggling and truly disturbing. Impossible to understand.
easy to understand if you assume they were trying to help their kids avoid obesity. the thing is that they apparently lacked the discipline to actually make that work which isn't surprising considering they're obese
@@andrewbrennan94ummm.... Dyscypline literally never involves starving a child... If it does, FBI needs to get involved...
@@KingaKucyk no idea how you read my post saying they lacked the discipline to control their child's food intake and somehow think I'm saying they have discipline
@andrewbrennan94 I appologise, I didn't intend to suggest You ment it for the children, I just understod it that way.
8:08 UNUSUALLY THIN??? That poor child looks starved to death. Pronounced jaw bone, cheek bones and chin; like a skeleton. With a big hoodie hiding the rest. Sickening.
You know something’s amiss when the 911 operator has to drag out the actual details for the call… urinates, wipes faeces on wall, G’ma kicked him out, acting up blah blah blah! Then… he’s unresponsive, not breathing, been put under the shower and is only 8 🤦🏻♀️ Wtaf??? Mum (I use that term loosely) starts with her defence then reveals a murder.
I'm unsure how the agent could see him & not think something was off...
@ApeHuncho unfortunately a lof them are just there for the paycheck
@@mbh8621All of them.
That’s another thing that sticks me with me about this case, in the photos of naven he was very emaciated. His jaw was so thin it was nothing but edged bone like his skin was pulled against it, with a sunken in face. And to know that cps took those photos and didn’t save him from that monster is beyond sickening.
Its obvious where all the food in the house goes 🤬😡🤬
She fed the dogs but not her children 🥹
And her nails are done... 😡
ANIMALS ALL THE WAY .. THE WAY ITS SUPPOSE TO BE
Her other child was fed
Nope. I just lost my 32 yr old son Alexander Aug 26th to suicide by train. I literally went through my front door collapsing and losing my mind. I've not been the same since. I cry all the time and just stare.....she couldn't even squeeze a damn tear. I've cried an ocean. 💔💔💔
Very sorry to hear that. This happened with a friend of mine.
So very sorry to hear this, my thoughts are with you , i can’t imagine the pain you are going through No parent should ever lose a child!
I’m sorry you’re going through this my heart is with you❤😢
I lost a son to suicide too. I’m still completely heartsick. I miss him, I’ll always miss him. I’ve cried an ocean. I can’t understand this inability to care for a child, to torture one, to see them wither away. 30 lbs at death? Oh wee boy I’d have loved you.
I didn't finish reading your first sentence and I cried. I'm so sorry. 🌹
It's insane how many times I've heard the whole "he's been drinking his own urine/smearing his feces everywhere" bit from abusive parents. I was just like "NOT AGAIN"
I've never heard that before and I've been reading true crime books for about 45 years, and yes I am that old.
Haven't heard that before.
Haven't heard that before.
....
And.
The DCFS also should be held responsible
In my city CS always bring a cop with them and if you don’t contact them or they believe a child is being abused, cops will either talk their way in or force their way in.
The child isn’t suffering anymore.
100%
Yes, but they are never held accountable.
They probably have some sort of immunity.
I'll just explain my life story before I tell you he is not breathing...WTF
Then take her time in between answers!!🙄
Tell-tale straight away...🤦😡
It was so casual
She clearly hasnt skipped any meals!
What a Monster...👹
I swear to god we need to make people pass a test in order to become a parent or have any children in their care. *This can’t keep happening.*
Child protection services drop the ball big time way too often. I feel like if there's a consequence maybe they'll do their job better.
CPS was created for this reaon😢 and it's heartbreaking how CPS is always involved in cases like this but never seem to act accordingly
Seriously. I’m sorry but I support getting people fixed (yes like dogs and cats) bc oh my god this is happening too much. And does no one use birth control? Does no one seek out the morning after pill!?
crazy you need a test to drive but anyone can have kids, sad thing is so many good parents cant have children, and these POS kill children
@@TheQueenOfShebayou’re advocating for eugenics, hope you realize that.
No legal duty? Some defense lawyers are just as sick as the criminals.
@@Emmfra74 it's their job to come up with an argument... they can't just say, "your honor, my client is guilty."
@@Emmfra74 having said that his argument is fucking stupid... I'll give you that.
Totally agree. What a sick pos that lawyer was. Not sure how any defence attorney sleeps at night
That lawyer is a scumbag. "They don't have the responsibility." Bull, everyone has the responsibility to help people, especially children. No hospital would have turned them away.
