And tabitha also heard someone say 'mom' in season 2 when she was in the caves with Victor after her house collapsed. Now it's confirmed it was Julie all along.
@@hitthisloudgbeforeichangem5749 he has to sound spaz wdym? anyone would if theyve been there for that long that just shows how much of a good actor he is
I think I figured the whole show out. In an interview, the writers have said that the whole thing was revealed in the first couple of episodes. Well, they talked a lot about the book Ethan is reading, "The Cromenockle". I think they're trapped in the story. Or at least a story. Some time in the past, the original townspeople performed a ritual that involved the sacrifice of children. Those children were read a story. I think something in the town has the power to bring people's thoughts, fears and imagination to life. So for the children that were sacrificed, the town brought the story they were read to life. Everybody in the town now, including the monsters, are characters in the book. That's why whenever a person or monster dies, they are replaced. The town has to contain all of the characters. So if one dies, someone else has to take on that role. I think the only way out of the town is to complete the story. Tabitha was only let out for long enough to bring back Henry because he's part of the story. The Boy In White is just trying to make sure that the story plays out the way it's supposed to. And I think the monsters are the wild card. They keep killing people and messing up the story. So the BIW is fighting the monsters to make sure the story plays out. That's my theory.
You would think they would right. I mean, the main goal is to get home isn’t it? So why isn’t everyone talking about every single thing they encounter or see. Elgin is another one who literally says nothing about what he’s experiencing or seeing. I’d expect fear and people disagreeing, but everyone refusing to share vital information?! Literally nobody is talking. Yea, they all rather stay stuck in the town.
As usual, Julie won't tell Boyd about how he was rescued from the well and Tabitha, Sara and Victor will stay mum about the town's history. Jade once talked about the town being a jigsaw puzzle with pieces missing. Guess the pieces are not missing rather in everyone's pockets.
So frustrating to still see characters who've been in that place for a long time, still acting like skeptical realists. They've seen so many supernatural events and they act like they've only been there yesterday. Biggest culprit is Jim. Still acting like the supernatural events don't exist and anyone with strange/supernatural ideas need to be brought back to reality. Or Tabitha still treating Victor as crazy regarding the doll despite being the most knowledgeable resident of the town.
And Jim shutting down ideas and theories like it's not necessary. One usually does that if they have an idea/working theory and they sticking to it. 😅 At the rate of how things are going, it would be best to just accept this fate and try to make it livable. Try to rebuild society in a way that will work under the circumstances and just go on with life.
But I understand Jim's reaction, he was like Jade but when he sought answers he was punished for it by almost losing his family and I think he has PTSD from that. He connects seeking answers with his family being unsafe.
Was interesting that Christopher rejected the boy in white’s advice and says “everything here lies.” Randall had the same attitude when Julie was saying they should go back to the ruins. Randall said something like “nothing here wants to help you.” Wonder if some people will follow evil visions, some will follow good visions, and some will ignore visions of any kind out of paranoia
I mean, time travel has been one of the theories to the show. It’s nothing new. It’s just that it’s now confirmed to be one of the factors. It also means that question has now been answered.
It was really time travel. Astral projection into the time stream. Idk.but she was definitely in more than 1 place in time. Bootstrap paradox and grandfather paradox.
I think one of the important details we have missed is that no one among the monsters is a child, I mean we have seen older monsters, younger one but never a child monster,maybe because the children murdered and were sacrificed And it's far easier yk as a child to manipulate the town people to get them inside but there isn't any child monster
we havent seen that teenager monster again since he spoke to julie. And the amount of monsters has gotten significantly smaller since the beginning as well
So I have a new theory!! What if the monsters are the anghkooey kids parents/relatives that betrayed them ??? & for their betrayal they became monsters, because remember with the autopsy on Smiley, they said they did have a similar anatomy like a human, everything was just dried up. I think the person/demon who is in control of everything is also the same person/demon that told the "monsters" back when they were human to sacrifice the kids. Now the real question would be is WHY would they want to sacrifice the kids ?? Immortality ?? Maybe the land (Fromville) use to be a real town where the crops & everything started dying for no reason & maybe the kids were dying of a unknown & untreatable disease at the time & the human/demon promised to make them better by doing a "ritual" but it instead trapped the kids there & made the parents/relatives monsters & they can't remember their past lives! I definitely think the Anghkooey kids are related to the monsters ! also look at the clothes that all the monsters wear, it's clearly from a whole different time era! I have a theory that (if time travel is possible) somebody will have to go back in time & convince the towns people NOT to trust the person/demon who says he's gonna cure the kids & fix the town! Idk it's a wild theory but I can definitely seen this happening !!
@@whitneydavis5096 the BIW is the evil entity. He wants the puzzle solved because he's trapped in that bubble world. He's trying to help so evil can escape
If so, this goes out of context for me. The nightmare creatures don’t eat for food (as far as we know). They are strictly terrorizers. Fatima eats spoiled crops aren’t fit for human consumption and then tastes the DEAD flesh and blood of that one girl. Elgin is a living being.
I think they will go, a way back to past somehow where they have to save Angkuyi children from getting killed by their loved ones. This is how from will end I think.
Yep ! They’ll need the 3 people who were screaming to get back into the runes ..I think Julie may have walked into the time of the children being sacrificed and was pulled out before she could see what was happening.
I was thinking the same thing! I was wondering a bit of that fallen tree as well because that was the beginning for everyone being trapped in the town. Nobody climbs over and tries to walk past it and since it's laying down we can't see if it's another faraway tree. It could simply be a prop to trap people though.
Totally agree Jim is a ass tart says to Tabitha do you know why the phone is off the wall proceeds to tell her somebody name Thomas called tell her everything dumb dumb smh
Definitely. It's frustrating and a bit illogical. "Here we are, trapped in a magic town that we can't leave, with undead monsters and mysterious amulets that can ward our homes, but I can't tell anyone that I saw something odd because they'll think I'm crazy."
I'm confused, did we watch the same season? They shared A LOT in this one confronting to the other seasons. Episodes 3-5-6 they talked to each other a lot about everything that happened to them.
The strangest thing about this episode for me was at the beginning, with Marielle walking calmly, humming a little song right at the moment that man found Tillie's body only for her to swear, run off somewhere and then never appears again in the episode; may be they forgot about her, may be she's into something else
@@CozyBatzThat’s not what *PLOTHOLE* means … It wasn’t narratively important for a nurse to hover over a long-dead body … She serves the living … I swear-this show has the dumbest fan base 😂
I feel like the show will have a completely insane ending similar to the 100 or lost 😂😂cause time travel with Julie throwing the rope gave me flash backs
You know what i like about your videos man? You're not like other youtubers that's just tell us what happened in an episode. You broke every scenes down with your own theories alongside them
I find it weird that they bring in new characters instead of just developing the story around the existing ones. Like I almost forgot about Ethan because somehow he has no story this season. Same for the bus driver - where did she go? She wanted to reopen the diner and changed her mind? They could have at least have a brief scene with her instead of bringing in random folks when they talked about the murder and Sara with a new cop.
This all could have been done like 2 episodes ago, now the last episode will be a major cliff hanger probably with Fatima, Julie, and Tabitha having the most mystery behind them for season 4
I believe when new characters get shown it doesn’t necessarily mean they are important but eventually more people will die and it has to be those background characters.
I think Tabitha is actually Elouise, when she ran after her mum she found both the rocks and ran from something worse making it to the faraway tree where she eventually ended up back in the real world with her memories blocked out due to the trauma and ended up adopted. So she's not having dreams, she's having memories.
Tabitha said she had that dream about the settlers village and the red rocks for months when she was a child and she would hide behind one of the rocks and she knew something bad was happening on the other side of those rocks but she would wake up before she could see what was happening every time. So I thought about the episode before that when Jade was at the village with Kenny and them gathering the crops to bring back to town. Remember he went to pee and when he was finished he noticed the red rocks. He dusted the snow off of one of them, and then as he looked up, he saw that ghost with the knife plunged into his eye/head. Then he got closer, and the ghost grabbed him by his shirt. If u go back and look, one of the red rocks is directly behind Jade. Then he saw the ghost again, drinking blood from a skull. Now, when he got back to town, Tabitha came into the bar and saw the drawings of the weird voodoo scarecrow things in the village, and she recognized them from her childhood dreams. So her and Jade went to the village and she showed him and Jim the rocks and said that in her dream she hid behind that one specific rock which happened to be the taller one that Jade was standing in front of when he saw that ghost with the knife plunged in his eye/head. So, I think her dreams are connected to whatever happened the day that ghost guy was killed/stabbed in the eye/head. Maybe the whole village was killed?? Kind of like the massacre in town when Victor was a kid. Obviously, the villagers were into some weird occult witchcraft kind of stuff, hence why the ghost guy was drinking blood from a skull! Something awful happened there, and Tabitha dreamt about it. The ghost guy's clothing and that village both appear to be maybe late 1600's early 1700's era. The dates on the wall behind Tabitha in that dream she had where she was walking up the basement steps and suddenly she was walking up the lighthouse steps included dates ranging from the 1500's to the 1900's. The latest date was 1978, which is the year Victor arrived in town, and when the massacre happened where everyone in town was killed, leaving him alone. I believe those dates correlate with tragic events. Jade saw those civil war soldiers too and another date on that wall correlates with that as well. Things are starting to string together slowly. The children Tabitha saw were sacrificed, and I believe they were maybe even born just to be sacrificed or born as some sort of weird ritualistic births. Remember, in the latest episode, Victor said the boy in white told Christopher that the children were BORN in the DARK! And that they were sacrificed in the dark! Tabitha saw them in the caves behind some wooden makeshift bars, almost like they were kept prisoner down in those caves. That is why they were so pale and their hair was falling out. Lack of sunlight and vitamin D will do that to u. I think the children are connected to the settlers village, and that is where their parents lived. I know I rambled on but I had to share when I realized the connection between Tabitha's childhood dreams and that ghost guy Jade saw in the village! 😂
I think the people who sacrificed children to "live forever" are the same people as our protagonists but trapped in an endless cycle of reincarnation and getting killed in that place
@ There has literally not been a single episode of filler. Just stop. Absolute absurdity 😂😂😂 You just have the patience of a toddler. Compare this series to something like Walking dead which is at least 60% filler … No comparison. Stupidity mixed with confidence is the most dangerous thing on this planet. That’s you-you’re dangerous.
the link between Jim and Henry is insane...remember Tabitha found a bracelet she made for Jim in Henry's car when they got into the accident. season 3 the first episodes
I think Tabitha is victor’s sister and she went through a tree but lived a normal life. And that’s why she had a “nightmare” of being there as a child. Even to the fact Victor told the story of how him and his sister would play hide and seek right so what if Tabitha is remembering her “nightmare” wrong. And that’s why Tabitha is having visions as her mom is Victor’s mom. Also maybe I believe Victor’s dad is “Martin”, the old man that’s in the alternate reality cave where Juli saved Boyd.
