I really like it a lot! I have a couple of body sprays still I wish the body spray was stronger, but I went through all of my body cream too three bottles within a couple of months. If it comes back in 2024, I will definitely be getting more of the body cream!
First! Excited to hear this review. Interesting. I haven’t smelled Everlasting Magic yet, but I loved Sugared Cherry Crisp. I would miss the crust note and the strength though. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if this is a repackage with a twist since that seems to be mostly what they do now.
Now that I’ve worn this scent, I know what it smells like, at least to my nose on my skin - cherry liqueur/cherry brandy. That’s what I get, and I still think you’re right about oils from Sugared Cherry Crisp being reused in this.
Everlasting magic smells very similar to cheirosa 40! Although everlasting magic is a bit more musky and dry while 40 is juicy and sweeter, they pair perfectly together:)
Oh yeah I love how you do your reviews. They're perfect to me, don't change a thing! Love the comparisons too since I don't live too close to a store. They're really helpful to me! I'm excited to sniff this one. Really hoping I smell cherry BC I'm really digging cherry this year hehhee 🧙🍒
I picked up my body care today and I’m completely OBSESSED with Everlasting Magic. I got Vampires Blood too, it’s nice but Everlasting Magic is too good! They need to make it into a perfume. I’m going to need to buy several backups. My Everlasting Magic is strong! I’ve had it on several hours and I can still smell myself. I did layer it with the body cream and the Shimmer Body Fizz. I really like the Shimmer Body Fizz, maybe I should get back ups of that too.
@@marymakers You're welcome!!! I went in today but didn't get anything. I smelled some stuff, smelled the Fall scents they have out & saw the new Halloween & Fall Wallflower plugs
Just got this in the mail today and I smelled it and I smelled Cherry. I agree this is sugared Cherry Crisp without the crust note. I stand with you on this.😊
Hey Mary and everyone.....can't wait to try this one! I went to BBW yesterday and picked up a couple of the mini mists....the Gingham Fresh and the new scent 'Chasing Daisies'.....couldn't believe they had in ......it's pretty strong, and reminds me of Dahlia (which I don't like), but this new one is better!
I think the petals are rose I compared the rose I think that’s in this to the rose in whipped rose vanilla and sweet petal Poundcake and I was like really it’s the same rose they just moved things around again And I think the berry is the blackberry in gingham vibrant. And it’s a shame I really like the scent but again gone very lightly skin scent in 10-15 minutes have to over spray for it to hang around. I’m gonna have to re sniff and now I’m looking for cherry lolol I have cherry crisp I’m intrigued maybe the cherry in sunset glow perhaps. I wish it was as strong as vampire blood at they gave that one a good projecting performance..
I finally got into the store, and after wearing this on my left wrist all night, I think it's a first or second cousin of Wild Sands, at least they share the same musk note. Years ago Victoria's Secret had a perfume named Feathered Musk and Everlasting Magic smells how I remember that smelling. I don't have Sugared Cherry Crisp to compare it to........
I love it, "they got the same daddy"!!!! Lol. I put my nose to this today Tuesday for the Halloween release. I ordered online, but wanted to go put my nose and eyes on things. My store had everything in stock and plenty of it. Including the luminary haunted castle. The only thing they had run out of was a dripping rose. I know I saw it online but can't remember in what decor it was in? Anyhow I thought Everlasting Magic was ok on first sniff. As you said I gotta wear it more before final decision. I've never smelled Cherry Crisp so can't tell if they smell alike. There was a note I couldn't figure out, maybe it was the cherry?
I still have not walked into my local store as of yet to check out everything. Will be doing so after work for sure today. This one sounds like I would not like at all. I actually was not a fan of Enchanted Candy Potion from last year. It was too sickening sweet for me. Just like I'm not a fan of Pastel Skies which I'm giving away the mini I have. I like sweet, but not that sweet. I probably will get this one though as I collect the Halloween mists. I can't see this one smelling like Midnight Amber Glow which is coffee based to me. I sometimes question people's noses LOL I'm hearing mixed reviews with Midnight Spell as well. I feel like Vampire Blood will be the one for me as I'm familiar with that one. I've had that one in all sorts of forms over the years including in body care. Thank you for your honesty.
@@marymakers Most of the mists these days don't have staying power 🙄Mary, I have a Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin mist from 2013 and it still smells strong lol
@@marymakers I walked into my local store. More than half of the items are not being sold in Canada like the U.S. has. Not surprised by that. I did pick this one up though to have in my collection.
