Rightly said Matthew..Mother mary was born to St. Anna and St. Joaquim..n they had only one daughter. That is Mother Mary.. the other names are the tittles given to her from the places she appeared.
Mathew, I like the way, you explain every word, so carefully that everyone can surely understand. Thank you very much, for coming out with this topic. 🙏🙏🌷
Very good explaned Bro Methew There is only one our heavenly mother that is mother of our God Jesus Christ different name's are given only this is my faith from the Holy Bible i believe 🙏 God bless you Bro Methew 🙏
Bab Mathew please correct yourself regarding the place where st. Jerome's church stands in which the milagris saibin feast is held, this property belongs to the communidade of mapusa an not of any family an there was no temple over there infact it was a hilly area. Regarding construction of the church, it was built by gaunkars of mapusa under the guidance of missionary priests.
You are a ghati from maharashtra Rahul hq1dd what history you will know about our goa. Rss popot an member of rss IT cell. You only tell me if you say that you are a goan then tell me you are a gaunkar of which village of goa an also your real name because you are using a fake ID to post comments.
Ghatia from maharashtra rss popot an member of rss IT cell an commenting using multiple fake ID'S. Ghatia Rahul hq1dd you don't even know the present history of goa an what you will know about past history of our goa? You only tell me you are a gaunkar of which village of goa if you say that you are a goan and also your real name because you are using a fake ID to post comments. Ghatia.@Rahul hq1dd.
Arree ghatia from maharashtra rss popot Rahul hq1dd member of rss IT cell ghatia if you want to meet then come to panjim bus stand I will be happy to meet you. I think you are commenting from nagpur that's the reason you can't come to panjim. It is ghatis like you who call panjim as panaji but we niz goenkars calls it ponje ghatia.
But in name of sister sister Both religion mix with each other Hindus are going for feast And Catholics are going for jatra, calling both as SAIBIN ❤ let be united
What about livrament saibinn? is Livrament a place? There is only one Biblical saibinn which is Mother of Jesus Mother Mary .Rest all Names are given by churches to celebrate different feasts. Specially in Goa most of the churches named as different Saibinn . However there is no church in Goa named as Mother Mary .Why?
Yes you are right! We Christians knows that,but some who dont know should know and i really appreciate the way you put it up brother thank you and God bless you.
U r misguiding here. She was not conceived vtout sin . She was a virgin who conceived our Savior Jesus Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit. Plz get this right.
@@zamiradsa8995 The Catholic Church was founded by Jesus through His words to Peter. Therefore whatever the Church teaches is divinely inspired. This is in the gospel of Matthew. "You are Peter and on this rock I shall build my church and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. Whatever you bind shall be bound, and whatever you loose shall be loosed.
@@mariaanadacosta1409 2 Timothy 3:16 All Scripture is given by inspiration by God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, Now, u plz show me the Scripture in the Holy Bible where it says that Mary (the mother of Jesus was conceived vtout sin and also the Scripture saying that the teachings of the Catholic church are divinely inspired. Read from the Book of Prophet Hosea chp 4 vs 6 Ask the Holy Spirit to guide u
0:12 Mother Mary had no sisters. She was spotted in different places, so she got the named ofb 0:220:220:250:260:33 different places.that photo milagris saibinn shud be removed from that picture. They are giving a wrong picture for our future generations. Also make a video on our lady of renedious, and cuncolkann. People believe that they are sisters and also they say that they are all seven Sisters. I don't know how they have created stories.
You have opened the eyes of our hindu bhav . Even some of the ignorant catholics. Christians open your eyes. This is modern world we are not in olden days, where people said and other believed.
These tales were created by the 77 IQ POGO poseurs who flooded into Bardez last century. Catholic Goans, as usual, bent over backwards for the outsiders and became a minority in their own backyard.
Matters of faith are not based on absolute rationality and I don't think we should question their beliefs I think most Christians are aware that Mother Mary had no sisters but that does not imply we can stop others from believing that she has a sister In fact their belief helps to build a bridge of unity and harmony among the two religious communities which is a dire need in India today as there are forces working very hard to sow communal disharmony
Well explained Bro.All these years I was waiting that a priest will give an explanation on this topic.Let the faith be at one point but truth is truth.May God bless you
In bible say only mother Mary is jesus mother . Who change her name? Mother Mary seen many places at jesus time . No change d name . Brother only u tell me which name I must praise jesus mother . Those who accept bible they praise mother Mary n religion praise many mothers .
