Israel is NOT alone! There are many non Jews who know your history, love and appreciate you and understand that never again is now. Oct 7 changed my life, I live with a heavy heart and I will now vote only for politicians and charities that support Israel’s right to win this very just war 🤍 (And no im not a Christian, I am just an ethical agnostic human being)
This is true. But such people are not important. The best you can do is vote, and politicians will just take your vote and do what they want. The world continues to be ruled by the powerful and the corrupt. By the money from Qatar.
@@Kurtlane But the world can be changed, as we have seen throughout history. And if we give up before we even start trying, then we’re doomed. We can try and we should try to change things.
Forgive me🤔I'm not sure I understand your point.....however I'd be in much debt in you'd encourage folk to learn about Holodomor (ww2/mainstream elbow) Oh yeah.....Blue&white have been kicked out of over 100+ countries throughout history🤔🇬🇧 expelled (way back)
In various regions across the globe, a significant number of individuals express their solidarity with Israel. Here, in Uganda, an overwhelming 85% of the population is Christian and aligns with and supports Israel. It is our fervent hope and wish for the protection of Israel from any malevolent forces. God bless Israel 🎉
Dear Messrs Tobin and Levy, thank you, thank you, for this conversation, in which could be sensed great insight and mutual respect, and occasionally something more beautiful than that… Real hope, and real realistic hope… it is so great to have the privilege of following this. I pray for the total victory of the israeli people which we all feel the world cannot do without.
Exactly like Taliban is terro-rists organization Trump should not sign peace with them in Qatar then this left biden too who left lots of US weapons for the Taliban both those presidents r stupid fr
Yes Marcello. Whomever ousted Mossadegh, is probably still running the show. Ronald Regan signed a Concordia. P2 and the New World Order. Father Bernhardt Stempfle is who wrote Mein Kampf. Iran has ballistic missiles with American parts, Israel doesn't.
I’m sorry….I don’t agree with this French guy I was a liberal too…… and after October 7 2023 you can NEVER convince me that a 2 state solution could ever work.
Arab muslims rejected two state solution 5 times and chose war instead. Why anyone still talks about 2states could only be explained by willful stupidity.
Yeah💯......the speedo trinity (unholy) Catholic Jewish & the Causasians.....unfortunately it can't be "many people" the Europeans are the world's minority ppl or amounts to (minus Russia 🇷🇺) 13% the global North & even though onwards (without fail) 1776 the west have sought to decimate indigenous people global south folk💪are journeying the right way.....can we agree "not many" few traffic with blue&white
Agreeing in prayer with Asaph, in Psalm 83! Clapping my hands in Praise for Psalm 2, which is being fulfilled! Happy with Isaiah, Jeremiah, Joel, Amos, Habbakak, Ezekiel, David and Zechariah! The LORD’S Word never fails!! AMEN!❤🇮🇱🙏⚡️
The French philosopher forgets to mention a third group that has to be defeated and that's the PA, which is a terrorist entity as well and which also wants Israel of the map.
@@brentdubecalgary5084 Arafat invented a fictitious people and a non existent country to justify his hatred of Israel. Arafat, like so many 'Palestinians', was Egyptian.
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban is correct in saying that Trump must be re-elected. As Caesar opined, “It is better to be feared than to be loved.” As Reagan was fond of repeating, “Peace through strength.” I do not understand American Jews who would vote for Harris.
Those american citizens who will vote for Kamala Harris and the democratic party, even they don't understand themselves. They actually vote against their country 's interest.
@@OhioVworld you are right. But I’m a Canadian and I did vote for Trudeau. Big mistake! I don’t have children but I am speaking for the parents. If I was an American I’d vote for Trump.
@@wendycool8934 Jesus, how do you vote for Trudeau?? Like, what is going through your head when you do that? Not bashing, but how do they brainwash you guys so completely?
@@OhioVworld well, I wouldn’t vote for him again. Justin’s father was very persuasive. He was urban, cultured, and highly educated. His foreign policy stank. Our choice was the conservative Harper or Justin. Big mistake. That’s how it happened for me and the majority.
@@wendycool8934I worry about Canada now. It seems to be becoming a colony of the Chinese Communist Party. 😰 And increasingly dangerous for Jews. Stay safe and stay free, Wendy!
In the Middle East, the old saying "First comes Saturday, then comes Sunday" is not a benign observation regarding the calendar system, but a chilling warning that after wiping out the Jews (who pray on Saturday), the Muslims will come for the Christians (who pray on Sunday).
Christians do not observe the Sabbath. They have made Monday the first day and Sunday their Sabbath. Only the Jews observe the 7th day for thousands of years before and after Christianity
@@LeeGee no bible says its saturday if it was on sunday why did constatine pass a law to change it to sunday unless you were a farm labour those who change the law of god is a pagan not a christan want more proof why was the title of constatine high priest of pagan religion
Bernard Henri Levi is completely engrossing .So glad to hv heard this interview. I'm happy , as well, to hear someone who, like me, supports both Israel & Ukraine. So many support 1 or the other. ✝️✡🇭🇲🇮🇱🇺🇦✝️✡🇭🇲🇮🇱🇺🇦
@@Seekthetruth3000 Ex-Muslims are usually very committed believers in Christ. They have been in very thick darkness, when they come into the light, of the gospel, their light shines very brightly.
