Indian Science: The Silent Struggle Between Research and Bureaucracy - Prof. Shobha Bhargava (4K)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 дек 2024

Комментарии • 41

  • @rattanlalbhatia
    @rattanlalbhatia 7 дней назад +1

    Very nice one of the podcast ❤❤

  • @Dr_Observer
    @Dr_Observer Месяц назад +4

    These ladies are quite right! I commend them for their serious discussion of very serious issues.
    Many of the Indian posters who comment negatively here, are not serious and frankly not very capable of intellectual assessment or analysis. They are the problem; but worse they have no solution.
    India has a long history of turning information into knowledge, but sadly this tradition appears to be distracted recently by replacing ‘outcomes’ with ‘output’. That is bureaucracy has become increasingly the ‘outcome’ rather than effectively & efficiently being the ‘output’ that leads to THE ‘outcome’. Put more simply, preparing a shopping list does not in itself lead to the eating of the meal. The plan for making the meal involves planning & timing; it is not enough making endless lists; endless visits to the market; endless washing of the pots & pans (etc. etc). At some stage the ingredients need to be prepared for cooking & cooked, all within a set time. Why can’t Indians extend this efficiency to other things in their lives? When will they stand up for their rights to expect the best outcomes in the best ways possible?

  • @tufailahmad6774
    @tufailahmad6774 Месяц назад +3

    I agreed with madam that our Indians must educated about basic causes and morality about their selfish mentality

  • @shaziayahiya4628
    @shaziayahiya4628 Месяц назад

    Omg
    This is so innovative, whether it is related with education or nature.
    Now even we can relate everything with Science.
    Basic science is related with nature...thats amazing.
    Famine mindsets or awaking all night is not good at all now it's more clear.
    Dr. Bhargava is very intelligent and Sheeba ji yours questions are too very intellectual although you are not Bhargava.
    Great going Kintu Parantu.

  • @qaziajaz2345
    @qaziajaz2345 Месяц назад +1

    Very informative 😊

  • @hemikovsky
    @hemikovsky 16 дней назад +1

    Our Best minds have always left this land because they were in the minority and did not conform to the rule of the majority! Today our brilliant scientist the PM of India has huge knowledge about everything! He knows all! And that is a national tragedy!

  • @rmzooprof
    @rmzooprof Месяц назад +1

    बहुत ही अच्छा बोला है

  • @abdulquadiransari7476
    @abdulquadiransari7476 Месяц назад +8

    Sahi kar rahe hain Bhartiya log. Jab desh me opportunity hai hi nhi to jaenge hi na.

  • @ajabsingh6778
    @ajabsingh6778 28 дней назад +1

    आयुर्वेद में रिसर्च नहीं है। दवा बनाने का तरीका वैज्ञानिक नहीं है। पहले तो सबा जी आपको बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद कि आप एक अच्छा चैनल चला रही है। नाम लाजवाब है किंतु परन्तु।

  • @Soft_boi_Hazard
    @Soft_boi_Hazard 17 дней назад +1

    Old lady smartly avoided taking names of Adani and Reliance who also need to invest lot of money in Research...

  • @venkateshbhat4131
    @venkateshbhat4131 Месяц назад +2

    Research is an area which can flourish only when government or private sector realises its importance and takes serious steps to support. Else the dreaming youngsters will end up on the street.

  • @avq512h
    @avq512h 29 дней назад +2

    Its so important to develop critical thinking, unfortunately all my colleagues in college who took Science didn't even understand fundamentals and passed on sheer regurgitating syllabus... To add to insult the Scientific academic in India is horrible and when ISRO ties nimbu mirchi to their rockets just seals the remaining asperation to practice in India.

    • @Homosapiens0804
      @Homosapiens0804 28 дней назад +2

      Although i agree with you in all aspects, let’s just not forget that those scientists are older generation of our population and nimbu mirchi is religious cultural practices which many of us grew up with so it is not easy to change cultural upbringing to become antithesis of such practices. Let’s just accept another part of psychological aspects of humans that we all are flawed in one way or another and working to be better versions of ourselves, acceptance of flaws and Coexistence with them represents high emotional intellect which is a step towards Progressive change.
      Hope it helps, all the best for future endaveours.