@@lenoygomendes1380 believe in bible n don't listion of devil. U have mother did u change yr mother name ? Who brought to birth n whom we r praising. Fatima valakhani n ect man made mother
Very good explanation son Methew there is only one our heavenly Mother that is mother of our Lord Jesus Christ different name’s are given .God bless you son 🙏💜
Nicely done👏🏼liked the way u explain it bro without hurting anyone(jst real facts), yes thrs something with that place ,nw hindus say that thr ws templen idol thr may b u shld do more videos on this (bring in more document n proofs)n ppl shld go in debt to find history n accept d truth n nt jst sit n say cholta te bore asa
Please if you don't have proper information don't make this type of video. You can directly go to Mapusa Church and asked for the information. It's wrong on your part to ask if anybody has the details to share. This are sensitive issue. Don't give rise to communal actives who are just waiting
Very true , and no one had asked you about it, by putting such videos on social media looks like uzwad jai mhunon ghor petovpak sodtaa ........ Aasu tuji aasu na jaalyer mhaji kide farak podtaa.....tujyaa jantyani jaav te mhaje jaante, kenaa oslo dubaav ghevknaa, je cholta te choloni
Isn't the government supposed to do it?? The Foral documents of Salcete is available...why not Bardez tiswaddi and so on?? Why is the Goa Government sleeping over it for past 12 years?
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357, according to my sources, most of the Portuguese records from Panjim were burned at Porvorim after the illegal Indian annexation of Goa in 1961.
I request u to do one video on shantadurga kunkalikarin, before that do visit the village and question local Christians about their saying on kunkalikarin.... ask them why Christians are given right to take out satryo from temple? Ask them why they flock in large no. In satryo? Ask them wht shantadurga kunkalikarin means to them ? Ask them why many of them donated gold to Kunkalikarin? You will get your answer...
Your genetic 77 IQ is showing again. That nonsensical behaviour didn't start till last century, when the dumb chardos of that village started believing Shantaram Naik's attempt to rewrite the Cuncolim Massacre as a nationalist revolt. Now that Goans know the full story (the majority of those killed by the chardos were other Goans from Salcette), the reputation of Cuncolim chardos has sunk even further.
Those who don't know Bible,they can talk anything,you are whatever is said its true,mother of Jesus only maria (mary)but we knows different types of names, but she didn't have any sisters n brothers
The meaning of belive itself says that something which is possible, but not certain. Do we believe that we have two hand, or do we know that we have two hands. When you make believe system a reality problem starts generating and you will be in trouble mentally as well as physically
Hats off to you for explain this to people, we Christian know the truth mama mary is the only child of her parents and her son is jesus, and her birth place is Jerusalem and they are Israelites. In Christian religion there are many saints but mama mary is the only one, hence she is known by many names according the way she appeared to people like Velankanni in India.
What he is sayin is right... Sadly ppl hav got used to it since years and now if we speak truth also ppl will drag us to police station as they got all powers
How can u say that ur sister is Hindu when your christian ...these were only beliefs in olden days ....even parish priest of St Jerome's Church wants to stop this
My mom had told me that Saibin maim is just one, daughter of st.anna & st.joaquim, mother of Jesus, was seen at different places, like Fatima, Lourdes, Madras, etc. That doesn't mean, there r different saibins, now since our hindu brothers & sisters have accepted our lady of milagres as d sister of leirei Devi let it b and let them continue with their belief even after your factual explanation, because this belief of theirs bind us together to maintain communal harmony amongst us. V r all brothers & sisters, v r humans, let's continue living here on earth with love, peace & joy. Ur topic was good indeed 💯
No, they're making up fairytales as part of their POGO posing. There weren't any such stories till the last century when Marathi migrants started flooding into Bardez.
It will be helpful if you can shed some light on how and when the practice of pouring oil started. This looks like a very old tradition. I don't see this in any other church dedicated to Mother Mary in Goa. Whatever faith one holds, I don't see any issue with someone putting oil as is being done now.
What are you trying to achieve from the this video? Don't try to find logic in religion! Basically you are further alienating catholic faith from India. And creating differences with Hindu. Serves no purpose.
Your right I thought in this world only me knows the truth about holy mother marry good to knw in this world there are also some people who knows about holy mother marry........ Marry never had sister she had cousins sisters n they where all christians...
