So some people hate Lana for killing her son, yet they love Tate even though he killed a lot of people because they think he’s “good looking”...make it make sense
Not cause he is good looking , but because he was abandoned and treated like trash. Hence he did the things he did. Same with Olliver. But whos gonna explain that to you.
The difference between Johnny and Oliver is that even though Johnny is a killer, you can see that he's clearly struggling himself and is not happy with his lifestyle. As for Oliver, he's a true psychopath who gets pleasure in killing people.
Yep. That’s why Johnny “can’t measure up.” Oliver was a calculating, vindictive psychopath that had a pure love of killing. Johnny was a disturbed sociopath.
“Baby.” She used that word twice - not only to disarm and ultimately kill her son, but also to keep Oliver from killing her. Worked both times. Lana Winter really is a piece of work.
She loved her son hence why she killed him. She knew that he could not be helped and his life was already ruined. Such a tragic story, this was AHS at its peak.
If she had never gone out of her way to meet her son, all of this would not have happened. That's pretty selfish. Her resolve wasn't as strong as she thought.
@@jimjam1766 no you cannot blame Lana when she was the one to get raped and almost killed. She even said that she tried to love her son but she couldn't. That's a whole another level of state of mind
@@omerundal2984 She abandoned her child after he was born. I am not blaming her for not wanting the baby because she was raped. She shouldn't have gone to see him because that really did him no good. Why visit him years later? Did she think he was going to look any different from his father? Goes to see him but abandons him for a second time. That can really mess a kid up.
She was right, his dad never loved him. He saw him as a thropy and a future experiment. Lana did gave her son a chance to a better life or to at least grow up better. If she woudl have raised him they would have both felt the pressure of hating the traumatic past în The background. Seeing how her son made the same wrong choices as his father made her realize he îsn't redemable. By that time it was too late for him, he was too unstable and damaged. Many people say she was cold and cruel here, but i think she was actually murceful, not only for him but for his future vitims too. She did the right thing. Also, i knew she recogknized him since she started the confession. It felt like she was preparing her defence în a way.
I remember being so anxious through this whole scene thinking he would suddenly kill her then being shocked when she got him . but I’m glad she did. I had a brief wavering for him when he says i hurt people mom but yeah he had to go and she knew that. She had to do it to close that chapter in her life and ensure he couldn’t hurt anyone else
I wish more fans appreciated Dylan McDermott's phenomenal range in the first 2 and arguably best seasons of AHS, Murder House and Asylum. He went from playing a pretty normal family man to a serial killer and was 100% believable in both parts. Sad he never got nominated for his portrayals of Ben and Johnny.
LANA IS NOT A VILLAIN. She is a fucking survivor and one of the best characters ever. She is not perfect , but not everyone can be like Kit. And don't try to justify her asshole psychopath son.
I dare to say that I am speaking for the biggest part of the fanbase that THIS season finale (and the whole season) is by far the best of the show. No other surpassed Asylum and I think, unfortunately, that none will, not even 1984 that comes to an end this week. A pity that after Coven, the seasons were very weak in plot and they always mess up after the half, especially Freak Show and Apocalypse.
I can’t emphasize this enough. The energy in asylum was so much different than in later seasons. I want more seasons like the first two, dark gritty and strong in plot
@@cambearie I completely agree. In my opinion the first four seasons were rich in storyline. Freak show could’ve done better but everything after that season was just garbage.
@@Skech- Roanoke was a huge drastic change of style and had the scariest moments especially since the house in Roanoke was more unsettling than Murder House
I did not expect this to happen. I literally was shivering when Johnny points out the gun to Lana and then I screamed when Lana shoots her own son. For me, this is a smart move. Lana just had the last laugh. It's time to end all the killings associated with Bloody Face and by that, I think she's finally free from.the trauma.
He was beyond redemption...doomed to kill without regard...That was why Mary Eunice/ Beelzebub wanted him born. He was the promise of tumult, where Kit Walker's offspring were calm, potential light, and hope to humanity.
Plenty of them don't turn into monsters but plenty of them do. It's easy to justify why they shouldn't act the way they do, but we don't know how they feel and sadly people all act different... I'm that orphan, I'm the child nobody wanted, I could have easily been a complete lunatic if my Grandma wouldn't have spent 6 years looking for me and then taking me in as her own.
His dad was a serial killer. Point is in its in his genetic make up. Of course there are other people who are the children of serial killers and don’t kill. Like Ted Bundy had kids... and as far as we know he’s not a murderer.
The people here saying that she should have tried to help him or at least not gone to see him on that playground and say she’s terrible for this should also probably consider that he just held a gun up to her head and was very unstable honestly this counts as pure self defense for me.
I mean...she *shouldnt* have gone to see him on the playground. She gave him up for both of their sakes, so she shouldve stayed fully away. Everything else you said I agree with though.
