Loved performing together with Karolina, what a kind and generous person❤If you liked our performance, come support and watch our behind-the-scenes video: ruclips.net/video/Vp9DR4Qtv84/видео.htmlsi=FEBMuVnX6Ch4A-76
I loved the video Ray, you too are a very kind and humble guy, it was a wonderful experience for us to see you at her street performance and playing so beautifully together and of course your classical display was amazzing.
Thank you Ray your great presence it means a lot for Karolina i follow her since 2019 i love what she do.And now you are on my liste of favorite.Your performances with her was extremely beautiful
My father was a classical violinist and a prisoner of war in the NETHERLANDS..his music was so beautiful..I use to cry listening to him at night when I was 5 yrs old..he never knew how he touched my little heart and how he still does, although he is gone I feel like he is with me and the song of war you both played brought me back to when I was 5..my parents were divorcing and I never got to listen to his most beautiful music again..ilu for how you help heal my heart...
I am Jewish and this week 1000 of my brothers and sisters - grandmas and little girls - were slaughtered just like the Holocaust but this time in Israel. I have been so in shock that I could not even cry - until this video came up - to see your beauty and hear the tragedy of the music at the same time - allowed me to cry a river over all the lost Jews from the Holocaust to this week...pray for us Karolina P.
I cry for our 10,000 and 20,000 Palestinian brothers and sisters - grandmas/grandpas and little girls and boys - being slauhtered just like the Holocaust. I am so shocked by this decade old slaughterhouse with the Israeli military as the butchers.
@@gabrielemartin2022 go to those arab leaders and aggressors and cry there, before them, for what they cause to happen! You are right crying for them, for all their being misguided, feeded with and following misleading informations and idealogy from childhood on and filled with hateress towards the jews. And tell them to flee to keep their lives, if you hv a heart for those families there, bc the Israelis for sure cannot accept this murderous attacks
@@gabrielemartin2022 Also it is not at all true what you write and compare. This is the poison you use against Israel with what the aggressors and their supporters are nourished with. Israel warns before each strike of defence and takes explicit certain goals.
We are truly blessed. I think this is the way the song was meant to be played. Nothing wasted here. Simple and direct to the heart and to the soul. Karolina, Ray and the equally wonderful Ella Protsenko.
Exquisitely delicate, moving, magnificent performance - by our Violin Angel, Karolina - and world renowned violinist, Ray Chen. Drawn from the depths of their hearts-souls, they share their combined years of classical music training. I listen to this inspiring classical duet, over and over, and each time my heart is touched deeply. I thank God for these two beautiful humble souls whose musical artistry touches all of our hearts worldwide. Thank you, Karolina Protsenko and Ray Chen. Love from Australia!
@@toivotraks Hi, Toivo! So happy at this news. :) Jimmy’s reactions will, no doubt, be memorable. Something very special to look forward to. Good wishes from Australia!
It is very sad what happened at that time and my sympathy lies with all the victims of this inhuman madness, depicted in a masterpiece of cinematography. But also the performance of Dir Karolina and Ray Chen is undoubtedly masterful. I really like your performance. Let's also remember at the same time all the fallen victims of the war in Ukraine. Kind regards from Ralf Neumann from Germany.😊💖💖👏🙏🙏🐼
Claro x culpa de los presidentes mundiales quedejan matar la humanidad ahi pues si la mayoria mandara " no deverian haver victimas inosentes solo combatientes muertos matecen ustedes y degen al civil quieto" y sano piensa " the charly no conchudos y cochinos" creo yo" the charly"???
Two Violin Masters playing a soothing melody for all to enjoy. I can’t help but be amazed how this young lady can remember all the notes and melody to so many songs.
Karolina's incredible talent, her angelic charisma, her emotions, great kindness and her heavenly joy make every of her performance perfekt, then togehter wiht Ray Chen, this can't be topped, What a thrill that must of been for every young musician. 🇺🇸🇹🇼❤️❤️
You are absolutely amazing together. I am a professional guitarist, but if you cane to London, I would be the first to buy a ticket. You seem to have total chemistry and what an amazingly beautiful song. In these times we need people like you to lift our spirits and believe in the beauty that humans are capable of producing. Bravo to you both. Please come to London, you are great. 🙋🎸
Two heavenly gifted and beautiful people giving their best through their crying violins. Thank you both - and Ella for beautiful keyboard accompaniment of course!
Hi igial que el que interpreta el sonido ho lo percusiona " pienso yo att " the charly" claro puede sonar como fue diseñado y hasta gravado" falta ver percusionado debe sonar distinto creo yo" el sonido nunca miente piensa " the charly se escucha ho no una de 2" se ve y se siente ho ni se ve ni se siente ho simplemente ese fue"? El liche"???
@@frankgustafson1905Hello, Frank! This video is already up at Jimmy's, if you haven't reached there yet. I was so smitten with this that I requested it as extra at once and he did it right away. Cheers!
