Updated manual pourover technique!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 дек 2024

Комментарии • 415

  • @JoejoeReference
    @JoejoeReference 4 года назад +135

    17:1 ratio
    20g of coffee
    340g of water
    1. BLOOM
    3x coffee weight
    20 x 3 = 60g water
    Agitate either through stirring with a spoon or swirling the brewer
    Wait 45 sec
    2. FIRST POUR
    Pour up to 210g
    Try to pour as high as possible while avoiding a splashing sound and maintaining an even height
    Move the kettle in concentric circles to ensure agitation and even coverage
    Wait until the slurry has drained halfway before starting the next pour
    3. SECOND POUR
    Pour to the final target brew weight of 340g
    Do a Rao Spin™ to ensure a flat bed and even extraction
    Wait for the slurry to fully drain and enjoy your coffee!

  • @Philosophaster
    @Philosophaster 3 года назад +82

    SCOTT’S RECIPE
    • Wet paper filter, add 20g coffee (Niche grind setting: 40)
    • Prewet grounds 60g water.
    Spin. Optionally, use spoon to gently dig into paper filter crevices as needed. Wait 45sec from initial pour, then
    • 2nd pour up to 210g and wait for slurry to drain about halfway, then
    • 3rd pour up to 340g (17:1 ratio).
    Gently spin. Allow to drain.

    • @AmericanUltras96
      @AmericanUltras96 3 года назад +3

      That’s for 20 grams. I need to come up with percentage calculation for varying amounts of starting coffee.

    • @mcesso
      @mcesso 3 года назад +4

      @@AmericanUltras96 you can use varying amounts with this method, just keep a 1:17 ratio

    • @error.418
      @error.418 2 года назад +2

      @@AmericanUltras96 he did 3:1 bloom, about 60% total intended water in 2nd pour, 3rd pour completes. this is a pretty typical technique. you'll often see 2x to 3x for the bloom, then the same 60%/40% next 2 pours. the 45 second bloom is very typical, anything in the 30-45 second range is reasonable. often the next 2 pours are 30 seconds each, meaning final pour must be slower since less water.

  • @PurpScurpington
    @PurpScurpington 3 года назад +95

    Genuinely love to see an esteemed coffee professional not using a scale that itself costs as much as a Bartza Encore

    • @hybridce99
      @hybridce99 3 года назад +1

      What's wrong with owning an acaia?

    • @davidespinoza9870
      @davidespinoza9870 3 года назад

      I thought the same haha. Am I wrong or he even used tap water to pre-wet the filter? Hahah only Scott is forgiven doing this

    • @spellbinder6818
      @spellbinder6818 2 года назад

      What he’s using is the GDEALER / Reflex I think. Brian Quan has reviewed it very favourably.

    • @zakariyabaker874
      @zakariyabaker874 2 года назад

      @@spellbinder6818 I've owned 2. Only bought the second because I immigrated. Extremely reliable, although it needs a bit of time when it comes to accurately measuring small doses, say under 15g

    • @IamMotionMedia
      @IamMotionMedia 2 года назад +1

      @@hybridce99 nothing just insanely overpriced and a poorly designed app

  • @alexandros_chatzis
    @alexandros_chatzis 4 года назад +3

    I was following your other technique with my V60 the whole summer as I started my coffee journey, 5 days ago I wanted to try the Kalita and you just uploaded a new technique with it. Amazing.

  • @andrewwdouglas
    @andrewwdouglas 4 года назад +35

    Hmm... interesting pairing using the Niche with a Baratza grinds bin.

  • @igottmituns
    @igottmituns 3 года назад +9

    The trend with pour over now is to maximize the sweets coffee and finding the balance between sweetness and acidity. Scott's recipe changes my conventional 1:15 method with a medium grind to 1:17 with a slightly finer grind. His method allows good, paced control on the slurry which is crucial with a finer grind. The swirl is still used as it evens the bed consistently.
    For those of you who may have been using my aforementioned technique - be prepared to play with your grinder with slightly finer settings. Do a taste comparison between one vs. the other. For me, depending on the beans, I find a ton more clarity, sweetness and a delicate finish with my cuppings BUT with a 1:15, with a slightly coarser grind - I find a bit less acidity, less sweetness but a bit more body. It's a welcome new recipe and technique in my arsenal. Thanks Scott.

  • @jonascampos1895
    @jonascampos1895 4 года назад +13

    The fact Rao has the same 12 euro scale as me is fantastic! 👌

  • @itellsri
    @itellsri 4 года назад +5

    Asser from “The coffee chronicler” talks about the same mod which includes using a spreader and also drilling larger holes for faster flow rate on a kalita wave ...According to Asser stainless kalita are the slowest and takes 53 seconds for 500 ml to drain as supposed to 30 plus seconds in ceramic/ glass ....

    • @coffeechronicler
      @coffeechronicler 4 года назад +7

      Thanks for the mention, Dan. You're right about the ceramic one being faster. Instead of a tea strainer I use the Flair Pro dispersion screen which fits perfectly in the bottom of the dripper 👍

    • @dwikafebrianto3016
      @dwikafebrianto3016 4 года назад +1

      @@coffeechronicler Yeah Asser, Scott should know this

  • @longcoffee
    @longcoffee 4 года назад +2

    Thanks for the update! I always enjoy the content you upload.

  • @PaulSolt
    @PaulSolt 4 года назад +3

    I pick up the filter with the Hario V60 to help it drain faster after rinsing the filters. Otherwise, I notice there is some suction created from the water adhesion can slow down the drain.

    • @PaulSolt
      @PaulSolt 4 года назад

      Depending on how the filter sits, it will drain differently.

  • @deo.strengthspan.project
    @deo.strengthspan.project 4 года назад +16

    Thank you for the update! Not really critically important, but I can’t help but be curious, since you mentioned it, as to why you’re not using the V60 as much?