@nadinenadine9739 The situation is not a dichotomy. Dichotomy is the thinking usually of someone new to thinking for oneself. I applaud you for thinking but, please, do go further. It is not one either supports Israel or Islaam. There are many views within the Arab camp for example, one of which is support for an enlightened pro-democracy and modern economics view. Another way of thinking about this is one of righteousness. What would lead to a good life for all people's in this conflict. The Islamic view generally pro-genocide. October 7th was part of that pro-genocide plan. I doubt you are on the side of genocide which is the aim of Hamas, Hizbolah, the Iranian regime, etc. I do not know why you are not on Israel's side. I won't debate that with you here but I think you are making a mistake by thinking I either support Israel or Islam. An example, seemingly absurd, is that after WW I the West imposed harsh conditions on Germany. The conditions helped destroy German democracy. Now just because I opposed those conditions does not mean I should support Hitler. That is there can be more than two solutions towards a problem.
There will be a one state solution when Israel takes into possession the inheritance promised to Abrahaam, Isaac, Jacov, the kingdom over which your king David and Soloman ruled.
Great interview! We made Aliyah over 7 months ago. We have seen rockets here Afula, with no damage, thank G-d, and were there for the recent barrage in Jerusalem. As scary as this sounds, there is such a feeling of unity. Hashem is with us! We are home!
Lévy loses it towards the end of this interview. There are entirely too many “ifs”. The capitulation he hopes for will never come. The two-state “solution” is a pipe dream. Hard-headed realism and not misplaced optimism is the need of the hour. It would be great to have Caroline Glick weigh in on some of the things Lévy said in this interview.
Caroline Glick is a rational thinker. She reminds me of Golda Meir. Maybe it is the combination of her Midwestern roots and the high Ashkenazi IQ. At any rate, Caroline Glick could make a great Israeli priminister.
There is a misunderstanding here. Paul in Romans chapters 9-11 says that we, who believe in Jesus, are grafted into the olive tree, which is Israel. That's why they stand with Israel, because they have become part of it.
You were grafted in to Christ Matthew tells us that Jesus fulfills Hosea 11 (Matt. 2:13-15). He is the true Israel, the faithful Israel who succeeds where old covenant Israel failed; . Christ is Israel. If you are in Christ, you are a new creature.. Galatians 6:16 says that those who believe in Jesus Christ are the true Israel of God, regardless of their ethnic origin
Paul calls the church "the Israel of God" (Galatians 6:16). I Peter 1:13-16 shows very clearly that Christians, spiritual Israelites, now have a responsibility to be holy as God is. It’s a spiritual thing. It’s not a earthly thing. Jesus said his kingdom was not of this world if you love the Jewish people, then preach the gospel to them to put their faith in Jesus Christ.
I totally disagree with proselytising. Leave everybody in peace to practise the religion of their choice, as long as it does not inspire and promote evil actions. I stand with Israel and Jews everywhere, because I believe they are in the right.
But why decide just based on this? Can you not discern that the terrorists are evil? Is this not enough? And do you not realize that they will come for the Christians next?
Thank you for this so much informative discussion. As a Christian I agree with you 💯 this is evil against good. 🇮🇱 IS GOD'S LAND GIVEN TO IS PEOPLE THE JEWS .AND NO ONE WILL MOVE THEM FROM GOD'S PROMESSE.🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💙💙 ISRAEL IS NOT ALONE GOD KEEPS IS PROMESSES PSALM 121 praying 🙏🏻 Standing with My LORD JESUS LAND AND ITS PEOPLE 🙏🏻💙🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱 from SOUTH AFRICA 🇿🇦
A wonderful discussion. Thank you. I have some more ideas and information to counter those around me. I'm so appalled at what our youth think. They seem to know nothing. But I now know this is what they've been taught.
Education begins at home, I think one can blame the teachers and professors only so much. Today's youth lacks critical thinking in general, and it makes you wonder just how they were brought up, no sense of right and wrong.
@Catssandra13 I agree with you. Our family often discusses and debate issues with our children. It's really wonderful. I wish more young people were doing this
The hope we all had when we agreed to giving the PALASTINIANS Gaza was that with the vast investment that it attracted in time trade and trust would grow in leaps and bounds and the right basis for a two state solution not forever in war would be a fact. I dumbly believed in that vision and regret that belief now!
are your family from europe or arab jew ive listened to a canadian lebbon jew who speaks french hebrew and arabric he says they knew the arabs would never want peace
We underestimated the power and enduring appeal of hate when mandated and celebrated by one’s religion. Compared to Paradise and what is “right,” material wealth means nothing.
@@TrustMe55 Thanks to all good Christians for your support of Israel. But we Jewish Israelis do not want to be "saved", and do not want to hear your gospel. With all due respect for your religious beliefs, please have some respect for ours too.
I am a Christian and stand 💯 % with Israel and the Jewish people. Jesus was Jewish and He lives in my heart. His teaching has so many reference to the Old Testament. Israel is God's chosen land and people for ever.
I agree mostly with this gentleman. Yet his apparent respect for Biden and Harris speaks volumes about his lack of understanding of those two being bad actors against the country these purport to represent.
I don't believe that Biden or Harris are evil people. What I do believe is that many of their policies have been disastrous for America. Trump is a vulgar person and also a petulant child and a liar. Unfortunately, he WILL get my vote in November because electing Harris as President would be catastrophic. It's not that Trump is terrific, it's just that the alternative is unthinkable.
Blessings. Catholics believe in replacement theology which is the wrong standing with the Jewish truth according to the Torah. God has NOT forgotten you, will never cut you off, He will keep his promises with Israel forever. We born again Christians are grateful that God grafted us gentiles for a time, but later he will continue His work with His people the Jews. We Christians are also grateful that we received the Torah, the Messiah so our love to pray for Israel is poured in our hearts by HaShem Himself. Praying for the salvation of Israel and the peace of Jerusalem
There are not two gospels there’s one gospel one Christ for all people the clearly speaks now is the day of salvation. Don’t put it off till tomorrow telling the Jewish people they can wait till the Messiah comes the biggest anti Semitism there is.