Karolina as a fan of yours from when u started the music channel. You have developed a lot and collabed with many of them but this one is a genius of classical music Ray Chen this shows your bright future
Hi Karolina Im 15, I live in Israel and ive been playing violin for 6 years. thank you so much for your music and support. you're my favorite violinist and i rly admire you !! pray for us......
Dear Carolina, Your playing and your singing are so lovely that it makes me feel good and very happy, you are the best, I just see you and I'm proud of you, May your parents and your siblings have a lot of happiness from you. You brighten my day with your unique face and smile, you brighten everyone's face, and the light of your face shines, I was born in 1944 in Israel, Even at my age, I really, really enjoy your songs and music. And now in these days of a strong and dark war on Israel, You always keep shining the light in my eyes, And you see that many admire and love you! May God be with you always! May you always continue to add goodness and light and joy to the entire world,🎉🎉🎉 I love you - Grandma Rebecca❤😊 
Karolina and Ray are the violin duet duos! 🎻 🎼 They are very talented in their performance! 🎵 🎭 ❤ They good playing music together! 🎶 😊 Bravo 🙌 Guys! You’re amazing! 😍🤩🥰❤️
Hard to believe those folks are surrounded there listening to this concert free. Two great musicians who could demand a pretty penny to listen to them play. This is the real thing here. I wish they would come to Ohio to play at the Blossom Music Center. I suppose Karolina is still too young to spread her wings so broadly but her day will come. Emotional.
RAY CHEN you are awesome!! 🤗 So beautiful and your expression says it all! This a very touching piece. Just love it and with Karolina even better just seeing the two of you with such promising talent. God bless your heart!
Una balada triste para una gran película " la lista de Schindler", Karolina Protsenko y Ray Chen un dúo espectacular que me hicieron derramar lágrimas 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏💙💛💪💪💪💪💪💪💪.
Karolina, this is a beautiful collaboration between you and Ray, and with mom and Leo accompanying you two. You give the violin a voice and an opportunity to show us the beauty of its soul and yours. You continue to show that you are a world-class violinist and can play with anyone. We love you out here. Marvelous. ❤🌹
Hi karolina😊 I Amichai from Israel, I adore you, and I hear you all the time, and I also tell my grandmother, who loves you very much, You inspire joy and pleasant light in all your songs, In days like these, when there are many wars and darkness in the world, Israel is my country, and in Ukraine, You continue to shine your unique and pleasant light, with songs and melodies on the violin, of high quality and really beautiful, And really relaxes and makes me happy to see and hear you. I hope and pray to good news and peace in the all world. And good luck in everything you do! Keep lighting up the world karolina❤
Karolina, that was an absolutely lovely performance by you, Ray, and your Mom. You all played this haunting piece of music beautifully, with such feeling. Even Leo caught the mood! Thank you all for this lovely rendition.
This piece of music played by Ray and Karolina matches each other perfectly and is just stunningly beautiful beyond words! Thanks for offering me this moment of beauty.
Dear Karolina, the performance by both of you is very good as it conveys the sad yet beautiful and powerful nature of this song. The high-pitched part that Karolina was in charge of had a very clear and beautiful sound. I was impressed by the performance of both of you. 👏👏👏❤❤❤
Воістину, правильно! Ви навіть не уявляєте собі, як зворушилось моє серце, коли я слухав цю мелодію! Вже не раз я написав, що ця музика нагадала мені пісні мого рідного Краю, моєї рідної України, де я живу, і яку я підтримую від усієї душі! Миру Вам, добра, і благополуччя! Нехай у серці Вашому радість буде!
This is a very beautiful and sad song performed by very talented musicians ray Chen and karolina protsenko who were absolutely fantastic together both hugely talented I have seen karolina in many videos and she can play any song but again super performance by both of them
My God!! Seldom have the performances of this magical young Karolina been as moving as this one. Karo not only played with her instrument, she played with her entire body, brain, heart, spirit and instrument, transmitting the deep emotion that she surely felt at that moment. Outstanding!!!
So soulfully played. It brought sadness from the bottom of heart. Thank you three musicians for the wonderful performance. I remember Karolina and her mom's another unforgettable rendition of this melody at the church that brought tears to my eyes.
Karolina, your collaborations are always exceptional! For such an amazing soloist, it's always surprising to see how well you mesh your performance with others. I've never seen any of your partners outperform you. You are always their equal or better. And you are fun to watch.
To be able to play with this artist Ray Chen is unbelievable. You really held your own, Karolina. What a privilege. How did you manage to get to play with him?
The violin is a unique instrument and very soothing tunes. The sounds of it brings joy to my heart And soul. The violin also calms my mind when listening to it. Very well played you two keep up the greatness well performed. Thanks for sharing this video.
Those who ignore the past,are doomed to relive it. America will repeat this if good people ignore THIS EVIL. Mydadwas a medic whose unit liberated Dachau and took pictures of the railroad carts stacked with bodies. May Jesus have mercy on all those who perished.