Why would u even want to rake up this topic now? We know what it is! Period! Those who want to believe, let them. These are not times to add fuel to fire (which isn't ur intention). Its just common sense! Yes we are in modern times but sadly religion is facing the brunt. So don't make such videos. Enough issues already. Its nice that both religions come together.
No, he has to speak the truth. The harsh reality is that this was a 77 IQ fairytale created by Marathi migrants who flooded into Bardez last century, while doing POGO posing. It has no basis in either Christianity or Hinduism.
Mother Mary is the Only daughter of Anna and Joaquin .God appointed her to becomes the Mother of his child.......never believe that nowadays this hindus creat story be careful
Thank you for explaining this very clearly. I wish many of our Christians in other parts of Goa understand this too well, where they believe that Mother Mary is the sister of some Goddess or the other
Very well explained. I like the way you break the subject to basics and explain each facet clearly and calmly. Well done. Please keep it up. I try not to miss watching your videos.
Why do we have to go 500 years backwards? This is the Strategie of the bjp. Divide and rule... Other states in between Hindus and Muslims and here in goa between Hindus and Christians... I think our PM takes tuitions from the central govt.
We know Mother May was a humble Jewish girl/woman who found favor with the Almighty. Mary never considered herself as Goddess, her Canticle " ... for He has looked with favor on His lowly servant......He has come to help of His servant Israel.." She was not colonial , she was Jewish, she cared about her Jewish people, the same Jewish people who killed her Son. The European/Roman spiritual landscape was polytheistic with many Goddesses, Venus -the Goddess of love, Juno- Goddess Of women well being, Minerva - Goddess of Wisdom and many others. But when the Roman empire embraced Christianity . They honored Mother Mary like their Goddess , as our Catholic dogma, She is the Queen of heaven. It's called syncretism , a merging of beliefs. And we cannot forget our Hindu roots, so all our former Goddesses reincarnated into Our Blessed Mother. The concept of reincarnation was prevalent in Our Lord's time , even in the Gospels, when Our Lord asked his disciple who do people think I am? and the response was John the Baptist, who was beheaded , Jeremiah and some other prophets of old. Of course Peter's response was sublime " you're the Messiah, the Son of the Living God" and Our Lord response was , " “Blessed are you, Simon (Peter) son of Jonah, for this was not revealed to you by flesh and blood, but by my Father in heaven” this was the moment of truth, when Peter identified our Lord, who He was? Son of the Living God, who walked our Planet.
Your genetic 77 IQ is showing again. There's no syncretism, just fairytale made up by Marathi migrants doing POGO posing when they entered Bardez last century.
Why can't all priest in Goa preach the truth on the blessed Virgin Mary, and the mama Mary in St Jeromes Church Mapusa Goa according to the Bible Mary was the only child of St. Joachim and St. Ana. Mama Mary never had any sisters or brothers. It's truth this can't be hidden even our Pope head of the Roman Catholic Church preaches this truth what has the bishop of Goa has to say about it.
Mely. All priest preach now n then especially during her feast. I think either u don’t attend mass regularly or u don’t know the doctrine of the church
Why are u even discussing this topic you will be the next target just keep this topic out do u want to put more petrol in the fire. You cannot change peoples mind as long as everyone are are in peace and harmony stay away from these topics.
It's called the LEGEND OF SEVEN SISTERS. It is important to understand the meaning of the word "legend". According to the online Cambridge Dictionary, Legend means a very old story or set of stories from ancient times, or the stories, not always true, that people tell about a famous event or person. Given that the Portuguese Inquisition/rule had long-lasting impact, the wrath of which is still persistent, our ancestors may have come up with this tale to maintain harmony amongst religions. In my opinion, if this maintains peace and harmony, so be it. ✌️
Your genetic 77 IQ is showing again. This "7 sisters" nonsense didn't start till the last century, when Marathi migrants started flooding into Bardez while doing their POGO posing. It's part of the 77 IQ Dharmic concoction with hathkatro, forced conversions, Inquisition atrocities, etc.
There is only one heavenly mother befoe creation of world and she is living amongst us and even her name is written in holy bible,God the the creator name,holy spirit name and jesus second coming name.....and that's only God's choosen children knows as written in bible
@@Rahul-K1822Your genetic 77 IQ is showing again. There's no relation between Mary and Lairai. That fairytale was made up by Marathi migrants flooding into Bardez last century as part of their POGO posing.
