Israel's Netanyahu Ordered Hamas Leader Ismail Haniyeh's Killing in Tehran to Scuttle Peace Talks
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 окт 2024
- Israel's Netanyahu ordered Ismail Haniyeh's killing to scuttle peace talks: Former Ambassador to Saudi Arabia, Oman and UAE, Talmiz Ahmad, to Karan Thapar for The Wire.
...........................................
One of India’s foremost experts on the Middle East and a former Ambassador to Saudi Arabia, Oman and UAE, Talmiz Ahmad, has said that he believes Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu could have ordered the killing of the Hamas leader and former Prime Minister of Palestine, Ismail Haniyeh, to scuttle the peace talks because if a successful ceasefire had been agreed to Netanyahu would have lost his job as Prime Minister of Israel.
Mr. Ahmad does not believe that the Biden Administration in Washington would have been consulted leave aside had given prior clearance before the assassination of Haniyeh. He also believes that although Hamas and Iran will retaliate - and separately Hezbollah for the killing of Fuad Shukr 24 hours earlier - they will do so in their own time and in a measured way because they do not wish to provoke a wider regional conflict.
I am only giving you the big main points made by Mr. Ahmad. This is a very topical interview, on an issue that only happened in the late hours of last night i.e. early this morning. With his experience and insight, Mr. Ahmad is able to give us an invaluable analysis of the issues involved which is why this is an interview you should see if you want to understand why Haniyeh was killed and what could be the outcome.
Here is the link:
Join The Wire's RUclips Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
Imagine if all countries start using violent methods to settle disputes instead diplomacy as a method where will wold stand.
Love Palestine from India
Nice presentation by karan and Brilliant answer by Mr.Ahmed
Beautiful assessment by Mr Ahmed ,truely impressed by his in depth knowledge
Only for Abduls. Only thing influences him is his religious believes. Unfortunate India had such a mole planted in Indian Foreign Service. 😂😂😂
Ghanta assessment!
This make us remember our heroes!!
Netaji and BHAGAT SINGH JI ! Who help us achieve freedom from
EAST INDIA COMPANY!
@13:56 Karan has shown how green he is in terms of military operations. Iran's retaliation was not meaningless. It was a successful attack. It hit the airfield from which the baghdad consulate was hit. It was also able to collect vast amounts of information about the missile defence system that israel and its allies use. The attacks were announced in advance for a reason. Please someone teach karan about some basics of military operations. Iran never had intentions of going to war with israel, it has learnt the lesson from Saddam Hussein. It will only strike when it has nuclear delivery capability.
Thanks!
Great interview! Very learned and insightful explanations (and with minimum characteristic interruptions by Karan Thapar) Well, thanks a lot, this is really very informative and clear-eyed analysis!
Once a islamist ...always an islamist
This interview discussion is sufficient for its clearity, for any 10th passed individual..
YSN.29 once a bhakt...always a bhakt
Thanks
Waisted 2$
Very smart diplomat ❤
Excellent interview
Karan,not for the inauguration of Pezkeshiyan but for the swearing-in ceremony
After October 7th the word Peace is wiped out of the Israel's dictionary 😂
Israel shivers by hearing the phrase ",wiped out". 😅
Insightful
Why do experts keep predicting future? every event has consequences which only time can tell
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
very caring ambassador who is so concerned about the hostages 😀
It couldn't have been possible without Iranian insider job.
Most of the Iranian youths, opposed to Khamenei regime, are in support of Israel. They are fast becoming Ex-Muslims. 50% Mosques in Iran have closed.
My condolences to Karan Thapar
Our sincere condolences to Rana Ayyub, Arfa Sherwani on the passing of their beloved leader.
🙏😃
This ex-ambassador's views are skewed and don't show balance .... You have interviewed him on this topic before, Karan and he shows the same biased views
He is an Abduls, he can not think beyond religion, another Ex Vice President of India
@@Waraqah-Ibn-Nawfal6485malbari low life
They still live in 634 AD...
Sir, how could this assassination be done deep inside Tehran without the consent of Iranian government.
Iranian intelligence loophole. Mossads informants in iran
Covert operations are meant to do that.
Quran Thappar.
😂😂😂
So all Karans belongs to islam including mahabharata
@@AhmedHasan12345any karan on side of adharma belongs to you only
@@AhmedHasan12345 Even your forefathers were fighting for Karna in Mahabharata.
@@user-kn5sg2hb2b afcourse puppets will not going to decide who belongs which sides...dharma is fastest growing in the world today.
Israel is more isolated gradually on the international stage.
Chinese way is good to maintain peace like in xinjiang
People should first differentiate between a terrorist vs a proper political leader.
Correct! Netanyahu is clearly a terrorist since he chooses war everytime instead of peace. Haniyeh on the other hand was willing to lay down his weapons if Israel agreed to 67 borders!
He was a political leader not a terrorist, for the people who don’t understand the difference.
Then why he did not stay in Palestine like Mahamood Abbas
@@Waraqah-Ibn-Nawfal6485 Some of the leadership of hamas stay outside of palestine and United States requested in 2011 that Qatar provide a base for the Hamas leadership to ease communications with the group. From 2012, Qatar hosted the Hamas party leadership when Hamas head Khaled Meshal relocated from Syria to Qatar.