I have thought that maybe Tabitha really came from there, and was someone like Victor a Lil kid that gone there.. But I didn't thought of it that way that maybe Tabitha is Eloise, it actually kinda make a lot of sense... But may that's why the title is "FROM" because Tabitha came from there..
Baller breakdown as usual! I didn’t find this episode slow at all. After one of the absolute worst eps of the series in 307, wasn’t expecting this to be one of my absolute favorites. Almost no filler and we got so much from Victor, Julie, and Fatima/Ellis (wtf). I always wondered how Martin got the rope down to Boyd… Teacup has wrestled the most annoying character distinction away from Acosta 😂 Randall had a line to Boyd on the bus similar to Martin’s, re: the monsters not being the worst part of the town. Same character? 😳
Same... Always when there's any important discussion going on she comes from nowhere and asks what's going on here... Like she already knows where to go and where's something going fishy... Remember in one episode of season 2 randall said this that how donna comes everywhere?
This. He was just a kid who witnessed something disturbing and talked about it with his mom ;_; how was he supposed to know she will react this way ;_; I felt so bad for Victor through the whole episode specially when he was saying he's not good enough ;_; he knows he 'should' be more helpful with his knowledge but at the same time burying these memories is his way to cope with the years of trauma
I was thinking about this. So she just left her two kids to fend for themselves so she can go to a tree. I get she was trying to get them out. But by leaving them behind with some monsters is messed up.
@ because they so ungrateful like the only y’all able to be in his face and be mad about Randall is because he choose to between saving literally everyone or Randall and yet Randall still found a way to make it 😩😒🤣🤣
You are right. I just watched this episode with subtitles. And when Christopher is talking to the boy in white. Christopher yells you are lying! Everything here lies!
Theory!! When the boy in white spoke to Christopher he said that " The answers to the end are at the beginning" which could be translated to the riddle "What is the beginning of eternity, the end of time, the beginning of every end, and the end of every place?" Which is "E" so Ethan😱🤔
Because the end of the cycle is the beginning of a new one. Like a calendar. That's why the Hero's Journey narrative is a circle. But, definitely Ethan is the new cycle, he arrived similar to Victor, and they mirror each other.
I believe I figured out more questions that nobody talks about or really looks into. I know a few people saw my comment on his breakdowns for ep 7 for from. But, I have more for ep 8 and my own ideas of past experiences no one else talked about nor explained. Please be considerate of my own thoughts and research I did! 1. Tabitha/Miranda: I believe that everyone brought into this town is part of the story, once Miranda mysteriously disappeared without any reason no explanation of her “death” shown. I think Tabitha replaced her. However, they were the only ones who knew about the children until jade, victor, Julie, and past tense reincarnations of jade as Christopher, Jim as Henry, Miranda as Tabitha, all play a part. But, we don’t exactly know if Miranda is dead or not. Here’s what I know; Miranda had a map in the white storage truck that was victors hideout! She drew what places the faraway trees took you, what bad spots not to visit. She knew all of this and went into the tree herself during the day Christopher killed everybody and redid the cycle. Miranda knew this was going to happen so she hid her children. I think Miranda may reappear in an episode or next season to explain more questions we possibly have! 2. “Flight of the cromenockle”: I just looked up the book that is referenced multiple times within the story Ethan brings up and Julie asks about during her “screams” she kept hearing while at the threshold. I did my research and found another book relating to the “flight of the cromenockle” it’s called “flight of the cormorant” since cromenockle isn’t really made from Kay dillons there’s no evidence to find if this book was written. But, the cormorant was and I found this you’ll want to know: The conveying and guiding of souls or of the deceased to their final resting place across and beneath the Western sea was believed to be the responsibility of the sea-faring Pied cormorant. The word “cormorant” loosely translates to “sea crow”. Large, mainly black birds, these master divers and fishing birds have a long history of superstition. They have been associated with oncoming storms and great evil. The root of distrust and hate for this birds has a more practical source: perceived competition. Think about this every time we see a cormorant it’s a black raven aka crow when something happens to someone. Think about when Fatima was doing her tarot card reading. Why is that ask yourselves? 3. I mentioned in one episode breakdown in 7 about the faraway trees being homes to pixies, fairy’s, gnomes, talking animals, and elf’s. I also mentioned them being a 9 parallel universe of different worlds. This answers my questions about them and how extremely unpredictable they actually are. I think this also explains how Julie was able to go back in time in from to help Boyd, meeting Martin, and could have possibly discovered things we needed answers too.
I don't think Miranda is dead. I like your whole sea thing. The light house was obviously a massive plot in the show. The crows, everything else. There definitely seems to be a cycle. They talked about ending where it started so that could actually be Miranda or Viktor as a new cycle. What do you think about Boyd's wife? She sh0t a bunch off ppl saying this is the only way to be free, the only way they'll wake up. Tabitha fell from the lighthouse "diied", woke up in what we assume was the real world.
@@grungekiid Hello, thank you so much for the positive feedback on my comment! I'll answer your question about Boyds wife and what I believe so far. 1. Abby: Boyds wife same as himself served within the military, Abby (his wife) was the "badass" in the family and a marine. But here's something no one discussed...Abby must've had dreams when she was little as well relating to Tabitha/Miranda! Why? because she started to not get "better" Elis claimed to his father and to come help her. Abby claimed they would all "wake up, it's just a dream, it's not real". I believe Abby is related to Sarah. How? Well, Sarah starts to be told to kill Ethan the little boy, she gets hand writings on her arm and voices in her "head". But Abby was getting this way as well, so she was told to Possibly kill everyone and restart the cycle again. But long story short Abby could have been suffering from the marine life and struggled to understand what was real or not. Abby looked as if she needed to take "medication" or go to therapy to fix her mental state. Something or someone definitely had control over her mind or herself. 2. Seabird: I recently found this from my research and thought about it more. I possibly came up with the solution that used to be a back in the day thing. Ravens, or crows, would take the dead's souls or guiding their spirits to places such as we know "Frome-vile". The birds could symbolize more than 1 thing in this show. But I am sure we will know why soon enough. 3. Lighthouse: The Lighthouse is where Tabitha will find enlightenment. It's still too early to tell exactly but I imagine she has to realize that she probably let Thomas go. Although, this show is built off what people's fears or hopes and dreams are. The lighthouse represents the foolishness of believing in human power over nature. Lighthouses are usually viewed as symbols of safety-they are beacons guiding lost ships to the safety of human civilization and out of the treachery of nature (the dangerous waves). However, metaphorically speaking lighthouses represent navigation through life's challenges and difficult times. They provide a sense of direction, hope, and the importance of staying on course, making informed decisions, and finding our way during darkness or uncertainty. This concludes that in order for Tabitha to use the lighthouse she either had to let go of Thomas, or Jim. just like the faraway trees only Certain people who see "Visions" are able to access these portals.
@@politicallyincorrect2564 Hi, I thought about this as well and how could Tabitha also relate to Eloise. Yeah, he never said he saw Eloise's body, and a few eps ago, he told Sara that he took things from the dead townspeople, as a kind of tribute. He never mentioned anything about Eloise, so I've been wondering what really happened to her. Or…. Eloise became trapped as one of the Ankoowee children. But she might've survived and went with her mother only to enter a "safe" faraway tree and are somewhere else in from "Safe" and "hidden" I think we will see them soon in from once again.
You guys, the answer is right in front of our faces. The time loop or space time mashup indicates the past, present and future connect. Meaning the present can alter the past. The reason they have to save the children is because if they can go back in time they can stop the original towns people from ever sacrificing the children which will ensure the evil trapping them in the town will never be released. Saving the children is the key to everything but this is a group project. The entire town had to be involved, because there will be several different time periods that need to be accessed to do this. My only question is why these particular people were chosen for this task. I think some of them are connected to the original townspeople and some are connecting to other people who have been trapped and died in that place. Either way the like Victor says, the answers to the end are at the beginning. Go back in time and save those kids!!!! And my prediction is the baby is not a demon at all. I think the baby will be perfectly normal if not magical, knowing things no one else will be able to figure out. Being born alive in that place will connect that baby to the children. The baby will also be necessary to leave. Just a theory ☺️
This show has a fascinating concept and creates a unique dynamic that keeps us guessing. Every time we get one answer, it's immediately followed by ten more questions. It's like a riddle trapped in a puzzle, wrapped in a maze! One of the major mysteries is about the motel-where is it, and what happened to it? Henry pointed out, "How come we see a sign, but there's no motel?" I also think the numbers in the bottles might represent hotel room numbers. At some point, I predict the motel will become a central element in this story. While I understand the comparisons to Lost, there are significant differences. What made Lost so iconic was its strong, alpha male leaders. However, in this show, all the men seem to be portrayed as beta males who struggle with making logical leadership decisions. They often rely on mentally stronger female counterparts. For example, Boyd follows Donna, Jim defers to Tabitha, Kristi leads Kenny, and Ellis looks up to Fatima. Conversely, the men who display alpha-like qualities, such as Jade and Randall, are depicted as jerks or bullies. Throughout human history, when people face extreme situations and adversity, we tend to revert to our natural roles: men often become warriors and protectors, while women take on the roles of healers and nurturers. But here, the men seem passive, almost waiting for those around them to be killed. A prime example is Frank, who drinks himself unconscious instead of protecting his family, allowing the monster to slaughter them. No real man would do that when he has a scared little girl at home. It’s an intriguing writing choice-every male character is led by a stronger female. Even Julie shows better leadership skills than her own father, Jim. I don't think this is a mere oversight; it seems intentional, creating more intrigue and conflict in the storyline. The lack of communication among the characters adds to the show's chaos. No one is trying to come up with a plan of attack; they’re all just surviving as best they can. In reality, when humans face threats, we don’t just sit around waiting-we build walls, moats, and traps. Human creativity, especially in the art of survival and war, is unmatched. Yet, all of this seems absent in the show’s portrayal of their survival efforts. Despite these observations, I think it's a great show, and I’m excited to see how it all unfolds in the end!
Since we have time travel now! So what if that Kimono Women is Fatima! Seems like Elgin might get her trapped in that room, Remember we saw skeleton in that room when Elgin went in first time.
I did wonder how Boyd got the rope and it had occurred to me that a second person must have been there. But I'm back on the "Tilly is evil" or has something to do with all this bandwagon. If she didn't die in that way, Fatima wouldn't have had to run and been told to run and then be in a situation where she could be kidnapped to be put in a root cellar and give birth to devil spawn.
