I am not a playgirlz but I have been watching alot of After School's videos recently... Although the old members have graduated.... I feel that the new and existing members have done a good job in covering their parts.... They bring a fresh feel to the old songs.... This change also allows the other members a chance to shine and let the fans discover the other sides of their talents.... The fans should be proud of them.... Old is Gold but New is Bold.
thats another reason i like this system when it gave chances to other members to contribute more part like my bias Lizzy, she got no lines in Because Of You when she just joined. But then she took lines bit by bit (not sure why she had to lipsync on Nana's rap when she could rap Bekah's part in japanese). And she could even took over one of the Kahi's parts. it's like a growth in her. And even we can see Jooyeon taking the rap as well, and we didnt know she could rap in this way either
And people that are complaining that are saying jooyeon has more lines than e young should stop. Juyeon deserves having a lot of lines, unforunately because she has a weaker voice she never had a lot of parts.. And pledis is not playing bias here, do you think it's easy to make a song in to a totally different style, and try to make it similar to the original one. Kaeun doesn't even have a lot of parts as well, she only has a little. So stop complaining, everyone got few lines.
Uhh no...Kaeun just came in and got 1-2 rap lines from Kahi's part, while Eyoung being in the group prior got absolutely no line in this song. Its Raina's part that baffles the shit out me, she got the whole chorus, and some singing parts already, then got tagged with 2 rap lines? When shes not even a rapper? What kind of distribution is this? Jooyeon deserves lines, however, its immediately after her existing line (which we all know, she lip-synced the shit out of it with every performance), which is another ridiculous idea. Eyoung should at least got a rap line from Raina. Oh and she got placed all the way in the back in term of dance line. Not everyone got a few lines, Uee got 2, Jung Ah got 2, Lizzi got 1 rap line, Jooyeon got 2.5, Nana got 1 and 1 huge rap line, Kaeun got 1.5 rap line, Raina got 1/2 of the damn song, while E young got 0....fuck that
@@nc_evin6891 Kaeun gained more line in old songs than E-young, even in Diva, E-young sang a small part compared to Kaeun, not hating Kaeun, but E-young was so underrated and so talented...
Nah. Eyoung is definitely a better vocalist than juyeon. Fact. Pledis was not ‘bias’ is a total BS even Uee got part like bridge on Bang. What would you call it then? Can the girl even sing? If pledis wasnt bias they shouldve given the part to lizzy since she is the way better vocalist. But no uee got it. It’s because she’s the (2nd) ace of AS. Juyeon got more lines bcs she’s a veteran member. Period. After school’s line distributions were always messed up since they always push kahi to forefront (she’s talented tho, sure) and when she left it was even getting worse
@@Agus-cz8hl 1) I literally wrote in my comment that this is how I would re-distribute the lines. So the member coding isn't even supposed to reflect the original distribution. 2) Jung Ah sings that part in their live performances, but if you listened to the audio (studio version), it's actually Raina's vocals. But also, this is supposed to be a redistribution anyway, so who that part belongs to doesn't even matter in this case.
Dude!!! I'm really pissed! How didn't E-young get any line in this song?? She's always in the back. What the hell is wrong with Pledis? E-young can sing, dance and play a lot of instruments VERY WELL. How come she doesn't get some attention from her company. C'mon, she was one of three of the group the got into the list of the most beautiful of 2013...
the entire song was re recorded when Kaeun came in. You can tell especially with the rapping Kaeun and Lizzy's portions don't sound like Kahi or Bekah at all.
with all the cheers from Nana, Pledis would let Nana sing the whole rap part. since in the background music Nana sings it all Lizzy just lip sync it.. common Pledis, update the new recordings 2013!!
I think if they re recorded it or perform it live with these 8 then the parts should be Spoken Part - EYoung 1st Verse - Jung Ah & Raina 1st Rap - Kaeun 1st Bridge - Jooyeon 1st Chorus - Raina 2nd Verse - Uee & Jooyeon 2nd Rap - Kaeun & Lizzy 2nd Chorus - Raina 3rd Verse - Uee & Nana Bridge - Jung Ah Last Chorus - EYoung & Raina share
I know all of you guys are upset that e young got no parts, but e young might be good at mostly everything but maybe she isn't as great in rapping that others. And the parts that Kahi and bekah sang are rapping parts
E-Young deserves more lines): Kaeun got more lines than E-Young and just joined...well, not surprised because when Raina came to the group she got most lines...
eyoung doesn't get more lines like jooyeon or uee won't take over someone else's lines. it's like why jungah gets less lines because raina is around. eyoung can play a million and one instruments but vocally, she's just not as strong.