I didn’t know I had Jewish ancestry until I was a teen and neither of my parents were in the Holocaust but I’m sure I lost lots of ancestors there. Aren’t we ONE PEOPLE after all.. I came to Israel to visit a friend as a teen and was amazed how it felt like home, how many people had my curly hair and personality, sense of humor, it was all there, even my crazy chutzpah. I lived in so many other countries, but never felt that connection anywhere else. This song gets me in tears as does HaTikvah. It gets me every time. Go figure. Am 🇮🇱 Israel Chai 🇮🇱❤️❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱
You realize again what music can move and, above all, the content like in this piece. You two fit together perfectly and two violins speak two different languages and yet say the same thing. You can feel the harmony between Karolina and Ray Thank you and hopefully more often together! Greetings from Germany
Extremely amazing and emotional duet of the 2 most incredible violin players! Outstanding, the piano of your mom matches perfectly, and Leo is proud to be part of this wonderful presentation. Great 'job', your 'Cocker Spaniel' from Germany.
Well played both of you, you put so much feeling into it, so much so, some would have tears in their eyes. Karolina, Ray, must be so affected after performing with you. Ella, was great again on the Piano. Love to all from Mike. ❤💙
Karolina Protsenko, That was a Lovely Violin Cover duet performance of Schindler's List that you and Ray Chen performed. Also, Schindler's List is one of the best Songs from the Movie Schindler's List. Also, Thank you for performing the Violin Cover Duet performance of Schindler's List that you and Ray Chen performed. Also, You are an awesome Violinist.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐
Ha si thank you" esa era la idea" jua.jua.jua " the charly "??? Ahora una gueidore para hidratar" el cuerpo"??? Ji.ji.ji" ho gotas para los ojos igual limpian el iris de los ojos"??? The charly"???
❤ Karolina it's just incredible how perfectly you play, esp at only 15 years old. And you keep getting better. ❤ Thank you for sharing your music! 😊❤️⭐️👍🎻🌹👏💞
A very somber n telling song...! You ( both ) did very well relaying that set of emotions... Thanks Miss K for this post, today,n this time.. Good job Ray! 👍🐺🧙♂️🦊🤙
🌹Absolutely beautiful. Especially in the middle when both were playing at the same time. Karolina plays the high notes and Ray plays the low notes. Like burning candles from both ends created Beautiful notes that come together in the middle🌹
Very sad 😢but beautiful music at the same time! Congratulations on your great talent and beautiful performance Karolina ❤!!! Wonderful trio!You are very pretty. I'm a huge fan of yours!🎻🎻🎹🌹❤️🙏
❤ I could not expected nore than the excelency of this artists, although I follow Karolina since years from now in violin ❤ and this extraordinary music makes all the hearts and souls that love music, just hear in tottaly silence and at the end...the claps!!! ❤ Bravo!!! ❤
You know how you can tell they're both great they both turn into the song they are actually playing. You can feel it through their expressions. Just awesome 👍
Вы прекрасны дуэтом. Каролина, как всегда, божественна. В эти трагические времена мира и любви всем нам. Каролина, продолжайте будить души и сердца. С любовью из России.
Hi Avelina! I caught a glimpse of U in the crowd. I know U also would've performed the music from Schindler's List beautifully, whether with your saxophone, or with your bow and violin.🙂🙏🇺🇦🇺🇲♥️
Congratulations on reaching the milestone of 1.8 Billion views on this channel! It's truly warranted. You are truly on the road to being an outstanding musician and you deserve all the success brought on by your hard work and earnest studies.
Dear karolina and raychen,this music is so emotional and nice to hear 🥰🥹, you two literally made the violin cry, your music is relaxing,i could hear it all day 🤩❤.....,
Schindler's List is one of the most moving experiences I have ever had. Your two covers of the music was both beautiful and heart wrenching at the same time! Good on you!
That is so incredibly beautiful. And it truly is the saddest song. I started crying the moment Ray started to play. It hits you like a punch in the gut, which is what the Holocaust was to the Jewish people and to all of humanity. I've seen the movie, I've been to the Anne Frank house in Amsterdam. It absolutely breaks my heart.
You are getting better and better Karolina. The two of you should collaborate more together as you each enhance the others performance... Well done both of you...
Hi good day claro eso se llama entrenamiento" lo contrario seria improvisacion jua.jua.jua = eso hace " the charly siempre improvisa la percusion del sonido x eso dirigirlo es inventar" lo que el toca" x que esta inventado y tocado" pero no percusionado"??? Creo yo"???
Loved it, Schindler's List is one of my top 5 favourite movies and I just love the soundtrack from it. A big well done to you both, this was brilliant. A big well done to your mum too on the Keyboard, awesome work all of you.
An incredibly moving piece of music. Thank you for playing to perfection. To the millions of Jews killed you will always be remembered Rest in eternal peace ❤
Just, WOW! That was beautiful. I was captivated. All of you portrayed so much emotion in that piece. ❤ Leo's interpretative dancing with the cutlass was inspired.