Please pass on correct information or please be prepared on correct story before posting video just don't do it to get subscribers and likes.. nonsense 😡😡😡
Atam devacher chod video yeta .. Ami tar munta ami sogllim bhav bhoinam zalear amchem natem khoinchean ani khoim sodpachem , so dista ami mandit aileavm tem ami sambalyea ani ani vinoti koruyea ani sounsarantle fudle dis bore baxen saruyea.
@@dipteshnaik4317 truth hurts isn't it.....yes we can decide .... We are the ones affiliated to the faith and who believe in Mary Mother of Christ...and it's a definite history....don't dilute it
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357Thr are many truth wic ul not accept so simply don't creat ur own things whatever it may it's ppl beliefs and u can't stop anyone ppl have faith and thy will believe..
Rightly said Matthew..Mother mary was born to St. Anna and St. Joaquim..n they had only one daughter. That is Mother Mary.. the other names are the tittles given to her from the places she appeared.
Mathew,
I like the way, you explain every word, so carefully that everyone can surely understand. Thank you very much, for coming out with this topic.
🙏🙏🌷
Very good explaned Bro Methew
There is only one our heavenly mother that is mother of our God Jesus Christ different name's are given only this is my faith from the Holy Bible i believe 🙏
God bless you Bro Methew 🙏
I always believed that mother mary never had a sister
What Believe ,,,🤔,,,Its there in our Holy Bible ,,,they only. Spreading false beliefs ,,to ,take over our ,places .n properties.
Bab Mathew please correct yourself regarding the place where st. Jerome's church stands in which the milagris saibin feast is held, this property belongs to the communidade of mapusa an not of any family an there was no temple over there infact it was a hilly area. Regarding construction of the church, it was built by gaunkars of mapusa under the guidance of missionary priests.
Right.. There was no temple.. Matthew before coming out with some information please get your facts clear.. You'll unnecessarily create problems..
@@Rahul-K1822you are a ghati what history a ghati like you will know about our goa?
You are a ghati from maharashtra Rahul hq1dd what history you will know about our goa. Rss popot an member of rss IT cell. You only tell me if you say that you are a goan then tell me you are a gaunkar of which village of goa an also your real name because you are using a fake ID to post comments.
Ghatia from maharashtra rss popot an member of rss IT cell an commenting using multiple fake ID'S. Ghatia Rahul hq1dd you don't even know the present history of goa an what you will know about past history of our goa? You only tell me you are a gaunkar of which village of goa if you say that you are a goan and also your real name because you are using a fake ID to post comments. Ghatia.@Rahul hq1dd.
Arree ghatia from maharashtra rss popot Rahul hq1dd member of rss IT cell ghatia if you want to meet then come to panjim bus stand I will be happy to meet you. I think you are commenting from nagpur that's the reason you can't come to panjim. It is ghatis like you who call panjim as panaji but we niz goenkars calls it ponje ghatia.
Mother Mary had no sister she had a cousin Elizabeth but not from India
But in name of sister sister
Both religion mix with each other
Hindus are going for feast
And Catholics are going for jatra, calling both as SAIBIN ❤ let be united
Yes, very true but it looks like no one is interested to stop .....I request to stop commenting on social media
Mixing of religion is dilution of truth...we can still be united and respect each other's belief without compromising on the teachings and truth
You have spoken very clearly without hurting any religious sentiments. As Catholics we have to accept this fact that Mother Mary is not a GODDESS!
It's important to read the Bible as it is the true word of God.
If anyone doesn't wish to discuss and learn , should not comment.
What about livrament saibinn? is Livrament a place? There is only one Biblical saibinn which is Mother of Jesus Mother Mary .Rest all Names are given by churches to celebrate different feasts. Specially in Goa most of the churches named as different Saibinn . However there is no church in Goa named as Mother Mary .Why?
Yes you are right! We Christians knows that,but some who dont know should know and i really appreciate the way you put it up brother thank you and God bless you.
We hv only one heavenly mother mary
Heavenly Mother is Jerusalem,
Gal 4:26.
Mother of our soul's.
@@manuelmilagresdcosta125 heavenly mother is mother Mary boy
U r misguiding here. She was not conceived vtout sin . She was a virgin who conceived our Savior Jesus Christ by the power of the Holy Spirit. Plz get this right.