  • @19Cluj
    @19Cluj 4 года назад +16

    Great video. I usually use the James Hoffman technique, which is not dissimilar. You do 2 pours, one up to about 60% of the water, then the next 40% in a second pour. James does one pour, but adapts the flow rate so that the first 60% take 30s to pour, and the next 40% also take 30s to pour. What would you say is the theoretical difference between your technique (2 pours, same flow rate), and his (1 pour, 2 flow rates)? Thanks!

    • @adamthemute
      @adamthemute 3 года назад +2

      The higher pour with this method would cause more agitation (ideally through deeper turbulence through the coffee bed), but also with letting the water drain a bit before the last pour, you'd get more extraction vs maintaining a higher slurry temp with Hoffman's.

  • @riograndecoffee4838
    @riograndecoffee4838 3 года назад +5

    I collect all of your book. You are my first coffee teacher. 🙏🙏🙏🇲🇲🇲🇲 Myanmar

  • @haterskeephatin101
    @haterskeephatin101 4 года назад +12

    I love how much less serious this is than the og v60 tut

  • @tukucoffee6044
    @tukucoffee6044 4 года назад +1

    it's cool, i'd love the analysis, that the important is the technique and it's very good tutorial, thank you

  • @jdrobison1967
    @jdrobison1967 4 года назад +1

    I cut some discs out of .4mm wire mesh that I bought on Amazon and fastened it to the bottom of my flat bottom drippers with a few tiny dabs of food grade silicon. 10 months later and they're all still firmly connected.

  • @dwikafebrianto3016
    @dwikafebrianto3016 4 года назад +4

    Then it is confirmed, there is so much issue with the stainless steel version of Kalita Wave. You should replace it with the ceramic version. Coffee Chronicler said that the ceramic version gives much better result although not a portable device.

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +1

      I'm sure the ceramic is better, but I already have the metal one (and many other brewers) and I like stuff that i can't break :0. Kalita is rarely my go-to brewer. thanks

    • @M000rdi
      @M000rdi 4 года назад +1

      @@scottrao5268 what is your go to brewer?

  • @MattHarris85
    @MattHarris85 3 года назад +41

    Did you know: when Scott Rao does the Rao Spin, is just called The Spin

    • @martyhopkirk6826
      @martyhopkirk6826 2 года назад +2

      I didn't. I know he can't pronounce 'niche', though.

    • @FleshyPink
      @FleshyPink 2 года назад +5

      @@martyhopkirk6826 in the American vernacular, the word "niche" is pronounced exactly how he pronounced it. In Britain, it is pronounced "neesh" but that's not correct in the US.

    • @VictorChavesVVBC
      @VictorChavesVVBC 2 года назад +1

      @@FleshyPink niche is a borrowed French word so that pronunciation is just wrong. In time, it becomes the right one because such is the way of spoken language... but it stays painful to hear lol

    • @error.418
      @error.418 2 года назад +2

      @@VictorChavesVVBC painful only to the pedant/prescriptivist, less so to the descriptivist

    • @VictorChavesVVBC
      @VictorChavesVVBC 2 года назад

      @@error.418 Fair enough. I'm not defending language stagnation, though. It's just that once you get used to a thing one way, change is uncomfortable.

  • @sunm7035
    @sunm7035 4 года назад

    Thanks for the video! I'm just starting with the V60 and this is just what I needed!

  • @sunwutzu
    @sunwutzu 4 года назад +4

    I feel stupid that I just realized why I always get that splashy sound when I pour a Chemex vs a v60. The Chemex especially with the square filters forces you to pour from much higher

  • @finesse_weapon
    @finesse_weapon 3 года назад +2

    So great to see this update. I like how simple your techniques are-but there's a lot of subtlety in your simplicity! I've been using your updated method for the past few months now (after using your original V60 method for years), and I always have huge bubbles both during the pre-wet and throughout brewing. Using a gooseneck kettle and trying to move in concentric circles. Any chance you could offer up some tips for a more even extraction?

  • @dadamj
    @dadamj 4 года назад

    Good timing, I've just received a new brewer (Espro Bloom) and have been looking to improve my technique. Thanks Scott

  • @matthewdeyn5530
    @matthewdeyn5530 4 года назад +2

    Monday's are much better with this kind of thing :)

  • @brandonbeardsley4684
    @brandonbeardsley4684 4 года назад +3

    Thanks Scott, gonna spin my Chemex now

  • @bartoszkleszcz5420
    @bartoszkleszcz5420 4 года назад +9

    What would be the optimal grind size for comandante using your method?

    • @patrickrachford7112
      @patrickrachford7112 3 года назад

      He said 40 on the niche

    • @bartoszkleszcz5420
      @bartoszkleszcz5420 3 года назад

      @@patrickrachford7112 Is 40 on the niche the same as 40 on comandante?

    • @error.418
      @error.418 2 года назад +1

      @@bartoszkleszcz5420 No. And annoyingly 40 on one Niche is not 40 on another, they're inconsistent according to the user forums. Amazing grinder, but not made for sharing grind settings.

  • @michaelvillasis1264
    @michaelvillasis1264 4 года назад +2

    Hi Scott! I have been using your (now old) V60 technique for quite some time now. Thanks for this! Just a question, what would the difference be between the old method's single main pour, with this two pour method? What I found attractive to that single pour method was its ease of replication, and the fact that (correct me if I'm wrong) the water weight allows for a faster drawdown and finer grind.

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +4

      the new method increases extraction at the expense of some slurry temperature.

    • @michaelvillasis1264
      @michaelvillasis1264 4 года назад

      @@scottrao5268 Thanks! Will try it on the V60 :)

  • @vickyl5686
    @vickyl5686 4 года назад +3

    During the pre-wet process, when you're using the spoon to ensure that all the grounds are getting wet ... Are you digging the spoon right into coffee grounds and stirring it a bit? I'm new to coffee and trying to refine my technique :) Thanks for the great video!

    • @davidwong2695
      @davidwong2695 4 года назад +1

      I don't find much difference in how much you dig. It creates agitation but the point is to wet all the grounds.