And it’s not a replacement theology the Old Testament people looked forward to the Messiah and they were saved by their faith by trusting in Christ to come New Testament Christians look back and put their faith in Christ. There’s no replacement theology. It’s been the same since the beginning of time. and I’m not a Catholic.
I'm a Catholic who has no idea what the term "replacement theology" means, so I can hardly believe in it. I don't think you should make such sweeping statements. I believe that as Christians we should stick together rather than bicker among different denominations.
Replacement Theology is not just a Catholic thing, it’s actually pervasive across the Protestant community. If the church you’re attending never discusses Israel and Bible prophecy, then your church ascribes to Replacement Theology. Some 27-33 percent of the entire Bible is on prophecy and its fulfillment. Again, if your church isn’t teaching Bible prophecy, then not only are you not being fully edified, you’re only being taught 3/4 of the Bible. Christ himself tells us not to ignore prophecy and those who believe and read about prophecy are blessed in His eyes. Replacement Theology simply means that most Christians (incorrectly) believe and are taught without some even realizing it, that the Church has replaced Israel and that God has broken his everlasting covenant with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Obviously, God has not or never will forget His chosen people, as prophecy was fulfilled on May 14, 1948 with the regathering of the Jewish people to Israel (Ezekiel 34-36). Let’s get back to why they were initially chosen, and that’s because the Father’s plan from the beginning was to offer salvation to both the Jews and the Gentiles. The Bible literally tells us that the God would make the Jews in that initial time jealous and envious by offering salvation to the Gentiles.. In order to understand what is actually going on up through today, one has to grasp the 70 Weeks of Daniel (Daniel 9:27-29) as that’s the foundation of God giving a ‘time out’ so to speak to the Jews. We, believers in Christ of the Church Age are literally between the 69th and 70th week. The Book of Revelation is the culmination of Daniel’s 70 Week prophecy told through him by God the Father. The 70th week of Daniel is the upcoming 7-year Tribulation period when Jesus Christ himself opens the (7) Seals, which then comes the (7) Trumpets, and finally the (7) Bowls. All which are God’s wrath to both punish the world for its sheer evil, but more importantly to bring the Jews of Israel to belief that Jesus Christ has been and always will be their true Messiah.
I am an Evangelical Christian, and I can tell you that my love for the Jews has nothing to do with what this wonderful guests ideas are. I love the Jewish people because they are God’s chosen people, the apple of His eye. When you love God, you love what He loves. He has plans for the Jewish people and the land of Israel, yes. But my love for them has nothing to do with God’s future plans. It has everything to do with my love for God. And my beliefs represent hundreds of thousands of Christians.
~48:00 “Who would have guessed that the 2005 withdrawal from Gaza would lead to October 7?” Says Bernard-Levy. Answer: Netanyahu! Perhaps that’s the reason he hates him. Then he goes into a delusion of how the Palestinians could come to love and accept Israel and Jews “very quickly”. Dream on, dude!
Jonathan might invite President Trump’s ambassador to Israel, David Friedman. Donald Trump’s ambassador to Israel was David M. Friedman. He served from 2017 to 2021 and was a key figure in shaping U.S. policy toward Israel during Trump’s presidency. Friedman was known for his strong pro-Israel stance and was instrumental in the administration’s decision to move the U.S. embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, a significant and controversial shift in U.S. foreign policy. His tenure also saw the signing of the Abraham Accords, normalizing relations between Israel and several Arab nations.
I jumped the gun and ordered the book early on, before following the entire conversation. Fortunately, I was able to cancel the order after the conversation started going downhill. So many points I disagree on, which I won't go into! I will say this, however, I feel he speaks as someone that is judging a culture based on Western mentality, and I think that is a big mistake. I'm expressing my personal opinion when I say that a two state solution or even a one state that absorbs Palestinians into the society will prove to be a grave mistake on many levels. (ETA: Douglas Murray's books I think would be a very useful read, along with certain topics discussed in Benjamin Netanyahu's book)
Jonathan. I lived among evangelicals 23 years. They were wonderful to me. I miss them. You are correct about them. I rarely disagree with HBL, but on this I do. They beat New Englanders in very critical ways. None of the disasters that keep befalling this Jew in a veritable desert would have happened in NC. And, HBL is wrong about the Germans post WWII. I met a lot in NC during the '90s. And the Midwest in the late '60s. The US spent Megabucks on denazification. Cher Henri, il n'a pas raison.
I saw this all coming even in thd early and mid 1990s. But even i am shocked how bad things have gotten and how quickly in the west. I think some very tough times are ahead very soon.
1. Self-defense is not "a right" to be granted or rescinded. It is a categorical, moral imperative, a sacred duty, an obligation. 2. Btw, great intro graphics. I approve. ;) 3. I have a dear Christian friend, a sort of 'born again' type, he had an epiphany quite a while back. He told me that he believes that Christians "need" the "son" to connect with the "father," but Jews do not.
Israel alone is an interesting statement. Firstly, God is always with Israel. Secondly, I'd reverse it to Only Israel. Only Israel has to shine its light onto the world that is turning into darkness and reverse it.
42:00 Most Evangelical Christians do not go to “mega churches” anyways, and there are many staunchly pro-Jewish Christians who belong to other denominations. The alleged theological reasons for their support for Israel are much, much overblown. I see good people who simply support the Jews and see right from wrong. I love them for it.
It is possible to deradicalise, both Gaza and the West Bank, but only if the world stops shipping aid to them. There is not enough resources (human and natural) to support millions who live there now. Stop the world aid and stop Israel giving them jobs. As a result most younger people will leave for greener pastures elsewhere. The old do not reproduce and equally importantly, they are not likely to cause future intefadas.
