Link to buy these CD Wallets: amzn.to/3rTwoZt And these are the boxes I've used: amzn.to/3sNgqPO If you thinking of doing this please make sure that wallets you use are NOT made from PVC as this can lead to disc damage eventually. POLYPROPYLENE is safe.
I couldn’t bring myself to it. There’s something satisfying about owning the disc with the original jewel casing. I admire your emotional strength during this very trying time😂
I agree James. I have thought about going Andrew’s route too but I can’t . I will say with Spotify I do not buy discs anymore. Just the box sets I want
I have nothing against buying new jewel cases if the previous ones are damaged. I know people like the old smooth sided cases from the 1980s though. I don't really care as long as the discs are safe. And I " upgraded" all those Beatles remasters from a decade back as well as the Beatles Capital albums sets by putting them safely into shiny new CD jewel cases. also I just hate more than one CD in a case so if I get a double set I will put them into separate cases.
James Dean Yes, you are correct. I completely agree with you. I couldn't bring myself to it too! It is always satisfying when keeping the discs with the original jewel cases and it also adds value to them.
@@phillipanderson7398 Yes, I agree with you. Did you put the Beatles remaster discs in new cases because the original jewel cases are damaged? I hope so, otherwise there's no point. Regarding placing two or more discs in the cases, there are double or multi disc jewel cases available in the market which will suit your needs.
@@janath9118 The Beatles remaster discs did not come in jewel cases. They were in glossy cardboard digi-paks, I put the remastered discs ( and any albums that come in mini LP cardboard covers like the Beatles Capital Albums sets) into new jewel cases I bought at the local Officeworks store. As for the mutli disc jewel cases I was saying that I don't like them. I always prefer single disc jewel cases. The only exception is " fat boy" multi jewel cases where I am ok with these cases that hold two discs and in some cases three or four discs.
@Andrew Dixon I, too, have recently gone this route for both my CDs and DVDs. I have no regrets. It actually makes me appreciate my collection a bit more. The CDs are now more akin to mini LPs in my mind. And I have re-examined a number of discs I have not considered for some time. Thinking about it? I say go for it!
I have about 1500 CDs and I used an intermediate solution: I placed in the thin sleeves only front cover and CD. I left back cover in the jewel case, and stored all jewel cases in boxes in the attic. That way, each CD still has his original jewel case, in case I want to recompose it, or sell it. Jewel cases have changed over the years, some have stickers particular to the CDs, so I like to be able to match CDs and jewel cases, just in case. Anyway, storage saving is about a factor of 4!
If you are keeping the back covers of CD's stored seperately with the jewel cases, how are you supposed to read or refer the song lists and other important details when playing those CD's? That's absurd. There's no meaning to whatever you did. If the point here is to save the space, you can leave out the jewel cases but it's necessary to keep at least both front and back covers together.
I did this several years ago and I regretted it not long afterwards. I’ve bought many jewel cases and replacement CDs over the last couple of years to undo my mistake. I think that many people would like your method for storage purposes and if they aren’t attached to the original style packaging.
The jewel case is a part of history. It was what we got our cds in. If you want to be true to your collection, keep them in jewel cases. You wouldn't treat your vinyl any different. Keep your media true to the way they were originally released. Thats my opinion.
I went this same route at the beginning of last year. The amount of space it saved was amazing, but, in the end, I thought it looked too messy and not all of the spines were easily readable. Plus, I still had my digi-paks in the alphabetical mix every so often. After about four months, I went back to jewel cases. I just really like the look and (somewhat) uniformity of those plastic cases.
I did the exact same thing with my DVDs and Blu-Rays but have not considered it with my CDs just yet. It's amazing how much space you save doing this. All my movies took up more than an entire rack but now they're down to just a few plastic bins on the shelf. One thing I did was to make some alphabetical index cards so I just look for the tab sticking out to find what I'm looking for quicker. I may just have to consider this for my CDs now as well.
I'm definitely going to have some alphabetical index cards. I'm wondering if there's some way I could use some of my empty jewel cases to make them from!? If they weren't so brittle it would be an easier task...
Did this a few years ago with most (90%) of my CDs, keeping doubles, box sets Beatles and a few others with particularly beautiful packaging aside. No regrets so far! Thanks for sharing!
Not if you use a suitable inner, If I ever want to sell any I just buy a jewel case and transfer it. I'm yet to damage a CD using sleeves. Your mileage may vary.@@janath9118
I couldn’t do it!!! I’m very OCD about having hype stickers because they add more value to the item, not that I would EVER sell my collection! It’s just satisfying to see people searching for a pristine copy of whatever album, knowing that I have exactly the copy they’re talking about!
This was something I considered, then I figured that I'm never going to sell them so the resale value is entirely irrelevant to me. Took me a while to come to that decision though.
Many of my CDs now in plastic sleeves, some I will never get rid of the original cases but many of the jewel cases just take up too much space. As long as they are grouped, they are not difficult to find
This is a great idea, I have 100s of CDs and hardly any storage space, So I'll be doing this ASAP, I've always hated Jewel Cases anyway. I do like some of these premium CD packaging designs like Mediabooks etc on recent releases. So much nicer than a lump of brittle plastic that will break if you look at it wrong.
There is a slightly different version of the sleeves you have which require the spine to be folded inward as opposed to outward. They are made by 3L and available on Amazon. I’ve done it, saves a ton of space. I still keep my favourite albums in jewel cases. So I have a mix of sleeves and jewel stored in separate shelving. There is also a feeling of replicating a vinyl collection with those sleeves which is weirdly satisfying, and it often brings to life the artwork after years of living behind scratched, brittle, often broken jewel cases. In fact the only advantage of a jewel case is the visibility of the spine.
I would never ever get rid of my Jewel Cases. No way. I put them in resealable PVC sleeves to keep them in the best possible condition and to protect them from dust, fingerprints etc. If a Jewel Case has scratches etc., I replace it. For me, it`s part of the package.
I've thought of doing this in the past and every now and then I do look up solutions to reduce shelf sizes of my cds. There is a place called slim disc and they have paper sleeves that you can put your discs inside to stop them being damaged by the outer sleeves.
Noooo! I love jewel cases, and they are replaceable when and if they crack or break. But I do understand that you're trying to conserve space. I couldn't do it, but good luck to you, Andrew!
I threw mine out (over 2000 at the time, closer to 3000 now) years ago. Using poly sleeves supplied (at the time) by Cadence Building, I obtained about a 5:1 reduction in space requirements for my CD collection. Welcome to the 21st century!
An old CD bought many times ago brings you some special memories as well as its worn out scratched jewel case, so... No, as for me I'd rather stick with my ancient things for a while 😊.
I did the same thing a few years ago and bunged the cases in the garage… Am in the process of undoing it all now. It just didn’t work for me, felt like too much of a compromise.
I did something very similar about a year ago. Saved so much space! I used a more narrow sleeve so I can fit 2 rows side by side in a drawer. It’s a bit like flipping through record bins so it’s not hard to find things.
I own somewhere close to 800 cds. I'd say that roughly 75% are jewel cases, but there are also plenty of digipacks which might be my favourite format:) Couldn't get rid of either anyway:)
I can understand the idea of it from a space saving perspective, but doing away with the jewel cases takes away that physical protection for the CD and cheapens the whole thing in my opinion. I'd never get rid of my jewel cases. In particular some of the ones from early 80's releases with the opaque edges are collectors items. They are hard to come by and the ones I own are my most treasured.
@@AndrewDixonMusic Nah, Andrew, I really doubt you'll end up regretting it. You still have the music (and even the artwork) and eventually you'll realize it's the music is all that really matters. Do you really need to keep a ton of plastic??
