Should Firing Squads Replace Lethal Injections? (HBO)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 мар 2017
- As states struggle with supplies of drugs used for lethal injections and with the fallout from some recent botched executions, some of the 31 states where the death penalty is legal are looking at firing squads as a backup form of execution.
Ronnie Lee Gardner was the last man killed by firing squad in the United States, in 2010. His brother, Randy Gardner, is now an advocate for ending capital punishment.
VICE News talks to Randy as well as reporter Sheryl Worsley, who witnessed the execution. We also speak with a professor who has studied capital punishment and believes that death by firing squad is actually better than death by lethal injection.
Subscribe to VICE News here: bit.ly/Subscribe-to-VICE-News
Check out VICE News for more: vicenews.com
Follow VICE News here:
Facebook: / vicenews
Twitter: / vicenews
Tumblr: / vicenews
Instagram: / vicenews
More videos from the VICE network: www. vicevideo
VICE speaks with a professor who has studied capital punishment and believes that death by firing squad is actually better than death by lethal injection.
WATCH NEXT: Inmates Are Using VR For A Chance To Get Out Of Prison - bit.ly/2ERYvN1
It took me 7 seconds of thought to figure this out. You don't need somebody with the title professor that study capital punishment to get your answer. Beheading with a large blade that is attached to a machine would work for another bandage slapped on society. Yes...firing squad would be better. I am glad the system and even to an extend society doesn't value philosophers anymore , it's a fun show to watch and laugh at , don't worry it's about to get much better.
VICE News It makes sense to me if the hit you in the head with more than one round
The most humane, effective, easiest and cleanest way to execute someone is by asphyxiation using any type of pure gas. Carbon Monoxide (CO) gas is best as it attaches to the hemoglobin in the blood more readily than oxygen. Any gas will work as long as it blocks oxygen from entering the blood stream.
Within 2 breaths you lose consciousness and in minutes you're history. I took 2 breaths of helium joking around and nearly blacked out. It was painless.
Cheaper too
Pa doesn't do death penalty alot it's vary rare as a Pennsylvanian I lived here my whole life aka 14 years so its rare in pa to get it you need a baddddd thing to haplen
He protests that the State killed his brother but not that his brother killed several innocent people.
i think you missed the point sir. the video isn't about whether or not he deserved it. he is just shown as an example. the motive of the video is more a demonstration of the effectiveness in with death penalties is cared out in the USA today, (sry bad English not native and dyslexic)
I think you missed the point of the comment...
Alan Heath
I don't agree with how the brother is going around town showing pics of his executed brother trying to build sympathy against the death penalty. whatever the inmate did, let's see pictures of his victims side-by-side at the brother's protests, and see what's fair.
Yea why doesn't vice ask the victims families about how they feel about it? I can appreciate that this guy is sad that his brother is dead but for fuck's sake, if he killed other people in cold blood during a robbery then he damn sight deserved it. Feelings be damned. He didn't take into account the feelings of the people he killed or their families.
Alan Heath supporting war mongering neo cons
I'd ask to be 360 no scoped
Mythrain Too easy. Gotta be at least a 540, ladder stall, YYR, silent shot
And headshots only
**Executioner does Fortnite dance and teabags corpse**
@@libertyprime1710 A memer mentioning fortnite? How rare.
Nah 1080 Nac
“My brother didn’t deserve this”
Neither did the people he killed but no one cares about that.
What do you mean no one cares about that. The dude who did it was killed......obviously someone cared.
@@gabriellec6863 it’s sarcasm people obviously cared.
@@mystic9806 uhhh yeah....that's my point. That people cared. What part of his comment was sarcasm?
@@gabriellec6863 he is trying to emphasize what the killer’s brother said that ‘my brother didn’t deserve this’ so he is saying that that the victims did not deserve there death but in a sarcastic way
@@mystic9806 yeah..I get that. Lol.
Can he show pictures of the people his brother murdered as well?
for real.
hes showing graphic photos to the public where children are,kinda fucked
He should also show the pictures of his murder victims as well.
@@SORRYBUTYOURENEXT, it's not really illegal, if you don't like it then don't look at it.
@Christian Ball he said showing those pictures is “kinda fucked”, not that it’s illegal. Don’t see how that statement proves he has a 60 iq and low bank account balance
@Christian Ball 558 Subscribers, huh? That's the difference between you and the IQ of mine. And trust me, *Me not that smart.*
He ASKED for the firing squad instead of lethal injection. If I were facing execution and had a choice I'd pick the gallows or firing squad before lethal injection.
I'd pick fighting an endless horde of katana wielding robots.
Shit I'd have em load up a .308 or 30-06 with v-max you'd be dead in a matter of seconds.
I'd choose death by Snu-Snu
Arkadiem nah, unga-bunga
unknown man no the first one is a sedative, second is a paralytic then the potassium chloride to stop the heart
Cost of Lethal Injection Chemicals to Tax Payer: $200
Cost of four .223 rounds to Tax Payer: $1
THEMilkSHAIKH and the cost of 35 years in prison?
Martin in the thousands per year.
Martin You're not accounting for the cost of death row, where people can remain for decades.