Great show. But I do think Bernard -Henri Levy, as brilliant as he is, is unrealistically optimistic about the possibility of a two state solution in the foreseeable future, if not ever. Putting a state in Israel's heartland would be suicidal. He is on target about Iran's aspirations. I don't know why he thinks the Palestinians are less intent on Israel's annihilation if they had the means to do it.
Israel has non Jewish allies . I’m saying here that one day while working , a coworker while getting ready for his break , was whistling your Nacional Anthem. I did approached him showing my wrist band in support of Israel 🇮🇱. He’s not Jewish either but he cannot stand all duality against Israel. He’s a veteran. Am Israel Chai 🇮🇱💙
I often listen to BHL in French and can testify that this is one of his best interviews. He truly spoke from the heart with the enlightenment of reason.
I saw some of the sadistic atrocities committed by individuals on human beings on that very sad day on YT. That there are some people that stand for those criminals is pure madness.
Literally, same old story of Amalek against the Jews. They always come back in different forms and disappear into history while Jews carry on. The people of eternity 🇮🇱 ♥️
" Every point in this war, from the point of contact on the border between occupied Palestine and Lebanon to the Litani River at least, every point there, every hill, every village, every house, and every region was a front line and a cover, and this cover was not a tangible, known cover, as is common in wars such as those that were. In our war, no, there was a special tactic. If I wanted an analogy, I would liken all of this tactic adopted by Hezbollah to a vast, clever minefield in which there is no safe empty point. Therefore, observe the enemy’s method of movement and you will see that the enemy was unable to enter some of the villages adjacent to the border, such as Aita al-Shaab, and was unable and unable to enter these villages. He was unable to enter the cities, and therefore he decided to go from the eastern valley to enter and advance towards the Litani, and that was in fact the enemy’s weak point and defeat" - The full text of the interview with Major General Qassem Soleimani, in which he narrated some of the events of the July War
Jonathan, on the eve of Erev Yom Kippur, I cannot think of 2 other people I would rather hear. I wish I had been 1 of the Jews shocked on Oct 7. Amelek had been back and planning in the open for years. I so wish I were otherwise. Did you see live reports from Boston last night?
It is the hand of G-d that the P's hearts are hard against the 2-state situation. No man has the authority to do anything with the land given to the tribes by G-d.
They have just done the same thing that they have done and Gaza And the Palestinian authority and the international community have given billions and billions of dollars to these criminals
BHL has an hand in the problems that the French jews are facing. He pushed for the removal of kafafi in libya and after that millions of Muslims immigrants moved to Europe and France.
I stand with Israel!🌹
Same here!
Ditto from USA!
I sit with israel.
It is an apartheid state like S Afrika (once upon a time).
James2:17-26...
Israel is NOT alone! There are many non Jews who know your history, love and appreciate you and understand that never again is now. Oct 7 changed my life, I live with a heavy heart and I will now vote only for politicians and charities that support Israel’s right to win this very just war 🤍
(And no im not a Christian, I am just an ethical agnostic human being)
This is true. But such people are not important. The best you can do is vote, and politicians will just take your vote and do what they want.
The world continues to be ruled by the powerful and the corrupt. By the money from Qatar.
@@Kurtlane But the world can be changed, as we have seen throughout history. And if we give up before we even start trying, then we’re doomed. We can try and we should try to change things.
Sure
All Evangelicals are welcomed to travel there with their Bibles.
Just avoid the Orthodox and Radical Settlers
They will spit on you
Same here! 😊 🇮🇱👍🙂🙌 🇮🇱 ❤️🔥
Forgive me🤔I'm not sure I understand your point.....however I'd be in much debt in you'd encourage folk to learn about Holodomor (ww2/mainstream elbow)
Oh yeah.....Blue&white have been kicked out of over 100+ countries throughout history🤔🇬🇧 expelled (way back)
In various regions across the globe, a significant number of individuals express their solidarity with Israel. Here, in Uganda, an overwhelming 85% of the population is Christian and aligns with and supports Israel. It is our fervent hope and wish for the protection of Israel from any malevolent forces. God bless Israel 🎉
Dear Messrs Tobin and Levy, thank you, thank you, for this conversation, in which could be sensed great insight and mutual respect, and occasionally something more beautiful than that… Real hope, and real realistic hope… it is so great to have the privilege of following this. I pray for the total victory of the israeli people which we all feel the world cannot do without.
I am with you Israel. Many of us are aware of the reality it’s going through. Never ever again must that happen.
Glad to see you back at the desk Jon. Hope you continue to make progress and return to full health.
Thank you for sharing your conversation with Bernard-Henri Lévy. It’s such a privilege to listen to such an insightful discussion
Ronald Regan said it was not possible to make any deal with terrorists.
Exactly like Taliban is terro-rists organization Trump should not sign peace with them in Qatar then this left biden too who left lots of US weapons for the Taliban both those presidents r stupid fr
It's like giving in to a blackmailer: in fact terrorism is blackmail.
Does the name “Oliver North” ring a bell?
Yes Marcello. Whomever ousted Mossadegh, is probably still running the show. Ronald Regan signed a Concordia. P2 and the New World Order. Father Bernhardt Stempfle is who wrote Mein Kampf. Iran has ballistic missiles with American parts, Israel doesn't.
Iran contra comes to mind because he did .
I’m sorry….I don’t agree with this French guy
I was a liberal too…… and after October 7 2023 you can NEVER convince me that a 2 state solution could ever work.
if arab paleistians werent muslum there would be peace
Exactly
was never going to happen
Arab muslims rejected two state solution 5 times and chose war instead. Why anyone still talks about 2states could only be explained by willful stupidity.
How about a NO STATE SOLUTION
Many people stand with Israel and love the Jewish people.