Dang so this whole tike Elgin has really become the new Sarah, and gives insight to how the town will find people to do it's bidding. But man not looking good for Boyds crew, I love Boyd, he's like a superhero, but everything is going bad. Kinda funny and ironic how harsh he's been to Acosta, just for him to turn around and cover up a straight up murder. Acosta's situation being 1000× more understandable and worth forgiving, and Boyd just looking at her, knowing who killed Tilly, saying "let's get to the bottom of this" is great writing, shits hitting the fan so hard
The time travelling theory has been something that I have considered for some time now. Tabitha in those clothes as a kid further solidified it for me, but then seeing that Julie was the one that threw the rope to Boyd; I do not need to question that time travel plays a major role on why things are so discombobulated in Fromville. Because it is only in time travel that people can be taken from a whole different part of the world and to a whole new one. With that said, can we talk about how Donna hardly has Boyd's back or am I imaging things? She basically plays the fun aunt whilst letting Boyd take all the blame for anything that goes wrong in Fromville, if people have lost faith in Boyd, she certainly has done nothing to help sway them otherwise; I honestly see her to be just as ungrateful as most of the townsfolk.
Ethan could be the boy in white, if time travel is real. Just look at his sister time travelling to drop the rope for Boyd. I don’t have evidence or a theory, but I feel like it’s possible. I’ve thought this since the boy in white was introduced to Ethan.
Not my theory but i liked it. The town itself was made by the entity and it's the boy in white. Where his understanding of the town is that of a child. It would explain why electric works with no cords connecting to a power source, running water and what not without plumbing. It's like a childs thought of things just work because they work.
so if boy in white told christopher the story and asked him to go to the tree to save the children .. how was miranda the chosen one when she ddnt even know what to do she actually heard from victor about the tree after victor eavesdropped ... if she was chosen why then ddnt she have the information on how to save them it was given to christopher
This is my theory. It relates the celtic mythology: In popular tradition, the Fae/Sídhe can have magical powers who may help or punish humans depending on their whims. Characteristics of the Fae/Sídhe: Parallel world: The Fae inhabit a realm separate yet adjacent to the human world, often hidden or invisible. This realm can overlap with ours in certain places. That could be Fromville. Nocturnality: The Fae are often believed to have a connection to the night, as it is the time when the boundaries between their world and ours grow thinner. That might explain why nights are time for monsters. Ability to make pacts: The Fae are known for making deals or offering bargains to humans, though these offers usually come with hidden traps or unforeseen consequences. we have seen that many times. 1. The Village and Its Connection to the Fae/Sídhe The village where the protagonists are trapped could have an ancient and dark history tied to the Fae. The villagers of Fromville might have triggered events leading to the nightly attacks. Here are some hypotheses: An ancient curse: Generations ago, the villagers' ancestors broke a pact with the Fae-perhaps by desecrating a sacred mound or stealing a magical object. Since then, the Fae have returned to punish them every generation and we are seing an iteration. Built on sacred territory: The village was constructed on an ancient Sídhe (a sacred mound), which acts as a portal to the Fae realm. The village as a trap: The village itself might be a creation of the Fae, designed to ensnare people. Farmville citizen could find themselves trapped in this place without understanding how they got there, with roads leading nowhere or looping back to the village in an infinite cycle. This aligns with many Fae stories where humans become lost in their realms for decades without realizing it. 2. The Nightly Attacks The attacks could be as varied as they are mysterious and terrifying. The Fae are masters of illusion and manipulation. These attacks wouldn’t necessarily start as direct violence but might grow progressively more psychological as we have seen so far this season. Subtle disturbances: The protagonists might start noticing small strange occurrences, like objects disappearing or moving, laughter or voices in the dark, or the sensation of being watched. They might also have unsettling dreams or nightmares where the Fae appear. Psychological attacks: The Fae could distort reality. The protagonists might begin seeing altered versions of their friends or family, making them doubt their sanity. The Fae might toy with their memories. Deadly illusions: Illusions might lead them into dangerous situations. They could also make the roles believe they are attacking each other, heightening paranoia. 3. The Rules of the Fae and Their Morality One fascinating aspect of the Fae is that they have strict rules, often unknown to humans, and breaking them can lead to severe consequences. Obviously that is the case of From because nobody knows what's going on: -Unspoken rules: For example, the Fae might punish someone for crossing a particular boundary in the village. -Trickster bargains: The Fae could offer the protagonists a way out or a solution to their problems, but always at a hidden cost. That would be the case of Tabitha's way out. -Shapeshifting into humans: The Fae are known for their ability to disguise themselves as humans and deceive them. Is there any Fae who is actually performing like human? That's something we are also willing to know. 4. The Final Escape or Bargain Is there a way to break the cycle or escape?. Several potential endings: - Uncovering the hidden truth: Perhaps there’s a way to break the curse if they discover the truth about what is making Fae control the whole thing. I still think that's likely to be the main option with the children that needs to be saved. It seems they made a ritual that did not end well and Fae is using people to break it. - Sacrifice: Maybe someone needs to make a terrible sacrifice to allow some people to escape-perhaps giving up their soul or being trapped in the Fae realm forever. That would explain why some people died in massive deaths. We don't know if they are dead out of Fromville. Who is gonna play this role this time? - Escaping the time loop: Perhaps they might realize that the village exists in a magical or temporal loop controlled by the Fae. They would need to find an exit-like a doorway between temporal worlds-before the loop resets or seals permanently.
The writers strike really crippled this show. 8 episodes in and barely any progress is terrible pacing for a show like this. No good writing made all the boring high school drama the main story lines.
I feel like Boyd can’t be trusted as a leader anymore, he will always place the interests of his family over the safety of the community, and the woman cop will probably use that to turn the town against him, I think Boyd is underestimating her
I feel that the martin chamber is some sort of time loop....when people are tied to chain they keeps living a horrible time again and again....once you are tied... you cannot escape.....remember Julie stops shaking as soon as she is carried out from the boundaries of the building that doesn't exist....so it is surely another dimension of time
I think Tabitha is Victor's sister who went after her mother and maybe passed by faraway tree to reality and sees the From town as a nightmare in childhood🙆🏻♂️😮....also is it only me who thinks martin (chained one old man) maybe is victor's father...but problem is old man didnt knew boyd but victor's dad know...🤔
2:32 ''Ellis said that he isn't good around blood. It's even more intersting because Ellis has type O negative blood, making him a universal donor. So Ellis seems to be collecting his blood to give to fatima'' You're mixing up Ellis en Elgin. Elgin isn't good with blood, but is collection his blood anyway. Ellis is the one with type O negative blood, making him a universal doner. We don't know Elgin his bloodtype.
Why they don't have a meeting in couple of days? And actually discuss what's happening with them with eachother. That will actually start making sense for them.
I noticed 2 things in the pilot. 1. After Julie tells ethan that nelson is dead in his puppet story. Tabitha tells ethan "well monsters aren't real so he can't be dead" so was boyds wife right in waking everyone up by killing them? 2. When the Matthew's pull up to the tree, after the second crow lands on the branch and the camera pans to the sky full of crows there's a sound subtitled *cawing intensifying* but it sounds more demon/pterodactyl like. I wonder if the fae are known for making those type of noises
Julie's hearing scream, and the seizure, remind me of Sara when she was out in the forest with Boyd. She also had the writing inside her arm (which seems to have disappeared now, after she killed Nathan). Is there a connection with her to the same fate that Martin, Julie, Randall and Marielle have had? Her "threshold" though, is someplace other than the at of Julie, also maybe its a similar but different situation?
@@Bradfrad362 Seeing as alot of people have finished the entire season already from what the comments keep saying "no idea where they found it". This is more than likely a better chance at being a spoiler lol.
I agree, she may have gone through all this when she went through the far away tree and forgot. This place makes her remember and it could be the same for everyone who have gone through the trees
@@tenma3108 Not really, I have watched really long and slow shows before. Changing the pace of the series every season is NOT GOOD, and specially when it is slowing down, rather than speeding up. 7 episodes can be summarized: Tabitha comes back with Victor's dad, Police offer on the ambulance shot someone, Fatima is pregnant (or not), Angil sees the Kimono woman, and They found vegetables in the woods where there are weird statues. Now compare that to other seasons
My thoughts; due to this occultist-like sh.t with ankhooey children Fromville is out of regular space and time that's why it devours people from all over the country at the random moment of their journey. Most people ended up here by pure accident like Donna and her sister, Kenny's family or Kristi. In the 2nd season Fatima told Elgin that some people had dreams/visions of this place before they arrived and I think those people are reincarnations of original townsfolk who lived during ankhooey kids ritual. They had some 'leftovers' of their previous lives imprinted in their memory and keep coming back to life and to the Fromville cause it's clearly some unsolved issue here(maybe children souls are trapped and need to be free or sth). Once they'll figure it out Fromville will stop existing/will free them all or at least will stop bringing new people in. Reincarnaited people are obviously Jade and Tabitha and most likely anyone who had someting unusual happened to them(Elgin, Sara etc.) Reincarnaited people can use some advantage like BIW guidance or using far away trees safely(Dale was the only one with no visible connection to the town and the only one to got killed by using the teleport). They can also walk through dimensions/time travel whith explains Tabitha's/Miranda's bracelets, bottle trees, Julie meeting Martin(and the monster that called her name in first season - maybe an encounter from the past/future?) but I guess this ability is hard to understand/be controlled. Victor and Ethan are heavily hinted to be the same soul and them being alive at the same time is probably an error caused by Victor's unexpected surviving. Also tho I love Victor's character- he'll probably won't make it out from the town as he already feels he doesnt belong to the outside world anymore. It will leave Ethan as his reincarnation. Characters like Henry and Jim- they not directly connected to the story but are meant to end up in town due to their relation to the chosen(reincarnaited) one.
An entire month of wasted episodes with about 30 mins max of anything worth helping the story build out of it all 🤦🤦. I see why they're begging for a season 4 now. This is the worst season by far and it's the writers fault.
I thing tabitha is victor's sister. •After the julie scene where she gives boyd the rope, this proves time travel exists. •The bracelet incident where tabitha and miranda made the same mistake on the bracelet. •tabitha getting memories of hide and seek instead of nightmares. •victor being absurdly calm when with tabitha
Jim is Henry reincarnated imo, I believe just about every Maine character in that town are reincarnated. Also Jim’s son was one of the monsters in season 1. He was on the porch and ask Julie does she recognize him. All my own opinions 🤷🏽♀️
I'm not sure a 100% Jim is the reincarnation of Henry because for being reincarnated Henry had to die, just like Miranda. The other stuf you wrote are interesting though
I think it a bit more layered; at this point Tabitha is 99% Miranda reincarnaited but when it comes to Jim I think he's just another version of Henry for this version of Miranda(sounds weird but u get me, right 😂?) In the earlier part of 2nd season Fatima told Elgin that some people in town had dreams/visions about this place before their arrival and I believe these people are the one who got reincarnated and have some 'leftovers' form their previous lives. Most prominent here are Tabitha and Jade. Abby, Boyd's wife was most likely also a reincarnation of someone. While all the other citizens like Kirsti, Kenny, Ellis or Bakta(bus driver) are more like bystanders and accidental victims of this whole situation.