А як я люблю таку музику! Я щойно в офіційному коментарі написав, що вона мені нагадала пісні мого рідного Краю! Вітання Вам з України! Миру Вам, добра, і процвітання!
For two weeks now I've been returning daily to hear this haunting music. Each time I hear it, I am taken back to the 70's when I visited Auswitch and my heart was forever broken.
Loved performing together with Karolina, what a kind and generous person❤If you liked our performance, come support and watch our behind-the-scenes video: ruclips.net/video/Vp9DR4Qtv84/видео.htmlsi=FEBMuVnX6Ch4A-76
I loved the video Ray, you too are a very kind and humble guy, it was a wonderful experience for us to see you at her street performance and playing so beautifully together and of course your classical display was amazzing.
Thank you Ray for being there together with Karolina, for both creating these wonders for us all! ❤️❤️❤️
Thank you Ray your great presence it means a lot for Karolina i follow her since 2019 i love what she do.And now you are on my liste of
favorite.Your performances with her was extremely beautiful
Hope you can do more with karolina ray ❣️ England
O❤❤😊
My father was a classical violinist and a prisoner of war in the NETHERLANDS..his music was so beautiful..I use to cry listening to him at night when I was 5 yrs old..he never knew how he touched my little heart and how he still does, although he is gone I feel like he is with me and the song of war you both played brought me back to when I was 5..my parents were divorcing and I never got to listen to his most beautiful music again..ilu for how you help heal my heart...
I am Jewish and this week 1000 of my brothers and sisters - grandmas and little girls - were slaughtered just like the Holocaust but this time in Israel. I have been so in shock that I could not even cry - until this video came up - to see your beauty and hear the tragedy of the music at the same time - allowed me to cry a river over all the lost Jews from the Holocaust to this week...pray for us Karolina P.
I pray it 🙏
yes they were slaughtered by by coward but when they are confronted by guns the start running like the cowards they are
I cry for our 10,000 and 20,000 Palestinian brothers and sisters - grandmas/grandpas and little girls and boys - being slauhtered just like the Holocaust. I am so shocked by this decade old slaughterhouse with the Israeli military as the butchers.
@@gabrielemartin2022 go to those arab leaders and aggressors and cry there, before them, for what they cause to happen! You are right crying for them, for all their being misguided, feeded with and following misleading informations and idealogy from childhood on and filled with hateress towards the jews. And tell them to flee to keep their lives, if you hv a heart for those families there, bc the Israelis for sure cannot accept this murderous attacks
@@gabrielemartin2022 Also it is not at all true what you write and compare. This is the poison you use against Israel with what the aggressors and their supporters are nourished with. Israel warns before each strike of defence and takes explicit certain goals.
We are truly blessed. I think this is the way the song was meant to be played. Nothing wasted here. Simple and direct to the heart and to the soul. Karolina, Ray and the equally wonderful Ella Protsenko.
Exquisitely delicate, moving, magnificent performance - by our Violin Angel, Karolina - and world renowned violinist, Ray Chen. Drawn from the depths of their hearts-souls, they share their combined years of classical music training. I listen to this inspiring classical duet, over and over, and each time my heart is touched deeply. I thank God for these two beautiful humble souls whose musical artistry touches all of our hearts worldwide.
Thank you,
Karolina Protsenko and Ray Chen.
Love from Australia!
Hello, Kate! I sent this as an extra request to Jimmy - should be up soon. Greetings from Estonia!
@@toivotraks
Hi, Toivo! So happy at this news. :)
Jimmy’s reactions will, no doubt, be memorable. Something very special to look forward to.
Good wishes from Australia!
Ray, you are boosting her street cred as a violinist in a literal way and we couldn't be happier. Thanks for these heart-warming collaborations.
I don’t think she needs a boost from Anyone really
@@BarB2-90Nineyour right Bruce
Who's Ray?
It is very sad what happened at that time and my sympathy lies with all the victims of this inhuman madness, depicted in a masterpiece of cinematography. But also the performance of Dir Karolina and Ray Chen is undoubtedly masterful. I really like your performance. Let's also remember at the same time all the fallen victims of the war in Ukraine. Kind regards from Ralf Neumann from Germany.😊💖💖👏🙏🙏🐼
🇮🇱❤️🇺🇦
Diesen Worten, lieber Ralf, kann ich nur zustimmen !!
Michael Deppner, auch aus Deutschland.
Claro x culpa de los presidentes mundiales quedejan matar la humanidad ahi pues si la mayoria mandara " no deverian haver victimas inosentes solo combatientes muertos matecen ustedes y degen al civil quieto" y sano piensa " the charly no conchudos y cochinos" creo yo" the charly"???
I so much agree with you; and, YES, remember the thousands of victims in Ukraine!!!!!!
And thousands of victims in Donbass and Palestine.
