Know-It-Alls: Survivor 47 Finale

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 янв 2025

Комментарии • 97

  • @gracem8885
    @gracem8885 17 дней назад +7

    I would love if they included some of the conversations at Ponderosa. What are the players saying about the remaining players.

  • @100bruinsrule
    @100bruinsrule 20 дней назад +113

    I heard someone else mention this somewhere, but I think that the best middle ground between the current aftershow and a full on live reunion would be giving everyone 24 hours between FTC and Jeff asking his questions. It's close enough to the reveal that the show gets the raw, emotional reactions they want, while also giving the finalists some time to eat, shower, and generally compose themselves before being questioned.

    • @meredithwemhoff9270
      @meredithwemhoff9270 20 дней назад +3

      I wish they’d do this!!!

    • @Entertainment-os4ig
      @Entertainment-os4ig 20 дней назад +3

      Survivor South Africa ; )

    • @EmmaVB82
      @EmmaVB82 20 дней назад +9

      One finale thing I really miss from watching S47 (after watching only S1-8 and S33 in their entirety, all within the last 3 months!) is not getting to see all the other players in the reunion who got voted out pre-jury and who we never saw again! Having never watched a true new-era season, I wasn’t prepared for that! I can see Jeff’s point about wanting the reunion part to be real and raw and not tainted with 6+ months of life back at home and seeing the social media reaction etc, but I do really miss a bit of a longer reunion with the full cast.

    • @duderanchboi9922
      @duderanchboi9922 18 дней назад +1

      I believe South Africa: Return of the Outcasts did something similar, where they brought everyone back for a reunion but gave the players a day to clean up and get relaxed.

  • @briankong-sivert6318
    @briankong-sivert6318 19 дней назад +13

    Sam was technically on the right side of every vote he cast, but it comes with a pretty large asterisk. The only reason he wasn't on the wrong side of the Sierra vote is because he didn't have a vote. The only reason he was on the right side of the Sol vote was because Rachel told him about it (and he even tried unsuccessfully to subvert that vote but gave up at the end and went with the majority). He voted correctly for Genevieve because it was her or him. And he also didn't have a vote (because Rachel blocked him) for Andy's boot. So however you would have viewed that vote (on the right side because of votes cast or because of the end result) he was a non-factor in it. Rome, Gabe, and Kyle were all lopsided obvious votes. He wasn't part of Tiyana's boot. That leaves Operation Italy, which was a great move, but not his entirely and one where Andy did a lot of the heavy lifting.
    And while he had the most votes cast against him, it was largely because he was the "Break Glass in Case of Idol" player 3 times. He was never Plan A for a vote in the entire game. So he's overselling his threat level there. He drove zero votes in the post-merge (Operation Italy was a group effort), and by his own admission played most of it from the bottom after the Sierra boot. I still think he played a very good game given his circumstances, but to say he was a bigger threat than Rachel just doesn't bear scrutiny for more than a minute.

  • @naomim5746
    @naomim5746 20 дней назад +46

    30:38 They can do both. Get raw and immediate reactions and film that, then bring them together and get their reactions to the edit and how they were protrayed.
    Jeff could be like, this was your immediate reaction during our discussions. Do you feel the same way?
    Also, its nice getting to hear from premerge boots. I would live to hear from Rome, TK, Tiyana, Anika etc.
    I agree. Its not memorable.

    • @Juicygiiraffe
      @Juicygiiraffe 20 дней назад +1

      Or even better, get a reaction of their reaction to the Final tribal council a year later Every season! This would keep seasons living on forever. Like a Season reunion every year, put it in their contracts that they have to come back every 2 years or so, this would invigorate the fanatics. Just think we could find out about them years later, or even see who is the last survivor to live in real life 😮

  • @davidmallard6127
    @davidmallard6127 19 дней назад +12

    Really Love the Know It Alls - highlight of each Survivor season!

  • @bengregory7859
    @bengregory7859 19 дней назад +11

    Despite not having big characters, I think 47 is now the best of the new era. Very well edited and I also think that operation Italy will go down as the most memorable move of the new era.

  • @HopeAndrea_HFG
    @HopeAndrea_HFG 20 дней назад +57

    Great finale but the revisionist history from Jeff about how the new reunion style is better than the old one is lame. I'm not buying it. They should just admit that they don't wanna pay for it anymore.