    • @error.418
      @error.418 2 года назад

      Swirling is better than stirring, tbh

  • @thorns66
    @thorns66 4 года назад

    To prevent clogging with Kalita I generally like to do something like 10-20% bypass (i.e. don't pour all the water on to the brew, add some afterwards). This generally gives a cleaner brew too.

    • @harrisonp7118
      @harrisonp7118 4 года назад

      Can Gencer what do you mean by this? I also have this problem with my metal 185

    • @thorns66
      @thorns66 4 года назад

      @@harrisonp7118 just finish pouring early, and add the rest of water directly to the brew (i.e. if you're doing 20/340g, pour up to 300, and add last 40g directly)

  • @doclogic
    @doclogic 4 года назад +3

    2 concerns here that I've had to overcome and makes a big difference. 1) try wetting the filter with the hot kettle water. The metal housing is a huge heat sink and pulls temperature away from the brew. 2) putting the kettle back onto the base will heat it back up, making a more consistent brew temperature. I like your technique, I'll give it a swirl.

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +10

      I've recently taken to putting the brewer on top of the kettle in place of the kettle lid while the kettle heats. Makes the brewer much hotter

  • @Gian.V
    @Gian.V 4 года назад +4

    Is the grind size the same as any other technique (so let's say medium)? Cause the drowdown really looked slow to me but I've only worked with V60 so far

  • @danielspence2179
    @danielspence2179 4 года назад +1

    Would really be interested to see you do an extraction analysis of the espro bloom brewer. It has a flat bottom and a built in micron mesh. It seems the big selling point is a

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +2

      I am curious, but I'm honestly tired of buying various coffee gear that I use for a day and then shelve forever because it's not so great.

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +5

      I decided to buy an Espro after your comment and someone else's here. I'm looking forward to trying it, thanks

  • @jgb4
    @jgb4 4 года назад

    Thank you for your update Scott!
    I love the explanations and details you layout!
    You ever bringing back the Q&A Coffee Podcast?

  • @andrewdicarlo4555
    @andrewdicarlo4555 4 года назад +1

    Awesome, really useful to get your input on the Kalita especially and thanks for the mesh tip. Have you experimented with covering the Kalita after final pour to retain heat in the slurry? I've been testing this out but haven't done a side-by-side comparison brew yet.

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +1

      I've done it, but it seems to offer marginal benefit. Still, it can't hurt

    • @andrewdicarlo4555
      @andrewdicarlo4555 4 года назад

      @@scottrao5268 good to know, thanks!

  • @rohanmisra7346
    @rohanmisra7346 3 года назад +5

    What’s a recommended grind setting for the Baratza Forte?

  • @tyleehamauku413
    @tyleehamauku413 3 года назад +1

    That is a good hack I can use.
    Thank you for the tip.

  • @ryansinclair2539
    @ryansinclair2539 4 года назад +3

    If you were to scale up to two servings, around 600g total, would you still do 2 pours if possible? Or split the brew into additional pours of around ~150g each?

    • @cz5696
      @cz5696 4 года назад

      Two pours if possible, but 600g is a pretty big batch for the wave

  • @jamesbrightman3997
    @jamesbrightman3997 4 года назад +1

    Thanks for updating Scott! I have been following your V60 method for some time now and it produces great coffee, but I'm wondering if you'd change the method you just outlined in this video if you were using a medium or dark roast? Would you change the 1:17 ratio to 1:16 or even 1:15 or would you use cooler water temps?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +6

      I might lower the water temp a bit for darker roasts, and of course the grind setting could change for any coffee/roast, but otherwise, I would keep the method the same.

    • @jamesbrightman3997
      @jamesbrightman3997 4 года назад

      @@scottrao5268 thanks for the reply!

  • @leftiesrule
    @leftiesrule 4 года назад +5

    Awesome tip on the mesh! I'm curious, what, if anything you'd change for a larger amount of coffee, say 500g of water to 29g ground coffee?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +1

      I wouldn't brew that much in a Kalita!

    • @leftiesrule
      @leftiesrule 4 года назад

      @@scottrao5268 Thanks Scott! Certainly not the answer I was expecting... I'd be curious why if you're willing to share (bed depth?). Maybe it's time to dust off the Chemex lol!!

  • @Crake71
    @Crake71 3 года назад +4

    Do you keep heating your kettle between pulse pours or do you let the kettle temperature fall?

    • @adamthemute
      @adamthemute 3 года назад +1

      If there's a decent amount of water in it, it should only drop a couple degrees. Wouldn't make much of a difference unless it's dropping 5+ in most cases, but maybe that would work with certain coffees. Could always do a side by side. I'd say it's better to keep it steady to eliminate that variable at first.

  • @144avery
    @144avery 4 года назад +2

    Thank you...keeping us new COVID coffee-heads in mind.

  • @taylorwhite3636
    @taylorwhite3636 4 года назад

    I have always been curious about trying the Kalita with the decent pour over head, as the Kalita seems to offer the most consistency for pour overs, and the decent allows for so much control.

  • @dan138zig
    @dan138zig Год назад +2

    Can you scale down this recipe?

  • @thebatiron5381
    @thebatiron5381 4 года назад +1

    Love the updates, can you tell me what water temperature you were using?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +9

      97c/207f

    • @c.j.c350
      @c.j.c350 3 года назад

      @@scottrao5268 do you tend to use less than boiling or was this due to a certain coffee in particular? I thought generally speaking boiling was best for high quality light roasts.

  • @mcsignson
    @mcsignson 5 месяцев назад +1

    would be fun to hear what you see the key differences between the former and current versions - a fan of the former version - using it reliably for - ever - this one has wet and two pours rather than one. Pour is still constant height. It seems it's gone from 360 to 340 as well? is that coffee type specific? or your generic ratio now? THANK YOU

    • @scottmcclements7566
      @scottmcclements7566 День назад

      It seems to the end of time there will be the "best" way, but I agree, I use the ~ former method. I bloom with 3x the coffee amount, but immediately stir it with a thin wood spoon to get it mixed evenly as quick as possible, then after 30 seconds, one pour to 16.3 times my coffee amount. No matter what amount I make in the V60 (up to a max of 30:490) , I get exactly the same extraction.