I thought the baby would be another monster since smiley died,, and also having a human birth mother makes sense, because it would give them human organs, as we saw when they disected smiley too
This is my idea so far putting eveything together. As many have speculated the people in the From are stuck as pawns in a game between a good and evil entity. The game is about the kids. A long time ago, probably the first people to settle the town, were trapped and tricked by the evil entity to sacrifice the kids (they were tricked by their loved ones). Ever since then, the town has been stuck in a never ending perpetual cycle, where the game is being played between the two entities, one trying to keep the kids trapped (i believe this is beause the kids being trapped allow the evil entity to have power) and one trying to set them free. Eventually while the game plays out the entities have their main players, Tabitha who is set to saved the kids, and Jade who is set to re-sacrifice or keep them trapped. The reason why the cycle continues is because no one has ever managed to free the kids. The last attempt was by Eloise, Victors mom. However she "lost" the game, which ended up in the massacre of the entire town, and the game (the current people we are watching) starting again.
WARNING THIS IS REAL. I know some people hate spoilers no matter what but I know for others it helps the experience. I have seen the episodes and this is what I remember, it is not divided by episode. sorry about that. ++9-10 SPOILERS++ Boyd and some colony house ppl figure out Elgin has Fatima hidden and they kidnap and torture him to tell them where she is but he doesnt say. He keeps saying "it" told him it was the only way to save the town. Boyd realizes Sara said similar things when she was killing folx in ssn1 so he goes to her. She says he'll never tell them bc she remembers how she felt. While boyd and the others are areguing they hear elgin screaming and go upstairs and sara has blinded him/removed an eye (hard to tell) and says Fatima is at the root cellar. Jade, Tabitha, Victor, and Jim realize the bottle tree numbers only go as high as 12 and they might be musical notes, Jade says he will stand in the woods and play the notes on his violin and see what happens. I saw someone on this sub guess it might be about music so good for them bc they were right. And now the big ending things: Boyd goes to where Fatima is. She has found a hatch in the floor of the room she is being kept in but cant open it. She gives birth to a baby-sized fleshy pod. The kimono woman appears and takes the pod down the hatch. Boyd quickly comes in and follows kimono. She goes to a chamber where all the monsters are standing in a circle and puts the pod in the middle. It grows very fast and turns into a standing man, who turns around and it is the smiling man monster reborn. In the woods, Jade plays the song and one of the angkhooey children shows up. She sais angkhooey one more time and it looks like it snaps something in both Jade and Tabitha. Tabitha runs off and jade says "oh god." Jade then says angkhooey means "remember" but doesnt explain why. Jim goes to talk to tabitha who remembers she's been here before and was victor's mother, and jade was christopher, explaining why they see things related to both. Tabitha also remembers that she and jade were 2 original people in fromville, and one of the grey children was theirs in a life long, long ago. Apparently most of the town sacrificed the children because "it" said they could live forever if they did. I'm just speculating but that seems to be connected to the monsters who are maybe also original citizens who made the deal. Jade and Tabitha didn't and "tried to save them." Tabitha tells Jim she needs time now that she remembers. RIGHT at the end, while jim is processing, a short haired julie runs up to him, probably from the future. She says he has to run and "this is when it happens" and then someone says "hello jim" and a bald man in a yellow suit appears. julie tells him to run. The man says "you shouldnt have let your wife dig that hole" and rips out jim's throat while julie screams. It should be noticed this final scene takes place in daylight so the rules for the man in yellow are different than the monsters.
Julie and Boyd need to have a quick chat 😂
y?
@NEWZ_EDITZ Boyd was stuck in that well kind of thing.. And julie threw that rope for him to climb up
Bryh that scene had me so confused 😂😂 shittt did she just travel to the past?!
This hurts my head ahH
@@justinm1721 it's just a pocket dimension
And tabitha also heard someone say 'mom' in season 2 when she was in the caves with Victor after her house collapsed. Now it's confirmed it was Julie all along.
Viktor is the best actor in this show. Hands down
I agree. That actor really has range.
Victor is great. Some of the others are very good. Some, like Tabitha and Henry, are just passable..
Boyd, Jade, Sarah too.
Boyd is the best by far. Victor is just a spaz and very annoying
@@hitthisloudgbeforeichangem5749 he has to sound spaz wdym?
anyone would if theyve been there for that long
that just shows how much of a good actor he is
I think I figured the whole show out. In an interview, the writers have said that the whole thing was revealed in the first couple of episodes. Well, they talked a lot about the book Ethan is reading, "The Cromenockle". I think they're trapped in the story. Or at least a story. Some time in the past, the original townspeople performed a ritual that involved the sacrifice of children. Those children were read a story. I think something in the town has the power to bring people's thoughts, fears and imagination to life. So for the children that were sacrificed, the town brought the story they were read to life. Everybody in the town now, including the monsters, are characters in the book. That's why whenever a person or monster dies, they are replaced. The town has to contain all of the characters. So if one dies, someone else has to take on that role. I think the only way out of the town is to complete the story. Tabitha was only let out for long enough to bring back Henry because he's part of the story. The Boy In White is just trying to make sure that the story plays out the way it's supposed to. And I think the monsters are the wild card. They keep killing people and messing up the story. So the BIW is fighting the monsters to make sure the story plays out. That's my theory.
I like this theory! It makes sense, especially given today's episode, (episode 8) !
I think they are using the Cromenockle book like how Stranger Things used Dungeons and Dragons...
beautiful very logical "hypothesis" --- this in the future we will see, if proven more plausible or true then "this will be a theory"...
That actually makes sense
I also thought it had something to do with that book too!!
If Boyd, Tabitha, Julie, Jade and Victor become a team... Everything will be a lot easier..
I wish they would share their part...
And Ethan
@ScreamQueen1313 but Ethan wasn't useful this season.. right!?
@@ScreamQueen1313😂😂
You would think they would right. I mean, the main goal is to get home isn’t it? So why isn’t everyone talking about every single thing they encounter or see. Elgin is another one who literally says nothing about what he’s experiencing or seeing. I’d expect fear and people disagreeing, but everyone refusing to share vital information?! Literally nobody is talking. Yea, they all rather stay stuck in the town.
@@FooFamBoomBinker exactly... Elgin never shared about his dreams and now he's acting as the kimono demon lady's assistant..
As usual, Julie won't tell Boyd about how he was rescued from the well and Tabitha, Sara and Victor will stay mum about the town's history. Jade once talked about the town being a jigsaw puzzle with pieces missing. Guess the pieces are not missing rather in everyone's pockets.
This is exactly what's wrong with this show, no wonder it ain't progressing.
Julie didn't know it was Boyd down there tho?
@@mrfake5251 skill issue, show's progressing fine
@jonessii you seem like a "I like it slow" kinda person
@@mrfake5251 Slow is good
So frustrating to still see characters who've been in that place for a long time, still acting like skeptical realists. They've seen so many supernatural events and they act like they've only been there yesterday. Biggest culprit is Jim. Still acting like the supernatural events don't exist and anyone with strange/supernatural ideas need to be brought back to reality. Or Tabitha still treating Victor as crazy regarding the doll despite being the most knowledgeable resident of the town.
And Jim shutting down ideas and theories like it's not necessary. One usually does that if they have an idea/working theory and they sticking to it. 😅 At the rate of how things are going, it would be best to just accept this fate and try to make it livable. Try to rebuild society in a way that will work under the circumstances and just go on with life.
@@martian6201 That's the colony house.
But I understand Jim's reaction, he was like Jade but when he sought answers he was punished for it by almost losing his family and I think he has PTSD from that. He connects seeking answers with his family being unsafe.
Tabitha wasn't treating Victor as crazy. She was being very Mom-like to him. Sara was being very sisterly.
I think they were all related.
It’s okay, he will be dead soon
Was interesting that Christopher rejected the boy in white’s advice and says “everything here lies.” Randall had the same attitude when Julie was saying they should go back to the ruins. Randall said something like “nothing here wants to help you.” Wonder if some people will follow evil visions, some will follow good visions, and some will ignore visions of any kind out of paranoia
Yes but if you don't communicate or follow what the place or visions are telling you then you're not getting anywhere so..
There is time travelling too😂😂 jesus can they stop giving us more and more questions!!!
I mean, time travel has been one of the theories to the show. It’s nothing new. It’s just that it’s now confirmed to be one of the factors. It also means that question has now been answered.
It was really time travel.
Astral projection into the time stream. Idk.but she was definitely in more than 1 place in time. Bootstrap paradox and grandfather paradox.
Never mind thelat did you notice they played the intro twice
Right???😂
They better explain what's going on in the last episode. If not, I'm done 😂
I think one of the important details we have missed is that no one among the monsters is a child, I mean we have seen older monsters, younger one but never a child monster,maybe because the children murdered and were sacrificed
And it's far easier yk as a child to manipulate the town people to get them inside but there isn't any child monster
we havent seen that teenager monster again since he spoke to julie. And the amount of monsters has gotten significantly smaller since the beginning as well
I think the monsters are the townspeople who sacrificed the kids
something happens to the baby and it grows to an adult person in no time, becoming smiley.
Maybe the monsters are the children who just have grown up ?
I thought the monster that killed the bartender, that was trapped under the house with Jim was a child, no?
So I have a new theory!! What if the monsters are the anghkooey kids parents/relatives that betrayed them ??? & for their betrayal they became monsters, because remember with the autopsy on Smiley, they said they did have a similar anatomy like a human, everything was just dried up. I think the person/demon who is in control of everything is also the same person/demon that told the "monsters" back when they were human to sacrifice the kids. Now the real question would be is WHY would they want to sacrifice the kids ?? Immortality ?? Maybe the land (Fromville) use to be a real town where the crops & everything started dying for no reason & maybe the kids were dying of a unknown & untreatable disease at the time & the human/demon promised to make them better by doing a "ritual" but it instead trapped the kids there & made the parents/relatives monsters & they can't remember their past lives! I definitely think the Anghkooey kids are related to the monsters ! also look at the clothes that all the monsters wear, it's clearly from a whole different time era! I have a theory that (if time travel is possible) somebody will have to go back in time & convince the towns people NOT to trust the person/demon who says he's gonna cure the kids & fix the town! Idk it's a wild theory but I can definitely seen this happening !!