Yeah💯......the speedo trinity (unholy) Catholic Jewish & the Causasians.....unfortunately it can't be "many people" the Europeans are the world's minority ppl or amounts to (minus Russia 🇷🇺) 13% the global North & even though onwards (without fail) 1776 the west have sought to decimate indigenous people global south folk💪are journeying the right way.....can we agree "not many" few traffic with blue&white
Thanks, what a wonderful discussion.
The bottom line is this is a difference between evil and good and evil can never compromise with Good and good can never compromise with evil. Period.
Killing innocent children, is that good or evil?
I agree with Jonathan in the point he makes about Evangelical support for Israel. We should be thankful for Evangelical support.
Agreeing in prayer with Asaph, in Psalm 83!
Clapping my hands in Praise for Psalm 2, which is being fulfilled!
Happy with Isaiah, Jeremiah, Joel, Amos, Habbakak, Ezekiel, David and Zechariah!
The LORD’S Word never fails!! AMEN!❤🇮🇱🙏⚡️
The French philosopher forgets to mention a third group that has to be defeated and that's the PA, which is a terrorist entity as well and which also wants Israel of the map.
YUP!!! TRUE.
Agreed.
yes they are PLO
bullshit
@@brentdubecalgary5084 Arafat invented a fictitious people and a non existent country to justify his hatred of Israel. Arafat, like so many 'Palestinians', was Egyptian.
Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban is correct in saying that Trump must be re-elected. As Caesar opined, “It is better to be feared than to be loved.” As Reagan was fond of repeating, “Peace through strength.” I do not understand American Jews who would vote for Harris.
Those american citizens who will vote for Kamala Harris and the democratic party, even they don't understand themselves. They actually vote against their country 's interest.
Mr. Lévy is a brilliant man. Thank you Jonathan for interviewing him.
This can’t be real! What did we do to raise such horrible immoral children?
So misguided. So heartless. Yes, an age of madness ‼️🇨🇦❤️🇮🇱
You voted D.
@@OhioVworld you are right. But I’m a Canadian and I did vote for Trudeau. Big mistake! I don’t have children but I am speaking for the parents. If I was an American I’d vote for Trump.
@@wendycool8934 Jesus, how do you vote for Trudeau??
Like, what is going through your head when you do that?
Not bashing, but how do they brainwash you guys so completely?
@@OhioVworld well, I wouldn’t vote for him again. Justin’s father was very persuasive. He was urban, cultured, and highly educated. His foreign policy stank. Our choice was the conservative Harper or Justin. Big mistake. That’s how it happened for me and the majority.
@@wendycool8934I worry about Canada now. It seems to be becoming a colony of the Chinese Communist Party. 😰 And increasingly dangerous for Jews. Stay safe and stay free, Wendy!
Thank you, Jonathan, for this wonderful interview. Very interesting thoughts.
Am Yisrael Chai ❤️
In the Middle East, the old saying "First comes Saturday, then comes Sunday" is not a benign observation regarding the calendar system, but a chilling warning that after wiping out the Jews (who pray on Saturday), the Muslims will come for the Christians (who pray on Sunday).
Yes you sound truthful
💯%!! The Truth of the saying is it IS the plan.
christans pray on saturday pagans pray on sunday because thats the day to pray to mirtha the sun god
Christians do not observe the Sabbath. They have made Monday the first day and Sunday their Sabbath. Only the Jews observe the 7th day for thousands of years before and after Christianity
@@LeeGee no bible says its saturday if it was on sunday why did constatine pass a law to change it to sunday unless you were a farm labour
those who change the law of god is a pagan not a christan want more proof why was the title of constatine high priest of pagan religion
Bernard Henri Levi is completely engrossing .So glad to hv heard this interview. I'm happy , as well, to hear someone who, like me, supports both Israel & Ukraine. So many support 1 or the other.
✝️✡🇭🇲🇮🇱🇺🇦✝️✡🇭🇲🇮🇱🇺🇦
Evangelicals should be praised for their support of lsrael. As a Jewish conservative, l am thankful to them.
A lot of ex-Muslims support Israel too.
We know what the Jews and Isreal represents, that is why we support them. We believe everything written in the Tanakh about God and His chosen.
@@Seekthetruth3000
Ex-Muslims are usually very committed believers in Christ. They have been in very thick darkness, when they come into the light, of the gospel, their light shines very brightly.
@@Seekthetruth3000… ı am jew and ı support 🇵🇸!
@nadinenadine9739 The situation is not a dichotomy. Dichotomy is the thinking usually of someone new to thinking for oneself. I applaud you for thinking but, please, do go further. It is not one either supports Israel or Islaam. There are many views within the Arab camp for example, one of which is support for an enlightened pro-democracy and modern economics view.
Another way of thinking about this is one of righteousness. What would lead to a good life for all people's in this conflict. The Islamic view generally pro-genocide. October 7th was part of that pro-genocide plan.
I doubt you are on the side of genocide which is the aim of Hamas, Hizbolah, the Iranian regime, etc.
I do not know why you are not on Israel's side. I won't debate that with you here but I think you are making a mistake by thinking I either support Israel or Islam.
An example, seemingly absurd, is that after WW I the West imposed harsh conditions on Germany. The conditions helped destroy German democracy. Now just because I opposed those conditions does not mean I should support Hitler. That is there can be more than two solutions towards a problem.
There will be a one state solution when Israel takes into possession the inheritance promised to Abrahaam, Isaac, Jacov, the kingdom over which your king David and Soloman ruled.
Great interview! We made Aliyah over 7 months ago. We have seen rockets here Afula, with no damage, thank G-d, and were there for the recent barrage in Jerusalem. As scary as this sounds, there is such a feeling of unity. Hashem is with us! We are home!