So....just got my Halloween order, strongly recommend to not waste your money on Everlasting Magic cream. Once again, like some other BBW creams, they ruined it, all I get is that gross smell of cocoa butter, with barely any fragrance. You are right, it is very light smelling, I never smelled Sugared Cherry Crisp before, as I just got back into BBW last fall. However, Vampire Blood & Midnight Spell cream aren't that bad, you can still smell the fragrance over the cocoa butter. I remember Indigo Dreams & Coco Paradise smelling Cocoa butter heavy and weren't good in the cream, but they were good in the lotions. Can't wait for your review on Midnight Spell🪄🌠, it smells so familiar, like something else to me, can't figure it out, is it kind of similiar to Wild Sands?
Mary I thought everlasting magic smelled cherry too. I love everlasting magic, but it doesn’t last. The body cream does help it last. I will have to go to Mercari and get sugared cherry crisp I saw it on there. Thanks for your reviews Mary! ❤❤
It reminds me of a weak 3 hr later with out a touch up of sunset glow in the initial first spray must be the cherry then it dries down to your correct cherry crisp with out the crust I have all 3 and I think your spot on why not call it cherry why say berries are in it they have to have some dumb excuse for it I bet you it’s because berries sell off topic but I have to say I don’t understand the obsession with berries from BBW it is over played I think they keep doing it cause it sells and majority of people with a large collection like my self are tired of it . Or it’s cheaper to make and they know fools like my self that are looking for the new new will buy it hopeful to get a new something to only be disappointed I have no idea why I continue to come back for more only to be disappointed. As for this mist I was at first because I wanted to believe they were honest with there note descriptors was looking for a berry and came up with blackberry the sweet one not as potent though In gingham vibrant. But I watched your review pulled out all the mist you mentioned and your right it’s a freaking cherry lolol
Girl... my sniffer is a highly tuned instrument. 🤣🤣🤣 it's a gift and a curse. 😆 but ya, they def keep playing on people with these 'berry' notes. I wish they'd just create more NEW scents instead of tweaking old ones.
I LOVE Sugared Cherry Crisp. I am definitely going to have to give Everlasting Magic a try. Do you think the EM cream wo mix well with the SCC mist (which I still have)? Thanks for your review!
Great review!! Would you say it smells like Enchanted Candy Potion? Hopefully BBW brings it back this year. OR I just need something similar/exactly like it!!❤️❤️❤️❤️
Ill tell ya what bathandbodyworks... Give me WICKED APPLE In body care like ya said ya would...then ill buy Halloween body care😅 Nothing interests me But the hand soaps!!!!!!!!😒
B&BW often dupes itself. "In The Stars" is VERY much "Midnight Blue Citrus". The latter being much stronger. "Champaign Toast" & Sparkling Orange Spritz" r also very similar. My daughter always laughs and says "They got u again huh" 😅
Well, u know we all interpret fragrance notes differently and that's ok 😉. I've worked in the fragrance industry a long time and always find it interesting how that happens! 😄
I heard that bbw is gonna start watering down all the scents so that you have to buy both perfume and lotion to layer them and make the scent strong so they make more money
Mary!!! Queen of the DUPE BUSTERS!!!🎉😅😊
Hell yes! 🤣🤣💯💯❤️
Mary, I always get a good laugh when I watch your reviews. Keep up the good work!
Glad you like them! ❤️❤️❤️❤️
My daughter took one sniff of the candle today and made the Sugared Cherry Crisp connection immediately. She loved that scent
I'm glad other people smell it like I did! Ya heard it here FIRST! 💯😍❤️
I really like it a lot! I have a couple of body sprays still I wish the body spray was stronger, but I went through all of my body cream too three bottles within a couple of months. If it comes back in 2024, I will definitely be getting more of the body cream!
She was such a good scent! 👍
@@marymakers ❤
@@marymakers I agree! I like the cherry note in it. ❤
First! Excited to hear this review.
Interesting. I haven’t smelled Everlasting Magic yet, but I loved Sugared Cherry Crisp. I would miss the crust note and the strength though. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if this is a repackage with a twist since that seems to be mostly what they do now.
It's a good one!
@@marymakersI smelled Everlasting Magic now and wore it out of the store and I think you’re spot on! Your review was worth the wait!