The Church teaches that Mary was conceived without sin.
@@mariaanadacosta1409 The Church teaches its own 'doctrine'. But where is it in the Scriptures (The Word of God)?
@@zamiradsa8995 The Catholic Church was founded by Jesus through His words to Peter. Therefore whatever the Church teaches is divinely inspired. This is in the gospel of Matthew. "You are Peter and on this rock I shall build my church and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it. Whatever you bind shall be bound, and whatever you loose shall be loosed.
@@mariaanadacosta1409 2 Timothy 3:16 All Scripture is given by inspiration by God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness,
Now, u plz show me the Scripture in the Holy Bible where it says that Mary (the mother of Jesus was conceived vtout sin and also the Scripture saying that the teachings of the Catholic church are divinely inspired.
Read from the Book of Prophet Hosea chp 4 vs 6 Ask the Holy Spirit to guide u
Well explained mathew hope this will open some of our brothers eyesight
Mathew bab excellent teaching of the catholic Church. Well done 👍
0:12 Mother Mary had no sisters. She was spotted in different places, so she got the named ofb 0:22 0:22 0:25 0:26 0:33 different places.that photo milagris saibinn shud be removed from that picture. They are giving a wrong picture for our future generations. Also make a video on our lady of renedious, and cuncolkann. People believe that they are sisters and also they say that they are all seven Sisters. I don't know how they have created stories.
You have opened the eyes of our hindu bhav . Even some of the ignorant catholics. Christians open your eyes. This is modern world we are not in olden days, where people said and other believed.
These tales were created by the 77 IQ POGO poseurs who flooded into Bardez last century. Catholic Goans, as usual, bent over backwards for the outsiders and became a minority in their own backyard.
Matters of faith are not based on absolute rationality and I don't think we should question their beliefs I think most Christians are aware that Mother Mary had no sisters but that does not imply we can stop others from believing that she has a sister In fact their belief helps to build a bridge of unity and harmony among the two religious communities which is a dire need in India today as there are forces working very hard to sow communal disharmony
Rightly said
The truth should be loud and clear, munis muxeak adharak pavunk zai, magir tho khoichea dormacho zanv🙏
No, that's just bending over backwards for the 77 IQ crowd. It's how Goa ended up becoming the only state where migrants outnumber natives.
Well explained Bro.All these years I was waiting that a priest will give an explanation on this topic.Let the faith be at one point but truth is truth.May God bless you
In bible say only mother Mary is jesus mother . Who change her name? Mother Mary seen many places at jesus time . No change d name . Brother only u tell me which name I must praise jesus mother . Those who accept bible they praise mother Mary n religion praise many mothers .
Mary, maria vo marian
@@lenoygomendes1380 believe in bible n don't listion of devil. U have mother did u change yr mother name ? Who brought to birth n whom we r praising. Fatima valakhani n ect man made mother
@@derrickcolaco5668 it is only a reference, and Mathew has explained it already.
I feel u r supporting to worship idols mothers . Please tell only mother Mary is jesus mother ? Never compromise bible
Thanks Matthew bab.
You are right for right information
Bro Matthew, I heard many people say, lairai devi and milagr Saibin they are sisters, but, there's lot of stories behind this ❤❤ but they are sister's
Very good explanation son Methew there is only one our heavenly Mother that is mother of our Lord Jesus Christ different name’s are given .God bless you son 🙏💜
Nicely done👏🏼liked the way u explain it bro without hurting anyone(jst real facts), yes thrs something with that place ,nw hindus say that thr ws templen idol thr may b u shld do more videos on this (bring in more document n proofs)n ppl shld go in debt to find history n accept d truth n nt jst sit n say cholta te bore asa
Please if you don't have proper information don't make this type of video. You can directly go to Mapusa Church and asked for the information. It's wrong on your part to ask if anybody has the details to share. This are sensitive issue. Don't give rise to communal actives who are just waiting
If you are Christian and a Goan ...you know whom we refer to as Saibinn Mai....
For ur kind info now parish priest of St Jerome's Church wants to stop all this ....even pouring of oil ..we have only one Mother Mary
Very true , and no one had asked you about it, by putting such videos on social media looks like uzwad jai mhunon ghor petovpak sodtaa ........