Thank you Danki31 you are more than some Christians. Maybe your comments will open thier eyes. (I'm a Canadian Christian for Israel)v
There are many left politicians in Israel who were following the US. If they would have been the leaders it would have been dramatic for Israel.
In addition to the left in Israel, there are left Jews in America. They are so stubborn in their leftism, that is the only thing they care about.
Thank you both so very much for your time and efforts.
Lévy loses it towards the end of this interview. There are entirely too many “ifs”. The capitulation he hopes for will never come. The two-state “solution” is a pipe dream. Hard-headed realism and not misplaced optimism is the need of the hour. It would be great to have Caroline Glick weigh in on some of the things Lévy said in this interview.
Caroline Glick is a rational thinker. She reminds me of Golda Meir. Maybe it is the combination of her Midwestern roots and the high Ashkenazi IQ. At any rate, Caroline Glick could make a great Israeli priminister.
@@Sara-k6y4h Perfect!
I stand with Israel. ❤ from the UK. 🙏 for the peace of Jerusalem. 🇮🇱🎗
There is a misunderstanding here.
Paul in Romans chapters 9-11 says that we, who believe in Jesus, are grafted into the olive tree, which is Israel. That's why they stand with Israel, because they have become part of it.
You were grafted in to Christ Matthew tells us that Jesus fulfills Hosea 11 (Matt. 2:13-15). He is the true Israel, the faithful Israel who succeeds where old covenant Israel failed; . Christ is Israel. If you are in Christ, you are a new creature..
Galatians 6:16 says that those who believe in Jesus Christ are the true Israel of God, regardless of their ethnic origin
You have not learned to rightly divide the word of God.
Paul calls the church "the Israel of God" (Galatians 6:16). I Peter 1:13-16 shows very clearly that Christians, spiritual Israelites, now have a responsibility to be holy as God is. It’s a spiritual thing. It’s not a earthly thing. Jesus said his kingdom was not of this world if you love the Jewish people, then preach the gospel to them to put their faith in Jesus Christ.
I totally disagree with proselytising. Leave everybody in peace to practise the religion of their choice, as long as it does not inspire and promote evil actions. I stand with Israel and Jews everywhere, because I believe they are in the right.
But why decide just based on this? Can you not discern that the terrorists are evil? Is this not enough? And do you not realize that they will come for the Christians next?
Evangelical religiously bound and love supporting Israel and our elder brothers the Jews.
Thank you for this so much informative discussion. As a Christian I agree with you 💯 this is evil against good. 🇮🇱 IS GOD'S LAND GIVEN TO IS PEOPLE THE JEWS .AND NO ONE WILL MOVE THEM FROM GOD'S PROMESSE.🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💙💙
ISRAEL IS NOT ALONE GOD KEEPS IS PROMESSES PSALM 121 praying 🙏🏻 Standing with My LORD JESUS LAND AND ITS PEOPLE 🙏🏻💙🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱 from SOUTH AFRICA 🇿🇦
I think the fact that France is now about 20% Muslim is a major factor.
@@Kurtlane I believe the percentage is much higher 😢
A wonderful discussion. Thank you. I have some more ideas and information to counter those around me. I'm so appalled at what our youth think. They seem to know nothing. But I now know this is what they've been taught.
Education begins at home, I think one can blame the teachers and professors only so much. Today's youth lacks critical thinking in general, and it makes you wonder just how they were brought up, no sense of right and wrong.
@Catssandra13 I agree with you. Our family often discusses and debate issues with our children. It's really wonderful. I wish more young people were doing this
My Father always encouraged us to discuss all types of topics at the dinner table. God bless him for that!!🕯️🌌💙🤍🦁🕊️
@lorenheard2561 we do that too. Usually, after dinner discussions . We love it, and the kids love it too. Everyone gets to voice and discuss ideas.
Young people lack critical thinking ability. Never mind the brain washing.
The hope we all had when we agreed to giving the PALASTINIANS Gaza was that with the vast investment that it attracted in time trade and trust would grow in leaps and bounds and the right basis for a two state solution not forever in war would be a fact. I dumbly believed in that vision and regret that belief now!
are your family from europe or arab jew
ive listened to a canadian lebbon jew who speaks french hebrew and arabric he says they knew the arabs would never want peace
We underestimated the power and enduring appeal of hate when mandated and celebrated by one’s religion. Compared to Paradise and what is “right,” material wealth means nothing.
@@edoboleyn
Do stop repeating your word salad otherwise I will know you are a bot!
We stand with Israel forever ♾
Well said 🇮🇱✡️🇮🇱👍,love you and your wisdom ,the truth cannot be denied….
My late husband was always saying that " the British were the biggest culprit in Jewish history of the 20th century". 💥
I love Israel because they are the people of God. The apple of His eye.
Then preach the gospel to them Believe in the Lord Jesus Christ, and you will be saved.
@@TrustMe55 Thanks to all good Christians for your support of Israel.
But we Jewish Israelis do not want to be "saved", and do not want to hear your gospel.
With all due respect for your religious beliefs, please have some respect for ours too.
I am a Christian and stand 💯 % with Israel and the Jewish people. Jesus was Jewish and He lives in my heart. His teaching has so many reference to the Old Testament. Israel is God's chosen land and people for ever.
I found that Jonathan has better and healthier skepticism than Mr Levy for survival reasons.
I agree mostly with this gentleman. Yet his apparent respect for Biden and Harris speaks volumes about his lack of understanding of those two being bad actors against the country these purport to represent.
I don't believe that Biden or Harris are evil people. What I do believe is that many of their policies have been disastrous for America. Trump is a vulgar person and also a petulant child and a liar. Unfortunately, he WILL get my vote in November because electing Harris as President would be catastrophic. It's not that Trump is terrific, it's just that the alternative is unthinkable.
