I’m not sure but i think it’s her meds?, it’s like she’s being calmed to a certain extent that it kinda makes her look and feel tired, but i can also sense that she’s trying her best to be energetic, again I’m not sure, but I will always love mimi regardless of what she’s going through 🤍
@@JeffBryannn I also thought it was her bi polar meds. In recent interviews she’s been so chill and calm, kinda like she was during charm, emancipation and e equals and angels era’s. Her personality switched up right around 2014… for obvious reasons, then she linked with Stella and she was really obnoxious and sometimes rude and arrogant during that era, she seemed to bounce back in 2018, then in 2020 she was always sort of hyper and energetic up til the end of last year. Considering she broke up with Bryan she could be down about that, or she could just be so overwhelmed with performing again. Ever since she started performing again she’s been getting terrible feedback specifically from the lambs and she could just be over the whole performing thing, and even though she’s an Icon, touring really is how artists make the majority of their money. I really don’t think she enjoys performing anymore. I think she misses Bryan, and I think her meds stabilizes her mood swings. But she sounds wonderful. Looks fantastic and is about to put out an album Let’s not forget about the terrible crisis happening in Gaza, she probably feels for all those families that have been destroyed and maybe she feels weird about celebrating Christmas so early amidst the tragedies that are taking place overseas
@@EduardPerez27 she’s looked uncomfortable on stage since she divorced Nick. Let’s be real, when Nick left she lost more than part of her. He took most of her confidence too.
She’s not sad or tired. Her voice has just simply changed. Understand that NO ONE on earth has a voice like hers and she sang at an unreachable level for over 25 years. She cant hit those notes anymore so she has to kind of learn to sing differently. Which is still better than most singers out today. We STAN Mariah.
she does look sad and tired, very 2017. no moving around, no genuine smile, looks bored in interviews and that's okay. but it's a very stark difference to last year
@@MegaJellyNelly i kinda disagree. Based on the progression of her las vegas and xmas tours her voice becomes more agile as time went by. Even her confidence - she gets more comfortable as the tour progresses
@@worldwidechubbyguy2.018 maybe on agility, but rasp and ease in the upper register definitely goes down throughout tours, you can tell from the beginning of her 2018 TBR to the end, or from last year's 4 shows, her 2 Toronto dates were miles better. Also from Caution Tour, the North American leg at least, she was much more consistent in Europe
Actually? I hope it doesn't take a toll on her like Nick, I'm glad when she sings live but I can't stand the low energy lipped songs, if she's not feeling like performing then take a break
Maybe her relationship, maybe something personal. I think she is having a realization that her live concerts and tours are on their final stages. I couldn’t imagine being Mariah and knowing that your main source of happiness is coming to an end
Impressionante como sua voz mudou da ultima performance pra cá!! Está mais limpa, clara e revigorada!! Nao reclamem das bases, ela está finalmente entregando algo vocalmente bom, prefiro uma performance como essa do que ela tentando fazer o que hoje é dificil e desgastando ainda mais sua voz
You are absolutely correct & I too would rather have this vocally, (at least it is improving) let's call it medicated Mariah, over the erratic, discombobulated, confused Mariah vocals anyday. She did a good job 👍
I love when she attempts the „lord knows” note in bridge. I love both versions with Eb5 or with Bb4, I don’t care if she dodges it. But I appreciate when she does it live. Unfortunately this belt was lipped. I hope she will try to do it live on some next show🙏
I love how her voice sounds so healthy now after a long time, I'm really glad. Even when she speaks it's clear and beautiful and it's not raspy anymore. Her tone is so pretty.
Just appreciate her still being here and trying. No one says this about male singers. If every time you watch her and expect 1995 then just move on. Not trying to be mean.
@@Abmb88 I am appreciating while also stating some observations. U don't have the right to shut down speech just because u feel like u have some kind of moral high ground. It has nothing to do with female or male singers. If I listen to a lot of male singers then I would comment on male singers videos. But I don't. I listen to Mariah religiously, and therefore I comment on her videos. Why bring some kind of sexism undertone in it?