One Pilot the cost would be the same if they were not on death because the prison still has to house them lol.
metallicaandchimaira Not true. Death row requires higher security than normal prisons and the numerous appeals people on death row go through are more expensive as well. It works out more expensive to keep someone on death row than in a regular prison. I'm opposed to the death penalty for moral reasons most of all, but from a financial standpoint, it doesn't make that much sense, either.
the brother is a real piece of work. his family are not victims, the people Gardner killed are the victims.
1:34 if you look closely you can see the Simpsons playing
I SAW IT 😂😂
hey yeah you are right one of the employees there is watching simpsons
Yeah good spot.
Ronnie Lee Gardner killed a person with a shot in the face, in order to rob the victim of $100. Later, while he was being taken through a court building, a person near him was able to pass him a gun. Using this gun, he shot a court officer in the abdomen, and a court lawyer in the eye. The lawyer died. Unable to escape, Gardner threw the gun on the ground and surrendered. Later, while in prison, Gardner became intoxicated on alcohol which he had brewed in the sink of his cell. He used a shiv to stab another prisoner nine times in the face, mouth, arm and chest. Randy Gardner talks about his brother as though he is an innocent victim, but the reality is the clear opposite. His death by firing squad was an act of mercy. A truly just society would have killed him with a gunshot to the face, as he had inflicted on his two murder victims.
Dillon Heller how is a court officer a non human entity?
HellBound he’s just acting like a sovereign citizen don’t listen to him
No a good society would feed him to a giant pit of fire ants...
Sorry, there is no room for sick twisted people like this man.
Justice was served🇺🇸
BeaverTerror thank you for those facts man! People need to know this
A couple of rounds of ammo is so much cheaper than the drugs for lethal injection. It's quicker and less painful.
Can reload 9mm for like 10 cents a round. Only need one bullet to kill some one.
Germ .Fish isnt there 3 people in a firing squad?
I thought it was 5 but I suppose you could get away with less.
Jake Paul Yes, but two have blanks.
Tj Moran and you don’t have to train the executor nearly as much
Can’t imagine how he feels that he lost his brother to an execution but it’s not about him it’s about his brother and the lives he took, just because it makes him uncomfortable doesn’t mean a murderer should be cut some slack that’s another consequence of doing a horrible thing you family suffers as well.
Does his brother think the way the store clerk died was humane? I believe an eye for an eye. We need to send a message to these criminals To prevent further ruthless murdering. I don't believe in us taxpayers paying for their incarceration. If they are guilty without a doubt, put a bullet in their heads
If u live by the sword u die by it he actually said he lived by the gun and wished to be killed by it
It never ceases to amaze me when the family member points out how brutal their death was but never thinking on how much the actual victim suffered at the hands of their dearly beloved. I have no tears to waste on monsters
While I don’t have much sympathy for the murderer themselves, I do see that innocent family members can’t just hate the criminals guts. For all we know the family never would have known what they were capable of and always saw the murderer as a good person.
None of that means that the innocent care nothing at all about the victim/s. They just never saw a monster until that day.
It’s a complicated psychology that is hard to understand.
Justice is not about revenge. By that logic we end up with justifying all sorts of crazy acts like torture. The families are not justifying the actions, they are objecting to the taking of another’s life. You’re conflating the two things.
I guess the people his brother killed didn't hurt his feelings?
hes also not accounting for the fact that his brother felt 0 pain in death. the shock of impact would have protected him from pain until he died. its the most humane way to go. sudden. but humane. i hope the families feel peace knowing that hes gone. and I hope that his own family finds peace knowing he didnt suffer
Who cares his brother died instantly no pain idk what is with all the fuss
You have to realize that everyone has feelings, unless you’re a psychopath lacking empathy. It’s easy to be angry at this, but imagine seeing your brother laid out like that, regardless of the fact his brother was a terrible person and a murderer he probably still loved him.
Also, you don’t just shoot someone in the head and not feel unless you literally are incapable of remorse
It would hurt to see someone you grew up with your whole life full of holes and lifeless even if they did horrible things to other people.
Oh no they murdered my brother who killed a bunch of people.
benada83 put him down
Yes I do actually.
narek hardnock yes and I’d rather it cost less than lethal injection
That's pretty weird tbh. Why does letting the state do your killing make you any better?
Kaon there's a huge difference between killing innocent people and guilty evil monster. They lost there right, there not the victim and never will be.
"A firing squad aounds pretty grisly, frankly"
Wow that is some elite journalistic discovery from vice. Real empirical and accurate stuff
Honestly if i were a death row inmate id want to go by firing squad. Both more satisfying for the family of the victims and even though i dont really care for death tow inmates it lets you say something cool before you die like “alright lets do this”
Correct. So was the murder. Did the victim deserve such a violent end? You live by the gun you die by the gun. That's justice.
Just buy a rope and wooden platform
The hanging method has its own challenges, as one has to factor in the prisoner's weight, the length of the rope, etc. Otherwise, you get situations where the prisoner strangles to death (which can take a REALLY long time) or where the prisoner's head pops off (which can be REALLY traumatizing for anybody watching and/or cleaning up) or where the rope breaks and the prisoner doesn't die at all (which can be REALLY complicated, legally speaking).