Aasu tuji aasu na jaalyer mhaji kide farak podtaa.....tujyaa jantyani jaav te mhaje jaante, kenaa oslo dubaav ghevknaa, je cholta te choloni
@@dattarajchari8037 I'm a Catholic! And you are right bro..👍 wise words
@@dattarajchari8037sarke ,both are called as saibin maay ❤
Truly said .. I respect you brother.. very well explained.. this generation needs peaceful people nd peaceful explanations like how u give ..
What we do is wrong ... do you know that? We don't follow bible exactly...
Get Foral of Mapuca from Archives Goa and you can confirm names of demolished temples in Mapuca and properties owned by each deity.
Isn't the government supposed to do it?? The Foral documents of Salcete is available...why not Bardez tiswaddi and so on?? Why is the Goa Government sleeping over it for past 12 years?
We should demand the government to tell portuguese government to release it....or if the government already has it ..they should release it
Our CM himself said there are no records of temples demolished
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357, according to my sources, most of the Portuguese records from Panjim were burned at Porvorim after the illegal Indian annexation of Goa in 1961.
@@royenfernandes248😳who is your source
Mary is documented in the Bible.
I request u to do one video on shantadurga kunkalikarin, before that do visit the village and question local Christians about their saying on kunkalikarin.... ask them why Christians are given right to take out satryo from temple? Ask them why they flock in large no. In satryo? Ask them wht shantadurga kunkalikarin means to them ? Ask them why many of them donated gold to Kunkalikarin? You will get your answer...
Your genetic 77 IQ is showing again. That nonsensical behaviour didn't start till last century, when the dumb chardos of that village started believing Shantaram Naik's attempt to rewrite the Cuncolim Massacre as a nationalist revolt. Now that Goans know the full story (the majority of those killed by the chardos were other Goans from Salcette), the reputation of Cuncolim chardos has sunk even further.
Those who don't know Bible,they can talk anything,you are whatever is said its true,mother of Jesus only maria (mary)but we knows different types of names, but she didn't have any sisters n brothers
The meaning of belive itself says that something which is possible, but not certain.
Do we believe that we have two hand, or do we know that we have two hands.
When you make believe system a reality problem starts generating and you will be in trouble mentally as well as physically
Good point....we christians are certain about our beliefs
Well explained brother I always wanted to know how it can happen
Very well Explained. You have done a great job by giving true explanation.
Hats off to you for explain this to people, we Christian know the truth mama mary is the only child of her parents and her son is jesus, and her birth place is Jerusalem and they are Israelites. In Christian religion there are many saints but mama mary is the only one, hence she is known by many names according the way she appeared to people like Velankanni in India.
What he is sayin is right... Sadly ppl hav got used to it since years and now if we speak truth also ppl will drag us to police station as they got all powers
U r right, very true 👍
Ask ur mother .ur son of same father or diffrent father's
Well explained 👏 👌
Whatever going on from past let's go on. Don't interfere in the matter. All religious in Goa live together. We want peace.
How can u say that ur sister is Hindu when your christian ...these were only beliefs in olden days ....even parish priest of St Jerome's Church wants to stop this
I can give you lots of examples but u won't expect it and whatever @agnesdias2519 said is true cholta te choloni.,...
Hakach lagun amkam he brashtachari politicians pixean kadtat, dolle Ani kann ugdat goemkarani, sorry for the comment 🙏
@@cirilosousa9664 tu jaavnaka piso .....aani shanoch raav ....
My mom had told me that Saibin maim is just one, daughter of st.anna & st.joaquim, mother of Jesus, was seen at different places, like Fatima, Lourdes, Madras, etc. That doesn't mean, there r different saibins, now since our hindu brothers & sisters have accepted our lady of milagres as d sister of leirei Devi let it b and let them continue with their belief even after your factual explanation, because this belief of theirs bind us together to maintain communal harmony amongst us. V r all brothers & sisters, v r humans, let's continue living here on earth with love, peace & joy. Ur topic was good indeed 💯
No, they're making up fairytales as part of their POGO posing. There weren't any such stories till the last century when Marathi migrants started flooding into Bardez.
It will be helpful if you can shed some light on how and when the practice of pouring oil started. This looks like a very old tradition. I don't see this in any other church dedicated to Mother Mary in Goa. Whatever faith one holds, I don't see any issue with someone putting oil as is being done now.
I believe in Mother Mary. She is mother of Jesus and she is our Lady of Miracles.
