I like how she tried to sing this. She's an amazing singer. But to be honest, I don't think her way of singing suits Bad Apple. If this was a rock version, it would've been better. Her voice would've suited best for a rock version of Bad Apple. But that's just my opinion
Hanatan is as incredible as always, but this song has a big problem. The original one looked for mixing the high pitch with the melody, and the singer actually had a high pitched voice, like if she was a little girl. Because of this, no one is used to a lower pitch of this song. Hanatan doesn't have that ultra girly high pitched voice, so she adds a bit of her style. People, used to the high pitched girl, dislike this song. For me, the problem is the song 100%. The song is not prepared to be covered, and if it's covered, it must be done by a girly high pitched voice. Hanatan is just trying to give this song some power, but sadly it didn't have any potential since the beginning, and it ended up restraining her of showing power because, as I said, 'Bad Apple' never had any power and people doesn't welcome any potential to it. And it sounds 'monotone' because the song is monotone, the only thing is that we don't notice it because of the original song's singer voice.
This is pretty much it in a nutshell. People are looking at it entirely one-sided. "Hanatan is too powerful" and etc. She has incredible range. She can hold back. But this song has to be done a very specific way or it just doesn't work. If she has any blame in this at all it's that she just didn't really try to do it that way. (She can I think, but then what's the point?) Well, just as an example of her doing a "girly" voice: ruclips.net/video/rpYLC-h6zMk/видео.html (Though I think, I've heard a few even more so than that.)
@@NazoKiyoubinbou I think a better example would be her cover of Romeo and Cinderella, although generally, I think Hanatan herself has a rather low pitch voice naturally (especially when you hear she talk and not just sing in real life), I often found her singing pitch lower than Pokota when they are doign a duet together which should say something. She can do high pitch and actually very good at it but not as good when having to do a sustained ultra high pitch. Personally, I don't mind that though and I think this song overall sounds great.
LYRICS UU♡ Nagareteku toki no naka de demo kedarusa ga hora guruguru mawatte Watashi kara hanareru kokoro mo mienai wa sou shiranai Jibun kara ugoku koto mo naku toki no sukima ni nagasare tsuzukete Shiranai wa mawari no koto nado watashi wa watashi sore dake Yume miteru? Nani mo mitenai? Kataru mo muda na jibun no kotoba Kanashimu nante tsukareru dake yo nani mo kanjizu sugoseba ii no Tomadou kotoba ataerarete mo jibun no kokoro tada uwa no sora Moshi watashi kara ugoku no naraba subete kaeru no nara kuro ni suru Konna jibun ni mirai wa aru no? Konna sekai ni watashi wa iru no? Ima setsunai no? Ima kanashii no? Jibun no koto mo wakaranai mama Ayumu koto sae tsukareru dake yo hito no koto nado shiri mo shinaiwa Konna watashi mo kawareru no nara moshi kawareru no nara shiro ni naru? Nagareteku toki no naka de demo kedarusa ga hora guruguru mawatte Watashi kara hanareru kokoro mo mienaiwa sou shiranai Jibun kara ugoku koto mo naku toki no sukima ni nagasare tsuzukete Shiranai wa mawari no koto nado watashi wa watashi sore dake Yume miteru? Nani mo mitenai? Kataru mo muda na jibun no kotoba Kanashimu nante tsukareru dake yo nani mo kanjizu sugoseba ii no Tomadou kotoba ataerarete mo jibun no kokoro tada uwa no sora Moshi watashi kara ugoku no naraba subete kaeru no nara kuro ni suru Muda na jikan ni mirai wa aru no? Konna tokoro ni watashi wa iru no? Watashi no koto o iitai naraba kotoba ni suru no nara "roku de nashi" Konna tokoro ni watashi wa iru no? Konna jikan ni watashi wa iru no? Konna watashi mo kawareru no nara moshi kawareru no nara shiro ni naru? Ima yume miteru? Nani mo mitenai? Kataru mo muda na jibun no kotoba? Kanashimu nante tsukareru dake yo nani mo kanjizu sugoseba ii no Tomadou kotoba ataerarete mo jibun no kokoro tada uwa no sora Moshi watashi kara ugoku no naraba subete kaeru no nara kuro ni suru Ugoku no naraba ugoku no naraba subete kowasu wa subete kowasu wa Kanashimu naraba kanashimu naraba watashi no kokoro shiroku kawareru? Anata no koto mo watashi no koto mo subete no koto mo mada shiranai no Omoi mabuta wo aketa no naraba subete kowasu no nara kuro ni nare!!!
I can't believe that people are complaining because this is original Bad apple sound track kkkkk (including me) why didn't she remix it like senbonzakura?