@@tonybs03 everyone knows her voice has changed. Everyone knows she doesn't sound like her 20 yr old self. Everyone knows she's never going to sound the same again. Everyone knows she lips. Everyone knows she struggles. Everyone knows she has good days and bad days. EVERYONE KNOWS. Enjoy her presence and essence or move on.
Clearly not her usual self but hopefully as the tour goes on her energy will pick up and she'll feel better. It's only the first night so cut her some slack.
Did she break up with Brian??👀 Its strange, usually he's the one who assisted her whenever she walk out from the stage. But anyway she sounds better than last year. I just hope she'll be happy when she meet her fans during this tour.
ow cmon, these fans disguised as haters dont feel tired of pretending to hate her by singing? y'all searching her before the people who are explicitly fans its funny. or hating anyone actually, if someone bothers you that much by just existing, you need therapy before its too late.
Can we have somebody to check on Mariah mentally fr😪 her energy seems so low 😒I don’t want anything to happen to her she’s one of the last greats we have
Hmmm. This makes me realize.. Hero is probably one of her best songs she ever made. MAYBE #2. I'd have to think about that.. 🤔 Anyways, this was wonderful. 🥰
Lambs LAMBS let’s check on this woman 😒😒😒her energy is way too low and the way she left that stage… something is going on bruh😪I don’t wanna lose this woman😪😪
She sounds a bit shaky, maybe because of the nerves, hopefully she'll improve as the tour progresses. Happy that she sounds better than last year's tour, but I'm not keen on the amount of playback. Wish she would have more confidence on her vocals. She also seems very sad, not her usual energetic festive self. Also what is it with the wardrobe? Lol Some very... interesting choices...
I can’t find her powerful voice since last year.. I suspect the last chorus might be lip-synced. Despite her voice not being in good condition, she sang live. However, that wasn't the case this year.
It's like Britney, being half present... It's not really fair to the fans if she's just doing it to collect a check, the medley she did with the lipped parts and low energy was so weird
Anyone who says her voice is clear/amazing/awesome must be tone deaf. She seems exhausted, it's almost heartbreaking to see her putting herself through this. She is obviously not having a good time. Perhaps she needs to retire and focus on her mental health and vocal rest. Who knows, a couple of years of not performing live and away from the media and spotlight could do wonders for her singing voice! She can age gracefully and do a studio recorded jazz/blues/soul album which will suit her more mature, low and raspy voice perfectly.
No quiero pensar que algunas partes de los temas sean playback, sería una gran decepción 😢. Pero a veces sus tonos agudos suenan claros y sin esfuerzo y en otros ni siquiera llega. Es sospechoso
I love Mariah Carey I can't understand why she's so stiff I mean Madonna has more energy at 65 on stage right now then she does Mariah needs to loosen up and start moving around I mean are her legs even real
Again. What a mess and I was actually ready for lambs making up illnesses and issues for Mariah’s shortcomings this time of the year. Last year was bronchitis, the year before was bc of tight dress. I don’t know this year.
she doesnt have bronchitis (it was CONFIRMED she was sick by the director of the filming last year) or a corset this year and she sounds very good, or at least compared to last year/earlier 2023.
Mariah parece muito desanimada no palco esse ano, até o palco está menos festivo que nos anos anteriores, o que é estranho, pois ela está linda, o figurino está lindo, as novas bases gravadas estão atualizadas e houve muita venda nos ingressos, tanto que novas datas foram inclusas, da pra ver que está lotado e Mariah nem insegura está, mas está desanimada ..... algo estranho está acontecendo na vida privada, quem é fã sempre percebe que Mariah transcende na música, apresentações, tudo que está vivendo no pessoal, foi assim na época que houve a traição do ex marido e ela fazia a turne do Elusive Chanteuse
I have to agree something wasn't right. I kept wondering what happened? ??? Sooner or later I hope we find out, she seemed so out of it, I think something happened.
