Audra MacDonald’s amazing as Reverend Mother. I love the spin they did on this song and how this scene tells us about Reverend Mother and Maria’s mother-daughter-type relationship.
in the actual film they sing this during the thunderstorm scene but in this they sing the lonely goatherd JULIE ANDREWS plays MARIA IN the movie in this scene they sing it at the ABBEY her name is CARRIE UNDERWOOD
Audra McDonald is a force to be reckoned with. I don’t see her “Climb Ev’ry Mountain” on this channel but I hope they upload it soon! She’s truly one of the most talented women of the modern era.
Carrie has a natural Broadway voice. Her speaking intonation when she isn’t singing just sounds like she is natural at performing and singing. You can hear how crisp her words come out in her songs and how she can change her dynamic so quickly. I think that’s one quality that Kelly Clarkson doesn’t really have. God blessed this woman with a good Respiratory System Audra McDonald is one of the best Soprano singers I have ever heard. Let me not forget that I cried when I heard her in Porgy and Bess.
My grandmother's favorite song to sing when I was a little girl was "My Favorite Things" I sang it in high school for a singing competition This song is special.
You can BUY The Phantom Of The Opera on YT and support the show. Seriously, it was so much fun when people used to watch these videos and just be grateful without demanding more.
@@naastyaaaaaaaaa I kinda agree with what you're saying but- A lot of people, don't have the money to buy the show. Including me. It doesn't give them a reason to demand a show. But at the same time, its past mid - August and they still haven't given us any updates. So (in a way) people do have a right to ask.
@@euphoria7372 I understand there are people who can't afford big purchases but for example in my country the entire TPOTO with Sarah's performance at the end and everything cost about 5 dollars.. I just think if you really really want something you'll seek opportunities to get it with your own effort. Like earn of save some money)) This way when you finally get it it'll give you such satisfaction that one only feels if they worked hard enough to ahieve their goal. :)
@@naastyaaaaaaaaa I completely get what you're saying. Its just, where I live its costs about R100 to R150. For a lot of people it might not seem like a lot but, for me, its a lot of money. I'm fine with them not posting the show. I know its a lot of work to work out the copyright issues. I was just trying to say _why_ a lot of people are asking for a show, or in other cases, demanding it. I completely agree with you, I'm just saying a lot of people just can't afford something like that.
@@euphoria7372 i just don't understand why some people nowadays demand stuff in such a way. I can't stop imagining myself in the shoes of whoever runs this channel. They do so much for us, but the more treats they give us the less gratitude they get in return. I simply wanted to say that it's just so sad to see these straightforward comments demanding more without even aknowledging what's already been shown.
I do think it says a lot about how great a singer Carrie Underwood is that she doesn't get entirely overshadowed by Audra McDonald, who's honestly God's gift to us.
In this performance, I think she does. I'd say Carrie struggled with this musical number, sounds rather pitchy while Audra sounded perfect. Carrie was good in other musical numbers in this musical though, her acting sadly was always awful though
THIS IS SO GOOD I feel like joining them and turning it into a trio, but I know if I actually was there it wouldn't sound as good, because, of course, who am I as a singer? But I wanna join because it feels so happy!! This is AMAZING
I loved her, too, and I saw the movie with Julie Andrews in the theater and loved it. I even have the original soundtrack LP. Julie Andrews herself, though, has always left me a bit cold with her androgynous looks (almost always the very short boyish haircuts, for example) Yes, Julie had great talent, but I preferred this live version Carrie is beautiful and feminine and with her coloring, looked like an "Alps" girl. I prefer Ms. Underwood's singing voice also, and remember that she had to do it all live!!!!! This was based not on the movie,, but on the stage version. Also two of the best songs were left out of the movie version! I was 'knocked out" by the spectacular acting and singing of Laura Benanti and Christian Borle. I love those two big numbers that they did!!!! All of the kids were great as well. I do not understand why people did not appreciate Stephen Moyer more. I had never heard of him before, but he is a very handsome guy and I liked his singing. Christopher Plummer, who played Von Trapp in the movie, was by many accounts, a nasty piece of work. He admitted to bring drunk in some of the scenes in the movie, and he was always really arrogant. Over the years, he made a lot of unkind remarks about Julie Andrews and about many things in the movie. I think the nasty father/,architect he played in "Lake House" captured his real, unpleasant personality.