    • @Mamcello
      @Mamcello 20 дней назад +4

      Agree. He thinks if he says it over and over, we'll agree, but I would think it's clear most folks just don't

    • @EmmaVB82
      @EmmaVB82 20 дней назад +1

      I can kind of see his point about wanting the raw and real reactions instead of those tainted by months of dealing with the real world and social media response etc… (and I’m absolutely feeling for the other finalists who didn’t win for having to take part in a discussion at that specific time! So giving them the grace of a night’s sleep and a hot shower and hot meal and time to compose their thoughts would be great) but I still think there must be a way to get both that rawness and the full-cast reunion, which I really miss.
      I’ve recently watched S1-8 in full for the first time, and I’m shocked by those early seasons with full ”where are they now” episodes of visiting all the cast in their home states, in addition to the live audience reunions! That must have cost a bomb!
      Surely there’s a way to do a full-cast reunion with even a scaled-down live audience (or none at all?! That part isn’t as important, I don’t think! Though the atmosphere at one of those massive live shows for the players must have been incredible and electric)

    • @westcrosby
      @westcrosby 19 дней назад +3

      I prefer to see the live reactions. They have an entire island; they have the money. I don't see it as gaslighting, or saving money. Remember COVID? They stopped doing the finales with a live audience because of COVID, not out of the need to save money. They had to change the entire format of the show. Condensing it down to a month provides more time for post-production, more breaks for their employees, perhaps a better work/life balance. There are other factors other than money driving this decision. The biggest factor being it's more exciting for me as a viewer. And Rachel implies that psychologically, it is easier to trust raw reactions versus everyone becoming tainted by online smears, then waiting a year later, and you don't trust a single thing cast members say. The ego is removed, and it's more authentic. Or, it's revisionist history, sure.

    • @ryanwest5179
      @ryanwest5179 19 дней назад +3

      I actually disagree. Jeff’s reasoning for why the new reunion style is better is very sound. I *always* used to complain about the old reunions because the players wouldn’t answer questions honestly. They’d been completely influenced by audience perception and the edit. Having the reunion immediately after makes it so their answers are the most honest & real that we’re ever gonna get.
      Honestly, the only downside, imo, is that Jeff himself hasn’t watched the edit, so he doesn’t know a lot of the more game intricate questions to ask.

    • @handsoaphandsoap
      @handsoaphandsoap 18 дней назад +2

      I don’t hate the concept of doing it on the island but it’s just oh so boring. Jeff needs a day or two to gather info from production on what is questions to ask to get interesting answers. I do miss the live winner reaction though, it’s so much more hype than like 8 jury members lukewarmly cheering.

  • @naomim5746
    @naomim5746 19 дней назад +7

    I'm going to keep posting this for everyone who keeps discounting Rachel's game due to luck:
    Survivor 43 idol holders: Jeanine, Cody and Jesse
    Survivor 44 idol holders: Mathew, Brandon, Danny, Carolyn
    Survivor 45 idol holders: Austin, Julie, Sabiyah
    Survivor 46 idol holders: Jem, Hunter, Tiffany, Q
    I cant remember everyone off top but finding an idol has proven to be very unlucky.

  • @vic-dianne
    @vic-dianne 20 дней назад +11

    31:51 what if they did it next day at Ponderosa? Still announce winners and do a toast… don’t give back their phones for one more night and do it the next day

  • @elitettelbach4247
    @elitettelbach4247 20 дней назад +7

    Another great season of knowing it all!

  • @ineedmorcowbellTV
    @ineedmorcowbellTV 20 дней назад +11

    Hey guys! I am also not a fan of what happens after the finale but I get Jeff's point. Everything still is raw right after. However, this is not a reunion. This is an after show. The FANS and pre-jury still need a reunion. I would have loved to have seen Aysha and Rome again. Emotions and feelings are also different months after the season has wrapped, so they would still have new and interesting content. It's not hard. After show. Reunion. Don't do a two part 2 hour season finale. Do a finale on one episode and the reunion on the next. Compromise for everybody.

  • @ProbingProbst
    @ProbingProbst 13 дней назад

    I love the Know it Alls! I love them toooo much!!

  • @Secretninja98
    @Secretninja98 19 дней назад +2

    Random thought but please let me know if anyone agrees.
    During the pre merge there was a random group split and Rachel was olaced on a team with 5 tuku's. Coincidentally, there was a secret advantage on the reward for the other team who won and Sol was able to find it and save Rachel. Overall, pretty balanced advantage for someone to use on someone that was disadvantaged by the challenge tribe split.
    So here's my real point. When Rachel used the block a vote on sam, and his parchment said "unless you have an extra vote please return to your seat", does anyone think potentially there was an extra vote advantage somewhere that no one claimed?
    It just seems so weird to me that the parchment was so specific instead of just saying "Your vote has been blocked."