Am I the only one who felt slightly sorry for him, he was clearly confused at his part within the world and thought if he became bloodyface he’d make his real father proud.
he never knew the love of a mother or father, he was conflicted on who his father was and why his parents never loved him. anyone would be fucked up with a history like his
No, you saw the human side if him, but psychopaths can flip in an instant. Lana was too wary to take any chances. Oliver seemed ambiguous about killing her in the basement. She caught his nutty butt off guard, learned from the past, took the window to freedom, and leapt out when she saw the opportunity. It was her or Johnny. How do you like those odds?
Lana killing both Oliver and her evil bastard son was SATISFIED! She went through hell in that place before she escaped and she was prepared in case Bloody Face's son comes back for her one day.
As Sister Jude Martin said " All monsters are human" even in the end that Lana survived all.those monsters back in the asylum. She kills her own son making her no better than any of the others only by her surroundings and fame is she taken to be any good
@@robyn964 are you for real you got to be joking the guy was a serial killer who murdered multiple women and was about to kill his mother who have to out smart him to save her own life
What made this season so brilliant for me was how complicated my emotions were for each of the characters. Everyone had a light and dark side and I never felt so ambiguous about so many characters before. I felt bad when Dr. Thredson and her son died and then I had to question myself, and also had to question whether Lana is really a 'hero' after all.
Some of these comments are pathetic. If the guy is cute he must be savable right? Idiots. Lana wasn’t some shit human being, she was human and overall a good person who got lost a bit bit made up for it just like the Jude, Kit, and Grace.
And this is the nature of human,I'm literally seeing the comments where people are judging lana for this move like they think that he would change, but lana knew that he will never change after everything he struggled in his life. She was a smart woman. People are so pathetic that they can show sympathy for a serial killer or a rapist but not for a woman like lana who was a survivor. And This is very hurtful.
nobody should hate lana for doing what needed to be done. she killed him because she knew he couldn't be saved. even though she didn't love him, she didn't want to see her only son have to continue down his dark path
I have always had conflicting thoughts on this scene but now I think I understand it..she gave him up because she knew she couldn’t be a good mother to him when she would look at him and every time see his monster father so she wanted him to have a “shot at a normal life” where she fucked up was going to see him at school that day And the look on her face when he told her that’s how he figured it out tells it all she wanted him to have a good life without carrying the baggage of his parents but it was too late..I’m not saying Lana is perfect but she did what she had to do
sᏆᎾᏒm7uᏒᏦ she sold and glamorized her tragic experience to the public only to get fame. She abandoned Judy who was the only reason why Lana was able to escape in the first place. She treated Kit, only companion throughout the Briarcliff, only as a source for news
@@mehmehmeh6130 Yes she tried to sell many copies but after all she's been through who wouldn't turn it at least into something that has value. And for us as a viewer Judy was sympathic at the end because of what happened to her but for Lana she was still the person that put her in this terrible situation. And she still tried to find her.
She could be a bitch at times, for sure, but she was raped by a psychopathic serial killer and gave birth to a son who would turn out to be just as bad. Yes, he showed remorse, but I think he would have killed again if given the chance. She could have handled things A LOT better, but that doesn't necessarily make her a bad person.
@@deerlord4729 What the heck are you talking about, he already knows he is a child of rape. If Lana gave him to her parents or relatives or friends atleast he would have had a chance to live a normal life and when he founds out how he was born atleast he would know his family doesn't hold him responsible, even Lana doesn't see him as an evil person. She says it herself that its her fault he ended up like this, because she wasn't there and that made John feel like his mother hated him and only his father loved him, thats why he became a murderer to make him proud. If Lana was there for him not as a mother but as an aunt, who helps him time to time he might have not felt alone and abandoned by his living family. Lana and John are both victims, none of them deserved what happened to them.
what does it takes for someone to intentionally pull a trigger point blank especially with their own kid ...i cant even imagine it .but that look on her face was all determination and finality there was no wavering in the end . makes you wonder if she planned for that moment all along . she did say she knew this day would come . i guess she told herself if he ever came to her bad she would finish him off . however she knew he was there but had no hidden weapon nothing to take him out so it’s all so very confusing 🤔
Very confusing. Like why would you visit your rape baby after abandoning him at the orphanage? And after meeting him, you abandon him AGAIN. From then on, he knew she was his mother and that sent him into the abyss.
I remember hating her for that as a kid (yes, probably wasn´t the best choice watching ahs as a 14 years old boy xd) But now as I rewatch the show i have a completely different opinion on this. He needed to be killed by her, there was no chance he could have been redeemed. So while it seems heartbreaking that she kills her son, it shows that Lana became so freaking strong after everything she went through and that she is ready to do what need to be done, even if it hurts her.
always thought this was kinda cold.. but she couldn't give him the answers he needed or do him any good he was damaged goods and she gave him a mercy killing instead... best season ever.. it had a very moving horrifying story with the richest character development ... i hate that fans complained about this masterpiece "wahhh wahhh it was too disturbing..too depressing" shut up! it was PERFECTION.. if social media hadn't whined about it so much maybe they would have made more seasons like this instead of those dreadfully cheesy, campy, annoying dialogue teeny bopper idiotic seasons that came later .. the show really went down the crapper :( season 1, 2, and 4 were masterpieces of perfection. I did really like season 5 but only cuz of liz and james patrick march..but it lacked soul and wasn't like the first 2 seasons and most importantly the characters weren't likeable it was hard to care for them and have sympathy unlike season 1,2, and 4.