[ LYRICS ] Raindrops on roses and whiskers on kittens Bright copper kettles and warm woolen mittens Brown paper packages tied up with strings These are a few of my favorite things Cream-colored ponies and crisp apple strudels Doorbells and sleigh bells and schnitzel with noodles Wild geese that fly with the moon on their wings These are a few of my favorite things Girls in white dresses with blue satin sashes Snowflakes that stay on my nose and eyelashes Silver-white winters that melt into springs These are a few of my favorite things When the dog bites When the bee stings When I'm feeling sad I simply remember my favorite things And then I don't feel so bad Raindrops on roses and whiskers on kittens Bright copper kettles and warm woolen mittens Brown paper packages tied up with strings These are a few of my favorite things Cream-colored ponies and crisp apple strudels Doorbells and sleigh bells and schnitzel with noodles Wild geese that fly with the moon on their wings These are a few of my favorite things Girls in white dresses with blue satin sashes Snowflakes that stay on my nose and eyelashes Silver-white winters that melt into springs These are a few of my favorite things When the dog bites When the bee stings When I'm feeling sad I simply remember my favorite things And then I don't feel so bad
I bet JULIE ANDREWS cried when she heard CARRIE UNDERWOOD following in her FOOTSTEPS as MARIA she says the same LINES THAT JULIE ANDREWS SAID the new MARIA
I really don't wanna comment on every single video you guys post but- Its past mid - August and you guys haven't given us any updates at all. I don't care if you decide not to do full shows anymore, just please, at least just say something.
Throughout the life of this channel, NBCUniversal have not entered into dialogue on these boards, wisely in my view. I believe their stance is that if they choose to post some of their programmes on here, it is at their prerogative. They are not answerable to anyone other than the copyright owners. They have not entered into any form of contract with users of this site, Let's face it, the content of this site is a miniscule proportion of all the free programmes available on RUclips. I really do not understand why people are getting so exercised about this.
@@brianaustin5467 I completely understand what you're saying. And its true but- The thing what upsets me is that, they said mid - August, they got a bunch of peoples hopes up for no reason. Of course They don't owe any of their viewers anything. but still, they could at least address it. Many people (From what I've seen) have very tight schedules, what they opened _just_ to watch, whatever show they put on, just to be disappointed. I'm personally fine with it. Its JUST my opinion. I fully respect yours. I'm grateful for them still putting work in, and still making videos for us. I just want them to address it.
@@euphoria7372 It is worthwhile to remember that the principal reason that this channel was initiated was to encourage people to contribute to charitable funds providing for out of work entertainment professionals, and other worthy causes. In this respect it has not been very successful. In fact the only site such as this, that I have seen, to provide a good level of contributions has been that of The Royal Opera House. In general contributions have averaged out at a few pence/cents per viewer. This aim seems to have escaped most people who come here clamouring for programmes that Universal does not have (or do not even exist). Many of them cannot even summon up the energy to say "please". From what I have observed, when Universal intend to post a programme, they inform the trade press a few days in advance, and place a notice on this site around 48 hours before launch. The programme is then on here for 24/48 hours. This should be plenty of time to allow people to plan their viewing. I was not criticising you in particular, rather the general sense of entitlement that some people display on these threads. Perhaps Universal made a rod for their own back by setting a timescale, but presumably they meant to honour it at the time. In any event, when they do start to repost shows the complaints will start from those who do not like them, wanted a repeat of a previous show, moaning that it is a repeat, or demanding something that is not in Universal's catalogue. And the contributions to worthy causes will still be pitiful.