Hmm, i expected her voice would only make it better, but it didn't. She should just sing this with the normal intonations as in the original, i usually really like her voice, but all that extra effort she put in here was way overdone, her voice almost sounds as if its tearing...
Ugh I used to like her but now she for some reason ups the audio input and lowers her singing volume... I can hardly hear her in most of her tracks now.
![Gunna - HIM ALL ALONG [Official Visualizer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HiCxoDeo0hc/mqdefault.jpg)
![【Multilanguage Cover】Touhou: Bad Apple [Happy Eur. Day of Languages!] (Orchestral Ver.) 〈Avlönskt〉](/img/1.gif)
Why is everyone freaking out? It sounds fine with her voice.
it sounds amazing, idk why people think the opposite
@@0seenu0 they're all tone deaf.
@@Jane00223 bro, I am tone deaf. And I find this amazing... Those people just doesn't have taste in good music
people are complaining about her voice because they're used to the original
this ^^
I've heard so many covers I sometimes forget what the original sounds like
So far her cover is the best.
Her voice is just amazing!!
HANATAN is my best singer!!!!!!
I dunno about you guys, but to me this is one of the best covers of this song.
Bad Apple can't contain Hanatan's Goddess Voice.
Can you kindly recommend me your favorites Hanatan's songs?
ZerdLR tengaku :))
I'm listening to it as I read this comment. It's my favorite one from her, I just can't get enough of it. But thanks anyway ^^
+ZerdLR Try Yuragi, If, Palette, Shiwa, Ao, Those are some of the songs that come to mind when I think of Hanatan's powerful voice
Kagerou variation is where she's her strongest honestly like that ending though
力強い声だなー
こんなに歌いこなせたら楽しいだろうね
花たんこの曲歌ってたんだ～
嬉しい♪(*≧∀≦*)
Props to her for covering the full version, rather than covering the 3 minute version
Sounds like the original singer but grown up, amazing
holy shit this sounds like a present from the gods themselves
this would have sounded a lot better/more fitting with the rock version of Bad Apple!! o:
69th like
Honestly, this is my favorite cover of bad apple.
I like how she tried to sing this. She's an amazing singer. But to be honest, I don't think her way of singing suits Bad Apple. If this was a rock version, it would've been better. Her voice would've suited best for a rock version of Bad Apple.
But that's just my opinion
agree, her voice is too powerful for a song that requires high pitched singer~
still like it thou~ but not the best Bad Apple cover yet enough
This is apple is the best!
Hanatan is as incredible as always, but this song has a big problem. The original one looked for mixing the high pitch with the melody, and the singer actually had a high pitched voice, like if she was a little girl. Because of this, no one is used to a lower pitch of this song. Hanatan doesn't have that ultra girly high pitched voice, so she adds a bit of her style. People, used to the high pitched girl, dislike this song.
For me, the problem is the song 100%. The song is not prepared to be covered, and if it's covered, it must be done by a girly high pitched voice. Hanatan is just trying to give this song some power, but sadly it didn't have any potential since the beginning, and it ended up restraining her of showing power because, as I said, 'Bad Apple' never had any power and people doesn't welcome any potential to it.
And it sounds 'monotone' because the song is monotone, the only thing is that we don't notice it because of the original song's singer voice.
This is so accurate! 😭😭😭😭
This is pretty much it in a nutshell. People are looking at it entirely one-sided. "Hanatan is too powerful" and etc. She has incredible range. She can hold back. But this song has to be done a very specific way or it just doesn't work. If she has any blame in this at all it's that she just didn't really try to do it that way. (She can I think, but then what's the point?) Well, just as an example of her doing a "girly" voice: ruclips.net/video/rpYLC-h6zMk/видео.html (Though I think, I've heard a few even more so than that.)
It does sound 8-bit or vocailoidy
@@NazoKiyoubinbou I think a better example would be her cover of Romeo and Cinderella, although generally, I think Hanatan herself has a rather low pitch voice naturally (especially when you hear she talk and not just sing in real life), I often found her singing pitch lower than Pokota when they are doign a duet together which should say something. She can do high pitch and actually very good at it but not as good when having to do a sustained ultra high pitch. Personally, I don't mind that though and I think this song overall sounds great.
