In today's video, I would like to talk about 'How to tell the difference between Blue Topaz and Aquamarine', since they are often a shade of blue, which can lead to some confusion. Both are beautiful and popular gemstones that are often used in jewelry. However, from my point of view, nothing can beat a natural aquamarine, cuz I don't prefer the stone with heat treatment. Enjoy the video. :)
Thank you for posting this video, very informative. After watching this video I'm questioning myself, I don't know what's original gem/crystal stone anymore. Point 1 I think in general it's harder to manufacture aquamarine rather than topaz because aqua quantity has its limitation when compare with topaz. The same goes with citrine, it's hard to find natural citrine, most of them are heat treated. (man made) Point 2. How is topaz treating color natural? It's harmless but it's still made by man. Correct me if I'm wrong. I'm not againsing anyone as I myself would love to have the original or natural one but in my collection, I also own crystal that I know they are not natural. You need to be a millionaire to own a specific natural piece, if you know what I mean? Thanks for sharing Karen❤️
Thank you for your thoughtful message and for watching the video! I'm glad you found it informative. Let's address your points: Point 1: You mentioned that it is generally harder to manufacture aquamarine compared to topaz due to the limited quantity of aquamarine. This is a valid observation. Aquamarine, a variety of beryl, is indeed less abundant than topaz, which contributes to its higher value and rarity. Similarly, natural citrine is rare, and many citrines on the market are actually heat-treated amethysts to achieve that vibrant yellow color. But heat-treated is not man-made because the crystal itself is natural, it's not glass, and yet it's not been added other substances while heating. Point 2: Regarding the treatment of topaz, you are correct that many blue topaz stones are treated to achieve their color. This process usually involves irradiating and then heating colorless topaz, which is a safe and common practice in the gemstone industry. While the treatment is man-made, it does not diminish the beauty or the durability of the stone, and it's still a natural crystal because no other substances are added while heating, just like heated citrine. However, it's important to distinguish between treated and untreated stones, especially for collectors and enthusiasts who value natural gemstones. Personal Collection: I completely understand your perspective on owning both natural and treated stones. Many collectors appreciate the uniqueness and beauty of natural stones but also recognize the practicality and affordability of treated stones. It's all about finding a balance that works for you and enjoying the beauty of each piece in your collection. Affordability: Indeed, owning specific natural gemstones can be quite expensive, sometimes requiring a significant investment. But the price also depends on the size, clarity, and color of the stone. You don’t need a millionaire to have the purchasing power. After all, crystals are not diamonds. You can buy natural crystals for even tens of dollars.
@@KarenHuiCrystals ohh thank you for replying. People just don't know how it felt like walking in to a crystal shop and end up being call a cheap customer for wearing 3 fake crystal on both hands. Even if I tried to explain that they are natural only that it's treated in some way, the sales person can't agree on that as being natural for them is entirely not altered anything and they are selling all natural in their shop. I never want to visit any millionaire crystal shop anymore. As for price range on my country I can get quite a nice topaz bracelet came in cert with around 40usd from a reputable online seller. I'm glad I found your channel. MY aquamarine 8mm looks just like the one you holding or close to something like the 1st aqua you received from your mom 🤗. I'm relief I learnt a lot from your channel. Thank you so much Karen, god bless you 🙏
I have what I think is a large aquamarine emerald cut ring in a rose gold mounting and accented with 2 small rubies on either side that is quite old. I don’t have any blue topaz to compare it to. I’ve had different jewelers tell me it’s aquamarine and others say blue topaz! Some jewelers say it’s worth about $130.00 but I don’t trust them. How do I find out what I have and how to appraise it?
In today's video, I would like to talk about 'How to tell the difference between Blue Topaz and Aquamarine', since they are often a shade of blue, which can lead to some confusion. Both are beautiful and popular gemstones that are often used in jewelry. However, from my point of view, nothing can beat a natural aquamarine, cuz I don't prefer the stone with heat treatment. Enjoy the video. :)
Thank you so much.