![BAK Jay - Find Out (For Your Love) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/10FJO_XBCvY/mqdefault.jpg)
Idk, but her energy and facial expressions give me 2017 vibes era
I’m not sure but i think it’s her meds?, it’s like she’s being calmed to a certain extent that it kinda makes her look and feel tired, but i can also sense that she’s trying her best to be energetic, again I’m not sure, but I will always love mimi regardless of what she’s going through 🤍
@@JeffBryannnthis was my guess. Reminds me of when I’m on Zoloft . Like you’re just not excitable .
@@JeffBryannn I also thought it was her bi polar meds. In recent interviews she’s been so chill and calm, kinda like she was during charm, emancipation and e equals and angels era’s. Her personality switched up right around 2014… for obvious reasons, then she linked with Stella and she was really obnoxious and sometimes rude and arrogant during that era, she seemed to bounce back in 2018, then in 2020 she was always sort of hyper and energetic up til the end of last year. Considering she broke up with Bryan she could be down about that, or she could just be so overwhelmed with performing again. Ever since she started performing again she’s been getting terrible feedback specifically from the lambs and she could just be over the whole performing thing, and even though she’s an Icon, touring really is how artists make the majority of their money. I really don’t think she enjoys performing anymore. I think she misses Bryan, and I think her meds stabilizes her mood swings. But she sounds wonderful. Looks fantastic and is about to put out an album
Let’s not forget about the terrible crisis happening in Gaza, she probably feels for all those families that have been destroyed and maybe she feels weird about celebrating Christmas so early amidst the tragedies that are taking place overseas
2017 performances looked uncomfortable to be honest
@@EduardPerez27 she’s looked uncomfortable on stage since she divorced Nick. Let’s be real, when Nick left she lost more than part of her. He took most of her confidence too.
i really miss her 2016-2019 vocals, energy and confidence. we took it for granted :( love u so much tho
She sounds good but feel like she isn’t as happy 😢
I really miss her 90s vocals and freshness and attitude
@@Lusonmusic well, she sounds better than last year but her energy is just way too off and low :( i hope she regains it as the tour progresses
She is now a vegetarian, so perhaps her body was still adapting, which is why she was tired.@@axeltimotheo2942
She literally sound like those era but the energy is low
I love how clear her voice is after a long time, I’m really glad. You can even hear her clarity when she speaks, her tone is beautiful.
She’s not sad or tired. Her voice has just simply changed. Understand that NO ONE on earth has a voice like hers and she sang at an unreachable level for over 25 years. She cant hit those notes anymore so she has to kind of learn to sing differently. Which is still better than most singers out today. We STAN Mariah.
she does look sad and tired, very 2017. no moving around, no genuine smile, looks bored in interviews and that's okay. but it's a very stark difference to last year
I think it's a confidence issue.. I think she still got it. Maybe not exactly the same
I can tell she’s been recording in the studio. She always has a husky heavy voice after recording in the studio.
Her voice sounds so rested…love it.
Her falsetto is awesome currently ! After all these years the emotion remains
Best Hero in years! Mother hasn't sounded this healthy since 2016's The Sweet Sweet Fantasy Tour ❤ I'm in awe ❤️
Its the first stop. Be patient guys! Queen is warming up.
Note, never go to one of Mariahs first shows. I would hate to have paid money to sit front row for that.
I think she’ll pull a Charmie .. the more she sings on tour , the stronger her voice will get ! But loving it regardless
Tbh, most often, her 1st 2 shows are the best, and then it goes downhill from that
@@MegaJellyNelly i kinda disagree. Based on the progression of her las vegas and xmas tours her voice becomes more agile as time went by. Even her confidence - she gets more comfortable as the tour progresses
@@worldwidechubbyguy2.018 maybe on agility, but rasp and ease in the upper register definitely goes down throughout tours, you can tell from the beginning of her 2018 TBR to the end, or from last year's 4 shows, her 2 Toronto dates were miles better. Also from Caution Tour, the North American leg at least, she was much more consistent in Europe
I’m really surprised and happy with the clarity of her voice her ❤
It was awesome 👏👏👏 since a long time that her voice wasn't that clean and balanced ❤ thank you for to post this video
So emotionally delivered 🥹😭
Thank you for pouring so much emotions into this.