RandomName Last Name does it say justin Y. Then?
Lol i was eating pizza,tasted better after i learned what he did
tintinismybelgian you’re supposed to have a bag on their head.. and the people watching are supposed to not be pussies
Or we could use that head-ripping-off machine they showed on ONN.
Fawkes4387 lmao!!
Say what? Where was this shown?
Clanton Blaylock ruclips.net/video/lfsMMVgIToA/видео.html
Yes
Fawkes4387 tht things scRry
The victims of this criminal had families too. Not crying a river over this.
Daniel Revas This is the problem with the American prison system. You handle executions based on your own revenge feelings. It's barbaric.
Aski i believe criminals should be treated the same way they treated their victims.
The Patriot We do not live in the stone age anymore. Every human deserves a second chance.
Think about this:
You get a new neighbour, but oh oh. He was just released from prison. You can choose one criminal that will live next to you. Who do you choose?
A) A criminal that has been locked in a cell, and treated with nothing but disrespect.
B) A criminal that got an education, learned to cook food and regrets what he did.
The obvious answer is B. The american justice system has to stop focusing on revenge. Yes, it feels good, but out justice system cannot be run by emotions. We have to make sure that society keeps running optimally, which is impossible if we ruin our criminals, instead of making them functioning, tax paying member of our society.
If you're actually interested, I recommend some of these clips about the norwegian justice system.
ruclips.net/video/jDjISR5OHa4/видео.html&t
ruclips.net/video/KPVPKEdCAwo/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/wgHdGr4aQoU/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/a7TfBLvw4FY/видео.html&t (This one is a full lenght documentary)
Aski
Your rebuttal is flawed. You are talking about a criminal that has been reformed through a recognizance of their own ways. They decided they were going to become a contribution to society instead of continuing to carry out acts of crime.
People who kill here and get the death penalty get it because they thought about it or did it heinously. It wasn't some person that accidentally struck and killed someone by running them over with a car. These people who get the death penalty get it because they are a drain on our taxation system to continue to support their life in a prison cell otherwise they would just go out and kill again. Those people are psychopathic and have no regard or remorse for life. If you were sentenced the death penalty here, i trust that the justice system was justified in that conviction. The justice system is not a revenge, it is there to replace the justice that a person of revenge would take. Get it straight.
Aski so a child rapist should be able to teach daycare by your rebuttal? Obviously we are not in the Stone Age but honestly these criminals often commit even more crimes upon release as well as when they remain in prison are detrimental to our nations tax system which could be money spent on something else like education or all of these social services that liberals teach. I’m all for executing these people honestly we should go back to hanging them instead of shooting them
When he said “it hurt my feelings” I laughed out loud 😂
Why? Is the famiy of a criminal worthless and without rights just because he is his brother? Are you insane or something?
I mean it's his brother obv he would care about his brother more than the victims its only natural
@@peteraugust5295 I don't care
You wouldn’t laughed if that was your brother
@@DilipKrJha-yb6nv WE, do not care
I can’t believe they actually showed the picture of him deceased 😱
Right before his brother murdered people did he stop and ask them if he was killing them humanly enough.
No but you have to get past whether the killer is a good person or not. They aren't. But they are alive, many mentally insane, but alive. Making them suffer is pointless if you are about to kill them. If you think about it objectively (which I tend to do), we should strive to make life as painless as possible, and it makes no sense to make another life suffer before death, even if that life belongs to a bad person.
That’s thinking like a sociopath. We are no better then them if we did so
so if someone skull fucks you're dead child you wouldn't want them to get fucking punished?
Rosez Of course I would want them to be punished. Who the hell wouldn't. There are two issues with that question. For one, I'm not saying that they shouldn't be punished, I'm saying we need to carefully consider how they are punished. Secondly, if my child gets skull fucked, then my opinion of the person who did it is legally irrelevant. I would be very biased at that point. That's why we don't let vigilantes enforce the law in this country.
RundownOyster your opinion isn’t irrelevant. Why do you think there are victim family impact statements before sentencing.
Wondering how many times he looked at the pictures of his brothers victims.
Jacob Kiser exactly
Why would he? He isn't responsible for someone else's actions, his brother is responsible for his own actions. The guy was probably just as shocked to even know his brother would do such a thing. The families grieve for their lost loved ones.. And may they find peace from their sorrow. Mind you, no one is saying to let a murderer roam free, but why is it wrong to feel sympathy for your own brother, flesh and blood, being blown apart?
Rongeli An I feel sympathy according to state sanctioned murderer yeah it was an execution
Rongeli An Agreed.
He probably did. It’s such a complex horrible situation and I feel bad for him, but the govt should understand his feelings are biased. I would be mad at my brother for putting me through that.
0:38 strapped to the bbc LMAO
People of the comments complaining about what the man said, I'm sure that he feels bad for the families of people who his brother killed but he's still a human being with a brother who was also a human being, and just because the cause of death was one less than hoped for doesn't mean that he's not allowed to feel remorse for his brother
"His brother was a human being". Yeah, let me catch u writing this if u were one of his victims. His brother was a cold-blooded monster.