Two Violin Masters playing a soothing melody for all to enjoy. I can’t help but be amazed how this young lady can remember all the notes and melody to so many songs.
Karolina's incredible talent, her angelic charisma, her emotions, great kindness and her heavenly joy make every of her performance perfekt, then togehter wiht Ray Chen, this can't be topped, What a thrill that must of been for every young musician. 🇺🇸🇹🇼❤️❤️
Karolina Protsenko and Ray Chen - You are both amazing musicians! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🎻🎻
Так! Ви праві! Чудові, й приголомшливі! Дай, Боже, їм здоров'я, радості, й миру!
Ladies first!!!!!!!
Except for Japanese!
@@The_land_of_truth_is_His😢😂😊
Agree..
You are absolutely amazing together. I am a professional guitarist, but if you cane to London, I would be the first to buy a ticket. You seem to have total chemistry and what an amazingly beautiful song. In these times we need people like you to lift our spirits and believe in the beauty that humans are capable of producing. Bravo to you both. Please come to London, you are great. 🙋🎸
Two heavenly gifted and beautiful people giving their best through their crying violins. Thank you both - and Ella for beautiful keyboard accompaniment of course!
Most definately,
“…heavenly gifted…”
Hi igial que el que interpreta el sonido ho lo percusiona " pienso yo att " the charly" claro puede sonar como fue diseñado y hasta gravado" falta ver percusionado debe sonar distinto creo yo" el sonido nunca miente piensa " the charly se escucha ho no una de 2" se ve y se siente ho ni se ve ni se siente ho simplemente ese fue"? El liche"???
Well said.100% agree.
@@frankgustafson1905Hello, Frank! This video is already up at Jimmy's, if you haven't reached there yet. I was so smitten with this that I requested it as extra at once and he did it right away. Cheers!
@@toivotraksHi Toivo! Went to Jimmy's page, watched it, loved it. Thanks for getting it requested so soon. So beautiful this performance is. Best!
Karolina as a fan of yours from when u started the music channel. You have developed a lot and collabed with many of them but this one is a genius of classical music Ray Chen this shows your bright future
I wish!!!beautiful performance from karolina and Ray's
The melody was sad but the performance was extraordinary. Hopefully, there will be many more collaborations between Ray and Karolina.
Karolina and Ray talents are great together. These two could make a amazing concert. I can hear Karolina’s classical training when she plays with Ray.
Hi Karolina
Im 15, I live in Israel and ive been playing violin for 6 years.
thank you so much for your music and support.
you're my favorite violinist and i rly admire you !!
pray for us......
Dear Carolina, Your playing and your singing are so lovely that it makes me feel good and very happy, you are the best, I just see you and I'm proud of you, May your parents and your siblings have a lot of happiness from you. You brighten my day with your unique face and smile, you brighten everyone's face, and the light of your face shines,
I was born in 1944 in Israel, Even at my age, I really, really enjoy your songs and music. And now in these days of a strong and dark war on Israel, You always keep shining the light in my eyes, And you see that many admire and love you!
May God be with you always!
May you always continue to add goodness and light and joy to the entire world,🎉🎉🎉
I love you - Grandma Rebecca❤😊

וגם הרבה מזל טוב ליום הולדת 15,🎉🎉🎉
תמשיכי להצליח!
ואלוהים יברך אותך!🎉
Words cannot say how beautiful John Williams score is to Schindler's List. You two are beautiful! Bravo to entire young group of musicians. Weeping...
Karolina and Ray are the violin duet duos! 🎻 🎼 They are very talented in their performance! 🎵 🎭 ❤ They good playing music together! 🎶 😊 Bravo 🙌 Guys! You’re amazing! 😍🤩🥰❤️
Hard to believe those folks are surrounded there listening to this concert free. Two great musicians who could demand a pretty penny to listen to them play. This is the real thing here. I wish they would come to Ohio to play at the Blossom Music Center. I suppose Karolina is still too young to spread her wings so broadly but her day will come. Emotional.
RAY CHEN you are awesome!! 🤗 So beautiful and your expression says it all! This a very touching piece. Just love it and with Karolina even better just seeing the two of you with such promising talent. God bless your heart!
There are no words to describe how beautiful that was. You and Ray just performed the most beautiful cover of Schindlers List that I have ever heard.
I agree it brings me back to the movie like I was in a daze almost and I’m amazed like angels playing music literally
Una balada triste para una gran película " la lista de Schindler", Karolina Protsenko y Ray Chen un dúo espectacular que me hicieron derramar lágrimas 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏💙💛💪💪💪💪💪💪💪.
Sad many humans have not learnt to live in peace yet with the war starting in Israel/Gaza
Karolina, this is a beautiful collaboration between you and Ray, and with mom and Leo accompanying you two. You give the violin a voice and an opportunity to show us the beauty of its soul and yours. You continue to show that you are a world-class violinist and can play with anyone. We love you out here. Marvelous. ❤🌹
This song makes me cry. It cries with lives of 6 million people and John Williams made it a memorial to all those who have passed.