    • @lancerag1437
      @lancerag1437 28 дней назад +1

      ​@@Homosapiens0804 nimbu mirchi is used to check whether I was bitten by a snake or not.
      If eaten nimbu do not cause sensation of bitterness then you might be bitten by a snake.

    • @avq512h
      @avq512h 28 дней назад +2

      @@Homosapiens0804 I see the point you are making but with time mentality has to change, the interference of religious practices in scientific approach sabotages the work of dedicated scientist and advancements. Religion and its practices/rituals are personal and should be that way. Science is for all of humanity so no particular religion/tribe/cast/government gets to hijack it with its agenda.

    • @Homosapiens0804
      @Homosapiens0804 28 дней назад +1

      @@avq512h
      All your points are not only agreeable but now when i look back to my past 18 years of educational And professional life i can say that the points u mentioned were followed in professional spheres very well in a progressive manner by educational, scientific and beauraucratic facets of our society prior to 2014, Then we saw a systemic derogation of social cultural and religious fabric of our society by certain extreme political-religious belief system, what we see now is the manifestation of these negative emotions harnessed in different individuals and there need to express it outside their personal spaces, the same individuals who earlier were very well able to distinguish and separate their personal beliefs and professional beliefs. I also hope we all can come out of these and truly practice the embracement of scientific temperament which was also described in us Indian citizens Fundamental duties of constitution.

    • @Homosapiens0804
      @Homosapiens0804 28 дней назад

      @@lancerag1437
      Sorry i am not exactly able to understand, but i can sense u might be telling me the significance of nimbu mirchi as cultural practice. It’s ok i appreciate your effort.

  • @nileshchauhan3984
    @nileshchauhan3984 27 дней назад +1

    🙆🏻‍♀️💬🗨👩🏻‍🏫✨️💯‼️❕️

  • @physics9540
    @physics9540 Месяц назад +4

    मॅडम... धर्म से ही अंधश्रद्धा आती हैं... अंधश्रद्धा की वाजह से सवाल पूछ ना बंद हो जाता है....
    आप dono खुद ही confussed हैं....
    ये सब knowledge भगवान ने हि दिया हैं .... ये अच्छा खासा मजाक हैं

  • @shubhambharti4174
    @shubhambharti4174 Месяц назад +1

    Engineering aur medicine bhi science hai.

  • @ManOfSteel1
    @ManOfSteel1 25 дней назад +1

    27:20 jisne padha tha usko pata tha .aapne nahi padha isliye pata nahi

  • @somsubhro
    @somsubhro Месяц назад +1

    1:08:13 main Khud ek scientist hoon, bhagwan ne pancreas banaya 😂😂

  • @pchillar
    @pchillar Месяц назад +1

    Madam .. how we can respect scientist bkz they support .. gutter Gas theory

  • @somsubhro
    @somsubhro Месяц назад +1

    It feels as if the prof is a bit disillusioned. 1:07:05 all engineers getting jobs and 8-12 lakh package.... 😅

  • @rajeevsharma7416
    @rajeevsharma7416 Месяц назад +1

    Yehi hoga is desh me or kya hi ummid?

  • @vishnumahale5863
    @vishnumahale5863 Месяц назад +2

    I stopped watching this the moment she says "I visit Temples and Mosque, I believe in a super power"
    I think she just read the Darwin theory of evolution just to clear the exams, bring a biology specialized how can you differ with Darwin theory of evolution.
    Someone believing the theory of evolution will never ever believe in any God or any superpower.

  • @arnavsarkar3954
    @arnavsarkar3954 Месяц назад +2

    Apko agar janna hai mahin manuwad kaise kam karta hai toh inke tark sunne, adoption ke bare meh ek shabd nahi, anath bacho ki kami thodi hai, par apna vansh chhaiye hota hai har savrana ko bhale hi scientist kyu na ban jaye.ek shabd nahi ki adopt kar le IVF ki jagah.

  • @tufailahmad6774
    @tufailahmad6774 Месяц назад

    Miss sheeba aap correction Q nahi karti apne pahle jihad phoonk kaha lekin madam ne jihad phoos samjha aur apne ek bar bhi unhen correct nahi kiya ki aap jihad phoos nahi kah rahi aap jihad phoonk kah rahi hai

  • @mittu-b2y
    @mittu-b2y Месяц назад

    Not so impressive 😕

  • @shaktiraigaonkar
    @shaktiraigaonkar Месяц назад +2

    This was the most boring interview. Far from truth