@@brianaustin5467 Woah... That must've taken long to type. I do agree with you completely (From what I understand from your comment) I was just upset that they said they were going to start streaming shows again, and then when the time came, they stayed completely silent. I get that they were probably just busy, and didn't have time to post an update. But its like if, a movie company or a brand, said they were going to release something and then, they don't, and they act like they never said anything about it. I've seen people do it before. I know the shows must go on channel is very different from other people who have done stuff like that. But I'm just saying. And also, I _didn't_ ask them to do shows again, I just asked them to address the situation. And also (I almost forgot) Andrew Lloyd Webber did make a video saying that thay raised over half a million dollars for the actors fund. From What I understand from your comment. You make it sound like they barely made any money. I don't want to continue this argument, I want a solution.
I still think they made the right decision when they made the film to relocate this to the bedroom scene and if this song seems familiar it’s the first part of seven rings
Can you believe they made Audra McDonald a boring background character in the beauty & the beast remake. One of the most beautiful voices of all time wasted.
raindrops on roses and whiskers on kittens bright copper kettles and warm woolen mittens brown paper packages tied up with strings these are a few of my favorite things cream colored ponies and crisp apple strudels doorbells and seligh bells and schnitzel with noddles wild geese that fly with the moon on their wings these are a few of my favorite things girls in white dresses with blue satin sashes snowflakes that stay on my nose and eyelashes silver white winters that melts into springs these are a few of my favorite things when the dog bites when the bee stings when I'm feeling sad i simply remember my favorite things and then i don't feel so bad
@@zfox8754 Casting in a musical should be color blind. It’s a story that is made up.. You do know that the real Von Trapps didn’t escape Austria over the mountains, right?
Carrie’s lack of acting experience badly showed in scenes like this one. The dialogue delivery is rushed and uneven and it felt like she tried to make up for that with her singing. Meanwhile Audra is pitch perfect.
Carrie was playing a young nun, not an Academy Award winning actress. I liked her vulnerability as it was very real and was appropriate for being anxious that she had upset the Mother Superior!!!!!
Audra should've been cast as Maria, maybe earlier in her career, but put her in a musical and you can tell the others have nothing on her. Carries tries and sounds great but she doesn't have the depth. That's why the phrasing here is all changed for the Ma Sup so she doesn't show up the weaker voice.
Apart from Audre...I really cannot listen to Carrie..with due respect, that fatal feature or string (call it the missing but crucial factor) that Julie infused once and for all times can never be replaced.. sorry, no bad feelings, just my opinion!
So sorry that the wonderful Audra McDonald had to work opposite an amateur for this production. Wasn't any talent on a calibre near Miss Julie Andrews available or was the cringeworthy Miss Underwood truthful in saying she was on her knees to get this role?
Underwood is extraordinarily vocally talented, so what nonsense are you on about? 🤣 Just because she wasn't classically trained like Andrews doesn't mean she's any less talented.
Carrie is vocally talented. It's really hard to do musical theatre well (singing+acting+dancing), so Audra is obviously the musical theatre talent here BUT Carrie isnt untalented.
@@motab9907 Completely different styles and vocal techniques, it has nothing to do with "talent" and EVERYTHING to do with training and stylistic choices. Underwood has top of the line RAW vocal talent in spades.
Carrie,'s voice is superb, and although I loved the movie and have the original soundtrack album, I prefer her singing to Julie's. I also saw absolutely nothing wrong with her acting. She gave her character an air of innocent vulnerability, which Ms. Andrews did not.
Well I saw it one time when I was 13. I cared more about the music than the story. It took me seven years to give the movie a second try. Of all motivations, it was to prepare for this telecast. I’ve seen the movie 10 times now. I’m 30 now
Audra McDonald could sing the Manhattan phone book and make it sound good. She’s such a talented, versatile, and gorgeous lady.
Audra MacDonald’s amazing as Reverend Mother. I love the spin they did on this song and how this scene tells us about Reverend Mother and Maria’s mother-daughter-type relationship.
The context was just like this in the original Broadway script! But I agree
I spent the whole musical thinking Maria was played by reese Witherspoon
Same
in the actual film they sing this during the thunderstorm scene but in this they sing the lonely goatherd JULIE ANDREWS plays MARIA IN the movie in this scene they sing it at the ABBEY her name is CARRIE UNDERWOOD
Lol 🤣
Sameeee
🤣
Audra's voice gives me goosebumps every time, even way back when I first heard her in Annie on vhs!