He had it coming. He was an absolutely terrible person. Lana is the good one and in the right. One of the best characters I love her and Sarah Paulson played her so well. And she is so pretty
I don’t get why Lana killed him once she had the gun. What’s he gonna do? She could have just kept him there and tried to get him taken to a mental hospital which he clearly needed. I’m not excusing what he did he was violently insane but as evil and fucked as he was I still kinda feel like Lana owed it to her son to at least get him therapy or something. Idk.
There was no redeeming him. He is his father's son to the core, and he would have kept killing to justify his feelings, just as Oliver did before him. She never truly wanted her son to begin with, as he was a product of her being raped, but she couldn't go through with the abortion either. The thing about her son was that his feelings were ultimately unfounded, so he was killing for basically no reason aside from imagined slights. For all the evil he did, she couldn't let him live, just like she couldn't let Oliver live either.
Will we ever find out what happend to Lana after killing him? Did she get in trouble for this? I guess her working with the police, which is how she knew he was coming, got her off?
She probably claimed it was self defense. IMO it was very easy for her to get away with that, keep in mind that she was already a famous person and an award-winning writer back then. Fame probably helped her too.
she wasn't charged, she probably claimed self defense. johnny was already the suspect for a few murders so it wouldn't be too hard for her to say that she was his next target. plus, she was famous, we all know how that goes.
I remember this scene. It flashes back to the begginning scene when Lana Winters meets Sister Jude for the very first ever time. When Sister Jude was running the place. You know? xxxx ☺ ☺ 💓 💓
Oh Lana, you could have prevented all of this. I do not know what she expected, she had a baby with a serial killer and she did to him exactly the same what turned Oliver into a monster. She should have completed an abortion.
@@oneshak Of course, but you can't blame her. She was raped by a total sadistic psychopath, he murdered her girlfriend, some women are not able to raise a child of their rapists. But Lana and Johnny could work, she had mother instinct when saw him as a boy, she felt something for him, she was able to raise him, but she needed some time to heal. Their reunion here showed he's not like his father and she has influence on him, she always had. Johnny could have had a good life and be a way different person. In the end of all he's such a tragic character.
@@oneshakAnd he would have been a constant reminder of the hell she went through. She tried to give him a chance at life and look what happened with that. A situation like this is so complicated. I can't blame her for giving him for adoption. How could she look at him and not see his evil father and what she suffered through?
it was. the thing is that it was her son and she did not even feel sorry. I would be devastated and feel guilty. But she did not which disturbs me. She planned this. She knew he was coming to get her. She waited the right time to finish him off. She could call the cops and ask them to hide at least. But not she wanted to shoot him like she did with his father.
@@Kid_Charlemagne76 so? I did not say why she killed her. I said she made her son this way. Then she understood what he was planning. and instead of arranging some policemen and getting him arrested (a man who already killed many times before and wanted by police) she shot him by tricking him saying she has love for him. and she looked happy and satisfied afterwards not one inch sorrowful. That was ice cold. The ending scene of "The Good Son" mother kills her own child because he is a psychopath, but she still looks sad. because he was her son after all.
A narcissistic, psychopathic person is incapable of love. They only love themselves and if he didn't measure up to what his father thought would reflect good on him, he would have been useless to him.
@@bluebay1031 or she could have just not made him aware of who he was by going in visiting him after she completely abandoned him, that’s a very very cruel thing to make a child aware that their own mother doesn’t give a shit about them.
A Lana é a culpada pelo que o filho dela se tornou, assim culpada por todos que ele matou, ela é um monstro, no lugar dela eu nunca teria abandonado meu filho, mas o criaria com todo amor.
She had to kill him ,he was a murder and he would kill her or other women again,there was no hope for him. It sounds harsh and cold ,but that was the best thing she could do. He wanted to kill her and I dont think he would like to go to jail
If someone do it once it can change him or even twice, but he was a serial killer, a sociopath , someone who does have a conscience what he is doing and may think about it and sometimes feel guilt,but in the he will still do it. His father on other hand was a psychopath, someone without conscience and who commit crimes and never ask himself if thats ok. But they both lack empathy for others,except for themself.
@@lorenvsk Well, Lana had a horrible background of being raped and having her lover killed by a serial killer... BUT. Okay, She didn't want to be a mother of a monster, she had a chance to stop this by an abortion. She rejected it, but nevertheless gave the child to the orphanage. She didn't even tried to make sure that her son will be at least at better hands, but no, she just abandoned him. I don't sympathize him though, he's a killer too. As for me, I think Lana was even more responsible for such a miserable life of her son. Cause it was her that broke Johnny's life.