I'm American, and I love Israel. How can I help? What can I do to help Israel? I'm genuinely interested in what I can do to help the people of Israel?
Speaking out against the propaganda is a massive help!
shame on UK allowing its own replacement and giving place to science as the one who signs , shame
Blessings. Catholics believe in replacement theology which is the wrong standing with the Jewish truth according to the Torah. God has NOT forgotten you, will never cut you off, He will keep his promises with Israel forever. We born again Christians are grateful that God grafted us gentiles for a time, but later he will continue His work with His people the Jews. We Christians are also grateful that we received the Torah, the Messiah so our love to pray for Israel is poured in our hearts by HaShem Himself. Praying for the salvation of Israel and the peace of Jerusalem
There are not two gospels there’s one gospel one Christ for all people the clearly speaks now is the day of salvation. Don’t put it off till tomorrow telling the Jewish people they can wait till the Messiah comes the biggest anti Semitism there is.
And it’s not a replacement theology the Old Testament people looked forward to the Messiah and they were saved by their faith by trusting in Christ to come New Testament Christians look back and put their faith in Christ. There’s no replacement theology. It’s been the same since the beginning of time. and I’m not a Catholic.
❤ Amen.
Blessings and Shalom.
I'm a Catholic who has no idea what the term "replacement theology" means, so I can hardly believe in it. I don't think you should make such sweeping statements. I believe that as Christians we should stick together rather than bicker among different denominations.
Replacement Theology is not just a Catholic thing, it’s actually pervasive across the Protestant community. If the church you’re attending never discusses Israel and Bible prophecy, then your church ascribes to Replacement Theology.
Some 27-33 percent of the entire Bible is on prophecy and its fulfillment. Again, if your church isn’t teaching Bible prophecy, then not only are you not being fully edified, you’re only being taught 3/4 of the Bible. Christ himself tells us not to ignore prophecy and those who believe and read about prophecy are blessed in His eyes.
Replacement Theology simply means that most Christians (incorrectly) believe and are taught without some even realizing it, that the Church has replaced Israel and that God has broken his everlasting covenant with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.
Obviously, God has not or never will forget His chosen people, as prophecy was fulfilled on May 14, 1948 with the regathering of the Jewish people to Israel (Ezekiel 34-36). Let’s get back to why they were initially chosen, and that’s because the Father’s plan from the beginning was to offer salvation to both the Jews and the Gentiles.
The Bible literally tells us that the God would make the Jews in that initial time jealous and envious by offering salvation to the Gentiles..
In order to understand what is actually going on up through today, one has to grasp the 70 Weeks of Daniel (Daniel 9:27-29) as that’s the foundation of God giving a ‘time out’ so to speak to the Jews. We, believers in Christ of the Church Age are literally between the 69th and 70th week. The Book of Revelation is the culmination of Daniel’s 70 Week prophecy told through him by God the Father.
The 70th week of Daniel is the upcoming 7-year Tribulation period when Jesus Christ himself opens the (7) Seals, which then comes the (7) Trumpets, and finally the (7) Bowls. All which are God’s wrath to both punish the world for its sheer evil, but more importantly to bring the Jews of Israel to belief that Jesus Christ has been and always will be their true Messiah.
I stand with Israel 🌼
So interesting. Thank you
Thank you prof'bernard henry levy
Shana tova🎉🙌
I hope you make a full recovery Jonathan
He compared Germany with Palestinians Arabs. That's again the same mistake he did when he was on the side of removing Jews from Gaza...
I am an Evangelical Christian, and I can tell you that my love for the Jews has nothing to do with what this wonderful guests ideas are. I love the Jewish people because they are God’s chosen people, the apple of His eye. When you love God, you love what He loves. He has plans for the Jewish people and the land of Israel, yes. But my love for them has nothing to do with God’s future plans. It has everything to do with my love for God. And my beliefs represent hundreds of thousands of Christians.
~48:00 “Who would have guessed that the 2005 withdrawal from Gaza would lead to October 7?” Says Bernard-Levy.
Answer: Netanyahu! Perhaps that’s the reason he hates him.
Then he goes into a delusion of how the Palestinians could come to love and accept Israel and Jews “very quickly”. Dream on, dude!
Jordan was the designated Palestinian country. Jordan was carved out of Israel.
Jonathan might invite President Trump’s ambassador to Israel, David Friedman.
Donald Trump’s ambassador to Israel was David M. Friedman. He served from 2017 to 2021 and was a key figure in shaping U.S. policy toward Israel during Trump’s presidency. Friedman was known for his strong pro-Israel stance and was instrumental in the administration’s decision to move the U.S. embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, a significant and controversial shift in U.S. foreign policy. His tenure also saw the signing of the Abraham Accords, normalizing relations between Israel and several Arab nations.
Thank you.
Henri is an erudite liberal that cannot escape his biases. Great show Jonathan as usual.
I jumped the gun and ordered the book early on, before following the entire conversation. Fortunately, I was able to cancel the order after the conversation started going downhill. So many points I disagree on, which I won't go into! I will say this, however, I feel he speaks as someone that is judging a culture based on Western mentality, and I think that is a big mistake. I'm expressing my personal opinion when I say that a two state solution or even a one state that absorbs Palestinians into the society will prove to be a grave mistake on many levels.
(ETA: Douglas Murray's books I think would be a very useful read, along with certain topics discussed in Benjamin Netanyahu's book)
I also don't understand Macron and very sorry to hear him...
Great discussion!!❤👍🤙🕎✡️
Israel isnt alone but the majority is silent just like during ww2
This Catholic stands with Israel.
Israel never stand alone, Israel God is standing by them and protecting them from being destroyed.