@@primekrunkergamer188 he was still his brother. It would be devastating to see your brother full of holes after hs execution, monster or not. I don't think people realise that this is a punishment for randy's family as well.
Just show them a BuzzFeed video
You forgot that it had to be humane
Can’t be cruel and in humane
Somebody Somewhere too far
They'll bleed internally to death. That's horrible.
Buzzfed It’s honestly not that bad yes some of it is cringeworthy stuff but the most of it is actually rather fascinating
"Any last words?"
"I do not, no."
Why make it painless. The people they kill didn't get a painless death. They simply don't deserve it.
Because cruel punishments are unconstitutional.
A man asks "Do you have any last words?"
The prisoner says "I do not, no."
But those are your last words.
Let the prisoner chose. Hanging or Firing Squad
sharks should also be a choice.
Avocado Gaming
But wasn't that changed due to people's opinions in the first place?
It's obvious that when it comes to your own choice, someone will get into your business.
what about euthanasia roller coaster? i'd choose that
noose
I'm loving these replies, so far plenty of them have been just interesting ways to get executed. A new take on "your final meal"
What if you were to be executed by playing VR Darksouls, maximum 5 lives.
Murder is killing innocents, execution is killing criminals.
The DEA has killed many innocents! They must be executed!
@richards0406 47
Constitution says no.
@richards0406 47
In your opinion.
Seagle what do you consider "innocents"?
Seagle 1.how does killing someone make anything better? 2. What about those who are in innocent and sit on death row? Shouldn't we then also kill those who execute, soldiers who killed civilians, cops that shot unarmed people etc. ?
I was eating when I saw the pictures of the dead guy thanks vice great work
Executions should be public to teach children the consequences of crime.
The deterrence argument is so stupid.
If the consequences are the only thing preventing you from killing someone, you're pretty messed up internally.
I believe it could give people traumas and nightmares when they see people dying in front of them
@Jarrod Lamp I understand. But people who are no killers or don't intend to kill might find it disturbing.
@@stephenmystery8313 So messed up people should therefore not be deterred? You should think it through lol
Most people forget - this man requested the firing squad
“I lived by the gun, I will die by the gun”
He chose how he wanted to die
The fact he had a choice is humane as far as the law allows, unlike his victims.
It is true his victims were denied that choice - but judgement came by means he would die as he lived
The justice for the victims’ families is that he is dead no more to do any more harm
I don't you watched the entire clip.
"My brother killed several people and committed robbery, my feelings are hurt that people don't want someone like him in this world"
He probably meant the way this guy was killed. I cannot judge the laws of another state, the court has made it's decision but I think firing squads are just a bit more... gross.
LMAO I know. I wanted to give him some Prep H wipes for his goddamn butthurt.
@@beebster_v1 look up what he did. There was no compassion for his victims who probably suffered unimaginable pain. Next to that a well-placed shot is an act of Mercy in my opinion.
@@ashley-cn3rz i do not deny in any way what he did. I just personally think that killing him in anesthesia would be an act of mercy.
@@beebster_v1 yes it would be, I'm just conflicted with whether or not it should be shown
I'd prefer this to the lethal injection, very little chance of this going wrong, with so many guns being fired. The lethal injection has been botched on countless occasions.
Money going to education nah
Money going to keeping god awful humans alive yes
Tzaron you mean the money going to kill them? The appeals process of death row and administrative costs far outweigh that of feeding and housing a prisoner over a lifetime
@@KufLMAO Yeah lol its genuinely hilarious how many people say what this guy said when a single execution is more expensive than holding someone in life for prison.
@@plugshirt1762 dawg this was 4 years I think the death penalty is frickin sweet now *SLAMS TABLE* BRING ME MORE CRIMINAL SKULLS GRUG
Lethal injection drug: thousands
Bullet: >1$
You be the judge
Enclave Radio Man 24 cents a pop
i think you meant
Unfortunately is still cost over 1 million dollars just to get him to execution day
Enclave Radio Man well i mean that’s the bullet cost when everything comes together I’m talking abt leagal fees,guns,people who are signed up,legal actions... it ends up costing the state millions
I'm getting Paul Harrell vibes from this comment
“It’s not humane to Ronnie, it’s not humane to anyone.” Yeah, except you’ve forgotten that Ronnie wasn’t humane to anybody either.
And being inhumane back fixes it how?
Pete Smyth Personally I feel that once you’ve committed homicide you forfeit the right to humanity.
But its not about revenge its about justice.
I think you fundamentally misunderstand our justice system.
Fox
His victims died just as quickly. They were shot in the head.
The Death Penalty needs to be abolished.
Giving someone the death penalty is probably the kindest thing you can give a convicted murdered.
yeah, not like there is many cases in which afterwards they figured out he was innocent. Because obviously a jury court can not fail haha
what the hell
2:40
youtube age restrict videos with swear words but not this??
educational use thats why, vice is best friends with youtube trust
Yeah, unbelievable - I reported it.