Why didn’t the parents, specifically the father, return the child to the grandmother if he truly cared about the child’s welfare??? Why were they allowed by DCFS and the court to keep the children if the grandmother was their legal guardian?
I’m like two seconds away from looking into what I need to become a DCFS agent bruh I am sick and tired of hearing these cases where these kids are failed, I’ll work 80 hours a week for the rest of my life if I can get these children out of these situations
I will be certified in January of 2025 in Illinois. I’m forty minutes from where this happened. Dcfs here never intervenes, unless you really didn’t need them. My great niece was abused to the point of no return, in Illinois temporary foster care. The foster mom was just convicted.
I am SO happy that the Justice System was able to deal with them, finally!
As always it was too late, the poor boy starved to death and the 2 fat pigs never missed a meal
Nobody is going to point out the parents are clearly related
They look identical
😂😅
I thought the same thing too, I'm glad I wasn't the only one! 👍
Meaning there son was a product of second generation incest ewwww
If my child died I would be holding them screaming and not want to let go ever… not sitting on the porch steps smoking….heartbreaking
Thank you!!!!
Absolute scumbags.
Again, another banger of a video. At 8:11 it says this is an actual image from the meeting, and if that's true and the DCFS officer saw that image of what could be mistaken for a holocaust victim and said 'looks okay to me' they also need to be in prison for child neglect or dereliction of duty or something
The 'agencies' need to be held responsible for their gross derelict of duties too. If the grandmother had legal custody, why did they let the children remain there? Why why why????
Because you get more money if you have more kids, more food stamps etc.
MONSTERS! & the parents look like siblings in those mugshots.
It’s so unsettling that in at least 4 or 5 cases like this they ALWAYS put the unresponsive child into a bathtub before calling 911… I get that in their mind it’s to try and rouse them to avoid getting in trouble but it’s such an eerie pattern to see 😔😔😔
Yes that's what I thought too.
They also do that to wash off blood or the filth that they leave on the child
They are trying to raise body temp to throw off time of death……and I think it also is a last ditch effort to conceal mistreatment!!!!!
I suspect it also might be because the poor child is filthy and the "parents" want to cover up their neglect. The victims are almost always denied access to the bathroom and sleep on unwashed bedding or the floor.
@@accidentallyamy1063 I think because they completely neglect the child they’re covered in waste, they use the “trying to wake ~ up” is there reason for putting the kid in the tub, only thing that makes any sense to me.
Even when they cry, they cry because they got caught not because they actually cared. At any second if there is remorse they immediately change their behaviour not a second sooner and that lawyer trying to defend them at the end 😮 smh.
His lawyer belongs in Hell for even saying that!!
@@HardRockMiner right... he has no legal responsibility for the child... except for the fact that he wouldn't give it back to the grandma...
Yes 🔥
When you can't even rely on your own parents to protect and provide for you who can you trust
Only yourself
💔
The government.
At 1:30. Am I the only one who thinks the parents look related? Round facial shape, protruding chin, cheek flaring angle from the nose down, shape and larger than average bridge of nose, angle of the eyebrows, paler band above the upper lip, tip of the nose pointing down, mouth corners, skin tone and amount of freckles, shape of the eyes and upper eyelids...
Sounds like foetal alcohol syndrome. Look up the facial characteristics you've basically just described them.
I agree.. they also.look related
Or maybe they just look similar because they have the sam.....issue
This is not just neglect, it is psycopathic torture of a child. Why? Something is wrong in their heads, very wrong. ❤ RIP boy
Imagine you’re calling 911 because your child is unresponsive and the first thing you say is a long summary of what bad things he’s been doing for the last week, insane
9:12 Holding a whole conversation while your child is on the floor deceased and never mentioned it until asked is diabolical. Sign of guilt
9:20 Trying to throw blame on someone else before even telling the 911 dispatcher that your son is unresponsive = guilty.
She is disgusting. And he is just as bad.
There's a reason why *gluttony* is one of the seven _deadly_ sins. Those poor kids. Those hideous, evil parents
That 911 call was horrifying 😮how truly despicable to start badmouthing you're beautiful son while he lay lifeless on the floor not attempting to help him in anyway. The shock of the dispatcher when she was told the child was only 8 yrs old😢 it makes me so angry and sad that he never stood a chance with that woman who birthed him, she wasn't a mother.
The only thing they are upset about is the fact they are about to be found out and they know it.
20:21 she seems so proud. But this child could have been saved. This happens way way to often. These kids deserve so much more.