Very logical
I think you’re right and the demon is the kimono woman. Birth of her kid will be the massacre / reset attempt.
Nice
@@whitneydavis5096 the BIW is the evil entity. He wants the puzzle solved because he's trapped in that bubble world. He's trying to help so evil can escape
Some of them are kind of old though
Elgins blood is food for Fatima so she can get strong to have the demon baby.
I wonder "whose" baby it is if "not hers" 💀
@@BokunoRicoit’s that dead witch lady Elgin keep seeing…Fatima saw her in the cabin
The Demon baby is the Smiley Monster
Agreed!
If so, this goes out of context for me. The nightmare creatures don’t eat for food (as far as we know). They are strictly terrorizers. Fatima eats spoiled crops aren’t fit for human consumption and then tastes the DEAD flesh and blood of that one girl. Elgin is a living being.
I think they will go, a way back to past somehow where they have to save Angkuyi children from getting killed by their loved ones. This is how from will end I think.
Yep ! They’ll need the 3 people who were screaming to get back into the runes ..I think Julie may have walked into the time of the children being sacrificed and was pulled out before she could see what was happening.
It will be end by a cancelation I think unfortunately
I was thinking the same thing! I was wondering a bit of that fallen tree as well because that was the beginning for everyone being trapped in the town. Nobody climbs over and tries to walk past it and since it's laying down we can't see if it's another faraway tree. It could simply be a prop to trap people though.
@@trueblade3636i dont know if it will get cancelled but i do know alot of shows like this end without ever giving us a answer of why its happened.😊
What if thats only how the Farway tree is made not the whole Fromville? Just a thought
What really disturbs me is that Elgin transfers blood into a dirty dusty jar.
Of all the creepy shit on this show that's what really disturbs you? Disturbing!
It probably for Fatima to drink
I don't think that matters to someone who eats rotten crops.
@@ramennoodles8546😂 yup, Fatima will chug it up lol
Bro this is the least important thing 😂
I think they would make a lot more progress if they TALKED TO EACHOTHER!!! AND SHARED THE THINGS THEY SAW AND STUFF OMG
I think they tried to arrange a meeting but it failed
Totally agree Jim is a ass tart says to Tabitha do you know why the phone is off the wall proceeds to tell her somebody name Thomas called tell her everything dumb dumb smh
Definitely. It's frustrating and a bit illogical. "Here we are, trapped in a magic town that we can't leave, with undead monsters and mysterious amulets that can ward our homes, but I can't tell anyone that I saw something odd because they'll think I'm crazy."
I'm confused, did we watch the same season? They shared A LOT in this one confronting to the other seasons. Episodes 3-5-6 they talked to each other a lot about everything that happened to them.
@@SimonTargaryenthey might have but they definitely don’t tell each other right away🫠 like it takes them ATLEAST a few episodes
Elgin dragging Fatima down the stairs by her ankles was so damn funny
I hate Fatima
And terrifying 😢
Serial killer type shii
And sus, and that baby was punishing hee for trying to leave
In episode 9 he will grab the axe and say ,,heeeere's Elgin''.
Its just incredible how they dedicate 30 min to boring talks and only 10 min for actually important plot twists and action.
Damn, how did you feel about ep 307? Nothing happened til the last 3 minutes-literally. How are people complaining about 308…
Exactly what's wrong with the show
@@kcmet79cause still close to nothing has happened
@@mrfake5251 facts, after watching this episode i was so frustrated
The Henry/Jade & Jim scenes weren't too bad but. I'd be a drunk too if I were stuck there
Props to Jade for being the voice of reasons..😂😂
And Henry being a drunk at the bar 😂
Henry was the voice of reason
Does anyone else dislike Jim as much as I do?
@@vietnguyen3007 jim and boyd, both have really strong hate writings for this season..
@@ritchierich2793 nah
The strangest thing about this episode for me was at the beginning, with Marielle walking calmly, humming a little song right at the moment that man found Tillie's body only for her to swear, run off somewhere and then never appears again in the episode; may be they forgot about her, may be she's into something else
Could just be a plot hole and they forgot about her 😅😅
@@CozyBatzI doubt that
@@CozyBatzThat’s not what *PLOTHOLE* means … It wasn’t narratively important for a nurse to hover over a long-dead body … She serves the living … I swear-this show has the dumbest fan base 😂
@@GourSmithlike you yes
@@stoneyoung2014well your doubt aged horribly 🤡
I feel like the show will have a completely insane ending similar to the 100 or lost 😂😂cause time travel with Julie throwing the rope gave me flash backs
Definitely trapped on a cursed land of memories. Can't believe how long it's dragged on.😅
That shit had me so confused..
It's good so far.
The ending of LOST wasn’t insane so what exactly do you mean
Is this 100 show similar to from
I am looking for shows like from
You know what i like about your videos man? You're not like other youtubers that's just tell us what happened in an episode. You broke every scenes down with your own theories alongside them
His theories have been consistently wrong the entire way through tho
I find it weird that they bring in new characters instead of just developing the story around the existing ones. Like I almost forgot about Ethan because somehow he has no story this season. Same for the bus driver - where did she go? She wanted to reopen the diner and changed her mind? They could have at least have a brief scene with her instead of bringing in random folks when they talked about the murder and Sara with a new cop.
Couldn't agree more, when you examine the details of the writing like this it starts to look quite amateur
This all could have been done like 2 episodes ago, now the last episode will be a major cliff hanger probably with Fatima, Julie, and Tabitha having the most mystery behind them for season 4
i think bus driver moment was still about kenny, not her, to unbound him completely from diner
Exactly!
I believe when new characters get shown it doesn’t necessarily mean they are important but eventually more people will die and it has to be those background characters.
I think Tabitha is actually Elouise, when she ran after her mum she found both the rocks and ran from something worse making it to the faraway tree where she eventually ended up back in the real world with her memories blocked out due to the trauma and ended up adopted. So she's not having dreams, she's having memories.
But Tabitha’s clothes in her memories are way older fashion than Victors and his sisters in his memories. It’s more like 50s fashion.
At what point did she suddenly develop a Spanish accent then?
Tabitha said she had that dream about the settlers village and the red rocks for months when she was a child and she would hide behind one of the rocks and she knew something bad was happening on the other side of those rocks but she would wake up before she could see what was happening every time. So I thought about the episode before that when Jade was at the village with Kenny and them gathering the crops to bring back to town. Remember he went to pee and when he was finished he noticed the red rocks. He dusted the snow off of one of them, and then as he looked up, he saw that ghost with the knife plunged into his eye/head. Then he got closer, and the ghost grabbed him by his shirt. If u go back and look, one of the red rocks is directly behind Jade. Then he saw the ghost again, drinking blood from a skull. Now, when he got back to town, Tabitha came into the bar and saw the drawings of the weird voodoo scarecrow things in the village, and she recognized them from her childhood dreams. So her and Jade went to the village and she showed him and Jim the rocks and said that in her dream she hid behind that one specific rock which happened to be the taller one that Jade was standing in front of when he saw that ghost with the knife plunged in his eye/head. So, I think her dreams are connected to whatever happened the day that ghost guy was killed/stabbed in the eye/head. Maybe the whole village was killed?? Kind of like the massacre in town when Victor was a kid. Obviously, the villagers were into some weird occult witchcraft kind of stuff, hence why the ghost guy was drinking blood from a skull! Something awful happened there, and Tabitha dreamt about it. The ghost guy's clothing and that village both appear to be maybe late 1600's early 1700's era. The dates on the wall behind Tabitha in that dream she had where she was walking up the basement steps and suddenly she was walking up the lighthouse steps included dates ranging from the 1500's to the 1900's. The latest date was 1978, which is the year Victor arrived in town, and when the massacre happened where everyone in town was killed, leaving him alone. I believe those dates correlate with tragic events. Jade saw those civil war soldiers too and another date on that wall correlates with that as well. Things are starting to string together slowly. The children Tabitha saw were sacrificed, and I believe they were maybe even born just to be sacrificed or born as some sort of weird ritualistic births. Remember, in the latest episode, Victor said the boy in white told Christopher that the children were BORN in the DARK! And that they were sacrificed in the dark! Tabitha saw them in the caves behind some wooden makeshift bars, almost like they were kept prisoner down in those caves. That is why they were so pale and their hair was falling out. Lack of sunlight and vitamin D will do that to u. I think the children are connected to the settlers village, and that is where their parents lived. I know I rambled on but I had to share when I realized the connection between Tabitha's childhood dreams and that ghost guy Jade saw in the village! 😂
this is solid
🤔Acosta bears a striking resemblance to the Smiley Monster! I can't unsee it now!!!
she also has something similar with Abby
Jim self-proclaimed dad of the century, cut to his kids in the woods, facing danger, time travelling and what not😂😂😂😂
Average shonen protagonist's dad type of shit 😂😂
I think the people who sacrificed children to "live forever" are the same people as our protagonists but trapped in an endless cycle of reincarnation and getting killed in that place
sounds like a good theory! or it can also be that the murderers turned into monsters to live forever
really good theory
The writing is amazing.
The images in the theme song, I think that's where all the clues are.
That would make sense why they’ve had the same intro for three seasons lol
@@FlimsyPicklesLMAO
Most definitely. I’ve thought the same thing.
The writing is not amazing. Come on now. This show has turned into 90% plodding filler and 10% unexpected twist. That is not amazing writing
@ There has literally not been a single episode of filler. Just stop. Absolute absurdity 😂😂😂 You just have the patience of a toddler. Compare this series to something like Walking dead which is at least 60% filler … No comparison. Stupidity mixed with confidence is the most dangerous thing on this planet. That’s you-you’re dangerous.
the link between Jim and Henry is insane...remember Tabitha found a bracelet she made for Jim in Henry's car when they got into the accident. season 3 the first episodes
Time travelling 🙄I'm enjoying the ride,my fave show
I think they are the same person. Kinda. Tabitha is Miranda
episode 3
What if she has been there before or at different times and left clues.
@@strawberriesarelife No Cap, been enjoying this show fam...so much mystery but time travel is something we cant doubt no more
I think Tabitha is victor’s sister and she went through a tree but lived a normal life. And that’s why she had a “nightmare” of being there as a child. Even to the fact Victor told the story of how him and his sister would play hide and seek right so what if Tabitha is remembering her “nightmare” wrong. And that’s why Tabitha is having visions as her mom is Victor’s mom. Also maybe I believe Victor’s dad is “Martin”, the old man that’s in the alternate reality cave where Juli saved Boyd.
I have thought that maybe Tabitha really came from there, and was someone like Victor a Lil kid that gone there.. But I didn't thought of it that way that maybe Tabitha is Eloise, it actually kinda make a lot of sense...