Mr. Thapar, get your facts right.
Absolutely
Satisfaction level 📈
Talmiz ahmed sir i do still remember he was the ambassador of India to Saudi Arabia.
He was THE HEAD of INDIAN EMBASSY SCHOOLS IN SAUDI ARABIA WHEN I WAS YOUNG.
HE IS A GOOD MAN.
EVERY ACTION HAD EQUAL & OPPOSITE REACTION THAT WHAT HE HAS DONE.
WHEN HON.PM.NETANYAHU CAN KILL MORE THAN 70000 PALASTENIANS WHERE WERE EVERYONE.
THERE WERE WOMEN THERE WERE KIDS WHO WERE KILLED BLEEDING.
It's result of Hamas making women and children as shield.
Double standard speech
Lots of love from india to you 🇮🇱 ♥️
If humans don't understand the good God or the chosen people of God when they are alive they will surely understand when they die. The Holy Bible says it all.
If Israel has done this then India should learn on how to deal with terror
😂
@@DigitUnni Modi devotees everywhere. How is your temple coming?
@@CosmicValkyrie True, He has become the PM third term. Inshallah
@@CosmicValkyrie Arfa khnum is mourning ...
अरफा खानम शोक मना रही है... 🤣🤣
@@SpookyRipples9 and? Why should I care? Cow lover.
Thappa your time ahead
Why he has to kill to scuttle? He would have other ways to scuttle. If killing is the only way then prime minister needs to be removed
Talmiz Ahmad echoes his biasness, no doubt as expected from followers of islam.
This comment is very biased and one should read history before making such comments.
What biased… history shows wherever peacefuls went, loot, death , abduction of women, forced conversions, destruction of others temples followed.
Selective targeted killing of Iranian & their resistance forces exposed the weakness of Iran , role of Saudi, UAE Jordan and rulers of middle East as well as this conflict exposed human rights champion of Western world, UN, ICJ,ICC. Israeli seems to be free from any international laws.
Shame on the humanity...
Non Muslim tho kafhir hai tho kis mu se humnity bolte ho tum log
Ismail Hani[ya wasn't a Palestinian child.. 🤣🤣
For Palestine they should have not started it now face the music
U seem to be more worried about the Middle East rather than worrying about Kerala crisis
What happens in Middle East decides the Future of people who appease Islamists back home.
This is why..
Natural crisis vs human inflicted crisis. On which do you have control over?
It's a hot topic now. You would speak on a hot topic not on the water leakage in parliament.
@@DrAin-g1q Why Somalia, or Sudan not given this much attention? Are they the children of a lesser God?
Two failed professional discussion
i have a question for the ex ambassador.
When you call the dead terrorist a political head of hamas what does it mean, what was his role in the terrorist act of his organisation on october 7 2023, was he the one who planned the attrocities by giving directions from Tehran or Doha?
I understand very little about the Ambassadors ideology or his religion but I would like to ask the ex ambassador about the Political leader of the terrosrist organisation Hamas, when he enter the Jannat of the peaceful religion becuase he orchestrated many attrocities on the Kafirs on October 7 2023, how many of 72 hoors would he be getting on day 1? Will normal followers of peaceful religion also share the same Jannat as the political leader of the terrorist organsiation of Hamas?
Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸✌️✌️🤲🤲🇱🇧🇾🇪🇿🇦🇪🇸
Badtameez Ahmad, showing true colours 😂😂
Indian Foreign Service is legendary.
There is one Kashmiri Indian litterateur called Salman. He has some Iranian connection since 1989.
Pl explain his story in terms of your new legend i.e. Strategic Patience - Force of Resistance - Technology Demonstration. You are allowed to invent new terms and add them to your legend if that helps in making the narrative convincing one.
By the way in the last Technology Demonstration by a member of Resistance Force, Salman lost his one eye. It was a failed attempt. Probably because of the odd antique weapon used. Afterall it was just a Technology Demonstration. Next time for sure Hi-tech weapon will be deployed. Only problem is that the coordinates of the target is controlled by CIA. They share it only with Israel. Which is quite unfair.
Importantly CIA is not US. It is of US. Not to blame US for any acts of CIA. Only Pentagon is and by the US.
Chat GPT can translate, in less than a second, any story written using new set of diction in common language for public consumption.
God is great. 🙏
Free Palestine
Correct but who advised Palestine to start it if u kill then u will be killed simple why hue and cry now first of condemn the action of Palestine
@@SiddharthNiranjan-hs6yo Going by your logic even Bhagat Singh is a terrorist...
Palestinians are fighting for their land. If you see the one in fear and crying are Israelis, more than 50lk have left Israel. The righteous land brings patriotism not fear.
Al-Jazeera, TRT, Wire, BBC etc lost one of their own in Hanniyeh 😂😂
Dimak me gobar Vara rahega to journalism ko kese respect kar paoge.