I started a similar thing a few years ago for space saving reasons with CDs that I’m less attached to (I’m not really one for selling on my music). My original intent was for it to be a temporary solution in that if I ever moved to somewhere with more room I would revert back to cases. I did have that “will I regret it” but happy enough considering I’ve only done it with a certain percentage of the collection (I reckon 40%, 220 CDs) One exception is my sleeves only hold the CD/booklet so I have to store the back inlets in one of those accordion folders. So, glad you found sleeves which take all the paperwork. Someone above mentioned a “shoebox” solution: I use a “Really Useful Box” (look up the 6.5 litre version) which typically holds 36 CDs. I managed to fit 130 albums into one box with plenty of room to spare. It could probably take 170-180 if pushed. I find by having them in this box, it recreates that feeling of flicking from front to back
re: Promo stickers on jewel cases- I would either retain the jewel case and store with other non-standard jewel cases for posterity/collector value if you ever want to resell. Or use a heat gun and carefully remove sticker(s) and put on a postcard and place in repack sleeve with booklet/disc/etc
I did the same thing. Some years ago I ran out of space when my collection got to 4000 jewelcases. I had 6 massive shelves but there was no room anymore for more jewelcases. I had 3 options: 1) Stop collecting, sell part of the collection or replace the jewelcases. In the beginning it was hard but I got used to it pretty quickly. Last year I had to move to a smaller apartment and I was glad I done it. Now I have a 6000 cd collection in 3 shelves so I can double it with my 3 empty shelves.
I did this with about 1/4 of the several thousand CDs I own. My discs are in storage cabinet drawers so I just file the ones in sleeves (similar to yours) alphabetically among those still in jewel cases and flip through them like LPs. Seems to work fine and I don't regret it at all. In fact, I've grown to pretty much hate jewel cases. They break, take up too much space and really are rather ugly!
Just started doing this, and the space I've saved is brilliant! I'm also putting the discs in an anti-static sleeve, the same mini LP sleeves they use in Japan for added protection. I store the discs in great box from Hobbycraft and fits the sleeves perfectly, it's the Really Useful Clear Box 5 Litres, it also has a lid and can be stacked... I've just ordered more sleeves!
In the 90s I swapped some 2-CD fat boxes with slim 2-CD cases that are sized like the regular jewel cases. But I changed my mind about that years ago, I put those double albums back into CD fat boxes to have them just the way they were originally released. In fact I actually prefer fat boxes for double albums (for example for the 1993 Beatles Red & Blue Album, the 1987 White Album etc.) For me, CDs with jewel cases are like books on the shelf, I love to look at the complete collection, being able to spot and find everything at once and to see the collection grow. I don`t want to flip through them like index cards in a box or CDs in a CD pocket album.
Thank you Andrew, well done. As I mentioned in the livestream Wednesday, I have done the exact same thing with my CD’s, and I have no regrets at all. I did keep some, like albums with special slipcases, for example. But as you mentioned, jewel cases break, take up too much space, and several hundred of them are quite heavy! (I had to move not too long ago, as you recently did). I used to have big CD shelves also, now I just keep my CD’s in a drawer. Very convenient. I look forward to seeing how this works out for you Andrew. Interesting item: my local recycling pickup refused to accept the empty jewel boxes, because they are considered CD’s, and CD’s are considered electronic equipment! Go figure!?!?
Ha, that's crazy, I've never seen a CD case plugged in to the electrics! I'm hoping a local record store might be interested in taking some but if not I'll have to find a way to recycle them
@@AndrewDixonMusic if the recycling people are intransigent, try donating them to an art school. Those students could no doubt find something creative to do with them! 🎨
Great video, Andrew. I have done the same thing myself & have not regretted it. I wish that when CD's first came out, the powers that be used cardboard digipacks, like your Impulse jazz collection Also I have done the same thing to my DVD collection. I feel very liberated
Same, I started to replace my standard jewel cases 2 years ago. Got mine from stationary company Kokuyo from Japan. I only replace the standard ones, special jewel cases remain on the shelf like if it is housed on a slipcase cardboard or plastic, colored jewel cases etc. Managed to reduce more than half of the space and happy to bring in more box sets.
Sorry, got here late. Andrew, I am like you, I have over two thousand CDs, not counting box sets. Yes, space is important, but I feel like I am in musical heaven when I am looking at all my CDs as well as all my records. I don't think I could ever do that. Besides I think it would be harder to find a particular CD that way. I keep my CDs, ( as I'm sure you and everyone else does), in alphabetical order, and if I have more of one musician or group, then it's in chronological order. For me it would be very difficult to find certain CDs. I just couldn't do it. By the way, I caught a lot of the musicians and groups that you have on CD, as I watched the video. You have great taste in music. Except for Queen. 😊
I've seen comments from other CD collectors that claim they want to preserve the original jewel case as-is for collector value moving forward. One guy claiming scuffs and scratches on the OEM jewel case, even if an industry standard case with no special markings or colors, would degrade the value of a collectible CD. I say just replace a damaged standard case with another. Don't know how anyone would be able to tell the difference, again assuming no special non standard molded in markings or colors. IMO, standard unmarked stock jewel cases, either black/gray tray or clear tray, shouldn't improve the value of a typical single or double CD. The long term value is in the physical disc, front book and tray insert, and O-ring or other non-standard-jewel-case packaging. The jewel case *may* have longer term value if it has non standard markings (besides the standard Compact Disc logo), printed or molded in. For example, some CD's come with transparent but color tinted jewel cases (Mickey Hart CD's), or custom colored trays that hold the CD REM MOnster = orange), or the music label logo molded into the back tray of the case (I have some with Warner logo molded into jewel case back). I keep these either in tact, or if I repackage the CD to save space, put the jewel case away in a storage box in an attic/garage where it will be dry at least, though temps and humidity may be an issue.
I did keep a specific jewel case for Queen's "Made In Heaven" album as the side of the case has letter Q's embossed in to the plastic. I've transferred the discs and book in to a wallet but will keep the case in a box in case that becomes valuable in future (it isn't at the moment)
Personally (though I enjoyed the video) I think it’s a bad idea… I just personally feel like it looks messy and would actually prefer storing them all together in the garage or loft rather than in those plastic sleeves… I very nearly ditched all my CDs. About 500 went to charity shops but now I have a really beautiful new cd transport machine I’m so glad I didn’t get rid of the most important ones as they hold so many memories and love bringing a few CDs to play in my music area now (also stops me from buying on vinyl) and then when I’m not playing vinyl. It will be interesting to see a follow up and see if you go through with it.
Very nice video! Im also a cd collector and I’ve noticed while changing jewelcases that there Sometimes is a ring on the backinsert. Do you know if there's any way to prevent this?
Mr Dixon please do not get rid of your original CD cases I tell you this because I once tried using these things that you are showing in this video and they scratched my disks Once again please don’t do it
@@AndrewDixonMusic I’am not exactly sure because It’s about 10 years ago when I tried it However what I do remember is that many of my friends had the same issue as me
Luckily I have a huge apartment, 900 square feet. Lots of room for a lot more lps and cds....Right now I only own about 300 lps and about 2,000 cds. Like my books, I cannot phantom reducing their impact on my lovely walls....
I have nominated two rooms in my home for CDs. I have created aisles with the book cases in the rooms. I’d rather do this than pull apart the CD. Hope it works out for you
Hi Andrew, a little off topic but I will be coming to the UK in May and was curious if you could suggest where I could purchase a new stylists /head she’ll specifically the Nagaoka MP110, we will be visiting Soho and Liverpool… thanks
Hi Steve, sorry I don't know where you'd need to go for that. Enjoy Liverpool! The Casbah and the John/Paul childhood homes tours are the best things to do if you get chance....