YES!! 1999 Annie! She was simply incredible!
@@kathrynberry7737 I know she’s the best grace ever Julie’s is better
It took me years to sit down through Annie
Audra McDonald is a force to be reckoned with. I don’t see her “Climb Ev’ry Mountain” on this channel but I hope they upload it soon! She’s truly one of the most talented women of the modern era.
Audra McDonald's Mother Superior was the highlight of this entire show. I adore her.
Carrie has a natural Broadway voice. Her speaking intonation when she isn’t singing just sounds like she is natural at performing and singing. You can hear how crisp her words come out in her songs and how she can change her dynamic so quickly. I think that’s one quality that Kelly Clarkson doesn’t really have. God blessed this woman with a good Respiratory System
Audra McDonald is one of the best Soprano singers I have ever heard. Let me not forget that I cried when I heard her in Porgy and Bess.
My grandmother's favorite song to sing when I was a little girl was "My Favorite Things"
I sang it in high school for a singing competition
This song is special.
Petition to get them to rerun phantom!
You can BUY The Phantom Of The Opera on YT and support the show.
Seriously, it was so much fun when people used to watch these videos and just be grateful without demanding more.
@@naastyaaaaaaaaa I kinda agree with what you're saying but-
A lot of people, don't have the money to buy the show. Including me. It doesn't give them a reason to demand a show. But at the same time, its past mid - August and they still haven't given us any updates. So (in a way) people do have a right to ask.
@@euphoria7372 I understand there are people who can't afford big purchases but for example in my country the entire TPOTO with Sarah's performance at the end and everything cost about 5 dollars.. I just think if you really really want something you'll seek opportunities to get it with your own effort. Like earn of save some money)) This way when you finally get it it'll give you such satisfaction that one only feels if they worked hard enough to ahieve their goal. :)
@@naastyaaaaaaaaa I completely get what you're saying. Its just, where I live its costs about R100 to R150. For a lot of people it might not seem like a lot but, for me, its a lot of money. I'm fine with them not posting the show. I know its a lot of work to work out the copyright issues. I was just trying to say _why_ a lot of people are asking for a show, or in other cases, demanding it. I completely agree with you, I'm just saying a lot of people just can't afford something like that.
@@euphoria7372 i just don't understand why some people nowadays demand stuff in such a way. I can't stop imagining myself in the shoes of whoever runs this channel. They do so much for us, but the more treats they give us the less gratitude they get in return. I simply wanted to say that it's just so sad to see these straightforward comments demanding more without even aknowledging what's already been shown.
Audra is of course A+++ 😍😍😍 and Carrie sounds beautiful!
Audra McDonald is everything.
I love Audra McDonald as an actress I love Carrie Underwood Voice when she sings my favorite things
I do think it says a lot about how great a singer Carrie Underwood is that she doesn't get entirely overshadowed by Audra McDonald, who's honestly God's gift to us.
In this performance, I think she does. I'd say Carrie struggled with this musical number, sounds rather pitchy while Audra sounded perfect.
Carrie was good in other musical numbers in this musical though, her acting sadly was always awful though
This is one of my favorite things actually.... This channel. And wild geese. And Mary Oliver.
Sounds like you're my kinda person!
This song: exists
Ariana Grande: hipitty hopitty this is now my property
Hey, I guess if she wants it, she's got it, lol.
@@kenzem.5612 Lol
She actually didn't. She pays almost 90 % of what 7rings brings in as royalties to the owners of this song
Audra was Madame garderobe in beauty and the beast!!!! 😍😍
And she was in the 1999 TV film version of Annie
@@williamfairchild7439 i love her IN ANNIE i was watching the new ANNIE I thought of AUDRA i love her as GRACE in ANNIE
Although I love the song better during the thunderstorm scene, I love how Carrie and Audra play off each other vocally here!
Please can we have show this week? Phantom, Jesus, anything!!!
JCS!
Carrie does a beautiful job at singing or acting.
Carrie Underwood is amazing! Who knew?