Love you Mariah forever ❤❤❤
The BGVs did an incredible job here 💯💯💯
Thank you for visiting! Glad you enjoyed the show!
She rested her vocal 🥰❤️❤️❤️ and did an amazing job. I love her!!!
Smashed it! Been a lamb for years but last year she was poor! Shining this year ❤
She looks and sounds Incredible. Thanks for sharing ❤
can’t wait to see her on Sunday! ❤🥲
Let's hope it won't rain like on Friday 😮
Favorite song by her is hero thank you for this
The way she just left the stage is heartbreaking i really hope she is okay 🙁
She seem so sad
She broke up with her bf, that's why she's sad
Actually? I hope it doesn't take a toll on her like Nick, I'm glad when she sings live but I can't stand the low energy lipped songs, if she's not feeling like performing then take a break
Maybe her relationship, maybe something personal. I think she is having a realization that her live concerts and tours are on their final stages. I couldn’t imagine being Mariah and knowing that your main source of happiness is coming to an end
she went for it!!
1.58......omg that in youuuuuuuuuuu that was heavenly just like the 90s 😍
Impressionante como sua voz mudou da ultima performance pra cá!! Está mais limpa, clara e revigorada!! Nao reclamem das bases, ela está finalmente entregando algo vocalmente bom, prefiro uma performance como essa do que ela tentando fazer o que hoje é dificil e desgastando ainda mais sua voz
Ia comentar isso agora, impressionante como mudou em tão pouco tempo.
Vc falou tudo que penso. ❤❤
You are absolutely correct & I too would rather have this vocally, (at least it is improving) let's call it medicated Mariah, over the erratic, discombobulated, confused Mariah vocals anyday. She did a good job 👍
Truely Remarkable! One and only 🙏😍
Man! I love Mariah! ❤
Amazing !!!!!
Impressed here!
Is it true she broke up with Tanaka?! So sad... He really seemed to light her up in the recent years...
We never saw her with Tanaka anynore and i saw something about a bad business he did. Maybe thats because of her relationship
what kind of business he got down there??
@@yabes1728I saw he was embezzling something in Brazil but not sure if it was true
The true Mariah is coming back ❤omgggg can’t wait to see her
This was amazing I love her so much always tries her best
I love when she attempts the „lord knows” note in bridge. I love both versions with Eb5 or with Bb4, I don’t care if she dodges it. But I appreciate when she does it live. Unfortunately this belt was lipped. I hope she will try to do it live on some next show🙏
Unfortunately that lord knows wasn’t live. It’s from the 2009 Hero studio version or some recent prerecording.
😂😂😂 Lord knows it’s lippeddddd
@@AlexGray19 it doesnt sound like 2009 version. It’s a recent prerecorded vocal
@@janveber5523the “lord” is from 2009 but not the “knows” 😭
@@popinsider450 trying singing for 30 plus years with 19 number #1's and then comeback here and start talking
Better than last year
She had covid
@@Eddo128umm no… quit pulling false stories from your ass
Much better than last year at MSG 😪😪 (only concert of hers I've ever been to)
I love how her voice sounds so healthy now after a long time, I'm really glad. Even when she speaks it's clear and beautiful and it's not raspy anymore. Her tone is so pretty.
I’m yet to see one Christmas song live form this concert
What a struggle :( but I think this is somewhat better than last year.
Just appreciate her still being here and trying. No one says this about male singers. If every time you watch her and expect 1995 then just move on. Not trying to be mean.
@@Abmb88 I am appreciating while also stating some observations. U don't have the right to shut down speech just because u feel like u have some kind of moral high ground. It has nothing to do with female or male singers. If I listen to a lot of male singers then I would comment on male singers videos. But I don't. I listen to Mariah religiously, and therefore I comment on her videos. Why bring some kind of sexism undertone in it?