I definitely would have liked warning even if it was for shock value
StaticStrike IKR
Welcome to America
Firing squad sure sounds archaic. But after googling it. It only took 2 minutes for the cornoner to pronounce this guy dead. Usually it takes 15 min to 8 hours for lethal injection. So.. Maybe this is better. I mean. What has been the best killing method for centuries? A gun.
Cheaper, faster, more effective, so why not? I mean, people thought the electric chair was more humane than firing squad, and look how that turned out.
Why don’t they use guillotine? I feel that would be the fastest
chris nemat the brain will still be active
Parnilli K Benally For like 20 seconds and it will be in shock. Better than 2 minutes after firing squad
Advocatus Diaboli That's just not true. There are been many many many instances showing that to not be true. I'm not saying firing squad is the way. But acting like the current injection is perfect is stupid and uneducated.
“It hurt my feelings” I’m sorry dude your brother hurt a lot of peoples feeling. Your brother took that from people including you.
I lost my shit and started busting out laughing when the brother said he felt like it was brutal I just think eye for an eye
You're sick
Most people forget the rest of the phrase
An eye for an eye… makes the whole world blind
@@dominicgunderson no he isn't
I would actually agree on this. As weird as this concept is, I just think firing squad is the most quickest and merciful death. Lethal injection just seems too slow
Hanging was always fast and effective. And public hanging deterred other criminals. It's a perfect system.
Except that hangings could also go wrong, where the neck wouldn't snap but you'd instead choke to death. In modern times, death by nitrogen asphyxiation would be the fastest, cheapest, and most humane.
@@ElusiveTy I don't see how that is a factor, honestly. Maybe the convict should've thought about how he was going to die before committing crimes.
Gaelan Brewer Maybe the person next to him was innocent. Maybe the person next to that guy was innocent
Too slow for the observer maybe, if everything goes right you just go out within seconds without feeling anything.
3:25 "It hurts my feelings."
Let me guess, the feelings of the families whose relatives were murdered by this guy aren't important, right?
You’re not wrong but still it does hurt if you’re family died.
He didn’t say it wouldn’t
Feelings and emotions should always make way for logic.
What does him being killed do for the families? Bring back their dead relative?
The brother didn't do anything wrong tho
"Everyone finds god before they die" a cold ass line
I’m genuinely surprised that we were allowed to see his corpse uncensored
Same that never happens
The corner also released morgue photos of Ted Bundy after he was executed too
Hmm I would be all for the death penalty if we knew with 100% certainty that every person on death row was NOT falsely convicted.
Vice has covered dozens of stories where people had been wrongfully convicted of awful crimes and it's hard to bare people being executed for crimes they did not commit.
This man was found guilty of multiple murders. False imprisonment is a reality, that's why death row inmates sit in prison for years and years before actually being executed. There's time to go over everything and double, triple, quadruple check that this inmate is guilty.
@@baileyhellmuth5526 And yet there has been plenty of executions where new evidence has shown that they were not guilty after their deaths. Especially against people that are outcasts or looked down upon by society.
@@krabbcake8371 think about it this way most if those false executions were way back then. That means no way to get fingerprinted, no technology that we have now. If you break into some ones house and murder them there's not much you can do if you don't have a witness. You can't search for DNA is fingerprints. Usually outcast or scums commit murder. Scums and outcast were usually the first ones to be looked at. If there's no witnesses what are they going to do.
Not just falsely convicted but unfairly convicted too. Unless you are pedophile, child killer, mass murderer, serial killer then you shouldn't be on the death row.
@@ihadtodancetosurvive1824 That's an awfully short list.
I think what the brother of the executed forgets is that his brother murdered a few people himself. Where was their humanity?
two wrongs don't make a right, We make ourselves more like his brother by killing him.
Alexander Colon the prisoner gets books, tv, meals, the chance to see loved ones and family, a view of the sky, warm showers, the opportunity to meet and connect with other people. The chance to grow, and tell others that they love them, and the chance to atone and make amends to those they have wronged to lesser degrees. The murder victim gets none of that. Justice demands, you take a life, you pay with your own.
Europa: That's not as many in the modern age as we think, but every single one is still a tragedy.
Strongly disagree
Falstad007 if you don't have siblings you won't understand
No it's not terrible, it's the best way
1:34 they have the simpsons on...
I wonder if his brother was having nightmares about the multiple people his brother killed, let's recap (warning extremely graphic). From wikipedia Gardner shot bartender Melvyn John Otterstrom in the face, killing him...(after capture while trying to escape trial) he wounded unarmed bailiff George "Nick" Kirk in the abdomen...then while running through the building he came across a man doing pro-bono work for his church when Gardner shot him in the eye. Otterstrom, a mountain climber and veteran of the 19th Special Forces Group of the Utah National Guard, was survived by his wife Kathy and his five-year-old son, Jason.[15] Burdell was a Vietnam veteran, former engineer, and member of the Summum Church.
By the by the man shot in the eye did not die right away, he suffered for 45 minutes before dieing in the hospital. Hey man your brother was a wild animal that could not control himself and the just thing to do was to put him down.