Wonderful comunication between 3 musicians.
The violins sang expressively to each other.
EXCELLENT PERFORMANCE!!!!
Hi karolina😊
I Amichai from Israel,
I adore you, and I hear you all the time, and I also tell my grandmother, who loves you very much,
You inspire joy and pleasant light in all your songs,
In days like these, when there are many wars and darkness in the world,
Israel is my country,
and in Ukraine,
You continue to shine your unique and pleasant light,
with songs and melodies on the violin, of high quality and really beautiful,
And really relaxes and makes me happy
to see and hear you.
I hope and pray to good news and peace in the all world.
And good luck in everything you do!
Keep lighting up the world karolina❤
Karolina, that was an absolutely lovely performance by you, Ray, and your Mom. You all played this haunting piece of music beautifully, with such feeling. Even Leo caught the mood! Thank you all for this lovely rendition.
Sad but very beautiful music played by two wonderfully talented humans, marvelous
Yeah this was wow im literally still lost for words speechless
Krásne hranie s citom. Výborne znejúci duet , bravo 👍👍🌹🌹
The greates Ray Chen and KArolina. I love to come back and watch these two play together. Thank you for this divine music
❤ Karolina and Ray, you are AMAZING together!
❤️⭐️👍🎻🌹😊
This piece of music played by Ray and Karolina matches each other perfectly and is just stunningly beautiful beyond words! Thanks for offering me this moment of beauty.
I love the playing with emotion, it gives me chills. Excellent performance by all. Thanks. ✌️🙏🏼🎸😎🇺🇸🇺🇦🇩🇪
That was a beautiful performance Karolina, Ray and Ella. You all play with such heartfelt passion. Absolutely Loved it. ❤👍🥰😃
Dear Karolina, the performance by both of you is very good as it conveys the sad yet beautiful and powerful nature of this song. The high-pitched part that Karolina was in charge of had a very clear and beautiful sound. I was impressed by the performance of both of you. 👏👏👏❤❤❤
Воістину, правильно!
Ви навіть не уявляєте собі, як зворушилось моє серце, коли я слухав цю мелодію! Вже не раз я написав, що ця музика нагадала мені пісні мого рідного Краю, моєї рідної України, де я живу, і яку я підтримую від усієї душі! Миру Вам, добра, і благополуччя! Нехай у серці Вашому радість буде!
@@The_land_of_truth_is_His Велике спасибі.
@@sandysmith8293
🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤🖖
@@The_land_of_truth_is_His 🙏🥰🥰
This is a very beautiful and sad song performed by very talented musicians ray Chen and karolina protsenko who were absolutely fantastic together both hugely talented I have seen karolina in many videos and she can play any song but again super performance by both of them
My God!! Seldom have the performances of this magical young Karolina been as moving as this one. Karo not only played with her instrument, she played with her entire body, brain, heart, spirit and instrument, transmitting the deep emotion that she surely felt at that moment. Outstanding!!!
So soulfully played. It brought sadness from the bottom of heart. Thank you three musicians for the wonderful performance. I remember Karolina and her mom's another unforgettable rendition of this melody at the church that brought tears to my eyes.
Karolina, your collaborations are always exceptional! For such an amazing soloist, it's always surprising to see how well you mesh your performance with others.
I've never seen any of your partners outperform you. You are always their equal or better. And you are fun to watch.
Yes,indeed! And on this occasion,she rose to the challenge and in MHO...played on a level equal to any out there!!
No question!!!!!!
👍🐺🧙♂️!
Thank you so much!!
Karolina & Ray - Mis sentimientos a flor de piel, mis ojos derraman lágrimas, gracias 🎻🎻🎻👏👏👏
To be able to play with this artist Ray Chen is unbelievable. You really held your own, Karolina. What a privilege. How did you manage to get to play with him?
Ray Chen is a top violinist in the world, and this is real performance on the street! Not like the others who play music use pre-recorded music.
The violin is a unique instrument and very soothing tunes. The sounds of it brings joy to my heart And soul. The violin also calms my mind when listening to it. Very well played you two keep up the greatness well performed. Thanks for sharing this video.
Sad but beautiful thank you Karolina for invited Ray to perform with you it’s great to see two amazing musicians perform together
Bueno ahora invitare ha Carlos santana y Rob Thomas 1999 liv.NEA ZlXNH dice ahi att " the charly"???
Ha no me les pegue yo ha ellos " thank you " the charly"???
I am the descendant of a concentration camp survivor and I am Jewish, it touches my heart deeply every time I hear this song...
Me too
Those who ignore the past,are doomed to relive it. America will
repeat this if good people ignore
THIS EVIL. Mydadwas a medic whose unit liberated Dachau and
took pictures of the railroad carts
stacked with bodies. May Jesus have mercy on all those who
perished.