  • @MrRockso99
    @MrRockso99 4 года назад +2

    Scott- you said a 40 on the niche grinder, which from looking seems on the coarser side, do I understand that correctly? I have a baratza encore and am trying to use your technique as close as possible for starters
    Also, great video and thanks for making it

    • @Julumon.
      @Julumon. 4 года назад

      It's prety fine

    • @J.T.K
      @J.T.K 4 года назад +1

      It's medium fine. I started with a 15 on my Encore with M2 upgrade. I could probably take it a little finer as well ( just did my first attempt).

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад

      I don't know what the Encore equivalent would be.

    • @BusterDarcy
      @BusterDarcy 3 года назад

      Still learning pour over after decades on a French press and have the baratza encore as well. Started at 10, am up to 12 now but still not happy with the results so thinking I may need to go coarser now (to complicate things I’m using a medium roast my wife got me for Xmas when I usually drink light roasts).
      Finding pour over much less forgiving than a French press, so many factors that can take the brew off course, but enjoying the learning process and looking forward to the rewards when I get it all dialled in right.

  • @kitcojuangco8429
    @kitcojuangco8429 4 года назад +4

    Hi Scott.
    What would be a good starting point grind size for a Comandante grinder?

    • @GuitaristBoi9
      @GuitaristBoi9 4 года назад +2

      Imo, 24-26 for v60

    • @r_bear
      @r_bear 4 года назад +5

      I'd suggest closer to 20 for a method like this

  • @greghazell4214
    @greghazell4214 4 года назад +2

    Hi Scott, thanks for the video! Question: You mention that you do a 45 second bloom pour to pour, but your bloom starts at 1:35 and next pour starts at about 2:40 for a bloom of a minute and 5 seconds. Just curious if I’m missing something?

    • @patrickhopkins5626
      @patrickhopkins5626 4 года назад +3

      I take the "do as I say, not as I do" method when watching demo videos like this.

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +9

      @@patrickhopkins5626 I wasn't timing it because my phone is my only timer and is also my video camera. Indeed, in this case, do as I say, not as i do.

    • @andyourbirdcansing64
      @andyourbirdcansing64 4 года назад

      Scott Rao hey Scott. Even though you didn’t use a timer here, what are your typical brew times for quantities like this?

  • @JapaneseLanguageMentor
    @JapaneseLanguageMentor 4 года назад +2

    Did you wet the filter with cold water? Warm? Hot? Does the filter need to be wetted with good water too?

    • @xdptwin1
      @xdptwin1 4 года назад

      I think wetting the filter is just so the coffee doesn't get any paper-y flavor. Just use tap to rinse the filter.

    • @andrabispeimle671
      @andrabispeimle671 4 года назад +1

      Might want to preheat as well if you have a light roast and ceramic cone

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +3

      I use hot water, doesn't have to be special water, no.

    • @JapaneseLanguageMentor
      @JapaneseLanguageMentor 4 года назад

      @@scottrao5268 Thank you so much!

  • @wwoodard8
    @wwoodard8 4 года назад

    Thanks for this! Question: do you ever use the smaller, one cup Kalita? Does that give you acceptable results? Would you change anything about your technique for that size?

  • @heynedajoon
    @heynedajoon 3 года назад

    Wow such even grind! It's amazing!

    • @margot6041
      @margot6041 3 года назад

      That has to be his grinder!
      Not my Encore

    • @error.418
      @error.418 2 года назад

      @@margot6041 yeah, Niche Zero

  • @Puffdad152
    @Puffdad152 4 года назад

    Thanks Scott for the helpful vid. Would your current recommendations for a Chemex brew differ greatly from this?

    • @maaaatt
      @maaaatt 4 года назад +1

      Scott's recommendation for a chemex would probably be to use it as a vase ;)

    • @dwikafebrianto3016
      @dwikafebrianto3016 4 года назад

      @@maaaatt Ooof. It is a really pretty vase tho ngl

  • @videoguy3110
    @videoguy3110 4 года назад +4

    Hey Scott, in my experience having used stainless steel as well as glass Kalita brewers, only the metal has a serious issue with getting blocked. If people are thinking of purchasing a Kalita, it's easier to buy glass or ceramic than needing to modify or use a mesh every time.
    Another question based on your brew ratio @ 24% extraction, this sounds like a stronger than typical coffee. Is that a preference?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +1

      it's a little stonger than i prefer, but i like the flavor of the high extraction. A higher brewing ratio would drop the TDS, but would make channeling more likely, so I stick with 17:1

  • @justchill1016
    @justchill1016 4 года назад +3

    4 minute 50 secs for extraction? Isn't it little bit long??

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +4

      depends on your dose, grind quality, and pouring method. It's definitely too long for some people and some equipment.

  • @hideostranding1944
    @hideostranding1944 3 года назад +1

    I found that with natural process coffee. This methode makes it overxtract with dry aftertaste. At least from my xperience. Maybe coz of the coffee roasted ?

  • @taelend5301
    @taelend5301 4 года назад

    Thanks for the guide. Im new to pour over coffee and this is very helpful. I have brewed 3 cups based on this. I have one problem. I get a slightly sour taste in my cup. I follow the general 3 minute rule. I have fresh coffee that I grind with a burr grinder and I weigh it all out. What could the issue be?

    • @majornukke
      @majornukke 4 года назад +2

      Google Coffee Compass, it's been a useful troubleshooting guide when I started brewing my own coffee.

    • @jonathanmanley6743
      @jonathanmanley6743 4 года назад +3

      Likely need to grind the coffee finer. Sour usually indicates under extraction. So in short you need to get more out of the coffee, thus a finer grind. (It could also potentially be to low a water temp but if you are using water that 195-205 that is not the issue).