What are you trying to achieve from the this video? Don't try to find logic in religion! Basically you are further alienating catholic faith from India. And creating differences with Hindu. Serves no purpose.
Truth hurts
@@cirilosousa9664 who's truth yours? 😂😂And what is it?! amkai sang
@@Rahul-K1822 Na re bro not that, this fellow just wants to show he's SMARTER then everyone else.
Very well explained bro thank you so much ❤
Your right I thought in this world only me knows the truth about holy mother marry good to knw in this world there are also some people who knows about holy mother marry........ Marry never had sister she had cousins sisters n they where all christians...
Why would u even want to rake up this topic now? We know what it is! Period! Those who want to believe, let them. These are not times to add fuel to fire (which isn't ur intention).
Its just common sense! Yes we are in modern times but sadly religion is facing the brunt. So don't make such videos. Enough issues already.
Its nice that both religions come together.
Well said,so true....
No, he has to speak the truth. The harsh reality is that this was a 77 IQ fairytale created by Marathi migrants who flooded into Bardez last century, while doing POGO posing. It has no basis in either Christianity or Hinduism.
Absolutely right
Our mother is mother and only one she dont have any sisters from any other religions.
Very true.
Thanks bro for this video " mama mary is the only daughter .❤
Only one Mother Mary 🙏
U r right person brother but who's telling for people
Well explained...
Mother Mary is the Only daughter of Anna and Joaquin .God appointed her to becomes the Mother of his child.......never believe that nowadays this hindus creat story be careful
Nicely explained bab..
Thank you for explaining this very clearly. I wish many of our Christians in other parts of Goa understand this too well, where they believe that Mother Mary is the sister of some Goddess or the other
That's just 77 IQ stupidity.
Very well explained. I like the way you break the subject to basics and explain each facet clearly and calmly. Well done. Please keep it up. I try not to miss watching your videos.
Why do we have to go 500 years backwards? This is the Strategie of the bjp. Divide and rule... Other states in between Hindus and Muslims and here in goa between Hindus and Christians...
I think our PM takes tuitions from the central govt.
Nobody said Mother Mary sister of Devi lahrai
ABSOLUTELY RIGHT MATHEW SIR THANK YOU
JESUS said I am the way rhe true n the life. N the truths la llast forever .
Bro u are right
We know Mother May was a humble Jewish girl/woman who found favor with the Almighty. Mary never considered herself as Goddess, her Canticle " ... for He has looked with favor on His lowly servant......He has come to help of His servant Israel.." She was not colonial , she was Jewish, she cared about her Jewish people, the same Jewish people who killed her Son. The European/Roman spiritual landscape was polytheistic with many Goddesses, Venus -the Goddess of love, Juno- Goddess Of women well being, Minerva - Goddess of Wisdom and many others. But when the Roman empire embraced Christianity . They honored Mother Mary like their Goddess , as our Catholic dogma, She is the Queen of heaven. It's called syncretism , a merging of beliefs. And we cannot forget our Hindu roots, so all our former Goddesses reincarnated into Our Blessed Mother. The concept of reincarnation was prevalent in Our Lord's time , even in the Gospels, when Our Lord asked his disciple who do people think I am? and the response was John the Baptist, who was beheaded , Jeremiah and some other prophets of old. Of course Peter's response was sublime " you're the Messiah, the Son of the Living God" and Our Lord response was , " “Blessed are you, Simon (Peter) son of Jonah, for this was not revealed to you by flesh and blood, but by my Father in heaven” this was the moment of truth, when Peter identified our Lord, who He was? Son of the Living God, who walked our Planet.
I am very happy with your thoughts.well said
Your genetic 77 IQ is showing again. There's no syncretism, just fairytale made up by Marathi migrants doing POGO posing when they entered Bardez last century.
Why can't all priest in Goa preach the truth on the blessed Virgin Mary, and the mama Mary in St Jeromes Church Mapusa Goa according to the Bible Mary was the only child of St. Joachim and
St. Ana. Mama Mary never had any sisters or brothers. It's truth this can't be hidden even our Pope head of the Roman Catholic Church preaches this truth what has the bishop of Goa has to say about it.
Mely. All priest preach now n then especially during her feast. I think either u don’t attend mass regularly or u don’t know the doctrine of the church
I see no substance in your comment bro other than targeting our bishop ! Is it????
You are right brother 100%.