But may that's why the title is "FROM" because Tabitha came from there..
Would make sense also with the weird bracelet coincidence 👀
I thought the same thing and what about the bracelets?
@@lili-annecharbonneau7143 yoooooo that's true
@@lili-annecharbonneau7143whoa 👀
[2:56] You said Ellis instead of Elgin a few times.
Baller breakdown as usual!
I didn’t find this episode slow at all. After one of the absolute worst eps of the series in 307, wasn’t expecting this to be one of my absolute favorites. Almost no filler and we got so much from Victor, Julie, and Fatima/Ellis (wtf). I always wondered how Martin got the rope down to Boyd…
Teacup has wrestled the most annoying character distinction away from Acosta 😂
Randall had a line to Boyd on the bus similar to Martin’s, re: the monsters not being the worst part of the town. Same character? 😳
the last point makes a good theory!
The biggest question of this series is: will it ever go anywhere?
No really.
They gonna try to drag it like Lost, we might have 10 seasons of this shit
I think the same thing I LOVED season 1 then by the end of season 2 I slowly lost interest
@@mrfake5251 Exactly what i was thinking.
Lots of what ifs and not enough explanations.
@@empurress77 Just wait for the finale. I can guarantee A lot of things will be answered then
too many plot lines, becoming too messy, and ultimately a nothing burger ! grrrrrrr
I really suspect Donna, don't know how to explain but there is instinct within me which says this!!
me too!! we never see her alone, she's usually there to manipulate the emotions/behaviours of the other characters...
nahh donna been a real one for far too long
Same... Always when there's any important discussion going on she comes from nowhere and asks what's going on here... Like she already knows where to go and where's something going fishy... Remember in one episode of season 2 randall said this that how donna comes everywhere?
No, she had a detailed and traumatic story about how her and her sister arrived
Victor has no blame for Miranda's death.
Miranda brought *her own children alone to save some random children, putting her children in danger*
This. He was just a kid who witnessed something disturbing and talked about it with his mom ;_; how was he supposed to know she will react this way ;_;
I felt so bad for Victor through the whole episode specially when he was saying he's not good enough ;_; he knows he 'should' be more helpful with his knowledge but at the same time burying these memories is his way to cope with the years of trauma
@@emilia-4911
Ion need all this yapping, just enjoy the show 🙏💀
I was thinking about this. So she just left her two kids to fend for themselves so she can go to a tree. I get she was trying to get them out. But by leaving them behind with some monsters is messed up.
If i were Boyd i legit would be like yall on yall own im done don’t call me for nothing matter fact don’t even look my way with yall ungrateful ass
😂
😂😂😂😂
Why did i hear this in his voice 😂😂
@ because they so ungrateful like the only y’all able to be in his face and be mad about Randall is because he choose to between saving literally everyone or Randall and yet Randall still found a way to make it 😩😒🤣🤣
They mad ungrateful for sure if it wasn’t for Boyd keeping some sort of order there everyone would of just went outside and been massacred
Anghkooey sounds like Aunt Julie to me 😂
Or aunt Tilly
I think the ankooey kids are trying to get Tabitha and Jade to remember who they are - or who they were.
@@mattgilbert7347 "you think" you ripped that straight from the leak 🤣 "you think" lmfao
@@nicholass3892these people are ridiclous
@@nicholass3892god damnnn it, i keep getting spoiled by comments like that, why do people present spoilers as their own theories 😢
Was it just me ? Or did Martin look and sound like Victor's father.
That was my first thought, too!
...or Julies father.
Interesting but then how did dude know about Boyd’s wife they came after the fact
@@raamthegreat5801 time is not linear there. Also, the voice on the radio will be Randall, even though it was hours before he even arrived.
They’re played by different actors. So maybe but I’d lean towards no
You are right. I just watched this episode with subtitles. And when Christopher is talking to the boy in white. Christopher yells you are lying! Everything here lies!
Theory!! When the boy in white spoke to Christopher he said that " The answers to the end are at the beginning" which could be translated to the riddle "What is the beginning of eternity, the end of time, the beginning of every end, and the end of every place?" Which is "E" so Ethan😱🤔
Good one!
Idk how you got this but im intrigued
Because the end of the cycle is the beginning of a new one. Like a calendar. That's why the Hero's Journey narrative is a circle. But, definitely Ethan is the new cycle, he arrived similar to Victor, and they mirror each other.
I don't know about anyone else, but in that 'clean' version of what Christopher said, it sounds like he said, "Everything lies, ETHAN".
Gyat daym
Slow episode? I loved this. When I got to the ending I was like nooooo
Yeah... only the ending was when something actually happened, otherwise the episode was just a nothing burger
@@mrfake5251facts
I believe I figured out more questions that nobody talks about or really looks into. I know a few people saw my comment on his breakdowns for ep 7 for from. But, I have more for ep 8 and my own ideas of past experiences no one else talked about nor explained. Please be considerate of my own thoughts and research I did!
1. Tabitha/Miranda: I believe that everyone brought into this town is part of the story, once Miranda mysteriously disappeared without any reason no explanation of her “death” shown. I think Tabitha replaced her. However, they were the only ones who knew about the children until jade, victor, Julie, and past tense reincarnations of jade as Christopher, Jim as Henry, Miranda as Tabitha, all play a part. But, we don’t exactly know if Miranda is dead or not. Here’s what I know; Miranda had a map in the white storage truck that was victors hideout! She drew what places the faraway trees took you, what bad spots not to visit. She knew all of this and went into the tree herself during the day Christopher killed everybody and redid the cycle. Miranda knew this was going to happen so she hid her children. I think Miranda may reappear in an episode or next season to explain more questions we possibly have!
2. “Flight of the cromenockle”: I just looked up the book that is referenced multiple times within the story Ethan brings up and Julie asks about during her “screams” she kept hearing while at the threshold. I did my research and found another book relating to the “flight of the cromenockle” it’s called “flight of the cormorant” since cromenockle isn’t really made from Kay dillons there’s no evidence to find if this book was written. But, the cormorant was and I found this you’ll want to know: The conveying and guiding of souls or of the deceased to their final resting place across and beneath the Western sea was believed to be the responsibility of the sea-faring Pied cormorant. The word “cormorant” loosely translates to “sea crow”. Large, mainly black birds, these master divers and fishing birds have a long history of superstition. They have been associated with oncoming storms and great evil. The root of distrust and hate for this birds has a more practical source: perceived competition. Think about this every time we see a cormorant it’s a black raven aka crow when something happens to someone. Think about when Fatima was doing her tarot card reading. Why is that ask yourselves?
3. I mentioned in one episode breakdown in 7 about the faraway trees being homes to pixies, fairy’s, gnomes, talking animals, and elf’s. I also mentioned them being a 9 parallel universe of different worlds. This answers my questions about them and how extremely unpredictable they actually are. I think this also explains how Julie was able to go back in time in from to help Boyd, meeting Martin, and could have possibly discovered things we needed answers too.
I don't think Miranda is dead. I like your whole sea thing. The light house was obviously a massive plot in the show. The crows, everything else. There definitely seems to be a cycle. They talked about ending where it started so that could actually be Miranda or Viktor as a new cycle. What do you think about Boyd's wife? She sh0t a bunch off ppl saying this is the only way to be free, the only way they'll wake up. Tabitha fell from the lighthouse "diied", woke up in what we assume was the real world.
Tabitha is Eloise which explains her connection to Victor.
@politicallyincorrect2564 what makes you think that?
@@grungekiid Hello, thank you so much for the positive feedback on my comment! I'll answer your question about Boyds wife and what I believe so far.
1. Abby: Boyds wife same as himself served within the military, Abby (his wife) was the "badass" in the family and a marine. But here's something no one discussed...Abby must've had dreams when she was little as well relating to Tabitha/Miranda! Why? because she started to not get "better" Elis claimed to his father and to come help her. Abby claimed they would all "wake up, it's just a dream, it's not real". I believe Abby is related to Sarah. How? Well, Sarah starts to be told to kill Ethan the little boy, she gets hand writings on her arm and voices in her "head". But Abby was getting this way as well, so she was told to Possibly kill everyone and restart the cycle again. But long story short Abby could have been suffering from the marine life and struggled to understand what was real or not. Abby looked as if she needed to take "medication" or go to therapy to fix her mental state. Something or someone definitely had control over her mind or herself.
2. Seabird: I recently found this from my research and thought about it more. I possibly came up with the solution that used to be a back in the day thing. Ravens, or crows, would take the dead's souls or guiding their spirits to places such as we know "Frome-vile". The birds could symbolize more than 1 thing in this show. But I am sure we will know why soon enough.
3. Lighthouse: The Lighthouse is where Tabitha will find enlightenment. It's still too early to tell exactly but I imagine she has to realize that she probably let Thomas go. Although, this show is built off what people's fears or hopes and dreams are. The lighthouse represents the foolishness of believing in human power over nature. Lighthouses are usually viewed as symbols of safety-they are beacons guiding lost ships to the safety of human civilization and out of the treachery of nature (the dangerous waves). However, metaphorically speaking lighthouses represent navigation through life's challenges and difficult times. They provide a sense of direction, hope, and the importance of staying on course, making informed decisions, and finding our way during darkness or uncertainty. This concludes that in order for Tabitha to use the lighthouse she either had to let go of Thomas, or Jim. just like the faraway trees only Certain people who see "Visions" are able to access these portals.
@@politicallyincorrect2564 Hi, I thought about this as well and how could Tabitha also relate to Eloise. Yeah, he never said he saw Eloise's body, and a few eps ago, he told Sara that he took things from the dead townspeople, as a kind of tribute. He never mentioned anything about Eloise, so I've been wondering what really happened to her. Or…. Eloise became trapped as one of the Ankoowee children. But she might've survived and went with her mother only to enter a "safe" faraway tree and are somewhere else in from "Safe" and "hidden" I think we will see them soon in from once again.
You guys, the answer is right in front of our faces. The time loop or space time mashup indicates the past, present and future connect. Meaning the present can alter the past. The reason they have to save the children is because if they can go back in time they can stop the original towns people from ever sacrificing the children which will ensure the evil trapping them in the town will never be released. Saving the children is the key to everything but this is a group project. The entire town had to be involved, because there will be several different time periods that need to be accessed to do this. My only question is why these particular people were chosen for this task. I think some of them are connected to the original townspeople and some are connecting to other people who have been trapped and died in that place. Either way the like Victor says, the answers to the end are at the beginning. Go back in time and save those kids!!!! And my prediction is the baby is not a demon at all. I think the baby will be perfectly normal if not magical, knowing things no one else will be able to figure out. Being born alive in that place will connect that baby to the children. The baby will also be necessary to leave. Just a theory ☺️
Idk if I’m tripping but I feel like the monsters could be the people who sacrificed the kids for like immortality idk tho 😅
then how did smiley died?