@lavender_coffee thank you luv! 😊
Now that I’ve worn this scent, I know what it smells like, at least to my nose on my skin - cherry liqueur/cherry brandy. That’s what I get, and I still think you’re right about oils from Sugared Cherry Crisp being reused in this.
I love your review style. Others give first impression. Others give dedicated reviews. We need the variety.
I appreciate that! Thank you luv! ❤️
Everlasting magic smells very similar to cheirosa 40! Although everlasting magic is a bit more musky and dry while 40 is juicy and sweeter, they pair perfectly together:)
I'm def about to pair them and see!
@@marymakers yes! you will be shook… this nose don’t lie hahaha
Smells like cherry crisps from bath and body works
I’ve heard together weather is a very close dupe to Cheirosa 40, so maybe those two are similar to each other, I wonder which one is stronger.
@@maurao6287 I don't think they are anything alike. At least not to my sniffer!
Oh yeah I love how you do your reviews. They're perfect to me, don't change a thing! Love the comparisons too since I don't live too close to a store. They're really helpful to me! I'm excited to sniff this one. Really hoping I smell cherry BC I'm really digging cherry this year hehhee 🧙🍒
Thank you so much! I think you'll like it for sure. 😍
I picked up my body care today and I’m completely OBSESSED with Everlasting Magic. I got Vampires Blood too, it’s nice but Everlasting Magic is too good! They need to make it into a perfume. I’m going to need to buy several backups.
My Everlasting Magic is strong! I’ve had it on several hours and I can still smell myself. I did layer it with the body cream and the Shimmer Body Fizz. I really like the Shimmer Body Fizz, maybe I should get back ups of that too.
It is really good! I just wish the spray alone lasted longer. 😪
@@marymakers Mine is fantastic, but I layered it. I think the fizz really helps. I’m going to go get the diamond shimmer today.
@@nolasalazar I think I def want that Shimmer mist spray!
I agree with you on the first spray with scents
Thank you! ❤️
@@marymakers You're welcome!!! I went in today but didn't get anything. I smelled some stuff, smelled the Fall scents they have out & saw the new Halloween & Fall Wallflower plugs
We picked up some goodies today, stayed tuned for our haul❤
Can't wait! I did a walk through today too! I'm so excited for the new, new!
Just got this in the mail today and I smelled it and I smelled Cherry. I agree this is sugared Cherry Crisp without the crust note. I stand with you on this.😊
Yassss! This nose should be insured! 🤣
It must smell good. Thank you 😊 for your review Mary 😊
It does! Thank you for watching! ❤️
I just got my order. You are so good! Everlasting Magic is exactly how you describe it.
I'm so glad you like it! It is def a good one. Just wish it was stronger.
Hey Mary and everyone.....can't wait to try this one! I went to BBW yesterday and picked up a couple of the mini mists....the Gingham Fresh and the new scent 'Chasing Daisies'.....couldn't believe they had in ......it's pretty strong, and reminds me of Dahlia (which I don't like), but this new one is better!
Chasing fireflies?? 🤔 dangggg, I wanna get my paws on that one asap!😮😊
@@marymakers Nah, Chasing Daisies.....hasn't officially been launched yet, should be in the next week or so.....😃
@@sarahannsmith3129 the only one I've heard of is chasing fireflies. ?? Now I'm thoroughly confused. 😆
I think the petals are rose
I compared the rose I think that’s in this to the rose in whipped rose vanilla and sweet petal Poundcake and I was like really it’s the same rose they just moved things around again
And I think the berry is the blackberry in gingham vibrant. And it’s a shame I really like the scent but again gone very lightly skin scent in 10-15 minutes have to over spray for it to hang around. I’m gonna have to re sniff and now I’m looking for cherry lolol I have cherry crisp I’m intrigued maybe the cherry in sunset glow perhaps. I wish it was as strong as vampire blood at they gave that one a good projecting performance..
I'm super bummed that this one is as light as it is. Like whyyyyyyy?!?!
🤩❤️😂❤️😘
I am definitely curious to smell it but not enough to buy it...too pricey!!!
I am most interested in getting Midnight Spell!😘
Review for midnight spell coming tomorrow!
I like this one! 💜
Me too!!
I have the mist I adore it!!! Getting compliments !!
I really like it allot! ❤️
Which one?