Bravo you made it
I didn’t know I had Jewish ancestry until I was a teen and neither of my parents were in the Holocaust but I’m sure I lost lots of ancestors there. Aren’t we ONE PEOPLE after all.. I came to Israel to visit a friend as a teen and was amazed how it felt like home, how many people had my curly hair and personality, sense of humor, it was all there, even my crazy chutzpah. I lived in so many other countries, but never felt that connection anywhere else. This song gets me in tears as does HaTikvah. It gets me every time. Go figure. Am 🇮🇱 Israel Chai 🇮🇱❤️❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱
@lenazorel690 how?/but your Chinese?🤔
You realize again what music can move and, above all, the content like in this piece. You two fit together perfectly and two violins speak two different languages and yet say the same thing. You can feel the harmony between Karolina and Ray
Thank you and hopefully more often together!
Greetings from Germany
Extremely amazing and emotional duet of the 2 most incredible violin players! Outstanding, the piano of your mom matches perfectly, and Leo is proud to be part of this wonderful presentation. Great 'job', your 'Cocker Spaniel' from Germany.
so beautiful!!! thank you to all of you, Karolina and Ray and Karolina's mother, Ella, playing so excellently on keyboards - just lovely
Well played both of you, you put so much feeling into it, so much so, some would have tears in their eyes. Karolina, Ray, must be so affected after performing with you. Ella, was great again on the Piano.
Love to all from Mike. ❤💙
When their name appears in the median, the doors of the fans' hearts open. Karolina you are just cool!! Richi ❤🧡💛💚💙
moving music especially in these times
THANKS Karolina / Ray
Excelente,que belleza escucharlos, gracias Karolina 🇦🇷👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼🤗❤️👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
776
😂 ❤
Karolina além de cantar, sente a música. Sobrenatural.Belíssimo dueto. 👏👏👏👏👏👏❤️🇧🇷
Скрипка зворушила серце моє! Я, справді, так люблю такі лагідні мелодії, такі, щоб душі торкалися! Боже, благослови Кароліну та її друга, Рея!
Bellissimo per un momento come questo.
Karolina Protsenko, That was a Lovely Violin Cover duet performance of Schindler's List that you and Ray Chen performed. Also, Schindler's List is one of the best Songs from the Movie Schindler's List. Also, Thank you for performing the Violin Cover Duet performance of Schindler's List that you and Ray Chen performed. Also, You are an awesome Violinist.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐
I never cry. Can't even remember the last time I cried. But this gave me a tear or two. How emotionally beautifull. ❤❤
I get it. I am tearful as well. A very moving performance. ❤
Ha si thank you" esa era la idea" jua.jua.jua " the charly "??? Ahora una gueidore para hidratar" el cuerpo"??? Ji.ji.ji" ho gotas para los ojos igual limpian el iris de los ojos"??? The charly"???
How ironic they played this song at this moment.. Sad many humans have not learnt to live in peace yet with the war starting in Israel/Gaza
I know. Disheartening…
I never cry either. I'm not a cold person but i never cry. I carry some guilt about that.
❤ Karolina it's just incredible how perfectly you play, esp at only 15 years old. And you keep getting better. ❤ Thank you for sharing your music!
😊❤️⭐️👍🎻🌹👏💞
The brazilian woman at the beginning screaming "maravilhosa!!!" (wonderful!!!), so priceless 🤗😄.
One of my very favorite melodies, you play it so exquisitely beautiful Karolina and Ray!!! Thank you, thank you, thank you!!!❤️🎻🎶🎻🎵⭐🙏
A very somber n telling song...! You ( both ) did very well relaying that set of emotions...
Thanks Miss K for this post, today,n this time..
Good job Ray!
👍🐺🧙♂️🦊🤙
🌹Absolutely beautiful. Especially in the middle when both were playing at the same time. Karolina plays the high notes and Ray plays the low notes. Like burning candles from both ends created Beautiful notes that come together in the middle🌹
アップありがとうございます👍美しい演奏に感謝です❤👏👏👏
Very sad 😢but beautiful music at the same time! Congratulations on your great talent and beautiful performance Karolina ❤!!! Wonderful trio!You are very pretty. I'm a huge fan of yours!🎻🎻🎹🌹❤️🙏
❤ I could not expected nore than the excelency of this artists, although I follow Karolina since years from now in violin ❤ and this extraordinary music makes all the hearts and souls that love music, just hear in tottaly silence and at the end...the claps!!! ❤ Bravo!!! ❤
Claro beautiful como en un concierto de bandas y sinfonicas ha la vez el publico no baila no canta y aplaude cuando terminan piensa " the charly"???
You know how you can tell they're both great they both turn into the song they are actually playing. You can feel it through their expressions. Just awesome 👍
❤❤❤
Вы прекрасны дуэтом. Каролина, как всегда, божественна. В эти трагические времена мира и любви всем нам. Каролина, продолжайте будить души и сердца. С любовью из России.