Or the monsters could be the sacrificed children as adults now
This show has a fascinating concept and creates a unique dynamic that keeps us guessing. Every time we get one answer, it's immediately followed by ten more questions. It's like a riddle trapped in a puzzle, wrapped in a maze! One of the major mysteries is about the motel-where is it, and what happened to it? Henry pointed out, "How come we see a sign, but there's no motel?" I also think the numbers in the bottles might represent hotel room numbers. At some point, I predict the motel will become a central element in this story.
While I understand the comparisons to Lost, there are significant differences. What made Lost so iconic was its strong, alpha male leaders. However, in this show, all the men seem to be portrayed as beta males who struggle with making logical leadership decisions. They often rely on mentally stronger female counterparts. For example, Boyd follows Donna, Jim defers to Tabitha, Kristi leads Kenny, and Ellis looks up to Fatima. Conversely, the men who display alpha-like qualities, such as Jade and Randall, are depicted as jerks or bullies.
Throughout human history, when people face extreme situations and adversity, we tend to revert to our natural roles: men often become warriors and protectors, while women take on the roles of healers and nurturers. But here, the men seem passive, almost waiting for those around them to be killed. A prime example is Frank, who drinks himself unconscious instead of protecting his family, allowing the monster to slaughter them. No real man would do that when he has a scared little girl at home. It’s an intriguing writing choice-every male character is led by a stronger female. Even Julie shows better leadership skills than her own father, Jim. I don't think this is a mere oversight; it seems intentional, creating more intrigue and conflict in the storyline.
The lack of communication among the characters adds to the show's chaos. No one is trying to come up with a plan of attack; they’re all just surviving as best they can. In reality, when humans face threats, we don’t just sit around waiting-we build walls, moats, and traps. Human creativity, especially in the art of survival and war, is unmatched. Yet, all of this seems absent in the show’s portrayal of their survival efforts.
Despite these observations, I think it's a great show, and I’m excited to see how it all unfolds in the end!
Since we have time travel now! So what if that Kimono Women is Fatima! Seems like Elgin might get her trapped in that room, Remember we saw skeleton in that room when Elgin went in first time.
I did wonder how Boyd got the rope and it had occurred to me that a second person must have been there. But I'm back on the "Tilly is evil" or has something to do with all this bandwagon. If she didn't die in that way, Fatima wouldn't have had to run and been told to run and then be in a situation where she could be kidnapped to be put in a root cellar and give birth to devil spawn.
Dang so this whole tike Elgin has really become the new Sarah, and gives insight to how the town will find people to do it's bidding.
But man not looking good for Boyds crew, I love Boyd, he's like a superhero, but everything is going bad.
Kinda funny and ironic how harsh he's been to Acosta, just for him to turn around and cover up a straight up murder.
Acosta's situation being 1000× more understandable and worth forgiving, and Boyd just looking at her, knowing who killed Tilly, saying "let's get to the bottom of this" is great writing, shits hitting the fan so hard
Bro,i just finished watching the latest episode right now and i was like okay time to watch Think Story cause i kinda got confused by victors story
It could be the man in the yellow suit returning that Martin is talking about
How’s the man in the yellow suit?
11:18 I think this is the essential moment of this episode. I think this is Tabitha reading the story to the kids
I just want one goddamn answer! I feel like I'm stuck in that shitty town with them 😂
Why, my child?
Same here for sure 😅
I honestly think that is the how the director wants the viewers to feel lol
The time travelling theory has been something that I have considered for some time now. Tabitha in those clothes as a kid further solidified it for me, but then seeing that Julie was the one that threw the rope to Boyd; I do not need to question that time travel plays a major role on why things are so discombobulated in Fromville. Because it is only in time travel that people can be taken from a whole different part of the world and to a whole new one. With that said, can we talk about how Donna hardly has Boyd's back or am I imaging things? She basically plays the fun aunt whilst letting Boyd take all the blame for anything that goes wrong in Fromville, if people have lost faith in Boyd, she certainly has done nothing to help sway them otherwise; I honestly see her to be just as ungrateful as most of the townsfolk.
On your voice program it sounded like Christopher says "everything lies ethan"
I got everything is a lie here
There were subtitles on the episode for me. “Everything lies here”
I think the boy on the porch is a young Jim. Elgin is a young Boyd, Acosta, a young Abby, and Victor's dad is the BIW.
Does no one else think Christopher is saying, “Everything lies Ethan” ?
Ethan could be the boy in white, if time travel is real. Just look at his sister time travelling to drop the rope for Boyd. I don’t have evidence or a theory, but I feel like it’s possible. I’ve thought this since the boy in white was introduced to Ethan.
@@traceredfield389interesting take I appreciate those who think uniquely gotta give credit to the creators especially irs so unpredictable
@@HasanAli-w9h4wyes this show gets the brain juices flowing. I’m loving it I hope you are too.
Definitely sounds like that. I think I had subtitles on though and it said “everything lies here”
@@Bradfrad362 yea I see that and you’re probably right I just want to hope for something crazy!
Not my theory but i liked it. The town itself was made by the entity and it's the boy in white. Where his understanding of the town is that of a child. It would explain why electric works with no cords connecting to a power source, running water and what not without plumbing. It's like a childs thought of things just work because they work.
Your reviews are more interesting than the episodes :))
so if boy in white told christopher the story and asked him to go to the tree to save the children .. how was miranda the chosen one when she ddnt even know what to do she actually heard from victor about the tree after victor eavesdropped ... if she was chosen why then ddnt she have the information on how to save them it was given to christopher
maybe it's Ethan who said to Julie don't you reconize me !!!🤔🤔
This is your best breakdown this season. Incredible
This is my theory. It relates the celtic mythology:
In popular tradition, the Fae/Sídhe can have magical powers who may help or punish humans depending on their whims.
Characteristics of the Fae/Sídhe:
Parallel world: The Fae inhabit a realm separate yet adjacent to the human world, often hidden or invisible. This realm can overlap with ours in certain places. That could be Fromville.
Nocturnality: The Fae are often believed to have a connection to the night, as it is the time when the boundaries between their world and ours grow thinner. That might explain why nights are time for monsters.
Ability to make pacts: The Fae are known for making deals or offering bargains to humans, though these offers usually come with hidden traps or unforeseen consequences. we have seen that many times.
1. The Village and Its Connection to the Fae/Sídhe
The village where the protagonists are trapped could have an ancient and dark history tied to the Fae. The villagers of Fromville might have triggered events leading to the nightly attacks. Here are some hypotheses:
An ancient curse: Generations ago, the villagers' ancestors broke a pact with the Fae-perhaps by desecrating a sacred mound or stealing a magical object. Since then, the Fae have returned to punish them every generation and we are seing an iteration.
Built on sacred territory: The village was constructed on an ancient Sídhe (a sacred mound), which acts as a portal to the Fae realm.
The village as a trap: The village itself might be a creation of the Fae, designed to ensnare people. Farmville citizen could find themselves trapped in this place without understanding how they got there, with roads leading nowhere or looping back to the village in an infinite cycle. This aligns with many Fae stories where humans become lost in their realms for decades without realizing it.
2. The Nightly Attacks
The attacks could be as varied as they are mysterious and terrifying. The Fae are masters of illusion and manipulation. These attacks wouldn’t necessarily start as direct violence but might grow progressively more psychological as we have seen so far this season.
Subtle disturbances: The protagonists might start noticing small strange occurrences, like objects disappearing or moving, laughter or voices in the dark, or the sensation of being watched. They might also have unsettling dreams or nightmares where the Fae appear.
Psychological attacks: The Fae could distort reality. The protagonists might begin seeing altered versions of their friends or family, making them doubt their sanity. The Fae might toy with their memories.
Deadly illusions: Illusions might lead them into dangerous situations. They could also make the roles believe they are attacking each other, heightening paranoia.
3. The Rules of the Fae and Their Morality
One fascinating aspect of the Fae is that they have strict rules, often unknown to humans, and breaking them can lead to severe consequences. Obviously that is the case of From because nobody knows what's going on:
-Unspoken rules: For example, the Fae might punish someone for crossing a particular boundary in the village.
-Trickster bargains: The Fae could offer the protagonists a way out or a solution to their problems, but always at a hidden cost. That would be the case of Tabitha's way out.
-Shapeshifting into humans: The Fae are known for their ability to disguise themselves as humans and deceive them. Is there any Fae who is actually performing like human? That's something we are also willing to know.
4. The Final Escape or Bargain
Is there a way to break the cycle or escape?. Several potential endings:
- Uncovering the hidden truth: Perhaps there’s a way to break the curse if they discover the truth about what is making Fae control the whole thing. I still think that's likely to be the main option with the children that needs to be saved. It seems they made a ritual that did not end well and Fae is using people to break it.
- Sacrifice: Maybe someone needs to make a terrible sacrifice to allow some people to escape-perhaps giving up their soul or being trapped in the Fae realm forever. That would explain why some people died in massive deaths. We don't know if they are dead out of Fromville. Who is gonna play this role this time?
- Escaping the time loop: Perhaps they might realize that the village exists in a magical or temporal loop controlled by the Fae. They would need to find an exit-like a doorway between temporal worlds-before the loop resets or seals permanently.
that old man tied in that cave is randall in future
I think he's (Randall) the man in yellow.
Randall a marine vet confirmed?
This video just explained Martin didn’t know Boyd so Martin can’t be Randall
@@Bougie_BonTon then how did he knw her name is julie
@@nobody6440 we can listed this as one of the unanswered question and probably won’t get an answer until the next 18th episode.
7:14 if you turn on close captions it will show what they're saying.
Christopher also called the boy a liar 😂
The writers strike really crippled this show. 8 episodes in and barely any progress is terrible pacing for a show like this. No good writing made all the boring high school drama the main story lines.
I feel like Boyd can’t be trusted as a leader anymore, he will always place the interests of his family over the safety of the community, and the woman cop will probably use that to turn the town against him, I think Boyd is underestimating her
I feel that the martin chamber is some sort of time loop....when people are tied to chain they keeps living a horrible time again and again....once you are tied... you cannot escape.....remember Julie stops shaking as soon as she is carried out from the boundaries of the building that doesn't exist....so it is surely another dimension of time
I thought I was watching the season finale episode - I am SO happy theres 2 more episodes!