He needs to think over how he is thinking and truly open his eyes
Jonathan. I lived among evangelicals 23 years. They were wonderful to me. I miss them. You are correct about them. I rarely disagree with HBL, but on this I do. They beat New Englanders in very critical ways.
None of the disasters that keep befalling this Jew in a veritable desert would have happened in NC.
And, HBL is wrong about the Germans post WWII. I met a lot in NC during the '90s. And the Midwest in the late '60s. The US spent Megabucks on denazification. Cher Henri, il n'a pas raison.
Israel ❤
I saw this all coming even in thd early and mid 1990s. But even i am shocked how bad things have gotten and how quickly in the west. I think some very tough times are ahead very soon.
1. Self-defense is not "a right" to be granted or rescinded. It is a categorical, moral imperative, a sacred duty, an obligation. 2. Btw, great intro graphics. I approve. ;) 3. I have a dear Christian friend, a sort of 'born again' type, he had an epiphany quite a while back. He told me that he believes that Christians "need" the "son" to connect with the "father," but Jews do not.
October 7th was an indescibable atrocity. The challenge is to not allow this atrocity to define what it means to be Jewish.
Israel alone is an interesting statement.
Firstly, God is always with Israel.
Secondly, I'd reverse it to Only Israel.
Only Israel has to shine its light onto the world that is turning into darkness and reverse it.
42:00 Most Evangelical Christians do not go to “mega churches” anyways, and there are many staunchly pro-Jewish Christians who belong to other denominations. The alleged theological reasons for their support for Israel are much, much overblown. I see good people who simply support the Jews and see right from wrong. I love them for it.
DE RADICALIZING GAZA AND WEST BANK IS IMPOSSIBLE
It is possible to deradicalise, both Gaza and the West Bank, but only if the world stops shipping aid to them. There is not enough resources (human and natural) to support millions who live there now. Stop the world aid and stop Israel giving them jobs. As a result most younger people will leave for greener pastures elsewhere. The old do not reproduce and equally importantly, they are not likely to cause future intefadas.
Get out of their land and they’ll stop being radical
Today.
IF IS A BIG WORD.
Great stuff.
Great show. But I do think Bernard -Henri Levy, as brilliant as he is, is unrealistically optimistic about the possibility of a two state solution in the foreseeable future, if not ever. Putting a state in Israel's heartland would be suicidal. He is on target about Iran's aspirations. I don't know why he thinks the Palestinians are less intent on Israel's annihilation if they had the means to do it.
Israel has non Jewish allies . I’m saying here that one day while working , a coworker while getting ready for his break , was whistling your Nacional Anthem. I did approached him showing my wrist band in support of Israel 🇮🇱. He’s not Jewish either but he cannot stand all duality against Israel. He’s a veteran. Am Israel Chai 🇮🇱💙
I love this Guy.
I often listen to BHL in French and can testify that this is one of his best interviews. He truly spoke from the heart with the enlightenment of reason.
I saw some of the sadistic atrocities committed by individuals on human beings on that very sad day on YT. That there are some people that stand for those criminals is pure madness.
If you weren't affected by the horrendous attacks on Israel and the repeated calls to repeat them, you are lost. Blinded by hate. Very sad.
The reason why UK was involved, at the end of WW1 , Ottoman empire fell
Literally, same old story of Amalek against the Jews. They always come back in different forms and disappear into history while Jews carry on. The people of eternity 🇮🇱 ♥️
Thank you for a fascinating discussion
With Israel.
" Every point in this war, from the point of contact on the border between occupied Palestine and Lebanon to the Litani River at least, every point there, every hill, every village, every house, and every region was a front line and a cover, and this cover was not a tangible, known cover, as is common in wars such as those that were. In our war, no, there was a special tactic. If I wanted an analogy, I would liken all of this tactic adopted by Hezbollah to a vast, clever minefield in which there is no safe empty point. Therefore, observe the enemy’s method of movement and you will see that the enemy was unable to enter some of the villages adjacent to the border, such as Aita al-Shaab, and was unable and unable to enter these villages. He was unable to enter the cities, and therefore he decided to go from the eastern valley to enter and advance towards the Litani, and that was in fact the enemy’s weak point and defeat" - The full text of the interview with Major General Qassem Soleimani, in which he narrated some of the events of the July War
I stand with and love Israel! 🙂💯🇮🇱💪👍🙏🎗️
This guy’s shock that Macron, Obama and Biden turned out to be anti Israel 😂
You can say we ❤
Jonathan, on the eve of Erev Yom Kippur, I cannot think of 2 other people I would rather hear.
I wish I had been 1 of the Jews shocked on Oct 7. Amelek had been back and planning in the open for years. I so wish I were otherwise. Did you see live reports from Boston last night?
It is the hand of G-d that the P's hearts are hard against the 2-state situation. No man has the authority to do anything with the land given to the tribes by G-d.
They have just done the same thing that they have done and Gaza And the Palestinian authority and the international community have given billions and billions of dollars to these criminals
It's not just antisemitism. It is anti-Bible-ism. That's why true Christians are also along for this ride with Jews.
Anti-Hashem, Anti-Messiah, Anti-God's people.
Well said and Amen 🙏 to that
Godstand with Israel
Why are the American people so incredibly silent?
Jonathan has the patience of Job.
There are Americans that are supporting just not the government.❤😊 And praying😅❤ 🙏🙏🤣🙏🙏🙏😊
This man is a waste of time, a scholar in a cave, even though he has been around.
The nazis didn’t disappear: operation Paperclip etc. The Azov battalion in Ukraine.
Bravo Thank You!
Thank you! Gmar hatima tova🙏🫶
BHL has an hand in the problems that the French jews are facing. He pushed for the removal of kafafi in libya and after that millions of Muslims immigrants moved to Europe and France.