Future of Israel-Hamas Deal Depends on President Trump
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 фев 2025
- Future of Israel-Hamas deal depends on Trump: former Israeli Justice Minister, Yossi Beilin, to Karan Thapar for The Wire.
..........................................
Israel’s former Justice Minister has said that the future of the Israel-Hamas deal i.e. whether there is a permanent ceasefire and Israel withdraws from Gaza depends on the position taken by President Trump, who will be sworn-in later today for his second term as President of the United States. Yossi Beilin says Phase 2 of the Israel-Hamas deal will not be implemented if that means leaving Hamas in power and in control of Gaza. If, however, Trump can persuade Netanyahu to accept control by the Palestine Authority, Netanyahu will have no credible grounds for not implementing Phase 2.
In a 20-minute interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, Yossi Beilin argues that Trump’s ambition and quest for a Nobel Prize could prompt him to put pressure on Netanyahu to accept control of Gaza by the Palestine Authority (in place of Hamas) and then, beyond that, agree to a permanent ceasefire and the complete withdrawal of Israeli defence forces from Gaza.
However, the truth is that the scenes widely shown on television last night, when the three Israeli hostages were released, of hundreds of Hamas fighters, holding assault rifles and wearing green bandanas, clearly establish the fact that although Hamas is diminished and debilitated it’s not as yet vanquished. Those scenes carry a clear message of Hamas’s continuing presence for the world to see.
This interview looks beyond the release of hostages and Palestine prisoners envisaged in Phase 1 of the Israel-Hamas deal. It addresses the bigger question i.e. will there be a permanent ceasefire and withdrawal of Israeli soldiers from Gaza in Phase 2. That, to be honest, is the real heart of the deal and its future is uncertain as of now. Mr. Beilin argues that the position taken by Donald Trump will finally determine whether Phase 2 will happen or not.
Join The Wire's RUclips Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
Thanks!
Very significant interview ❤
Thanks Karan you brought again Mr. Yossi
Only Palestinians can decide who will rule them, if they choose Hamas as they did in past, it's none of your business
Everyone has the right to express opinion.
Karan, could you interview Palestinians instead of Zionists? Is there a reason why you folks do not want to share Palestinian experiences to humanize them?
Yes Mr Karan need to interview them.
What is the proof that he is a Zionist?
Thanks 🙏🏾
No one brings insight in current issue than you.
Especially your guests.
😂😂😂😂 tu karega kya insight lekar? Gaza patti jaega ? 😂😂😂
Mr. Yossi is a very nice person.
If Hamas has to be disarmed and dismantled from Ghaza then lsrael will have to disband the IDF, the occupying force which has been terrorising the poor Palestinians for the past seven decades. Such stringent conditions for the ceasefire will not be viable to maintain lasting peace in the region.
Israel doesn't have to worry about the Gaza administration .
It has to when administration is hands of islamic organisations like hamas
Mr.Karan Thapar please bring Palestinian representative like Mr.Bourguti he has vast experience and knowledgeable person..Do your best.
Thank u.
The PA isn't taking charge in Gaza. I didn't see anyone waiving Fatah flags in Gaza today. At most Hamas will allow the PA to set up an office in Gaza in order to provide them with political cover. But Gaza belongs to Hamas.
Hamas is a militant group and political party. Gaza belongs to the people of Gaza, not to a political party.
Like south african apertheid ,israelis apertheid is in its last phase.
Mr.Karan Thapar sorry.i misspelled his Name.Palestinian representative name is.Mr Mustafa Burghouti. Thanks you will enjoy with depth of knowledge. I saw him quite a few international programs as guest speaker.
Having been defeated at the hands of Khamas, the Israeli regime is trying to get Khamas eliminated by negotiating tables. By the way, will Natanyahu survive the judicial inquiry against him on corruption charges.
Grab your popcorn and enjoy this meltdown show 🍿😂
O u love the enthusiasm. BRITISHERS did same thing to India 🇮🇳
Informative pragmatic and effective interview- Mohammad Ali Khalid freelance journalist Chicago Illinois USA 🇺🇸
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Trump has the liberty to design a well decoratwd medal ,designate it a noble prize and award it to himself .
Jai Hind sir. The ceasefire between two parties is made to some extent or other , nothing other than the consent of Trump. The same decision will be made in other field too.
Y not Palestinian leaders?? Talk about Palestine also
Duniya Mein Jitna Bhi Dharm hai vah Sabse Jyada munafe yah hoti hai isko Vishwas Nahin Hai yah Dobara Hamla kar sakta hai isliye Padosi Mulk Jitna Bhi Muslim country hai usko Apna Munh kholna Padega
😂😂😂😂 pls dont comment
@@thetroll1887 At least it is more meaningful than your comment.
Deal is off within 40 days -- from reliable sources
😂😂😂😂😂
Future of deal depends on Saudia Arabia
Baat dosri karo.saudi ek napak entity hay
Deal is a more deeper understanding between USA, Saudi , Qatar, UAE and Egypt. They will reveal it slowly slowly. PA will take over administration of GAZa and PA will itself be revamped and representatives from HAmas will be part of PA. Also a , 2 state solution will be worked out in coming few years ..
U both looking brothers 😄
@yashagrawal88 Wrong opinions have to be criticized
We stand with isreal.
Bcoz Netin yahu has induced a heavy and crazy dNA in ur body
you stand on the wrong side of history and humanity.
@@Petitions. Bigoted people do. After killing of so many children, if you can say that then your stand doesn't matter
@yashagrawal88 Wrong opinions have to be criticized