Thank you so much for uploading this song 😍❤️
Audra McDonald!!! ❤️
The most inspirational, hopeful song ever.
I've waited for this so long omg
I'm still salty that Disney didn't cast Audra as Mrs. Potts... she would have killed it singing Beauty & the Beast...
Amazing! Carrie is such a beautiful Lady
I like this!
THIS IS SO GOOD
I feel like joining them and turning it into a trio, but I know if I actually was there it wouldn't sound as good, because, of course, who am I as a singer? But I wanna join because it feels so happy!! This is AMAZING
Love Carrie
Queen Audra all hail Queen Audra
She and Idina have got to do a duet
I don’t understand why no one liked Carrie as frauline Maria I loved her
I loved her, too, and I saw the movie with Julie Andrews in the theater and loved it. I even have the original soundtrack LP. Julie Andrews herself, though, has always left me a bit cold with her androgynous looks (almost always the very short boyish haircuts, for example)
Yes, Julie had great talent, but I preferred this live version
Carrie is beautiful and feminine and with her coloring, looked like an "Alps" girl. I prefer Ms. Underwood's singing voice also, and remember that she had to do it all live!!!!! This was based not on the movie,, but on the stage version. Also two of the best songs were left out of the movie version! I was 'knocked out" by the spectacular acting and singing of Laura Benanti and Christian Borle. I love those two big numbers that they did!!!! All of the kids were great as well. I do not understand why people did not appreciate Stephen Moyer more. I had never heard of him before, but he is a very handsome guy and I liked his singing. Christopher Plummer, who played Von Trapp in the movie, was by many accounts, a nasty piece of work. He admitted to bring drunk in some of the scenes in the movie, and he was always really arrogant. Over the years, he made a lot of unkind remarks about Julie Andrews and about many things in the movie. I think the nasty father/,architect he played in "Lake House" captured his real, unpleasant personality.
The issue that I had with Carrie was the acting. Her singing was excellent.
[ LYRICS ]
Raindrops on roses and whiskers on kittens
Bright copper kettles and warm woolen mittens
Brown paper packages tied up with strings
These are a few of my favorite things
Cream-colored ponies and crisp apple strudels
Doorbells and sleigh bells and schnitzel with noodles
Wild geese that fly with the moon on their wings
These are a few of my favorite things
Girls in white dresses with blue satin sashes
Snowflakes that stay on my nose and eyelashes
Silver-white winters that melt into springs
These are a few of my favorite things
When the dog bites
When the bee stings
When I'm feeling sad
I simply remember my favorite things
And then I don't feel so bad
Raindrops on roses and whiskers on kittens
Bright copper kettles and warm woolen mittens
Brown paper packages tied up with strings
These are a few of my favorite things
Cream-colored ponies and crisp apple strudels
Doorbells and sleigh bells and schnitzel with noodles
Wild geese that fly with the moon on their wings
These are a few of my favorite things
Girls in white dresses with blue satin sashes
Snowflakes that stay on my nose and eyelashes
Silver-white winters that melt into springs
These are a few of my favorite things
When the dog bites
When the bee stings
When I'm feeling sad
I simply remember my favorite things
And then I don't feel so bad
TNX !!
Carrie acts better when she’s singing! Definitely not the worst performance of this song!
I bet JULIE ANDREWS cried when she heard CARRIE UNDERWOOD following in her FOOTSTEPS as MARIA she says the same LINES THAT JULIE ANDREWS SAID the new MARIA
@@gracepuckett8310 OH MY GOSH I've been seeing you throwing hates to Carrie. 😂
@@tayloralisonswift9544 I Just like both people that play MARIA
Amazing voices!!
This song is better when the kids sing it
Excellent!
This show is based on the original Broadway performance. While I think the film version was better, this is a pretty solid performance.
I have the same feeling
Mary Martin was Maria in the original production of Sound of Music.
Love Carrie!
that was her mountain 🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️🏔️
Great performance 👏👏
Petition to get them to rerun phantom! Sign in the replies i guess lol
i have a saved recording >:)
I signed
usually musical-ly can you share the recording?
Carter Henley sure! would you mind doing it over email?
usually musical-ly I found a free 25th anniversary on dailymotion
Merry Christmas!