I have a collection of more than 5000 Compact Discs but I do not like the idea of removing the jewel cases of the CD's. Although it's a practical way to save storage space, it is not a wise idea. The main purpose of the jewel cases is to keep the CD's inside them to protect them from dust, dirt or any other substance, and to protect them from any scratches or shocks. If the jewel cases are removed the storage space can be saved but it will compromise or lose the protection of the valuable CD's. If the CD's are kept this way inside the thin polythene cases, the CD's can easily get soiled or scratched by fingers when taking them out or replacing them back, and this cannot be avoided. The value of the album artworks will also lose if the jewel cases are removed. So its always vital to keep the CD's in their properly designed jewel cases due to these sentimental reasons. So I will not recommend this method of storing CD's to anybody else if they want to preserve their disc collection well. But there is only one option left, if somebody is running out of space to store CD's the proper way, they can adopt this method only to keep their less favoured or mediocre CD's.
It's very nice to see that you too are doing just the same thing with your CD collection as what I've already been doing for years! with my own CD collection! because in that way you really save a lot of space! although those plastic sleeves that you bought are a little bit too expensive in your place! since in my place which is in Mexico City you could get 100 pack of those plastc sleeves for a little as less than just $2 US dollars in the legal market! and that cost could even go down to just $1 US dollar! on the street markets that don't pay taxes!
No no no and no! I understand though. I live in a small one room apartment with the ongoing issue of fighting for room/space . I have CD 💿 wallets filled with CDs 💿; however, the CDs 💿 are from cardboard digisleeve cases, to protect the CDs from scratching. But I still have the cases. I did the similar thing but with DVD/Blu-ray movies/ TV shows. Disposed the cases. I deeply regret it. I love the appearance of having a collection of original material. Although it takes up room. Keep the jewel cases!
Regrets, I've had a few, But then again, too few to mention. I did what I had to do, And saw it through without exemption, etc... Update coming soon! 😉
i might be a few years late but i just noticed they started selling new cd's in cardboard folders. i recently got one in the mail and complained to the seller i didnt get a jewel case with my cd. he informed me thats how they make them now. since it was and older album i ended up ordering another of the same used cd from a different seller that came with an actual jewel case. its sad to see they got cheap these days by selling cd's in cardboard folders. i'll never part with my jewel cases.
I think it's a great solution. Sometimes with Jewel Cases it's difficult to remove/insert a booklet causing fraying/creasing etc. If you drop one on a hard surface there go the lugs! Someone suggested the Mini Japanese "LP's" which are great but expensive, also not sure if their catalogue is that broad. I'll be following suit for space reasons and no more broken scratched Jewell Cases.
I've done this about 20 years ago when I had to shift house. I'm saving a lot of space but hygiene is important, i.e, clean discs and inserts. I've decided to put the flap at the bottom so dust doesn't settle where there's an opening. I do regret getting rid of some special jewel cases though, for example, Madonna's Bedtime Stories, as it was part of the album design. Something to keep in mind :)
Did the same a little while ago and have never looked back. Really happy to throw out all the old scuffed and broken Jewel Cases that take too much room. Worth the investment
Thanks for the idea Andrew but I love originality and seeing that most of the newer CD releases don't have Jewel cases I think might keep my collection which is probably only a few hundred the way it is at least for the time being. However I'm interested to see how you go with yours.
I have hundreds of CDs But I like to keep them in their original jewel case in Alphabetical order on my shelves that way I can find what ever CD I want quicker. Then I put extras in a big CD holder that holds 400 or 500 CDs at a time
I’m also in the process of doing this. I’ve only done 100 so far but I am holding onto many of the jewel cases for now (throwing out the broken ones - which are many) - storing them in storage boxes in the attic in case I change my mind. If all goes good for at least a year, I’m recycling the jewel cases (maybe even sell them)
I have limited space also. Have about 2,000 cd's, so I've placed them in cd folders. Some hold 200 or up to 300. I've kept all the jewel cases, they're in plastic crates in my shed. Just couldn't get rid of the jewel cases because I've left the artwork with them. I do have some of my cd's out in my living room in the jewel cases. I collect records also, they take up most of my space. Have over a thousand records.
I was a just as apprehensive when I decided to go down this route, but it was the best thing I have ever done, I only have 150 CD's (so far) and I used the offerings from 3L, I purchased the sleeves, a pack of inner sleeves (really soft), and a couple of storage boxes which seemed a little cheaper than Amazon when I purchased them. They have great customer service. which is easily contactable, Danish in origin and supplied in the UK from Oxfordshire. They may turn out at times to be a little dearer than Amazon, but the ability to talk to a human being at times is worth it. No I'm not connected with the company, I offer it as an alternative to the Amazon Juggernaut. Anyhow that aside the space saved is worth it, I've indexed the boxes and finding what I want is so easy, I love the way they look like Mini LP's. Like yourself I have cardboard sleeves, and even they fit in the pouches just great, the Inner's I have will take 2 CD's and it still fits in the outer sleeve. I have a few triple albums, and box sets I've left them as is. As usual there are always the Albums that are produced that will benefit from leaving as is. The point is the only thing we are discarding is the jewel case, and allowing more space to dedicated to the collection.
That’s a terrible idea Andrew. Apart from devaluing the CDs and making them harder to find by not revealing the spines anymore, you have to ask yourself is the space worth more than your collection itself? I think not, the answer is: find more space or sell the CDs you don’t listen to anymore!
I thought for a while about this in advamce, and on the basis that I don't intend to ever sell the CDs, I'm not really bothered what the resale value would be. And with no end in sight to the Beatles related box sets I'll want to buy, I'd rather have extra space available for those.
@@AndrewDixonMusic what is the point of owning the CDs when they are being treated so disdainfully. There is something to appreciate and covet simply by handling the jewel case, not to mention ease of extraction of the disc and less damage from sliding it over paper.
Hi Andrew, I have considered something similar myself but have always steered away from it by and large. Whilst I hold no sentimental attachment to the cases themselves necessarily, I do feel I would miss being able to see my whole collection at a glance and making listening choices from that. I do however have a large cd wallet holder where I place older issues of albums that I have since duplicated, keeping the covers and booklets too - this created quite a bit of space and didn’t bother me at all. Something to consider perhaps if you end up unsure
I did this several years ago but I put mine in albums that had 4 sleeves per page but I did not keep the backs since it is just a repeat of the back of the insert and they are the older version that are not wider to accommodate the spine.. The one disadvantage is that it is harder to find a CD you are looking for but I have not regret doing it... Also I never figured out what to do with all the empty jewel cases so they are still in storage in big boxes
I could do this for soundtracks or various compilations or "best of" / "greatest hits" of people I'm just a casual fan of but I'm happy to keep the jewel cases for my very favorite artists or very favorite albums. Can't explain the logic (or lack there of) for feeling this way. It's just what would do it.
Hi Andrew! I just have a quick question. My local record store is selling reasonably priced copies of those deluxe 3-disc versions of Oasis' first three albums, that I see on your shelf! Which one is your favorite, that gives you the most value, based on sound quality and bonus tracks? Thanks! :)
I'd say Definitely Maybe is very good for the early demos and first attempts at recording the album, you get to see how much better the final version was! Best bit about Be Here Now is Noel's remix of D'You Know What I Mean? Where you get onhear all sorts of strings that were always there but buried in the mix. Honestly don't remember much about the contents of the Morning Glory box!
Ripped the audio as WAV, put the discs in CD books with cloth backed pages, and chucked the jewel cases years back. Can count on one hand the number of times I’ve gone back to those folders.
I ripped all mine as flacs backed up on two drives and then highlights from the collection on two custom iPods. I keep a small amount of physical copies, just ones that are rare printings or limited editions just in case I need to do new backups but I got rid of most of the originals.
@@ChromeDestiny Yeah, I understand a lot of folks are attached to the physical object, but it also feels really good to be able to just get rid of it all or at least reduce it down to a bare minimum.
Oh, Andrew... this could go so wrong..... I admire you for trying this.... maybe do another video in 3 months to update us on this..... I really hope this works out!!!!
