ARE YORK CITY BUYING THE NATIONAL LEAGUE? VNL MONTHLY

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 фев 2025

Комментарии • 74

  • @markreynard6913
    @markreynard6913 28 дней назад +6

    One of the biggest signings for me has been getting Malachi Fagan Walcott on a long term permanent deal. Again young with terrific potential. I don’t believe this will be the end of the signings either. It’s fair to say there will be a level of envy and everyone is going to want to beat us.

  • @andrewcopeland
    @andrewcopeland 28 дней назад +1

    Rob is correct on the crowds, Bootham Crescent average around 2,500 and first season at the LNER was around 3,500. Since then our average attendance has grown even when we were flirting with relegation. Positive Marketing, Engagement in the community and working with the supporters trust has made a huge difference.

  • @garyrodgers9620
    @garyrodgers9620 27 дней назад

    Brilliant podcast lads...from a York City fan...you're right money does talk in football but the way it's been used this season has created a fantastic, entertaining football team. Best manager and style of football we've seen here in the capital of Yorkshire. O and Luke...can't wait to see you here at the stadium. ....one team in Yorkshire! 😂 Love Woking and Aldershot especially their fans. Ardley is a good fit and Aldershot will keep plugging away and entertaining us. "Fitting in" is a job for the manager. In a 433 your front 3 can be interchangeable strikers rather than "two wingers and a striker". Hinsh will think creatively.

  • @Robhalifax
    @Robhalifax 28 дней назад +5

    York fan here. Akinyemi will be on his way. He's a frustrating player. We've lacked a strong forward who can hold the ball at times. John-Lewis is in the twilight of his career. Not sure how Stones will fit in in our present system but Hinsh is creative and can make it work. He can be ruthless at times.

    • @lukewalsh2007
      @lukewalsh2007  28 дней назад

      @@Robhalifax I might be totally way off the mark here. But I think Uggla’s seen this as an opportunity to weaken a title contender rather than Stones fitting into the side. Yes he’s a great addition but was that season really necessary?
      I don’t think he was someone Adam Hinshlewood targeted tbh

    • @Matthew-fb6lh
      @Matthew-fb6lh 28 дней назад

      Stones is the wrong player for your club the money uve spent on him is crazy to be honest. He was valued at 85 to 110 madness to be honest and he will be on serious money he was at ours but good luck in rest of your season.

    • @Robhalifax
      @Robhalifax 28 дней назад +1

      @lukewalsh-vnlpodcast1799 Apparently we were in for him 2 months ago but couldn't get it across the line. So it's not new. Stones brings something that we didn't have.

    • @Robhalifax
      @Robhalifax 28 дней назад

      @Matthew-fb6lh £350k is just guesswork from people on the internet.

    • @lukewalsh2007
      @lukewalsh2007  28 дней назад

      @@Robhalifax be interesting to know how he fits into the system.
      Can’t imagine Hinshlewood wanting to change it and he’s not going to get in over Pearce.

  • @onlineretro
    @onlineretro 28 дней назад

    1st time viewer. Decent video. Think York are going to 2 up front. Now that the shop is back and dipo needs to be played there too.

    • @lukewalsh2007
      @lukewalsh2007  28 дней назад

      @@onlineretro cheers for tuning in. We’re live every Thursday from 9pm previewing all fixtures👍

  • @willlatham4716
    @willlatham4716 28 дней назад +2

    As a York Fan I can say that I think we didn't need another striker but there are rumours that Akinyemi is on his way to Chesterfield and John-Lewis is not a consistent finisher and is obviously fairly old. Pearce is also getting on so Stones is a young option up top. I'm sure a part of it was to weaken Oldham but ultimately that was not the only reason in my opinion.

    • @lukewalsh2007
      @lukewalsh2007  28 дней назад +1

      @willlatham4716 how I see it is. It’s not the only reason I agree. But I think if Stones was on loan at a Gateshead or a Solihull. York wouldn’t touch him.
      It’s a swipe at Oldham. And that’s the main reason.

    • @paruddock
      @paruddock 28 дней назад +1

      @lukewalsh-vnlpodcast1799 Rubbish. His loan was up and he was a Wigan player not Oldhams !