Wow, I agree. Also they added a hint of musk, but definitely similar. Im happy because I love cherry and vanilla!!!! ❤
Me too! Just wish it was stronger!
Is this a cherry vanilla scent? Cause I've been begging for a cherry vanilla scent forever!🍒
@@noellelopez560 I wouldn't say a solid cherry vanilla..... but it def has the qualities of it. Go sniff before you buy if possible!
@@noellelopez560 I think Mary’s sniffer is spot on and it’s most definitely Cherry and Vanilla!!!! 🍒 🖤🥰
@@erikkasepiphany Thanks. I'm going into the store Friday to check it out
I finally got into the store, and after wearing this on my left wrist all night, I think it's a first or second cousin of Wild Sands, at least they share the same musk note. Years ago Victoria's Secret had a perfume named Feathered Musk and Everlasting Magic smells how I remember that smelling. I don't have Sugared Cherry Crisp to compare it to........
If you did..... you'd totally see what I'm talking about. Ya can't miss it!
I love it, "they got the same daddy"!!!! Lol. I put my nose to this today Tuesday for the Halloween release. I ordered online, but wanted to go put my nose and eyes on things. My store had everything in stock and plenty of it. Including the luminary haunted castle. The only thing they had run out of was a dripping rose. I know I saw it online but can't
remember in what decor it was in? Anyhow I thought Everlasting Magic was ok on first sniff. As you said I gotta wear it more before final decision. I've never smelled Cherry Crisp so can't tell if they smell alike. There was a note I couldn't figure out, maybe it was the cherry?
I'm betting it wasssss!
@@marymakers omg I'm going bonkers, today was Monday first day of the Halloween rollout, not Tuesday. Sorry 🤯
I still have not walked into my local store as of yet to check out everything. Will be doing so after work for sure today. This one sounds like I would not like at all. I actually was not a fan of Enchanted Candy Potion from last year. It was too sickening sweet for me. Just like I'm not a fan of Pastel Skies which I'm giving away the mini I have. I like sweet, but not that sweet. I probably will get this one though as I collect the Halloween mists. I can't see this one smelling like Midnight Amber Glow which is coffee based to me. I sometimes question people's noses LOL I'm hearing mixed reviews with Midnight Spell as well. I feel like Vampire Blood will be the one for me as I'm familiar with that one. I've had that one in all sorts of forms over the years including in body care. Thank you for your honesty.
I think you may actually like this one though. It's not sickeningly sweet like that. It's very light though. No staying power at all. 😒
@@marymakers Most of the mists these days don't have staying power 🙄Mary, I have a Sweet Cinnamon Pumpkin mist from 2013 and it still smells strong lol
@@marymakers I walked into my local store. More than half of the items are not being sold in Canada like the U.S. has. Not surprised by that. I did pick this one up though to have in my collection.
@crafting_after_midnight4154 awww, that's a bummer!
So....just got my Halloween order, strongly recommend to not waste your money on Everlasting Magic cream. Once again, like some other BBW creams, they ruined it, all I get is that gross smell of cocoa butter, with barely any fragrance. You are right, it is very light smelling, I never smelled Sugared Cherry Crisp before, as I just got back into BBW last fall. However, Vampire Blood & Midnight Spell cream aren't that bad, you can still smell the fragrance over the cocoa butter. I remember Indigo Dreams & Coco Paradise smelling Cocoa butter heavy and weren't good in the cream, but they were good in the lotions. Can't wait for your review on Midnight Spell🪄🌠, it smells so familiar, like something else to me, can't figure it out, is it kind of similiar to Wild Sands?
Their creams used to be soooo much stronger. I'm bummed. And you def don't want to miss the midnight spell review..... cause whewwwww wheeeeee!!!
Everlasting magic to me smells like sensual amber and cashmere glow
You partial to ambery scents? Soft and sensual? Cause both of those are so creamy dreamy!
I wonder what Everlasting Magic would smell like layered with Christmas Cookies? Might have to try this combo.
Oooooo!! Now I'm running to check!
@marymakers oouu let us know what u think!!😊
Glad I got the diamond shimmer mist & shower gel otw. I love SCC. I'm always up for a cherry scent!
I love it! I just wish it lasted longer. It's def on the light side!
