India doesn't want to be a 'traditional' U.S. ally, think tank says
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- Alyssa Ayres, adjunct senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, says India is a "very independent" country, and the traditional alliance relationship the U.S. has with other countries "creates an almost unexpectable level of deference on the part of the other country."
India doesn't want to ally with any one. India stands for global good. Indian itself a country of 1.497 Billion people is a Pole in itself ,why would they allign with someone..world needs to ally with them..those days are coming back. Congratulations India!
1.4 billions with 20% of them living near poverty line while the other 20% is unemployed....
@@Commievn true but India is improving and millions have been lifted out of poverty and millions more will.
@@Commievn name a nation which becomes prosperous in one day? 18% of humanity lives in India...they'll take time but certainly they have arrived
@@Commievnyeah so? They also have a more advanced space program then most of Europe and is a rising economy. Over time they will get better and more wealthy just like china did. Stay strong India bros don't let the haters get to you.
@@Commievn440mn lifted out of poverty in the last 15 years.
Unemployed is 8% and poverty rate is 15%.
Ally means modern colony like japan or south korea
true dat
Exactly, and India proudly refuses to do that.
Very true!
Ally = Vassal
It is not just vassal rather they will slowly bring the Pantecostal Pastors a d try to convert the natives of the Land like what they successfully did in South Korea & Phillipines which are their cuckold vassal.
They tried that in Japan but failed as Japanese culture & religion is superior to the American ones.
They tried that in Vietnam 🇻🇳 and ended up having their ass handed to them by the valiant Vietnamese.
Same in Afghanistan.
USA is a malignant power which destabilizes other nations, Bangladesh is the recent example of it.
India was never part of any alliance even in the past. Not the US, nor the Soviet Union. Won't be in present day either.
actually India has been Russia's ally
@@wolverineiscool7161 As a counter to China. That's all.
@@wolverineiscool7161 Well, why is that? Remember US support for Pakistan and China which came back to bite it in the behind. India does not change friends overnight. The West needs to understand that.
@@wolverineiscool7161 Are you saying military allies then give proof of it, any doc signed by india with Russia?
@@TroyxxtYes the very famous, India - Soviet friendship treaty which was essentially a binding one that would force Soviet to help India in case of war. India was non aligned in its true sense till Nehru was alive. Get your facts straight.
India is aware of Henry Kissinger's famous statement, that being an enemy of the US is dangerous but being an ally of the US is fatal. India is well aware of the many US vassals out there. Example, France and Germany were wary regarding NATO expansion to Russia's border, but vassals cannot affect decisions.
right said ..Racist Americans crying in corner😂
No Allie ... We will chose what is good for us ..
USA should clear that India is not Pakistan.
1:00 This is definately a commercial for the new Royal Enfield Bullet
Lol... 😂
🤣🤣🤣
We are nobody's ally....even in days of bipolar world of USA and SOVIAT...and in today's multipolar world Being one of the rising power,we don't need to dependent on anybody.We have own policies, diplomacy and right to make our own decision.😊
My respect goes out to the United States for supporting democracy and diverse causes internationally. In my opinion, the United States and India are good allies and will remain so in the future.
However, India can't rely on precarious US support that is at the discretion of its Congress/Senate. What Washington foreign policy person thinks it's fair to expect India to bow down to the US.
Look at what’s happening with Ukraine, military aid is at the mercy of house/senate votes.
Pakistan and China surround India with strong armies. I don't see how US expects India to make enemies with Russia or anyone else in Asia. US shouldn't ask India to get expensive oil by avoiding cheaper oil from Russia while American politicians are flip-flopping on Ukraine aid.
Yes, the US donated money/weapons to Ukraine, but that doesn't mean India should risk its oil security and ignore the needs of millions of its citizens.
As an Indian , we want to have our own saying and self respect and wants to be good with others too . We do not want to be ruled by any other country , we gave gain our independence with very hard and our ancestors have died for the freedom we ,now are enjoying
India follows Chanakya Neeti. You may ask, who is Chanakya?
He was the greatest war strategist, economist, foreign affairs expert and political brain of the ancient world who lived 2300 years back in India.
what does that even mean if it has not translated into making us a strong independent nation ! badgering is one thing demonstrating it is another
India deserves her say in the global affairs. As long as they are a democracy and not expansionist like China, India is a natural ally
You're right. And India will never go the dictatorial route as Congress once tried in the 70s and failed miserably.
Quite conditional I think. America has a flawed democracy as well. No representation of native Americans, blacks etc. what if we were to make things as conditional? Unless America has a multi-party democracy, it doesn't count as a democracy and hence let's invade/ regime change/ install our puppet etc.? You people are the ones that are expansionists. And you have no right to dictate terms on which we're 'allowed' to have our say. Weird
Ally = Vassal
As per White House and Pentagon defination
You are $22T USD for 400M Americans, We are $3.7B for 1.45B Indians. We will continue to think about our interests for those 1.45B Indians with 2 nuclear countries as top enemies, Pakistan and China. Sorry US, we will not tow anyones line. Fend and Defend is key for India now.