Amazing!!
Great clip to celebrate the new banner!:)
ariana could never
I really don't wanna comment on every single video you guys post but-
Its past mid - August and you guys haven't given us any updates at all. I don't care if you decide not to do full shows anymore, just please, at least just say something.
Throughout the life of this channel, NBCUniversal have not entered into dialogue on these boards, wisely in my view. I believe their stance is that if they choose to post some of their programmes on here, it is at their prerogative. They are not answerable to anyone other than the copyright owners. They have not entered into any form of contract with users of this site,
Let's face it, the content of this site is a miniscule proportion of all the free programmes available on RUclips. I really do not understand why people are getting so exercised about this.
@@brianaustin5467 I completely understand what you're saying. And its true but-
The thing what upsets me is that, they said mid - August, they got a bunch of peoples hopes up for no reason. Of course They don't owe any of their viewers anything. but still, they could at least address it. Many people (From what I've seen) have very tight schedules, what they opened _just_ to watch, whatever show they put on, just to be disappointed. I'm personally fine with it. Its JUST my opinion. I fully respect yours. I'm grateful for them still putting work in, and still making videos for us. I just want them to address it.
@@euphoria7372 It is worthwhile to remember that the principal reason that this channel was initiated was to encourage people to contribute to charitable funds providing for out of work entertainment professionals, and other worthy causes. In this respect it has not been very successful. In fact the only site such as this, that I have seen, to provide a good level of contributions has been that of The Royal Opera House. In general contributions have averaged out at a few pence/cents per viewer. This aim seems to have escaped most people who come here clamouring for programmes that Universal does not have (or do not even exist). Many of them cannot even summon up the energy to say "please".
From what I have observed, when Universal intend to post a programme, they inform the trade press a few days in advance, and place a notice on this site around 48 hours before launch. The programme is then on here for 24/48 hours. This should be plenty of time to allow people to plan their viewing.
I was not criticising you in particular, rather the general sense of entitlement that some people display on these threads. Perhaps Universal made a rod for their own back by setting a timescale, but presumably they meant to honour it at the time. In any event, when they do start to repost shows the complaints will start from those who do not like them, wanted a repeat of a previous show, moaning that it is a repeat, or demanding something that is not in Universal's catalogue. And the contributions to worthy causes will still be pitiful.
They have a new banner!
@@brianaustin5467 Woah... That must've taken long to type. I do agree with you completely (From what I understand from your comment) I was just upset that they said they were going to start streaming shows again, and then when the time came, they stayed completely silent. I get that they were probably just busy, and didn't have time to post an update. But its like if, a movie company or a brand, said they were going to release something and then, they don't, and they act like they never said anything about it. I've seen people do it before. I know the shows must go on channel is very different from other people who have done stuff like that. But I'm just saying. And also, I _didn't_ ask them to do shows again, I just asked them to address the situation. And also (I almost forgot) Andrew Lloyd Webber did make a video saying that thay raised over half a million dollars for the actors fund. From What I understand from your comment. You make it sound like they barely made any money. I don't want to continue this argument, I want a solution.
Audra❤️❤️❤️
Iconic!!
I still think they made the right decision when they made the film to relocate this to the bedroom scene and if this song seems familiar it’s the first part of seven rings
@Bowbow 7w6😊 I don’t think so
Can you believe they made Audra McDonald a boring background character in the beauty & the beast remake. One of the most beautiful voices of all time wasted.
Ommmmmgggg Carrie Underwood
Wow!!
S L A M S T A B L E ! !🤣
Excellent
superb
My Favorite Things- song on Sounds Of Music 🎵.
raindrops on roses and whiskers on kittens bright copper kettles and warm woolen mittens brown paper packages tied up with strings these are a few of my favorite things cream colored ponies and crisp apple strudels doorbells and seligh bells and schnitzel with noddles wild geese that fly with the moon on their wings these are a few of my favorite things girls in white dresses with blue satin sashes snowflakes that stay on my nose and eyelashes silver white winters that melts into springs these are a few of my favorite things when the dog bites when the bee stings when I'm feeling sad i simply remember my favorite things and then i don't feel so bad
❤❤❤
Step aside Carrie.... Audra will take it from here!