Lana made this monster by choosing to not be in his life. This was HER fault for her ego and her narcissism that created this. She’s lied her way to success.
Wow she’s a murderer, love the black and white view people commenting, he deserved redemption not a slap in the face after a lifetime of pain, he only murdered cause he had nobody, denied by everybody and had serious psychological problems which anyone criticizing could never understand, and don’t say plenty people have and don’t do this everyone is different.
So let's just let him go free. Screw all the people he tortured and murdered. You sound like a damn fool and this is one of the reasons we have so many criminals getting paroled after murdering numerous people.
So some people hate Lana for killing her son, yet they love Tate even though he killed a lot of people because they think he’s “good looking”...make it make sense
misogyny
@Eriona Pillow you're right and you should say it
@@christian-jordainecalvert2258 preach 🙌🏼
didn’t he also r violets mom??
Not cause he is good looking , but because he was abandoned and treated like trash. Hence he did the things he did. Same with Olliver. But whos gonna explain that to you.
The difference between Johnny and Oliver is that even though Johnny is a killer, you can see that he's clearly struggling himself and is not happy with his lifestyle. As for Oliver, he's a true psychopath who gets pleasure in killing people.
Yep. That’s why Johnny “can’t measure up.” Oliver was a calculating, vindictive psychopath that had a pure love of killing. Johnny was a disturbed sociopath.
“Call an ambulance but not for me “😼
Kkkkkkkkk
😭
lol
I remember watching this for the first time and was NOT expecting it
me too
Lana is such a survivor. She shot him gooooooood
“Baby.” She used that word twice - not only to disarm and ultimately kill her son, but also to keep Oliver from killing her. Worked both times. Lana Winter really is a piece of work.
Showing for us hes same as he father
This moment was so satisfying yet so heartbreaking.
She loved her son hence why she killed him. She knew that he could not be helped and his life was already ruined. Such a tragic story, this was AHS at its peak.
If she had never gone out of her way to meet her son, all of this would not have happened.
That's pretty selfish. Her resolve wasn't as strong as she thought.
@@jimjam1766 no you cannot blame Lana when she was the one to get raped and almost killed. She even said that she tried to love her son but she couldn't. That's a whole another level of state of mind
@@omerundal2984 She abandoned her child after he was born. I am not blaming her for not wanting the baby because she was raped. She shouldn't have gone to see him because that really did him no good. Why visit him years later? Did she think he was going to look any different from his father? Goes to see him but abandons him for a second time. That can really mess a kid up.
@@jimjam1766 agreed. Such a strong survivor that she just had to go visit him at the orphanage and ruin any chance he had at a normal life.
no she didnt love her son in my opinion thats why she abandoned him because she could never love him she even says it to him
Man that was so unexpected
She was right, his dad never loved him. He saw him as a thropy and a future experiment. Lana did gave her son a chance to a better life or to at least grow up better. If she woudl have raised him they would have both felt the pressure of hating the traumatic past în The background. Seeing how her son made the same wrong choices as his father made her realize he îsn't redemable. By that time it was too late for him, he was too unstable and damaged. Many people say she was cold and cruel here, but i think she was actually murceful, not only for him but for his future vitims too. She did the right thing. Also, i knew she recogknized him since she started the confession. It felt like she was preparing her defence în a way.
I remember being so anxious through this whole scene thinking he would suddenly kill her then being shocked when she got him . but I’m glad she did. I had a brief wavering for him when he says i hurt people mom but yeah he had to go and she knew that. She had to do it to close that chapter in her life and ensure he couldn’t hurt anyone else
im so anxious too i thought he wants another breastfeed. its so disgusting when he hired a prostitute to breastfeed himself
anon but they never say what happened to her it’s implied he killed her but they don’t actually show it
Lana is the best AHS character ever, you cannot change my mind.
Sister Jude,The Countess,Constance Langdon,Liz Taylor, Fiona Goode, Myrtle Snow,Marie Laveau and Cordelia Goode would all like a word with you.
@@EternalPayne and we say bye to them 🧡
Jessica Lange wants to know your location
I would say the same
@@dlievitanz ah, yes, Jessica Lange, my favorite AHS character😂
I wish more fans appreciated Dylan McDermott's phenomenal range in the first 2 and arguably best seasons of AHS, Murder House and Asylum. He went from playing a pretty normal family man to a serial killer and was 100% believable in both parts. Sad he never got nominated for his portrayals of Ben and Johnny.
I wouldn’t say the best. Murder house was good & while asylum had its moments, it was an extremely draining & depressing season the whole time
Lana's such a damn survivor, you go sistah
Elle The Animator she not better then the girl from scream
@@SawYouDie sidney? Lmao
@@SawYouDie ok but do u know who's better than sidney ? Channel Oberlin , she won't ever die 😩
@@EternalPayne yes her lol i hope the new scream movie is good that’s coming out
@@star-mc8hg 👀👀
LANA IS NOT A VILLAIN. She is a fucking survivor and one of the best characters ever. She is not perfect , but not everyone can be like Kit. And don't try to justify her asshole psychopath son.