In the first verse, it was Kaeun > Raina > Lizzy, Jooyeon sings > Kaeun In the second verse, it was Jooyeon > Raina and then Lizzy and Nana do Bekah's part
same song, same band...but something is still wrong :/ The original song with Bekaj and Kahi is better, more emotional..more After School. I miss the original After Schhol :( Please JungAh and Jooyeon never graduate!!
Nana was flawless in this 😍😍
One of the reasons why I hate Pledis' Graduation system. Old songs just can't be the same without the originals =/.
I am not a playgirlz but I have been watching alot of After School's videos recently... Although the old members have graduated.... I feel that the new and existing members have done a good job in covering their parts.... They bring a fresh feel to the old songs.... This change also allows the other members a chance to shine and let the fans discover the other sides of their talents.... The fans should be proud of them.... Old is Gold but New is Bold.
thats another reason i like this system when it gave chances to other members to contribute more part
like my bias Lizzy, she got no lines in Because Of You when she just joined. But then she took lines bit by bit (not sure why she had to lipsync on Nana's rap when she could rap Bekah's part in japanese). And she could even took over one of the Kahi's parts. it's like a growth in her.
And even we can see Jooyeon taking the rap as well, and we didnt know she could rap in this way either
tonnes of surprises in this performance here
First of all, Kaeun's rap, O.M.G.
And then, Jooyeon's rap
i cant believe jooyeon can rap that good! daebak!
And people that are complaining that are saying jooyeon has more lines than e young should stop. Juyeon deserves having a lot of lines, unforunately because she has a weaker voice she never had a lot of parts.. And pledis is not playing bias here, do you think it's easy to make a song in to a totally different style, and try to make it similar to the original one. Kaeun doesn't even have a lot of parts as well, she only has a little. So stop complaining, everyone got few lines.
Uhh no...Kaeun just came in and got 1-2 rap lines from Kahi's part, while Eyoung being in the group prior got absolutely no line in this song. Its Raina's part that baffles the shit out me, she got the whole chorus, and some singing parts already, then got tagged with 2 rap lines? When shes not even a rapper? What kind of distribution is this?
Jooyeon deserves lines, however, its immediately after her existing line (which we all know, she lip-synced the shit out of it with every performance), which is another ridiculous idea. Eyoung should at least got a rap line from Raina. Oh and she got placed all the way in the back in term of dance line.
Not everyone got a few lines, Uee got 2, Jung Ah got 2, Lizzi got 1 rap line, Jooyeon got 2.5, Nana got 1 and 1 huge rap line, Kaeun got 1.5 rap line, Raina got 1/2 of the damn song, while E young got 0....fuck that
@@nc_evin6891 Kaeun gained more line in old songs than E-young, even in Diva, E-young sang a small part compared to Kaeun, not hating Kaeun, but E-young was so underrated and so talented...