Some of the most beautiful music ever written and some ppl just walk past without stopping.
Perfect timing to post this. Thank you, Ray. It makes me shiver every time I hear this piece. How I would love to see you play it
You can see the pure anguish in Rays face as he plays, a real master in his art. And Karolina gives a solemn performance. What talent.
So wonderful performance and hearts touching music ❤❤🎉🎉
Справді, вірно! Я також вельми зворушений цим прекрасним виступом! Дай Боже миру і здоров'я цим талановитим людям!
That was an AWESOME Duo!! Many Thanks to Both of you!! God Bless!! Jerry
Ray Chen, you brought tears to my eyes with your playing!!!! 😥
This is beautiful, it brought me back to the movie, and brought tears to my eyes. They should do more like this.
Very beautifully played Karolina, Ray, Mom and Leo ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Karolina you are amazing as always 🥰 whenever notification comes from this platform I'm like 🥳🥳
Wow ! You both so talented musicians 👍👍👍👏👏👏👏👏👏👏🤎
Amazing performance🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷
Hi Avelina! I caught a glimpse of U in the crowd. I know U also would've performed the music from Schindler's List beautifully, whether with your saxophone, or with your bow and violin.🙂🙏🇺🇦🇺🇲♥️
Very beautiful performance, Ray, Ella and Karolina, totally amazing, very emotional ❤❤❤
One of my favourite pieces of music, performed by two amazing players, sorry three amazing players.
Congratulations on reaching the milestone of 1.8 Billion views on this channel! It's truly warranted. You are truly on the road to being an outstanding musician and you deserve all the success brought on by your hard work and earnest studies.
Dear karolina and raychen,this music is so emotional and nice to hear 🥰🥹, you two literally made the violin cry, your music is relaxing,i could hear it all day 🤩❤.....,
Schindler's List is one of the most moving experiences I have ever had. Your two covers of the music was both beautiful and heart wrenching at the same time! Good on you!
Karolina what a good interpretation done by excellent musicians. Thank you🎼🎻
Karolina, you always make us feel like in heaven. Amazing duet with Ray.👋👋👋👋
КРАСИВО И КЪСМЕТ ЗА ДУШАТА НА ВСИЧКИ
КОГАТО СЛУШАТЕ МУЗИКА..
ЧУДЕСНИ СТЕ МЛАДИ ХОРА.
СОФИЯ БЪЛГАРИЯ
That is so incredibly beautiful. And it truly is the saddest song. I started crying the moment Ray started to play. It hits you like a punch in the gut, which is what the Holocaust was to the Jewish people and to all of humanity. I've seen the movie, I've been to the Anne Frank house in Amsterdam. It absolutely breaks my heart.
Très belle interprétation, réalisée avec beaucoup de sensibilité. On est littéralement captivé en écoutant ces deux interprètes hors-norme.
You are getting better and better Karolina. The two of you should collaborate more together as you each enhance the others performance... Well done both of you...
Hi good day claro eso se llama entrenamiento" lo contrario seria improvisacion jua.jua.jua = eso hace " the charly siempre improvisa la percusion del sonido x eso dirigirlo es inventar" lo que el toca" x que esta inventado y tocado" pero no percusionado"??? Creo yo"???
素晴らしい、二人のバイオリン🎻演奏に心がうっとりしています😍
素敵な演奏を聴けてとっても嬉しいです、Japan ❤❤🎉
So beautiful I just had to watch it twice!!
Loved it, Schindler's List is one of my top 5 favourite movies and I just love the soundtrack from it. A big well done to you both, this was brilliant.
A big well done to your mum too on the Keyboard, awesome work all of you.
Que canção,amo violino,Karolina voce e esse Lindo Rapaz estao me deixando bastante feliz e emocionafa.👏👏👏.🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Excelente Carolina y el acompañante lo haces muy bien gracias por compartir tus vídeos con nosotros . 🤗🥲😘😘
Humans are perishing on both sides- pray for all souls💜😇
Beautiful far , far beyond words. Thank you Karolina❤❤❤
Very good music and excellent played. Thank you very much.❤❤❤❤❤😊
Thank you so much for helping Karolina, you are the perfect mentor for such a talented and beautiful musician.
An incredibly moving piece of music. Thank you for playing to perfection. To the millions of Jews killed you will always be remembered Rest in eternal peace ❤
Just, WOW! That was beautiful. I was captivated. All of you portrayed so much emotion in that piece. ❤ Leo's interpretative dancing with the cutlass was inspired.
Wow i love it ❤❤❤
А як я люблю таку музику! Я щойно в офіційному коментарі написав, що вона мені нагадала пісні мого рідного Краю! Вітання Вам з України! Миру Вам, добра, і процвітання!
For two weeks now I've been returning daily to hear this haunting music. Each time I hear it, I am taken back to the 70's when I visited Auswitch and my heart was forever broken.
It’s good to hear you guys play together and that harmony was beautiful.