I dare to say that I am speaking for the biggest part of the fanbase that THIS season finale (and the whole season) is by far the best of the show. No other surpassed Asylum and I think, unfortunately, that none will, not even 1984 that comes to an end this week. A pity that after Coven, the seasons were very weak in plot and they always mess up after the half, especially Freak Show and Apocalypse.
1984 fell apart in the last 4 episodes. If it had ended at Episode 5, then it would have been perfect.
I can’t emphasize this enough. The energy in asylum was so much different than in later seasons. I want more seasons like the first two, dark gritty and strong in plot
@@cambearie I completely agree. In my opinion the first four seasons were rich in storyline. Freak show could’ve done better but everything after that season was just garbage.
Cult was great imo
@@Skech- Roanoke was a huge drastic change of style and had the scariest moments especially since the house in Roanoke was more unsettling than Murder House
One of the greatest endings to a series
This scene was mind blowing
LMAO
I did not expect this to happen. I literally was shivering when Johnny points out the gun to Lana and then I screamed when Lana shoots her own son. For me, this is a smart move. Lana just had the last laugh. It's time to end all the killings associated with Bloody Face and by that, I think she's finally free from.the trauma.
I love this scene, she was as much of a villain as he was, all the circumstances that surrounded her made her that way. Such a good character ter
Shes not as much of a villain as he is, but she sure as hell wasn't kit level.
Plenty of people grow up without parents and don’t become serial killers or murderers. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Well they might if they find out the parent of the same gender as them was, and found out the the other parent didn't want them to even exist
Plenty of people aren't mentally insane
He was beyond redemption...doomed to kill without regard...That was why Mary Eunice/ Beelzebub wanted him born. He was the promise of tumult, where Kit Walker's offspring were calm, potential light, and hope to humanity.
Plenty of them don't turn into monsters but plenty of them do. It's easy to justify why they shouldn't act the way they do, but we don't know how they feel and sadly people all act different... I'm that orphan, I'm the child nobody wanted, I could have easily been a complete lunatic if my Grandma wouldn't have spent 6 years looking for me and then taking me in as her own.
His dad was a serial killer. Point is in its in his genetic make up. Of course there are other people who are the children of serial killers and don’t kill. Like Ted Bundy had kids... and as far as we know he’s not a murderer.
She's iconic
So tell me again why Dylan McDermott didn't get an Emmy for this?
i've been wondering the same thing for years
The people here saying that she should have tried to help him or at least not gone to see him on that playground and say she’s terrible for this should also probably consider that he just held a gun up to her head and was very unstable honestly this counts as pure self defense for me.
I mean...she *shouldnt* have gone to see him on the playground. She gave him up for both of their sakes, so she shouldve stayed fully away. Everything else you said I agree with though.
Not only self defense, also justice, she did what she have to do, and knew that was the best choice
Am I the only one who felt slightly sorry for him, he was clearly confused at his part within the world and thought if he became bloodyface he’d make his real father proud.
Ryan C Your not the only one; I felt sorry for him too
he never knew the love of a mother or father, he was conflicted on who his father was and why his parents never loved him. anyone would be fucked up with a history like his
ginger psycho plenty of kids grow up without parents and they don’t grow up to kill people, he’s mental and had no redemption, good riddance.
Well i had a brief moment when he says i hurt people mom but he had to go and she knew that
No, you saw the human side if him, but psychopaths can flip in an instant. Lana was too wary to take any chances. Oliver seemed ambiguous about killing her in the basement. She caught his nutty butt off guard, learned from the past, took the window to freedom, and leapt out when she saw the opportunity. It was her or Johnny. How do you like those odds?
probably one of the best endings to an ahs season
Lana killing both Oliver and her evil bastard son was SATISFIED! She went through hell in that place before she escaped and she was prepared in case Bloody Face's son comes back for her one day.
As Sister Jude Martin said " All monsters are human" even in the end that Lana survived all.those monsters back in the asylum. She kills her own son making her no better than any of the others only by her surroundings and fame is she taken to be any good
Well, she put and end to the killing. He wasn't going to stop on his own. She did a good thing.
K. Kelly you have to be somewhat evil to look your son in the eyes and kill him, a mother love is meant to be unconditional no matter what.
@@robyn964 so what's your trying to say is if your son's try to kill you let him ?
@@imanigabbana6629 nope, u can literally shoot without shooting to kill
@@robyn964 are you for real you got to be joking the guy was a serial killer who murdered multiple women and was about to kill his mother who have to out smart him to save her own life
What made this season so brilliant for me was how complicated my emotions were for each of the characters. Everyone had a light and dark side and I never felt so ambiguous about so many characters before. I felt bad when Dr. Thredson and her son died and then I had to question myself, and also had to question whether Lana is really a 'hero' after all.
Some of these comments are pathetic. If the guy is cute he must be savable right? Idiots. Lana wasn’t some shit human being, she was human and overall a good person who got lost a bit bit made up for it just like the Jude, Kit, and Grace.