Why are u even discussing this topic you will be the next target just keep this topic out do u want to put more petrol in the fire. You cannot change peoples mind as long as everyone are are in peace and harmony stay away from these topics.
It's called the LEGEND OF SEVEN SISTERS. It is important to understand the meaning of the word "legend". According to the online Cambridge Dictionary, Legend means a very old story or set of stories from ancient times, or the stories, not always true, that people tell about a famous event or person. Given that the Portuguese Inquisition/rule had long-lasting impact, the wrath of which is still persistent, our ancestors may have come up with this tale to maintain harmony amongst religions. In my opinion, if this maintains peace and harmony, so be it. ✌️
Your genetic 77 IQ is showing again. This "7 sisters" nonsense didn't start till the last century, when Marathi migrants started flooding into Bardez while doing their POGO posing. It's part of the 77 IQ Dharmic concoction with hathkatro, forced conversions, Inquisition atrocities, etc.
Very good 👌
There is only one heavenly mother befoe creation of world and she is living amongst us and even her name is written in holy bible,God the the creator name,holy spirit name and jesus second coming name.....and that's only God's choosen children knows as written in bible
Our lady of Guadeloupe in Mexico , another example.
You are right mother Mary no have sister
Hindu bhaw? Tu hindunk bhaw maataaslo jalyaa ho video kaadina aaslo. 😂
Sarkhe. Hanche dakhovpache ek Ani korpache ek.
Padri suddha. Miss sangtana bhaini munta 🙏
Let us leave it at that. If people want to believe let the believe. Let us not rake up an issue. God is one in different forms.
Can't allow a historical or religious truths of a religious community get diluted to satisfy somebody else's fantacised beliefs
What do you mean by fantacised beliefs please explain it
Please find it in the dictionary 👍
@@Rahul-K1822Your genetic 77 IQ is showing again. There's no relation between Mary and Lairai. That fairytale was made up by Marathi migrants flooding into Bardez last century as part of their POGO posing.
Nicely explained bro Mathew
Please pass on correct information or please be prepared on correct story before posting video just don't do it to get subscribers and likes.. nonsense 😡😡😡
What ???? Is it true ???? Seriously
Yes, it's well-documented in Christianity. Fault lies with Catholic Goans for going along with fairytales made up by 77 IQ POGO poseurs.
We don't want your explanations, we knw what is the truth.
They are not sisters. Period!.
Mother mary is daughter of joaquim and anna
Good one
Ur right
Atam devacher chod video yeta ..
Ami tar munta ami sogllim bhav bhoinam zalear amchem natem khoinchean ani khoim sodpachem , so dista ami mandit aileavm tem ami sambalyea ani ani vinoti koruyea ani sounsarantle fudle dis bore baxen saruyea.
What ever it is. Its faith that bring people here.let not comment pn the faith of the faithful.
Right 👍.
So is it okay to dilute and manipulate the teaching of another religion to satisfy ones own fantacised faith?
hey ur wrong don't play the faith card Mother Mary is one she has no sisters that too in India
🙏
Totally unnecessary topic IMO.
People of Goa knows who is Milagris saibin. One must know history of Lairai devi. All questions will be solved.
That history was created last century when Marathis doing POGO posing like Velingkar started flooding into Bardez.
@@cg8397 do u know history???
We spoken mathew
Miss Pooja
Our Mother Mary did not have any sister
Ata modern periodan ravta zalyar why u belive in religion become a athiest instead 🤣😂
No. They are not. Mother Mary did not have any sisters. Nowhere it is written.😊
Correct
Ppl have their own beliefs let it be how it is ....kon manta teka manuni
Belief cannnot supersede or overpower rationalisation and historical facts
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357nobody can decide that ....ur nobody to decide it ..
@@dipteshnaik4317 truth hurts isn't it.....yes we can decide .... We are the ones affiliated to the faith and who believe in Mary Mother of Christ...and it's a definite history....don't dilute it
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357our temples were razed by Portuguese not gaunkars
@@mygoawithmathewalmeida3357Thr are many truth wic ul not accept so simply don't creat ur own things whatever it may it's ppl beliefs and u can't stop anyone ppl have faith and thy will believe..
No
Yes of course sisters
Our Mother Mary is a saint she never committed sin.
What brought you to talk about mother Mary sir after so long , please don't talk anything 🙏 i think you got up late
❤