Hi Andrew , like others I have been doing this for years I have over 1,500 CDs what I do I put them in a CD box the width of a CD and about 15" long and they are onin a shelving unit about 15" deep it's great you can just take out the box and flip through your CDs - label the box up with the artists - you don't see the CDs on display though just the boxes but CDs inside are in plastic sleeves - I have to keep the back cover out as it doesn't fit into my sleeves - you could have them in a drawer flip through style but it is the weight - my only concern is with getting rid of plastic casings is if in the future my kids decided to sell them all they haven't got the cases
I have just done this with my DVDs over the last month and the space I've saved (again) is incredible. Once you take the disc(s) and sleeve out of the plastic case and you're left with the empty box it really makes you realise how little emotional attachment you can have to an empty plastic box, and it makes it much easier to deal with losing them.
@@AndrewDixonMusic That’s very true. Of course, there will be some DVDs where I won’t take them out of their plastic case, such as my Carry On films and my Chucky films, which are some of my absolute favourites.
Love it! I did a similar thing and hadn't missed the jewel case at all and that's been about four years ago. You can always hold on to the case for a bit until you are sure you like your new set up. I am going to order this same set of sleeves for my Bob Dylan CDs. I missed out on his big box set so I am going to get a box and put all his in my homemade Bob box. Thanks for sharing I like how they look. Take care!
Been thinking about your CD situation. I think I would not put them on a shelf but make a holder similar to a shoebox and store them back to front, maybe with letter tab dividers. You could keep them table top or in a cabinet or drawer.. Take care!
Andrew, you are way more courageous than me. I wouldn’t get rid of any of the jewel cases I own. I just think they are part of the original package. I wouldn’t do it, but if you have to, more power to ya! I’d rather buy another case to shelve ‘em.
aggghhh there's no way I could do that. I am with James in that there is something satisfying about owning the disc with original jewel casing. But then I still love dvds. Just remember Andrew if you change your mind you will eventually not be able to buy the proper cd cases? Except scratched to death ones from second hand shops etc... I remember when everyone was thrilled with cds because over them being smaller than LP.s. Look what happened over time. I have cds stored in my music room, my lounge room and even my kitchen. They are priceless to me. Good luck Andrew!
I've been thinking about it although I found slim double cases of amazing quality. Problem is there's no place for the booklet. The reason i wanted to do it that way was I got hooked up on how my few self printed cdr bootlegs looked like. Uniform yet colourful. Like an art installation
Sleeves will need to be replaced eventually. Most of the latest CDs I have bought no longer have Jewel cases, been phasing them out for some time. Good luck with it Andrew, but keep the cases stored someplace if you change your mind. Maybe even get some storage boxes for discs you don't want on display or don't play that often? That could be a storage solution.
I think a better solution is cd or media cabinets for example from Bisley, one low cabinet with 5 drawers can accomodate 270 cds, with nice telescopic drawers, 50 cm deep. Also the metal media cabinets from Bisley maximalizes usable space. Do not splash the cd’s on all the walls of your house!
My initial reaction to this as a fellow collector was to grimace - but honestly space is such a huge factor and hinderance when it comes to collecting. I could see myself doing this with bog standard releases at some point, no hype sticker on the case etc. It’s crazy how much space you have saved
How well are you able to see the titles? Are you finding you have to dig through them to find the titles? From watching the video, I could only see one title from afar. I have the same storage challenges you have, but not being able to see the spines would not make it worth it for me.
I've been considering do something similar, I've wanted transfer the jewel case CDs into those smaller replica LP sleeves, I've no idea how you would go about doing this but it would save alot of space
I did that for all my dvd’s, including music dvd’s. The dvd case just takes so much space... For cd’s though, I do that for cd’s I don’t care for too much anymore. It’s better option than selling them or throwing them away. For the ones that do get listened, I would not replace the jewel case.
I have a couple of hundred cd's stacked in this way. The only problem I encountered with plastic CD sleeves is that some stick to the CD and might partly tear off the printed label. But as long as you make sure you put the cd itself between the booklet/front cover and the back-cover, you'll be just fine. (For safety reasons you can put the cd in a paper sleeve and put that into your plastic sleeve, but that's some extra money and time...;) ) It's a bit more harder to find a cd, but you can grab a bunch of them and swipe through that quite easily. But it's a great way of saving space (and for dvd's/blu rays even more).
Hi Andrew I have over 10.000 cd plus 1,000 vinyl plus 100s box sets I have been doing this for years my I add it cuts down on cleaning! I find if you stack them flat with dividing plastic I got from my record store works better Paul in Dublin
great for saving space Andrew, but not for me, I have around 960 cd's plus box sets, and while they are in their jewel cases I can easily see who the artist and album is, altho all my collection is ripped to a 2TB Brennan B2 in FLAC, so I do not get them out too often. Of course many of the releases today do not come in Jewel cases, last years new releasees of Jackson Browne's Downhill of Everywhere, David Crosby's For Free and Steely Dan's Northwest Corridor came in card folders as many seem to now. Great for saving space I agree but I could not do it, good for you tho!
This has me interested, but I wished you would have shown how the slipcases are in selecting certain CDs from the shelf. It would be nice if there were some kind of indexing system (A, B, C, D....etc) on the shelf so you can pick out certain CDs without having to go through a bunch of them.
I have 6,000 CDs and 2,000 LPs/45s, so did this to some of my collection and I agree, not as clean, harder to spot on the spine - I bought dividers - I kept any special CD Holders, but still on the fence if I want to do it to my whole collection.
I've just done this with around 250 cds (Classic, Blues & Jazz Collections from magazine subscriptions). The amount of space saved is incredible. Problem now, what to do with the Jewel Cases! I've yet to find anyone who could use them or anywhere that'll recycle them. 😮 I've also done the same with my DVD collection and can't believe the space thats freed up.
I like the idea of saving space a whole lot. But I think I’d lose CDs in the row and some music might get played less. Anyone who has done this … did you find it hard to find music?
Link to buy these CD Wallets: amzn.to/3rTwoZt
And these are the boxes I've used: amzn.to/3sNgqPO
If you thinking of doing this please make sure that wallets you use are NOT made from PVC as this can lead to disc damage eventually. POLYPROPYLENE is safe.
thanks, but no thanks.
I couldn’t bring myself to it. There’s something satisfying about owning the disc with the original jewel casing. I admire your emotional strength during this very trying time😂
I agree James. I have thought about going Andrew’s route too but I can’t . I will say with Spotify I do not buy discs anymore. Just the box sets I want
I have nothing against buying new jewel cases if the previous ones are damaged. I know people like the old smooth sided cases from the 1980s though. I don't really care as long as the discs are safe.
And I " upgraded" all those Beatles remasters from a decade back as well as the Beatles Capital albums sets by putting them safely into shiny new CD jewel cases.
also I just hate more than one CD in a case so if I get a double set I will put them into separate cases.
James Dean Yes, you are correct. I completely agree with you. I couldn't bring myself to it too! It is always satisfying when keeping the discs with the original jewel cases and it also adds value to them.
@@phillipanderson7398 Yes, I agree with you.
Did you put the Beatles remaster discs in new cases because the original jewel cases are damaged? I hope so, otherwise there's no point.
Regarding placing two or more discs in the cases, there are double or multi disc jewel cases available in the market which will suit your needs.
@@janath9118 The Beatles remaster discs did not come in jewel cases. They were in glossy cardboard digi-paks, I put the remastered discs ( and any albums that come in mini LP cardboard covers like the Beatles Capital Albums sets) into new jewel cases I bought at the local Officeworks store.
As for the mutli disc jewel cases I was saying that I don't like them. I always prefer single disc jewel cases. The only exception is " fat boy" multi jewel cases where I am ok with these cases that hold two discs and in some cases three or four discs.
@Andrew Dixon I, too, have recently gone this route for both my CDs and DVDs. I have no regrets. It actually makes me appreciate my collection a bit more. The CDs are now more akin to mini LPs in my mind. And I have re-examined a number of discs I have not considered for some time. Thinking about it? I say go for it!
