They usually close them a few days after the episode airs. I've emailed them asking to keep them open to let people discuss points in the future but disappointingly no response and comments continue to get closed. Pretty poor for a show about discussing important topics.
22:40 dissapointing that this response and Susan's comments went completely unchallenged. Inceitives to public transport takes cars off the road, and the 50c fares have massively increased ridership. It is flat out wrong to say that they don't help motorists.
LNP just don’t get it. Oh your rent has gone up by 8% and wage 3%. Oh it’s supply, supply, supply. Oh that answer did not seem supported so it must be inflation or nuclear.
Not sure if you remember but few years ago when I was renting. You used to be able to get 2 weeks free rent due to not enough people renting,so supply and demand is the answer
Best if the teacher and his partner do the sums and talk with a bank about their individual situation. A quick search of 2 x teachers income and house prices in Brisbane tells me they could afford to buy if that was their focus.
@@bradkeen1973 Except, now the sacrifice necessary is four times what it was only forty years ago to achieve the same result. You can't sacrifice the whole farm and expect a better yield. My parents sacrificed to buy their first home at 30, my sister and her husband sacrificed and got their first home at 40, then lost it due to debt and had to try again nearly a decade later. Their kids are just entering uni and buying a home isn't even an option due to a hex debt and housing prices beyond their reach. I entered the workforce too late and too lower wages to ever consider buying a home and being single I will be in my 80's by the time I can afford to enter the housing market, if ever. The concept of sacrifice is not lost, it has just become an increasingly futile exercise for many of us.
Both major party reps dancing around the issue of housing. Whats the point of 100 new houses if 95 get bought out by investors? Their policies about grants, stamp duty to FHB just add more money to the housing fire. Kicking the can down the road rather than attempting to solve the structural problem
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Nice, nose... Not mature enough it would seem, this is a grown woman. The right of conquest exists regardless of what you may believe. This land belongs to the crown now. If you wanted a treaty you needed a civilization before the British arrived. No cities, no uniform language, no agriculture, no technology beyond stone age hunter gatherer tools zero. All you had was groups fighting over the most convenient resources, infanticide was rife this is a joke really.😂😂😂😂😂 still funny though.
Larissa sitting there like she never lied on her form to nominate for election to the senate. Was never prosecuted, was never fined and wasn’t required to repay the salary and super she was paid but wasn’t entitled to. Shame on her
Liberal and Labour are not my choice for the next federal election for sure. I'm doing tough on spiked rent and I don't see those 2 big parties housing policy will help.
The problem then becomes "who to vote for" and if you put them on the smaller parties, those votes will just go to either lib or lab anyway 🤷♂️ it seems like a no win scenario sometimes.
No completely opposite, if looking at facts and statistics is empathy then yes but she's doing no different then the liberal senator just the other side of the discussion that no one wants to hear. Put kids in jail with adult time they come out as hardened adults with much less cares and are more then 90 % percent vulnerable to reoffend with much less to loose. By enabling adult crime adult time is legitimately raise a generation or two kids that might have a chance of rehabilitation taking their lives from their hands and turning them into criminals for life
@@WaanyiLanguage I'm not saying we should simply put them in jail in a first instance but I also believe there are limits as to how much one can re-offend before the overriding obligation has to be to protect the community. It seems to me the main principle missing from your argument is accountability, if you dont want to send them to jail, fine but how else are you going to make that person accountable for their actions ?
@@WaanyiLanguage unfortunately a number of youth offenders are committing crime to go back into detention because their mates are in there! They enjoy the socialising, the sports, the fun activities, the takeaway food etc. So it's all a jolly good time instead of being in there and completing schooling (that they aren't interested in on the outside) or some rehabilitation programs because they just don't want to! So if the "worst" or "punishment of last resort" is not really a punishment to these youth then things will never change.
