Modern Architecture: Le Corbusier: Why the “5 Points of a New Architecture” are SCAM

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
  • Le Corbusier was a great architect. Nevertheless he produced quite some nonsense - in this video I "debunk" his "5 Points of a New Architecture”.
    Forgive me the word "debunk" and also that I might get angry about that topic in some times.
    If you are a good human, subscribe me!!
    If you are a bad human, do whatever you want.
    I am Sebastian - a German Architect and University Lecturer.
    #architecture #modernarchitecture #bauhaus
    Let me know in the comments if you have IDEAS for NEW videos

Комментарии • 21

  • @ivaylosimeonov6691
    @ivaylosimeonov6691 7 месяцев назад +4

    The narrative of roof gardens reminded me of the mirror glass gallery story in Versailles. So, as per the initial design, it used to be a huge terrace with a fountain after fashionable, at the time, Italian baroque palaces. However, it was profoundly inappropriate and practically unuseful for cold, rainy and snowy french climate. And it did not take that much long for Louis the 14th to commission an enclosure to architect Mansard which became the now famous mirror glass gallery.

    • @SebastianvonThaden
      @SebastianvonThaden  7 месяцев назад

      maybe they could build a mirror glass gallery on top of the villa savoye also ;)

  • @deralufe9094
    @deralufe9094 7 месяцев назад +2

    Le Corbusier thought: "If it looks good, it is good"
    Although most of his work did not even look good
    He is really the prime example of an architecture, nether living inside a building for more then 2 secs, he created himself.

    • @SebastianvonThaden
      @SebastianvonThaden  7 месяцев назад

      that is not correct ;) he lived inside 2/3 houses, that he built himself :)

    • @deralufe9094
      @deralufe9094 7 месяцев назад +1

      @@SebastianvonThaden than he is really insane

  • @evanhadkins5532
    @evanhadkins5532 7 месяцев назад +1

    My idea for new videos. Modern buildings you want to celebrate?

    • @evanhadkins5532
      @evanhadkins5532 7 месяцев назад +1

      How modern buildings have used traditional ideas for beautiful results.

    • @evanhadkins5532
      @evanhadkins5532 7 месяцев назад +1

      How traditional principles have been modified for new materials.

    • @SebastianvonThaden
      @SebastianvonThaden  7 месяцев назад +1

      yeah, good idea. there are plenty of "good" modern and contemporary buildings.

  • @Addi_the_Hun
    @Addi_the_Hun 7 месяцев назад +2

    idk why youtube brought me here but this is cool i guess

  • @pcatful
    @pcatful 7 месяцев назад +1

    Thank you!

  • @jakobresas3427
    @jakobresas3427 5 дней назад

    you keep saying that Le Corbusier was a great and remarkable architect.. but why? despite the fact he was good in selling his work you didn't really pointed out any bright sides of his work as an architect.. and I honestly can't see them
    yeah there are a few ideas in the monestry i might also call remarkable though definitly not asthetic or beautiful!
    I think this why I can not get the point. Houses are made for humans. Le corbusiers buildings are representing big ego without touching my heart in the aspect of beauty..

    • @jakobresas3427
      @jakobresas3427 5 дней назад

      haha the church in the end i liked most xD

    • @SebastianvonThaden
      @SebastianvonThaden  4 дня назад

      well, there are criteria why I think Le Corbusier was a great architect. I might do another video explaining why..

  • @halnineooo136
    @halnineooo136 7 месяцев назад +4

    Jericho and Jerusalem aren't in Israel. They are in the Palestinian Occupied Territories. Please don't insult the suffering of millions of Palestinians by denying their very existence. Check the United Nations websites or your country's government websites. Please correct. Thank you

    • @chriskappert1365
      @chriskappert1365 6 дней назад

      Palestine stopped in 1948 , after that it became Israel ........😮

    • @halnineooo136
      @halnineooo136 6 дней назад

      @@chriskappert1365
      It did not. These are two distinct countries. Look up the UN or your official government maps.