I have about 1500 CDs and I used an intermediate solution: I placed in the thin sleeves only front cover and CD. I left back cover in the jewel case, and stored all jewel cases in boxes in the attic. That way, each CD still has his original jewel case, in case I want to recompose it, or sell it. Jewel cases have changed over the years, some have stickers particular to the CDs, so I like to be able to match CDs and jewel cases, just in case. Anyway, storage saving is about a factor of 4!
If you are keeping the back covers of CD's stored seperately with the jewel cases, how are you supposed to read or refer the song lists and other important details when playing those CD's? That's absurd. There's no meaning to whatever you did. If the point here is to save the space, you can leave out the jewel cases but it's necessary to keep at least both front and back covers together.
I did this several years ago and I regretted it not long afterwards. I’ve bought many jewel cases and replacement CDs over the last couple of years to undo my mistake. I think that many people would like your method for storage purposes and if they aren’t attached to the original style packaging.
The jewel case is a part of history. It was what we got our cds in. If you want to be true to your collection, keep them in jewel cases. You wouldn't treat your vinyl any different. Keep your media true to the way they were originally released. Thats my opinion.
I totally agree
I went this same route at the beginning of last year. The amount of space it saved was amazing, but, in the end, I thought it looked too messy and not all of the spines were easily readable. Plus, I still had my digi-paks in the alphabetical mix every so often. After about four months, I went back to jewel cases. I just really like the look and (somewhat) uniformity of those plastic cases.
Yes, the jewel cases are necessary to protect the CD's.
Same here. Been there before. The cases are part of the whole thing. Never thought about doing that again.
I did the exact same thing with my DVDs and Blu-Rays but have not considered it with my CDs just yet. It's amazing how much space you save doing this. All my movies took up more than an entire rack but now they're down to just a few plastic bins on the shelf. One thing I did was to make some alphabetical index cards so I just look for the tab sticking out to find what I'm looking for quicker. I may just have to consider this for my CDs now as well.
I'm definitely going to have some alphabetical index cards. I'm wondering if there's some way I could use some of my empty jewel cases to make them from!? If they weren't so brittle it would be an easier task...
Did this a few years ago with most (90%) of my CDs, keeping doubles, box sets Beatles and a few others with particularly beautiful packaging aside. No regrets so far! Thanks for sharing!
I've transferred a few doubles to the new cases, seems to still work ok!
But doing that will compromise the protection of the CD's.
Not if you use a suitable inner, If I ever want to sell any I just buy a jewel case and transfer it. I'm yet to damage a CD using sleeves. Your mileage may vary.@@janath9118
I couldn’t do it!!! I’m very OCD about having hype stickers because they add more value to the item, not that I would EVER sell my collection! It’s just satisfying to see people searching for a pristine copy of whatever album, knowing that I have exactly the copy they’re talking about!
This was something I considered, then I figured that I'm never going to sell them so the resale value is entirely irrelevant to me. Took me a while to come to that decision though.
All Kinds Of Collecting Yes, I agree with you. They add more value to the item.
Well, it’s easy to scratch if you don’t put in original jewelry case, also, the booklet could easily damaged
Many of my CDs now in plastic sleeves, some I will never get rid of the original cases but many of the jewel cases just take up too much space. As long as they are grouped, they are not difficult to find
This is a great idea, I have 100s of CDs and hardly any storage space, So I'll be doing this ASAP, I've always hated Jewel Cases anyway. I do like some of these premium CD packaging designs like Mediabooks etc on recent releases. So much nicer than a lump of brittle plastic that will break if you look at it wrong.
There is a slightly different version of the sleeves you have which require the spine to be folded inward as opposed to outward. They are made by 3L and available on Amazon. I’ve done it, saves a ton of space. I still keep my favourite albums in jewel cases. So I have a mix of sleeves and jewel stored in separate shelving. There is also a feeling of replicating a vinyl collection with those sleeves which is weirdly satisfying, and it often brings to life the artwork after years of living behind scratched, brittle, often broken jewel cases. In fact the only advantage of a jewel case is the visibility of the spine.
I would never ever get rid of my Jewel Cases. No way. I put them in resealable PVC sleeves to keep them in the best possible condition and to protect them from dust, fingerprints etc. If a Jewel Case has scratches etc., I replace it. For me, it`s part of the package.
I've thought of doing this in the past and every now and then I do look up solutions to reduce shelf sizes of my cds. There is a place called slim disc and they have paper sleeves that you can put your discs inside to stop them being damaged by the outer sleeves.
Noooo! I love jewel cases, and they are replaceable when and if they crack or break. But I do understand that you're trying to conserve space. I couldn't do it, but good luck to you, Andrew!
I've been an emotional wreck this week Joe, but I'm still not regretting it!
I threw mine out (over 2000 at the time, closer to 3000 now) years ago. Using poly sleeves supplied (at the time) by Cadence Building, I obtained about a 5:1 reduction in space requirements for my CD collection. Welcome to the 21st century!
An old CD bought many times ago brings you some special memories as well as its worn out scratched jewel case, so... No, as for me I'd rather stick with my ancient things for a while 😊.
I did the same thing a few years ago and bunged the cases in the garage… Am in the process of undoing it all now. It just didn’t work for me, felt like too much of a compromise.
I did something very similar about a year ago. Saved so much space! I used a more narrow sleeve so I can fit 2 rows side by side in a drawer. It’s a bit like flipping through record bins so it’s not hard to find things.
I own somewhere close to 800 cds. I'd say that roughly 75% are jewel cases, but there are also plenty of digipacks which might be my favourite format:) Couldn't get rid of either anyway:)
I can understand the idea of it from a space saving perspective, but doing away with the jewel cases takes away that physical protection for the CD and cheapens the whole thing in my opinion. I'd never get rid of my jewel cases. In particular some of the ones from early 80's releases with the opaque edges are collectors items. They are hard to come by and the ones I own are my most treasured.
I've well over 6000 CDs i've amassed over the last 30+ years & i'll change absolutely nothing about any of them & if you do Andrew you WILL regret it!
Time will tell! 🙂👍
How long do you think it will take to listen to 6,000 CDs ?
30 years sounds about right.
@@AndrewDixonMusic Nah, Andrew, I really doubt you'll end up regretting it. You still have the music (and even the artwork) and eventually you'll realize it's the music is all that really matters. Do you really need to keep a ton of plastic??
I started a similar thing a few years ago for space saving reasons with CDs that I’m less attached to (I’m not really one for selling on my music). My original intent was for it to be a temporary solution in that if I ever moved to somewhere with more room I would revert back to cases. I did have that “will I regret it” but happy enough considering I’ve only done it with a certain percentage of the collection (I reckon 40%, 220 CDs)
One exception is my sleeves only hold the CD/booklet so I have to store the back inlets in one of those accordion folders. So, glad you found sleeves which take all the paperwork. Someone above mentioned a “shoebox” solution: I use a “Really Useful Box” (look up the 6.5 litre version) which typically holds 36 CDs. I managed to fit 130 albums into one box with plenty of room to spare. It could probably take 170-180 if pushed. I find by having them in this box, it recreates that feeling of flicking from front to back
Thanks, I'm definitely interested in some kind of box to store them in.
re: Promo stickers on jewel cases- I would either retain the jewel case and store with other non-standard jewel cases for posterity/collector value if you ever want to resell.
Or use a heat gun and carefully remove sticker(s) and put on a postcard and place in repack sleeve with booklet/disc/etc
I like the wallets, but I could never toss the jewel cases. Cheers for keeping CDs alive 👍🙌
I did the same thing. Some years ago I ran out of space when my collection got to 4000 jewelcases. I had 6 massive shelves but there was no room anymore for more jewelcases. I had 3 options: 1) Stop collecting, sell part of the collection or replace the jewelcases. In the beginning it was hard but I got used to it pretty quickly. Last year I had to move to a smaller apartment and I was glad I done it. Now I have a 6000 cd collection in 3 shelves so I can double it with my 3 empty shelves.