  • @Nipperjag
    @Nipperjag 4 года назад

    Thanks for the update. Did you already test the new ESPRO Bloom Filter? I would appreciate your comment on it. Thanks

  • @applepieclub5012
    @applepieclub5012 9 месяцев назад

    What grind setting would recommend for a fellow ode with gen 1 burrs?

  • @thefreshestprince89
    @thefreshestprince89 4 года назад +2

    What setting do you guys with Porlex Mini Hand Grinders use? How many clicks?

    • @bettyflores8687
      @bettyflores8687 3 года назад

      I usually use it between 8 and 9 (I believe it has 18 clicks)

  • @reggiepaquette5677
    @reggiepaquette5677 4 года назад

    When you use the Stag brewer, do you do a finer grind to maintain the same extraction time as the wave? Because it has more holes, it seems to brew very fast. I'm coming to the stag brewer from a chemex and still struggling to dial it in. Just curious if you alter anything in your brewing process here for the wave when using the stag. Thanks!

  • @TheTRudor
    @TheTRudor 3 года назад +1

    Hi Scott! After finishing the brew, do you stir the coffee? I read somewhere that there are less soluble at the top than at the bottom. Thanks!

    • @adamthemute
      @adamthemute 3 года назад

      Different flavours are coming throughout the brew so you can't go wrong with a few stirs

  • @Andy-ux3ge
    @Andy-ux3ge 4 года назад +7

    In other words.. you’re saying the kalita dripper has been poorly designed all along! 😆

    • @dwikafebrianto3016
      @dwikafebrianto3016 4 года назад

      The stainless steel version of Kalita Wave is pretty much shitty. But it is a full different story with the Tsubame version tho.

  • @johnmalin4933
    @johnmalin4933 4 года назад

    Thanks for the video! Why don't you spin after the first pour?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +8

      While a spin there would probably decrease channeling, it will also dramatically slow the rate of drawdown.

    • @johnmalin4933
      @johnmalin4933 4 года назад

      Thanks for the quick reply! I love your content on RUclips, Instagram, Blog, etc. Keep up the great work!

  • @CreamyDrummer
    @CreamyDrummer 4 года назад

    Hi Scott,
    Thanks for the lovely video.
    I read earlier that the Kalita is not your go to coffee maker, curious to hear what is :)

  • @jordanjones6119
    @jordanjones6119 4 года назад +1

    Hey Scott! Any idea what Comandante grind setting would work best for this method? Not sure if you've played around with it.

    • @jsiminski
      @jsiminski 4 года назад

      I find 23-28 clicks to work best

    • @deenman60
      @deenman60 4 года назад +2

      @@jsiminski It's way finer than that. 23-28 click on comandante gives you a normal brew time of 2:15-3:15 minutes. This brew time is close to 5 minutes, you grind probably under 18 on comandante.

    • @jsiminski
      @jsiminski 4 года назад

      @@deenman60 You must be right, I thought it went quite faster

    • @Bean15_
      @Bean15_ 4 года назад

      It looks like it’s about 16 to 18 clicks

  • @NickBiancalana
    @NickBiancalana 4 года назад

    Interesting using the screen at the bottom, I've noticed my rate drops significantly during the second half of the pour, so I bet mine is doing the same thing under the filter

  • @MrMonsterchow
    @MrMonsterchow 4 года назад +3

    Hello!! thanks for the update :)
    Was wondering what are your opinions on this method for a smaller volume? I find myself brewing a smaller cup in the morning, around 250ml. So at 17:1 that would be roughly 15g to 250ml.
    Would you still recommend doing two separate pours ? or do you think a single pour would be preferable. Thank you!

    • @Seanhaibao
      @Seanhaibao 4 года назад +1

      Give it a try. I'm assuming he won't answer with confidence since he hasn't tried it, but in principle, it should be relatively similar, though heat retention may be different, and so on and so forth. I will definitely give it a try though~

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +2

      It will work fine with 15/250, same number of pours, etc. I do that once in a while.

  • @mariofasolo5832
    @mariofasolo5832 4 года назад

    Have you heard of/tried the Bloom pourover by Espro? I switched to it from the Kalita with amazing results. Incredibly good extractions in 1:30, I have no idea how it works so quickly, but my cups have been the best of any device I've used. Curious to see your measurements of extractions if you got your hands on one! The bottom is completely flat so there's almost no opportunity for channeling or clogging.

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад

      I have not. Though I'm not sure why a flat bottom would prevent channeling?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +2

      I decided to buy an Espro after your comment and someone else's here. I'm looking forward to trying it, thanks

    • @adamthemute
      @adamthemute 3 года назад

      @@scottrao5268 What are your thoughts on the Espro after a few months of usage?

  • @lambertronix
    @lambertronix 4 года назад +1

    love it, scott!

  • @philave5482
    @philave5482 4 года назад

    Is there any place where it is explained why having a vertical stream out of the spout is important? As well as splashless pouring height?
    Thanks a lot!) Great video, as always.)

    • @arna437
      @arna437 4 года назад +4

      Go to the "coffeeadastra " blog. Jonathan Gagné explains it beautifully

    • @philave5482
      @philave5482 4 года назад

      @@arna437 thanks!)

  • @jamesoffer6758
    @jamesoffer6758 4 года назад +2

    Excited to try your new method! I followed your instructions exactly but unfortunately my coffee came out burnt and not able to taste anything but a smokey/thick consistency. I've found a little success when I removed the v60 just before it was done pouring. Not sure if anyone else had the same results 🤷🏻‍♂️

    • @daniels2423
      @daniels2423 4 года назад +1

      That's due to the coffee you have used especially grind quality and not to the method described in the video. If you got better results when removing the V60 earlier it means that the grind had too many fines therefore you were over extracting. Try to grind a little more coarser.

    • @jamesoffer6758
      @jamesoffer6758 4 года назад +1

      @@daniels2423 Ah, but here lies my conundrum; if I use a coarcer grind, then the water goes straight through the grind and doesn't create a slurry at all, one that is too dense/dry, to swirle, mix, or let alone, leave to rest for longer than a few seconds

    • @daniels2423
      @daniels2423 4 года назад

      You don't have to go to that extreme. One or two tics on your grinder should be enough.