Nah. Eyoung is definitely a better vocalist than juyeon. Fact. Pledis was not ‘bias’ is a total BS even Uee got part like bridge on Bang. What would you call it then? Can the girl even sing? If pledis wasnt bias they shouldve given the part to lizzy since she is the way better vocalist. But no uee got it. It’s because she’s the (2nd) ace of AS. Juyeon got more lines bcs she’s a veteran member. Period. After school’s line distributions were always messed up since they always push kahi to forefront (she’s talented tho, sure) and when she left it was even getting worse
How I would have distributed the lines:
[Jooyeon] Ajikdo na geudaereul itji motae
[Jungah] I never forget boy, I never forget boy
[Nana] He eojin ji beolsseo myeot nyeoni jinanneun ji molla
[Nana] Geudae saenggangman hamyeon jakku nunmulman heulleo
[Raina] Oneulttara wae geureoke niga bogopeulkka
[Raina] Chang bakkui bissoriga nae mameul heundeureonwa
[Kaeun] Saranghaji mal geol geuraesseo jeong juji mal geol geuraesseo
[Kaeun] Butjapji mal geol geuraesseo wae ireoke na honja apa
[Eyoung] Saranghaji mal geol geuraesseo jeong juji mal geol geuraesseo
[Eyoung] Butjapji mal geol geuraesseo wae ireoke na honja apa
[Lizzy] Nan hangsang neomanui jangmiga doeryeodeon nae maeumeul ani
[Lizzy] Ije jogak nan sarangui machimpyoga dwaetdaneun geol
[Jooyeon] Nunmuri millyeowa memareun ipsuri jeojeo
[Lizzy] Ije eotteokhae geudael ijeul su eobseo
[All] Neo ttaemune manhido ureosseo
[All] Neo ttaemune manhido useosseo
[All] Neo ttaemune sarangeul mideosseo
[All] Neo ttaemune neo ttaemune modu da irheosseo
[Raina] Jeongmal dap dap daphae gap gap gaphae
[Raina] Mak mak makhae
neo eomneun sesangi
[Jungah] Nae mameul sibeonoko jajonsim jitbarbanoko
[Jungah] Nae mameul jjijeonoko wae nareul tteonaga
[Uee] Geu naldo biga wasseotji hanchameul geudaen mareobsi
[Uee] Nareul barabogiman haesseo sseo sseo sseo
[Jooyeon] Heundeullineun nunbitgwa aesseo jitneun eosaekhan misoga
[Jooyeon] Ibyeoreul yaegihaejwo jwo jwo jwo
[Kaeun] Saranghaji mal geol geuraesseo jeong juji mal geol geuraesseo
[Kaeun] Butjapji mal geol geuraesseo wae ireoke na honja apa
[Eyoung] Saranghaji mal geol geuraesseo jeong juji mal geol geuraesseo
[Eyoung] Butjapji mal geol geuraesseo wae ireoke na honja apa
[Lizzy] Nabogo tteonarago hal ttaen eonjego tteonandanikka eojjeogo
[Lizzy] Michin saram chwigeumman hae jeongmal himdeureo boy slow down
[Nana] Amureon maldo motan chae ureo cuz I want to stay next to you
[Nana] My love is true, wanna go back to when I was with you
[All] Neo ttaemune manhido ureosseo
[All] Neo ttaemune manhido useosseo
[All] Neo ttaemune sarangeul mideosseo
[All] Neo ttaemune neo ttaemune modu da irheosseo
[Raina] Jeongmal dap dap daphae gap gap gaphae
[Raina] Mak mak makhae neo eomneun sesangi
[Jungah] Nae mameul sibeonoko jajonsim jitbarbanoko
[Jungah] Nae mameul jjijeonoko wae nareul tteonaga
[Uee] I miss you I need you kkum sogeseon ajikdo I’m with you
[Nana] I miss you I need you siganeul doedollyeo wanna kiss you again ma boy
[Jungah] Mami neomu apeunde gyeondigi goerounde
[Jungah] Neoneun eodiseo mwol hani, na ureosseo cham manhi
[Jungah] Neo eobsin nan mot sareo naegero dorawajwo nal tteonagaji ma
[All] Neo ttaemune manhido ureosseo [Jungah] (Yeah)
[All] Neo ttaemune manhido useosseo [Raina] (Manhido useosseo nan)
[All] Neo ttaemune sarangeul mideosseo [Raina] (Oh yeah)
[All] Neo ttaemune neo ttaemune modu da irheosseo [Raina] (Neo ttaemune nan)
[Kaeun] Jeongmal dap dap daphae gap gap gaphae
[Kaeun] Mak mak makhae neo eomneun sesangi [Raina] (No, no)
[Lizzy] Nae mameul sibeonoko [Raina] (Sibeonoko)
[Lizzy] Jajonsim jitbarbanoko [Raina] (Barbanoko oh)
[Lizzy] Nae mameul jjijeonoko
wae nareul tteonaga [Raina] (Yeah yeah yeah)
Line Distribution:
1) Raina = 45.4 secs
2) Jungah = 40.9 secs
3) Lizzy = 26.7 secs
4) Kaeun = 23.7 secs
5) Nana = 23.4 secs
6) Eyoung = 15.5 secs
7) Jooyeon = 15.5 secs
8) Uee = 15.1 secs
For the record "manhido usseo nan" at the end is sung by Jungah, not Raina.