Excellent, that gives me hope that I won't regret this!
I did this with about 1/4 of the several thousand CDs I own. My discs are in storage cabinet drawers so I just file the ones in sleeves (similar to yours) alphabetically among those still in jewel cases and flip through them like LPs. Seems to work fine and I don't regret it at all. In fact, I've grown to pretty much hate jewel cases. They break, take up too much space and really are rather ugly!
Jewel cases are better than anything else you could use because the rest either scratch the disc or don't have spines.
Just started doing this, and the space I've saved is brilliant! I'm also putting the discs in an anti-static sleeve, the same mini LP sleeves they use in Japan for added protection. I store the discs in great box from Hobbycraft and fits the sleeves perfectly, it's the Really Useful Clear Box 5 Litres, it also has a lid and can be stacked... I've just ordered more sleeves!
Excellent! 🙂👍
In the 90s I swapped some 2-CD fat boxes with slim 2-CD cases that are sized like the regular jewel cases. But I changed my mind about that years ago, I put those double albums back into CD fat boxes to have them just the way they were originally released. In fact I actually prefer fat boxes for double albums (for example for the 1993 Beatles Red & Blue Album, the 1987 White Album etc.) For me, CDs with jewel cases are like books on the shelf, I love to look at the complete collection, being able to spot and find everything at once and to see the collection grow. I don`t want to flip through them like index cards in a box or CDs in a CD pocket album.
Thank you Andrew, well done. As I mentioned in the livestream Wednesday, I have done the exact same thing with my CD’s, and I have no regrets at all. I did keep some, like albums with special slipcases, for example. But as you mentioned, jewel cases break, take up too much space, and several hundred of them are quite heavy! (I had to move not too long ago, as you recently did).
I used to have big CD shelves also, now I just keep my CD’s in a drawer. Very convenient. I look forward to seeing how this works out for you Andrew.
Interesting item: my local recycling pickup refused to accept the empty jewel boxes, because they are considered CD’s, and CD’s are considered electronic equipment! Go figure!?!?
Ha, that's crazy, I've never seen a CD case plugged in to the electrics!
I'm hoping a local record store might be interested in taking some but if not I'll have to find a way to recycle them
@@AndrewDixonMusic if the recycling people are intransigent, try donating them to an art school. Those students could no doubt find something creative to do with them! 🎨
Great video, Andrew. I have done the same thing myself & have not regretted it. I wish that when CD's first came out, the powers that be used cardboard digipacks, like your Impulse jazz collection
Also I have done the same thing to my DVD collection. I feel very liberated
Same, I started to replace my standard jewel cases 2 years ago. Got mine from stationary company Kokuyo from Japan. I only replace the standard ones, special jewel cases remain on the shelf like if it is housed on a slipcase cardboard or plastic, colored jewel cases etc. Managed to reduce more than half of the space and happy to bring in more box sets.
I prefer to keep the jewel cases.
That's exactly what I did when moving house 2 years ago as I had way too many CDs and it was taking way too much space. I don't regret it at all! :)
Sorry, got here late. Andrew, I am like you, I have over two thousand CDs, not counting box sets. Yes, space is important, but I feel like I am in musical heaven when I am looking at all my CDs as well as all my records. I don't think I could ever do that. Besides I think it would be harder to find a particular CD that way. I keep my CDs, ( as I'm sure you and everyone else does), in alphabetical order, and if I have more of one musician or group, then it's in chronological order. For me it would be very difficult to find certain CDs. I just couldn't do it.
By the way, I caught a lot of the musicians and groups that you have on CD, as I watched the video. You have great taste in music. Except for Queen. 😊
Hi George, I'm definitely just limiting this to bog standard jewel cases, anything remotely more visually appealing is safe! 👍
I've seen comments from other CD collectors that claim they want to preserve the original jewel case as-is for collector value moving forward. One guy claiming scuffs and scratches on the OEM jewel case, even if an industry standard case with no special markings or colors, would degrade the value of a collectible CD.
I say just replace a damaged standard case with another. Don't know how anyone would be able to tell the difference, again assuming no special non standard molded in markings or colors.
IMO, standard unmarked stock jewel cases, either black/gray tray or clear tray, shouldn't improve the value of a typical single or double CD. The long term value is in the physical disc, front book and tray insert, and O-ring or other non-standard-jewel-case packaging.
The jewel case *may* have longer term value if it has non standard markings (besides the standard Compact Disc logo), printed or molded in.
For example, some CD's come with transparent but color tinted jewel cases (Mickey Hart CD's), or custom colored trays that hold the CD REM MOnster = orange), or the music label logo molded into the back tray of the case (I have some with Warner logo molded into jewel case back). I keep these either in tact, or if I repackage the CD to save space, put the jewel case away in a storage box in an attic/garage where it will be dry at least, though temps and humidity may be an issue.
I did keep a specific jewel case for Queen's "Made In Heaven" album as the side of the case has letter Q's embossed in to the plastic. I've transferred the discs and book in to a wallet but will keep the case in a box in case that becomes valuable in future (it isn't at the moment)
I love collecting CDs only because of Jewel Cases ✨️
How easy are they to remove from the sleeves each time you play them?
Very easy, it's no different to removing anything from any kind of envelope.
Personally (though I enjoyed the video) I think it’s a bad idea… I just personally feel like it looks messy and would actually prefer storing them all together in the garage or loft rather than in those plastic sleeves… I very nearly ditched all my CDs. About 500 went to charity shops but now I have a really beautiful new cd transport machine I’m so glad I didn’t get rid of the most important ones as they hold so many memories and love bringing a few CDs to play in my music area now (also stops me from buying on vinyl) and then when I’m not playing vinyl. It will be interesting to see a follow up and see if you go through with it.
Very nice video! Im also a cd collector and I’ve noticed while changing jewelcases that there Sometimes is a ring on the backinsert. Do you know if there's any way to prevent this?
Thanks. Don't know a way around that, sorry
@@AndrewDixonMusic alright, Thanks for the help anyway. Luckily it isn’t as bad as ringwear on vinyl records
Mr Dixon please do not get rid of your original CD cases
I tell you this because I once tried using these things that you are showing in this video and they scratched my disks
Once again please don’t do it
What was it that scratched them, being next to the paper/card from the CD sleeve?
@@AndrewDixonMusic I’am not exactly sure because It’s about 10 years ago when I tried it
However what I do remember is that many of my friends had the same issue as me
Luckily I have a huge apartment, 900 square feet. Lots of room for a lot more lps and cds....Right now I only own about 300 lps and about 2,000 cds. Like my books, I cannot phantom reducing their impact on my lovely walls....
I did the same. No regrets I saved loads of room. But your wallets look much nicer the cheap sleeves I got so I think I’ll upgrade . Good vid.
I have nominated two rooms in my home for CDs. I have created aisles with the book cases in the rooms. I’d rather do this than pull apart the CD. Hope it works out for you
Hi Andrew, a little off topic but I will be coming to the UK in May and was curious if you could suggest where I could purchase a new stylists /head she’ll specifically the Nagaoka MP110, we will be visiting Soho and Liverpool… thanks
Hi Steve, sorry I don't know where you'd need to go for that. Enjoy Liverpool! The Casbah and the John/Paul childhood homes tours are the best things to do if you get chance....
Ok thank you for responding
I have a collection of more than 5000 Compact Discs but I do not like the idea of removing the jewel cases of the CD's. Although it's a practical way to save storage space, it is not a wise idea. The main purpose of the jewel cases is to keep the CD's inside them to protect them from dust, dirt or any other substance, and to protect them from any scratches or shocks. If the jewel cases are removed the storage space can be saved but it will compromise or lose the protection of the valuable CD's. If the CD's are kept this way inside the thin polythene cases, the CD's can easily get soiled or scratched by fingers when taking them out or replacing them back, and this cannot be avoided. The value of the album artworks will also lose if the jewel cases are removed. So its always vital to keep the CD's in their properly designed jewel cases due to these sentimental reasons.