@melsy7720 it's common sense for them to think like that because they are by definition children they make these decisions because of that reason, most of the time these are children with no direction not a good support line ect there are numerous reasons. Repeat offending happens because they know no better of course they're going to do it. There isn't remotely enough support from organisations or the government to get these kids the help they need. Getting them to serve adult time is doing nothing but sweeping dust under the carpet then when the time comes they get out and will spend a life yo yoing between jail and society. That's a life reality that no one especially adults should wish. Youth detention had its dash done it got exposed for the abuse and misconduct that they're so called supervisors carry out on them. Kids still commit suicide in youth detention these are all matters that the boarder public doesn't want to hear that are iron clad facts and rising statistics, help them make better decisions and a life don't let yourself become a accessory or a part of the problem that these kids face or you yourself by principle and definition become no better then they are or the negligence that drove them to these decisions by lack of guidance, education ect
@user-ln8we1ud9c accountability makes up for a very jaded perception. They go to jail thats the accountability simple yes, no it's not because to a child committing these acts it's a splash in the water they know what the risks are and where they are going, the part that's lost in the middle is how they deal with the jail time. Jail slaps a crime = time solution, which is fine in retrospect but it doesn't teach them the coping mechanisms, giving them the rehabilitation and misses vital steps that are generally needed to educate them. They aren't animals to be locked in a cage they are people, humanitarian approaches, therapy, future planning ect are all very basic but lacking things that these kids need before and after they get into these situations. It's a very simple thing but lack of funding and resources are given to the Australian public and organisations on both a state and federal level to do such
We voted for a republic 25 years ago and the yes vote lost. Voting again would be a pointless waste of money that would change very little for Australians on the whole. What it would do is cost hundreds of millions just like the Voice referendum. Then if it passes hudrededs of millions if not billions in rebranding. I'd much rather we spend that money helping improve the lives of Australians. As for nuclear; this is the only way forward. Wind and solar simply do not cut it and will only result in higher energy costs.
@@steveremington more likely that you lack any actual arguement or the intelligence to come up with one. I'm an LNP surrogate. Wow what an insult. Stop being a loser and come up with something a little more complex.
Their talking about what a fool Lidia Thorpe was, not something to hang ya hat on, everyone has an opinion, and some choose to express theirs in childish ways
Really? I thought it was pathetic. It was a point on Thorpe not sending the correct message and the senator was doing the right thing and bringing up the real point without grandstanding.
The panel is 2/4 LNP members lol, don't get your knickers in a twist just because the audience raises points you don't hear in your little echo chambers.
Duttons worth 10 of you Watt watt watt. Guy, Smiley is nothing but a muppet 0.50c fares buy now pay later thats gonna hit the taxpayer's along with other so called freebies. Record debt. A desperat Watt. Shut up stop interjecting.
@@aciavarella yes and the people of Victoria gave their votes to the Greens not Lydia specifically. The seat she holds rightfully belongs to the Greens not Lydia. Without the Greens she wouldnt be a senator. On the bright side without the Greens come the next election she'll no longer be a senator.
@@adamsmith8765 That's rubbish. Firstly, Thorpe got 40,000 votes directly not through the party ticket, second to that was Labor senator Linda White with 30k. We'll see what happens in the next election, but the Green vote has been steadily increasing nationwide over the past 20 years because citizens are sick of the BS that the ALP and the LNP have been peddling for the past 100 years.
That bloke tims first mistake is expecting the government to work for him... you need to work to be independent of any handouts from the Government.. otherwise you are just a modern indentured servant of society..
We invited Robbie Katter but he pulled out. If you tune in, you'll see that we had pollies from regional Queensland sharing their experience and what they heard from their constituencies :)
Statistics can be interpreted however someone wants them to be interpreted, so telling qlders affected by youth crime that rates are down is a joke... it's absolutely rampant. Get real!! Try telling the hardworking people having their cars stolen every single day then smashed up for fun, driven into a river or ocean or set alight, having used syringes left in their cars, defecating in them etc. Tell this to those people traumatised by waking in the middle of the night to find a teen by their bedside looking for car keys and stuff to steal from you whilst being armed with knives that its not that bad!! Tell it to the poor tourists whose child has a fractured skull and in hospital due to teens finding it funny to throw rocks at a train...or the man shot by teens at a bus stop with a sling-shot and ball bearings...tell it to those who are having rocks, eggs, mangoes, ball bearings thrown at them by teens while driving! The stories are endless. If pollies want to feel empathy for them, maybe they can help "rehabilitate" them by having them live at their house for a while, see how that goes.