I agree
Killing another human being will always feel immoral no matter the method, but I think that the least we can do is make sure that it's the quickest and least painful way possible
It feels bad not immoral, we must all do things we dislike.
Star Cherry maybe dont do it at all?
Nitrogen suffocation (all copied and pasted from the internet)
According to the U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board, in humans, "breathing an oxygen deficient atmosphere can have serious and immediate effects, including unconsciousness after only one or two breaths. The exposed person has no warning and cannot sense that the oxygen level is too low."
Also,
Physiologically inert gases (those that have no toxic effect, but merely dilute oxygen) are generally free of odor and taste. As such, the human subject detects little abnormal sensation as the oxygen level falls. This leads to asphyxiation (death from lack of oxygen) without the painful and traumatic feeling of suffocation
@@de0509 neat
some people deserve to die for what they did that way a mass murderer cant weasel his way out of prison
Hell yeah, with a firing squad you can yell 'long live Stalin' before they shoot.
Yes, the answer is yes.
Mercy to the cruel is cruelty to the innocent.
some people are angry the way these people get executed but remember some of these people probably murdered a lot of people in worse ways
Can we get 5000 subscribers with no videos? That makes it okay to turn the squad to murderers?
Eye for an eye
city untill everybody is blind. Interesting to see that the US is on a level with China and other undemocratic countries
Eye for an eye makes the whole world blind
+Douwe Huysmans would you prefer feeding and housing a serial killer until he dies ?
1 bullet doesn;t cost much and is instant.
Duchess only in the best case
Duchess Stirling archer
they actually use 4
A knife is reusable :)
The only problem with that is that someone has to be on the other end pulling the trigger. No one should ever have to or want to be that person...
i know his brother was a killer but you can’t blame him for being hurt. he didn’t know his brother as a murderer so seeing those pictures really did get to him.
He isn't a victem of murder. He brother killed two people and yet he bitching about how he is the victim.
After a quick google search I found out that a 9mm bullet costs about $0.16 cents. Why not?
The vast majority of the cost of capital punishment is not in the method of execution itself, but rather the associated legal costs. (deathpenaltyinfo.org/costs-death-penalty)
9mm bullet? lol. You would have needed a much bigger bullet than that to cause those wounds. I bet they used close to a 50 cal.
Public hanging! Yayyy !!! Much better entertainment than RUclips vids.
So it 16 cents or .16 cents?
Those bullet holes were not caused by any 9mm lol
Breaking news: Family member of executed man disagrees with execution. More at 11.
TheCptCoy best comment
In other news... Water.. Wet!
He said it was a coping method. What would you do if someone you grew up with ur whole life was killed like that and saw the photos? Just ignore it. I mean you can say that but no one will fucking believe you.
Christian Kerr That doesn’t make it not murder.
The law is simple, you kill someone and you can face death, you don't get to decide someone else can die and then live the rest of your life in a prison cell protected by guards and given a decent life. And don't say it isn't decent, you get free food, water, bedding, medical care, and are cared for through ANYTHING that happens to you.
Some ppl are just unbelievable when it comes to being considerate to the victim’s family and holding ppl who commit heinous crimes accountable. His brother chose his fate when he decided to kill others.
Looks like a good method to me, maybe use a larger size round.
"We feel like victims of a state sanctioned murder" uhm buddy, your brother had committed multiple murders.
Jacob R If my mom killed someone, I’d be hurt that she would do it, but she would get what’s coming to her regardless.
I prefer the head ripper
Justin Y. For once, I kinda agree with the commie
The onion!
@mike cafamo r/woooosh
😂😂 that video is a fake tho
@@PabloEscobar-gu8sd r/woooosh
"inhumane suffering", what a joke.
How about an automated gun that does job? The person pushing the button will probably feel less guilty than an executioner who might have trauma later on
Honestly it pisses me off so much that his brother had a problem with his brother dying despite all the people his brother murdered.
It's stupid for you to say that. He didn't tell his brother to kill innocent people.
yeah it terrible, what his brother did, and to us hes a monster. i have no sympathy for the man, but for his brother i can empathize. we all love somebody, and to realize that your flesh and blood was a murderer would be devastating. to then see his corpse filled with holes would destroy anybody
marcellbuscemi x
the main problem is on the way he was killed, not the fact that he was killed
marcellbuscemi his brother wasn’t murdered he’s punished fool
Just make them listen to nickelback
Dude no...Holy shit you monster
Fear America we're trying to kill them quickly not make them suffer
Fear America nigga you a ice cold ass nigga. Damn nigga
The 8th Amendment states that cruel and unusual punishment is not allowed 🤣
lol ^
My family said they should do publuc execution again and was like "it'll teach any kids not to get into jail"
It's actually funny you mention this I watched a documentary on all the different executions and hanging was the most popular back than and the states would hold goal public hanging executions like it was the new years partys we have in New York city, but basically they stopped because it made people more violent and violent crimes occurred just minutes and hours after a public hanging plus it was promoting death to the public like coca cola promotes drinking soda
The number of people who appear to think the penal system is basically a state-run revenge system is honestly alarming
Was not ready for that picture god damn
TrendSource fr a warning would have been nice 😂😂
Yhea, they could have warned
TrendSource lol snowflake
Tom Smyth being shocked by photos of a gory death being suddenly displayed without warning doesn't make you a "snowflake" dumbass
burritoking180 Fr 😂😂
I feel bad for the brother there, but he's not thinking about the victims and what his brother did to them. That's a "terrible terrible murder", too. I have a hard time reconciling to holding the murderers hand because he found Jesus hanging out in the corridors of prison. Strange Jesus wasn't hanging around with the victims. He got what he had coming.