And this is the nature of human,I'm literally seeing the comments where people are judging lana for this move like they think that he would change, but lana knew that he will never change after everything he struggled in his life. She was a smart woman. People are so pathetic that they can show sympathy for a serial killer or a rapist but not for a woman like lana who was a survivor. And This is very hurtful.
nobody should hate lana for doing what needed to be done. she killed him because she knew he couldn't be saved. even though she didn't love him, she didn't want to see her only son have to continue down his dark path
"I don't imagine at my age you'd be much interested in this skin". I would. Even old, Lana is a goddess. So beautiful. ❤❤❤
I have always had conflicting thoughts on this scene but now I think I understand it..she gave him up because she knew she couldn’t be a good mother to him when she would look at him and every time see his monster father so she wanted him to have a “shot at a normal life” where she fucked up was going to see him at school that day And the look on her face when he told her that’s how he figured it out tells it all she wanted him to have a good life without carrying the baggage of his parents but it was too late..I’m not saying Lana is perfect but she did what she had to do
You all are mad at her for killing him but he was about to kill her lol
Man i thought her son wanted a breastfeed
Me too hahahaha
What I most love about the series is that the "supposed" hero, Lana Winters is such a bad person.
sᏆᎾᏒm7uᏒᏦ she sold and glamorized her tragic experience to the public only to get fame. She abandoned Judy who was the only reason why Lana was able to escape in the first place. She treated Kit, only companion throughout the Briarcliff, only as a source for news
@@mehmehmeh6130 Yes she tried to sell many copies but after all she's been through who wouldn't turn it at least into something that has value.
And for us as a viewer Judy was sympathic at the end because of what happened to her but for Lana she was still the person that put her in this terrible situation. And she still tried to find her.
@@mehmehmeh6130 And she also didn't kill Bloody Face for Kit
Well everytime a woman shares her story ...there will always be some people to bash her
She could be a bitch at times, for sure, but she was raped by a psychopathic serial killer and gave birth to a son who would turn out to be just as bad. Yes, he showed remorse, but I think he would have killed again if given the chance. She could have handled things A LOT better, but that doesn't necessarily make her a bad person.
*I just finished Asylum and this part left me speechless.*
I felt bad for Johnny because he didn't deserve anything he got and ended up like his father. Now if Lana raised him and got him therapy .
@@deerlord4729 Atleast she could habe made sure he was in good hands, Johnny wasn't responsible for the rape.
Lesbo Beans - Oh yeah and he could grow up yo find out he's a child of rape. *What a life*
@@deerlord4729 What the heck are you talking about, he already knows he is a child of rape. If Lana gave him to her parents or relatives or friends atleast he would have had a chance to live a normal life and when he founds out how he was born atleast he would know his family doesn't hold him responsible, even Lana doesn't see him as an evil person. She says it herself that its her fault he ended up like this, because she wasn't there and that made John feel like his mother hated him and only his father loved him, thats why he became a murderer to make him proud. If Lana was there for him not as a mother but as an aunt, who helps him time to time he might have not felt alone and abandoned by his living family.
Lana and John are both victims, none of them deserved what happened to them.
EggTheTalonflame 145 She was fucking raped, show her some damn sympathy!!!🧐 She’s psychologically ducked too!!!🙁
You are in another reality , man
It appears that she had way more time to think about their meeting and how it would end than her son 💔
Lana was a ruthless, pragmatic genius.
what does it takes for someone to intentionally pull a trigger point blank especially with their own kid ...i cant even imagine it .but that look on her face was all determination and finality there was no wavering in the end . makes you wonder if she planned for that moment all along . she did say she knew this day would come . i guess she told herself if he ever came to her bad she would finish him off . however she knew he was there but had no hidden weapon nothing to take him out so it’s all so very confusing 🤔
Very confusing. Like why would you visit your rape baby after abandoning him at the orphanage?
And after meeting him, you abandon him AGAIN. From then on, he knew she was his mother and that sent him into the abyss.
Because... he held a trigger to her face first?
I remember hating her for that as a kid (yes, probably wasn´t the best choice watching ahs as a 14 years old boy xd)
But now as I rewatch the show i have a completely different opinion on this. He needed to be killed by her, there was no chance he could have been redeemed. So while it seems heartbreaking that she kills her son, it shows that Lana became so freaking strong after everything she went through and that she is ready to do what need to be done, even if it hurts her.
This enemy ladies and gentlemen is an example of a tragic character, lana did the right thing, the world already changed him forever
SHE ATE
The most iconic piece of media in television
always thought this was kinda cold.. but she couldn't give him the answers he needed or do him any good he was damaged goods and she gave him a mercy killing instead... best season ever.. it had a very moving horrifying story with the richest character development ... i hate that fans complained about this masterpiece "wahhh wahhh it was too disturbing..too depressing" shut up! it was PERFECTION.. if social media hadn't whined about it so much maybe they would have made more seasons like this instead of those dreadfully cheesy, campy, annoying dialogue teeny bopper idiotic seasons that came later .. the show really went down the crapper :( season 1, 2, and 4 were masterpieces of perfection. I did really like season 5 but only cuz of liz and james patrick march..but it lacked soul and wasn't like the first 2 seasons and most importantly the characters weren't likeable it was hard to care for them and have sympathy unlike season 1,2, and 4.