@@Agus-cz8hl 1) I literally wrote in my comment that this is how I would re-distribute the lines. So the member coding isn't even supposed to reflect the original distribution.
2) Jung Ah sings that part in their live performances, but if you listened to the audio (studio version), it's actually Raina's vocals. But also, this is supposed to be a redistribution anyway, so who that part belongs to doesn't even matter in this case.
My favorite song of AS. Full of emotions.
I've watch a clip wherein UEE was teary-eyed while singing her part on 2:44 .
Because Of You is and will always be their best song.
omg Kaeun voice o.o
I really love Uee, her the most. She doesn't have that many lines nor rapping, and I did not see her that much in this video.
Dude!!! I'm really pissed! How didn't E-young get any line in this song?? She's always in the back. What the hell is wrong with Pledis? E-young can sing, dance and play a lot of instruments VERY WELL. How come she doesn't get some attention from her company. C'mon, she was one of three of the group the got into the list of the most beautiful of 2013...
im quite sure she didnt get along well with AS or Pledis. she barely had a line/only had one line in Shampoo when she debuted lol.
NANAAAAAAAA!!!!! waaaaa!!!!
the entire song was re recorded when Kaeun came in. You can tell especially with the rapping Kaeun and Lizzy's portions don't sound like Kahi or Bekah at all.
2022 June 12th
I miss them so much🥺
RAINA ♥
Wow, Kaeun's rapping is amazing! But I wish E-Young got a part.. For the entire thing she's at the back :(
謝謝上傳
Lizzy was so cute ~♥
with all the cheers from Nana,
Pledis would let Nana sing the whole rap part.
since in the background music Nana sings it all
Lizzy just lip sync it..
common Pledis, update the new recordings 2013!!
애프터스쿨내가제일좋아하는가수
Nana😘😘😘😘
I think if they re recorded it or perform it live with these 8 then the parts should be
Spoken Part - EYoung
1st Verse - Jung Ah & Raina
1st Rap - Kaeun
1st Bridge - Jooyeon
1st Chorus - Raina
2nd Verse - Uee & Jooyeon
2nd Rap - Kaeun & Lizzy
2nd Chorus - Raina
3rd Verse - Uee & Nana
Bridge - Jung Ah
Last Chorus - EYoung & Raina share
I know all of you guys are upset that e young got no parts, but e young might be good at mostly everything but maybe she isn't as great in rapping that others. And the parts that Kahi and bekah sang are rapping parts
Lol, Raina and Jooyeon aren't good rappers either...they are just playing favorites at this point. At least Eyoung have rapped before joining Pledis
I want new recordings for the old songs!! It's imperative!
it'd be amazing if pledis release this recording ;;
But Kaeun is a rapper too
Fan so good ^ ^
全程看uie
Jupal's rap
Ueeeee❤❤
I cant believe that eyoung doesn't get any lines. It makes me so mad. Yes shes my bias
👍👍👍👍👍
Where's eyoung lines?
I have the same question😢
E-Young deserves more lines): Kaeun got more lines than E-Young and just joined...well, not surprised because when Raina came to the group she got most lines...
i think Raina's voice is comparable to snsd's taeyeon and why does E-young have much less lines then Kaeun?
eyoung doesn't get more lines like jooyeon or uee won't take over someone else's lines. it's like why jungah gets less lines because raina is around. eyoung can play a million and one instruments but vocally, she's just not as strong.
It is so weird when E Young has less line to sing than Kaeun o.o
Who did Kahis part? And i think lizzy and nana did Bekahs
Kaeun took most Kahi's rap part I think
In the first verse, it was Kaeun > Raina > Lizzy, Jooyeon sings > Kaeun
In the second verse, it was Jooyeon > Raina and then Lizzy and Nana do Bekah's part
aku ngipi ibuketegar
Jungah performing without Bekah and Kahi is a crime
Shut up.
KaEun 和 Lizzy 唱唸的還是 KaHi 的聲音 XD
As if raina didn't have enough lines.. They could've given the rap to nana.
E-young got no part wtf
e - young not siging 😕
same song, same band...but something is still wrong :/
The original song with Bekaj and Kahi is better, more emotional..more After School.
I miss the original After Schhol :( Please JungAh and Jooyeon never graduate!!
Jooyeon already graduated