Yep, every time I hear people try to make it seem wrong to execute bad people who commit serious violent crimes I always ask what about their victims' rights?
Elisa Mastromarino I couldn’t have said it better myself, you wanna date?
I have to disagree. Killing people for killing people is like trying to right a wrong with a wrong. What we should be doing is giving people rehabilitation and correcting them so they can be a part of society once more. Even if a loved one of mine was murdered, I'd still say that the murderer deserves to be rehabilitated and brought back into society, because killing him wouldn't be righting a wrong, it would just make it even wronger.
Justice is an abstract concept. For some, it would be justice to kill shoplifters or jaywalkers. Abduction and murder, however, are fairly straightforward. In a sense, cops are, in fact, state-sanctioned abductors, as they are taking people by threat of potentially lethal force. Most would agree, however, that this is necessary to some extent to maintain order in our society.
Likewise, executioners are committing state-sanctioned murder, as they are taking the life of another person outside of self-defense. Some people, again, believe this is a necessary facet of a society that wishes to maintain order. On this point, I must disagree. There is always the option to keep killers in prison. To kill them as retribution serves only to soothe the crying of the families of victims by creating another grieving family, and at an enormous cost to the public.
William Mendes Humbane No way! Once you have went down that dark path of taking another life, it becomes nothing but easier for them to commit the same act again.
DOKXtv:*becomes firing squad member*
Also DOKXtv:*starts drinking mountain dew and 360 noscoping people*
if its a murderer they should let the victim's family be the squad to send him off.
I heard theres a head ripper.
That's only in Ohio though
It’s fake dude lmao, The Onion type shit
@@jojobateria23
What are you talking about? It's the most legit story out there *BRO* . This dude is trippin.
Bobby Bush lmao
It’s the most painless way to kill someone my guy lol
"we felt like we're victims of a murder"
Your brother killed people. Now you know how his victims' family members feel.
hmm.... very dumb comment bro, do you understand what you said? You're satisfied because the brother of a criminal feels bad... Imagine (really hope never happens to you btw) if they do the same with someone from your family... how would you feel? are you gonna continue to see your state the same as before? i don't think so bro.... see, even is isn't you the person who pulls the trigger, all people ALL people of that state are responsible of the death of that persone. Solution time: LIFE SENTENCE so none gonna have bloody hand and prisoner gonna work to gain his life till he die
Iss993 ITA thats the problem with people man !
They never seem to realise the ‘what if’ scenario !
I mean okay the criminals deserve it and no matter what, the victim’s families can never be repaid.
While the criminal deserves it, even then, his close family members will always feel grief and regret at their close one’s death !
@@ismaeelrossan2728 Death is imminent to every immortal being. Murderers deserve death even if they didn't die out naturally. They KILLED someone innocent who probably was a mother, a child, a caring father or loving sibling and it also messed up their family members. It's a traumatizing situation for them to lose someone they love the most! So what you sow is what you reap! When you kill someone innocent who has done you no harm you too deserve to die no matter what your family thinks. The same pain is deserved to be felt by the murderer and his family too. The fact that he's a murderer says alot about his wrong upbringing by the ones who raised him as well as his own actions that he's done over the period of his life time. So executioning him means both families suffer on equal measures. Ofcourse, the pain will be unbearable for the murderer's family too but his/her conscious action to kill someone INNOCENT without emotion and mercy deserves no mercy.
Ivy A. Vaz yes I totally agree with you on this !
Mercy should not be shown to these people since they never had or showed it in the first place !
While the murderer’s family will probably feel saddened (most of them) , it does not change the fact that this man who was executed totally deserves it !
To rob someone’s life is a deceitful and unforgivable sin IMO !
Mercy should not be shown to these people !
Treating them as a human being with the rest of us itself seems overly cared for !
@@ivyvaz well, if you think soo... 👀
I swear 20% of Americans are intent on bringing the USA back into the 19th century 🤣
What rounds were they using for the execution? Very large entry wounds. Seems like a single headshot with a relatively low powered round would be cleaner as long as the head was secured well enough.
Firing squad>all
then they'll complain ammo manufacturers are lobbying for it
I'd vote for them being covered in molasses, strung up, then bring wild pigs or farmed pigs in. No one pulls a trigger. Pigs get fed. Circle of life.
Lusion except gas is expensive and dosent actually work very well*
Tony Brion Normal decomposition by bacteria is still circle of life.
Jon Smith I am curious as to how the hell was the gas chamber even invented as an execution method?
And now you know how his victims felt. Sorry but no pity here.