Good job Lana, you ruined your lovely carpet with Johnny’s blood.
And that is justice fulfilled regardless
He had it coming. He was an absolutely terrible person. Lana is the good one and in the right. One of the best characters I love her and Sarah Paulson played her so well. And she is so pretty
I just wanna know why they made her look like Hillary Clinton😭😂😂
BAHAHA
Haha 😂
I don’t get why Lana killed him once she had the gun. What’s he gonna do? She could have just kept him there and tried to get him taken to a mental hospital which he clearly needed. I’m not excusing what he did he was violently insane but as evil and fucked as he was I still kinda feel like Lana owed it to her son to at least get him therapy or something. Idk.
There was no redeeming him. He is his father's son to the core, and he would have kept killing to justify his feelings, just as Oliver did before him. She never truly wanted her son to begin with, as he was a product of her being raped, but she couldn't go through with the abortion either. The thing about her son was that his feelings were ultimately unfounded, so he was killing for basically no reason aside from imagined slights. For all the evil he did, she couldn't let him live, just like she couldn't let Oliver live either.
Murder House and Asylum quality are waaaay too high compared to the other seasons. Third is the second half of Roanoke.
i feel like for all that she should’ve just got the abortion 💀 she thought she was giving him a better life but she wasn’t
facts 🗣🗣🗣🗣💯💯💯
What an extraordinary woman!
Will we ever find out what happend to Lana after killing him? Did she get in trouble for this? I guess her working with the police, which is how she knew he was coming, got her off?
Spoilers:
Lana appears again in season six, Roanoke, but she wasn’t charged for her son’s death.
She probably claimed it was self defense. IMO it was very easy for her to get away with that, keep in mind that she was already a famous person and an award-winning writer back then. Fame probably helped her too.
sirens are heard after she shot him but his alibi could be self defense since he's an intruder at her home
@@fr0sty391 also name dropped in Cult but no physical appearance
she wasn't charged, she probably claimed self defense. johnny was already the suspect for a few murders so it wouldn't be too hard for her to say that she was his next target. plus, she was famous, we all know how that goes.
Al final, Lana si abortó a su hijo. Que poético.
Lana Winters has haunted my dreams for years...
This season was the most engrossing and harrowing to watch. (Well, of the ones I watched. I gave up around Roanoke.)
Still dissapointed that the hitchhiker in season 9 wasn't meant to be the son of lana banana.
Best abortion ever.
I remember this scene. It flashes back to the begginning scene when Lana Winters meets Sister Jude for the very first ever time. When Sister Jude was running the place. You know? xxxx ☺ ☺ 💓 💓
Lana is the best! I was a bit sad but I laughed when she killed him, she's smart and super strong, Jude and her were the best that season
I knew it was going to happen the whole time
Made him and unmake him. Killed the monster and its seed.
Good season but the alien aspect of it was so random lol
Oh Lana, you could have prevented all of this. I do not know what she expected, she had a baby with a serial killer and she did to him exactly the same what turned Oliver into a monster. She should have completed an abortion.
@@oneshak Of course, but you can't blame her. She was raped by a total sadistic psychopath, he murdered her girlfriend, some women are not able to raise a child of their rapists. But Lana and Johnny could work, she had mother instinct when saw him as a boy, she felt something for him, she was able to raise him, but she needed some time to heal. Their reunion here showed he's not like his father and she has influence on him, she always had. Johnny could have had a good life and be a way different person. In the end of all he's such a tragic character.
@@oneshak take care the son of your rapist, torturer that murder your girlfriend?. Who could do that?
abortion would've prevented lots..
@@oneshakAnd he would have been a constant reminder of the hell she went through. She tried to give him a chance at life and look what happened with that. A situation like this is so complicated. I can't blame her for giving him for adoption. How could she look at him and not see his evil father and what she suffered through?
She dont kill his Son she kill a bloody killer😂
Let's be honest...we all would have done the same thing as Lana. It was pure self defense
it was. the thing is that it was her son and she did not even feel sorry. I would be devastated and feel guilty. But she did not which disturbs me. She planned this. She knew he was coming to get her. She waited the right time to finish him off. She could call the cops and ask them to hide at least. But not she wanted to shoot him like she did with his father.
@@gmp8613 if my kid was a serial killer and if i was on his list, it would be kill or be killed
@@Kid_Charlemagne76 so? I did not say why she killed her. I said she made her son this way. Then she understood what he was planning. and instead of arranging some policemen and getting him arrested (a man who already killed many times before and wanted by police) she shot him by tricking him saying she has love for him. and she looked happy and satisfied afterwards not one inch sorrowful. That was ice cold. The ending scene of "The Good Son" mother kills her own child because he is a psychopath, but she still looks sad. because he was her son after all.