@@tonybs03No one is shutting you down. You started it. He/she just share their say too.
@@tonybs03 everyone knows her voice has changed. Everyone knows she doesn't sound like her 20 yr old self. Everyone knows she's never going to sound the same again. Everyone knows she lips. Everyone knows she struggles. Everyone knows she has good days and bad days. EVERYONE KNOWS. Enjoy her presence and essence or move on.
She sounds great. This doesn’t sound like a struggle. Just the song is changed up for her current ability .
Omg! Her voice is back
You think so?
👍
@@TheGrowthmaneven not the same as her prime but getting better than the past few years
Clearly not her usual self but hopefully as the tour goes on her energy will pick up and she'll feel better. It's only the first night so cut her some slack.
Thank you for sharing 🫶
Did she break up with Brian??👀 Its strange, usually he's the one who assisted her whenever she walk out from the stage. But anyway she sounds better than last year. I just hope she'll be happy when she meet her fans during this tour.
Shit, maybe that’s why she seems so sad lately? Haven’t seen her in any photos with him either 😬
Word on the street says yes
Cutting in and out of playback?
The second half of the song yes
Her voice is improved!!!
That dress needs ta go
I think it’s pretty
I think that she changed her technique a little from early performances. It sounds like she can make throughout her songs more easily
ow cmon, these fans disguised as haters dont feel tired of pretending to hate her by singing? y'all searching her before the people who are explicitly fans its funny.
or hating anyone actually, if someone bothers you that much by just existing, you need therapy before its too late.
Can we have somebody to check on Mariah mentally fr😪 her energy seems so low 😒I don’t want anything to happen to her she’s one of the last greats we have
Rumor has it her and Tanaka split. Maybe that’s making her sad? And who knows what else is going on in her life she’s human after all
Best hero preformance since 2019. As someone who can tell if she lips, 90% of this was live. Sad to see she lipped most of this show tho
Yeah I noticed an increase in playback in almost every song 😶 CBPCH, WBT, oh Santa etc
she starts lipping from lord knows....
@@odumosuolusegun2781 thats why i said that 10% is lipped
4:40 😍😍😍
Hmmm. This makes me realize.. Hero is probably one of her best songs she ever made. MAYBE #2. I'd have to think about that.. 🤔 Anyways, this was wonderful. 🥰
MERRY CHRISTMAS INDONESIA VERRY LOVE❤❤❤❤❤❤
Io amo Mimi, ❤❤❤❤❤
THERES NO O HOLY NIGHT IN THE SETLIST 😭😭🥹🥹
I think the setlist was cut short because of venue rules, let's hope she sings it in the rest of her shows 😭
What? nooo 😭
@@butterdream IKR
That’s always 3/4 lipped anyway so not a huge loss 💀
Sleepy and No voice at all ... Climax is mostly lipped
Omaygot.. she sang it LIVE dahlin.. just a little bit playback.. 👍👍👍🦋🦋🦋
Lambs LAMBS let’s check on this woman 😒😒😒her energy is way too low and the way she left that stage… something is going on bruh😪I don’t wanna lose this woman😪😪
She sounds a bit shaky, maybe because of the nerves, hopefully she'll improve as the tour progresses. Happy that she sounds better than last year's tour, but I'm not keen on the amount of playback. Wish she would have more confidence on her vocals. She also seems very sad, not her usual energetic festive self.
Also what is it with the wardrobe? Lol Some very... interesting choices...
nerves after 33 years? when will she stop being nervous?
She’s getting older and it’s normal. Her voice was overused, because of her concert everywhere when she was young and even up to this time
Ela tá triste?
I can’t find her powerful voice since last year.. I suspect the last chorus might be lip-synced. Despite her voice not being in good condition, she sang live. However, that wasn't the case this year.
The chorus is definitely lipped, but atleast is seamless now
@ladyhaha7548 Seamless?!! I laughed my head off, it's so obvious!