I AM SO.. CONFUSED😭😭
I think Tabitha is Victor's sister who went after her mother and maybe passed by faraway tree to reality and sees the From town as a nightmare in childhood🙆🏻♂️😮....also is it only me who thinks martin (chained one old man) maybe is victor's father...but problem is old man didnt knew boyd but victor's dad know...🤔
2:32 ''Ellis said that he isn't good around blood. It's even more intersting because Ellis has type O negative blood, making him a universal donor. So Ellis seems to be collecting his blood to give to fatima'' You're mixing up Ellis en Elgin. Elgin isn't good with blood, but is collection his blood anyway. Ellis is the one with type O negative blood, making him a universal doner. We don't know Elgin his bloodtype.
This story really does play out like a horror fairytale. Ritualistic references, children and stories, colorful characters etc..
Jule has a urge to go to that place, well am taking my brother with me 😂
Why they don't have a meeting in couple of days? And actually discuss what's happening with them with eachother. That will actually start making sense for them.
You said Ellis multiple times instead of Eljian.
Good anaylisis thanks you!
I noticed 2 things in the pilot.
1. After Julie tells ethan that nelson is dead in his puppet story. Tabitha tells ethan "well monsters aren't real so he can't be dead" so was boyds wife right in waking everyone up by killing them?
2. When the Matthew's pull up to the tree, after the second crow lands on the branch and the camera pans to the sky full of crows there's a sound subtitled *cawing intensifying* but it sounds more demon/pterodactyl like. I wonder if the fae are known for making those type of noises
The guy in the cell said that Boyd should hurry before “he” comes I’m assuming he was talking about the man in yellow that show up in those drawing
Julie's hearing scream, and the seizure, remind me of Sara when she was out in the forest with Boyd. She also had the writing inside her arm (which seems to have disappeared now, after she killed Nathan). Is there a connection with her to the same fate that Martin, Julie, Randall and Marielle have had? Her "threshold" though, is someplace other than the at of Julie, also maybe its a similar but different situation?
I think the “he’ll be back soon” is referring to the man in the yellow suit we may meet soon.
The symbols sort of looks like the word HOPE. You can make out the H and E fairly easy. The O is the circle and the P is inverted
Fatima will go to the Box but the Monsters wont kill her
That would be be unfortunate 😂
Yeah, I’ve heard. I wonder if it’s because of the suspected baby.
Is this a theory or spoiler?
@@Bradfrad362 Seeing as alot of people have finished the entire season already from what the comments keep saying "no idea where they found it". This is more than likely a better chance at being a spoiler lol.
that's not how it ends 😅
Ethan had a seizure the first episode. Did he go somewhere and some when that will later be revealed?
Instead of "time travel" you can look it as a "flashback". Everybody is Remembering stuff. Julie is remembering.
I agree, she may have gone through all this when she went through the far away tree and forgot. This place makes her remember and it could be the same for everyone who have gone through the trees
except she's acting like she was just with her lil bro and now she's not
she even said to ethan this season in like episode 3 or 4, that she doesn’t remember some things
Hey I need 10 seasons of this show
I’am in LOVE
Martin sort of reminds me of Henry. Is it me or do they both have similar voices?
Yeah he does ay..
Did no one else catch that the narrator kept calling Elgin "Ellis"?
It took 8 episodes this season for 'something interesting happens'. Weakest season of the show
You forgot the first 2-3 episodes,later it turned boring
Nah y'all just have the attention span of a Chihuahua.
FROM CAST
Best Season Yet 😂😂😂
@@tenma3108 Not really, I have watched really long and slow shows before. Changing the pace of the series every season is NOT GOOD, and specially when it is slowing down, rather than speeding up.
7 episodes can be summarized:
Tabitha comes back with Victor's dad, Police offer on the ambulance shot someone, Fatima is pregnant (or not), Angil sees the Kimono woman, and They found vegetables in the woods where there are weird statues.
Now compare that to other seasons
calm down dude, wait til 9 and 10 it'll be the best one yet
When the past, present, and future meet in one moment, it’s called “eternity” or the “eternal now.” Some call it katiros-the perfect, timeless moment.
My thoughts;
due to this occultist-like sh.t with ankhooey children Fromville is out of regular space and time that's why it devours people from all over the country at the random moment of their journey. Most people ended up here by pure accident like Donna and her sister, Kenny's family or Kristi.
In the 2nd season Fatima told Elgin that some people had dreams/visions of this place before they arrived and I think those people are reincarnations of original townsfolk who lived during ankhooey kids ritual. They had some 'leftovers' of their previous lives imprinted in their memory and keep coming back to life and to the Fromville cause it's clearly some unsolved issue here(maybe children souls are trapped and need to be free or sth). Once they'll figure it out Fromville will stop existing/will free them all or at least will stop bringing new people in. Reincarnaited people are obviously Jade and Tabitha and most likely anyone who had someting unusual happened to them(Elgin, Sara etc.)
Reincarnaited people can use some advantage like BIW guidance or using far away trees safely(Dale was the only one with no visible connection to the town and the only one to got killed by using the teleport). They can also walk through dimensions/time travel whith explains Tabitha's/Miranda's bracelets, bottle trees, Julie meeting Martin(and the monster that called her name in first season - maybe an encounter from the past/future?) but I guess this ability is hard to understand/be controlled.
Victor and Ethan are heavily hinted to be the same soul and them being alive at the same time is probably an error caused by Victor's unexpected surviving. Also tho I love Victor's character- he'll probably won't make it out from the town as he already feels he doesnt belong to the outside world anymore. It will leave Ethan as his reincarnation.
Characters like Henry and Jim- they not directly connected to the story but are meant to end up in town due to their relation to the chosen(reincarnaited) one.
Jade makes the most sense, love this character. Jim getting offended by every word anyone says is too much
I think this has to be underwhelming FROM season. It was a lot of filler and all talk episodes.
Nah, season 2 was so much worse.
That ruined house is a time travelling place. They will have to use it to help other progress with the story
Banger episode
Copium
An entire month of wasted episodes with about 30 mins max of anything worth helping the story build out of it all 🤦🤦. I see why they're begging for a season 4 now. This is the worst season by far and it's the writers fault.
I thing tabitha is victor's sister. •After the julie scene where she gives boyd the rope, this proves time travel exists.
•The bracelet incident where tabitha and miranda made the same mistake on the bracelet.
•tabitha getting memories of hide and seek instead of nightmares.
•victor being absurdly calm when with tabitha
Jim is Henry reincarnated imo, I believe just about every Maine character in that town are reincarnated. Also Jim’s son was one of the monsters in season 1. He was on the porch and ask Julie does she recognize him. All my own opinions 🤷🏽♀️
I'm not sure a 100% Jim is the reincarnation of Henry because for being reincarnated Henry had to die, just like Miranda.
The other stuf you wrote are interesting though
I think it a bit more layered; at this point Tabitha is 99% Miranda reincarnaited but when it comes to Jim I think he's just another version of Henry for this version of Miranda(sounds weird but u get me, right 😂?)
In the earlier part of 2nd season Fatima told Elgin that some people in town had dreams/visions about this place before their arrival and I believe these people are the one who got reincarnated and have some 'leftovers' form their previous lives. Most prominent here are Tabitha and Jade. Abby, Boyd's wife was most likely also a reincarnation of someone.
While all the other citizens like Kirsti, Kenny, Ellis or Bakta(bus driver) are more like bystanders and accidental victims of this whole situation.
I thought the baby would be another monster since smiley died,,
and also having a human birth mother makes sense,
because it would give them human organs,
as we saw when they disected smiley too
10:29 What if he's Ethan grown up? 😮
This is my idea so far putting eveything together. As many have speculated the people in the From are stuck as pawns in a game between a good and evil entity. The game is about the kids. A long time ago, probably the first people to settle the town, were trapped and tricked by the evil entity to sacrifice the kids (they were tricked by their loved ones). Ever since then, the town has been stuck in a never ending perpetual cycle, where the game is being played between the two entities, one trying to keep the kids trapped (i believe this is beause the kids being trapped allow the evil entity to have power) and one trying to set them free. Eventually while the game plays out the entities have their main players, Tabitha who is set to saved the kids, and Jade who is set to re-sacrifice or keep them trapped. The reason why the cycle continues is because no one has ever managed to free the kids. The last attempt was by Eloise, Victors mom. However she "lost" the game, which ended up in the massacre of the entire town, and the game (the current people we are watching) starting again.
I thought we didn't get any answer after season 6 is realising
WARNING THIS IS REAL. I know some people hate spoilers no matter what but I know for others it helps the experience. I have seen the episodes and this is what I remember, it is not divided by episode. sorry about that.
++9-10 SPOILERS++
Boyd and some colony house ppl figure out Elgin has Fatima hidden and they kidnap and torture him to tell them where she is but he doesnt say. He keeps saying "it" told him it was the only way to save the town. Boyd realizes Sara said similar things when she was killing folx in ssn1 so he goes to her. She says he'll never tell them bc she remembers how she felt. While boyd and the others are areguing they hear elgin screaming and go upstairs and sara has blinded him/removed an eye (hard to tell) and says Fatima is at the root cellar.
Jade, Tabitha, Victor, and Jim realize the bottle tree numbers only go as high as 12 and they might be musical notes, Jade says he will stand in the woods and play the notes on his violin and see what happens. I saw someone on this sub guess it might be about music so good for them bc they were right.
And now the big ending things:
Boyd goes to where Fatima is. She has found a hatch in the floor of the room she is being kept in but cant open it. She gives birth to a baby-sized fleshy pod. The kimono woman appears and takes the pod down the hatch. Boyd quickly comes in and follows kimono. She goes to a chamber where all the monsters are standing in a circle and puts the pod in the middle. It grows very fast and turns into a standing man, who turns around and it is the smiling man monster reborn.
In the woods, Jade plays the song and one of the angkhooey children shows up. She sais angkhooey one more time and it looks like it snaps something in both Jade and Tabitha. Tabitha runs off and jade says "oh god." Jade then says angkhooey means "remember" but doesnt explain why.
Jim goes to talk to tabitha who remembers she's been here before and was victor's mother, and jade was christopher, explaining why they see things related to both.
Tabitha also remembers that she and jade were 2 original people in fromville, and one of the grey children was theirs in a life long, long ago. Apparently most of the town sacrificed the children because "it" said they could live forever if they did. I'm just speculating but that seems to be connected to the monsters who are maybe also original citizens who made the deal. Jade and Tabitha didn't and "tried to save them." Tabitha tells Jim she needs time now that she remembers.
RIGHT at the end, while jim is processing, a short haired julie runs up to him, probably from the future. She says he has to run and "this is when it happens" and then someone says "hello jim" and a bald man in a yellow suit appears. julie tells him to run. The man says "you shouldnt have let your wife dig that hole" and rips out jim's throat while julie screams. It should be noticed this final scene takes place in daylight so the rules for the man in yellow are different than the monsters.
Let's not forget Elgin knew the town already when they came in on the bus. He panicked and vomited.