Robbie Katter was invited but he ended up pulling out. And if you tune in, you'll see that we had candidates and pollies from regional Queensland who shared their experience and what their constituencies want :)
Surprised comments aren't locked
They forgot
yea strange I hope it continues
They usually close them a few days after the episode airs. I've emailed them asking to keep them open to let people discuss points in the future but disappointingly no response and comments continue to get closed. Pretty poor for a show about discussing important topics.
@@Pgt93 The left love diversity except diversity of views it seems, and it is the ABC
Me too.
22:40 dissapointing that this response and Susan's comments went completely unchallenged. Inceitives to public transport takes cars off the road, and the 50c fares have massively increased ridership. It is flat out wrong to say that they don't help motorists.
LNP just don’t get it. Oh your rent has gone up by 8% and wage 3%. Oh it’s supply, supply, supply. Oh that answer did not seem supported so it must be inflation or nuclear.
Not sure if you remember but few years ago when I was renting. You used to be able to get 2 weeks free rent due to not enough people renting,so supply and demand is the answer
Best if the teacher and his partner do the sums and talk with a bank about their individual situation. A quick search of 2 x teachers income and house prices in Brisbane tells me they could afford to buy if that was their focus.
You proably need an education in basic economics then
@@Robert-cu9bmyes, and here is where the concept of sacrifice is lost.
@@bradkeen1973 Except, now the sacrifice necessary is four times what it was only forty years ago to achieve the same result. You can't sacrifice the whole farm and expect a better yield. My parents sacrificed to buy their first home at 30, my sister and her husband sacrificed and got their first home at 40, then lost it due to debt and had to try again nearly a decade later. Their kids are just entering uni and buying a home isn't even an option due to a hex debt and housing prices beyond their reach. I entered the workforce too late and too lower wages to ever consider buying a home and being single I will be in my 80's by the time I can afford to enter the housing market, if ever. The concept of sacrifice is not lost, it has just become an increasingly futile exercise for many of us.
You’re on Queensland country and Australia country.
Both major party reps dancing around the issue of housing. Whats the point of 100 new houses if 95 get bought out by investors? Their policies about grants, stamp duty to FHB just add more money to the housing fire. Kicking the can down the road rather than attempting to solve the structural problem
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂Nice, nose... Not mature enough it would seem, this is a grown woman.
The right of conquest exists regardless of what you may believe. This land belongs to the crown now. If you wanted a treaty you needed a civilization before the British arrived. No cities, no uniform language, no agriculture, no technology beyond stone age hunter gatherer tools zero.
All you had was groups fighting over the most convenient resources, infanticide was rife this is a joke really.😂😂😂😂😂 still funny though.
Larissa sitting there like she never lied on her form to nominate for election to the senate. Was never prosecuted, was never fined and wasn’t required to repay the salary and super she was paid but wasn’t entitled to. Shame on her
Liberal and Labour are not my choice for the next federal election for sure. I'm doing tough on spiked rent and I don't see those 2 big parties housing policy will help.
The problem then becomes "who to vote for" and if you put them on the smaller parties, those votes will just go to either lib or lab anyway 🤷♂️ it seems like a no win scenario sometimes.
Greens senator had huge empathy for criminals but none for the victims of crime.