Did she have an opening act?
Gente ela tá triste por algum motivo ?
OMG was it everything you dreamed of?
We need more energy. It’s like she fell asleep during the whole concert. 🤔
It's like Britney, being half present... It's not really fair to the fans if she's just doing it to collect a check, the medley she did with the lipped parts and low energy was so weird
Chile not fell sleep
@@TheHeat205Network😂
@@TheHeat205Networkinstead of sleepwalking, she invented sleep singing 😌🎤 🎶
@@rainbowstarmced191 good one ☝️ 😂
Anyone who says her voice is clear/amazing/awesome must be tone deaf. She seems exhausted, it's almost heartbreaking to see her putting herself through this. She is obviously not having a good time. Perhaps she needs to retire and focus on her mental health and vocal rest. Who knows, a couple of years of not performing live and away from the media and spotlight could do wonders for her singing voice! She can age gracefully and do a studio recorded jazz/blues/soul album which will suit her more mature, low and raspy voice perfectly.
Did the twins perform?
Ela largou do Tanaka será? 🤔
I think she's on meds now being more calm but I don't know she looks sad. I guess where is bryan tanaka
She need to care .
No quiero pensar que algunas partes de los temas sean playback, sería una gran decepción 😢. Pero a veces sus tonos agudos suenan claros y sin esfuerzo y en otros ni siquiera llega. Es sospechoso
I love Mariah Carey I can't understand why she's so stiff I mean Madonna has more energy at 65 on stage right now then she does Mariah needs to loosen up and start moving around I mean are her legs even real
She seems so sad
Again. What a mess and I was actually ready for lambs making up illnesses and issues for Mariah’s shortcomings this time of the year. Last year was bronchitis, the year before was bc of tight dress. I don’t know this year.
she doesnt have bronchitis (it was CONFIRMED she was sick by the director of the filming last year) or a corset this year and she sounds very good, or at least compared to last year/earlier 2023.
She sounds just fine for a woman in her 50s and we're lucky to still have her performing, sadly unlike other legends.
😢
Mariah parece muito desanimada no palco esse ano, até o palco está menos festivo que nos anos anteriores, o que é estranho, pois ela está linda, o figurino está lindo, as novas bases gravadas estão atualizadas e houve muita venda nos ingressos, tanto que novas datas foram inclusas, da pra ver que está lotado e Mariah nem insegura está, mas está desanimada ..... algo estranho está acontecendo na vida privada, quem é fã sempre percebe que Mariah transcende na música, apresentações, tudo que está vivendo no pessoal, foi assim na época que houve a traição do ex marido e ela fazia a turne do Elusive Chanteuse
Que significa ese vestido 😅
This tour is going to get worse and worse as her voice gives out 😭
touring helps her voice & always has, unless she pushes herself to do crazy belts which she isn't doing
Where are the Christmas trees, the presents, the childrens? I didn't like this stage
I have to agree something wasn't right. I kept wondering what happened? ???
Sooner or later I hope we find out, she seemed so out of it, I think something happened.
Lipped in all the high notes, the rest is very soulless
I can't define if this dress is ridiculous or funny hahaha
It's really ugly
I like the dress. Great gowns beautiful gowns 👗
What access.. The ppl in the front rows didn't seem to have a great time either.. no cheering no nothing. They were ready to leave..
Oh absolutely not this is just a back angle people were enjoying themselves
Even the music sounds sad….
I think it's the most horrible dress I've ever seen happen to Mariah.
we adore Mariah's legacy, but that doesn't mean she could do half of the job. 0 enthusiasm made at this performance.
Her voice sounds tired, and the harder parts toward the end of the song were all back track. You’re delusional if you think otherwise.
Such a depressing show.
Not as festive as I was hoping 😞. But I’ll always love MC and I wish her happiness and joy ❤
@@rainbowstarmced191 she looks like she should be at home in bed.
Mariah please this entire show is terrible 😢
Terrible is pretty harsh
@@rainbowstarmced191 it is what it is dahling 🥲