So I will not recommend this method of storing CD's to anybody else if they want to preserve their disc collection well. But there is only one option left, if somebody is running out of space to store CD's the proper way, they can adopt this method only to keep their less favoured or mediocre CD's.
It's very nice to see that you too are doing just the same thing with your CD collection as what I've already been doing for years! with my own CD collection! because in that way you really save a lot of space! although those plastic sleeves that you bought are a little bit too expensive in your place! since in my place which is in Mexico City you could get 100 pack of those plastc sleeves for a little as less than just $2 US dollars in the legal market! and that cost could even go down to just $1 US dollar! on the street markets that don't pay taxes!
No no no and no! I understand though. I live in a small one room apartment with the ongoing issue of fighting for room/space . I have CD 💿 wallets filled with CDs 💿; however, the CDs 💿 are from cardboard digisleeve cases, to protect the CDs from scratching. But I still have the cases. I did the similar thing but with DVD/Blu-ray movies/ TV shows. Disposed the cases. I deeply regret it. I love the appearance of having a collection of original material. Although it takes up room. Keep the jewel cases!
I'm thinking about doing this as I need to free up space. I'm waiting to see if Andrew expresses any regrets.
Regrets, I've had a few,
But then again, too few to mention.
I did what I had to do,
And saw it through without exemption, etc...
Update coming soon! 😉
i might be a few years late but i just noticed they started selling new cd's in cardboard folders. i recently got one in the mail and complained to the seller i didnt get a jewel case with my cd. he informed me thats how they make them now. since it was and older album i ended up ordering another of the same used cd from a different seller that came with an actual jewel case. its sad to see they got cheap these days by selling cd's in cardboard folders. i'll never part with my jewel cases.
I think it's a great solution. Sometimes with Jewel Cases it's difficult to remove/insert a booklet causing fraying/creasing etc. If you drop one on a hard surface there go the lugs! Someone suggested the Mini Japanese "LP's" which are great but expensive, also not sure if their catalogue is that broad. I'll be following suit for space reasons and no more broken scratched Jewell Cases.
I've done this about 20 years ago when I had to shift house. I'm saving a lot of space but hygiene is important, i.e, clean discs and inserts. I've decided to put the flap at the bottom so dust doesn't settle where there's an opening. I do regret getting rid of some special jewel cases though, for example, Madonna's Bedtime Stories, as it was part of the album design. Something to keep in mind :)
Did the same a little while ago and have never looked back. Really happy to throw out all the old scuffed and broken Jewel Cases that take too much room. Worth the investment
Ive got over 4000 cds, i could never take them out of their jewel cases
That Would Take Bloody Forever...
Thanks for the idea Andrew but I love originality and seeing that most of the newer CD releases don't have Jewel cases I think might keep my collection which is probably only a few hundred the way it is at least for the time being.
However I'm interested to see how you go with yours.
I have hundreds of CDs But I like to keep them in their original jewel case in Alphabetical order on my shelves that way I can find what ever CD I want quicker. Then I put extras in a big CD holder that holds 400 or 500 CDs at a time
I’m also in the process of doing this. I’ve only done 100 so far but I am holding onto many of the jewel cases for now (throwing out the broken ones - which are many) - storing them in storage boxes in the attic in case I change my mind. If all goes good for at least a year, I’m recycling the jewel cases (maybe even sell them)
I have limited space also. Have about 2,000 cd's, so I've placed them in cd folders. Some hold 200 or up to 300. I've kept all the jewel cases, they're in plastic crates in my shed. Just couldn't get rid of the jewel cases because I've left the artwork with them. I do have some of my cd's out in my living room in the jewel cases. I collect records also, they take up most of my space. Have over a thousand records.
I was a just as apprehensive when I decided to go down this route, but it was the best thing I have ever done, I only have 150 CD's (so far) and I used the offerings from 3L, I purchased the sleeves, a pack of inner sleeves (really soft), and a couple of storage boxes which seemed a little cheaper than Amazon when I purchased them. They have great customer service. which is easily contactable, Danish in origin and supplied in the UK from Oxfordshire. They may turn out at times to be a little dearer than Amazon, but the ability to talk to a human being at times is worth it. No I'm not connected with the company, I offer it as an alternative to the Amazon Juggernaut.
Anyhow that aside the space saved is worth it, I've indexed the boxes and finding what I want is so easy, I love the way they look like Mini LP's. Like yourself I have cardboard sleeves, and even they fit in the pouches just great, the Inner's I have will take 2 CD's and it still fits in the outer sleeve. I have a few triple albums, and box sets I've left them as is. As usual there are always the Albums that are produced that will benefit from leaving as is. The point is the only thing we are discarding is the jewel case, and allowing more space to dedicated to the collection.
That’s a terrible idea Andrew. Apart from devaluing the CDs and making them harder to find by not revealing the spines anymore, you have to ask yourself is the space worth more than your collection itself? I think not, the answer is: find more space or sell the CDs you don’t listen to anymore!
I thought for a while about this in advamce, and on the basis that I don't intend to ever sell the CDs, I'm not really bothered what the resale value would be.
And with no end in sight to the Beatles related box sets I'll want to buy, I'd rather have extra space available for those.
@@AndrewDixonMusic what is the point of owning the CDs when they are being treated so disdainfully. There is something to appreciate and covet simply by handling the jewel case, not to mention ease of extraction of the disc and less damage from sliding it over paper.
Hi Andrew, I have considered something similar myself but have always steered away from it by and large. Whilst I hold no sentimental attachment to the cases themselves necessarily, I do feel I would miss being able to see my whole collection at a glance and making listening choices from that. I do however have a large cd wallet holder where I place older issues of albums that I have since duplicated, keeping the covers and booklets too - this created quite a bit of space and didn’t bother me at all. Something to consider perhaps if you end up unsure
Sounds like a good idea 👍
Excellent idea Andrew but I can’t personally do this,now let’s see how you get on doing this to your Beatles collection can’t wait for the video 😂
The Beatles are not going to be part of this process, they've been given special exemption! 👍
I did this several years ago but I put mine in albums that had 4 sleeves per page but I did not keep the backs since it is just a repeat of the back of the insert and they are the older version that are not wider to accommodate the spine.. The one disadvantage is that it is harder to find a CD you are looking for but I have not regret doing it... Also I never figured out what to do with all the empty jewel cases so they are still in storage in big boxes
I did this a few years ago when I moved in with my fiancé. DVDs too. It saves a lot of space.
PS I wouldn’t do this with double CDs only single ? I sold a lot of cases back to a second hand record store or trade them ?
I've done a few doubles, seems to work fine. I'll first of all be offering the jewel cases to a local record store.
I could do this for soundtracks or various compilations or "best of" / "greatest hits" of people I'm just a casual fan of but I'm happy to keep the jewel cases for my very favorite artists or very favorite albums. Can't explain the logic (or lack there of) for feeling this way. It's just what would do it.
Space is definitely an issue, but I like being able to find things at a quick glance. Will watch for your updates !
Hi Andrew! I just have a quick question. My local record store is selling reasonably priced copies of those deluxe 3-disc versions of Oasis' first three albums, that I see on your shelf! Which one is your favorite, that gives you the most value, based on sound quality and bonus tracks? Thanks! :)
I'd say Definitely Maybe is very good for the early demos and first attempts at recording the album, you get to see how much better the final version was!
Best bit about Be Here Now is Noel's remix of D'You Know What I Mean? Where you get onhear all sorts of strings that were always there but buried in the mix.
Honestly don't remember much about the contents of the Morning Glory box!
Ripped the audio as WAV, put the discs in CD books with cloth backed pages, and chucked the jewel cases years back. Can count on one hand the number of times I’ve gone back to those folders.