I bought me one❤❤❤❤love it
Oh yayyy!! ❤️
😀🙌
❤️😍
Mary I thought everlasting magic smelled cherry too. I love everlasting magic, but it doesn’t last. The body cream does help it last. I will have to go to Mercari and get sugared cherry crisp I saw it on there. Thanks for your reviews Mary! ❤❤
Thank you so much for watching! ❤️
It reminds me of a weak 3 hr later with out a touch up of sunset glow in the initial first spray must be the cherry then it dries down to your correct cherry crisp with out the crust I have all 3 and I think your spot on why not call it cherry why say berries are in it they have to have some dumb excuse for it I bet you it’s because berries sell off topic but I have to say I don’t understand the obsession with berries from BBW it is over played I think they keep doing it cause it sells and majority of people with a large collection like my self are tired of it . Or it’s cheaper to make and they know fools like my self that are looking for the new new will buy it hopeful to get a new something to only be disappointed I have no idea why I continue to come back for more only to be disappointed. As for this mist I was at first because I wanted to believe they were honest with there note descriptors was looking for a berry and came up with blackberry the sweet one not as potent though In gingham vibrant. But I watched your review pulled out all the mist you mentioned and your right it’s a freaking cherry lolol
Girl... my sniffer is a highly tuned instrument. 🤣🤣🤣 it's a gift and a curse. 😆 but ya, they def keep playing on people with these 'berry' notes. I wish they'd just create more NEW scents instead of tweaking old ones.
I literally can't smell anything with this!! Maybe a very watered down version of raspberry jam donut?? Ugh lol.
Oh no! I wonder if you got a super weak batch. That's not good!
I LOVE Sugared Cherry Crisp. I am definitely going to have to give Everlasting Magic a try. Do you think the EM cream wo mix well with the SCC mist (which I still have)? Thanks for your review!
Absolutely! Def try!
Jerry Jerry Jerry 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣💀💀 gurl u took me out 🤣🤣✊🏾 I always wanted to try sugared cherry crisp,,, so I’m have to go sniff it and see what’s up 🤣✊🏾
🤣🤣🤣 get yo sniffer on it asap!
Great review!! Would you say it smells like Enchanted Candy Potion? Hopefully BBW brings it back this year. OR I just need something similar/exactly like it!!❤️❤️❤️❤️
Noooo. Nothing like enchanted candy potion. I loved that one too!
Ill tell ya what bathandbodyworks...
Give me WICKED APPLE
In body care like ya said ya would...then ill buy Halloween body care😅
Nothing interests me
But the hand soaps!!!!!!!!😒
Omg wicked apple would be AMAZING in body care! 😍
I'll be grabbing the lotion while they're 5.50🤑
I highly recommend!
Mary, do you feel like Everlasting Magic smells like Bare Vanilla Candied? I feel like they are almost identical.
Ahhhhh....... not really to me..... but my nose can be different! Lol I pick up more cherry than anything else.
Also do you like everlasting magic better or Vampire Blood better? Thanks Mary
Ooooo......I like everlasting magic better but vampire Blood lasts longer!
B&BW often dupes itself. "In The Stars" is VERY much "Midnight Blue Citrus". The latter being much stronger. "Champaign Toast" & Sparkling Orange Spritz" r also very similar. My daughter always laughs and says "They got u again huh" 😅
Girl definitely not lol! Neither one of those smell anything alike lol
I'm gonna have to respectfully disagree doll. All four of those scents are unique to themselves.... to my sniffer anyway.
Well, u know we all interpret fragrance notes differently and that's ok 😉. I've worked in the fragrance industry a long time and always find it interesting how that happens! 😄
@broncotia3125 oh absolutely! Every nose is different. It's crazy.
@@marymakers And can change from season to season. Endlessly fascinating 👍
It’s funny you say that because I think Midnight Spell smells like a weaker version of Wild Sands. Curious to hear thoughts on that too!
Oh just you wait! That review is coming asap!
It’s cherry pipe tobacco
Now that's one I haven't heard before!
I heard that bbw is gonna start watering down all the scents so that you have to buy both perfume and lotion to layer them and make the scent strong so they make more money
That wouldn't surprise me. Grrrr.....
It seems they already do that😢
Hey Mary i just watched a youtuber compare everlasting magic to pumpkin cupcake and said they are alot alike. Lol. Ummm whhhaaattt ?? No way 😅🎃🎃🎃🎃
See.... they be lying out here in these streets. 🙄🤣🤣🤣🤣