    • @keerthikumar2023
      @keerthikumar2023 4 года назад +1

      simple you have two options 1. buy a better grinder 2. sift out some of the fines

  • @adamthemute
    @adamthemute 4 года назад +1

    What different characteristics would using 2 VS 3 pours after the bloom have?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +7

      fewer pours = hotter slurry but slightly lower extraction . tradeoffs.

  • @MiguelGebremedhin
    @MiguelGebremedhin 3 года назад

    Hey Scott, I'm gonna try this for Chemex. What temperature did you have your kettle at when you did the pour ? I usually have mine at 208. Also, what grind setting do you recommend on a Baratza Virtuoso + ?

  • @terioops
    @terioops 4 года назад

    thanks for the update!

  •  3 года назад

    I usually fill up my kalita pretty full to keep the slurry temperature as high as possible, do you find it detrimental to fill the brewer completely?

  • @FruitlessRoaster
    @FruitlessRoaster 4 года назад

    Have you found a downside to fairly vigorous agitation at the time of blooming? Or do you simply find this method more consistent.

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +2

      It's more consistent, but can lead to choking/clogging if you overdo it.

  • @adamthemute
    @adamthemute 4 года назад +3

    I'm new to a V60 and was wondering if a ~3:30 brew time (same 20g/340ml used) with a V60, and 15 clicks on Timemore C2 sounds about right or am I pouring too fast? Or, maybe try finer grind before it tastes too dry/bitter? I know time shouldn't be a huge factor but it helps a new user dial it in a bit. Thanks!

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +2

      sounds about right. You can always inch the grind a little finer, and if you find astringency, back off a little coarser from there and you're probably in the sweet spot.

    • @leonmog8346
      @leonmog8346 4 года назад

      Same setup. Although I always set my setting between 17-19. Didn't think to try to grind finer.
      I'll def try since u mention it. Thanks!

  • @vizzo7
    @vizzo7 Год назад

    did you use the rao perger water profile?

  • @yarostlove9795
    @yarostlove9795 4 года назад

    Thank you very much!

  • @MinimalUnbox
    @MinimalUnbox 3 года назад +8

    Anybody can recommend grind size on commandante? Also, any perspective on pros/cons of this method vs 4:6 method?

    • @Philosophaster
      @Philosophaster 3 года назад +3

      Would love to know others' opinions too. With mine, I am usually around 21-23 clicks

    • @MinimalUnbox
      @MinimalUnbox 3 года назад +4

      @@Philosophaster I also tried Comandante 21 (Origami S + Wave 155 filter) and it turned out pretty good. I liked that he doesn’t focus on timing but rather tasting to adjust. I used to focus and adjust based on timing which always resulted in frustration. My current challenge is this: I get a very nice, transparent and fruity cup, but at the end of it there is a bad harshness can be tasted at roof of my mouth. It’s not regular bitterness so that I can fix it by grinding coarser. Coffee tastes amazing but this harshness kills me. Any idea how to fix it?

    • @19Cluj
      @19Cluj 3 года назад

      @@MinimalUnbox maybe change the water, or the temperature of the extraction.

    • @MegiddoProductions
      @MegiddoProductions 3 года назад

      @@MinimalUnbox when have you cleaned your grinder last time?
      My biggest breakthrough with a persistent bitterness I couldn't fix was cleaning my grinder.

    • @Joseph-C
      @Joseph-C 2 года назад

      @@MinimalUnbox It sounds like you might be describing a dry finish? Coffee will have a dry or soapy finish when it is under extracted. Make sure you're using hot enough water, ideally right off the boil assuming you're not using dark roast. Poor quality water will also cause poor extraction. I was using pure RO water for years but could never make light roasts taste good without the dry/soapy finish until I started remineralizing my pure water, which increased extraction.

  • @ecapsdira
    @ecapsdira 4 года назад +1

    Interested to know, what scale is being used in the video?

    • @patrickhopkins5626
      @patrickhopkins5626 4 года назад +2

      Google "AMIR coffee scale" and you'll find it on Amazon.

    • @ecapsdira
      @ecapsdira 4 года назад +1

      @@patrickhopkins5626 thanks!

    • @aeidein
      @aeidein 4 года назад

      Will add my recommendation as well. Coming from the "Hario V60 coffee scale", the AMIR is faster and more reliable. Main downsides are: you can't turn the backlight off, and no built-in timer.

  • @emmaivettematos8055
    @emmaivettematos8055 4 года назад

    Time between 1rst pour at 210 grs and 2nd pour at 340 grs ?
    After pouring to 340 grs, how long should it take so the water pass through the slurry ? Total brewing time ?
    Any feedback will be appreciated.
    Thanks.

    • @edwickson
      @edwickson 4 года назад +1

      he's not cutting the videos, so there's all your answer

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +2

      I don't have a set time between the pours, i wait for the slurry to drop in half. typical total brew time is 4:30, but your ideal brew time is dependent on your grind quality and the dose used.

  • @taylorwhite3636
    @taylorwhite3636 3 года назад +3

    4:30-ish pour (to draw down) time?
    That seems a bit slow to me (I aim for around 3:30-ish). What time do you aim for??

    • @baristaodla7640
      @baristaodla7640 3 года назад

      1:20 I get dry & bitter notes above 2:00

    • @armLocalhost
      @armLocalhost 3 года назад +1

      It depends on your grinder. Some coffees taste good at 4 and even 5 with good grinders.

    • @baristaodla7640
      @baristaodla7640 3 года назад

      @@armLocalhost I sift out dust/fines. So I dont think its about the grind. Either I love underextracted coffees, or the roast here is pretty bad.

    • @hugensmugen
      @hugensmugen 3 года назад

      Its gonna depend a lot on your beans (and grinder). Time doesnt really matter too much it varies a lot depending on what kind of beans you have. I can get up to 1 minute variation in brewtime with the exact same recipe just by swapping out the beans.