  • @houstonbarenholtz316
    @houstonbarenholtz316 14 дней назад

    18:27 “I actually have no idea”
    Classic Know-It-All shenanigans

  • @bjb5byrne
    @bjb5byrne 20 дней назад +12

    Operation Italy was the biggest move of the game, Jeff wtf man

    • @jasonmuiruri
      @jasonmuiruri 20 дней назад +1

      Clearly not since Rachel's Idol play secured her the win

    • @bjb5byrne
      @bjb5byrne 20 дней назад +7

      @jasonmuiruri alright she made the best move, operation italy in terms of an overall move was historic, with no advantages or idols pure genius

    • @ninoj3774
      @ninoj3774 20 дней назад +5

      @@jasonmuiruri Operation Italy was the most praised move of the season and one of the most praised in recent years. Rachel's idol only really impressed the jury and I don't even understand why since she used it in the most obvious way possible.

    • @MoeSzyslak20
      @MoeSzyslak20 20 дней назад +1

      ​she got an idol in her food and played it when she knew she was getting voted. I respect rachel but that move in particular deserves little credit. @@jasonmuiruri

    • @willms7173
      @willms7173 17 дней назад

      There was also the block a vote, and the fact that Rachel and Sue managed to eliminate Andy. I forgot for a moment, and thought it was Genevieve.

  • @caitlinmaillet3606
    @caitlinmaillet3606 15 дней назад

    Around 52:42
    I think the only reason operation Italy works is because no one had shots in the dark. Had anyone had it remaining (or all of them probably) it adds another layer of "will this person who may be in trouble actually vote or will they just play the shot in the dark" which I think makes the plan much less viable

  • @AudioEv1
    @AudioEv1 19 дней назад +1

    I’m already camping out at the bookstore for Stephen’s next book. Looks like I’m first in line suckers! 📘⛺️👏🏼

  • @coneil72
    @coneil72 19 дней назад +4

    HOW DID RACHEL FORGET TO MENTION HER SHOT IN THE DARK PLAY??? The most innovative move of the past 10 seasons?!???

    • @AndyTempleman-ot6lu
      @AndyTempleman-ot6lu 19 дней назад

      Yes, I thought that too. Maybe she did but it was edited out????

    • @maria44688
      @maria44688 19 дней назад +3

      She says it in her exit interview with Rob, but she just didn't think it was that good of a move. Now in hindsight, she sees that it was worth talking about. But she thought of it at tribal council as a way to avoid voting for Gabe (who wouldn't be going home) and also to check to see if people might be voting for her. But since it was such a last-minute decision, she didn't value it as much as her other moves.

  • @Ninab.03
    @Ninab.03 19 дней назад +1

    Rob: “Money, please!” 😂

  • @mystic7934
    @mystic7934 19 дней назад +4

    49:14 is spot on. Rachel + Sam = Genevieve

  • @therealbensoule652
    @therealbensoule652 18 дней назад

    In my opinion,
    1. 43
    2. 46
    3. 47
    4. 45
    5. 42
    6. 44
    7. 41
    I think I just clicked with the cast of 43 the most. Coupled with the scaled back advantages from 41 + 42 and Jesse’s move at final 6, 43 cemented itself as one of my favorite seasons and is easily my favorite of the new era

  • @eeg0415
    @eeg0415 19 дней назад +1

    I really enjoyed watching Mike Holloway's season.

  • @KevinLie-u9g
    @KevinLie-u9g 20 дней назад +1

    Stephen with The Nix by Nathan Hill on his shelf is such a flex.

  • @JalebJay
    @JalebJay 20 дней назад +5

    I hope we get a goat vote out season. I worry about boring ftc each season.

    • @creativegaze
      @creativegaze 20 дней назад

      She created those circumstances, they didn't just fall into her lap. Sam was utterly useless and then complained about not being higher up in the hierarchy while simultaneously calling himself a "big player."

    • @JalebJay
      @JalebJay 20 дней назад +2

      @creativegaze Sam wins if Rachel doesn't reach f3. So you can't consider him as a bad player. Especially with his ftc performance.