No I wouldn’t
She is far too young. People dont age that slow in real life. She would according to timeline be like 70 or 80 but she looks like 40-50.
Me in front of my tv when she shot him: 🤯
I love lana winters in this season and she killed bloody face and bloody face son.
MY JAW DROPPED
Why this part is so emotional tho.
No. But tell Pete what you did.
The only parent that loved him was his father that's why he followed in his footsteps
A narcissistic, psychopathic person is incapable of love. They only love themselves and if he didn't measure up to what his father thought would reflect good on him, he would have been useless to him.
You really missed every part of this season huh
The child rejected by the village will burn it down.
Where did he get the mask there's no way the shops just had them in and sold them like how did he find his dad's mask wtf
He made his own
bloody face was very infamous in that universe tho. And with Lana Winters' talking about them again the masks probably became popular
Which part
Everyone in the comments praising Lana...
Like God forbid the boy try and redeem himself or get better. -_-
He murder and torture women 😅
He murdered and skinned people alive, hun. The only dislike I have for Lana in this situation is that she should've killed him before he was born.
@@bluebay1031 She tried but could't go through with it.
@@roxane4594 bruh it's Lanas fault for going to meet him on the playground if she hadn't done that he wouldn't have found out who he was smh.
@@bluebay1031 or she could have just not made him aware of who he was by going in visiting him after she completely abandoned him, that’s a very very cruel thing to make a child aware that their own mother doesn’t give a shit about them.
U have to be Ruthless and Survive
What is the name of the song that starts in the end please?
Its the kahoot song ya kno??
A Lana é a culpada pelo que o filho dela se tornou, assim culpada por todos que ele matou, ela é um monstro, no lugar dela eu nunca teria abandonado meu filho, mas o criaria com todo amor.
2:06
Lana Winters is not a likable character after I saw this ending. I can’t believe people like her so much.
She had to kill him ,he was a murder and he would kill her or other women again,there was no hope for him.
It sounds harsh and cold ,but that was the best thing she could do. He wanted to kill her and I dont think he would like to go to jail
@@doriansz3130 I don’t think he wanted to kill her, he started to feel bad, but then she killed him. What a bad person.
This scene is one of the reasons she's one of my favorite characters from any season of the show to date
if Lana had committed her son to a good sanatorium that took care of murderers couldn't that change him?
Once somebody has committed several murders, there's no changing them
If someone do it once it can change him or even twice, but he was a serial killer, a sociopath , someone who does have a conscience what he is doing and may think about it and sometimes feel guilt,but in the he will still do it.
His father on other hand was a psychopath, someone without conscience and who commit crimes and never ask himself if thats ok.
But they both lack empathy for others,except for themself.
Why would she do that?
He'd keep killing people
@@ozlembozkurt8013 I dont think so
@@ozlembozkurt8013 her abandonement of him made him the killer in the first place.
@@28maitreyagupta21 but don't forget that she never wanted to have this child, she was raped... only Thredson's fault here
@@lorenvsk Well, Lana had a horrible background of being raped and having her lover killed by a serial killer... BUT. Okay, She didn't want to be a mother of a monster, she had a chance to stop this by an abortion. She rejected it, but nevertheless gave the child to the orphanage. She didn't even tried to make sure that her son will be at least at better hands, but no, she just abandoned him. I don't sympathize him though, he's a killer too. As for me, I think Lana was even more responsible for such a miserable life of her son. Cause it was her that broke Johnny's life.
Lana made this monster by choosing to not be in his life. This was HER fault for her ego and her narcissism that created this. She’s lied her way to success.
Well she was raped from a man who wanted skin her,but I do get what you mean, maybe the best would have been if she just aborted him
Wow she’s a murderer, love the black and white view people commenting, he deserved redemption not a slap in the face after a lifetime of pain, he only murdered cause he had nobody, denied by everybody and had serious psychological problems which anyone criticizing could never understand, and don’t say plenty people have and don’t do this everyone is different.
So let's just let him go free. Screw all the people he tortured and murdered. You sound like a damn fool and this is one of the reasons we have so many criminals getting paroled after murdering numerous people.
@@KKelly-ng1ni If I were her, I would've had him arrested or let someone else kill him. There's no way I could kill my own son🙈🙈
you condemn people for having a "black and white view" and then go ahead and call lana a murderer with your whole chest. oh the irony
Hey
Harshest mom ever
She didn't ask to be a mom. She was raped and got pregnant
This scene made me sad cause she deserved to die for neglecting her son but she survived
God I hate this scene. I can’t believe that she killed his son. I hate Lana Winters.
as she should
@@jaydc9110 disagree
I mean I get her side but he is still her son.
He also killed a bunch of people and was conceived through rape. BuT tHaT's StIl hEr SoN 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
@@belladonna6988 So you are saying if he wasn’t conceived through rape he’s worth not being killed. What kind of psychopath are you?
2:03