Hanatan is a goddess, your argument is invalid, she always improves songs with her heavenly voice
んあぁぁ
いいっすねぇ(*´Д｀*)
ベースのアレンジがカッコよくて
美しくも力強い歌声、めっちゃ好きです
冬黒兎
あ、これこの音源nomicoさんも使ってますよー
This came out amazing!!!
my favorite song
I don't think it sounds bad I think she's trying to convey the emotion of the song like she always does with her songs
カッコイイー
うんめぇ！
This is from the well known bullet hell game called "Touhou "
LYRICS UU♡
Nagareteku toki no naka de demo kedarusa ga hora guruguru mawatte
Watashi kara hanareru kokoro mo mienai wa sou shiranai
Jibun kara ugoku koto mo naku toki no sukima ni nagasare tsuzukete
Shiranai wa mawari no koto nado watashi wa watashi sore dake
Yume miteru? Nani mo mitenai? Kataru mo muda na jibun no kotoba
Kanashimu nante tsukareru dake yo nani mo kanjizu sugoseba ii no
Tomadou kotoba ataerarete mo jibun no kokoro tada uwa no sora
Moshi watashi kara ugoku no naraba subete kaeru no nara kuro ni suru
Konna jibun ni mirai wa aru no? Konna sekai ni watashi wa iru no?
Ima setsunai no? Ima kanashii no? Jibun no koto mo wakaranai mama
Ayumu koto sae tsukareru dake yo hito no koto nado shiri mo shinaiwa
Konna watashi mo kawareru no nara moshi kawareru no nara shiro ni naru?
Nagareteku toki no naka de demo kedarusa ga hora guruguru mawatte
Watashi kara hanareru kokoro mo mienaiwa sou shiranai
Jibun kara ugoku koto mo naku toki no sukima ni nagasare tsuzukete
Shiranai wa mawari no koto nado watashi wa watashi sore dake
Yume miteru? Nani mo mitenai? Kataru mo muda na jibun no kotoba
Kanashimu nante tsukareru dake yo nani mo kanjizu sugoseba ii no
Tomadou kotoba ataerarete mo jibun no kokoro tada uwa no sora
Moshi watashi kara ugoku no naraba subete kaeru no nara kuro ni suru
Muda na jikan ni mirai wa aru no? Konna tokoro ni watashi wa iru no?
Watashi no koto o iitai naraba kotoba ni suru no nara "roku de nashi"
Konna tokoro ni watashi wa iru no? Konna jikan ni watashi wa iru no?
Konna watashi mo kawareru no nara moshi kawareru no nara shiro ni naru?
Ima yume miteru? Nani mo mitenai? Kataru mo muda na jibun no kotoba?
Kanashimu nante tsukareru dake yo nani mo kanjizu sugoseba ii no
Tomadou kotoba ataerarete mo jibun no kokoro tada uwa no sora
Moshi watashi kara ugoku no naraba subete kaeru no nara kuro ni suru
Ugoku no naraba ugoku no naraba subete kowasu wa subete kowasu wa
Kanashimu naraba kanashimu naraba watashi no kokoro shiroku kawareru?
Anata no koto mo watashi no koto mo subete no koto mo mada shiranai no
Omoi mabuta wo aketa no naraba subete kowasu no nara kuro ni nare!!!
かんばて 花たん♡♡
I can't believe that people are complaining because this is original Bad apple sound track kkkkk (including me) why didn't she remix it like senbonzakura?
すきやわー
Ah this is awesome♥
bad apple!!!
guys ngl shut up its fabulous
Joliiiiiiii !!!!
Oh quelqu'un qui parle français ! Miracle !
Oriane-sama La rouquine un peu folle Vuiii! Je ne suis plus la seule! *^*
ちょっとドスきいた感じなのね
Nice job. :)
坏苹果🍎
ชอบเสียงอ่ะค่ะ
อุ้ววเจอคนไทยด้วยนานๆจะเจอทีนะนี่ ปกติเจอตามไทยซับ
0:57
まだ聞いてる(´・ω・｀)
❤️🥳🥳
花姐唱的嗎?好聽ㄝXDD
2020?=v
Hanatan is too loud and powerful for this song.
I like how Remilia and Flandre are doing Rem and Ram's signature pose.
@mkzhero SOMEONE UNDERSTANDS XD
personally it would sound better in the Draw the Emotional Ver
Hmm, i expected her voice would only make it better, but it didn't. She should just sing this with the normal intonations as in the original, i usually really like her voice, but all that extra effort she put in here was way overdone, her voice almost sounds as if its tearing...
mkzhero Brutal honestly, but yeah, I think maybe you're right. This style isn't where her own abilities really shine.
花たん好像和這首不搭........
출처가없다
ㅋ
Nit bad if compared to Nomico's voice
Her voice doesn't fit this song at all :P
Yes it does!
agree, not a good song for her
Ugh I used to like her but now she for some reason ups the audio input and lowers her singing volume... I can hardly hear her in most of her tracks now.
Leimiful lol I've never seen a song other than love is war where she isn't loud
+Akai Tsuki
Many other songs.
Bad apple is the standard for singers to attempt to reach if they dare.This is a ok try.
Hanatan can't even sing this song, original best. Seriously
bad apple!!!