    • @lukewalsh2007
      @lukewalsh2007  28 дней назад +1

      @@paruddock yes but we both know that Oldham were in for signing him on a permanent.
      If it was not for that reason. Then why didn’t York sign a striker like Regan Linney scored more goals.
      A 6 figure some would surely be enough for Alty to have sold him

    • @freddiemills4068
      @freddiemills4068 28 дней назад

      @lukewalsh-vnlpodcast1799 because Linney is 27 and Stones in 21. Uggla sees him as someone who can grow with the clubs at the league. Think thats the main reason is that no only are we trying to get out this league but also planning for the future just like the signing of Fagan-Walcott. We were in for Stones before he went to Oldham on loan too.

    • @wobblybobengland
      @wobblybobengland 28 дней назад

      @lukewalsh-vnlpodcast1799 I think you are not far off. We (OAFC) tabled a sensible bid for Stones (believed to be 225k) and Wigan used that as a barganing chip, York have paid over his estimated value given his injury history and lack of experience, 3k a week said our Dave Bradley. We wanted him in August but that failed, but I'm glad that we didn't blow a lot of money on a silly bidding war. The important thing though is that we have a budget for another striker and what Mellon does with Reid who has been called back after scoring 11 in 12 for Wealdstone. And there are some Linney to Oldham rumours but I can't vouch for them.

  • @anthonybrown4874
    @anthonybrown4874 28 дней назад

    York have eeded another reliable striker for the last 2 seasons hopefully this digning is the one to give consistency.

  • @markreynard6913
    @markreynard6913 28 дней назад

    I would say it’s between ourselves (York) and FGR for the title, I think Gateshead will not now have enough having lost further key players, Oldham don’t have a strong enough squad, and Barnet are too inconsistent. I think we’re just going to carry on strengthening if needed which no one else can really match.

  • @Matthew-fb6lh
    @Matthew-fb6lh 28 дней назад +1

    Alex reid is supposedly on his way but on loan. Forest green is just rumours. We are looking at a couple of young strikers from championship clubs but not been able to aquire the names.

    • @elaineblackhurst1509
      @elaineblackhurst1509 22 дня назад

      Alex Reid (gloves from September to May) was off-loaded as not good enough by Stockport County when they won the NL title ahead of Wrexham in 2021/22 (1 goal in 13 appearances in a very good team); he was a disruptive influence at Oldham, but did ok at Wealdstone in the recent loan.
      Would like to see York back in the EFL, but Reid is not good enough.

  • @andrewcopeland
    @andrewcopeland 28 дней назад +2

    So signings were free except for Ricky Aguair (5k), Alex Hunt (5k), Fagan-Walcott (75k) and now Stones.

    • @samcollyer9699
      @samcollyer9699 28 дней назад

      Every signing costs something! Wage bill is significantly higher!

  • @johnparnham5945
    @johnparnham5945 28 дней назад

    With all those Notts County connections, I will be looking at Woking with interest. NO mention was made of Adam Chicksen who is staying at Woking. How is he doing at the moment. He was great for Notts in the National league and I think that under Neil Ardley he can find his former form. Only time will tell.

    • @samcollyer9699
      @samcollyer9699 28 дней назад +2

      Hi mate! So far chicksen has been alright, he was (like many) a victim of the previous manager and has a tough start, but under ardley he’s getting better and better as games go on

  • @mickeybarrass3625
    @mickeybarrass3625 28 дней назад

    I've said all along the Heed weren't Championship material, play off chasing YES. The next few weeks will define our season. I think we will sign players to replace those gone. Will McGowan has been brought back from his loan spell at Darlo and scored at the weekend. So hope springs eternal.

  • @andrewcopeland
    @andrewcopeland 28 дней назад +2

    Stones never did belong to Oldham, they borrowed him!!

  • @raymondoakford8357
    @raymondoakford8357 28 дней назад

    Can we have our players back at Worthing, thanks.

    • @lukewalsh2007
      @lukewalsh2007  28 дней назад

      @@raymondoakford8357 you’re still going strong in N/S tbf. Done better than I expected

    • @raymondoakford8357
      @raymondoakford8357 28 дней назад

      @ And me as well Luke.

  • @andrewcopeland
    @andrewcopeland 28 дней назад

    £350k is the max. That includes promotion clauses, appearances, goals etc.