Thank you Karen! I am obsessed with aquamarine :)
Excellent information! Thank you very much❤
@@RUGRAF-rf8fi Thank you for watching. ❤️
Thank you for posting this video, very informative. After watching this video I'm questioning myself, I don't know what's original gem/crystal stone anymore.
Point 1
I think in general it's harder to manufacture aquamarine rather than topaz because aqua quantity has its limitation when compare with topaz.
The same goes with citrine, it's hard to find natural citrine, most of them are heat treated. (man made)
Point 2.
How is topaz treating color natural? It's harmless but it's still made by man.
Correct me if I'm wrong.
I'm not againsing anyone as I myself would love to have the original or natural one but in my collection, I also own crystal that I know they are not natural.
You need to be a millionaire to own a specific natural piece, if you know what I mean?
Thanks for sharing Karen❤️
Thank you for your thoughtful message and for watching the video! I'm glad you found it informative. Let's address your points:
Point 1:
You mentioned that it is generally harder to manufacture aquamarine compared to topaz due to the limited quantity of aquamarine. This is a valid observation. Aquamarine, a variety of beryl, is indeed less abundant than topaz, which contributes to its higher value and rarity. Similarly, natural citrine is rare, and many citrines on the market are actually heat-treated amethysts to achieve that vibrant yellow color. But heat-treated is not man-made because the crystal itself is natural, it's not glass, and yet it's not been added other substances while heating.
Point 2:
Regarding the treatment of topaz, you are correct that many blue topaz stones are treated to achieve their color. This process usually involves irradiating and then heating colorless topaz, which is a safe and common practice in the gemstone industry. While the treatment is man-made, it does not diminish the beauty or the durability of the stone, and it's still a natural crystal because no other substances are added while heating, just like heated citrine. However, it's important to distinguish between treated and untreated stones, especially for collectors and enthusiasts who value natural gemstones.
Personal Collection:
I completely understand your perspective on owning both natural and treated stones. Many collectors appreciate the uniqueness and beauty of natural stones but also recognize the practicality and affordability of treated stones. It's all about finding a balance that works for you and enjoying the beauty of each piece in your collection.
Affordability:
Indeed, owning specific natural gemstones can be quite expensive, sometimes requiring a significant investment. But the price also depends on the size, clarity, and color of the stone. You don’t need a millionaire to have the purchasing power. After all, crystals are not diamonds. You can buy natural crystals for even tens of dollars.
@@KarenHuiCrystals ohh thank you for replying. People just don't know how it felt like walking in to a crystal shop and end up being call a cheap customer for wearing 3 fake crystal on both hands.
Even if I tried to explain that they are natural only that it's treated in some way, the sales person can't agree on that as being natural for them is entirely not altered anything and they are selling all natural in their shop.
I never want to visit any millionaire crystal shop anymore.
As for price range on my country I can get quite a nice topaz bracelet came in cert with around 40usd from a reputable online seller.
I'm glad I found your channel. MY aquamarine 8mm looks just like the one you holding or close to something like the 1st aqua you received from your mom 🤗.
I'm relief I learnt a lot from your channel. Thank you so much Karen, god bless you 🙏
Thanks for the video i love it..
I have what I think is a large aquamarine emerald cut ring in a rose gold mounting and accented with 2 small rubies on either side that is quite old. I don’t have any blue topaz to compare it to. I’ve had different jewelers tell me it’s aquamarine and others say blue topaz! Some jewelers say it’s worth about $130.00 but I don’t trust them. How do I find out what I have and how to appraise it?
also wont know difference between the two thank you for the information Karen Hui
Very nice
Thank you so much Ma'am 👍👌👍👌👍👌👍👌🖐🙏🙂🇮🇳India Bharat
👍20～非常漂亮 喜歡👍👍👍