@@Ujjal-uy7ufGobarbhakt.😮
News dekhna hai to dekho, nahi dekhna hai to mat dekho tumhe kisi ne force nahi kiya is video ko dekhne ke liye
@@Ujjal-uy7uf It is Camels dung😂
who started first??? why not talk about the attack & those hostages living in constant fear????.. This is ridiculous!!
In which world are you in!!??? It did not start with the Hamas attack, Hamas attack was a reaction to the continued oppression and tyranny of Israeli Govt.People of Gaza were living in 'Open Prison'. Open your eyes and ears, know the truth and stand by the truth for the sake of humanity!!!
Do you know how many underaged children and women in Israel prison before oct 7 without any consequences. Hamas took hostage in order to exchange its people in Israel prison. Israel has taken 26 times more Palestinians hostages. Half are kids and women. It's not the power that determines good or bad but your behaviour.
Lot of speculations as no one is sure of what really happen , inside job , outside job , sold out etc as someone is mentioned if Haniyeh was political leader why was not in Palestine
We have even terrorist in various governments in world who use official terrorism to their survival. We had in Gujrath now in Delhi so in Tel aviv , so in London to date no WMD discovered but a leader was overthrown killed by the boss and puddle
Our ambassador looks like Hamas ambassador.
Ambassador is well informed, his evaluation is to the point and direct.
And you look like a andh-Modi-bhakt.🤣🤣
Ummah dictates it...BTW nobody in world is saying Israel did it, this Ambassador is just assuming without any proof.
@@prajkta123 "BTW nobody in world is saying Israel did it, this Ambassador is just assuming without any proof"
--- Only a person who is not acquainted with Middle East politics would make such an ignorant statement!🤣🤣🤣
@@shantanusapru bcoz everybody knows that only Mossad's hit unit, Kidon or Shinbet can carry out such operations... Nobody else can even dare to carry out such operations!
The Wire in mourning..
Is this guy an Ex-Ambassador of Hamas?
Around 23 min he calls the Hamas terrorist prominenet warriors.
indian Govt should take note of this and consider action against this Hamas lover.
His adminration of terrorist organisations like Hamas and Hezbollah is something to be looked at more carefully who knows what kind of information about India is available to this terrorist lover.
Anybody can be that neutral on the Israeli Palestinian conflict. Even Israel's behaviour many times matches with a terrorist organisation.
@@TheoSophii that is unfair to say and I do not agree with your opinion.
But imagine this, a person like Osama bin blasen was hailed as a hero by a select group of people and we can draw certain conclusions about such a group. I would assume, calling the Political leader of a terrorist organisation- a prominent warrior should raise atleast a couple of alarm bells and that too from an ex ambassador who could have connections in the department which can be misused, don't you think?
I fail to understand the mindset of such people who consider Hamas anything other than a terrorist organisation and people who are associated with it should be considered only with utmost caution
What your thoughts about NETAJI AND BHAGAT SINGH JI, AGAINST EAST INDIA COMPANY!
THIS IS SAME THING.
@@igp4tel I whole heartedly disagree with your comparission, I hope you reconsider comparing freedom fighters with Terrorists.
I hope people who use terms like Prominent warriors to describe the leaders of terrorist organisations like Hamas realise the dangers of such filthy organisations and condemn their actions without reservation and people (especially someone influential) like the Ex- Ambassador ( I am thankful that atleast a person like the ex ambassador no longer represent India) stop idolising these religious fundementalist extremist terrorists like Hamas.
@@TheoSophii I totally agree with that!
He is bullshit
If hamas is resistance then same argument is also used by LeT child Kasab.
Atleast kashmiri are far better than Indian muslim.
Rubbish
Kashmiri are far better than Indian Muslim what do u mean is Kashmir not a part of Bharat kindly explain
Highly biased, showing just one side view by both Karan as well as the guest. Barkha conducts better interview. U didn't confront the guest for his thoughts even once.
Hi
"he lives in doha"... *lived
Palestine
Is imagination
@@aadityachourasia2124 so is your brain. but expected from people who vote for BJP.
@@CosmicValkyrie all pleasure is mine
@@aadityachourasia2124 no wonder India is a medium power. It should be kicked out of BRICS. It is such a burden. It should be replaced with Indonesia.
@@CosmicValkyrie Pls someone tell Israel that an agent of Hamas known as Owaisi is hiding in India...
IF ISMAIL HANIYA WAS A POLITICAL LEADER WHY DID NOT HE REMSINED IN PALESTIN LIKE MOHAMMED ABBAS?
Listen how two touts are discussing
Ismail haniya also order to kill Netanyahu but as usual result was same
I have watched a few interviews of Talmiz Ahmad & his line of thinking seems to have been shaped by Nehru 's timely suited secularism for India.
First abused by his daughter Indra & now by the present dispensation. And the irony is that libral secularism is appearing to be taking last breath. Then in that case who will agree to what he says.
there os not a single muslim majority which is Secular. All hellhole for Non muslim .
Iran is awaiting the same fate as Haniye.
Typical wire interview ...
And
Ex Indian Diolomat ...
Hundreds of Godi media are out there to satisfy you. Why you wining around here.