I ripped all mine as flacs backed up on two drives and then highlights from the collection on two custom iPods. I keep a small amount of physical copies, just ones that are rare printings or limited editions just in case I need to do new backups but I got rid of most of the originals.
@@ChromeDestiny Yeah, I understand a lot of folks are attached to the physical object, but it also feels really good to be able to just get rid of it all or at least reduce it down to a bare minimum.
Oh, Andrew... this could go so wrong..... I admire you for trying this.... maybe do another video in 3 months to update us on this..... I really hope this works out!!!!
I'll definitely do a follow up video, hopefully it's not just me crying in a corner! 😄👍
@@AndrewDixonMusic lol
Hi Andrew , like others I have been doing this for years I have over 1,500 CDs what I do I put them in a CD box the width of a CD and about 15" long and they are onin a shelving unit about 15" deep it's great you can just take out the box and flip through your CDs - label the box up with the artists - you don't see the CDs on display though just the boxes but CDs inside are in plastic sleeves - I have to keep the back cover out as it doesn't fit into my sleeves - you could have them in a drawer flip through style but it is the weight - my only concern is with getting rid of plastic casings is if in the future my kids decided to sell them all they haven't got the cases
I am liking this idea of having the sleeves in boxes to flip through, a few people saying they've done that. 👍
@@AndrewDixonMusic
I’m considering doing this with my DVDs. I have a LOT of DVDs, but I don’t want to stop buying them.
I have just done this with my DVDs over the last month and the space I've saved (again) is incredible. Once you take the disc(s) and sleeve out of the plastic case and you're left with the empty box it really makes you realise how little emotional attachment you can have to an empty plastic box, and it makes it much easier to deal with losing them.
@@AndrewDixonMusic That’s very true. Of course, there will be some DVDs where I won’t take them out of their plastic case, such as my Carry On films and my Chucky films, which are some of my absolute favourites.
@@Authori_tah My complete Carry On collection has remained in its original box! 😄👍
Love it! I did a similar thing and hadn't missed the jewel case at all and that's been about four years ago. You can always hold on to the case for a bit until you are sure you like your new set up. I am going to order this same set of sleeves for my Bob Dylan CDs. I missed out on his big box set so I am going to get a box and put all his in my homemade Bob box. Thanks for sharing I like how they look. Take care!
Thanks Sharon, glad to hear you have no regrets!
Been thinking about your CD situation. I think I would not put them on a shelf but make a holder similar to a shoebox and store them back to front, maybe with letter tab dividers. You could keep them table top or in a cabinet or drawer.. Take care!
That's something I've been considering! 👍
Andrew, you are way more courageous than me. I wouldn’t get rid of any of the jewel cases I own. I just think they are part of the original package. I wouldn’t do it, but if you have to, more power to ya! I’d rather buy another case to shelve ‘em.
The paper/plastic will deteriorate and destroy the disk. There's no danger of this with jewel cases which hold the disk suspended in air.
aggghhh there's no way I could do that. I am with James in that there is something satisfying about owning the disc with original jewel casing. But then I still love dvds. Just remember Andrew if you change your mind you will eventually not be able to buy the proper cd cases? Except scratched to death ones from second hand shops etc... I remember when everyone was thrilled with cds because over them being smaller than LP.s. Look what happened over time. I have cds stored in my music room, my lounge room and even my kitchen. They are priceless to me. Good luck Andrew!
I've been thinking about it although I found slim double cases of amazing quality. Problem is there's no place for the booklet. The reason i wanted to do it that way was I got hooked up on how my few self printed cdr bootlegs looked like. Uniform yet colourful. Like an art installation
Sleeves will need to be replaced eventually. Most of the latest CDs I have bought no longer have Jewel cases, been phasing them out for some time. Good luck with it Andrew, but keep the cases stored someplace if you change your mind. Maybe even get some storage boxes for discs you don't want on display or don't play that often? That could be a storage solution.
I think a better solution is cd or media cabinets for example from Bisley, one low cabinet with 5 drawers can accomodate 270 cds, with nice telescopic drawers, 50 cm deep. Also the metal media cabinets from Bisley maximalizes usable space. Do not splash the cd’s on all the walls of your house!
I would love to do it to save the space but would worry that i would massively regret it later on!
I know the feeling! No regrets so far...
My initial reaction to this as a fellow collector was to grimace - but honestly space is such a huge factor and hinderance when it comes to collecting.
I could see myself doing this with bog standard releases at some point, no hype sticker on the case etc. It’s crazy how much space you have saved
Since recording this I'm up to 200 done and I'm still nowhere near filling that 1 shelf!
How well are you able to see the titles? Are you finding you have to dig through them to find the titles? From watching the video, I could only see one title from afar. I have the same storage challenges you have, but not being able to see the spines would not make it worth it for me.
I'll be able to show that better once I've done a load more and put them in their final position. I'll do an update that shows that 👍
I've got about a thousand cds still on the spools that you buy the blanks on. Most are burned but a lot are out of the cases.
I've been considering do something similar, I've wanted transfer the jewel case CDs into those smaller replica LP sleeves, I've no idea how you would go about doing this but it would save alot of space
I tried, but in the end I thrown the annoying and not so nice looking plastic sleeves away and put the cd's back in nice jewel cases.
I did that for all my dvd’s, including music dvd’s. The dvd case just takes so much space... For cd’s though, I do that for cd’s I don’t care for too much anymore. It’s better option than selling them or throwing them away. For the ones that do get listened, I would not replace the jewel case.
I have a couple of hundred cd's stacked in this way. The only problem I encountered with plastic CD sleeves is that some stick to the CD and might partly tear off the printed label. But as long as you make sure you put the cd itself between the booklet/front cover and the back-cover, you'll be just fine. (For safety reasons you can put the cd in a paper sleeve and put that into your plastic sleeve, but that's some extra money and time...;) )
It's a bit more harder to find a cd, but you can grab a bunch of them and swipe through that quite easily. But it's a great way of saving space (and for dvd's/blu rays even more).
Thanks, yes I have the disc in between the front and back covers 👍
I still have the long boxes.
If you turn them sideways you could label the flaps which might help finding a particular one.
Hi Andrew I have over 10.000 cd plus 1,000 vinyl plus 100s box sets I have been doing this for years my I add it cuts down on cleaning! I find if you stack them flat with dividing plastic I got from my record store works better Paul in Dublin
great for saving space Andrew, but not for me, I have around 960 cd's plus box sets, and while they are in their jewel cases I can easily see who the artist and album is, altho all my collection is ripped to a 2TB Brennan B2 in FLAC, so I do not get them out too often. Of course many of the releases today do not come in Jewel cases, last years new releasees of Jackson Browne's Downhill of Everywhere, David Crosby's For Free and Steely Dan's Northwest Corridor came in card folders as many seem to now. Great for saving space I agree but I could not do it, good for you tho!
This has me interested, but I wished you would have shown how the slipcases are in selecting certain CDs from the shelf. It would be nice if there were some kind of indexing system (A, B, C, D....etc) on the shelf so you can pick out certain CDs without having to go through a bunch of them.
Once I've done a load more, I will definitely be adding some indexing, and I'll do a follow up video showing how it looks, and ease of searching 👍
I have 6,000 CDs and 2,000 LPs/45s, so did this to some of my collection and I agree, not as clean, harder to spot on the spine - I bought dividers - I kept any special CD Holders, but still on the fence if I want to do it to my whole collection.
I couldn't get rid of my jewel cases as they are part of the original package, but I admire your strength to do it.
I've just done this with around 250 cds (Classic, Blues & Jazz Collections from magazine subscriptions). The amount of space saved is incredible. Problem now, what to do with the Jewel Cases! I've yet to find anyone who could use them or anywhere that'll recycle them. 😮 I've also done the same with my DVD collection and can't believe the space thats freed up.
I like the idea of saving space a whole lot. But I think I’d lose CDs in the row and some music might get played less. Anyone who has done this … did you find it hard to find music?