U guys realize that Cindy is a pop singer/dancer/songwriter/actress right? Although she majored in piano in college, she obviously hasn't practiced since she became a singer.. She said later on that she was not even prepared and was suddenly called on by the host to play something. So Chopin was a piece she remembered from a long ago. I think for something so improper se did her best, under those circumstances without any practice i think we should be more forgiving. I've heard her play live be
I meant for something so "improptu"... Also, I've heard her play live before and she is, trust me, very good. You can also search her performances of mozart's sonata and Prokofiev sonata no.2 on RUclips. I don't think there are any other taiwanese artists that can play up to cindy's level!
I agree with what you said,but I think that Cindy is just trying to show off,without the excellent skills and talent as the professional pianist has.A pianist myself,it is very obvious for me that the guy is indeed a professional pianist.He is very articulate,with very strong finger work,very clear-textured,with a lot of control and dynamics. Whereas the girl,she is still at student-level.Messy,few phrases were a lil rushed,which is not supposed to happen if you are at professional level.
Most importantly,this is a classic Chopin's piece that is supposed to be very expressive and it is not about speed.Which I think is ridiculous how the girl was just rushing through the notes without counting her beat and missing notes,its just like a student who hasn't really practice enough for the recital exam.This piece has many cross-rhythm (the right hand playing 16notes against the left playing triplets).So rushing them and missing certain notes,to me,spoils the whole beauty of the piece
Lol. Please, she's a SINGER. She have to rush out her albums. She have no time to practice her piano. Student level? Unless you're Beethoven, if not put the shut to the up before you judge or comment.
薛啸秋弹得比较smooth and professional but cindy just show off her talent and it is meaningless and a little bit messy .chopin fantasie impromtu should be smooth and very expressive and not just show off your skill and talent.
贏太多了,聲音乾淨好多~
那是一個相較更初階的年代，變得更能聆聽和感受只是matter of time，想像未來的幽默感裡也會充滿期待，敬我們始終不斷進步的觀感。
鬥鋼琴速度是沒用的, 鬥快是極低層次的鬥琴
因为乘风破浪的姐姐 来看 袁咏琳 我心中的 实力派三号学生 没想到以前这么杀马特😂
0:35 Cindy 音色終於開始亮出來了 接著就聽到 好了 好了 好了
尛 到底有沒有在欣賞音樂阿 WTF
還有 樂器的演奏不是一昧的求快 我承認這在視覺上可以造成短暫的熱情
但是音色的共鳴和情感的穿透 才是音樂的本質不是嗎?
U guys realize that Cindy is a pop singer/dancer/songwriter/actress right? Although she majored in piano in college, she obviously hasn't practiced since she became a singer.. She said later on that she was not even prepared and was suddenly called on by the host to play something. So Chopin was a piece she remembered from a long ago. I think for something so improper se did her best, under those circumstances without any practice i think we should be more forgiving. I've heard her play live be
那些專業鋼琴家是每天得花5 6小時來練 有些甚至不夠 袁詠琳他又沒那麼多時間練 連發個專輯就很累了
一首有沒有感情甚至有沒有靈魂的曲，你聽的出來嗎？即便有也只是與你產生共鳴而已，要知道一個東西是好是壞，取決你對他的了解多少。簡單來說，對一樣不了解的東西，你也只能分辨好與壞，而不能分辨哪裡好怎麼好，哪裡壞怎樣壞，因為你對這東西不了解。所以一段在好的美的曲，到了不了解的人他也不知道這首曲是好還是壞，更別說這首曲有沒有感情與靈魂了。PS:有感覺有靈魂的曲，也是有分別的，只有包含強烈的感情和靈魂的曲，才能連外行人都聽的出。
cindy 刚开始弹错了好多音
幻想即興曲 不過Cindy彈錯有點多 真可惜 不過後面彈得很棒~
I meant for something so "improptu"...
Also, I've heard her play live before and she is, trust me, very good. You can also search her performances of mozart's sonata and Prokofiev sonata no.2 on RUclips. I don't think there are any other taiwanese artists that can play up to cindy's level!
I agree with what you said,but I think that Cindy is just trying to show off,without the excellent skills and talent as the professional pianist has.A pianist myself,it is very obvious for me that the guy is indeed a professional pianist.He is very articulate,with very strong finger work,very clear-textured,with a lot of control and dynamics. Whereas the girl,she is still at student-level.Messy,few phrases were a lil rushed,which is not supposed to happen if you are at professional level.
好想跟薛嘯秋的手指談戀愛！
你們也知道自己是外行人!?那就等人家彈完!
為什麼要打斷?? 因為一首彈完要5分鍾給她彈完就都不用錄了吧...
蕭邦 幻想即興曲
chopin fantasie impromptu
正常速度
不太難
周杰倫來了時候為什麼不舉辦這個給他啊？一直問緋聞。
Most importantly,this is a classic Chopin's piece that is supposed to be very expressive and it is not about speed.Which I think is ridiculous how the girl was just rushing through the notes without counting her beat and missing notes,its just like a student who hasn't really practice enough for the recital exam.This piece has many cross-rhythm (the right hand playing 16notes against the left playing triplets).So rushing them and missing certain notes,to me,spoils the whole beauty of the piece
Lol. Please, she's a SINGER. She have to rush out her albums. She have no time to practice her piano. Student level? Unless you're Beethoven, if not put the shut to the up before you judge or comment.
你说的是，不过薛啸秋比速度的话比袁咏琳快难道不是正常的事吗？
他们弹的曲叫什么名啊???
蕭邦的「幻想即興曲」。
蔡康永到底在做什麼，根本不尊重人阿，
彈琴中被打斷是非常不禮貌的不知道嗎?
薛啸秋弹得比较smooth and professional but cindy just show off her talent and it is meaningless and a little bit messy .chopin fantasie impromtu should be smooth and very expressive and not just show off your skill and talent.
小s太小看和污辱了专业钢琴家的水准了。
因為沒有鋼琴譜，所以錯是正常的- -
男的彈的比較好乾淨 袁他談的比較髒
拿蕭邦曲子來比速度不是問題, 但請先把它轉搖滾風格好嗎?
兩個都有彈錯 難怪臉都臭=.=