    • @HighGuyy420
      @HighGuyy420 20 дней назад

      ​@@JalebJaySame wins F3 IF he gets there with Sue and Tenie. If he gets there with Andy, Genevieve or Rachel he loses which is exactly what we saw when his closest ally voted for Rachel instead of him. Outside of operation Italy he was really dead in the game from the Sierra boot onward.

    • @pictureperfect6556
      @pictureperfect6556 19 дней назад

      ​@@HighGuyy420he only needed one different outcome in the final 4? Thats not drawing dead lmao. Its not hard to bank on teeny and sue reaching the final 3, was pretty likely. Seems like you just have a distaste for him clouding your judgement.

    • @HighGuyy420
      @HighGuyy420 19 дней назад

      @@pictureperfect6556 what did Sam do to deserve a win? I don't have distaste for him, I just don't see him doing anything to earn a win over anyone else in final 6.

  • @mystic7934
    @mystic7934 19 дней назад +3

    With so many fan events and meetups happening I struggle to see why they can’t do an in-person real time after show. I love seeing them all get their flowers after the show airs. If it’s too expensive for cbs, make it low budget and air it on paramount plus. We were ROBBED of andy and sol getting their king-making moments from a live audience.

  • @bobsiyt6548
    @bobsiyt6548 19 дней назад

    My main gripe is that they extended each episode to 90 minutes to give the audience a full view of what is really going on… only to use editing to trick the audience to what’s not really going on. It could be 3 hour episodes and they still would leave out critical moments in the game. What’s the purpose of expanding it 30 minutes, if you’re just leaving great moments on the cutting room floor?

  • @ja1207
    @ja1207 17 дней назад

    Kyle admitted into voting Sam to not give Sue 2nd.

  • @houstonbarenholtz316
    @houstonbarenholtz316 14 дней назад

    Stephen said that he didn’t get the production that is would be close. As a Stephen Stan watching Tocantins the first time I didn’t understand why he lost, except that his tribal was not good at all whatsoever

  • @koshyvaidyan4741
    @koshyvaidyan4741 18 дней назад

    Great winner. Totally deserved by Rachel. Was disappointed with a 20 min after show. I wish the 1 hour reunion is brought back and reading of the votes back in US. Was also disappointed with the final talk by the final 3. No opening statements- given by final 3 but only closing remarks by them. Was looking for better questions by Genevieve and- Andy but Rachel shut them down. Sue wanted to play the age card to win the jury votes and I didn't understand what Sam was babbling about as Rachel was going for his throat everytime he opened- his- mouth. Sue hoards christmas trees. The only highlight of the finale was the fire making challenge. That was a cliff hanger. The wind Gods really helped Sam to make it to final 3.

  • @icedcovfefe6580
    @icedcovfefe6580 19 дней назад +1

    Man I gotta respectfully disagree with 45 being better than 47. Nothing remotely exciting happens after Kellie goes home. 46 at least was more fun, but those first few episodes...

  • @juliapernicka2698
    @juliapernicka2698 18 дней назад

    Apparently, Kyle did tell Sam that he knew everyone was voting for Rachel but he voted for Sam so he would come in second place and not tie with Sue.

    • @leahs1195
      @leahs1195 17 дней назад

      Where did you hear that?

    • @juliapernicka2698
      @juliapernicka2698 17 дней назад

      @ i’ve watched several exit interviews with him… But cannot remember which one he actually said that.

  • @daviddanielmerkle9520
    @daviddanielmerkle9520 19 дней назад +1

    44>47>42>43>45>46>41

  • @jeffaa2009
    @jeffaa2009 20 дней назад

    Couldn't find you last night

  • @chicagokong
    @chicagokong 13 дней назад

    Rachels path was a bit paved, thought Sam had a much harder road.

  • @koshyvaidyan4741
    @koshyvaidyan4741 18 дней назад

    Coming up on Season 48 RHAP will be interviewing serious nutcases and self obsessed contestants who think they are having one on one conversations with Jeff Probst on the island haha

  • @ifeyinwaokolo1246
    @ifeyinwaokolo1246 17 дней назад

    Sam to me wasn't even a close second. I didn't find him to be smart at all. His and Sierra's people management skills were horrible especially when it came to Andy and Sierra exit was even more telling negatively on Sam.
    For all his speech about his prowess, being a wolf in wolf's clothing I found his physical performance to be abysmal.
    I would give determination to him but his claim of making someone his shield was laughable. If anything, Racheal biggest mistake for me was thinking Sam was a huge threat.