No completely opposite, if looking at facts and statistics is empathy then yes but she's doing no different then the liberal senator just the other side of the discussion that no one wants to hear. Put kids in jail with adult time they come out as hardened adults with much less cares and are more then 90 % percent vulnerable to reoffend with much less to loose. By enabling adult crime adult time is legitimately raise a generation or two kids that might have a chance of rehabilitation taking their lives from their hands and turning them into criminals for life
@@WaanyiLanguage I'm not saying we should simply put them in jail in a first instance but I also believe there are limits as to how much one can re-offend before the overriding obligation has to be to protect the community. It seems to me the main principle missing from your argument is accountability, if you dont want to send them to jail, fine but how else are you going to make that person accountable for their actions ?
@@WaanyiLanguage unfortunately a number of youth offenders are committing crime to go back into detention because their mates are in there! They enjoy the socialising, the sports, the fun activities, the takeaway food etc. So it's all a jolly good time instead of being in there and completing schooling (that they aren't interested in on the outside) or some rehabilitation programs because they just don't want to!
So if the "worst" or "punishment of last resort" is not really a punishment to these youth then things will never change.
@melsy7720 it's common sense for them to think like that because they are by definition children they make these decisions because of that reason, most of the time these are children with no direction not a good support line ect there are numerous reasons. Repeat offending happens because they know no better of course they're going to do it. There isn't remotely enough support from organisations or the government to get these kids the help they need. Getting them to serve adult time is doing nothing but sweeping dust under the carpet then when the time comes they get out and will spend a life yo yoing between jail and society. That's a life reality that no one especially adults should wish. Youth detention had its dash done it got exposed for the abuse and misconduct that they're so called supervisors carry out on them. Kids still commit suicide in youth detention these are all matters that the boarder public doesn't want to hear that are iron clad facts and rising statistics, help them make better decisions and a life don't let yourself become a accessory or a part of the problem that these kids face or you yourself by principle and definition become no better then they are or the negligence that drove them to these decisions by lack of guidance, education ect
@user-ln8we1ud9c accountability makes up for a very jaded perception. They go to jail thats the accountability simple yes, no it's not because to a child committing these acts it's a splash in the water they know what the risks are and where they are going, the part that's lost in the middle is how they deal with the jail time. Jail slaps a crime = time solution, which is fine in retrospect but it doesn't teach them the coping mechanisms, giving them the rehabilitation and misses vital steps that are generally needed to educate them. They aren't animals to be locked in a cage they are people, humanitarian approaches, therapy, future planning ect are all very basic but lacking things that these kids need before and after they get into these situations. It's a very simple thing but lack of funding and resources are given to the Australian public and organisations on both a state and federal level to do such
We voted for a republic 25 years ago and the yes vote lost. Voting again would be a pointless waste of money that would change very little for Australians on the whole. What it would do is cost hundreds of millions just like the Voice referendum. Then if it passes hudrededs of millions if not billions in rebranding. I'd much rather we spend that money helping improve the lives of Australians. As for nuclear; this is the only way forward. Wind and solar simply do not cut it and will only result in higher energy costs.
Thanks LNP surrogate.
How about making referenda cheaper and more frequent?
Switzerland does at least 3 per year.
@@steveremington O no you got me good there. Try harder.
@@adamsmith8765 I don't have to try very hard when you make it so easy.
@@steveremington more likely that you lack any actual arguement or the intelligence to come up with one. I'm an LNP surrogate. Wow what an insult. Stop being a loser and come up with something a little more complex.
41:00 She really doesn't want to answer the question.
Love this show
9:26 audience members reply was spot on!
Their talking about what a fool Lidia Thorpe was, not something to hang ya hat on, everyone has an opinion, and some choose to express theirs in childish ways
Really? I thought it was pathetic. It was a point on Thorpe not sending the correct message and the senator was doing the right thing and bringing up the real point without grandstanding.
Embarrassing comment. We aren't even able to have a decent conversation, says a lot about your character that you commend it.
If this country hadn't been colonized what would it look like today?
@@kuddi5313and neither Canadian or Nee Zealand First Nations have any socio economic, domestic abuse or substance abuse problems……oh hang on
There would be no Lydia Thorpe for starters.
@@kuddi5313 I dont believe dividing people by race is moral
@@kuddi5313 It's actually not basic
A heck of a lot worse for the indigenous when the Asians were coming next to claim it.