    • @francofhernandez6922
      @francofhernandez6922 3 года назад +1

      Just tried it today 1:17 ratio. Used 16.5g with 280g water and it tasted wonderful with last drops dripping at around 3:30. Second pour was 170g.

  • @carlcutajar86
    @carlcutajar86 4 года назад +4

    Hi Scott, when I do the bloom phase the water goes down really fast, what am I missing? I am talking about the Hario coz I've seen your other vid as well

    • @xsr8
      @xsr8 3 года назад

      Have you tried a finer grind?

  • @shawnsgear
    @shawnsgear 4 года назад +1

    Interesting! Was that about a 4:40 brew time? That seems like quite a while for a 20g dose. Seems like I’ve always heard 3:15-3:45 was a good time for 20g. I usually do 1:15 or 1:16 ratios. Does that explain the longer brew time for you since you did a 1:17? Also do you normally use a timer? I couldn’t tell if that scale had a timer. I would have loved to try that coffee!
    Since you use the Niche do you use the slow bean feed technique or do you just load all the beans at once?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +7

      ideal brew time depends on the grind quality, pouring method and the dose used. Your grinder may favor shorter brew times, etc. I put all of the beans at once in the niche, but that's not to say it's the "best" option. Yes, I normally use a timer but when doing the video I didn't, as my phone is my only timer and also my only video camera :0. the video is NOT meant to prescribe exact timing for anyone else's setup. it's more about the method.

    • @shawnsgear
      @shawnsgear 4 года назад

      Scott Rao got it! Thank you!

    • @36ss36
      @36ss36 4 года назад

      @@scottrao5268 ll

  • @user-tr8rg1xg9e
    @user-tr8rg1xg9e Год назад +1

    Has anyone tried to grind the coffee in the grinder with boiling water? 🤔

  • @DanMars27
    @DanMars27 4 года назад +1

    Why not the smaller Kalita - 155 - with only 20 grams?

  • @devlin2427
    @devlin2427 4 года назад +1

    That's an insane amount of fines. I'd probably throw my ghost burr grinder away if it did that.

  • @aaronkahn-bork1120
    @aaronkahn-bork1120 4 года назад

    As much anxiety as parts of this gave me, I can’t wait to try it. The only part I didn’t understand: why the pour height? I’ve always tried to pour from fairly low to reduce agitation.

    • @dkim51
      @dkim51 4 года назад

      agitation increases extraction which rao seems to be going for here

    • @mjod
      @mjod 4 года назад +3

      There's a very interesting blog post by Coffee ad astra on this subject. The photo in the 'about me' is taken by Scott Rao, so they're probably acquaintances or even friends.
      You can find the blog post here: coffeeadastra.com/2020/05/23/the-physics-of-kettle-streams/

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +5

      @@mjod we are indeed friends, and Jonathan is now probably the world's leading expert on the dynamics of filter brewing. everything he writes is worth reading.

  • @kuzmanmarinov2832
    @kuzmanmarinov2832 4 года назад

    The temperature is as in the previous technique - about 97-98 C°, right?

  • @tankerfiveohh
    @tankerfiveohh 4 года назад

    Any chance this will work out for a hario nel pot? Or is that just too different?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад

      I don't know what the "nel pot" is.

    • @calebk7545
      @calebk7545 4 года назад +1

      I think they mean the Hario Woodneck with cloth filter?

  • @sebastianf7071
    @sebastianf7071 4 года назад

    I have had the same issues as you on the metal Kalita, but never on the sandstone Kalita. Any thoughts to why that is?

    • @lekweekeat
      @lekweekeat 4 года назад +1

      @the coffee chronicler did a couple of videos on this, check out his youtube or website.

    • @dwikafebrianto3016
      @dwikafebrianto3016 4 года назад +1

      I bet the sandstone version is fancier than the ceramic one. Any opinion on this sandstone vs ceramic?

    • @sebastianf7071
      @sebastianf7071 4 года назад

      @@dwikafebrianto3016 never used the ceramic Kalita, sadly!

    • @dwikafebrianto3016
      @dwikafebrianto3016 4 года назад +1

      @@sebastianf7071 Does your sandstone Kalita look really pretty when you brew a coffee? IMO Stainless Steel Kalita (even the ultimate Tsubame one) doesn't look that good. Plastic V60 is prettier I guess

    • @sebastianf7071
      @sebastianf7071 4 года назад

      @@dwikafebrianto3016 it sure does. Check out my Instagram (@sebastianscoffee) where there are quite a few photos of the sandstone.

  • @kevinrosacia
    @kevinrosacia 2 года назад +9

    Does anyone know approximately how many microns a 40 on the Niche translates to? Just curious! (Thanks in advance!)

    • @error.418
      @error.418 2 года назад

      Problem is each Niche Zero is different for those settings. So one persons's Niche Zero at 40 will be one micron measurement, someone else's will be another.

    • @ronmcdowell1341
      @ronmcdowell1341 2 года назад +2

      @@error.418 I personally wish that instructional videos would use a measurement tool such as the Brewler to give a comparable grind size ( for example in microns with the Brewler).

    • @error.418
      @error.418 2 года назад +1

      @@ronmcdowell1341 I agree, the Brewler is a great tool. That said, even with such a tool, viewers may still struggle to get the exact grind, and that's okay. Part of tweaking your brew is bracketing grind size until you find what works for you. Everyone's taste is different. But it's still nice to have an example to work from with a clear starting point, like showing your grinds next to the Brewler.

  • @KostasSiderisBarista
    @KostasSiderisBarista 3 года назад +5

    I doubt Niche with its ground particle distribution profile, can deliver so high EY% without any astrigency. I can see also that your brew here, choked by the fines produced by this grinder.

    • @BariSaxGod25
      @BariSaxGod25 3 года назад +1

      No, he and Jonathan Gagne discussed this in their IG live thing, and they think it’s because the niche grinds up chaff, which doesn’t really affect anything other than making the brew look muddy. He also has compared the niche to his baratza forte and they can produce high extractions art similar times.