Yes! What the fuck is she thinking , she’s gonna show the town what a great prosecutor she is, it’s a slam dunk case. She looks foolish.
I don't get how people can do this to their own kids. Seriously disgusting and crazy.
Talk about them like you do other ethnics
@@jaykisuke3397 ...what?
@@jaykisuke3397what are you talking about
@@jaykisuke3397
What?!
@@malegirlbossJay is projecting racism.
Hello, and thank you for sharing Precious Navin's Heart Shattering Story.
The fathers reaction is so bizarre! That poor boy, failed by the people who were supposed to love and protect them unconditionally! I hope the other boy is back with his grandmother and thriving ❤
My grandson is 4.5 yrs and weighs 30 lbs. He's a tiny kid. Unflippinbelievable..neither of these 2 creatures missed a meal. 🤬 Whatever social workers that saw this little boy in that condition and thought it was a good idea to leave him with these 2 idiots should be fired and jailed. I'm not a Dr nor a social worker, no training in that area, it's not hard to see that he is on the brink of death. Jesus..he looks like a victim of the Holocaust. So disgusting, sick, bloodboiling.. I hope both rot and the rest of their days are filled with misery, hunger, and suffering. Prayers for the Grandma and surviving brother. RIH little man 🙏💙🕊 You deserved so much better.
Welp…looks like the two evil so called parents never missed a meal!
Poor kid. May he RIP and justice is served swiftly. 😪
did you miss the part where she was cooking chicken for their dogs and they got mad at the kid for eating the chicken that they cooked for the dogs???
@ yes! What an evil garbage she is.
And not one tear for either one of them.
That lawyer is 'tarded! These parents KIDNAPPED their neglected and abused children from her mother and refused to give them back to Grandma. The kids were living under their elusive roof and completely in their care! Social services totally dropped the ball, then kicked it into the opponents field goal on this one. Those kids should've been taken back to Grandma and given full custody, where they were thriving, since their parents failed to do the basic for them and arrested the parents on the spot for felony kidnapping. Those boys deserved a stable environment and better treatment.
The thing that gets me the most is that grandma has custody, reported abuse when she allowed the parents to see him, yet she still left him with the parents while she went out of town for a “few weeks”. I absolutely agree that the authorities should have taken them back, but the kids should have been put into foster care instead of with the grandma.
Imadgine how his poor grandma feels. She tried so so hard😢😢😢
She was let down big time
Having a child should absolutely be more outlawed than having an abortion.
The pain of being born and raised into a traumatic environment are infinitely more detrimental to that individual and society as a whole than realizing you’re unequipped beforehand and preemptively doing something to prevent a future of prolonged torture.
Not a defense for murder. I'm sure the child wanted to live.
The whole system let that kid down 😢
Rest in peace baby boy 💔😭
So many children endure parents like these every day all around the globe.
It's such a sad world.
I couldn't finish this one, but I wanted to leave a comment for the algorithm.
❤
Can tell that lady doing the press conference was so angry and disgusted by what they did. Got emotional watching her. Poor little boy😞
DCFS had a chance to save this child. Whoever conducted that meeting should have been held accountable, also. How can you look at that child and think “he’s just thin”????
I can’t bear looking at that poor, innocent child 😢 he literally looked like a skeleton yet the DCFS worker didn’t call the cops and immediately take him from the depraved monsters? Until these incompetent workers start being prosecuted this will continue to happen! RIP Nathan 🕊️
During that call you can practically hear her realize
"OH WAIT IM NOT CRYING" switch flicks "i dont know what to doooo T-T"
DCFS clearly failed to protect these Kids!!! This poor kid starved to D**th, and both looks like they didn't skip a meal!! Disgusting!
I watch alot of body cams. It's always the same profiles in "parenting". And there is always a poor lil pet that no one shows any regard. It's so gutting all around!!!
After watching so many crime videos... I have noticed something. When a "victim" call 911 and instantly starts explaining details instead of stating the emergency... They are guilty.
There will be a very special welcoming party for these two when they get to prison. It's good to know that even inmates have a code of conduct when it comes to these kind of individuals.
🤘🏻🇬🇧
Is it just me, or do the parents 2:25 look like close relatives to each other? Creepy, I've been down that street and used to live not too far from there near the university.
Nah I definitely thought they were at least first cousins
They look like siblings🤮
why are these "parents" who starve their children always rotund?!
I'm so confused...
The grandmother is granted custody.
The grandmother goes away for a few weeks and leaves the boys with their obviously unfit parents.
Upon returning, the grandmother goes to pick up the boys, but the parents won't let them go.