Why should the families of criminals be made to suffer when they aren't party to the crime? The families of criminals are just as innocent as the families of victims; neither deserves to have a loved one taken away. To murder a murderer does nothing to bring back the victim. If the goal is to punish the criminal, we have a whole penal system dedicated to that end. All extra killing does is create another permanently broken family.
BeanSand agreed. We have no more right to take a life than the murderer has. The death penalty has no place in the modern world and the US should do what most developed countries have already done and abolish it.
No. Keep the death penalty.
BeanSand By your logic, we shouldn't put anyone in prison, because by doing so the families of the criminals would be suffering, i.e. a child will lose his or her father, a wife will lose her husband. There comes a point where you draw the line and enact punishment that is fit to the crime committed, not anymore nor any less. Everything is jolly in your la la land, but in the real world we have things called deterrents that keep people from doing terrible things to each other.
nygeek64 and we have no evidence to believe the death penalty deters crime. In fact the states where capital punishment is in use generally have a higher crime rate than those without.
I was not prepared for when they showed the picture of the aftermath🤯
Fill those damn flat tires with some NITROGEN please..........
Think what your brother did to the innocent people he killed.your brother committed a horrible murder . You need a wake up call
Gator Guy You expect his own brother to stand against him? My brother would be last person I'd let down in front of anyone. He's the only person I can ever rely on, I trust him more than I trust myself.
Chicken Fight I’m not saying he should stand against his own brother at all. His brother is trying to end capital punishment because his brother went out that way. He’s not thinking about the other family that was the victim and lost there family member . If my brother killed people I know that he’s going to face consequences for that crime. I would be by his side but stay neutral after the fact . (Why ) both families had a lost for no reason,
Whatever is cheaper.
Amen!
Yup
The cheapest way is to drop the criminal to a river full of crocodiles. Or send them to North Korea border, where the North Korean soldiers will shoot him for free. The only they need to pay is a plane ticket.
Thank you, sir
pinoy426 atleast the US is a 1st world country not like he philippines we know how to handle our country dont decide for others
Without watching the video I can already say
Yes damn it.
Randy saying it hurt his feelings is just the quintessential thing wrong with this country.
Poor murderer gets murdered.
LMAO
Lol 360 no scoped
aikam007 Lmaoooo
Victory .Studios Across the map lmfao
it was a killing not a murder. there's a difference.
if there is irrefutable evidence that the accused actually did comit murder/s then they deserve the same death they caused the victim.
Daywalker777r well I would say yes but if it is particularly brutal then that could actually mess with a “normal” person’s mind as well all know that murderer’s are often mentally ill to some point
But who would be the person to, say, cut up the actual criminal with a chainsaw?
Mobile Mayhem invent a robot
You going to volunteer to choke someone to death while ass raping them? Cut someone up and eat them? The problem is anyone who volunteers is as big a piece of shit as the person who committed the crime.
"you know, we felt like we were victims of a state-sanctioned murder" what the actual f-
The brother feels he's the victim of a killing, wow! And yet his brother killed several innocent people.
Lost for words.
i think the person that's going to die should get to choose the way they die. it's an easy solution.
welcome to hell they should give them pre set options in that case. But the whole point of execution is dehumanization. They lose their ability to make the choice
pretty sure that they do sometimes or in certain states
What if he/she chooses "old age"?
When you commit a crime and become a prisoner you forfeit most of your rights. After all the innocent people that this man murdered didnt get to choose how they died, so why should he get to?
@@abreknoxcho damn straight
I don't feel bad for the criminals but I do feel bad for the families of them.
MD Supreme if my family killed a person for no reason they arent my family anymore.
I feel bad for the taxpayers who spend more on a death penalty prisoner than it would cost for life with no parole.
The criminal's families are hypocrites.
So Tim, you wouldn't accept a cop, soldier or hangman in your family?
MD Supreme I hear you on that. I consider the family is going to grieve no matter what, knowing their child or sibling conducted a heinous act, perhaps they will be at ease knowing they will not commit them anylonger. Is it more humane to die in the hands of the state than by the hands of the state? I would hope the criminal would be met with a chance of redemption of their character then put to death.
Oohh I didn't expect a picture of the body
probably more traumatising to spectators but yeah it should replace lethal injections
I don't know...although firing squad seems to be humane on some level, I would suggest that it was done remotely, so that no actual person has to stand there holding a gun shooting a guy. It can really mess you up, no matter who you're shooting, to kill someone.
If it messes you up to kill somebody, then don't do it.
loads of people are completely detached from everything, they can do it.
They choose like 4-5 people and they are behind a partition type thing and the guns are already aimed at the inmate all they have to do is pull the trigger. Also I think only two guns have live ammo in them so nobody knows who actually shot the kill shot. My brother worked at the Utah State prison and told me this is how it's done.
I think it's like one gun has a blank, and all of them are shooting live ammos. There is way more than 2 bullets in that picture that's for sure
komorebi木漏れ日 Well the guy who made the machine probably feels guilt and so does the operator
I laughed when he said that his brothers execution was murder.
Well he's not too far off for a few philosophical reasons I wont get into.
It's a deterrent, I guess.