    • @KostasSiderisBarista
      @KostasSiderisBarista 3 года назад +2

      @@BariSaxGod25 IO don't doubt the numbers. I doubt the taste. I mentioned astrigency

    • @skiqwerty12
      @skiqwerty12 3 года назад +1

      @@KostasSiderisBarista hater

    • @nadmanganiankutasu
      @nadmanganiankutasu 3 года назад

      Bro it's Scott Rao. This man shaped the speciality coffee industry into what it is today. You don't doubt Scott Rao.

    • @KostasSiderisBarista
      @KostasSiderisBarista 3 года назад

      @@nadmanganiankutasu that was said for David Sommer.... Look where we are now!

  • @stististi
    @stististi 4 года назад

    Hi Scott, is a narrow spout from a single drip kettle at 7mm better?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад

      I'm not sure what a single drip kettle is, sorry

    • @stististi
      @stististi 4 года назад

      @@scottrao5268 Hi Scott, thanks for replying. Example would be www.marucoffee.com/products/kettle-white

    • @EntelSidious_gamzeylmz
      @EntelSidious_gamzeylmz 4 года назад +1

      @@stististi I have always found these harder to pour from. And they also have some other downsides, I can tell about those if you are interested

    • @stististi
      @stististi 4 года назад

      @@EntelSidious_gamzeylmz I bought one from japan and realised its hard to maintain high temperature when brewing light roasts, a brewista would always be ideal it seems

    • @EntelSidious_gamzeylmz
      @EntelSidious_gamzeylmz 4 года назад

      @@stististi Yes that is the biggest downside. You can't use them stovetop (which leads to water starting at about 91 degrees even if you pour boiling water directly) and they don't have big enough thermal mass that they can hold it for the entire duration of the brew. Electric goosenecks are the best but you can boil in your normal kettle, get it in the stovetop and boil it again in the stovetop (it will take about 20-30 seconds to boil it again).

  • @kiweep7
    @kiweep7 4 года назад

    Just a quick question; that’s a WAVE 155, is it?

    • @wwoodard8
      @wwoodard8 4 года назад +2

      (I’m guessing that’s a 185...)

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +4

      it's a 185

    • @evanb5733
      @evanb5733 4 года назад

      @@scottrao5268 Can this recipe be done with a Kalita 155 as well?

  • @madrian_hello
    @madrian_hello 4 года назад +2

    Anyone trying this on Kinu grinder, what settings do yo use? Grind size looks extremely fine on the video. It should be around 2:0:0 or even finer. I tried at 2:9:0, but I have big chunks in the coffee on the video looks much finer.

    • @Acontinouslean
      @Acontinouslean 4 года назад

      I don't have a kinu but I can tell you the grind is fairly fine

    • @sethjack952
      @sethjack952 4 года назад +1

      Hmmm I Grind for V60 around 4.0

    • @nAlvaradoProductions
      @nAlvaradoProductions 4 года назад +1

      @@sethjack952 Right where I'm at as well on an m47p.

  • @bt18
    @bt18 4 года назад

    Would you do anything differently with V60?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +2

      not really.

    • @devlin2427
      @devlin2427 4 года назад

      form the top of my head, how about a brew grinder.

    • @bt18
      @bt18 4 года назад +2

      @@scottrao5268 I am getting excellent results with V60 using this method. Thanks!

  • @AdamCooperman
    @AdamCooperman 4 года назад +3

    You said you're using a Niche Zero grinder, but it looks like a different grounds basket? Can I ask if there's some reason or is that just what you had at the time or something? (Or am I just incorrect?)

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад

      it's an anti-static bin from my Baratza Forte. I always grind into that.

    • @TerrapinSuite
      @TerrapinSuite 3 года назад

      @@scottrao5268 Hi Scott and thank you for the video. I have been making several V60's a day for about 3 years. I see you mention the Baratza Forte. I was considering the Forte BG to upgrade from my first grinder which is a Breville Smart Grinder Pro. Wondering what your thoughts are on the Forte BG, or other grinder for pour over use.

  • @johnbarthalameuwhaler
    @johnbarthalameuwhaler 4 года назад +1

    which scale is that?

    • @scottrao5268
      @scottrao5268  4 года назад +3

      I don't know; i got it for $10 on amazon years ago and it has no brand name on it. But it was $10 well spent!

  • @dowhatIdo
    @dowhatIdo 4 года назад

    Fresh coffee tend to give sour taste. So is it true that you can put the coffee you are going to use tomorrow overnight outside the bag? Let just say on small tray and leave it for 8hours. And it will degase faster ?

    • @edwickson
      @edwickson 4 года назад

      your first statement is not correct. I'm a roaster and I rarely find my fresh roast taste sour, unless you're robusta drinker and judge every arabica is sour. Every decent roastery out there will sell their coffee AFTER (minimum) 4 days of resting (in a proper one way valve sealed bag). It is not recommended to leave your beans open air. So instead, try to buy from high quality roastery and tweak you grind size. hope that helps.

    • @dowhatIdo
      @dowhatIdo 4 года назад

      @@edwickson Hallo, Im from Indonesia and been drinking single origin coffee for 5 years. And honestly maybe the way or the technique our roaster use. But Im not the only one who said about this sour coffee. One local roaster in my place said needs 1month to get clean coffee, and he said if you brew coffee less than that time, you will get that sour or astringent. That's the reason why I ask the previous question. Anyways thanks for your information :)

    • @edwickson
      @edwickson 4 года назад

      @@dowhatIdo well that's not normal.

    • @rainiersauer4288
      @rainiersauer4288 4 года назад

      @@dowhatIdo 1. Try a different roaster, good coffee roasts are hard to find. 2. It could be your water temps 3. try a longer bloom

    • @dowhatIdo
      @dowhatIdo 4 года назад

      @@rainiersauer4288 Already tried diffrent roaster that avail in Indonesia. I tried sometimes coffee roastery from another continent like april, gardelli, homeground. And never found that over sour or astringent. So I think it's our roastery