How far left is this show. I have to go 🤮🤮🤮🤮
It is as far left as you can go unfortunately
The panel is 2/4 LNP members lol, don't get your knickers in a twist just because the audience raises points you don't hear in your little echo chambers.
@@hoodie3810 -LOL they are nothing but wolfs in sheep's clothing, they couldn't be further from an actual LNP if they tried!
@@virtuaconker85 so LNP supporters are sheep then? Yeah that actually makes sense now you mention it 🤣
Duttons worth 10 of you Watt watt watt.
Guy, Smiley is nothing but a muppet 0.50c fares buy now pay later thats gonna hit the taxpayer's along with other so called freebies.
Record debt.
A desperat Watt.
Shut up stop interjecting.
Sack Lydia Thorpe
It's a democracy champ, look it up.
@@aciavarella yes and the people of Victoria gave their votes to the Greens not Lydia specifically. The seat she holds rightfully belongs to the Greens not Lydia. Without the Greens she wouldnt be a senator. On the bright side without the Greens come the next election she'll no longer be a senator.
@@adamsmith8765 That's rubbish. Firstly, Thorpe got 40,000 votes directly not through the party ticket, second to that was Labor senator Linda White with 30k. We'll see what happens in the next election, but the Green vote has been steadily increasing nationwide over the past 20 years because citizens are sick of the BS that the ALP and the LNP have been peddling for the past 100 years.
Thanks for publicly declaring you are against the human right to freedom of speech.
@@kuddi5313 interenational attention ... lol. Nobody outside Australia cares.
That bloke tims first mistake is expecting the government to work for him... you need to work to be independent of any handouts from the Government.. otherwise you are just a modern indentured servant of society..
Free lunches and free breakfasts…….. Senator, nothing is free, someone pays for it
coal royalties my guy
Through the tens of billions of dollars in surpluses the QLD Labor government has recorded
Pauline Hanson or Bob Katter should have been Panellist in Queensland.
We invited Robbie Katter but he pulled out. If you tune in, you'll see that we had pollies from regional Queensland sharing their experience and what they heard from their constituencies :)
If you had paid attention during the entire show rather than jumping to an ignorant conclusion you would know why they they were not there.
@@steveremington No need to be nasty, the person you are responding to wasn't
@@user-ln8we1ud9c I was not being "nasty". I was just stating a fact.
Why replay her disgusting behaviour!!!!
Why don't they just give the artifacts back?
Good point @@andrewthomas695
Statistics can be interpreted however someone wants them to be interpreted, so telling qlders affected by youth crime that rates are down is a joke... it's absolutely rampant. Get real!!
Try telling the hardworking people having their cars stolen every single day then smashed up for fun, driven into a river or ocean or set alight, having used syringes left in their cars, defecating in them etc. Tell this to those people traumatised by waking in the middle of the night to find a teen by their bedside looking for car keys and stuff to steal from you whilst being armed with knives that its not that bad!!
Tell it to the poor tourists whose child has a fractured skull and in hospital due to teens finding it funny to throw rocks at a train...or the man shot by teens at a bus stop with a sling-shot and ball bearings...tell it to those who are having rocks, eggs, mangoes, ball bearings thrown at them by teens while driving! The stories are endless.
If pollies want to feel empathy for them, maybe they can help "rehabilitate" them by having them live at their house for a while, see how that goes.
Shame on Q&A for not having Pauline Hanson or Bob Katter on a Q&A show in Queensland.
Robbie Katter was invited but he ended up pulling out. And if you tune in, you'll see that we had candidates and pollies from regional Queensland who shared their experience and what their constituencies want :)
Neither of those yokels can string two sentences together and have nothing sensible to say or contribute.
If you had paid attention during the entire show rather than jumping to an ignorant conclusion you would know why they they were not there.
Try watch it more than the Tiktok length of time mate 😂
@@qanda - there is a reason they pull out as you are all extreme far left and it would just be a witch hunt on them if they came!