  • @colindilbo2989
    @colindilbo2989 28 дней назад

    Gateshead have said they will not release funds for players coming in. They will use the lone market

    • @samcollyer9699
      @samcollyer9699 28 дней назад

      Did Magnay also not say he hopes to have a permanent striker in in the coming days?

    • @colindilbo2989
      @colindilbo2989 28 дней назад

      @ yes onl lone

  • @unionjakjakson
    @unionjakjakson 28 дней назад

    Well if they are...they are doing their doe. Got beat by Gainsborough Trinity who operate on a £2k a week budget!!!

  • @andrewcopeland
    @andrewcopeland 28 дней назад +1

    Oldham didn't have the money. Don't forget Oldham never held his registration Wigan did.

    • @wobblybobengland
      @wobblybobengland 28 дней назад +1

      OAFC tabled a sensible bid for Stones (believed to be 225k) and Wigan used that as a barganing chip, York have paid over his estimated value given his injury history and lack of experience, 3k a week said our Dave Bradley. I think we did the sensible thing and walked away.

  • @yorkiethelion7734
    @yorkiethelion7734 28 дней назад +1

    Anything to get out of this league! 😂

  • @alangilbert6064
    @alangilbert6064 28 дней назад +1

    We're top but we haven't won anything yet. Forest Green have a multi millionaire chairman and I assume parachute payments. Where are the accusations of them trying to "buy the league"? Don't even get me started on Wrexham!!
    If FGR win midweek they go top though we will have a game in hand. Us, FGR, Barnet or Oldham could go on to win it. I'm not crowing about being top, pride comes before a fall but picking on us for doing what other clubs have done is a bit much.

  • @christopherakers2640
    @christopherakers2640 23 дня назад

    What if York are buying the league Wrexham did it

    • @lukewalsh2007
      @lukewalsh2007  23 дня назад

      @@christopherakers2640 watch the pod👍
      Not one of us think you’re buying the league

  • @davidmiddleton6479
    @davidmiddleton6479 28 дней назад

    Don’t blame them. We did it, Notts county made it difficult on us. Can’t buy ur way out of the league. Not this one. It’s a brutal hell scape of a league. Grounds are sketchy, refs even worse, some of the stadiums are just short of a cockfighting pit. Can’t say I blame them

  • @twinz0wn4
    @twinz0wn4 28 дней назад

    Gateshead do not have 35 players😂😂😂 miles off it! You must have counted the academy!

    • @samcollyer9699
      @samcollyer9699 28 дней назад

      Believe it or not at the time of recording (before carr and home went) including loans, it was exactly 35!

    • @twinz0wn4
      @twinz0wn4 28 дней назад

      @samcollyer9699 I could name our full team and it's no where this, do you have a link for the list Sam? Curious if it's includes all of the academy who played in the fa trophy vs farlsey

    • @samcollyer9699
      @samcollyer9699 28 дней назад

      @ I dont have a full list link but in the squad currently there is based off my personal up to date NL database u now have 33, and that includes academy players who have pro deals

    • @samcollyer9699
      @samcollyer9699 28 дней назад

      @ and on your club website with the removal of Carr and Home you have 33 listed

    • @twinz0wn4
      @twinz0wn4 28 дней назад

      @samcollyer9699 with 7 or 8 academy we probably do hit around that number, id be curious if we have more "pros" at the academy than other teams hence the higher number but maybe not a true reflection

  • @briantimbs2866
    @briantimbs2866 28 дней назад

    Hinshelwood keeps telling York fans about the strength and depth of their squad. Surely they should have been able to select any team from their squad and beat Gainsborough, from two divisions lower. They made eight changes, their finishing was below Sunday League standard. They are the Brentford of the NL, brilliant at home, but look at their away record.

    • @samcollyer9699
      @samcollyer9699 28 дней назад +1

      Yet they are still top of the league

    • @garyrodgers9620
      @garyrodgers9620 28 дней назад

      Top of the league for all that. 😂

    • @alistairmountain1832
      @alistairmountain1832 27 дней назад

      The guy up front against Gainsborough literally was a Sunday league player at the start of the season! Focus on the league. No interest in the FA Trophy.