India respects its Freedom.
Nationalists didn’t die for us to compromise India’s strategic autonomy and freedom.
Indians starved themself to protect India’s sovereignity in 1971.
This generation will not spoil there sacrifices.
India can only be a Mutual Friend if you maintain mutual Respect
For you...Ally means "just be US servant and follow my orders"!.....surprisingly India is not going to do so under your command...as it is autonomous state.
You're misunderstanding an Ally is a friend and a dependable partner, A group of people you can share military equipment, sure supplies, technology, share each other's military Bases, the most importantly you will not have to fight alone.
@@lilavall4735what bases does pakistan have on American soil? I'll wait...
Pakistan was a US 'ally' for 50 years. Where did they get with that? Germany is a key ally and what did they get? (Nordstream😅). UK has been the 'true blue' lackey and where are they now? Caveat emptor😅.
The Definition of an Ally for US and India are different.
India is not any think of an ally period.
India First. 😎😎
The understanding for ally for Europeans and Western people is complete control of all deplomatic policy and its economics.
India is 1/5th of humanity. The world will pivot where india pivots.
India does not need alliances or to be anyone’s vassal.
Is she really discussing Geopolitics.. India traditionally not accepting culture of Alliance/Ally , as India believes in Partnership. In USA Phrase polics are favorable from decades, like UK US friends sweeter than honey .. etc. India does not believe in such words politics. If yu looking growth, profit , socia economic benefit, welcome as Partner..
There is no alliance only mutual cooperation. We r modern humans don't live in jungle with tribalism. 😂
It’s not only America which likes to be independent thinker !! Every other country has the right to put their interests first and be fiercely independent!!
War History of Russia and America showing which one is right .
Russia 🇷🇺 ❤️
Indians prefer values more than 💲
As a developing country it should be wary of charming offensives coming from the side that is for stoking blocks of conflicts in other parts of the world.
Those are not the signs that indicate a side that is interested in world peace and in the well being of all of mankind.
Its the similar relationship that US has with Israel. Even though the US doesn't want to help Israel, its polity is taken care of by the jews and its lobby in the US. Similar, our relationship is taken care by Hinjews (Hindus and Jews), the Hindu Jewish lobby working for the greater good of both countries and world at large. We have a multilayered relationship with Israel as a brother as we are religiously connected and that's the reason Israel helped us even when they did not have diplomatic ties with India till 1992. One must look through many videos of Jewish Hindu Interfaith dialogue to know the similarities.
Let's not sugar cot American alliance, it's basically means a american colony (just like a British colony)
We simply dont trust snakes
Reporter tried his best to create an anti India narrative but failed..Lady was spot on.
1:03 that's a royal Enfield bullet sound 😎👍
It is a friend ship of friends with benefits,
This will totally depend upon USA
The "Alliance" term as a whole is losing its ground. More & more countries are now diverting from alliance to mutual relationships even in International market. The Alliance became trending post World war Era specially during Cold war. Now many countries find themsleves indulging in matters that are harmful for their national interest but they are forced to do that cuz of their commitment to one Alliance. We are moving towards a World that wont be dominated by own power bit several & in that case there will be multiple alliance like groups & u will see one Country in several groups based on their national interest. Theres a trend of " Nation comes first " in all Democracies now days & that also reflects in Geopolitics.
It depends on what alies means in US
enemy of the US is dangerous but being an ally of the US is fatal
Lady this is natos war
Power ❤
it's necessary to remain challenging😅😅😅😂...
We wish to but we cannot believe US if one really sees their past with allay countries.. in comparison Russian friendship is so far always very solid let come what may
Committee of 300 ??
Bharat is not an ally. Bharat is a partner, you wanna work with us level your shoulders.
America wants to be Bahubali and India is Vishwaguru
Us want pet 🐶 dog.
Arey hii bhabi ji sadanand dhume aka (6adwa) kaisa hai.........😂😂
Because our goal is to get to 1st position..so we don’t ally with anyone. We could be friends though
In a multipolar world there will be no no 1,only co operation with benefits
1sr Position in What? This is such a stupid comment. India should aspire to become a country with a good living standard for all classes and a sustainable growth. Also develop Great technologies for its safety. Doesn't need to be number 1 like US and see downfall.
@@seventhuser904 1st position by having largest economy of the world which will lead us to become financial and military superpower of the world..and that’s what the Government is doing…financially supporting tech start ups and innovation, rapidly banning variety of weapons imports and start developing weapon systems at home, achieving self reliance.
India needs to be self-dependance for all its needs and not piggyback on the USA. I don't think India will ever be 1st position ever. Remember US and China are not going to stop growing because India is growing. Indias 1.4 billion people or uneducated and un feed. If India don't stop burning coal. Everyone is going to die with the air pollution.