The police and CPS are notified but don't take the children from the parents despite the fact that the grandmother is the legal guardian.
Given, those facts, I'm thoroughly confused as to the actions of everyone involved.
Why did the grandmother leave them with the unfit parents?
Why did the parents want to keep children who they obviously don't give a flying f*ck about?
Why did the police and CPS allow the parents to keep the kids despite the grandmother having legal guardianship of them?
What the f*ck is going on???
F**K!! I can’t even watch this it upsets me so much! She, the sea mammal doesn’t feed the kid!
Huge people starving their kids always get me the MADDEST... SO sick...
This woman makes me sick!!!
Can’t tell me those parents aren’t brother and sister. Sick pos both of them. They’re certainly not starving. The defence attorney was a pig too. Poor little boy must have been so alone and terrified. The grandmother should NEVER have left those boys with those monsters while she went to see her mum. They were thriving with her. They went to school. They were fed and happy. She had legal guardianship yet no one felt the need to get them out of that house of horrors and give them back. As usual child services fail another innocent child
How can you lack maternal primal insinct to nourish your offspring?
DCF is a JOKE!! My 7 year old son was physically and mentally abused by his 2 teachers at school. He is autistic and developmentally delayed. My husband and I knew something was up when he would start fighting us and act absolutely terrified to go. We stopped sending him because we knew something was wrong, but he couldn't tell us.
The principal finally told us that an investigation was opened up and what had happened.
Did the school district do anything against the teachers? Nope, but they opened up a truancy case against us that lasted almost 3 years.
3 years of constant threats to put him in foster care. 3 years of constant home visits, court dates, meetings, and so much trauma.
We finally were able to get him back to a different school with the help of home behavioral therapy, but absolutely NOTHING happened to the 2 "educators." They were reassigned and are still teaching to this very day.
It's interesting how the agent told us on numerous occasions that she thought the case was ridiculous and totally unnecessary.
My son is 20 now and suffers severe PTSD. I think I suffer a bit from it too.... these people put us through hell, and nothing ever happened to the school district after we pleaded with multiple attorneys to help us.
Hey Ape Huncho! I always look forward to your awesome videos! ❤
This is what this world is coming too! Evil everywhere.in the homes , government, hospitals, schools etc . Thank you for the story 😊
I'm glad that cop standing there with his body cam on her. It's just going to show the jury how fake ass she is. She's more concerned about late and that cigarette then she is about her kid being dead.
I too was born in Peoria. But I grew up in Moline. This story is so sad 😢. RIP Navin 🙏 you were such a sweet soul!
JESUS CHRIST
THIS IS LITERALLY HAPPENING IN PEOPLE FACES AND YET LOOK THE OTHER WAY.....THIS IS JUST SICK
One last F you to this poor Angel is his parents trying to blame him for his death..
14:15 That was cute
They all walked away 😂
14:22 he was outta breath, needed a minute 😂
Well done video my guy. Did anyone else get the feeling something was off with those two and the lawyer? Something just aint right man...
26:22 Oh my God. His facial expressions, & complete cockiness while on the stand, he’s gonna get his self laid out in prison.
🤞
With any luck 🙏🏼
How do you not realize your child is unresponsive at 2 in the afternoon ?!?! No contact from 8:30 the night before till 2:00 pm next day !!! Unreal !!! Such scumbag parents.
Unfortunately most of the time dcf does nothing until its too late. My friend is a teacher and he and his coworkers have made multiple dcf complaints about abuse in homes but they do nothing about it. There's a LOT of red tape that seems to not allow them to help children in need.
10 minutes in & I'm literally fuming already !!! 😡🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬 why can't they just let him go to his grandparents who love him.
this is f****** stupid. if they didn't have legal guardianship how did the kids just not immediately get given back to the grandmother?
it's crazy how these people are both literally so incompetent that they didn't even realize that they were too incompetent to try raise kids
She’s a badass!!! I love strong women like her! You go girl! Those horrific people should be sent to prison for the rest of there lives!!
The parents look like brother and sister.
I feel for the grandmother she had those babies lives in her heart. I hope the parents never get out. God Bless you grandma so sorry for your loss.
She can still hold her smoke then light it ,p.o.s!
She can cook chicken for the dogs but she starves her children? Looks like mom and dad never missed a meal in their lives!! Horrendous! Justice for those innocent children!
The parents & the system failed that poor child
If your first instinct during an emergency is to justify yourself instead of desperately asking for help, something feels deeply off. 😢💔