    • @willms7173
      @willms7173 17 дней назад +1

      Although she targeted Andy, when she realized that Andy could possibly be a bigger threat. Her impression of Sam might have been formed prior to the merge, and she wasn't sure of how he was still being perceived by some of the members on the jury.

    • @ifeyinwaokolo1246
      @ifeyinwaokolo1246 17 дней назад

      @ agreed

    • @willms7173
      @willms7173 16 дней назад +1

      In hindsight, Sierra probably should have went with Anika and Rachel. Although she might have believed that she was in a better spot with Sam.

    • @ifeyinwaokolo1246
      @ifeyinwaokolo1246 16 дней назад +1

      @@willms7173 this! I believed 3 of them would have made a formidable trio.

    • @willms7173
      @willms7173 16 дней назад

      @ifeyinwaokolo1246 Same here

  • @nomercy4186
    @nomercy4186 18 дней назад +1

    This was a weak season in my opinion I might get dogged by the Rachel fan boys but I don’t think she was that great of a winner but that’s kinda been the case in recent seasons as well

  • @Noid1220
    @Noid1220 20 дней назад

    46 over 47??????

  • @lazarusmetcalfe2423
    @lazarusmetcalfe2423 20 дней назад +1

    I know that boots 5th and 6th place can be undersold with the long finale, but the long finale would have been better. Rachel won immunity in 20 minutes and about 99% of the suspense was gone for the night immediately. Also, weird that we seemingly know more about all the other top 6 than our winner, but that’s on the edit, not Rachel,

  • @roger_towny_jr
    @roger_towny_jr 19 дней назад

    You KNOW Q has to be secretly a massive Christmas fan and probably has 5 Christmas trees too.

  • @Juicygiiraffe
    @Juicygiiraffe 20 дней назад

    I want the savage edits they used to do for the people whobwere villains

  • @iRocz.
    @iRocz. 19 дней назад

    Honestly they gave the game to that girl Rachel lol lucky my boy kyle got voted out

  • @michaelmcdermott9008
    @michaelmcdermott9008 20 дней назад +11

    It’s so idiotic winning challenges is now a negative. The younger generations suck.

    • @kaiwistoski9858
      @kaiwistoski9858 20 дней назад +16

      dude rachel won

    • @marshallscot
      @marshallscot 20 дней назад +6

      ​@kaiwistoski9858 Rachel stans still bitter after she won lmao

    • @pictureperfect6556
      @pictureperfect6556 19 дней назад +3

      Older generations cant be happy even with the outcome they wish for. You are a perpetual negativity machine.

  • @supermish8912
    @supermish8912 19 дней назад

    Kyle’s wins were harder than Rachel’s because he competed against more people

    • @willms7173
      @willms7173 17 дней назад

      It might be harder to compete against more people, but it seems that each win becomes more significant as the number of players goes down. And a player might not necessarily have to have a lot of wins.

  • @countryboy9389
    @countryboy9389 20 дней назад +6

    Rachel is a luckbox. Who wouldn’t win with her circumstances

    • @LivTheSlayer
      @LivTheSlayer 20 дней назад +1

      Everyone on 46 who didn’t play their advantages and everyone who never won a challenge

    • @naomim5746
      @naomim5746 19 дней назад +1

      Survivor 43 idol holders: Jeanine, Cody and Jesse
      Survivor 44 idol holders: Mathew, Brandon, Danny, Carolyn
      Survivor 45 idol holders: Austin, Julie, Sabiyah
      Survivor 46 idol holders: Jem, Hunter, Tiffany, Q
      I cant remember everyone off top but finding an idol has proven to be very unlucky.

    • @josephlim6854
      @josephlim6854 19 дней назад

      I was surprised Sam didn't mention that more. Sam was right that he didn't need any advantages to make it to the final 3 which is impressive in its own right. I do think Rachel took advantage of all the opportunities given to her at the right time and that's what made her win.

    • @dbarller
      @dbarller 19 дней назад

      It wasn’t all Luck but that’s new survivor for you. It’s just Mario party

  • @Dylan_B23
    @Dylan_B23 18 дней назад

    46 > 45 > 42 > 47 > 41 >>> 44 >>>>> 43
    First 5 are great to good. 44 is not good and generally overrated. But 43 is absolute garbage.

    • @tmm4195
      @tmm4195 15 дней назад

      Crazy take lol. 41 is at the bottom and it's not even close. Season 43 is actually one of the better seasons