Are full length shows ever going to return?
Lonely goatherd pls
Woah Karen who’s mountain?
Couldn’t resist
It was good,a little. But before she sang every word, she took in a sharp breath.😑😒🤏
❤️
Бог не против песен и танцев! Я думаю, это не грех!
2nd omg!
I love Carrie, but I think Audra did it better. Wonderful, joyful piece by two great ladies!
Julie foreverr
I prefer the attitude in Schadenfreude
Me listening to Julie Andrews: Hmmm silk and satin
Me listening to Carrie Underwood: Ouch ouch get this sandpaper off my ass
what is this acting
😂😂😂
Reality check: Black people would NOT be in Austria in the early 1900s. No Offense.
@Thomas Sheridan I seriously doubt it.
Actually, my HS had a black Mother Abbess in 1994. We were double cast (I had 4 shows, she had 3)
@@ElleCee62978 yeah but we're talking the 1930s
@@zfox8754 Casting in a musical should be color blind. It’s a story that is made up.. You do know that the real
Von Trapps didn’t escape Austria over the mountains, right?
Why isn't there any Britons in these
because its an american production!!
This is set in Austria
Carrie’s lack of acting experience badly showed in scenes like this one. The dialogue delivery is rushed and uneven and it felt like she tried to make up for that with her singing.
Meanwhile Audra is pitch perfect.
Carrie was playing a young nun, not an Academy Award winning actress. I liked her vulnerability as it was very real and was appropriate for being anxious that she had upset the Mother Superior!!!!!
Carrie can sing but her acting leaves a lot to be desired. Ruined it for me!
i wish that DOVE CAMERON was cast as maria i watched the movie last week i love JULIE ANDREWS as maria
Audra should've been cast as Maria, maybe earlier in her career, but put her in a musical and you can tell the others have nothing on her. Carries tries and sounds great but she doesn't have the depth. That's why the phrasing here is all changed for the Ma Sup so she doesn't show up the weaker voice.
Apart from Audre...I really cannot listen to Carrie..with due respect, that fatal feature or string (call it the missing but crucial factor) that Julie infused once and for all times can never be replaced.. sorry, no bad feelings, just my opinion!
Nada como Julie Andrews ):
Such hubris for Underwood to think she could pull this off. She embarrassed herself.
I think Amanda Seyfried should have played Maria cause Carrie has a great voice but her acting is not good enough
So sorry that the wonderful Audra McDonald had to work opposite an amateur for this production. Wasn't any talent on a calibre near Miss Julie Andrews available or was the cringeworthy Miss Underwood truthful in saying she was on her knees to get this role?
Underwood is extraordinarily vocally talented, so what nonsense are you on about? 🤣 Just because she wasn't classically trained like Andrews doesn't mean she's any less talented.
Carrie is vocally talented. It's really hard to do musical theatre well (singing+acting+dancing), so Audra is obviously the musical theatre talent here BUT Carrie isnt untalented.
@@motab9907 Completely different styles and vocal techniques, it has nothing to do with "talent" and EVERYTHING to do with training and stylistic choices. Underwood has top of the line RAW vocal talent in spades.
I bet JULIE ANDREWS saw this PREFORMANCE and she cried a little she should have sang this version with PEGGY wood who pLays MOTHer
Carrie,'s voice is superb, and although I loved the movie and have the original soundtrack album, I prefer her singing to Julie's. I also saw absolutely nothing wrong with her acting. She gave her character an air of innocent vulnerability, which Ms. Andrews did not.
So bad. That’s why the likes to views ratio is so bad
Elaborate on what is so bad about this version?
This made me love the sound of music..never cared to watch the movie before.
Julie Andrews version is wonderful too you should see it
Well I saw it one time when I was 13. I cared more about the music than the story. It took me seven years to give the movie a second try. Of all motivations, it was to prepare for this telecast. I’ve seen the movie 10 times now. I’m 30 now
Turned it off as soon as I saw it was woke.